This invention relates to reducing dispersion due to vias in planar microfluidic separation devices.
An objective of chemical separation techniques such as high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) and capillary electrophoresis (CE) is to separate different components of a mixture of chemical species based, for example, on differential chemical affinity with a stationary phase or differential migration velocity in a gel. The result of a separation is typically a chromatogram (HPLC) or electropherogram (CE) showing a series of peaks eluting at different times from the separation column or channel and detected by a variety of techniques such as UV absorbance, laser-induced fluorescence, or mass spectrometry. The quality of the separation is considered highest when the peaks are sharpest.
While chemical selectivity is a motive force of separation technologies, dispersion is a key physical phenomenon that causes peaks to become broader. The second principle of thermodynamics implies that the molecules in a narrow band of analyte will redistribute themselves spatially through diffusion and convection so that an initially sharp peak will gradually broaden as it travels through a chromatographic system. Understanding and minimizing dispersion is a key concern for separation scientists.
Modern liquid chromatography separations for analytical applications (as opposed to preparative applications) are typically conducted in stainless steel tubes of inner diameter between 1.0 and 4.6 mm and length between 5 and 15 cm. These tubes, or columns, are packed with porous particles of average diameter 1.7 to 3.5 microns. Frits are placed at both ends of the columns to hold the particles in place and prevent loosening of the packed bed when fluids flow through the packed bed. The immobile packed bed of porous particles is commonly referred to as stationary phase, with a fluid flowing through it referred to as mobile phase. Tubes of inner diameter 0.250 mm or smaller are typically attached through threaded ports at both ends of the column, referred to as inlet and outlet. An inlet tube is typically connected between the inlet of the column and an injection valve and pump, which are arranged upstream of the column. The pump delivers a flow of mobile phase at a specified flow rate, which is typically constant throughout a separation. In the case of reversed-phase liquid chromatography (RP-LC), which is a common modality of LC, the mobile phase is typically a mixture of water and an organic solvent such as acetonitrile in a composition that is either fixed (isocratic separation) or varies in linear fashion (gradient separation). The injection valve injects into the mobile phase a plug or band of the mixture of chemical species that is to be separated. This band travels with the mobile phase to the column, where its components are separated. An outlet tube connected to the outlet of the column transports the separated components to a detector (e.g., a UV detector or mass spectrometer).
Dispersion in a homogeneous packed bed can be represented and calculated by the Van Deemter model. After a peak or band has travelled a distance L, it has broadened and its width can be quantified by its spatial variance σL2 or temporal variance σt2=σL2/u2, where u is the linear velocity, defined below. Two common metrics of band broadening are the plate height, defined as H=σL2/L=u2σt2/L, and the plate count, defined as N=L/H. Separation scientists seek to minimize band broadening, and therefore minimize the plate height H and maximize the plate count N. A commonly used Van Deemter model predicts that
where dp is the average particle diameter, Dmol is the molecular diffusion coefficient of an analyte (sample), and u is the linear velocity of the mobile phase. The linear velocity is itself calculated as u=Us/εt where Us=Q/A is the superficial velocity in the bed, Q is the flow rate of the mobile phase, A is the cross-sectional area of the column, and εt is the total porosity of the packed bed. Since the particles are porous, the total porosity is the sum of the intraparticle porosity and interparticle porosity (the volume between particles when they are considered as solid spheres).
In the Van Deemter model, the three terms account respectively for non-uniformities in the packed bed, dispersion in the mobile phase between particles, and mass transfer to the stationary phase of the porous particles. The model illustrates that dispersion is caused to a significant extent by the geometry of the separation medium, not only by the diffusion of the analyte in the mobile phase. The 1.5dp term assumes that the bed is well-packed. If this is not the case, the constant could be larger than 1.5. In cases where the separation medium is a regular, ordered array of pillars fabricated using photolithographic methods, as opposed to a packed bed where the particles are arranged randomly in space, the constant could be significantly lower (see, e.g., U.S. Pat. No. 6,595,144 B1; see also “Advantages of perfectly ordered 2D porous pillar arrays over packed bed columns for LC separations: A theoretical analysis” P. Gzil, N. Vervoort, G. Baron, G. Desmet, Analytical Chemistry 2003, 75, 6244-6250).
