Patent Grant
10014587
The invention relates generally to chaff created to defeat target acquisition. In particular, the invention relates to multiple deflectors of electromagnetic energy away from an intended target.
The concept of chaff goes back as far back as 1937, but not until 1942 was chaff investigated for military use. Typically, aircraft use chaff as a false target to counter against radar-guided missiles. However, chaff can also be used for distress signals so friendly radar can find military platforms that may otherwise have damaged communication systems. Concepts for directed energy weapons have been around for many decades. Incrementally, technology has advanced to a point that the large amounts of energy necessary for directed energy weapons can be stored efficiently and in “relatively” small volumes.
However, directed energy possesses a significant disadvantage of carrying very little momentum and can easily be reflected, or deflected. Electromagnetic waves have very little momentum rendering their reflection or deflection fairly straightforward. For example, the momentum of a projectile that weighs 1 kg can be compared to a light beam that has a micrometer wavelength of 10.6 μm (a typical CO2 laser used to cut steel). Holding the energy constant in both cases to 100 joules (J), the momentum for each case can be calculated.
For the projectile, the velocity, v can be calculated from the energy E and mass, m by formula:
Thus, the momentum for the projectile can be calculated by formula:
Pp=m·v=(1 kg)(14.14 m/s)=14.14 N, (2)
where 1 newton (N)=1 kg-m/s. For the light beam, the energy in the laser beam is determined by formula:
where h is Planck's constant equals 6.626·10−34 m2-kg/s, c is the speed of light in vacuum, λ is the wavelength of the laser, and n is the number of photons.
The momentum of laser beam photons is determined by formula:
The momentum of the laser beam having 100 J of energy can be calculated as:
P1=E/c=(100 J)/(3·108·m/s)=3.3·10−7N. (5)
So the momentum of light photon is 3.3·10−7 N versus 14.14 N for the projectile. Thus, the projectile has 4,246,246,246% more momentum than the light beam, even though they both have the same 100 J of energy.
Conventional chaff is designed to scatter electromagnetic radiation from a source to inhibit detection and target acquisition from a hostile adversary. In some cases, conventional chaff can be used to block electromagnetic radiation in the form of obscurants.
Conventional chaff configurations yield disadvantages addressed by various exemplary embodiments of the present invention. In particular, exemplary embodiments provide chaff that returns electromagnetic radiation to its source for purposes of disablement. These embodiments provide for retro-reflective chaff by particulate fabrication with individual retro-reflection.
Various exemplary embodiments provide chaff for deployment from an aerial platform for retro-reflecting electromagnetic radiation projected to the platform. The exemplary chaff includes a plurality of retro-reflecting particles, with each particle being a retro-reflector. The plurality forms a cloud having aerial buoyancy. The particles can be a corner reflector with adjacent sides substantially perpendicular to one another, and in particular a trihedral corner reflector. Alternatively, the particles can be lens reflectors, such as a cat's eye. In addition, chaff is provided for deployment from an aerial, ground or sea platform for retro-reflecting electromagnetic radiation projected to the platform. The chaff includes a plurality of retro-reflecting particles and a substrate. Each particle of the plurality is a retro-reflector. The substrate attaches the plurality of particles.
Various exemplary embodiments alternatively or additionally provide individual chaff particulates attachable to ribbons or confetti from various materials, including those with indices of refraction that differ from the chaff material. Alternate exemplary embodiments provide retro-reflecting chaff to return electromagnetic energy to its source. Exemplary embodiments provide a method for neutralizing an electromagnetic emitter by releasing the retro-reflecting chaff composed of particles, each having a geometry adapted to redirect the electromagnetic radiation back to the source and away from its intended target. Alternative embodiments provide for the particles having a variety of sizes to reflect radiation at different wavelengths.
The above and other features described in exemplary embodiments, including various novel details of construction and combinations of parts, will now be more particularly described with reference to the accompanying drawings and pointed out in the claims. The principles and features of this invention may be employed in various and numerous embodiments without departing from or otherwise limiting the scope of the invention.
