The present invention relates generally to carbon dioxide capture and the regeneration of reagents relating to the carbon dioxide capture, particularly chemical regeneration of an alkali absorbent solution and carbon dioxide by the chemical reaction of sodium bicarbonate with an acid and the resultant solution subjected to electrodialysis with bipolar membrane separation for regenerating the alkali absorbent solution and the acid reagent.
Flue gas emissions—the emitted material produced when fossil fuels such as coal, oil, natural gas, or wood are burned for heat or power—may contain pollutants, including carbon dioxide (CO2), nitrogen oxides (NOx) and sulfur oxides (SOx). Capturing flue gases from power plants is typically a multi-step process.
With current environmental regulations, CO2 capture is very crucial for the survival of coal-fired power plants in the near future. Efforts to capture CO2 at some power plants have been successful, but the cost of installing and operating the required equipment is high. As such, very few power plants have carbon capture and storage (CSS) systems. In order for the sale of captured CO2 to become a profitable venture, the cost of capturing the CO2 from a flue gas must be reduced.
Several post-combustion CO2 capture technologies exist, such as chemical absorption, physical adsorption and membrane separation. Among all of the CO2 capture technologies, post combustion chemical absorption CO2 capture is the most mature, competitive and economically viable for CO2 capture from fossil fuel fired power plants. The only draw back associated with post combustion capture is the high energy requirement for CO2 capture reagent regeneration.
Reagent regeneration energy accounts for approximately 70% of the CO2 capture costs. It has previously been reported that thermal regeneration energy with amine solvents is in the range of 3-4 MJ/Kg of CO2 captured. This makes thermal regeneration highly energy intensive, increasing the overall CO2 capture costs to around 55-60 $/ton of CO2 captured. In order to reduce this cost and make CO2 capture affordable, alternate reagent regeneration routes have to be explored.
Previously, CO2 capture with NaOH and direct electrodialysis of resulting NaHCO3 solution for regenerating NaOH and CO2 in the electrolysis with dipolar membrane (EDBM) cell has been examined, which has a lot of process inefficiencies such as low current efficiency, low CO2 recovery (40-60%) and high cell resistance, etc, as discussed below. Amines, ammonia and alkaline solutions have been thoroughly studied by several researchers as absorbents to capture CO2 from post-combustion flue gases. Extensive research has been performed on the aspects of absorption process, reagent efficiency, mass transfer coefficient, etc. The chemical reactions for CO2 capture with alkali absorbent solutions of sodium hydroxide (NaOH) and sodium carbonate (Na2CO3) are shown in Equations (1)-(3):
CO2(aq)+H2O(l)→H2CO3(aq) (1)
H2CO3 (aq)+Na2CO3 (aq)→NaHCO3(aq) (2)
NaOH(aq)+H2CO3(aq)↔NaHCO3(aq)+H2O(l) (3)
When CO2 is dissolved in water it forms carbonic acid (H2CO3) as shown in Equation (1), which reacts with an alkali absorbent, such as sodium carbonate (Na2CO3) in Equation (2) and sodium hydroxide (NaOH) in Equation (3), to form sodium bicarbonate (NaHCO3). While Na2CO; solution and NaOH solution have varying chemical absorption for CO2 capture from flue gas, one of the major problems facing post-combustion CO2 capture is the high energy requirement for reagent regeneration.
Reagent regeneration is the most energy intensive step in post combustion CO2 capture process. One approach to reagent regeneration is thermal regeneration as shown in
A different approach to thermal regeneration involves capturing CO2 with an alkali absorbent solution and then directly regenerating the CO2 by electrodialysis of the resultant NaHCO3 solution. Not only has the study of this process been limited, but there are many draw backs associated with direct electrodialysis of a NaHCO3 solution. One draw back is part of the energy for catalyzing the reaction between the H+ and HCO3− ions for producing CO2. Another draw back is that the presence of CO2 gas bubbles in the electrodialysis cell increases electrical resistance across the cell, reducing electrical conductivity and resulting in low current efficiency and high energy consumption. Also, it has been reported that the CO2 recoveries are only 40-60% with the lowest energy being 2.1 MJ/Kg CO2. A further observed electrodialysis drawback of CO2 loaded monoethanolamine (MEA) solution is membrane degradation due to heat stable salt anions. Still further, during direct electrodialysis, as the current density of the EDBM cell increases, the CO2 recovery often increases, but the tremendous increase in energy consumption does not make the high CO2 recovery a very good trade off at higher current densities. Still further, due to the presence of gas bubbles in the EDBM cell, elevated pressures as high as 10 atm have to be applied to keep the CO2 in the solution phase until the pressure is released downstream, which drastically increases pumping and other variable costs.