To provide an illustrative example, the plate height H predicted by the van Deemter model, also referred to as the van Deemter curve, is plotted in
In some applications, notably when the amount of sample is limited, or when it is desired to interface the LC column to a mass spectrometer (MS), it is advantageous to use columns with smaller inner diameters, typically ranging from 75 to 300 microns, with associated mobile phase flow rates of typically less than 12 microliters/min. This scale of chromatography is usually referred to as microscale or nanoscale chromatography. It can be difficult to make columns out of metallic tubes with the dimensional consistency and surface finish required for high-quality HPLC. Typically, 75 to 150 micron ID columns are made out of fused silica and 300 micron ID columns are made out of polyether-ether-ketone, such as PEEK polymer (available from Victrex PLC, Lancashire, United Kingdom). Although it is possible to achieve high quality separations with minute amounts of sample, the challenges associated with minimizing extra-column band broadening due to tubing and fluidic connections, in particular with avoiding dead volumes, have limited the use of such columns to specialized applications such as proteomics.
Within the field of microscale or nanoscale chromatography, planar microfluidic devices have been gaining interest in recent years as alternatives to stainless steel, PEEK, or fused silica tubes traditionally used for HPLC and CE. CE microchips fabricated in glass or polymers allow to create smaller injection plugs, to better dissipate heat arising from Joule heating, and to integrate multiple parallel separation channels into a single planar device. Likewise, in the HPLC and ultra-performance liquid chromatography (UPLC™) realm, microchips have several advantages over commercially available tubular columns made out of fused silica or PEEK. Those advantages include the integration of a trapping channel on the same device as the analytical channel with minimum dead volume between the two channels, better ease of use, reduction of fluid connections and associated dead volume, and reduced risk of leakage.
The invention arises, in part, from the realization that dispersion, and therefore loss of separation performance or efficiency in a planar microfluidic chemical separation device can be reduced by reducing the fluid transport volume in regions of via-channel transition. This can be achieved by decreasing the diameter of the via, and, in some cases, narrowing or tapering the channel entrance, i.e., the region where the via and the channel join.
One aspect of the invention provides a planar microfluidic chemical separation device. The device includes a separation channel that is located in the plane of the device. The device also includes one or more vias situated perpendicular to the separation channel. The vias extends between the separation channel and an outer surface of the substrate for fluid communication with the separation channel. The vias have cross-sectional areas that are substantially less than a cross-sectional area of a first region of the separation channel to inhibit band-broadening caused by passage of a sample band through the one or more vias.
Another aspect of the invention features a method that includes delivering a mobile phase fluid carrying a sample band through a first via in a substrate so as to drive the sample through a separation channel defined by the substrate, such that components of the sample band are separated and subsequently driven out through a second via in the substrate. The first and second vias have cross-sectional areas that are substantially less than a cross-sectional area of a first region of the separation channel thereby inhibiting band-broadening caused by passage of the sample band through the first and second vias.
In another aspect, the invention features a method of forming a planar microfluidic chemical separation device. The method includes forming a pair of vias in a first substrate layer; forming a first groove in a second substrate layer; and connecting the first substrate layer and the second substrate layer to form a substrate and such that the first groove forms at least a portion of an enclosed separation channel and the vias allow for fluid communication with the separation channel. The vias have cross-sectional areas that are substantially less than a cross-sectional area of a first region of the separation channel thereby inhibiting band-broadening caused by passage of a sample band through the vias.
Implementations may include one or more of the following features.
In some implementations, the cross-sectional areas of the vias are 1.7 times to 9.0 times smaller (e.g., 4.0 times smaller) than the cross-sectional area of the first region of the separation channel.
