Patent Grant
10166546
The disclosure relates to plates and plate segments for refiners and dispersers (also known as dispergers) used in mechanical pulping and paper recycling processes to produce pulp material and recycled pulp material for various end uses.
In the production of pulp material to be used in the making of paper or other paper based packaging material. One conventional method is to employ a mechanical refiner. Mechanical refiners include, but are not limited to, refiners to process comminuted cellulosic material such as wood chips, etc. to produce pulp, and dispersers typically used in the processing of recycled paper material. Mechanical refiners typically include a set of opposing discs, such as a pair of flat discs at least one of which rotates, a pair of conically shaped discs, and an assembly of parallel flat and conical discs. As feed material moves through a gap between the opposing discs, fibers in the material are separated to produce refined pulp; ink, and other contaminates may be dispersed from paper to produced a recycle pulp material.
Mechanical refiners that produce pulp from wood chips and other comminuted cellulosic material, typically referred to as refiners, have plates with bars and grooves on the front face of their plates. The plates are mounted on opposing discs. The gap between plates with bars and grooves is typically planer and formed between the upper ridges of the bars on opposing plates. Mechanical refiners used to process recycled paper and paperboard material are typically referred to as dispergers or dispersers, and have plates with teeth on the front face of the plates. The gap between opposing plates in a disperser may have a serpentine shape formed by the intermeshing rows of teeth on the opposing front faces of the plates.
The refining or dispersing action occurs as feed material, e.g., wood chips or recycled paper, enters the gap between the discs through an opening in one of the plates. The feed material is driven by centrifugal force to move radially outwardly through the gap and between the front faces of the plates. The refining or dispersing surfaces on the front faces act on the feed material as the material moves through the gap and is subjected to pulsating forces due to the crossing of the bars or teeth on the plates.
Plates may be formed by an annular assembly of plate segments mounted on the discs. The plates are generally an annular array of plate segments, such as pie shaped segments. The segments are mounted side-by-side to form a circular plate mounted onto the disc mounting surface. The plates have a front face with bars and grooves forming refining surfaces in a pulp refiner or rows of teeth forming dispersing surfaces in a disperser. The gap in the refiner or disperser is formed between the front faces of the plates on the opposing discs. The back faces of the plates are mounted to a disc mounting surface. Bolts and other fasteners hold the plates to the disc mounting surface.
Plate segments, for a convention mechanical refiner (capable of handling high, medium or low consistency feed material) or a disperser (capable of handling recycled material feed material), are a critical component of the refining or dispersing equipment. As the feed material moves across the surface of the plate segments, the surface of the fronts of the plate segments wear down. The refining and dispersion action performed by the plate segments become less effective as the plates wear down. The worn plate segments must be replaced. Generally, plate segments are periodically replaced on refiners and dispersers.
A typical annular array of plate segments for a refiner or disperser includes three (3) to twenty four (24) equally-sized plate segments. At every plate change, all segments of an annular array of plate segments are removed and inspected, mounting surface (surface of the discs) cleaned, and the new segments installed. The plate segments that can be reused are cleaned and new segments are substituted for worn segments, typically all plate segments are replaced but there are times when some plate segments may be cleaned and reused. The cleaned and new segments are mounted one-by-one onto the disc mounting surface. The mounting of each segment requires a shimming process to maintain equal spacing between the segments. The mounting also involves applying a proper torque to the fastener securing the segments to the disc mounting surface.
Refiners and dispersers usually have two annular plates arranged opposite to each other in the refiner. In the twin refiners or twin dispersers, there may be four plates arranged in two opposing pairs of plates. The refiner or disperser may have one rotor (which may be a double-sided rotor in a twin refiner or disperser) facing a stationary stator. Alternatively, the refiner or disperser may have opposite counter-rotating rotors. Regardless of the specific disc configuration, the plate segments mounted to the discs are periodically replaced. Plate segment replacement is needed because the refining or dispersing surface on the segments wears down by the abrasiveness of the feed material rubbing against these surfaces. A worn refining or dispersing surface reduces the efficiency of the refiner or disperser.
