Regenerative cooling method and apparatus

Information

  • Patent Grant
  • 10618026
  • Patent Number
    10,618,026
  • Date Filed
    Monday, February 1, 2016
    9 years ago
  • Date Issued
    Tuesday, April 14, 2020
    4 years ago
Abstract
A method of cooling a liner in a plasma chamber. A recycle gas is contacted with or passed through the liner to cool the liner and pre-heat the recycle gas. The pre-heated gas is then recycled through the plasma chamber to become part of the plasma forming process. The method further comprises the liner is graphite, the recycle gas passes through at least one cooling channel present in the liner, at least one of the cooling channels are covered with at least one removable liner/channel cover, carbon deposits are formed from the presence of hydrocarbons in the recycle gas, at least one channel is formed in a spiral cooling channel pattern, at least one channel is formed in a substantially straight cooling channel pattern, and a plenum to aid in the production of an even distribution of cooling gas in the channels.
Description
TECHNICAL FIELD

The field of art to which this invention generally pertains is methods and apparatus for making use of electrical energy to effect chemical changes.


BACKGROUND

There are many processes that can be used and have been used over the years to produce carbon black. The energy sources used to produce such carbon blacks over the years have, in large part, been closely connected to the raw materials used to convert hydrocarbon containing materials into carbon black. Residual refinery oils and natural gas have long been a resource for the production of carbon black. Energy sources have evolved over time in chemical processes such as carbon black production from simple flame, to oil furnace, to plasma, to name a few. As in all manufacturing, there is a constant search for more efficient and effective ways to produce such products. Varying flow rates and other conditions of energy sources, varying flow rates and other conditions of raw materials, increasing speed of production, increasing yields, reducing manufacturing equipment wear characteristics, etc. have all been, and continue to be, part of this search over the years.


The systems described herein meet the challenges described above, and additionally attain more efficient and effective manufacturing process.


BRIEF SUMMARY

A method of cooling a liner in a plasma chamber is described including, contacting the liner with or passing through the liner, at least one recycle gas to be used to create the plasma in the plasma chamber, to cool the plasma chamber liner and pre-heat the recycle gas, and returning the pre-heated recycle gas to the plasma chamber to create the plasma.


Additional embodiments include: the method described above where the liner is graphite; the method described above where the recycle gas passes through at least one cooling channel present in the liner; the method described above where at least one of the cooling channels are covered with at least one removable liner/channel cover; the method described above where the cover is removed to remove any carbon deposits in the channels; the method described above where the carbon deposits are formed from the presence of hydrocarbons in the recycle gas; the method described above where at least one channel is formed in a spiral cooling channel pattern; the method described above where at least one channel is formed in a substantially straight cooling channel pattern; the method described above including more than one channel; the method described above including a plenum to aid in the production of an even distribution of cooling gas in the channels; the method described above including adding an oxidizing gas to the recycle gas to reduce or eliminate the presence of hydrocarbons in the recycle gas and/or reduce the formation of carbon deposits; the method described above where the oxidizing gas is steam and/or carbon dioxide; the method described above including passing an oxidizing gas through at least one of the channels to remove any carbon deposits in the channel; the method described above where the oxidizing gas is steam and/or carbon dioxide; the method described above where the carbon deposits are formed from the presence of hydrocarbons in the recycle gas; the method described above where the liner contains a plurality of perforations providing an ingress for the pre-heated recycle gas; the method described above where the perforations comprise one to six sets of co-planar perforations along the plasma chamber; the method described above where the plasma chamber is cylindrical and the perforations are along the curved sections of the plasma chamber cylinder; the method described above where the perforations allow aspirational cooling; the method described above where the plasma chamber contains a plasma torch annulus, and the gas is recycled to inside and/or outside the torch annulus; the method described above where the plasma is generated using an AC power source; the method described above where the plasma is generated using a DC power source; the method described above including injecting a hydrocarbon feedstock into the chamber such that over 30% of the energy input into the system measured in Joules is transferred to the hydrocarbon feedstock within the first 1 second of injection; the method described above where the hydrocarbon feedstock is natural gas; the method described above where the hydrocarbon feedstock is injected downstream of the plasma creation; and the method described above where the hydrocarbon feedstock is injected upstream of the plasma creation.


These, and additional embodiments, will be apparent from the following descriptions.





BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

The FIGS. 1, 2 and 3 show schematic representations of typical methods and apparatus described herein.





DETAILED DESCRIPTION

The particulars shown herein are by way of example and for purposes of illustrative discussion of the various embodiments of the present invention only and are presented in the cause of providing what is believed to be the most useful and readily understood description of the principles and conceptual aspects of the invention. In this regard, no attempt is made to show details of the invention in more detail than is necessary for a fundamental understanding of the invention, the description making apparent to those skilled in the art how the several forms of the invention may be embodied in practice.


The present invention will now be described by reference to more detailed embodiments. This invention may, however, be embodied in different forms and should not be construed as limited to the embodiments set forth herein. Rather, these embodiments are provided so that this disclosure will be thorough and complete, and will fully convey the scope of the invention to those skilled in the art.


Unless otherwise defined, all technical and scientific terms used herein have the same meaning as commonly understood by one of ordinary skill in the art to which this invention belongs. The terminology used in the description of the invention herein is for describing particular embodiments only and is not intended to be limiting of the invention. As used in the description of the invention and the appended claims, the singular forms “a,” “an,” and “the” are intended to include the plural forms as well, unless the context clearly indicates otherwise. All publications, patent applications, patents, and other references mentioned herein are expressly incorporated by reference in their entirety.


Unless otherwise indicated, all numbers expressing quantities of ingredients, reaction conditions, and so forth used in the specification and claims are to be understood as being modified in all instances by the term “about.” Accordingly, unless indicated to the contrary, the numerical parameters set forth in the following specification and attached claims are approximations that may vary depending upon the desired properties sought to be obtained by the present invention. At the very least, and not as an attempt to limit the application of the doctrine of equivalents to the scope of the claims, each numerical parameter should be construed in light of the number of significant digits and ordinary rounding approaches.


Notwithstanding that the numerical ranges and parameters setting forth the broad scope of the invention are approximations, the numerical values set forth in the specific examples are reported as precisely as possible. Any numerical value, however, inherently contains certain errors necessarily resulting from the standard deviation found in their respective testing measurements. Every numerical range given throughout this specification will include every narrower numerical range that falls within such broader numerical range, as if such narrower numerical ranges were all expressly written herein.


