The present invention relates to systems for the treatment of water, especially but not exclusively systems for the treatment of drinking water. In particular, the invention relates to the regeneration of ion exchange materials used in such systems and/or to treatment and minimisation of waste streams produced during the regeneration of ion exchange materials used in such systems.
Nitrate-selective ion exchange resins are in widespread use for removal of nitrate and other anions from drinking water and from water streams used for or produced in other industrial applications. A problem with all nitrate-selective resins is that they are not entirely selective for nitrate over other anions (such as sulphate and bicarbonate) which are also present in water. Under normal operating conditions, the resin is periodically regenerated with a brine solution and effluent, comprising chloride, nitrate, sulphate and bicarbonate anions and (normally) sodium counter ion is disposed to a sewage treatment works.
British Patent specification No. 2348209A describes a method for treating the effluent to recover the regenerant for re-use in a closed loop system. In order to make the process sustainable over a high number of regeneration cycles it is necessary separately to remove bicarbonate and sulphate anions from the nitrate anions absorbed on the ion exchange resin. A certain level of sulphate and bicarbonate will however pass into the closed loop as described in the above Patent specification and that level will progressively increase until solubility limits are approached, when the entire closed loop volume will have to be removed and replaced with new solution. The removed solution is a waste volume.
A waste volume also arises from the generation of softened water (that is, water with calcium and/or magnesium ions removed) which is required for making up of the brine solutions used, as described above, to regenerate the nitrate-selective resins.
The waste streams produced by the regeneration process require appropriate disposal. The elimination or reduction in volume of waste streams potentially offers advantages in terms of reduction in the cost and complexity of equipment required to handle the waste streams and to treat them to achieve environmentally appropriate concentrations for discharge.
The invention provides a method for operating and regenerating ion exchange material, comprising
preparing a wash fluid for rinsing the ion exchange material and/or for generating solutions for eluting the ion exchange material;
collecting as a by-product of said preparation a first waste stream including cationic species to be eliminated;
subjecting the ion exchange material to a wash step in which there is eluted from the ion exchange material by the wash fluid or solution an anionic species to be eliminated and obtaining a second waste stream including the anionic species to be eliminated;
combining the first waste stream and the second waste stream to form a precipitate comprising a reaction product of said cationic species and said anionic species; and
removing the precipitate.
The method of invention enables waste steams to be reduced, for example, by permitting the residual liquid, following precipitate removal, to be recycled for re-use in the regeneration process instead of being discarded.
In one preferred embodiment of the invention, the ion exchange material is a selective anion ion exchange material, especially a nitrate-selective ion exchange material, which is subjected to liquid washing, preferably comprising sequential wash steps using different liquids, for example, a first elution step with a dilute brine solution and a second elution step with a concentrated brine solution. Advantageously, anionic species including the anionic species to be eliminated (e.g. sulphate) are removed in sequential wash steps, and there are formed a plurality of fractions comprising said anionic species to be eliminated, the second waste stream comprising one or more said fractions. It has been found that, surprisingly, such a method of regeneration of a nitrate-selective ion exchange material can be made to result in the generation of first and second waste streams which contain stoichiometrically balanced or approximately balanced quantities of, respectively, cationic species and anionic species to be eliminated. In an especially preferred method, the step of preparing a wash fluid for eluting the ion exchange column comprises passing water over a cation exchange material thereby obtaining softened water for use as the wash fluid. On periodic regeneration of the cation exchange material by elution with brine, there is obtained the first waste stream, containing hardness ions, especially calcium and magnesium. In the sequential removal of anions as described above by different concentrations of brine the amount of sulphate preremoved from the nitrate-selective ion exchange material is dependent upon the length of time during which elution with the dilute brine solution is carried out (and therefore the volume of dilute brine solution). For a given source of water, the quantity of hardness ions extracted from softened water is dependent on the volume of water softened. It will therefore be seen that an increase in sulphate preremoval may be balanced by an increase in hardness ion in the waste stream from the cationic exchange material. The balancing works as described below, where the step of obtaining the second waste stream includes subjecting the second elution effluent from the ion exchange material in said wash step to a treatment in which nitrate is removed. Any suitable treatment method may be used for removal of nitrate from the effluent. Illustrative of suitable treatment methods are, for example, electrolytic treatment methods or microbiological treatment methods. Preferably, the effluent is treated to remove nitrate in an electrocatalytic method. It is preferred for the electrocatalytic treatment to be carried out in an electrocatalytic cell having a cathode surface that is coated with a layer of rhodium metal, which gives good electrical efficiency. One suitable form of electrocatalytic cell and its mode of operation is described in GB 2348209A. A further suitable method of operating such a cell is described in GB 2365023A.
