Reinforced composite pallet assembly of the sandwich-type with a locally crushed cellular core

Information

  • Patent Grant
  • 6748876
  • Patent Number
    6,748,876
  • Date Filed
    Tuesday, July 30, 2002
    22 years ago
  • Date Issued
    Tuesday, June 15, 2004
    20 years ago
Abstract
A reinforced composite pallet assembly of the sandwich-type having a cellular core which is locally crushed is provided. The assembly includes a pair of substantially flat decks having front, back and side edges. Each of the decks includes a load-bearing skin made of a reinforced thermoplastics material, a grid of reinforcing slats, a cellular core made of a thermoplastics material, and a tine-engaging skin made of a reinforced thermoplastics material. The grid of reinforcing slats is positioned at predetermined places against the tine-engaging skins. The distance between the skins of each deck is reduced during molding of the deck which molding locally crushes the core at the predetermined places. A plurality of supports support the decks at the predetermined places against the reinforcing slats so that tines can lift and support the pallet assembly at the tine-engaging skin. The resulting assembly is ultra light weight, meeting all forecasted government weight restrictions. Other features include molded-in features added as part of the forming process (i.e., pockets, grooves, and/or ribs on retraining walls).
Description




BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION




1. Field of the Invention




The present invention relates generally to pallet assemblies of sandwich-type composite structure having a cellular core and, in particular, to such pallet assemblies whose structure is reinforced locally.




2. Background Art




Sandwich-type materials having cellular cores have very important characteristics resulting from their being light in weight yet very rigid.




Conventionally, such a panel is constructed by sandwiching a cellular core having low strength characteristics by gluing it or bonding it between two skins, each of which is much thinner than the cellular core but has excellent mechanical characteristics.




The patent document FR 2 711 573 discloses a method of making a panel of sandwich-type composite structure having a cellular core. In that method, said panel is made in a single step by subjecting a preheated stack to cold-pressing in a mold, which stack is made up of at least a first skin made of a stampable reinforced thermoplastics material, of a cellular core made of a thermoplastics material, of a second skin made of a stampable reinforced thermoplastics material, and of a first external covering layer made of a woven or non-woven material, the skins and core being preheated outside the mold to a softening temperature.




Such a method is particularly advantageous because of the fact that it makes it possible, in a single operation, both to generate cohesion between the various layers of the composite structure, and to shape the panel.




The resulting panel conserves all of the mechanical properties imparted by the cellular core sandwich structure.




European patent EP 0 649 736 B1 explains the principle of molding substantially flat parts out of thermoplastic sandwich material (TSM). The part is made in a single stage by pressing in a cold mold, at a pressure in the range of 10 bars to 30 bars, a stack consisting of at least a first top skin layer of stampable reinforced thermoplastics material, a cellular or honeycomb core of thermoplastics material and a second bottom skin layer of stampable reinforced thermoplastics material. The axes of the cells of the cellular core are generally oriented perpendicular to the skin layers. The skin layers and core are previously heated outside the mold to a softening temperature. Such sandwich material is also described in U.S. Pat. No. 5,683,782. The cellular core of such material enables the part to be very rigid while being light in weight.




U.S. Pat. No. 6,050,630 discloses a molded composite stack including a cellular core for a vehicle and a mold for forming the stack into a vehicular part, such as a floor panel.




Panels of sandwich-type composite structures having a cellular core have strength characteristics sufficient to enable mechanical structures subjected to large stresses to be reinforced structurally without making them too heavy. Such panels are in common use in shipbuilding, aircraft construction, and rail vehicle construction.




However, the non-uniformness of the mechanical stresses to which they are subjected sometimes makes it necessary to form local reinforcing plies at those places in said panels where the mechanical stresses are greatest.




In the field of aircraft construction, sandwich structure composite panels are made that are based on thermosettable resins reinforced with fibers.




In order to impart the desired shapes to the panels, and to maintain the shapes, the fibers and the thermosettable resin (in the form of pre-impregnates) are deposited layer-by-layer in a mold, and are then heated to high temperatures so as to cure (i.e. polymerize) the resin permanently.




The molds used may have a punch and/or machining device integrated into the mold.




Making such locally-reinforced panels consists firstly in defining zones where stresses are concentrated in the resulting panels, such zones being defined either by real testing or by computer simulation, and then in adding reinforcing plies at those places so as to make it possible to withstand such stresses.