Plate segments generally must be rigid and structurally strong. The plate segments must support the front faces that comprise many bars and grooves for refiners and teeth for dispersers, which are subjected to continuous refining or dispersing action of the abrasive feed material as they encounter the feed material, centrifugal forces in the refiner or disperser, and stresses from the fasteners, e.g., bolts, that affix the segments to the disc mounting surface. A minimum plate thickness is conventionally in a range of 1.0 to 1.5 inches (25 to 38 millimeters (mm)). Additionally, the back face of the plate segments conventionally have a network of raised ribs, posts surrounding the bolt holes and other raised structures to provide structural support to the segments and to provide abutments that seat against the disc mounting surface.
The thickness requirement and network of raised structures on the plate segments contribute substantially to the mass of the segments. The segments are formed by casting molding metal. The cast plate segments tend to have a large mass (i.e., heavy in weight), which makes the cast plate segments difficult to handle when replacement is necessary. The large mass of the plate segments increases the cost of casting due to the cost for a large amount of metal, cost of shipping and cost to handle and mount the segments to the disc. It is desirable to produce a plate segment using a less amount of metal while meeting the mounting and structural requirements needed for a structurally strong and rigid segment.
A plate segment useful for mechanical refiner plate segments and disperser plate segments has been conceived having a reduced mass (i.e., lighter in weight). The reduction of mass is achieved by minimizing the network of raised ribs and other raised structures on the back face (non-grinder and refining surface) of a conventional plate segment. The novel light weight plate segment has sufficient strength to support the grinding and refining surfaces on the front of the segment without unduly increasing the risk that the segment will break.
The novel plate segment may lack conventional ribs along the edges of the segment, outer diameter (OD) ribs (also referred to as support material), and many (but not all) of the conventional reinforcement ribs or support material. Minimizing the network of raised ribs and other structures reduces the weight of the plate segment by 20 to 40 percent, as compared to conventional plate segments. Using the invention disclosed herein, the network of ribs and other raised structures on the back face of a plate segment may be achieved without adversely affecting the structural integrity and rigidity of the plate segments.
A novel plate segment has been conceived that is configured to be mounted on a disc of a disperser or refiner for comminuted cellulosic material, the segment comprises: a front face including disperser teeth or refining bars; a back face including a raised post surrounding a fastener attachment structure and a raised plate positioning section, and side edges; extending between the side edges are both a radially outer edge and a radially inner edge; wherein the back face lacks raised structures along the side edges.
It is desirable to provide a refiner or disperser plate segment with mass (i.e., weight) removed from the back face of the plate (i.e., the side adjacent the surface of the disc) while maintaining the strength required to provide refining or dispersing actions without structural damage to the plate segments.
The intended functions served by the network of ribs 110 support the conventional wisdom that such a network is needed on a plate segment. The inventors of the light weight plate segments disclosed herein broke from conventional wisdom. The inventors realized that the conventional network of ribs and other raised areas could be replaced by a reduced arrangement of support posts for each bolt hole and a supporting strip associated with each post.
The back face of a novel plate segment that has reduced mass includes raised posts and raised plate positioning sections. Each raised post surrounds one of the bolt holes and has a mounting surface seated against a disc mounting surface. The raised plate positioning sections are also mounting surfaces that seat against the disc mounting surface. The posts and plate positioning sections provide sufficient mounting surfaces to support the plate segment on the disc mounting surface. They also provide structural support to the plate segment.
The posts and the plate positioning sections fix the position of the plate segment with respect to the plate segment. The posts and plate positioning sections may have the only surfaces on the plate segment that abuts the disc mounting surface. An inner ring segment (arc-edge) on the plate segment may also abut the disc mounting surface and fix the plate segment to the disc. The post, plate positioning sections and inner ring segment support the plate segments. Other raised structures on the back face are not needed to support the plate segments.