Accordingly, there is a need in the industry to decrease reagent cost for post-combustion CO2 capture. There is also a need in the industry to provide reagents for CO2 capture that have an acceptable absorption rate and low energy regeneration of the reagents, such that the reagents can be recycled and reused for additional acceptable absorption of CO2 capture. There is still further a need in the industry to provide acceptable CO2 capture with reagents that do not result in undesirable oxidative degradation and corrosion of equipment or that are harmful to the environmental.
The system and processes of the present invention meet the needs of the industry by providing reagents for CO2 capture that have an acceptable absorption rate, low energy regeneration of the reagents, such that the reagents can be recycled and reused for additional acceptable absorption of CO2 capture, reagents that do not result in undesirable oxidative degradation and corrosion of equipment, and a technology that is economically feasible while also being environmentally benign.
In some aspects, the system and process of the present disclosure is directed to carbon dioxide capture with reagent regeneration having reduced energy consumption, particularly carbon dioxide captured from a flue gas employing a scrubber solution in a scrubber column.
In some aspects, the system of the present invention comprises a scrubber column having a scrubber solution configured to capture carbon dioxide in the scrubber column by a gaseous feedstock reacting with the scrubber solution to form a sodium bicarbonate solution, the system further comprising a reaction tank whereby carbon dioxide is capable of being regenerated from the sodium bicarbonate solution by reaction with an acid providing regenerated carbon dioxide in a clean form and a resultant salt solution, the system further comprising an electrodialysis regeneration unit having a bipolar separation membrane whereby the resultant salt solution can be subjected to electrodialysis with bipolar membrane separation for separation of the resultant salt solution into an acid and base. In some preferred aspects, the regenerated base can be circulated back to the scrubber column to capture additional carbon dioxide as a scrubbing solution. In some preferred aspects, the regenerated acid can be circulated back to an acid reaction tank for additional acid reaction with sodium bicarbonate for carbon dioxide regeneration. In some preferred aspects the system provides a continual loop of carbon dioxide capture from the gaseous feedstock and reagent regeneration.
In some aspects, the process of the present invention comprises feeding a gaseous stream into a scrubber column having a scrubber solution, the scrubber solution configured to capture carbon dioxide in the scrubber column from the gaseous feedstock by reacting the carbon dioxide in the gaseous stream with the scrubber solution to form a sodium bicarbonate solution. The process further comprising feeding the sodium carbonate solution from the scrubber column to an acid reaction tank, and reacting the sodium carbonate solution with an acid in the acid tank to regenerate carbon dioxide from the sodium bicarbonate solution and also form a resultant salt solution, the carbon dioxide preferably being provided in a clean form. The process further comprising feeding the resultant salt solution to an electrodialysis regeneration unit having a bipolar separation membrane for regeneration of the slurry solution and the acid, and subjecting the resultant salt solution to electrodialysis with bipolar membrane separation for separating the resultant salt solution into the regenerated acid and 30) base. In some preferred aspects, the regenerated base is the slurry solution, which can be circulated back to the scrubber column to capture additional carbon dioxide as a scrubbing solution. In some preferred aspects, the regenerated acid can be circulated back to an acid reaction tank for additional acid reaction with sodium bicarbonate for carbon dioxide regeneration. In some preferred aspects the processes is continual, such that carbon dioxide is continually captured from the gaseous feedstock by the slurry solution in the slurry column, and the reagents employed for carbon dioxide capture and regeneration are also capable of being regenerated.
In some preferred aspects of the system and process, the scrubbing solution for capturing CO2 in the scrubbing column is an alkali absorbent solution. In some aspects, the scrubbing solution is an alkali metal hydroxide solution. In some preferred aspects, the scrubbing solution is sodium hydroxide (NaOH), potassium hydroxide (KOH), or a combination thereof. In some preferred aspects, the scrubbing solution comprises sodium hydroxide.
In some preferred aspects of the system and process, the acid for regenerating CO2 from the NaHCO3 solution is an organic, a mineral acid, or a combination thereof. In some preferred aspects, the acid comprising a mineral acid. In some more preferred aspects, the acid comprises sulfuric acid (H2SO4), such that the acid regeneration to form CO2 provide the resultant salt solution comprising a sodium sulfate (Na2SO4) solution.