The anionic species to be eliminated advantageously is or includes sulphate. The cationic species to be eliminated advantageously is or includes calcium ions.
Preferably, the ion exchange material is contained in more than one vessel, for example in two, three or four vessels, and the ion exchange material in a first said vessel can be loaded to chemical equilibrium by contacting the liquid from which nitrate is to be removed with the ion exchange material in said first vessel, the liquid subsequently being contacted with the ion exchange material in a second said vessel.
The invention also provides for eliminating anionic and cationic species from waste streams produced in regeneration of an ion exchange column, comprising:
feeding to a waste treatment vessel a first waste stream including a cationic species to be eliminated, which first waste stream is the waste stream generated from a water-softening treatment;
feeding to the waste treatment vessel a second waste stream which comprises a regenerant solution including an anionic species to be eliminated that reacts with said cationic species, which anionic species has been eluted from the ion exchange column by the regenerant solution;
allowing said cationic and anionic species to react to form a precipitate; and
separating and removing the precipitate.
It will be appreciated that the reaction product of the cationic and anionic species to be eliminated must have a solubility product that is low. In that way, more than 50%, for example, more than 75%, preferably more than 90% and more preferably substantially all of the cationic species and/or the anionic species, and preferably of both, can be precipitated out in the waste treatment vessel.
In a second aspect of the invention there is provided a method of regenerating an ion exchange column containing a nitrate-selective ion exchange material loaded with nitrate ions, in which the loaded ion exchange column is subjected to a regeneration cycle comprising:
passing through the column a dilute brine solution;
collecting the dilute solution effluent containing at least one anion, other than nitrate, eluted from the column;
passing through the column a second, and optionally a third, brine solution, the second, and if present the third, solution having a higher concentration than the first;
collecting the second, and optional third, solution effluent containing nitrate ions;
passing water through the column and collecting the effluent wash water; and
using the effluent wash water in a further regeneration treatment.
The term “brine solution” is used herein to include solutions of sodium chloride and solutions of potassium chloride. Advantageously, the first dilute solution is a dilute sodium chloride or potassium chloride solution, for example a 0.2 to 2.0% w/v solution Advantageously, the second solution is a more concentrated solution of the same compound as the first. Advantageously, the second solution is a sodium chloride or potassium chloride solution, for example, a 6 to 15% w/v solution
Preferably, there is passed through the column a third brine solution, the third brine solution having a concentration similar to the second brine solution. In a preferred arrangement, the third solution effluent, containing a lower level of nitrate ions than the second solution effluent, is collected and retained for use as the second brine solution in a subsequent (usually the next) regeneration cycle. Thus, in an especially preferred arrangement, the second brine solution comprises brine solution that has been used previously as the third brine solution in a previous regeneration cycle.
The wash water is advantageously softened water. It may instead be raw water, for example, ground water, with or without further treatment, such as ground water that has been treated for removal of nitrate. A combination of softened water and raw water may be used, applied in a mixture or sequentially. The relative proportions of softened to raw water used can be varied to suit the incident levels of hardness cations and of other ions, for example, sulphate in the raw water. Advantageously, the wash water is recycled for use as the, or for the manufacture of the, first dilute solution. Advantageously, the water wash step is carried out in two phases, comprising a first phase in which a minor proportion of the wash water to be used is passed through the column and a second phase in which a major proportion of the wash water to be used is passed down the column. That enables a chloride ion spike conventionally observed when a freshly generated column is returned to service to be reduced or substantially eliminated.
The method of the invention is in particular applicable to ion exchange material in a fixed bed, moving bed or fluidized bed, especially in a fixed bed. As will be apparent, the invention describes a novel method for treating the waste volumes arising from both an anion-removing ion exchange system and a cation-removing ion exchange system, by controlled reactions between these to minimize total waste volumes and recover solutions to recycle for further operations of the system.
Two embodiments of the invention will now be described in detail, by way of illustration, with reference to the accompanying drawings, in which:
a illustrates a first phase of regeneration cycle for a nitrate removal column of a nitrate treatment plant having three nitrate removal columns operating in parallel;
b is a schematic view of a second phase in the regeneration cycle of
c illustrates the third phase of the regeneration cycle of
d illustrates the fourth phase of the regeneration cycle of
e illustrates the fifth phase of the regeneration cycle.
The regeneration loop of
The column 1 has an inlet 1a and an outlet 1b. During use of the column 1 in an operation mode the water to be treated, optionally after being subjected to a previous treatment, enters the column at inlet 1a and leaves the column at outlet 1b. The pathways for delivery of the water to be treated to the column 1 and transport of treated water away from the column 1 are not illustrated in
Unless periodically regenerated, the ion exchange material eventually becomes saturated with nitrate. As the nitrate concentration in the ion exchange material increases, the efficacy of the nitrate removal decreases. Accordingly, to maintain a suitable level of nitrate-removing efficiency, the column needs to be subjected to a regeneration treatment at appropriate intervals.