The reinforcing plies are one-directional mats or woven fabrics of glass fibers, of carbon fibers, or of natural fibers embedded in a thermosettable resin, with an orientation that is determined by the orientation of the stresses. They are cut out to a pattern using special machines, e.g. water-jet cutting machines.




The reinforcing plies are disposed layer-by-layer in a mold, either manually or by means of a robot, with each ply having its own orientation.




That operation may be referred to as the “laying up” operation.




Then comes the baking step which is the longest step of the method of making such pieces because the stack of layers must be heated sufficiently to cure the thermosettable resin.




The various layers disposed in the mold are pressed in the mold by evacuating the mold. Such evacuation serves to press the materials against the die or the punch, and to remove surplus resin.




The desired shape is thus obtained with the fibers being impregnated with the resin as well as possible.




That “lamination” technique, and in particular the “laying up” operation, is characterized by a very low level of automation, and a large labor input.




Although, by means of the concept of localizing the strength, that technique makes it possible to achieve performance levels that are high for the pieces that are made in that way, it requires rigorous monitoring of quality.




As a result, that technique is very costly and cannot be used at the high production throughputs implemented in many fields such as the automobile industry.




Generally, plastic pallets can be easily molded and are lighter in weight than wooden pallets. Also, such pallets are more mold, bacteria, pest and insect resistant. Furthermore, in general, plastic pallets are more durable than wooden pallets as shown in U.S. Pat. No. 5,497,709.




Plastics processing technology has enjoyed significant recent advances, such that traditional high-strength materials such as metals are being replaced with fiber composite materials. These materials are not only light, but also are flexible and durable.




U.S. Pat. Nos. 5,891,560 and 6,165,604 disclose fiber-reinforced composites prepared from a depolymerizable and repolymerizable polymer having the processing advantages of a thermoset without being brittle. Impregnation of polymer into the fiber bundle is achieved, while still producing a composite with desirable physical properties and high damage tolerance.




One factor that has limited the number of plastic pallets is that plastic pallets require a given amount of relatively expensive plastic material for a desired measure of pallet strength. U.S. Pat. Nos. 5,868,080 and 6,199,488 disclose reinforced plastic pallet constructions and assembly methods wherein multiple reinforcing bars are employed. The reinforcing bars preferably comprise composite structural members of fiberglass reinforced thermosetting plastic fabricated from a pultrusion process.




As noted in the above-mentioned '560 and '604 patents, although thermoset composites have excellent mechanical properties, they suffer from several disadvantages: thermoset matrices have relatively limited elongation, the thermoset precursors are a source of undesirable volatile organic compounds (VOCs), the composites cannot be reshaped or recycled, and their production rates are limited.




Other factors limiting the use of plastic pallets are the need for expensive equipment, long cycle times and high capital investment.




Consequently, in principle at least, thermoplastic composites would solve many of the problems associated with thermosets. For example, unlike thermosets, thermoplastics can be reshaped, welded, staked, or thermoformed. Furthermore, thermoplastics are generally tougher, more ductile, and have greater elongation than thermosets.




SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION




An object of the present invention is to provide a reinforced composite pallet assembly of the cellular core sandwich-type which can be made simply and cheaply, and can be implemented at high throughputs.




In carrying out the above object and other objects of the present invention, a reinforced composite pallet assembly of the sandwich-type having a cellular core is provided. The assembly includes a substantially flat deck having front, back and side edges and including: a) a load-bearing skin made of a reinforced thermoplastics material; b) a grid of reinforcing slats; c) a cellular core made of a thermoplastics material; and d) a tine-engaging skin made of a reinforced thermoplastics material. The grid of reinforcing slats is positioned at predetermined places against the tine-engaging skin, and the distance between the skins is reduced during molding of the deck which molding locally crushes the core at the predetermined places. The assembly further includes at least one support for supporting the deck at the predetermined places against the reinforcing slats so that tines can lift and support the pallet assembly at the tine-engaging skin.




Slats of the grid may be positioned adjacent to the front, back and side edges of the deck, and at least one of the slats may extend from positions adjacent the edges to a center of the deck.




The load-bearing skin may extend downwardly to the tine-engaging skin at the front, back and side edges of the deck so that the core is substantially totally enclosed by the skins and the edges are finished.