In some preferred aspects of the system and process, electrodialysis with bipolar membrane separation (EDBM) is employed on the resultant salt solution to separate an alkali metal hydroxide solution from a mineral acid, more preferably to separate sodium hydroxide, potassium hydroxide, or a combination thereof from sulfuric acid, and even more preferably to separate sodium hydroxide from sulfuric acid. In some preferred aspects, the regenerated base, preferably an alkali metal hydroxide solution, more preferably sodium hydroxide, potassium hydroxide, or a combination, and even more preferably sodium hydroxide, is circulated back to the scrubber column as a scrubber solution for additional capture of carbon dioxide from the gaseous stream. In some preferred aspects, the regenerated acid, preferably an organic acid, a mineral acid, or a combination thereof, preferably a mineral acid, more preferably sulfuric acid, is circulated back to the acid reaction tank as an acid additional reaction with sodium bicarbonate to regenerate carbon dioxide and a salt solution.
In some aspects, the EDBM unit comprises one or more EDBM cells. In some aspects, the EDBM unit comprises two or more EDBM cells. In some other aspects, the EDBM unit comprises a plurality of EDBM cells. In some aspects, a EDBM unit may comprise between 1 and about 10,000 EDBM cells, in some aspects between about 10 and about 5,000 EDBM cells, in some aspects between about 50 and about 4,000 EDBM cells, in some aspects between about 100 and about 3,500 EDBM cells, in some aspects between about 250 and about 3,250 EDBM cells, and in some other aspects between about 500 and about 3,000 EDBM cells.
In some aspects, each EDBM cell includes at least one cation exchange membrane and at least one bipolar membrane, each of the cation exchange and bipolar membranes proximately located between an anode and a cathode. In some aspects, each EDBM cell includes at least one cation exchange membrane and at least two bipolar membranes, wherein the cation exchange membrane proximately located between two of the at least two bipolar membranes, such that the membranes are proximately located between an anode and a cathode. In some aspects, each EDBM cell includes a series of membrane assemblies, each membrane assembly having at least one cation exchange membrane and at least two bipolar membranes, wherein each cation exchange membrane proximately located between two adjacent bipolar membranes, such that the membranes are proximately located between an anode and a cathode.
In some aspects, each EDBM cell has at least one acid compartment and at least one base compartment. In some aspects, the base compartment is the space between a cation exchange membrane and an adjacent bipolar membrane that is proximately located on the cathode side of the cation exchange membrane. In some aspects, the acid compartment is the space between the cation exchange membrane and an adjacent bipolar membrane proximately that is located on the anode side of the cation exchange membrane.
In some aspects, the scrubbing column is a counter current absorption column.
In some aspects, the regenerated sodium hydroxide solution fed to the scrubbing column, reaction of the CO2 of the gaseous mixture fed into the scrubber column with the regenerated sodium hydroxide solution to provide a sodium bicarbonate solution, the sodium bicarbonate solution being subjected to an acid for carbon dioxide regeneration and to provide a salt solution, and the regeneration and separation of the acid and base from the salt solution, is continuous comprising one or more regeneration cycles.
In some aspects, CO2 regeneration of at least 90% is achieved, in some aspects at least 95%, in some aspects at least 98%, in some aspects at least 99%, in some aspects at least 99.5%, in some aspects at least 99.9%, and in some aspects essentially 100%.
In some aspects of the system and process, a concentration of sodium hydroxide in the scrubbing solution is between about 0.1 and about 0.4 mol/L, more preferably between about 0.225 and about 0). 375 mol/L, more preferably between about 0.25 and about 0.35 mol/L.
In some aspects, the EDBM unit comprises a two-compartment configuration or a three-compartment configuration, preferably a two-compartment configuration.
In some aspects, a current density of the EDBM unit is over 100 A/m2, in some aspects over about 100 A/m2, in some aspects over about 110 A/m2, in some aspects over about 120 A/m2, in some aspects over about 130 A/m2, and in some preferred aspects over about 140 A/m2. In some aspects, the current density of the EDBM unit is less than about 200 A/m2, in some aspects less than about 195 A/m2, in some aspects less than about 190 A/m2, in some aspects less than about 185 A/m2, and in some preferred aspects less than about 180 A/m2. In some aspects, the current density of the EDBM unit is over 100 A/m2 and less than about 200 A/m2, in some aspects over about 110 A/m2 and less than about 190 A/m2, in some aspects over about 120 A/m2 and less than about 195 A/m2, in some aspects over about 130 A/m2 and less than about 185 A/m2, and in some preferred aspects over about 140 A/m2 and less than about 180 A/m2.
In some aspects, a current efficiency of the EDBM unit is at least 80%, in some aspects at least about 85%, in some aspects at least about 90%, and in some other aspects at least about 95%.
In some aspects of the system and process, a concentration of sodium hydroxide regenerated by the EDBM unit is between about 0.1 and about 0.4 mol/L, more preferably between about 0.225 and about 0.375 mol/L, more preferably between about 0.25 and about 0.35 mol/L.
