1. Field of the Invention
This invention discusses a new gasket technology to address the increasing demands of providing effective sealing solutions for exhaust systems in engines and power plant industries.
There is an increasing demand (Reference 2) for more effective exhaust system joints to meet environmental and emissions regulations. These hot-gas applications are especially difficult to seal (
Prior art in O-rings or “liquid” gaskets utilize organic materials that pyrolyze giving off noxious smoke by-products when subjected to temperatures greater than 300 to 400° C. where the majority of organic materials pyrolyze. Other silicone polymer pastes and cements do not retain elastic properties after heat curing at 400° C. These silicone prepreg materials are excellent for producing ceramic products which cannot perform as gaskets without elastic properties.
The current EPA pollution testing is currently limited to the tail pipe and inspection under the hood to make sure the pollution control equipment is properly installed which misses the underhood exhaust manifold gasket pollution. This invention solves this pollution problem economically at a significant cost savings to engine manufacturers which includes elimination of storage, inventory and costly tooling required for multilayer steel gaskets which weigh four times more than the composite O-rings applied as liquid gaskets.
2. Description of the Previously Published Art
The Beckley U.S. Pat. No. 5,552,466 is specific to teach methods of producing processable resin blends that produce high density silica ceramics in the red heat zone. The preferred catalyst, zinc hexanoic acid produces a high cross-link density polymer by the Beckley methods of processing that favor the formation of high yield ceramic composites compared the high temperature elastic silicone polymers produced by the Clarke methods of using boron nitride, silica and a preferred boron oxide catalyst. No mention is made of compression-recovery properties common to Clarke related composites.
The Boisvert, et al. U.S. Pat. No. 5,972,512 is specific to teach silanol-silanol condensation cured methylsilsesquioxane resins enabling the fabrication of non-burning composites with superior performance than organic laminates. No mention is made of producing a high temperature elastic silicone containing boron nitride and silica to produce the fire resistant elastic silicone laminate that slowly transforms into a flexible ceramic then ceramic with no burn through at 2000° F. after 15 minutes. Also, the fire resistance is specific to methyl resins overlooking the high thermal advantages of phenyl resins even when used sparingly. Also, elastic composites have dissimilar materials joining advantages not mentioned in the Boisvert patent.
The Clarke U.S. Pat. No. 6,093,763 is specific to teach the use of the zinc hexanoic acid catalyst for a specific ratio of 2:1 for two specific silicon resins with boron nitride as filler. The zinc hexanoic acid catalyst produces a different high cross-link density polymer than the preferred elastic composite produced from a reaction mixture of boron nitride, silica and boron oxide and controlled reaction methods. The amount of zinc catalyst required to enable the sealant to perform is also excessive in comparison to the boron oxide catalyst which is sparingly used to favor a slow reaction for producing elastic composites.
The Clarke U.S. Pat. No. 6,161,520 is specific to teach that the gasket materials derived from Clarke's copending U.S. patent application Ser. Nos. 08/962,782; 08/962,783 and 09/185,282, all teach the required use of boron nitride as the catalyst for condensation polymerization of the resin blend needed to produce the gaskets. Clarke has verified that boron nitride is not a catalyst as incorrectly claimed. Clarke verified the certainty that boron nitride is not a catalyst by attempting to repeat the 873 patent's FIG. 1 “gel” curve at 177° C. using the preferred CERAC, Inc. item #B-1084-99.5% pure boron nitride. Other research associates have also confirmed the certainty that boron nitride is not a silicone condensation catalyst. Numerous possible contaminates would need to be investigated to find the actual catalyst or combination of catalysts including the possibility of humidity. No mention of using boron nitride, silica and boron oxide as a reaction mixture processed in a rotating cylinder at ambient temperature to favor the production of a high temperature elastic composite. Neither is boron oxide mentioned as catalyst with boron nitride cost advantage addressed when boron oxide is used as a residual from the chemical processing (Reference 4) of boron nitride.