Additional advantages of the invention will be set forth in part in the description which follows, and in part will be obvious from the description, or may be learned by practice of the invention. It is to be understood that both the foregoing general description and the following detailed description are exemplary and explanatory only and are not restrictive of the invention, as claimed.


Heat transfer or cooling mechanisms in the past have typically been external to the plasma chamber. For the furnace process, the burner does not need excessive cooling because of the inherent lower temperatures in the furnace process compared to a plasma process. An example of what could be considered as inefficient cooling/pre-heat of recycle gas can be found in published patent application US2014/190,179. The heat exchanger is located external to the plasma chamber resulting in inefficient cool down or lack of cool down in plasma chamber and an insufficiently heated recycle/plasma gas.


As described herein, the use of regenerative cooling enables higher plasma temperatures to be used in chemical processes without generating excessive plasma chamber liner temperatures. Previous uses of plasmas to make carbon black, for example, either limited the plasma temperatures which could be used, or used water cooling to limit the loss of, for example, graphite when used in the process, e.g. as a liner, to sublimation. As described herein, recycle plasma gas is used to cool the lining, e.g. graphite, with the gas ultimately to be used in the plasma chamber.


Energy absorbed in cooling the liner is returned to the process as preheated gas used in the plasma chamber, which can represent significant energy cost savings to the overall process. As mentioned previously, in published patent application US2014/190,179, the heat transfer mechanism is external to the plasma chamber. The system described herein provides for a simultaneously cooled plasma chamber liner and heated recycle/plasma gas by engineering and incorporating the cooling mechanism into the inner skin of the liner itself. The gas cools the liner by heat-transfer contact with the liner along various places in or on the liner. In one embodiment, the gas flows in channels cut into the liner. In another embodiment, the cut channels are covered with a removable cover or seal. This use of a removable liner cover or seal enables easy replacement of the liner should it get too hot, for example, and also allows easy access to the channels for cleaning or whatever other maintenance may be needed. Instead of using recycled plasma gas as described herein and lowering temperatures inside the chamber, an alternative would be to run the torch at higher power density (increased power with the same gas flow). With the recycled plasma gas system as described herein turned on the result would be chamber temperatures similar to the lower power density case without the recycled plasma gas system being used as described herein. The advantage would be the gas leaves the chamber at a higher temperature, giving it more usable enthalpy per unit of power consumed, leading to a more thermally efficient process.


While the perforations are shown in FIG. 3 as regularly spaced circular holes, it should be noted that any openings that provide for the injection of the pre-heated recycle gas (such as hydrogen) into the plasma chamber can be used, e.g., random holes or perforations, zig-zag patterns, slit shaped perforations, etc. Similarly, the plasma chamber can be of any shape, such as cylindrical, and the perforations therefore would be along the curved sections of the cylindrical plasma chamber.


Should the cooling recycle gas contain trace amounts of hydrocarbons or other contaminants which lead to the formation of carbon or other deposits in the cooling channels, such deposits can be easily removed so as not to limit or otherwise interfere with the cooling in the liner which would be otherwise achieved. Steam, carbon dioxide and/or other oxidizing gases can also be added to the recycle gas to help reduce the amount of hydrocarbons or other contaminants which may be present in the recycle cooling gas, again, so as to reduce or eliminate the deposition of carbon or other contaminants in the cooling channels. In addition, if any deposited carbon or other contaminants are deposited in the channels, feeding steam, carbon dioxide and/or other oxidizing gas into the channels can also assist in eliminating any such deposits from the channels.


It is advantageous to obtain as uniform a cooling as possible in the liner, e.g., to avoid formation of “hot spots” in or on the liner. Accordingly, it is beneficial to subject the liner to as uniform and continuous a contact with cooling gas as possible, either externally and/or internally One embodiment for achieving a more even distribution of cooling gas is the use of one or more spiral cooling channels in the liners, although one or more straight, curved, or otherwise non-spiral channels can be used as well, either in combination or instead of spiral channels. If multiple channels are used, the use of a plenum to help provide an even distribution of the cooling gases within the channels is also beneficial.


The size and spacing of the channels will of course depend on the temperatures being generated in the plasma and/or reaction chambers, and the amount of cooling desired. Typical temperatures in the plasma chamber range from about 2500° C. to about 6000° C. and about 1200° C. to about 3000° C. in the reaction chamber. The channels are typically machined in as grooves, e.g., using conventional graphite cutting techniques and equipment, and are typically square or rectangular in cross section, and can be any size to accommodate the amount of cooling desired, e.g., 15 to 30 millimeters (mm) across and 50 to 100 mm deep.


Typically, between about 2 and about 20 MegaWatts of power are employed to create the plasma. The energy as measured in Joules will first be employed to create the plasma, and then be subsequently absorbed into the walls of the reactor, transferred to the plasma gas that did not go through the annulus or the plasma zone, and either immediately absorbed by the hydrocarbon or transferred to the injected hydrocarbon from the walls or from the plasma gas. The energy is absorbed by the hydrocarbon in the first one second after injection in the amount of at least 20%, 30%, or 40% or greater as measured in Joules. This energy can be absorbed from the electrodes, the plasma gas, the wall of the reactors, etc.


A perforated liner to enable aspirational cooling of the liner can also be used. Not only could this allow cooling gases to pass through the liner more uniformly, but it could also accelerate passage of gases in the hottest areas to dissipate heat more quickly, again to assist in attaining more uniform cooling. The pores present in the liner could either be drilled into the liner, or their formation incorporated into the process of manufacturing of the (porous) graphite used to form the liner.


Depending on the shape of the plasma assembly, the cooling gases can also be used in the torch annulus and/or outside of the torch annulus. Gas heated in the channels can be added to the plasma chamber or to the plasma gas which then flows through the annulus between the electrodes, i.e., since not all torches have an annulus, the recycle gas can be added to the plasma or mixed into the plasma after the arc. The torch annulus is defined as the space between two nested, concentric hollow cylinders that are used as the positive and negative electrodes of the torch.


As described herein, the cooling gases are used to cool the liner with the gas used in the plasma chamber, and in doing so preheat the gas used in the chamber, thereby reducing the amount of energy required to heat the plasma chamber gases to achieve a given temperature.