In some aspects, a regeneration energy for the system and process of the present invention is less than about 3.0 MJ/KgCO2, preferably less than about 2.5 MJ/KgCO2, preferably less than about 2.0 MJ/KgCO2, preferably less than about 1.5 MJ/KgCO2, preferably less than about 1.4 MJ/KgCO2, preferably less than about 1.3 MJ/KgCO2, preferably less than about 1.2 MJ/KgCO2, preferably less than about 1.1 MJ/KgCO2, and preferably less than about 1.0 MJ/KgCO2.
In some aspects, the system and process are capable of regeneration of carbon dioxide, acid and/or base at room temperature.
In some aspects, the system and process are capable of regeneration of carbon dioxide, acid and/or base at atmospheric pressure conditions.
In some aspects, the system and process are capable of regeneration of carbon dioxide, acid and/or base at room temperature and atmospheric pressure conditions.
In some aspects, the system and process further comprise a filtration assembly prior to the scrubber column, wherein the filtration assembly filters particulates from the gaseous feedstock.
The above summary is not intended to describe each illustrated embodiment or every implementation of the subject matter hereof. The figures and the detailed description that follow more particularly exemplify various embodiments.
Subject matter hereof may be more completely understood in consideration of the following detailed description of various embodiments in connection with the accompanying figures, in which:
While various embodiments are amenable to various modifications and alternative forms, specifics thereof have been shown by way of example in the drawings and will be described in detail. It should be understood, however, that the intention is not to limit the claimed inventions to the particular embodiments described. On the contrary, the intention is to cover all modifications, equivalents, and alternatives falling within the spirit and scope of the subject matter as defined by the claims.
Post combustion CO2 capture with reagents such as amines, sodium carbonate and sodium hydroxide is the most mature CO2 capture technology. One of the major challenges facing post combustion CO2 capture is the high energy requirement for reagent regeneration. Thermal regeneration energy is currently in the range of 3-4 MJ/Kg CO2 captured.
The present inventors were able to significantly reduce reagent regeneration energy by employing electrodialysis with bipolar membrane separation (EDBM), as shown in
As shown by the process flow diagram in
Capture assembly 110 can comprise any apparatus or system for capturing CO2 from a feedstock. In some preferred aspects as shown by the process flow diagram in
Slurry scrubbing solution 114 and gaseous feedstock 130 are each preferably fed into scrubbing column 112, such that scrubber assembly 110 is capable of providing continuous CO2 capture. During normal operation, CO2 is absorbed from gaseous feedstock 130 by slurry scrubbing solution 114 providing resultant product 140, which is preferably a resultant product solution, configured to exit scrubbing column 112 proximate at a resultant product outlet 142, preferably proximately located bottom portion 134 of scrubbing column 112, providing resultant product stream 144. Gaseous feedstock 130 preferably being a flue gas or other carbon dioxide containing gaseous feedstock. A stream of resultant product 140 from scrubbing column 112 can be introduced into regeneration assembly 120. In some preferred aspects, resultant product 140) comprises a sodium bicarbonate solution. In some preferred aspects, a stream of resultant product 140 is continuously introduced into regeneration assembly 120.
Regeneration assembly 120 preferably comprises a reaction tank. Resultant product 140 introduced into regeneration assembly 140 can be reacted with an acid reagent 145 to regenerate CO2 160 in a purified form and a resultant salt solution 150. In some preferred aspects, acid reagent 145 comprises sulfuric acid. In some preferred aspects, resultant salt solution 150 preferably comprises a sodium carbonate solution.
Resultant salt solution 150 can be fed to EDPM assembly 140, wherein resultant salt solution 150 can be subjected to electrodialysis with one or more CEM and BPM to separate acid and base as regenerated acid 145 and regenerated base 170, respectively.
Regenerated base 170 can be circulated back to capture assembly 110, which in the instance of a scrubbing assembly to the scrubbing column 112 as scrubbing solution 114 to capture additional CO2. In instances where regenerated base 170 is circulated back to scrubbing column 112 as slurry scrubbing solution 114, regenerated base 170 can comprise a portion of scrubbing solution 114, such as being mixed with a fresh portion of slurry scrubbing solution 114. In some alternative aspects, regenerated base 170 is continually circulated, such that regenerated base 170 becomes regenerated scrubbing solution that is part and parcel of slurry scrubbing solution 114 once introduced into slurry column 112. In some preferred aspects, regenerated slurry scrubbing solution preferably comprising sodium hydroxide, sodium carbonate, or a mixture thereof. In some other preferred aspects, regenerated slurry scrubbing solution comprises sodium hydroxide.
Regenerated acid 145 can be circulated back to regeneration assembly 120 for additional reaction with resultant product 140 to regenerated CO2 160 and resultant salt solution 150.