The Clarke U.S. Pat. No. 6,183,873 B1 is specific to teach the use of boron nitride as the catalyst in producing polysiloxane resin formulations for hot melt or wet impregnation of ceramic reinforcements. As stated above, boron nitride is not a catalyst as incorrectly claimed. The more costly and toxic hot melt and wet processing methods of the above described '873 patent are eliminated with the superior ambient temperature methods addressed by the inventor. No resin formulations using boron oxide as the catalyst are mentioned. Additionally, the methods of producing “flexible ceramic” high temperature elastic laminates are not addressed. Also, the use of laser processing (up to 16,500° C.) to increase the tensile strength by 25% and form ceramic sealed edges is not addressed. The economical advantage of using residual boron oxide contained in boron nitride as a source for the catalyst addition is not mentioned.
The Clarke SAE 2002-01-0332 paper (Reference 3) refers to high purity boron oxide as a Lewis acid catalyst with silica mentioned as an unobvious inhibitor for these silicone condensation polymerization catalysts. High cost boron nitride and boron oxide are added separately. No mention is made of producing resin formulations using boron nitride containing boron oxide residues as a source of boron oxide catalyst and cost savings advantage. Additionally, the methods of producing “flexible-ceramic” laminates capable of high-temperature elastic recovery (
The Zurfluh SAE 2007-01-1520 paper (Reference 2) refers to new alloys (HTAs) and an unique high temperature coating (undefined) for solving the exhaust systems multi-layer steel (MLS) gasket environmental and emissions problems where traditional MLS gaskets “often do not provide an effective seal, typically degrading or creeping at operating temperatures”. The high costs associated with the MLS gaskets are not eliminated by the proposed new metals and the coating cannot have sufficient compression-recovery to act as a gasket, so the MLS recovery from compression is needed to provide the gaskets recovery which is not the same as the more economical viscoelastic recovery provided by the composite gaskets.
It is the objective of this discovery, derived from the above background experience to exploit the use of the liquid composite blend in producing emissions free exhaust system gaskets for assuring elimination of under hood pollution from exhaust systems particularly in front of the catalytic converter at significant cost savings to engine manufacturers.
It is the further objective of this discovery to provide options to exhaust systems engineers which allow. the same high temperature sealing capability with applied liquid gaskets or complex network beaded gaskets, molded O-rings and continuous braided fiber reinforced helical O-rings.
It is the further objective of this discovery to design the O-ring options so the compression of the ring provides a 10 to 1 minimum ratio of the compressed ring's land width to thickness, so engineers can restrict the flow of the compressed gasket within their desired design perimeters.
It is the further objective of this discovery to provide engine exhaust manifold liquid and molded O-rings that have successfully completed durability testing on Ford 460 V8 truck engine dynamometers for greater than 6000 hours fired by methane gas.
It is the further objective of this discovery to have exhaust manifold O-ring gaskets that have successfully completed over 350,000 miles cab fleet testing on Ford Crown Victoria 4.6 V8 engines.
It is the further objective of this discovery to have out performed the current Ford Crown Victoria 4.6 V8 engine MLS exhaust manifold gaskets with the composite gaskets measuring pressure decay from 30 psi at 300 to 400° C. flange temperatures with essentially no leakage.
It is the further objective of this discovery to have greater than 95% recovery from 15% compression of composites made with the invention's polymer matrix cured from 200 to 750° C. and densified with the invention's resin blend (see
It is the further objective of this discovery to make the resin blend from the methyl and phenyl silsesquioxane resins and additives and apply the resin blend to reinforcing materials to provide a liquid composite that can be used to apply O-rings, mold O-rings or impregnate braided reinforcement to make “helical” O-rings (
This invention extends the elastic range of silicone composite gaskets from typically −40 to 300° C. to temperatures within the “red heat”, i.e., 600 to 1000° C. applications. The composite gaskets comprise a matrix of cured methyl and/or phenyl-silsesquioxane resins, boron nitride, boron oxide and silica additives and a reinforcing material that enables highly thermally stable elastic composites to be fabricated into durable composite exhaust system gaskets. The high temperature composite gaskets are assembled as an O-ring or as a liquid bead forming an O-ring on engine exhaust manifolds just before assembly. High performance engine exhaust gas temperatures are typically 871° C. for sustained and 982° C. for spike temperatures. The heat from the hot gases contained within the compressed composite O-rings form a protective sealed ceramic barrier on the inside of the compressed edge that allows the compressed composite material to remain elastic. The applied composite O-ring gaskets invention enables the seals to control their flow within precise thickness and land width limits when compressed in assembly and durability tested. The method for making the composite gaskets comprises applying the above resin blend to continuous or discontinuous fiber reinforcing material and curing the resin.