A light weight refiner or disperser plate segment has been invented comprising radially inner and outer edges; a front face with refining or dispersing features, a back face including a post providing a bolt hole and a raised plate positioning section, wherein the post and plate positioning section include surfaces configured to abut against a disc mounting surface.
One embodiment of this light weight plate segment removes material from the backside of the segment, such as all side and outer diameter (OD) support material, ribs, or support material being strips or mass of solid metal material, and removes most, but not all, reinforcement ribs or support material other than those supporting the plate positioning sections. The embodiment allows reduction in overall weight of the plate segment. The light weight plate segment is less costly to manufacture, easier and less costly to transport, easier to handle (less manpower required to move and install the plates), quicker to install, and safer to handle in both manufacturing and customer premises. This light weight segment allows customers to further optimize their operating and maintenance processes by providing flexibility in the replacement frequency of the plate segments as the plate segments are quicker, safer and easier to change, thereby reducing the costs associated with their replacement.
In an embodiment of the invention the borders or edges of the plate segment are removed with the exception of the border or edge facing the feed flow (such as the inner periphery or diameter). That is, three of the four plate segment borders or edges are removed. The removal of these plate segment borders or edges (three of the four borders or edges) results in even further reduction of the weight of the plate segment.
A border at the inner periphery or diameter of the plate segments, remains such that a ring (referred to as an inner ring or face ring) is formed at the inner diameter of the plates segments. The inner periphery border is important to support the seal. This inner ring may be formed in one piece and assist in positioning the plate segment on the disc. The inner ring may be a single, solid ring section at the radially inward edge of the plate segment. The inner ring allows for improved congruent placement of the plate segments to the disc mounting surface, thereby forming a smooth, continuous series of plate segments into a complete plate.
A seal may be in a grooved space, e.g., about 0.5 to 2.5 mm, between the inner ring and the disc. The seal may be formed by a suitable material, such as a soft flexible seal material or a hard metal to metal seal material.
The light weight plate segments tend to be easier and safer to handle, less costly to manufacture, and apply lower forces to the disc. Replacement of the conventional plate segments with the light weight plate segments may be accomplished quickly. Due to their lighter weight, there is less risk of physical injury to the mill personnel and to personnel involved in the manufacturing of the light weight plate segments. Light weight plate segments can be moved and mounted to the discs quickly as compared to conventional heavier plate segments.
Because the light weight plate segments may be quickly and easily replaced, the period between plate replacements may be shortened without substantially increasing the overall downtime of the refiner or disperser. As the plate segments may be more frequently replaced without decreasing the operating time for a machine, the surface condition of the plate segments over a machine operating period is better (i.e., less worn) than the conventional solid back heavy plate segments. Thus, using the new light weight plate segments in refiners or dispersers allows for a better refining (e.g., fiber rubbing) or dispersing (e.g., contaminant breakage and further removal) action to be maintained which results in an improved final product.
The back face of the light weight plate segment 200 is a substantially flat surface 205, which has a thickness T1, T2 similar to the thickness of the narrowest thickness of a conventional plate segment. The flat surface 205 may be truly planar or may have a slight curvature along a radial direction. The thickness T1, T2 of the light weight plate segment 200 may be substantially constant over the flat surface 205, or the thickness T1, T2 may gradually narrow in a radially outward direction. For example, T1 may be wider than T2 by a factor of 1.2 to 2.5. The thickness T1, T2 may be measured from the flat surface 205 of the back face to the front face and particularly to the bottom of the grooves between the bars on the front face or to the mounting surface at the bottom of the teeth on the front face. The thickness T1, T2 may be in a range of 1.0 to 1.5 inches (25 to 38 millimeters (mm)).