Referring to the Figures, which are schematic representations of systems described herein, conventional plasma gas (11, 21 and 31) such as oxygen, nitrogen, argon, helium, air, hydrogen, etc. (used alone or in mixtures of two or more) is injected into a plasma forming zone (12 and 22, and below the perforations 37 in FIG. 3) containing conventional plasma forming electrodes (10, 20 and 30) (which are typically made of copper, tungsten, graphite, molybdenum, silver etc.). The thus-formed plasma then enters into the reaction zone (13, 23 and 33) where it reacts/interacts with a carbon containing feedstock (14, 24 and 34) to generate a carbon black product. The liners (16, 26 and 36) can be any conventionally used material which can withstand the plasma forming temperatures, with graphite being preferred. Materials that can only withstand plasma forming temperatures with cooling may also be used. As shown, the recycle cooling gas flows through the cooling channels (15, 25 and 35), cooling the liner (16, 26 and 36) and heating the gas. The heated gas then flows into the plasma arc (as all or part of stream 11) as demonstrated in FIG. 1 and/or mixes into the plasma gas (formed from stream 21) with the mixing occurring in the plasma zone (22) as demonstrated in FIG. 2, or through the perforations (37) shown in FIG. 3. The mixture then flows into the reaction zone (13, 23 and 33) to contact the feedstock gas (14, 24 and 34).


Adding the heated cooling gas into the plasma gas stream (11) could potentially cause problems for the arc formed between the electrodes (10), so in some cases it may not be desirable. In these instances, all of or a portion of the cooling gas can instead get added to the plasma zone (22 and through perforations 37), preferably along the inside of the liner so that the gas provides additional protection for the liner from the hot plasma gas. The mixture then flows into the reaction zone (23 and 33) to contact the feedstock gas (24 and 34). It should also be noted, that that the direction of flow shown for the cooling gases (15 in FIG. 1) can also be in a direction reverse of that shown. The desired direction of flow will be dependent on the radiation flux on the liner, which is in turn dependent on the actual geometry of the liner. Thus flow can be counter current to plasma gas flow, co-current and/or cross-flow. The pre-heated gas can be injected through a co-planar set of perforations or multiple sets of co-planar perforations. The upper section (38) of the perforated section of FIG. 3 can be cylindrical in shape, with the lower section (39) being a converging cone. Although not shown in FIG. 3, it should also be noted that the perforations can extend above the space in the plasma chamber occupied by the electrodes as well.


The Figures demonstrate liners with curved channels contained therein. However, it should be understood that the cooling of the liners can take place by simply passing the cooling recycle plasma gas along one or more surfaces of the liners (depending on liner design), or through the liner by virtue of the presence of one or more straight, curved, spiral or other shaped channels. Since there are numerous advantages associated with uniformity of cooling by and/or within the liner, if multiple channels are present in the liner, a plenum can be used to assist in leveling the flow into the respective channels to help produce more even heat distribution within the liner. The liners can also contain pores, or be porous, such that the cooling can take place as aspirational cooling. The size and shape of the liners, the pores and the cooling surfaces or channels will depend on the size and shapes of the plasma forming zone and reaction zone, the temperatures desired in each zone, the amount and rate of cooling desired, the specific plasma gas being used, etc. For example, the generation and use of plasma at temperatures in excess of 1000° C. are not uncommon, which is one reason temperature control can be important to the process.


The Figures show a narrowing plasma chamber that then expands to a larger area downstream of plasma generation. An alternative configuration can entail a plasma chamber that does not narrow, but can or cannot expand downstream of plasma generation. The regenerative cooling would still take place in the general vicinity of the plasma generation (plasma chamber). Additionally, the hydrocarbon injection can occur either upstream or downstream of the plasma generation and can be centrally injected rather than the side injection that is depicted in FIGS. 1, 2, and 3.


Acceptable hydrocarbon feedstock includes any chemical with formula CnHx or CnHxOy where n is an integer, and x is between 1 and 2n+2, and y is between 0 and n. For example simple hydrocarbons such as: methane, ethane, propane, butane, etc. can be used, as well as aromatic feedstock such as benzene, toluene, methyl naphthalene, pyrolysis fuel oil, coal tar, coal, heavy oil, oil, bio-oil, bio-diesel, other biologically derived hydrocarbons, or the like. Also, unsaturated hydrodcarbon feedstocks can also be used, such as: ethylene, acetylene, butadiene, styrene and the like. Oxygenated hydrocarbons such as; ethanol, methanol, propanol, phenol, ether, and similar are also acceptable feedstocks. These examples are provided as non-limiting examples of acceptable hydrocarbon feedstocks which can further be combined and/or mixed with other acceptable components for manufacture. Hydrocarbon feedstock referred to herein, means that the majority of the feedstock is hydrocarbon in nature. A preferred hydrocarbon feedstock for this process is natural gas.


The recycle plasma gas is flowed through the channels in the liner which in addition to reducing the temperatures in the plasma and/or reaction chambers, raises the temperature of the cooling gas as well. After being heated, the recycle plasma gas is then used as is or mixed with the plasma gas being injected into the plasma zone. As can be appreciated, this pre-heating of the plasma gas can provide significant energy costs savings to the process.


In one embodiment, the channels are open and accessible, but covered or sealed during use. This accessibility facilitates such things as repair and replacement of the liners, and/or cleaning of the channels. For example, the plasma gas can contain hydrocarbons or other contaminants. At the high temperatures experienced in typical plasma processes, carbon or other deposits can end up on the liner or in the channels or pores. A removable cover or seal can facilitate the cleaning of such deposits. The covers are typically made of the same material as the liners, but can also be made of a porous material (e.g., carbon fibers, graphite foam, etc).


Even without the covers or seals described above, another way to reduce or eliminate such deposits from the channels, is to add an oxidizing gas to the plasma forming gas prior to entry into the cooling channel. Similarly, an oxidizing gas can be simply run through the channels for the same purpose. Exemplary oxidizing gases could be steam and/or carbon dioxide, for example.


In some cases, the plasma forming zone may contain a conventional plasma torch annulus, as shown schematically in FIG. 1, e.g., having a cathode (11), anode (12), plasma or carrier working gas (10) and plasma jet region (13). In such cases, the cooling recycle plasma gas may be flowed inside or outside the torch annulus, i.e., the plasma recycle gas can be added to the carrier working gas stream (10), or added to the plasma jet region (13).