These and various other features and aspects of various exemplary embodiments will be readily understood with reference to the following detailed description taken in conjunction with the accompanying drawings, in which like or similar numbers are used throughout, and in which:
In the following detailed description of exemplary embodiments of the invention, reference is made to the accompanying drawings that form a part hereof, and in which is shown by way of illustration specific exemplary embodiments in which the invention may be practiced. These embodiments are described in sufficient detail to enable those skilled in the art to practice the invention. Other embodiments may be utilized, and logical, mechanical, and other changes may be made without departing from the spirit or scope of the present invention. The following detailed description is, therefore, not to be taken in a limiting sense, and the scope of the present invention is defined only by the appended claims.
The disclosure generally employs metric units with the following abbreviations: length in micrometers (μm) or meters (m), mass in milligrams (mg) or kilograms (kg), time in seconds (s), angles in degrees (°) or radians (rad), energy in joules (J). Supplemental measures can be expressed derived from these, such as density in micrograms-per-cubic-meters (μg/m3) or milligrams-per-cubic-meter (mg/m3), and the like.
The Oxford Dictionary defines “chaff” as “strips of metal foil or metal filings released in the atmosphere from aircraft, or deployed from missiles, to obstruct radar detection or confuse radar-tracking missiles.” These typical types of chaff are often designed to resonate with the radio frequency of an electromagnetic wave to enhance multi-directional scattering. They are designed to provide passive defense of a platform such as an aircraft against missile threats, for example, but are not designed to be used in an offensive manner.
Exemplary embodiments provide an exemplary type of chaff with the additional capability to retro-reflect, and thus can be used in an offensive manner in addition to a more typically defensive manner to serve as decoys. Of particular interest is retro-reflection of laser energy directed towards a target, for which return radiation can serve to degrade or disable the laser source. Retro-reflectors, also called retroflectors or cataphotes, reflect electromagnetic radiation back to its source with minimal scattering. The reflection vector is parallel and opposite in direction to the emission source vector. The mechanism of retro-reflection can include many examples including the octal trihedral, Porro prism, cat's eye, Luneburg lens, and there could even be potentially new mechanisms yet to be developed. They can be fabricated purely from metals, purely from dielectrics or a combination of metals and dielectrics. For example, the reflectivity of a metal layer can be enhanced with a dielectric layer.
Additionally, a layer of pure dielectric spheres has been shown to result in extremely high reflection, which could be fabricated in a retro-reflection manner. Published results are available at Phys. Rev. B 88, 165116 (2013) and Appl. Phys. Lett. 104, 171102 (2014); highlighted in Nature Photonics 8, 498 (2014). Exemplary embodiments provide novel chaff that can be used offensively, as well as defensively, without limiting the mechanism for obtaining retro-reflection. In particular, the exemplary chaff includes ability to damage a high energy laser directed at an intended target that dispenses the chaff.
Exemplary embodiments describe three principle aspects of the retro-reflective chaff:
(1) the retro-reflective chaff has the same intrinsic physical deployment behaviors as all other chaff types (e.g., the ability to loiter as a cloud);
(2) each chaff unit exhibit rotationally indifferent optical retro-reflectance; and
(3) chaff can loiter or fall at a predetermined rate based on size and weight.
Physical devices unable to satisfy these criteria do not constitute retro-reflective chaff. Instead, retro-reflective chaff physical requirements include storability in a small compact volume (e.g., within a launch canister) until deployment by mechanisms currently used for conventional chaff. Thus, deployment can control the shape and density of the cloud to have different offensive and defensive effects. However, retro-reflective chaff can be combined with conventional chaff to amplify the effects.
By changing the tilt of the first flange 120, the angular offset can be shifted to a second angle θ2. Although changing the angular offset angle can alter the displacement 190, the reflection returning to the source is independent of the corner reflector's angle from 0°≤θ≤90°. As shown in views 100, the corner reflector 110 is a dihedral for clarity, but a more effective design could be a trihedral with all planes forming internal angles of 90° (or π radians).
The reflector unit 210 comprising three perpendicular planes can form eight corner reflectors within a single trihedral. This configuration can operate in any orientation. The outer corners 260 can be rounded to form circular edges 270 so the overall shape is a sphere or an alternative geometry. The size of the particles, and of the confetti or ribbon can be selected based on the concept of operation. For select circumstances, the exemplary chaff can be designed to loiter for extended periods. Alternatively, the exemplary chaff can be configured to fall so as to provide a directional vector with which to divert the offensive seeker. In yet other alternatives, the retro-reflective chaff can be combined with conventional radio-frequency reflecting chaff.