The back face of the light weight plate segment 200 lacks the extensive conventional network of ribs 110 and other raised surfaces, such as shown in
The plate positioning sections 210 and the posts 260 surrounding each of the bolt holes 220 may be the primary raised sections on the back face of the light weight plate segment 200. The plate positioning sections 210 and posts 260 may also include the contact surfaces 212, 215 that abut the disc mounting surface and support the plate segment when mounted to the disc mounting surface. If the disc mounting surface has a flat contact surface, then the contact surfaces 212 on the posts 260 and the contact surfaces 215 on the plate positioning sections 210 may be substantially flat and in a common plane. Alternatively, if the disc mounting surface is conical, the contact surfaces 212, 215 may conform to a conical surface. The contact surfaces 212, 215 cooperate with bolt fasteners to align the light weight plate segments 200 with respect to the disc mounting surface, and the bolt fasteners and contact surfaces 212, 215 carry the forces applied to the light weight plate segments 200.
The plate positioning sections 210 may also have an outer sidewall with a contact surface 280 that abuts a rim or post 260 on the disc mounting surface. The sidewall contact surfaces 280 align the radial position of the plate segment on the disc mounting surface and carry radial forces applied to the plate segment 200. The sidewall contact surfaces 280 replace the “butt pads” on conventional plate segments.
The plate positioning sections 210 may be at the radially outer edge of the plate segment 200 or on the back face between the outer edge and the post 260. Each plate positioning section 210 may be radially aligned with a post 260 such that a radial line from an axis of the disc to which the plate segment 200 is mounted passes through both the post 260 and the plate positioning section 210. Ribs, such as parallel ribs 270 extend from the post 260 to the plate positioning sections 210. The ribs 270 may have a height less than the height of the post 260 or plate positioning sections 210. The ribs 270 may also be a pair of ribs 270 extending from the post 260 to the plate positioning section 210. The ribs 270 provide structural support for the plate positioning sections 210 and posts 260. The ribs 270 may extend along radial lines from an axis of the disc or be parallel pairs of ribs 270.
In some embodiments, the ribs 270 may have the same height as the outer periphery plate positioning sections 210 (solid material sections) and may end at the post 260 where the height at the plate positioning section 210 end is in a range of between the post 260 height and half the height of post 260.
The width W of the contact surface 215 on the plate positioning sections 210 may be substantially, e.g., within 20 percent, of the diameter of the post 260. For example, the width W of the contact surface 215 and diameter of the post 260 may be in a range of 3 mm to 30 mm. The height of the plate positioning section 210 and post 260 may also be substantially, e.g., within 20 percent, the same or in a range of 2 mm to 50 mm.
The inner ring 330 may be a separate component from the light weight plate segment 300 to avoid adding mass to the plate segment. The inner ring 330 may be a one piece annular ring that fits around the center cap (not shown) of the refiner or disperser. The inner ring 330 may have a width WE of approximately 1 inch (25 mm) and a height substantially the same as the thickness of the light weight plate segment 300 at the inner most edge 385 of the light weight plate segment 300. A seal 390 may be placed between the inner most edge 385 of the light weight plate segment 300 and the outermost edge 350 of the inner ring 330. The seal 390 is made of suitable material (material capable of withstanding the operating environment of temperature, chemicals, etc. in a refiner or disperser).
During manufacturing, e.g., casting, of the light weight plate segments 300, tighter tolerances on the sides of the light weight plate segments 300 may be to reduce the opening between adjacent light weight plate segments 300 when mounted to the stator or the rotor disc, thereby removing the need for a raised border (such as edge rib 140 shown in
The inner ring 330 prevents feed material entering the region between the plate segments and mounting surface of the disc. Feed material going between the plate segment and the mounting surface of the disc cause plate segment balance problems. If the light weight plate segments 300 become off balance, the refiner or disperser machine may begin to vibrate and would need to be shut down for cleaning and replacement of the light weight plate segments 300 (the same being true for conventional plate segments 100 as shown in
The inner ring 330 may be the thickness of the thickest part of the light weight plate segment 300, and may be removed from the surface of the disc or may remain in position on the disc allowing for easy removal of the light weight plate segment 300. The inner ring 330 may also be part of the center cap of the refiner or disperser. The inner ring 330 as a functional feature may also be integrated into the center cap, so that it is not a separate part.