The regeneration is carried out by washing the column 1 sequentially with regenerant liquids. Softened water for use in the regeneration operation is produced using a cation exchange vessel 2 in which water is passed over a cation exchange resin in order to effect replacement of water hardness ions, especially of calcium and magnesium ions, by sodium or potassium. The cation exchange vessel may be a standard cation exchange column as used widely to provide softened water by removing calcium and or magnesium ions. Those columns require periodic regeneration by brine solution (sodium or potassium chloride), designated as “B” in
The softened water so obtained is then used, after optional combination with recycled regenerant solution and concentration adjustment, where appropriate, to wash the column 1, to which it is transported via lines 3 and 4. That at least partly recycled brine stream is designated “R” in
1. A very dilute brine solution made up of recycled effluent regenerant wash water from column 1 as noted in (3) below together, optionally, with added salt or additional softened water for adjustment to a salt concentration of 0.2 to 2% w/v is delivered from tank T4 as shown by arrow A1 into line 5 and via line 4 into column 1 through inlet 1a and collected from outlet 1b (see
2. A more concentrated brine solution (6 to 15% w/v), comprising the effluent from a previous regeneration cycle as a result of which it contains some nitrate, is then passed from tank T3 (second nitrate tank) as shown by arrow A2 through the column 1 to remove nitrate from the column (
3. Fresh concentrated brine solution (6 to 15% w/v), either made up from softened water generated from column 2 (see
4. A rinse step is carried out in which a volume of softened water SW from column 2 (see
5. A second water wash step is carried out in which a second volume of softened water from column 2 is passed through column 1. The second volume of softened water is selected to be larger than the first volume of softened water referred to in 4 above. The rinse water is collected at outlet 1b and recycled to the tank T4 where it is retained with the wash water from step 4 for use as the dilute brine solution referred to in step 1 above of a subsequent regeneration cycle.
In the regeneration regime described, the anion exchange column is washed by a relatively dilute, brine solution and subsequently and sequentially by first and second volumes of concentrated brine solution. The dilute solution washes from the column primarily anions other than nitrate, in particular, sulphate and bicarbonate. The first and second volumes of more concentrated brine solution wash from the column the nitrate ions, which are replaced by chloride ions.
Optionally, the wash process may omit step 4 above. If desired, the wash water used in step 4 and/or step 5 above may be raw ground water, instead of softened water from column 2. In that case, however, the proportion of wash water used in the production of the dilute regenerant solution must be so controlled that the concentration of water hardness ions (especially calcium and magnesium) does not exceed values at which the efficacy of the dilute regenerant solution is detrimentally affected.
Referring now to
Thus the decomposition of the nitrate ions is balanced by the formation of hydroxide ions. The hydroxide can be eliminated by addition of an acid, for example, hydrochloric acid, regenerating chloride salt. The electrocatalytically treated solution is then recycled after correction of pH and addition of hydrochloric acid to make new regenerant solutions, as schematically illustrated by line 11 in
The electrocatalytic treatment does not remove from the regenerant fluid sulphate ions that are present therein. As the regenerant fluids are recycled through successive wash steps, in successive regeneration cycles, the concentration of sulphate will increase until; the solubility limit is approached, when efficiency of the system reduces unless the sulphate-saturated solution is removed from the closed loop and replaced with fresh brine solution. In the regeneration cycle described above, sulphate-containing brine is automatically removed from the system for sulphate removal under predetermined conditions, for example, after a given number of wash steps, or once a given sulphate concentration is reached.
When sulphate removal treatment is to be carried out, the sulphate-containing solution is drawn off from cell 10 via line 12 and fed into a precipitation tank 13. The precipitation tank 13 also receives, via line 14, cation-containing waste stream generated by the ion exchange vessel 2. Typically, that waste stream from ion exchange vessel 2 will contain hardness cations (especially calcium). The solubility product of calcium sulphate is low (4.9×10−5), and therefore even at the concentrations of sulphate and calcium in the waste streams it is possible to obtain precipitation of most of the calcium and sulphate ions present in the precipitation tank. The precipitated solids are removed. Solids removal can be effected by any suitable technique, for example, by filtration or sedimentation. After removal of the solids, designated “W” in
Once the anion exchange resin has been regenerated, the ion exchange column 1 can be used again for the removal of nitrate from water containing nitrate ions. The regeneration cycle can be carried out repeatedly as and when the ion exchange resin becomes fully loaded with nitrate ions. The nitrate concentration in the treated water may be monitored continuously or non-continuously by any suitable method. In order for treatment of water to be uninterrupted, it is preferred to operate at least two anion exchange columns in parallel. That enables one of the columns to be regenerated whilst the other is in operation mode to treat water. In the embodiment of
In the manner described, it is possible for the waste streams from the regeneration processes to be substantially eliminated enabling much of their volume to be recycled, resulting in a reduced requirement for discharge of waste streams from the system and for the treatment of such streams to remove unacceptable levels of environmental contaminants.