As provided by the foregoing disclosure of CO2 capture and regeneration system 100, the process of capture and regenerating CO2 and the associated reagents can be a continuous process. In certain aspects of the present invention. NaHCO3 formed in the capture assembly 110 can be subjected to acid regeneration in the presence of an acid to regenerate CO2 in a purified form and form a resultant salt solution, and then the resultant salt solution can be subjected to EDBM to regenerate an alkali absorbent solution. Employing the acid regeneration and EDBM to the resultant salt solution not only regenerates a high level of CO2, but the separation of a salt solution into acid and base, such that the starting acid and base reagents are also substantially regenerated. Accordingly, the alkali absorbent solutions that can capture CO2 from the gaseous feedstock, such as a flue gas, can be recycled and reused, preferably recycled and reused in a continuous manner.
In some aspects, the system and process of the present invention includes capturing CO2 in a scrubbing column with a scrubbing solution, in some aspects an alkali absorbent solution, in some aspects an alkali metal hydroxide solution, in some preferred aspects sodium hydroxide (NaOH), to form a NaHCO3 solution, and then regenerating pure CO2 by an acid regeneration process comprising reacting the NaHCO3 solution with an acid, in some aspects a mineral acid, in some preferred aspects sulfuric acid (H2SO4), to form a resultant salt solution, in some preferred aspects a sodium sulfate (Na2SO4) solution.
In some aspects, the resultant salt solution, such as the preferred Na2SO4 solution, is subjected to electrodialysis with bipolar membrane (EDBM) for regenerating the starting scrubbing solution, such as the preferred alkali absorbent solution, more preferably the NaOH solution. The EDBM also regenerates the acid that reacts with the NaHCO3 solution. One unique aspect of acid regeneration is the high recovery of CO2, which then allows employing the EDBM method to essentially separate the salt solution into acid and base, thus achieving low reagent regeneration energy of CO2 and the scrubbing solution.
In some aspects, the reagent regeneration of the present invention eliminates the disadvantages of direct electrodialysis of NaHCO3, such as low current efficiency, low CO2 recovery (40-60%) and high cell resistance.
Also, switching from toxic reagents like amines to alkali absorbents like sodium carbonate and sodium hydroxide can further save reagent costs. Still further, the cost of reagent regeneration energy utilizing EDBM according to certain embodiments of the present invention is anticipated to even go down further as membrane prices decrease in cost. Solar energy, or other renewable energy sources, can be used for energizing EDBM cell, further minimizing energy costs. These traits not only make the technology of the present invention economically feasible, but also environmentally benign.
The chemical reactions for CO2 capture with alkali absorbent solutions of NaOH and Na2CO3 are shown in Equations (1)-(3):
CO2(aq)+H2O(l)→H2CO3(aq) (1)
H2CO3(aq)+Na2CO3(aq)→NaHCO3(aq) (2)
NaOH(aq)+H2CO3(aq)↔NaHCO3(aq)+H2O(l) (3)
As provided in
For example, the reaction in Equation (4) has been found to effectively liberate CO2 from bicarbonate:
H2SO4+2NaHCO3→Na2SO4+2H2O+2CO2 (4)
As provided in
Without wishing to be bound by theory, the EDBM process uses a bi-polar membrane to specifically catalyze water dissociation to form free protons and hydroxide anions as shown in Equation (5):
H2O→H++OH− (5)
Then, as shown in
It is also noted that the function of an ion exchange membrane is to act like a thin selective barrier. Such membranes enable the electrically-driven selective transfer of ions between the two solutions, which they separate. Ion exchange membranes are composed of a polymer matrix on which are fixed ionized functional groups. These fixed charges are neutralized by mobile ions of opposite charge, called counter ions. Due to the Donnan effect, in an electrolyte solution, such membrane tends to reject ions with the same charge as the ionized groups, called co-ions. The cation exchange membranes (CEM) utilized in the EDBM exchange only cations between cathode and anode compartments, which is in contrast to anion exchange membranes (AEM) that exchange only anions between the electrode compartments in an electrolysis cell.
The bipolar membrane (BPM) utilized in the EDBM is composed of one cation-exchange layer and one anion-exchange layer joined together, which is used for water splitting. In contrast to cationic and anionic membranes, bipolar membranes have a required orientation between the electrodes: the anion-exchange layer should be oriented towards the cathode, and cation-exchange layer should be oriented towards the anode. If BPMs are placed with the wrong orientation, ions accumulate between the two layers resulting in blistering of the membranes. Unlike the conventional electrolysis, gas generation is minimized in the EDBM process due to membranes restricting the H′ and OH ions from reaching the electrode. Hence, theoretically the energy requirement is reduced to about 40% of what is required for water electrolysis. With an increase in number of unit cells or membrane stacks in the EDBM compartment, total energy consumption decreases, due to decrease in energy consumption in electrode compartment with minimized gas generation.