This inner ring 330 need not come in direct contact with the light weight plate segments 300. Its primary purpose is to prevent the fiber material from getting to the back side of the light weight plate segments 300. The light weight plate segments 300 can be either cast or machined to achieve tight enough tolerances in between them, so that the fiber does not go behind the light weight plate segments 300. Outer diameter edge of the light weight plate segments 300 is left open with the idea that centrifugal force will keep the area free of unwanted material. The material of the inner ring 330 is a material suitable for use in the abrasive environment experienced by plate segments of the refiner and disperser machines.
The contact surface 215 on the positioning section 210 and contact surface 212 on the post 260 are in substantially the same contact plane 406. The radially inner most edge 485 of the light weight plate segment 400 may also have a contact edge in the contact plane 406. Similarly, the inner ring 430 has a contact surface in the contact plane 406. The contact plane 406 conforms to the mounting surface of the disc. If the mounting surface is not planar, e.g., conical, then the contact surfaces 215 and 212, as well as the inner most edge 485 and inner ring 430 are aligned with the mounting surface and not aligned in a plane.
The light weight plate segment 400 has an inner most edge 485 facing and opposite to the outermost edge 450 of the inner ring 430. The opposing edges may have surfaces designed for one or more of simplicity, supporting a seal between the opposing edges and aligning the plate segment on the disc mounting surface.
The inner ring 430 may also include a lower surface 454 that is not slanted, e.g., parallel to the axis of the disc. The corner between the lower surface 454 and the slanted edge surface 453 provides an abutment to the slanted inner edge surface 483 of the light weight plate segment 400B. The abutment assists in preventing debris and feed material from passing through the slanted space 497.
In
The inner lip 498 extends radially outward under an inner portion of the light weight plate segment 400C. The inner lip 498 and the corner between the inner lip 498 and slanted space 497 prevent feed material and debris from entering the region 493 between the light weight plate segment 400C and disc mounting surface 492. A seal (not shown) may be positioned in the region 493 and between the inner lip 498 and the light weight plate segment 400C.
The grooved sector 510 may be located near and radially outward of the inner most edge 585 of the light weight plate segment 500. The seal 520 between the back face ring section 588 and disc mounting surface 586 prevents feed material and debris entering the region between the light weight plate segment 500 and disc mounting surface 586.
The inner most edge 414 is similar to the inner most edge 585 shown in
A fastener, such as a bolt 718, extends from the disc 714, 716 into the bolt holes of the posts 720 on the back face of the light weight plate segments 710, 712. The bolts 718 fasten the light weight plate segment 710, 712 to the disc 714, 716. The contact surface 722 on the post 720 and the contact surface 724 on the plate positioning sections 726 abut the disc mounting surface 728 of the disc 714, 716. The bolt fastener and the abutments between the contact surfaces 722 and the mounting surface 728 fix the light weight plate segment 710, 712 to the disc 714, 716.
A ledge 730 on disc mounting surface 728 may abut a sidewall contact surface 732 on each of the plate positioning sections 726. The ledge 730 resists radial movement of the light weight plate segment 710, 712 and aligns the light weight plate segment 710, 712 on the disc 714, 716. An annular seal 734 on the disc mounting surface seats in a space 736 on an inner edge region of the light weight plate segment 710, 712. The seal 734 prevents feed material (represented by arrow 738) from getting in the region behind the light weight plate segment 710, 712 and between the light weight plate segment 710, 712 and disc 714, 716. The feed material 738 moves radially outward and between the opposing front faces of the light weight plate segment 710, 712.
The plate segments may be formed by casting metal. Conventional manufacturing processes include pouring melted metal into a mold having the desired design for the specific plate segment of interest. Once the molded plate segment has cooled, the plate segment is removed from the mold and sent for cleaning and gate removal followed by grinding and rough inspection including bolt hole preparation, a second grinding step, robotic grinding of the plate segment prior to heat treatment and precision grinding.