In another set of cases, AC or DC power can be used to form the plasma. Examples of an AC plasma system can be found in U.S. Pat. No. 7,452,514, for example. The AC system can utilize a plurality of electrodes that has the advantage of more efficient energy consumption as well as reduced heat load at the electrode surface. Examples of a suitable DC plasma system can be found, for example, in U.S. Pat. No. 7,462,343, and the references therein.


Example 1

Hydrogen gas is run through a conventional plasma torch electrode assembly in a plasma forming zone. Graphite liners with cooling channels line the plasma forming zone. As can be seen in the Table below, the average temperature of the plasma chamber wall is 2640 K and the maximum temperature is 3210 K. Through the diversion of 10%, 20%, and 30% of the total recycle gas, which is greater than 90% H2, the following examples B, C, and D show a significant decrease in plasma wall temperature. For diversion of 30% of the total recycle gas the average temperature at the plasma wall is reduced from 2640 K to 2450 K and the maximum temperature is reduced from 3210 K to 3040 K. Each of these examples is with a heat input through the plasma torch of 750 KW (kilo watts) and a plasma gas flow rate of 340 Nm3/hr (normal cubic meter/hour) of hydrogen.












TABLE






Hydrogen Gas at %
Average
Maximum


Example
of total
Temperature (K)
Temperature (K)


















A
0
2640
3210


B
10
2490
3140


C
20
2470
3090


D
30
2450
3040









Thus, the scope of the invention shall include all modifications and variations that may fall within the scope of the attached claims. Other embodiments of the invention will be apparent to those skilled in the art from consideration of the specification and practice of the invention disclosed herein. It is intended that the specification and examples be considered as exemplary only, with a true scope and spirit of the invention being indicated by the following claims.

Claims
  • 1. A method of cooling a liner in a plasma chamber, comprising: providing at least one recycle gas from the plasma chamber;contacting the liner with or passing through the liner the at least one recycle gas to cool the liner and pre-heat the at least one recycle gas to generate a pre-heated recycle gas; anddirecting the pre-heated recycle gas to the plasma chamber to create a plasma.
  • 2. The method of claim 1, wherein the liner is graphite.
  • 3. The method of claim 1, wherein the at least one recycle gas passes through at least one cooling channel present in the liner.
  • 4. The method of claim 3, wherein a cooling channel of the at least one cooling channel is covered with at least one removable liner cover or channel cover.
  • 5. The method of claim 4, wherein the at least one removable liner cover or channel cover is removed to remove any carbon deposits in the cooling channel.
  • 6. The method of claim 5, wherein the carbon deposits are formed from a presence of hydrocarbons in the at least one recycle gas.
  • 7. The method of claim 3, wherein a cooling channel of the at least one cooling channel is formed in a spiral cooling channel pattern.
  • 8. The method of claim 3, wherein a cooling channel of the at least one cooling channel is formed in a substantially straight cooling channel pattern.
  • 9. The method of claim 3, including more than one cooling channel.
  • 10. The method of claim 9, including a plenum to aid in the production of an even distribution of cooling gas in the more than one cooling channel.
  • 11. The method of claim 3, including adding an oxidizing gas to the at least one recycle gas to reduce or eliminate a presence of hydrocarbons in the at least one recycle gas and/or reduce the formation of carbon deposits.
  • 12. The method of claim 11, wherein the oxidizing gas is steam and/or carbon dioxide.
  • 13. The method of claim 3, including passing an oxidizing gas through a cooling channel of the at least one cooling channel to remove any carbon deposits in the cooling channel.
  • 14. The method of claim 13, wherein the oxidizing gas is steam and/or carbon dioxide.
  • 15. The method of claim 13, wherein the carbon deposits are formed from a presence of hydrocarbons in the at least one recycle gas.
  • 16. The method of claim 1, wherein the liner contains a plurality of perforations providing an ingress for the pre-heated recycle gas.
  • 17. The method of claim 16, wherein the perforations comprise one to six sets of co-planar perforations along the plasma chamber.
  • 18. The method of claim 16, wherein the plasma chamber is cylindrical, and wherein the perforations are along curved sections of the plasma chamber cylinder.
  • 19. The method of claim 16, wherein the perforations allow aspirational cooling.
  • 20. The method of claim 1, wherein the plasma chamber contains a plasma torch annulus, and wherein the at least one recycle gas is recycled to inside and/or outside of the plasma torch annulus.
  • 21. The method of claim 1, wherein the plasma is generated using an AC power source.
  • 22. The method of claim 1, wherein the plasma is generated using a DC power source.
  • 23. The method of claim 1, including injecting a hydrocarbon feedstock into the plasma chamber such that over 30% of the energy input into the system measured in joules is transferred to the hydrocarbon feedstock within the first 1 second of injection.
  • 24. The method of claim 23, the hydrocarbon feedstock is natural gas.
  • 25. The method of claim 23, the hydrocarbon feedstock is injected downstream of the plasma creation.
  • 26. The method of claim 23, wherein the hydrocarbon feedstock is injected upstream of the plasma creation.
CROSS-REFERENCE TO RELATED APPLICATIONS

The present application claims the benefit of and priority to provisional patent application Ser. No. 62/111,341 filed Feb. 3, 2015, the disclosure of which is herein incorporated by reference.