The assembly may further include another deck, wherein the at least one support interconnects the decks at their tine-engaging skins, and the assembly may be stackable or rackable.




The load-bearing skin of the another deck may extend upwardly to the tine-engaging skin at the front, back and side edges of the deck so that the core of the another deck is substantially totally enclosed by the skins of the another deck and its edges are finished.




At least one reinforcing slat may be received and retained within a cavity formed between the tine-engaging skin and the at least one support.




A plurality of supports may support the deck, and the reinforcing slats may be received and retained within a plurality of cavities formed between the tine-engaging skin and the plurality of supports.




The skins may be made of a woven fabric or mat of glass fibers and of a thermoplastics material.




The reinforcing slats of the grids may be made of a thermoplastic or a composite material.




The composite may be fiber-reinforced and may include a depolymerizable and repolymerizable thermoplastic polymer resin.




The resin may be a thermoplastic polyurethane.




The thermoplastics material of the skins may be a polyolefin and preferably polypropylene.




The cellular core of the deck may have an open-celled structure of the tubular or honeycomb cell type, constituted mainly of polyolefin and preferably polypropylene.




A plurality of spaced supports may support the deck adjacent corners and possibly other locations of the deck.




The at least one support may be made of a thermoplastics material, and substantially the entire pallet assembly may be recyclable.




The at least one support may further be a hollow thermoplastic foot and may interconnect the decks at their tine-engaging skins adjacent at least one of the edges.




A plurality of spaced supports may interconnect the decks at their tine-engaging skins adjacent the front, back and side edges of the decks.




The above object and other objects, features, and advantages of the present invention are readily apparent from the following detailed description of the best mode for carrying out the invention when taken in connection with the accompanying drawings.











BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS





FIG. 1

is a side schematic view, partially broken away and in cross-section, of a double-deck design for a stackable and rackable pallet assembly of the present invention;





FIG. 2

is a top plan view of a pallet assembly of the present invention with a grid of reinforcing slats illustrated by phantom lines; and





FIG. 3

is a top plan view of another pallet assembly of the present invention with a different grid of reinforcing slats.











DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS




Referring now to the drawing Figures, there is illustrated in

FIG. 1

, a portion of a reinforced composite pallet assembly, generally indicated at


10


, of the sandwich-type having a cellular core. The assembly


10


includes a substantially flat deck, generally indicated at


12


, having front, back and side edges


13


. The deck


12


includes a load-bearing skin


14


made of a reinforced thermoplastics material, a grid of reinforcing bars or slats


16


, a cellular core


18


made of a thermoplastics material, and a tine-engaging skin


20


made of a reinforced thermoplastics material. The grid of reinforcing slats


16


are positioned at predetermined places against the tine-engaging skin


20


wherein the distance between the skins


14


and


20


is reduced during molding of the deck which molding locally crushes the core at the predetermined places. The assembly


10


also includes at least one support, generally indicated at


22


, for supporting the deck


12


at the predetermined places against the reinforcing slats


16


so that tines can lift and support the pallet assembly


10


at the tine-engaging skin


20


.




The slats


16


of the grid are positioned adjacent to the front, back and side edges


13


of the deck


12


, as best shown in phantom in

FIG. 2. A

central slat


16


extends across the deck


12


. Referring to

FIG. 3

, another assembly


10


′ is shown which is substantially identical to the assembly


10


, but central slats


16


′ of a grid of slats


16


′ extend from positions adjacent front, back and side edges


13


′ of a deck


12


′ to a center of the deck


12


′ for additional load support.




Referring again to

FIG. 1

, the load-bearing skin


14


extends downwardly to the tine-engaging skin


20


at the front, back and side edges


13


of the deck


12


so that the core


18


is substantially totally enclosed by the skins


14


and


20


. In this way the edges


13


are finished not only for safe handling, but also to stop pest and dirt intrusion. Also, the finished edges


13


are cosmetically appealing.




The slats


16


of the grid are received and retained within cavities


24


formed between the tine-engaging skin


20


and the support


22


.




The assembly


10


may further include a second deck, generally indicated at


30


, also including a tine-engaging skin


32


wherein the at least one support


22


interconnects the decks


12


and


30


at their tine-engaging skins


20


and


32


and wherein the resulting assembly is at least stackable or rackable. A load-bearing skin


34


of the second deck


30


extends upwardly to the tine-engaging skin


32


at front, back and side edges


36


of the deck


30


so that a core


38


of the second deck


30


is substantially totally enclosed by the skins


32


and


34


of the second deck


30


.