In certain implementations, the first region of the separation channel has a cross-sectional area of 0.07 square millimeters to 0.20 square millimeters. That is, the first region of the separation channel can have a cross-sectional area that corresponds to that of a 300 micron to 500 micron diameter column.
In some implementations, the separation channel has a length of 5 cm to 25 cm, e.g., 10 CM.
In certain implementations, the separation channel is configured to perform a chromatographic separation.
In some implementations, the first region of the separation channel accounts for 90% to 99% of the length of the channel.
In certain implementations, the separation channel also includes one or more transition regions which interface with and taper towards the vias. The transition regions account for 1% to 10% of the length of the channel.
In some implementations, the separation channel has a second region extending between the first region and the vias, the second region having a channel width that narrows towards a junction with the vias.
In certain implementations, the second region has a channel height that narrows towards a junction with the vias.
In some implementations, the separation channel has transition regions extending between the first region and the vias. The second regions have a channel height that narrows towards a junction with the via. In some examples, the separation channel narrows from a first channel height in the first region to a second channel height in the transition regions that is 10% to 50% smaller (e.g., 25% smaller) than the first channel height.
In certain implementations, the substrate includes porous particles disposed within the separation channel.
In some implementations, the substrate includes a first substrate layer defining at least part of the separation channel and a second substrate layer which overlies the first substrate layer and defines the via.
In certain implementations, the separation channel has a square or rectangular cross-sectional shape.
In some implementations, the separation channel has a rounded cross-sectional shape.
In certain implementations, the separation channel terminates at a rounded corner at the junction with the via for inhibiting stagnation of fluid flow at the junction.
In some implementations, tapered regions are formed at terminal ends of the first groove such that the separation channel tapers in transition regions interfacing with the vias.
In certain implementations, a second groove is formed in the first substrate layer such that, when the first and second substrate layers are connected, the first and second grooves together form the enclosed separation channel.
In some implementations, tapered regions are formed at terminal ends of the second groove such that separation channel tapers in transition regions interfacing with the vias.
In certain implementations, tapered regions are formed at terminal ends of the first and second grooves such that separation channel tapers in transition regions interfacing with the vias.
Implementations can provide one or more of the following advantages.
In some implementations, the penalty in chromatographic performance due to the transition between vias and channels in planar microfluidic chemical separation devices can be reduced.
In certain implementations, sample band broadening is reduced in regions of via—channel transition.
In some implementations, planar microfluidic separation devices are provided with performance characteristics that are the substantially the same as those of convention straight separation columns.
Other aspects, features, and advantages are in the description, drawings, and claims.
Like reference numbers indicate like elements.
The invention aims at reducing fluid transport volume in regions of via—channel transition in planar microfluidic separation devices, thereby to reduce the band-broadening that is caused by passage of a sample band through those regions. This can be achieved by decreasing the diameter of the via, and, in some cases, narrowing or tapering the channel entrance, i.e., the region where the via and channel join.
The first substrate layer 201 and the second substrate layer 202 are connected together, such as by lamination, welding, or diffusion bonding, to form the substrate. In some cases, the first and second substrate layers 201, 202 are titanium layers which are diffusion bonded together. When the first substrate layer 201 and the second substrate layer 202 are connected together, the second substrate layer 202 overlies the first substrate layer 201 such that the groove forms an enclosed separation channel 204 and the vias 203 allow for fluid communication with the separation channel 204. The separation channel 204 is packed with chromatographic particles and fits are formed at the ends of the separation channel 204 to lock the packed particles in place. The length of the separation channel typically ranges between 5 cm and 25 cm, e.g., 10 cm. The separation channel 204 has two 60° turns and one 180° turn in order to fit a channel of length 10 cm or more into the small size planar substrate, of length 5.0 cm and width 2.5 cm in this example. The width and height of the separation channel 204 are chosen so that the cross-sectional area of the separation channel 204 is equal to that of already commercially available microscale or nanoscale columns, ranging typically between 75 and 300 microns. In this regard, the separation channel 204 has a width of 67 microns to 265 microns and a depth of 67 microns to 265 microns.