In some aspects, the scrubber solution provides a CO2 capture efficiency of at least 90%, in some aspects at least 92.5%, in some aspects at least 95%, in some aspects at least 95.5%, in some aspects at least 96%, in some aspects at least 96.5% and in some aspects at least 97%.
In some preferred aspects, the scrubber solution comprises sodium hydroxide having a concentration between about 0.05 mol/L up to about 1 mol/L, preferably between about 0.075 mol/L up to about 0.75 mol/L, more preferably between about 0.1 mol/L up to about 0.5 mol/L, and in some preferred aspects preferably between about 0.25 mol/L up to about 0.4 mol/L.
The scrubber solution preferably captures CO2 forming a captured CO2 solution. In some aspects, the captured CO2 solution comprises a sodium bicarbonate solution. In some preferred aspects, a scrubber solution comprising sodium hydroxide reacts with a flue gas to capture CO2 forming the captured CO2 solution comprising a sodium bicarbonate solution. Preferably the captured CO2 solution is a sodium bicarbonate solution. In some preferred aspects, the captured CO2 solution comprises at least 80%, in some aspects at least 85%, in some aspects at least 90%, in some aspects at least 95%, in some aspects at least 97.5%, in some aspects at least 98%, in some aspects at least 98.5%, in some aspects at least 99%, in some aspects at least 99.5%, in some aspects at least 99.9%, and in some aspects 100%, of a sodium bicarbonate solution.
In some aspects, the CO2 is regenerated from the captured CO2 solution such that a recovery rate of at least 90% is achieved, in some aspects at least 95%, in some aspects at least 98%, in some aspects at least 99%, in some aspects at least 99.5%, in some aspects at least 99.9%, and in some aspects essentially 100%.
In some aspects, the regenerated CO2 produced from the captured CO2 solution has a purity of at least 90%, in some aspects at least 95%, in some aspects at least 97.5%, in some aspects at least 98%, in some aspects at least 99%, in some aspects at least 99.5%, in some aspects at least 99.9%, and in some aspects essentially 100%.
The regenerated CO2 is preferably produced by reacting the captured CO2 solution with an acid reagent to provide the regenerated CO2 and a resultant salt solution.
In some aspects, the scrubber solution is regenerated from the resultant salt solution by electrodialysis such that a regenerated scrubber solution yield of at least 90% is achieved, in some aspects at least 95%, in some aspects at least 98%, in some aspects at least 99%, in some aspects at least 99.5%, in some aspects at least 99.9%, and in some aspects essentially 100%.
In some aspects, the acid reagent is regenerated from the resultant salt solution by electrodialysis such that a regenerated acid reagent yield of at least 90% is achieved, in some aspects at least 95%, in some aspects at least 98%, in some aspects at least 99%, in some aspects at least 99.5%, in some aspects at least 99.9%, and in some aspects essentially 100%. In some aspects, the scrubber solution and the acid reagent are both regenerated from the resultant salt solution by electrodialysis, such that a regenerated scrubber solution yield of at least 90% is achieved and a regenerated acid reagent yield of at least 90% is achieved, in some aspects at least 95%, in some aspects at least 98%, in some aspects at least 99%, in some aspects at least 99.5%, in some aspects at least 99.9%, and in some aspects essentially 100%, for both the regenerated scrubber solution yield and the regenerated acid reagent yield.
Continuous CO2 capture and regeneration experiments were conducted on a mini pilot scale setup, as illustrated in the block diagram of
CO2 absorption with NaOH
The scrubber column shown on the left side in
The percentage CO2 of the simulated flue gas exiting out from the top of the column was measured with Quantek Model 906 infrared gas analyzer calibrated with a 20-vol % CO2/N2 reference gas. CO2 capture efficiency of a NaOH solution as the scrubbing solution was measured by continuously recording percentage CO2 absorption data by the data logger connected to the gas analyzer. After each experiment the data logger was connected to the computer and the graph generated from it was integrated to calculate the total moles of CO2 absorbed per minute. The accuracy of the data was ensured by repeating these experiments in triplicates. For a 16% CO2 gas stream (simulating a power plant flue gas), the optimum parameters were found to be: 0.3 mol/L NaOH solution at 6.4 Liters per minute flow rate.