A reinforcing slat


40


is received and retained within a cavity


42


formed between the tine-engaging skin


32


and the support


22


.




Preferably, a plurality of supports


22


support the deck


12


and wherein the reinforcing slats


16


and


40


are received and retained within a plurality of cavities


24


and


42


, respectively, formed between their tine-engaging skins


20


and


32


, respectively, and the plurality of supports


22


. Also, supports such as the supports


22


typically support the deck


12


at two center edge locations on opposite sides of the deck


12


. An additional support may also support the deck


12


at a center of the deck


12


.




Materials Used for the Skins




The skin materials are made of a polyolefin such as polypropylene reinforced with fibers. However, other materials can also be used.




The properties of the skins depends on:




Glass content (typically 20 wt % to 60 wt %);




Glass orientation, woven 50/50 or 80/20 as needed for loads;




Structure of the reinforcement (continuous woven fibers, continuous UD fibers, random glass mats, chopped glass fibers, etc) and core; and




Thickness, which depends on load and application but generally not to exceed 30 mm.




The skin is characterized by its weight per surface within a range of typically 400 to 1500 g/m2.




Some examples of the materials used for skins are:




Woven co-mingled fibers. Glass fibers and polypropylene fibers are co-mingled to form a hybrid roving. The process yields a product in which the glass fibers and thermoplastic fibers are uniformly dispersed. This co-mingling technique allows for a high glass fibers content (60 to 75 wt %) because it ensures a good fiber wetting by the matrix. Adequate wetting of the glass fibers ensures high mechanical performance of the composite. Hybrid rovings are then woven with several possible orientations. When the roving is heated above the melting point of the thermoplastic fibers, the thermoplastic flows around the glass fibers. The uniform co-mingling of the glass and thermoplastic fibers limits the distance the thermoplastic is required to flow and allows the material to be molded with very low pressures (about 10 bars). A commercial material is Twintex manufactured by Vetrotex Saint Gobain. Twintex is typically preconsolidated before being used in the process.




Mat of fibers with PP. It is a thin, continuous roll stock made of partially-consolidated polypropylene reinforced with fiber glass mat. Many thicknesses are available from a glass basis weight of 80 g/m2 up to 1000 g/m2. Glass content can vary from 20% by weight to 50% or more. The glass fibers are in a random configuration. It is also possible to use other types of fibers such as natural fibers, carbon fibers, and aramid fibers.




The reinforcing slats


16


and


40


of the grids are made of reinforced thermoset or thermoplastic composite such as a fiber-reinforced composite. The composite may include a depolymerizable and repolymerizable thermoset or a thermoplastic polymer resin such as a thermoplastic polyurethane.




The slats


16


and


40


may be solid or hollow elongated profiles using pultrusion techniques as described in U.S. Pat. No. 5,891,560. Such technology is generally known as Fulcrum® thermoplastic composite technology wherein Fulcrum® is a trademark of the Dow Chemical Co. of Midland, Mich.




Alternatively, the slats


16


and


40


may be made using a pultrusion technique to form a composite sandwich utilizing resin binders to form dense cores of glass, ceramic or phenolic microspheres with flanking long fiber reinforcements such as carbon, glass, aramid, matte, woven or other metallic or non-metallic materials such as wood or plastic.




Alternatively, the slats


16


and


40


may be made of other types of pultrusions or other materials such as metal.




Each of the cellular cores


18


and


38


of the decks


12


and


30


, respectively, has an open-celled structure of the tubular or honeycomb cell type, constituted mainly of polyolefin and preferably polypropylene. However, three main areas of core technologies can be used, i.e., honeycomb-type materials, foams, and other shapes such as a wave. Honeycomb can be either cylindrical cells or hexagonal, square. Their axis is perpendicular to the surface of the sandwich. An example of a honeycomb structure that can be used consists of cylinders that are extruded (diameter typically 8 mm). Cylinder density is adjusted (cylinder size and wall stock) as needed for load. The tubes are heated and because they are made of two types of PP, the outer layer melts at a lower temperature than the inner, thereby bonding the tubes together. The blocks are then cut to the required thickness (typically between 5 and 30 mm).