The composite matrix materials contained in exhaust manifold composite gaskets have passed cab fleet durability testing (under confidentiality agreement) for over 350,000 miles (with 150,000 mile requirement). The economical “Liquid gaskets” applied as liquid bead formed “O” rings on 460 V8 truck engine exhaust manifolds before assembly performed for nine months on dynamometers (under confidentiality agreement) for over 6000 hours the equivalent of 400,000 miles on methane fired engines. Methane fires hotter than conventional fossil fuel. The composites have passed FAA fire penetration, burn through, heat release (<10 kW/m2), smoke density and Boeing toxicity testing per BSS 7239.
Durability testing (under confidentiality agreement) of the resin blend used to make composite laminate internal combustion engine exhaust manifold gaskets has revealed that they can perform up to and exceeding 350,000 miles cab fleet durability testing (typical automotive requirement is 150,000 miles) with “spike” exhaust hot-gas temperatures up to 932° C.
To accomplish the above product performance, the resin blend additive materials are selected with high flexible and thermal resistant properties.
The unique resin blend is typically mixed from three silicone resins and two or more ceramic additives. To accomplish the elastic compression recovery performance (see
A variety of polysiloxane oligomers are well known in the art that exhibit similar functionality; however, the discovery's most preferred organic groups are the methyl or phenyl because of their high thermal stability.
A typical resin blend with the preferred additive systems is given in Table 2.
In Table 3, the formulation using preferred commercially available resins is set forth.
The preferred resin blend additives are silica and boron nitride retaining 2±1.0 wt % residual boron oxide. These additives provide high thermal capabilities.
Silica was discovered by Clarke (Reference 3) to slow down the time it takes for the silicone resin reaction mass catalyzed by boron oxide to reach “gel” at 177° C. (Table 1). Using this capability, the silicone reaction mass is slowly polymerized at ambient temperature in excess acetone favoring the formation of high molecular weight silicone polymers with high elastic increased linear chain (Si—O—Si) growth. Additionally, a mixture of silica and boron nitride added to the silicone resin reaction mass produces a superior flexible elastic polymer with high-temperature elastic properties than can not be produced using silica or boron nitride alone.
Silica alone will increase the polymer modulus causing it to become nonelastic above 300° C. Boron nitride alone at the suggested 16 wt % will produce an excessively plasticized soft low modulus weak polymer that will fail in interlaminar shear loading as a gasket. But when boron nitride and silica are in a 10/6 to 20/6 parts by weight ratio with 100 parts resin blend the elastic polymer produced by the boron oxide processing will become a thermally stable high-temperature flexible elastic polymer up to 500° C. because the silica is increasing the modulus to compensate for the plasticizing effect of the boron nitride which is thermally stable as a lubricant to 850° C. (Reference 6).
Boron nitride retaining 2.0±1.0 wt. % boron oxide is available from the Momentive Performance Materials (grade SAM-140) and ZYP Coating (grade ZPG-18 and -19) Companies who can selectively provide this preferred residual boron oxide and within the boron nitride from their commercial synthesis and leaching production operations. This aggregate boron nitride retaining 2% residual boron oxide is superior to high purity boron nitride (requiring a separate catalyst addition) in processing efficiency and cost advantage.
The residual boron nitride containing the residual boron oxide is typically added up to 20 parts by weight for every 100 parts resin as shown in Table 3. The submicron boron nitride containing residual boron oxide is then about 16 wt. % of the resin blend and silica is added at 4.8 wt. %.