For the light weight plate segments disclosed herein, a modified conventional manufacturing process is possible. The modified manufacturing process provides a lighter weight plate segment, thereby significantly reducing manufacturing steps and cost of manufacturing without adversely impacting the strength of the new, lighter weight plate segment.
Manufacturing of the light weight plate segment design begins with casting of the plate segment by taking molten metal 901, and pouring molten metal into a mold 910. The mold to be used has the new back face surface design that is largely devoid of raised surfaces, such as the conventional network of ribs and particularly the ribs around the edges and sides of the segment. The mold may include features for forming the raised surfaces, such as the post, positioning section and mass support ribs. Once the mold has been filed with molten metal, the molded plate segment is allowed to cool 912 to a temperature that is sufficient for safe handling.
The cooled light weight plate segment is removed from the mold. The molded plate is cleaned and molding gates are removed 914 by grinding. Rough inspection and bolt hole preparation are also performed on the molded light weight plate segment. At this point the light weight plate segment may be ready for shipment 918 to the customer 950, or optionally, the light weight plate segment may undergo the manufacturing steps of robotic rough grinding 920 and possibly precision grinding 922, and heat treatment 924 before shipment 918. If the optional manufacturing process step of heat treatment is excluded, the metal material used to form the light weight plate segment may have sufficient strength to produce a light weight plate segment such that a heat treatment step is unnecessary.
Due to the lower manufacturing costs of the light weight plate segment, a mill plan with refiners or dispersers may be able to afford more frequent replacement of sets of plate segments. Replacement of the light weight plates can be accomplished more easily, in less time and safer as compared to heavier plates. More frequent replacement of plates allows for more efficient refining or dispersing because the plates are replaced before their bars or teeth become dull or broken.
When an inner ring is present, the light weight plate segments may be removed from the stator and rotor discs without removing the inner ring itself. The inner ring may be incorporated to the center cap of the disc. When the inner ring becomes damaged or requires replacement it is removed at the same time as the light weight plates.
Using the combined light weight plate segment and the inner ring in the inner diameter of the light weight plate segment will result in multiple advantages over the conventional plate segments used in refining and dispersing machines. These advantages include: less material needed to manufacture the plate segments; ease of removing and installing the plate segments thereby reducing time required to remove and install plate segments; reduced transportation costs for both the new plate segments being delivered to the mill and the cost to return used plate segments (used plate segments are typically returned to the manufacturer so the metal can be reclaimed); because of the lighter weight of the plate segments, handling of the light weight plate segments is safer for the mill personnel as well as others involved in the transport of the plate segments.
In another alternative embodiment, the backside of the light weight plate segment may have a groove space on the backside of the plate segment to hold a seal. The groove space for the seal is set back, radially inward from the edge of the inner periphery of the backside of the light weight plate segment. The seal material is a flexible material capable of withstanding the operating (temperature, chemical, etc.) environment of the machine without decomposing while holding the light weight plate segment to the mounting surface of the disc.
While preferred embodiments have been shown and described, various modifications and substitutions may be made thereto without departing from the spirit and scope of the invention. Accordingly, it is to be understood that the present invention has been described by way of illustration and not limitation.
This application claims priority and incorporates by reference U.S. provisional application Ser. No. 61/823,566 filed May 15, 2013.