PCT Information
Filing Document Filing Date Country Kind
PCT/US2016/015942 2/1/2016 WO 00
Publishing Document Publishing Date Country Kind
WO2016/126600 8/11/2016 WO A
US Referenced Citations (216)
Number Name Date Kind
1339225 Rose May 1920 A
1536612 Lewis May 1925 A
1597277 Jakowsky Aug 1926 A
2062358 Frolich Sep 1932 A
2002003 Eisenhut et al. May 1935 A
2393106 Johnson et al. Jan 1946 A
2557143 Royster Jun 1951 A
2572851 Gardner et al. Oct 1951 A
2603669 Chappell Jul 1952 A
2616842 Sheer et al. Nov 1952 A
2785964 Pollock Mar 1957 A
2850403 Day Sep 1958 A
2951143 Anderson et al. Aug 1960 A
3009783 Sheer et al. Nov 1961 A
3073769 Doukas Jan 1963 A
3288696 Orbach Nov 1966 A
3307923 Ruble Mar 1967 A
3308164 Shepard Mar 1967 A
3309780 Goins Mar 1967 A
3331664 Jordan Jul 1967 A
3344051 Latham, Jr. Sep 1967 A
3408164 Johnson Oct 1968 A
3409403 Bjornson et al. Nov 1968 A
3420632 Ryan Jan 1969 A
3431074 Jordan Mar 1969 A
3464793 Jordan et al. Sep 1969 A
3619140 Morgan et al. Nov 1971 A
3637974 Tajbl et al. Jan 1972 A
3673375 Camacho Jun 1972 A
3725103 Jordan et al. Apr 1973 A
3922335 Jordan et al. Nov 1975 A
3981654 Rood et al. Sep 1976 A
3981659 Myers Sep 1976 A
3984743 Horie Oct 1976 A
4028072 Braun et al. Jun 1977 A
4035336 Jordan et al. Jul 1977 A
4057396 Matovich Nov 1977 A
4075160 Mills et al. Feb 1978 A
4101639 Surovikin et al. Jul 1978 A
4199545 Matovich Apr 1980 A
4282199 Lamond et al. Aug 1981 A
4289949 Raaness et al. Sep 1981 A
4317001 Silver et al. Feb 1982 A
4372937 Johnson Feb 1983 A
4404178 Johnson et al. Sep 1983 A
4452771 Hunt Jun 1984 A
4472172 Sheer et al. Sep 1984 A
4553981 Fuderer Nov 1985 A
4601887 Dorn et al. Jul 1986 A
4678888 Camacho et al. Jul 1987 A
4689199 Eckert et al. Aug 1987 A
4787320 Raaness et al. Nov 1988 A
4864096 Wolf et al. Sep 1989 A
4977305 Severance, Jr. Dec 1990 A
5039312 Hollis, Jr. et al. Aug 1991 A
5045667 Iceland et al. Sep 1991 A
5046145 Drouet Sep 1991 A
5105123 Ballou Apr 1992 A
5147998 Tsantrizos et al. Sep 1992 A
5206880 Olsson Apr 1993 A
5352289 Weaver et al. Oct 1994 A
5399957 Vierboom et al. Mar 1995 A
5476826 Greenwald et al. Dec 1995 A
5481080 Lynum et al. Jan 1996 A
5486674 Lynum et al. Jan 1996 A
5500501 Lynum et al. Mar 1996 A
5527518 Lynum et al. Jun 1996 A
5593644 Norman et al. Jan 1997 A
5604424 Shuttleworth Feb 1997 A
5611947 Vavruska Mar 1997 A
5673285 Wittle et al. Sep 1997 A
5717293 Sellers Feb 1998 A
5725616 Lynum et al. Mar 1998 A
5749937 Detering et al. May 1998 A
5935293 Detering et al. Aug 1999 A
5951960 Lynum et al. Sep 1999 A
5989512 Lynum et al. Nov 1999 A
5997837 Lynum et al. Dec 1999 A
6068827 Lynum et al. May 2000 A
6099696 Schwob et al. Aug 2000 A
6188187 Harlan Feb 2001 B1
6197274 Mahmud et al. Mar 2001 B1
6358375 Schwob Mar 2002 B1
6380507 Childs Apr 2002 B1
6395197 Detering et al. May 2002 B1
6403697 Mitsunaga et al. Jun 2002 B1
6441084 Lee et al. Aug 2002 B1
6442950 Tung Sep 2002 B1
6444727 Yamada et al. Sep 2002 B1
6602920 Hall et al. Aug 2003 B2
6703580 Brunet et al. Mar 2004 B2
6773689 Lynum et al. Aug 2004 B1
6955707 Ezell et al. Oct 2005 B2
7167240 Stagg Jan 2007 B2
7312415 Ohmi et al. Dec 2007 B2
7431909 Rumpf et al. Oct 2008 B1
7452514 Fabry et al. Nov 2008 B2
7462343 Lynum et al. Dec 2008 B2
7563525 Ennis Jul 2009 B2
7655209 Rumpf et al. Feb 2010 B2
7777151 Kuo Aug 2010 B2
8147765 Muradov et al. Apr 2012 B2
8221689 Boutot et al. Jul 2012 B2
8257452 Menzel Sep 2012 B2
8277739 Monsen et al. Oct 2012 B2
8323793 Hamby et al. Dec 2012 B2
8443741 Chapman et al. May 2013 B2
8471170 Li et al. Jun 2013 B2
8486364 Vanier et al. Jul 2013 B2
8501148 Belmont et al. Aug 2013 B2
8581147 Kooken et al. Nov 2013 B2
8710136 Yurovskaya et al. Apr 2014 B2
8771386 Licht et al. Jul 2014 B2
8784617 Novoselov et al. Jul 2014 B2
8850826 Ennis Oct 2014 B2
8911596 Vancina Dec 2014 B2
9095835 Skoptsov Aug 2015 B2
9315735 Cole et al. Apr 2016 B2
9445488 Foret Sep 2016 B2
9574086 Johnson et al. Feb 2017 B2
10138378 Hoermman et al. Nov 2018 B2
20010029888 Sindarrajan et al. Oct 2001 A1
20010039797 Cheng Nov 2001 A1
20020000085 Hall et al. Jan 2002 A1
20020050323 Moisan et al. May 2002 A1
20020051903 Masuko et al. May 2002 A1
20020157559 Brunet et al. Oct 2002 A1
20030103858 Baran et al. Jun 2003 A1
20030152184 Shehanee et al. Aug 2003 A1
20040047779 Denison Mar 2004 A1
20040071626 Smith et al. Apr 2004 A1
20040081862 Herman Apr 2004 A1
20040148860 Fletcher Aug 2004 A1
20040168904 Anazawa et al. Sep 2004 A1
20040211760 Delzenne et al. Oct 2004 A1
20040216559 Kim et al. Nov 2004 A1
20040247509 Newby Dec 2004 A1
20050063892 Tandon et al. Mar 2005 A1
20050230240 Dubrovsky et al. Oct 2005 A1
20060037244 Clawson Feb 2006 A1
20060068987 Bollepalli et al. Mar 2006 A1
20060107789 Deegan et al. May 2006 A1
20060226538 Kawata Oct 2006 A1
20060239890 Chang et al. Oct 2006 A1
20070140004 Marotta et al. Jun 2007 A1
20070183959 Charlier et al. Aug 2007 A1
20070270511 Melnichuk et al. Nov 2007 A1
20080041829 Blutke et al. Feb 2008 A1