Scrubber Solution Regeneration with EDBM
The scrubber solution, particularly a NaOH solution, was regenerated through an EDBM unit as shown in
In the setup illustrated in
CO2 capture and regeneration experiments were conducted with the setup shown in
Before running and regeneration setup in continuous mode with the capture column, EDBM cell was run for 30 minutes until the desired acid and base concentrations were reached, starting with 0.2 mol/L Na2SO4, 0.1 mol/L NaOH and 0.02 mol/L H2SO4 concentrations. Acid and base concentrations were started at 0.024 mol/L and 0.1 mol/L, respectively, to ensure the initial conductivity of the cell was greater than 20 mS/cm, for proper functioning of EDBM. Several voltage ranges were tested for the EDBM cell, and for each constant voltage, current density was recorded every minute until it reached a maximum value. Then the setup shown in
CO2 Absorption with NaOH
The CO2 absorption efficiency of NaOH solution at various concentrations is shown in
NaOH Regeneration with EDBM
Initial batch tests were conducted on EDBM cell for 30 minutes until the desired acid and base concentrations were reached. The maximum acid and base concentrations were reached in about 30 minutes as shown in
Comparing Two Compartment Configuration with Three Compartment Configuration
Since the energy consumption was the primary focus, the effect of current density on energy consumption was studied. Current density and energy consumption also have a direct influence on NaOH concentration, which in turn has an effect on CO2 capture efficiency. With increase in the concentration of electrolyte solution (0.2 M Na2SO4), the current efficiency decreases. Also, higher concentration leads to high osmotic pressures and reduction in water dissociation at the bipolar membrane.
Current efficiency defines how effectively the ions are transported across the membranes. Current efficiency decreases as the electrolyte and base concentrations increase. A low current efficiency may also result from the imperfect orientation of the membranes that allow the transfer of some co-ions, particularly when the concentrations are higher. Current efficiency is calculated from Equation (6).
where n is the number of cells (repeating membrane units; n=7 in the present experiment), V (L) is the circulated volume of the solution. F is Faraday's constant (96,500 coulombs/mol) Co and C; are the concentrations (mol/L) of NaOH at time 0 and time t, z=1 in the present situation with OH carrying unit negative charge, and I(A) is the current across the cell.
Total energy consumption in kWh Kg−1 of CO2 captured is calculated from Equation (7). This energy is converted to MJ Kg−1 by multiplying with a conversion factor of 3.6.
wherein U (V) is voltage across EDBM cell, I(A) is the current across the cell, C; is the concentration of CO2 at time t. Vt (L) is the volume of the solution circulating through the setup, and M is the molecular weight of CO2 (44.01 g/mol).
Decrease in current efficiency was observed at lower current density and base concentrations. In the two-compartment configuration the hydron (H′), which migrates through the cation exchange membrane and recombines with hydroxide ion (OH), slightly reducing the current utilization. The energy consumption is less in case of two compartment configurations because of dilute base concentration, while that of acid concentration effect on energy consumption follows the opposite trend, as previously observed by others when conducting studies on recovery of H2SO4 from Na2SO4 salt solution.
The regeneration energy of 1.18 MJ/KgCO2 when compared to 3-4 MJ/KgCO2 in case of thermal regeneration with amines and other absorbent solutions is a huge breakthrough in terms of energy savings. In the case of thermal regeneration, evidence suggests that an increase in stripper energy from 3 MJ/KgCO2 to 4 MJ/KgCO2 will reduce the power plant output by at least 20%. The important advantage of using EDBM process is that renewable sources like photovoltaics can be used to energize the EDBM cell. Some researchers who worked on direct electrodialysis of NaHCO3 solution were able to achieve low energy values (2-3 MJ/KgCO2) compared to thermal regeneration, but the direct electrodialysis process has its own fair share of process complications as mentioned above, and more importantly very low CO2 recoveries (40-60%).
As opposed to direct electrodialysis, an important trait in the presently disclosed process is the greater than 60%, in some aspects greater than 70%, in some aspects greater than 80%, in some aspects greater than 90%, in some preferable aspects greater than 95%, in some other preferable aspects greater than 98%, in some even more preferable aspects greater than 99%, in some aspects up to 99.5%, in some aspects up to 99.6%, in some aspects up to 99.7%, in some aspects up to 99.8%, in some aspects up to 99.9%, in some aspects up to 99.99%, and in the most preferable aspect up to 100%, recovery rate of CO2.
Since all the CO2 is essentially capable of being recovered prior to the EDBM step, the system and method of the present disclosure eliminates the presence of gas bubbles in the cell, avoiding unnecessary resistance across the cell. Hence, a very high current efficiency of 91% was observed, due to relatively lower concentration of acid and base generated. It is hypothesized that the limitation in current efficiency could be due to the leakage of protons through the cation exchange membrane. In a commercial scale EDBM unit, the number of unit cells could be much larger as opposed to lab scale unit of the present experiment, in which case voltage drop across the EDBM stack would be much less at lower current densities. Thus, the energy requirement is anticipated to be further lowered in a commercial scale unit.