| Number | Name | Date | Kind |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1160964 | Warren | Nov 1915 | A |
| 3104837 | Steinlger | Sep 1963 | A |
| 3125306 | Kollberg | Mar 1964 | A |
| 3326480 | Jones | Jun 1967 | A |
| 3387796 | Cormack et al. | Jun 1968 | A |
| 3910511 | Leider | Oct 1975 | A |
| 4005827 | Frair | Feb 1977 | A |
| 4023737 | Leider | May 1977 | A |
| 4023739 | Lampe et al. | May 1977 | A |
| 4157669 | Pilao | Jun 1979 | A |
| 4274602 | Johansson | Jun 1981 | A |
| 4610400 | Sjobom | Sep 1986 | A |
| 4620675 | Kirchner | Nov 1986 | A |
| 4628643 | Gile | Dec 1986 | A |
| 4676440 | Perkola | Jun 1987 | A |
| 4896838 | Vendelin | Jan 1990 | A |
| 5048768 | Bernhard | Sep 1991 | A |
| 5203514 | Mokvist | Apr 1993 | A |
| 5228629 | Bernhard | Jul 1993 | A |
| 5335865 | Kohler | Aug 1994 | A |
| 5373995 | Johannson | Dec 1994 | A |
| 5425508 | Chaney | Jun 1995 | A |
| 5449122 | Berger | Sep 1995 | A |
| 5747707 | Johansson | May 1998 | A |
| 5823453 | Garasimowicz | Oct 1998 | A |
| 5836525 | Garnier | Nov 1998 | A |
| 5875982 | Underberg | Mar 1999 | A |
| 5979809 | Bartels et al. | Nov 1999 | A |
| 6024308 | Bartels | Feb 2000 | A |
| 6053440 | LaRiviere | Apr 2000 | A |
| 6189821 | James | Feb 2001 | B1 |
| 6250573 | Kriebel | Jun 2001 | B1 |
| 6616078 | Gingras | Sep 2003 | B1 |
| 6969019 | Aikawa | Nov 2005 | B2 |
| 7419112 | Sjostrom | Sep 2008 | B2 |
| 7758726 | Sabourin | Jul 2010 | B2 |
| 7766269 | Gingras | Aug 2010 | B2 |
| 8061643 | Gingras | Nov 2011 | B2 |
| 8573521 | Gingras | Nov 2013 | B2 |
| 9181654 | Gingras | Nov 2015 | B2 |
| 9670615 | Gingras | Jun 2017 | B2 |
| 20020070303 | Johansson | Jun 2002 | A1 |
| 20020166912 | Schneid | Nov 2002 | A1 |
| 20030071155 | Healey | Apr 2003 | A1 |
| 20050167538 | Doelle | Aug 2005 | A1 |
| 20050211809 | Lutz | Sep 2005 | A1 |
| 20060175447 | Duggan | Aug 2006 | A1 |
| 20060192040 | Johansson | Aug 2006 | A1 |
| 20060289689 | Matthew | Dec 2006 | A1 |
| 20070095962 | Virving | May 2007 | A1 |
| 20080191078 | Gingras | Aug 2008 | A1 |
| 20090200411 | Stager | Aug 2009 | A1 |
| 20090242679 | Briggs, Jr. | Oct 2009 | A1 |
| 20090256020 | Sued | Oct 2009 | A1 |
| 20090302140 | Johansson | Dec 2009 | A1 |
| 20120024999 | Hackl | Feb 2012 | A1 |
| 20120032014 | Wang | Feb 2012 | A1 |
| 20120267459 | Beirakh | Oct 2012 | A1 |
| 20130284841 | Pellman | Oct 2013 | A1 |
| 20140196858 | Gingras | Jul 2014 | A1 |
| 20140339348 | Rehnstrom | Nov 2014 | A1 |
| 20160045919 | McDaniel | Feb 2016 | A1 |
| 20160138220 | Gingras | May 2016 | A1 |
| Number | Date | Country |
|---|---|---|
| 47-16244 | May 1972 | JP |
| 51-123718 | Oct 1976 | JP |
| 60-501063 | Jul 1985 | JP |
| WO 8404057 | Oct 1984 | WO |
| Entry |
|---|
| Office Action dated Aug. 3, 2016, in a corresponding Japanese Patent Application No. 2014-099151 (3 pages), and a partial English translation thereof (4 pages). |
| Extended European Search Report, Munich Germany, Application No. 14167866.4-1710/280376, dated Jan. 1, 2015, pp. 1-5. |
| Chinese Office Action, dated Jun. 12, 2017, Chinese Patent Office, Beijing, China. |
| Number | Date | Country | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 20140339348 A1 | Nov 2014 | US |
| Number | Date | Country | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 61823566 | May 2013 | US |