In use, an inlet tube is connected between a first one of the vias 203 of the planar microfluidic chemical separation device 200 and an injection valve and pump. The pump delivers a flow of mobile phase at a specified flow rate, which is typically constant throughout a separation. The injection valve injects into the mobile phase a plug or band of the sample. This band travels with the mobile phase to the separation channel 204, where its components are separated. An outlet tube, which is connected to the other one of the vias 203 at the opposite end of the separation channel 204, transports the separated components to a detector (e.g., a UV detector or mass spectrometer), which, in turn, may be connected to a computer data station for recording an electrical signal from the detector and generating a chromatogram.
Notably, the vias 203 are provided with a smaller cross-sectional area than that of the separation channel. For example, the vias can have a cross-sectional area that is 1.7 to 9 times smaller, e.g., 4 times smaller, than the cross-sectional area of the separation channel. This arrangement can help to reduce band-broadening caused by passage of a sample band through the vias.
The following examples illustrate the benefits of this type of arrangement by way of comparison with an arrangement in which the channel and vias have the same cross-sectional area.
The first contribution can be calculated by doing a computer simulation of a 300 micron diameter cylindrical tube of length 5.889 mm, equal to the sum of the lengths of the via 300 and channel 301 of
Thus, the extra band broadening specifically due to the via—channel transition in the inlet via is calculated as Δσt,inlet2=(σt,12−σt,02)−(σt,22−σt,02)=σt,12−σt,22. A similar simulation was performed for the outlet via, in which case the peak is introduced at 305 and exits at 303. It was found that the extra dispersion in the outlet via is equal to the extra dispersion in the inlet via: Δσt,outlet2=Δσt,inlet2.
This allows the effective plate height Heff for an entire device to be calculated as follows. A straight column with the above parameters would have a plate height H=3.94 microns, as discussed above. For a planar microfluidic device having a L=10 cm long separation channel and two vias of diameter 300 microns as shown in
Although an exemplary embodiment been described above, other modifications are possible. For example, in another embodiment, the cross-sectional areas of the vias are smaller than that of the channel, and, in addition, the channel width narrows down as it joins the vias. For example, the vias can have a cross-sectional area that is 1.7 to 9 times smaller, e.g., 4 times smaller, than the cross-sectional area of a first region of the separation channel, and the separation channel can narrow down such that in a second region the width of the separation channel is the same as the diameter of the via.
In yet another embodiment, the diameter of the vias is decreased and the separation channel height narrows down as it joins the vias. For example, the separation channel may narrow from a first height in a first region to a second height in a second region, near the via, that is 10% to 50%, e.g., 25%, smaller than the first height. In some cases, taking into account a narrowing of both the width and the height of the separation channel, the separation channel may narrow from a first cross-sectional area in a first region to a second cross-sectional area in a second region, near the via, that is 60% to 70%, e.g., 68%, smaller than the first cross-sectional area.
In
Referring to
A variety of fabrication techniques can be used to create the geometries shown in the examples above. The preferred materials are titanium and titanium alloys. The vias can be fabricated in one or more layers using mechanical drilling, electric-discharge machining (EDM) hole drilling, or laser hole drilling. The channels can be fabricated in one or more separate physical substrate layers using mechanical milling, wire EDM or electrochemical micromachining (EMM). The substrate layers containing the vias and channels can be stacked, aligned and joined using diffusion bonding to form hermetically sealed fluidic channels. Channels having square or rectangular cross sections, such as the ones shown in
Accordingly, other implementations are within the scope of the following claims.
This application claims priority to U.S. Provisional Application No. 61/495,043, filed Jun. 9, 2011. The entire contents of U.S. Provisional Application No. 61/495,043 are incorporated herein by reference.
Filing Document | Filing Date | Country | Kind | 371c Date |
---|---|---|---|---|
PCT/US2012/041451 | 6/8/2012 | WO | 00 | 1/23/2014 |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
61495043 | Jun 2011 | US |