The following Example illustrates the invention:
An ion exchange column containing nitrate selective resin (in this example A520E supplied by Purolite Ltd is used) loaded to chemical equilibrium with raw water containing typical levels of nitrate, sulphate, bicarbonate, calcium, magnesium and other impurities found in raw water, is regenerated using firstly a dilute solution of potassium chloride followed by a more concentrated potassium chloride solution.
It is apparent from
It is a requirement that the dilute potassium chloride solution is made up using softened water. This can be obtained by passing raw water through a small ion exchange column containing cation resin, where the calcium ions in the raw water are exchanged with potassium ions on the cation resin. This soft water can firstly be used to rinse the column containing the nitrate selective resin (
It is known that the solubility of calcium sulphate is low (4.9×10−5) and therefore mixing together the concentrated solution that has been used to regenerate the nitrate selective resin with the regenerant from the cation resin will precipitate the calcium and the sulphate as calcium sulphate, which can be removed by standard filtration methods, with all the brine (potassium chloride) solution being recovered for re-use.
In practice, it is feasible to match the chemical equivalent of sulphate build up in the recycled concentrate potassium chloride solution passing through the destruction cell to the chemical equivalent of calcium removed in the generation of the required volume of soft water. Thus, when the cation column is regenerated, the used regenerant containing calcium can be mixed with the concentrated regenerant used to regenerate the nitrate selective resin with the result that the sulphate levels in the concentrate will be reduced to virtually zero. In this way, the re-use of the concentrated potassium chloride solution can be extended indefinitely and there will effectively be no liquid waste arising from the regeneration of the cation column.
Table 1 shows data relating to a regeneration regime in which 2.25 bed volumes (the volume of ion exchange resin within the column; hereafter “by”) of 2% potassium chloride solution is used in step 1. The bed volume of a typical column is 1.7 m3. Therefore, regeneration of the nitrate selective resin will require about 3.83 m3 of soft water. Generation of this soft water from water containing 100 mg/l calcium will load about 382.5 g of calcium onto the cation column. This is equivalent to about 19 chemical equivalents of calcium. The corresponding increase of sulphate levels during the concentrated regeneration of the nitrate selective resin can be seen in
Table 2 shows data relating to another regeneration regime that can be carried out in the same column, with the quantity of dilute potassium chloride used in step 1 being increased. That will a) directly increase the amount of calcium removed by the cation column and b) reduce the residual sulphate levels seen in step 2. The volume and concentration of the dilute potassium chloride solution used in step 1 can therefore be tailored to match the sulphate build up in step 2, allowing minimum overall effluent production from the process. In the regime of Table 2, the volume of the dilute potassium chloride used in step 1 was increased to 5.2 by. As a result, the residual sulphate level would increase in step 2 by 500 mg/l per cycle and the calcium removed on the cation column to generate the soft water would substantially exactly match the increased sulphate level in step 2. Thus when the used regenerant from regeneration of the cation column is mixed with the concentrate regenerant from step 2, the calcium and sulphate ions will be in stoichiometric balance and will all or substantially all precipitate out as calcium sulphate, allowing the potassium chloride solution to be re-used.
Thus, the data in Table 2 demonstrates how in practice the chemical equivalent of sulphate build-up in the concentrated potassium chloride solution can be matched to the chemical equivalent of calcium removed in the generation of the required amount of soft water.
The data in the Tables relates to water from a typical single source of ground water in the UK (site reference “LF WTW”). In the Tables, “Regen” means “regeneration”, “Eq” means “equivalents” and “M Wt” means molar weight.
The sulphate removed by the dilute regenerant in step 1 can either be returned to the treated water or can be further treated by the addition of the chemical equivalent of calcium bicarbonate to precipitate out the sulphate present in this regenerant, allowing bicarbonate to be returned to the treated water. The latter is advantageous where there are concerns over the chloride ion alkalinity ratio of the treated water.
Number | Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
0505689.0 | Mar 2005 | GB | national |
Filing Document | Filing Date | Country | Kind | 371c Date |
---|---|---|---|---|
PCT/GB2006/001002 | 3/17/2006 | WO | 00 | 10/7/2008 |