The preferred fiber for preparing the braid reinforced polysiloxane composite helical O-rings are S-glass and E-glass. Atkins & Pearce has worked with the inventor to develop a proprietary braid identified as 6×6×6 which essentially uses 6 yarn bobbins to braid a core braid that is then over braided with 2 layers of 6 yarns each that form a near hexagonal braid that is ideal for forming a high temperature helical O-rings (
A simple right cylinder tooling mandrel at the desired O-ring inside diameter is used to apply the prepreg braided fiber around and heat cure by first staging for 30 minutes at 100° C. followed by 200° C. for exhaust manifold applications. The cured helical composite braid is removed from the tooling and cut with a 0.300 inch circumferential overlap as shown in
The fiber reinforcements can be selected from any of the glass (E-glass, S-glass, quartz or chemically altered variations of these), Nextel® or refractory (e.g., zirconia) high temperature fibers or advanced composite graphite or pitch fiber weaves or styles provided by the textile industry. When using graphite or pitch fabrics, electro-less metal (such as nickel or aluminum) coated fibers are preferred for producing these advance composite polysiloxane matrix composites with high performance mechanical properties. Nickel oxide activates the silicone resin blends just as aluminum oxide assuring increased bond strength.
It has been observed by the inventor that the thickness of the composite gaskets is the major cost and performance driver in making such products as automotive or aerospace gaskets have reliable durability. The laminate uniform thickness is the most critical quality control capability requirement for assuring high durability sealing of exhaust manifold gaskets operating at “spike” exhaust gas temperatures of 927° C. Pressure decay testing (Table 4) of laminate gaskets reveals the maximum thickness standard deviation should not be greater than ±0.45×10−3 inches to assure extended durability. Laminates made to the composite gasket's composition requirements and molded to the above thickness standard deviation limits have performed well over 4 years in cab fleet testing (under confidentiality agreement) up to 350,000 miles (exceeding 150,000 mile test requirement).
All optional liquid gaskets have been made and extensively tested in exhaust manifold engine testing. The liquid gaskets require discontinuous fiber weight % of 50% with 50% resin blend. The molded O-rings use a preferred 40 to 50% discontinued fiber weight %. The helical O-rings are made with the Atkins& Pearce “6×6×6” braid reinforcement with the prepreg preferred resin content at 33±3%. The network applied liquid gasket is prepared the same as the liquid gasket. Many prototype parts have been made (under confidentiality agreement) which demonstrate that most engine components of diesel, internal combustion (IC) and turbine engines that operate from 500 to 1000° C. can be made with fiber reinforced composites made with the resin blend.
Examples include engine gaskets, multiple ignition fuel saving devices, turbine engine combustion liners, diesel engine head and exhaust gaskets, aircraft fire walls, and liquid exhaust gaskets, O-rings. Testing (under confidentiality agreement) has been extensive on IC engine dynamometers including cab fleet testing and deep thermal shock, steam testing of head gaskets and multispark ignition prototypes. Automotive, coolant, oil and combustion gas sealing has been tested and reviewed with major automotive companies (under confidentiality agreement) including fleet testing. Liquid exhaust gaskets and multiple ignition composite devices are recent developments which solves current costly pollution and fuel burning efficiency automotive IC engine CAFÉ standards capability requirements.
Fire protective testing of the inventions under FAA typical tests has proven the superior performance of the discoveries to pass the FAA major testing requirements for aircraft interior, cargo container, fire blankets and fire wall requirements. The composites have passed FAA fire penetration, burn through, heat release (<10 kW/m2), smoke density and Boeing toxicity testing per BSS 7239.
The inventions resin blend when used as composite exhaust gasket matrix material has been evaluated for a year (under confidentiality agreement) on Jasper Engine Company Generators powered with Ford 460 V8 truck engines. All engines performed without a problem for 6640 hours which is equivalent to 400,000 miles of truck engine durability. Cab fleet testing has confirmed the durability in performing over 350,000 miles in Crown Victoria 4.6 liter V8 engine exhaust manifold composite gasket testing.
The present application claims benefit from commonly owned, co-pending U.S. Application for Provisional Patent, Application No. 60/936,472, filed Jun. 19, 2007. The present application is related to commonly owned co-pending applications, Silicone Resin Composites for High Temperature Durable Elastic Composite Applications and Methods for Fabricating Same, application Ser. No. ______, and Internal Combustion (IC) Engine Head Assembly Combustion Chamber Multiple Spark Ignition (MSI) Fuel Savings Device and Methods of Fabrication Thereof, application Ser. No. ______, each filed on even day herewith.
Filing Document | Filing Date | Country | Kind | 371c Date |
---|---|---|---|---|
PCT/US08/07719 | 6/19/2008 | WO | 00 | 12/19/2009 |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
60936472 | Jun 2007 | US |