20080121624 Belashchenko et al. May 2008 A1
20080169183 Hertel et al. Jul 2008 A1
20080182298 Day Jul 2008 A1
20080226538 Rumpf et al. Sep 2008 A1
20080279749 Probst et al. Nov 2008 A1
20080292533 Belmont et al. Nov 2008 A1
20090014423 Li et al. Jan 2009 A1
20090090282 Gold et al. Apr 2009 A1
20090142250 Fabry et al. Jun 2009 A1
20090155157 Stenger et al. Jun 2009 A1
20090173252 Nakata et al. Jul 2009 A1
20090208751 Green et al. Aug 2009 A1
20090230098 Salsich et al. Sep 2009 A1
20100249353 MacIntosh et al. Sep 2010 A1
20110036014 Tsangaris et al. Feb 2011 A1
20110071692 D'Amato et al. Mar 2011 A1
20110076608 Bergemann et al. Mar 2011 A1
20110155703 Winn Jun 2011 A1
20110180513 Luhrs et al. Jul 2011 A1
20110239542 Liu et al. Oct 2011 A1
20120018402 Carducci et al. Jan 2012 A1
20120025693 Wang et al. Feb 2012 A1
20120201266 Boulos et al. Aug 2012 A1
20120232173 Juranitch et al. Sep 2012 A1
20120292794 Prabhu Nov 2012 A1
20130039841 Nester et al. Feb 2013 A1
20130062195 Samaranayake et al. Mar 2013 A1
20130062196 Sin Mar 2013 A1
20130092525 Li et al. Apr 2013 A1
20130194840 Huselstein et al. Aug 2013 A1
20130292363 Hwang et al. Nov 2013 A1
20130323614 Chapman et al. Dec 2013 A1
20130340651 Wampler et al. Dec 2013 A1
20140057166 Yokoyama et al. Feb 2014 A1
20140131324 Shipulski et al. May 2014 A1
20140190179 Barker et al. Jul 2014 A1
20140224706 Do et al. Aug 2014 A1
20140227165 Hung et al. Aug 2014 A1
20140248442 Luizi et al. Sep 2014 A1
20140290532 Rodriguez et al. Oct 2014 A1
20140294716 Susekov et al. Oct 2014 A1
20140339478 Probst et al. Nov 2014 A1
20140357092 Singh Dec 2014 A1
20140373752 Hassinen et al. Dec 2014 A2
20150044516 Kyrlidis et al. Feb 2015 A1
20150056516 Hellring et al. Feb 2015 A1
20150064099 Nester et al. Mar 2015 A1
20150180346 Yuzurihara et al. Jun 2015 A1
20150210856 Johnson et al. Jul 2015 A1
20150210857 Johnson et al. Jul 2015 A1
20150210858 Hoermann et al. Jul 2015 A1
20150211378 Johnson et al. Jul 2015 A1
20150217940 Si et al. Aug 2015 A1
20150218383 Johnson et al. Aug 2015 A1
20150223314 Hoermann et al. Aug 2015 A1
20160030856 Kaplan et al. Feb 2016 A1
20160210856 Assenbaum et al. Jul 2016 A1
20160243518 Spitzl Aug 2016 A1
20160293959 Blizanac et al. Oct 2016 A1
20170034898 Moss et al. Feb 2017 A1
20170037253 Hardman et al. Feb 2017 A1
20170058128 Johnson et al. Mar 2017 A1
20170066923 Hardman et al. Mar 2017 A1
20170073522 Hardman et al. Mar 2017 A1
20170349758 Johnson Dec 2017 A1
20180015438 Taylor et al. Jan 2018 A1
20180016441 Taylor et al. Jan 2018 A1
20180022925 Hardman et al. Jan 2018 A1
Foreign Referenced Citations (78)
Number Date Country
2897071 Nov 1972 AU
830378 Dec 1969 CA
964 405 Mar 1975 CA
2 353 752 Jan 2003 CA
2 621 749 Aug 2009 CA
1644650 Jul 2005 CN
101092691 Dec 2007 CN
102108216 Jun 2011 CN
102993788 Mar 2013 CN
103160149 Jun 2013 CN
203269847 Nov 2013 CN
211457 Jul 1984 DE
198 07 224 Aug 1999 DE
0 325 689 Aug 1989 EP
0 616 600 Sep 1994 EP
0 635 044 Feb 1996 EP
0 635 043 Jun 1996 EP
0 861 300 Sep 1998 EP
1 188 801 Mar 2002 EP
1 088 854 Apr 2010 EP
2 891 434 Mar 2007 FR
2 937 029 Apr 2010 FR
395 893 Jul 1933 GB
987498 Mar 1965 GB
1 400 266 Jul 1975 GB
1 492 346 Nov 1977 GB
4-228270 Aug 1992 JP
6-322615 Nov 1994 JP
9-316645 Dec 1997 JP
11-123562 May 1999 JP
2004-300334 Oct 2004 JP
2005-235709 Sep 2005 JP
2005-243410 Sep 2005 JP
10-2008-105344 Dec 2008 KR
2014-0075261 Jun 2014 KR
2425795 Aug 2011 RU
2488984 Jul 2013 RU
9312031 Jun 1993 WO
9318094 Sep 1993 WO
9320153 Oct 1993 WO
WO-9320152 Oct 1993 WO
9323331 Nov 1993 WO
1994008747 Apr 1994 WO
9703133 Jan 1997 WO
9813428 Apr 1998 WO
WO-0018682 Apr 2000 WO
03014018 Feb 2003 WO
2012015313 Feb 2012 WO
2012067546 May 2012 WO
2012094743 Jul 2012 WO
2012149170 Nov 2012 WO
2013134093 Sep 2013 WO
2013184074 Dec 2013 WO
2013185219 Dec 2013 WO
2014000108 Jan 2014 WO
2014012169 Jan 2014 WO
2015049008 Apr 2015 WO
2015093947 Jun 2015 WO
2015116797 Aug 2015 WO
2015116798 Aug 2015 WO
2015116800 Aug 2015 WO
2015116807 Aug 2015 WO
2015116811 Aug 2015 WO
2015116943 Aug 2015 WO
2016012367 Jan 2016 WO
2016014641 Aug 2016 WO
2016126598 Aug 2016 WO
2016126599 Aug 2016 WO
2016126600 Aug 2016 WO
2017019683 Feb 2017 WO
2017027385 Feb 2017 WO
2017034980 Mar 2017 WO
2017044594 Mar 2017 WO
2017048621 Mar 2017 WO
2017190015 Nov 2017 WO
2017190045 Nov 2017 WO
2018165483 Sep 2018 WO
2018195460 Oct 2018 WO
Non-Patent Literature Citations (107)
Entry
Bakken et al. “Thermal plasma process development in Norway.” Pure and applied Chemistry 70.6 (1998): 1223-1228.
Breeze, “Raising steam plant efficiency—Pushing the steam cycle boundaries.” PEI Magazine 20.4 (2012).
Chiesa et al., “Using Hydrogen as Gas Turbine Fuel”. ASME. J. Eng. Gas Turbines Power (2005),127(1):73-80. doi:10.1115/1.1787513.
Donnet et al. “Observation of Plasma-Treated Carbon Black Surfaces by Scanning Tunnelling Microscopy,” Carbon (1994) 32(2):199-206.
Larouche et al. “Nitrogen Functionalization of Carbon Black in a Thermo-Convective Plasma Reactor,” Plasma Chem Plasma Process (2011) 31:635-647.