While not shown, a plurality of spaced supports


22


support the deck


12


adjacent corners of the deck


12


. The supports


12


are made of a thermoplastics material. In this way, substantially the entire pallet assembly


10


is recyclable. The supports


22


are preferably hollow thermoplastic feet which are hotplate welded or bonded to the skins


20


and


32


.




In addition, the assembly


10


may include an outer covering layer made of a woven or non-woven material disposed on one or both of the skins


14


and


34


. The outer covering layer may be made of foil or felt or of carpeting such as polypropylene carpeting.




An identification device in the form of a microchip or an RF identification card may be positioned within one of the hollow feet


22


to allows the pallet assembly


10


and its goods to be quickly and simply identified.




The process of forming each of the decks


12


and


30


is a thermocompression process. The two skins and the core of each deck


12


or


30


are stacked together and heated together in an IR oven. The preheated sandwich is then transferred into a cold tool. At this stage, there is no bond between the core and the skins. The sandwich structure is then stamped in the tool with a pressure of about 10 bars. The structure and the part are formed in a single step during molding. It is possible to place in the tool carpeting or foil on one or both sides of the sandwich.




The tool is typically designed to cut the sandwich and the carpet/foil during the molding step so that the finished deck comes out of the tool. Cycle time for the part is about 1 minute and varies only slightly with the thickness and the types of materials. Each of the decks


12


and


30


are locally crushed to form the cavities


24


and


32


, respectively, and to also finish the edges


13


and


36


, respectively.




U.S. patent application entitled “Method and System for Molding Thermoplastic Sandwich Material and Deep-Drawn Article Produced Thereby,” filed Mar. 15, 2000 and having U.S. Ser. No. 09/525,785, discloses a method and system for molding thermoplastic sandwich material to form a deep-drawn article utilizing a clamping technique and mechanism. The deep-drawn material does not significantly stretch or tear during the method due to the clamping technique and mechanism disclosed therein.




While embodiments of the invention have been illustrated and described, it is not intended that these embodiments illustrate and describe all possible forms of the invention. Rather, the words used in the specification are words of description rather than limitation, and it is understood that various changes may be made without departing from the spirit and scope of the invention.



Claims
  • 1. A reinforced composite pallet assembly of the sandwich-type, the assembly comprising:a substantially flat deck having front, back and side edges and including: a load-bearing skin made of a reinforced thermoplastics material; a grid of reinforcing slats; a cellular core made of a thermoplastics material; and a tine-engaging skin made of a reinforced thermoplastics material; the grid of reinforcing slats being positioned at predetermined places against the tine-engaging skin wherein the distance between the skins is reduced during molding of the deck which molding locally crushes the core at the predetermined places to form respective pockets for the reinforcing slats and to produce the substantially flat deck; and at least one support for supporting the deck at the predetermined places against the reinforcing slats so that tines can lift and support the pallet assembly at the tine-engaging skin.
  • 2. The assembly as claimed in claim 1 wherein slats of the grid are positioned adjacent to the front, back and side edges of the deck.
  • 3. The assembly as claimed in claim 2 wherein at least one slat of the grid extend from positions adjacent the edges of the deck to a center of the deck.
  • 4. The assembly as claimed in claim 1 wherein the load-bearing skin extends downwardly to the tine-engaging skin at the front, back and side edges of the deck so that the core is substantially totally enclosed by the skins and the edges are finished.
  • 5. The assembly as claimed in claim 1 further comprising another deck as claimed in claim 1 wherein the at least one support interconnects the decks at their tine-engaging skins and wherein the assembly is at least stackable or rackable.
  • 6. The assembly as claimed in claim 5 wherein the load-bearing skin of the another deck extends upwardly to the tine-engaging skin at the front, back and side edges of the deck so that the core of the another deck is substantially totally enclosed by the skins of the another deck and its edges are also finished.
  • 7. The assembly as claimed in claim 1 wherein the cellular core of the deck has an open-celled structure of the tubular or honeycomb cell type, constituted mainly of polyolefin and preferably polypropylene.
  • 8. The assembly as claim in claim 1 wherein a plurality of spaced supports support the deck adjacent corners of the deck.
  • 9. The assembly as claimed in claim 5 wherein the at least one support interconnects the decks at their tine-engaging skins adjacent at least one of the edges.
  • 10. The assembly as claimed in claim 5 wherein a plurality of spaced supports interconnect the decks at their tine-engaging skins adjacent the front, back and side edges of the decks.
  • 11. The assembly as claimed in claim 1 wherein at least one reinforcing slat is received and retained within the respective pocket that comprises a cavity formed between the tine-engaging skin and the at least one support.
  • 12. The assembly as claimed in claim 1 wherein a plurality of supports support the deck and wherein the reinforcing slats are received and retained within a plurality of respective pockets that comprise cavities formed between the tine-engaging skin and the plurality of supports.
  • 13. The assembly as claimed in claim 1 wherein the skins are made of a woven fabric or mat of glass fibers and of a thermoplastics material.
  • 14. The assembly as claimed in claim 1 wherein the reinforcing slats of the grids are made of a thermoplastic or a composite material.
  • 15. The assembly as claimed in claim 14 wherein the composite material is fiber-reinforced.
  • 16. The assembly as claimed in claim 15 wherein the composite material includes a depolymerizable and repolymerizable thermoplastic polymer resin.
  • 17. The assembly as claimed in claim 16 wherein the resin is a thermoplastic polyurethane.
  • 18. The assembly as claimed in claim 14 wherein the at least one support is made of a thermoplastics material and wherein substantially the entire pallet assembly is recyclable.
  • 19. The assembly as claimed in claim 18 wherein the at least one support is a hollow thermoplastic foot.
  • 20. The assembly as claimed in claim 13 wherein the thermoplastics material of the skins is a polyolefin and preferably polypropylene.
CROSS-REFERENCE TO RELATED APPLICATION