An advantage of the system and regeneration method of the present disclosure is that the regeneration can be performed at room temperature and atmospheric pressure conditions, as opposed to high pressures required for direct electrodialysis of NaHCO3 as mentioned earlier. This ensures high process safety and also easier start-up and shutdown.
In some aspects, a particulate filtration step is recommended before the scrubber to ensure no particulates enter the EDBM cell. The usual norm in industrial flue gas capture is to remove/filter suspended particulates before sending the gas for flue gas desulfurization (FGD) and subsequently CO2 capture. Accordingly, the system and method of the present disclosure may in some aspects having a particulate filter and particulate filtration step prior to the scrubber in order to avoid suspended solids going into the EDBM cell and fouling membranes.
Economic analysis was also carried out by considering a hypothetical case of 400 MW coal-fired power plant, which corresponds to 300 tons/h of CO2 emissions and a continuous operation of CO2 capture and regeneration for 350 days a year at 24 h per day. With 97% CO2 capture efficiency of NaOH from the foregoing experimental results, this accounts to 2.4 Mton/year of CO2 captured. All assumptions for cost estimation are shown in Table 3.
Considering the foregoing base case scenario for capital cost, the operating cost is estimated by calculating the direct energy cost.
Cost of CO2 capture with thermal regeneration from previous literature was estimated to be around 45-60$/ton of CO2 captured, and others estimated that 30% of this cost corresponds to CO2 absorption equipment, which includes absorption column and pumping system. Considering the same base case scenario, the CO2 absorption cost is estimated to be 13.5$/ton of CO2 captured.
Cost of CO2 regeneration or reagent regeneration was estimated based on laboratory results of EDBM experiments. The cell in the lab has a cell volume of 0.012 m3 and handles 7.5 L/min of solution. At the L/G ratio of 4.3 and gas flow of 5 tons/min the total liquid to be handled by EDBM cells is 21500 LPM. Therefore, the number of cells required are 2867. Cost of each EDBM stack was estimated as 1.5 times the cost of membranes, based on previous work in the industry. Total equipment cost and operating costs are provided in Table 4.
Total capital cost including equipment cost, construction, valves, piping, etc. is calculated based on NETL guidelines as provide in Table 5.
The total capital investment is about 145.73 M$ for 15 years of operation and 36 Mtons of total CO2 processed. As such, for 1 ton of CO2, captured the total capital investment turns out to be about 4.04$/ton of CO2 captured. If both capital expenditure and variable operating costs are combined, the total cost of CO2 capture and regeneration would be 38.07$/ton of CO2 captured. Although the operating costs are very low, the capital cost increases the total cost due to high EDBM unit prices and membrane prices. Membrane prices are expected to go down further in the future, in such a case the total cost can be less than 38.07$/ton of CO2.
Depending on the project timeline, EDBM will be advantageous if the project period is extended over 15 years. It can also be made profitable over a shorter period of time if the membrane prices are lowered. Further decreases in electricity costs may also be anticipated by 2050, with developments in renewable energy technologies.
An additional benefit of the EDBM method is that you can regulate the base concentration as required by adjusting the voltage and current across the cell. If the CO2 concentration from the flue gas is fluctuating due to load variation from the power plant, this turning might help reduce the cost on daily basis. Considering 15 years of project timeline, the average cost per ton of CO2 captured is roughly 38$. It is contemplated that the reagent regeneration energy of 1.18 MJ/kg could be further reduced with numerous performance improvements and careful design choices, further making CO2 capture economically feasible and environmentally benign.
As provided by the foregoing, the present inventors have developed a new regeneration method for CO2 capture with an alkali absorbent solution, whereby sodium bicarbonate is reacted with an acid, preferably sulfuric acid, and the resultant salt solution, preferably a sodium sulphate solution, is subjected to an EDBM process for regenerating the alkali absorbent solution, preferably NaOH, and the acid. The present inventor were able to achieve reagent regeneration energy as low as 1.18 MJ/kg of CO2 captured at a current efficiency of 91.2% for the EDBM cell. The cost of processing flue gas is around 38.07$/ton of CO2 captured based on 2020 prices. This cost could be even lower if membrane costs were competitive. As such, the system and process of the present invention provides a very promising choice for post-combustion CO2 capture.
This application is a National Phase entry of PCT International Application PCT/US2023/011818 filed Jan. 30, 2023 which claims the benefit of priority of U.S. Provisional Patent Application No. 63/267,320 filed Jan. 31, 2022, the subject matter of which is incorporated by reference in its entirety.
Filing Document | Filing Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
PCT/US2023/011818 | 1/30/2023 | WO |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
63267320 | Jan 2022 | US |