Polman et al., “Reduction of CO2 emissions by adding hydrogen to natural gas.” IEA Green House Gas R&D programme (2003).
Reynolds, “Electrode Resistance: How Important is Surface Area” Oct. 10, 2016. p. 3 para[0001]; Figure 3; Retrieved from http://electrofishing.net/2016/10/10/electrode-resistance-how-important-is-surface-area/ on May 8, 2018.
Tsujikawa, Y., and T. Sawada. “Analysis of a gas turbine and steam turbine combined cycle with liquefied hydrogen as fuel.” International Journal of Hydrogen Energy 7.6 (1982): 499-505.
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, “Guide to Industrial Assessments for Pollution Prevention and Energy Efficiency,” EPA 625/R-99/003, 1999.
Verfondern, K., “Nuclear Energy for Hydrogen Production”, Schriften des Forschungzentrum Julich, vol. 58, 2007.
Wikipedia “Heating Element” Oct. 14, 2016. p. 1 para[0001]. Retrieved from https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Heating_element&oldid=744277540 on May 9, 2018.
Wikipedia “Joule Heating” Jan. 15, 2017. p. 1 para[0002]. Retrieved from https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Joule_heating&oldid=760136650 on May 9, 2018.
Corrected Notice of Allowance dated Feb. 9, 2018 in U.S. Appl. No. 14/601,761.
Extended European Search Report from EP Application No. 15743214.7 dated Jan. 16, 2018.
Extended European Search Report from EP Application No. 16747055.8 dated Jun. 27, 2018.
Extended European Search Report from EP Application No. 16747056.6 dated Jun. 27, 2018.
Extended European Search Report from EP Application No. 16747057.4 dated Oct. 9, 2018.
Extended European Search Report from EP Application No. 16835697.0 dated Nov. 28, 2018.
Final Office Action dated Oct. 13, 2017 in U.S. Appl. No. 14/591,476.
Final Office Action dated Oct. 13, 2017 in U.S. Appl. No. 14/591,541.
Final Office Action dated Sep. 19, 2017 in U.S. Appl. No. 15/221,088.
Final Office Action from U.S. Appl. No. 15/259,884, dated Oct. 11, 2018.
Invitation to Pay Additional Fees dated Jun. 18, 2018 in PCT/US2018/028619.
Invitation to Pay Additional Fees in PCT/US2018/048378 dated Oct. 26, 2018.
Invitation to Pay Additional Fees in PCT/US2018/048381 dated Oct. 9, 2018.
IPRP from PCT/US2015/013482, dated Aug. 2, 2016.
IPRP from PCT/US2017/030139 dated Oct. 30, 2018.
IPRP from PCT/US2017/030179 dated Oct. 30, 2018.
ISR and Written Opinion for PCT/US2018/048374 dated Nov. 26, 2018.
ISR and Written Opinion for PCT/US2018/048378 dated Dec. 20, 2018.
ISR and Written Opinion for PCT/US2018/048381 dated Dec. 14, 2018.
ISR and Written Opinion from PCT/US2018/021627, dated May 31, 2018.
ISR and Written Opinion from PCT/US2018/028619, dated Aug. 9, 2018.
Non-Final Office Action dated Apr. 20, 2018 in U.S. Appl. No. 15/221,088.
Non-Final Office Action dated Jan. 16, 2018 in U.S. Appl. No. 14/591,528.
Non-Final Office Action dated Jan. 9, 2018 in U.S. Appl. No. 15/259,884.
Non-Final Office Action dated Jul. 6, 2018 in U.S. Appl. No. 15/241,771.
Non-Final Office Action dated Jun. 1, 2018 in U.S. Appl. No. 15/262,539.
Non-Final Office Action dated Jun. 7, 2018 in U.S. Appl. No. 14/591,476.
Non-Final Office Action dated Jun. 7, 2018 in U.S. Appl. No. 15/410,283.
Non-Final Office Action from U.S. Appl. No. 15/548,352 dated Oct. 10, 2018.
Notice of Allowance dated Jan. 18, 2018 in U.S. Appl. No. 14/601,761.
Notice of Allowance dated Jun. 19, 2018 in U.S. Appl. No. 14/601,761.
Notice of Allowance dated Jun. 7, 2018 in U.S. Appl. No. 14/591,541.
Search report from RU Application No. 2016135213 dated Feb. 12, 2018.
Translation of Official Notification of RU Application No. 2016135213 dated Feb. 12, 2018.
Invitation to Pay Additional Fees in PCT/US2018/057401 dated Dec. 19, 2018.
Final Office Action for U.S. Appl. No. 15/262,539 dated Jan. 4, 2019.
Gago et al., “Growth mechanisms and structure of fullerene-like carbon-based thin films: superelastic materials for tribological applications,” Trends in Fullerene Research, Published by Nova Science Publishers, Inc. (2007), pp. 1-46.
ISR and Written Opinion from PCT/US2015/013482, dated Jun. 17, 2015.
ISR and Written Opinion from PCT/US2015/013505, dated May 11, 2015.
ISR and Written Opinion from PCT/US2015/013794, dated Jun. 19, 2015.
Donnet, Basal and Wang, “Carbon Black”, New York: Marcel Dekker, 1993 pp. 46, 47 and 54.
Boehm, HP, “Some Aspects of Surface Chemistry of Carbon Blacks and Other Carbons”, Carbon 1994, p. 759.
“The Science and Technology of Rubber” (Mark, Erman, and Roland, Fourth Edition, Academic Press, 2013).
“Carbon Black Elastomer Interaction” Rubber Chemistry and Technology, 1991, pp. 19-39.
“The Impact of a Fullerene-Like Concept in Carbon Black Science”, Carbon, 2002, pp. 157-162.
ISR and Written Opinion from PCT/US2015/013510, dated Apr. 22, 2015.
ISR and Written Opinion from PCT/US2016/015939, dated Jun. 3, 2016.
ISR and Written Opinion from PCT/US2016/015941, dated Apr. 22, 2016.
ISR and Written Opinion from PCT/US2016/015942, dated Apr. 11, 2016.