This application is a continuation-in-part of U.S. application entitled “A Reinforced Composite Pallet Assembly of the Cellular Core Sandwich-Type”, filed Oct. 30, 2001 and having U.S. Ser. No. 10/016,081, now issued as U.S. Pat. No. 6,655,299.

US Referenced Citations (41)
Number Name Date Kind
3695188 Granatstein Oct 1972 A
3719157 Arcocha et al. Mar 1973 A
4013021 Steinlein et al. Mar 1977 A
4507348 Nagata et al. Mar 1985 A
4937125 Sammartin et al. Jun 1990 A
5337681 Schrage Aug 1994 A
5365859 Schrage Nov 1994 A
5413052 Breezer et al. May 1995 A
5497709 Gonzalez et al. Mar 1996 A
5566624 Brown et al. Oct 1996 A
5596933 Knight et al. Jan 1997 A
5673630 Schutz Oct 1997 A
5676064 Shuert Oct 1997 A
5683782 Duchene Nov 1997 A
5687652 Ruma Nov 1997 A
5720229 Schrage Feb 1998 A
5755162 Knight et al. May 1998 A
5791262 Knight et al. Aug 1998 A
5806436 Weichenrieder Sep 1998 A
5845588 Gronnevik Dec 1998 A
5865315 Uitz Feb 1999 A
5868080 Wyler et al. Feb 1999 A
5888610 Fournier et al. Mar 1999 A
5891560 Edwards et al. Apr 1999 A
5921189 Estepp Jul 1999 A
5937767 Togawa et al. Aug 1999 A
5950546 Brown et al. Sep 1999 A
5967057 Nakayama et al. Oct 1999 A
6006677 Apps et al. Dec 1999 A
6050630 Hochet Apr 2000 A
6125770 Brandenburg Oct 2000 A
6155181 Chilcutt Dec 2000 A
6165604 Edwards et al. Dec 2000 A
6173657 Espejo Jan 2001 B1
6180203 Unkles Jan 2001 B1
6187411 Palmer Feb 2001 B1
6199488 Favaron et al. Mar 2001 B1
6216608 Woods et al. Apr 2001 B1
6357366 Frankenberg Mar 2002 B1
6389990 Apps May 2002 B1
6446563 Ohanesian Sep 2002 B1
Foreign Referenced Citations (7)
Number Date Country
0 473 422 Mar 1992 EP
0 551 776 Jul 1993 EP
0 649 736 Apr 1995 EP
0 783 959 Jul 1997 EP
79 23257 Apr 1980 FR
2711573 May 1995 FR
WO 8803086 May 1988 WO
Continuation in Parts (1)
Number Date Country
Parent 10/016081 Oct 2001 US
Child 10/208506 US