ISR and Written Opinion from PCT/US2016/044039, dated Oct. 6, 2016.
ISR and Written Opinion from PCT/US2016/045793, dated Oct. 18, 2016.
ISR and Written Opinion from PCT/US2016/050728, dated Nov. 18, 2016.
ISR and Written Opinion from PCT/US2016/051261, dated Nov. 18, 2016.
ISR and Written Opinion from PCT/US2015/013484, dated Apr. 22, 2015.
Non-Final Office Action dated Mar. 16, 2016 in U.S. Appl. No. 14/591,476.
Final Office Action dated Jul. 11, 2016 in in U.S. Appl. No. 14/591,476.
Non-Final Office Action dated Mar. 16, 2016 in U.S. Appl. No. 14/591,541.
Final Office Action dated Jul. 14, 2016 in U.S. Appl. No. 14/591,541.
Non-Final Office Action dated Apr. 13, 2016 in U.S. Appl. No. 14/601,761.
Final Office Action dated Oct. 19, 2016 in U.S. Appl. No. 14/601,761.
Non-Final Office Action dated Apr. 13, 2016 in U.S. Appl. No. 14/601,793.
Final Office Action dated Aug. 3, 2016 in U.S. Appl. No. 14/601,793.
Notice of Allowance dated Oct. 7, 2016 in U.S. Appl. No. 14/601,793.
Non-Final Office Action dated Dec. 23, 2016 in U.S. Appl. No. 15/221,088.
AP 42, Fifth Edition, vol. I, Chapter 6: Organic Chemical Process Industry, Section 6.1: Carbon Black.
Fulcheri, et al. “Plasma processing: a step towards the production of new grades of carbon black.” Carbon 40.2 (2002): 169-176.
Grivei, et al. A clean process for carbon nanoparticles and hydrogen production from plasma hydrocarbon cracking. Publishable Report, European Commission JOULE III Programme, Project No. JOE3-CT97-0057, circa 2000.
Fabry, et al. “Carbon black processing by thermal plasma. Analysis of the particle formation mechanism.” Chemical Engineering Science 56.6 (2001): 2123-2132.
Pristavita, et al. “Carbon nanoparticle production by inductively coupled thermal plasmas: controlling the thermal history of particle nucleation.” Plasma Chemistry and Plasma Processing 31.6 (2011): 851-866.
Cho, et al. “Conversion of natural gas to hydrogen and carbon black by plasma and application of plasma black.” Symposia—American Chemical Society, Div. Fuel Chem. vol. 49. 2004.
Pristavita, et al. “Carbon blacks produced by thermal plasma: the influence of the reactor geometry on the product morphology.” Plasma. Chemistry and Plasma. Processing 30.2 (2010): 267-279.
Pristavita, et al. “Volatile Compounds Present in Carbon Blacks Produced by Thermal Plasmas.” Plasma Chemistry and Plasma. Processing 31.6 (2011): 839-850.
Garberg, et al. “A transmission electron microscope and electron diffraction study of carbon nanodisks.” Carbon 46.12 (2008): 1535-1543.
Knaapila, et al. “Directed assembly of carbon nanocones into wires with an epoxy coating in thin films by a combination of electric field alignment and subsequent pyrolysis.” Carbon 49.10 (2011): 3171-3178.
Krishnan, et al. “Graphitic cones and the nucleation of curved carbon surfaces.” Nature 388.6641 (1997): 451-454.
Hoyer, et al. “Microelectromechanical strain and pressure sensors based on electric field aligned carbon cone and carbon black particles in a silicone elastomer matrix.” Journal of Applied Physics 112.9 (2012): 094324.
Naess, Stine Nalum, et al. “Carbon nanocones: wall structure and morphology.” Science and Technology of advanced materials (2016), 7 pages.
Fulcheri, et al. “From methane to hydrogen, carbon black and water.” International journal of hydrogen energy 20.3 (1995): 197-202.
ISR and Written Opinion from PCT/US2016/047769, dated Dec. 30, 2016.
D.L. Sun, F. Wang, R.Y. Hong, C.R. Xie, Preparation of carbon black via arc discharge plasma enhanced by thermal pyrolysis, Diamond & Related Materials (2015), doi: 10.1016/j.diamond.2015.11.004, 47 pages.
Non-Final Office Action dated Feb. 22, 2017 in U.S. Appl. No. 14/591,541.
Non-Final Office Action dated May 2, 2017 in U.S. Appl. No. 14/610,299.
Ex Parte Quayke Action dated May 19, 2017 in U.S. Appl. No. 14/601,761.
Extended European Search Report from EP Application No. 15 742 910.1 dated Jul. 18, 2017.
Search report in counterpart European Application No. 15 74 3214 dated Sep. 12, 2017.
ISR and Written Opinion from PCT/US2017/030139, dated Jul. 19, 2017.
ISR and Written Opinion from PCT/US2017/030179, dated Jul. 27, 2017.
A.I. Media et al., “Tinting Strength of Carbon Black,” Journal of Colloid and Interface Science, vol. 40, No. 2, Aug. 1972.
Reese, J. (2017). Resurgence in American manufacturing will be led by the rubber and tire industry. Rubber World. 255. 18-21 and 23.
Non-Final Office Action dated Feb. 27, 2017 in U.S. Appl. No. 14/591,476.
EP17790549.4 Extended European Search Report dated Nov. 26, 2019.
EP17790570.0 Extended European Search Report dated Nov. 8, 2019.
U.S. Appl. No. 15/548,346 Office Action dated Oct. 22, 2019.
U.S. Appl. No. 14/591,528 Office Action dated Oct. 28, 2019.
U.S. Appl. No. 15/229,608 Office Action dated Oct. 25, 2019.
Related Publications (1)
Number Date Country
20180015438 A1 Jan 2018 US
Provisional Applications (1)
Number Date Country
62111341 Feb 2015 US