Other types of retro-reflectors can be used for chaff.
The Porro prism 310 utilizes the same 90° angle as in a corner reflector 110, but instead of using a mirrored reflective surface, the prism uses total internal reflection. As shown in view 300, total internal reflection is caused by a difference in index of refraction between the prism material and the material outside the prism, which usually will be air. Total internal reflection occurs when both internal angles θ1 and θ2 are greater than the critical angle θc given by:
where n2 is the index of refraction of the air, and n1 is the index of refraction of the prism, which is assumed to be more optically dense than the air. Thus, the ratio n2/n1 is typically less than unity. As with the corner reflector 110, multiple prisms can be fabricated in multi-corner units 210 in order to be effective towards electromagnetic radiation from any direction.
As an alternative example, the so-called cat's eye reflector 410 can also be used for chaff. By fabricating transparent spheres (at the wavelengths of interest) that have an index of refraction (n) twice that of the surrounding material (usually air), then a back mirrored surface is not required (as in some versions) and the sphere functions at any rotational angle. An added advantage of the spherical shape of the cat's eye reflector 410 is that these can be sufficiently small to loiter by buoyancy, approaching a diameter of a few wavelengths long. (In the optical realm, such diameters would be on the order of one micrometer.) The corresponding density (mass per unit volume) can be adjusted for a desired loiter time, for example.
Retro-reflective particulates of the exemplary chaff can be attached to ribbons or confetti fabricated from various materials, depending on the purpose. For example, retro-reflective chaff can be attached to materials having indices of refraction that differ from that of the particulate material. In particular, the cat's eye reflector 410 can be attached to ribbons that are electrically or magnetically conductive to serve doubly as conventional radio frequency chaff. The retro-reflective chaff can be formed in thin metalized materials, such as plastic with imprinted trihedrals. The thin metalized materials can form shapes of confetti, ribbons or ping-pong size balls having corner retro-reflecting trihedrals distributed along the outer surface (analogous to dimples on a golf ball incorporated to reduce drag by extending boundary layer attachment). These concepts extend to other types of retro-reflectors that rely on metalized backings of different indices of refraction from a primary retro-reflector.
Individual retro-reflectors can be fabricated at varying scales or painted onto substrate materials to control buoyancy in air. Under select conditions, the exemplary chaff can remain buoyant for extended periods. Other circumstances might prefer exemplary chaff to descend gradually to shift an active infrared seeker off-course from the intended target that dispensed the chaff. The particulate size and the density substrate of the exemplary chaff can be tailored to loiter or fall at a substantially constant rate of descent, while reflecting back (rather than dissipating away) the electromagnetic energy being directed at the chaff-dispersing target.
The advantage of chaff using the corner reflector 110 is that this configuration can neutralize a threat using the threat's own energy. Thus, the defense mechanism can be cheap, light weight and low cost due to its passivity. Further, the chaff can be fabricated so as to be environmentally safe and thereby acceptable to the international community. For example, the chaff can be fabricated from biodegradable corn starch or wood that has been metalized, i.e., coated or plated with metal.
After being deployed, chaff often disperses approximately into an ellipsoid cloud, though this can be influenced by the delivery technique.
For the first plot 1010, the flat concentration 1050 at constant 11 mg/m3 denotes a first global location Gaussian profile at 50 feet. The leveling concentrations 1060 and 1070 denote Gaussian profiles for first and second global locations from 50 mg/m3 and descending. For the second plot 1020, the tapering concentration 1080 starting at 11 mg/m3 denotes first global location profile at 50 feet, while precipitating concentration 1090 denotes first global location profile at 1000 feet that starts at near 48 mg/m3.
An exemplary ribbon 1340 represents a second such substrate example. The ribbon 1340 includes a long thin strip substrate 1350 with trihedral retro-reflectors 1360 attached thereto. Alternatively, the ribbon 1340 can constitute a thin panel of confetti. The substrate 1350 and retro-reflectors 1360 can include metallic or dielectric exteriors. For metallic exteriors, the ribbon 1340 can act as a retro-reflector to optical through millimeter wave radiation, and as typical scattering chaff to radio frequency (RF) radiation wavelengths.
Alternatively, the retro-reflectors can be prisms or cat's eyes in configuration. Both substrates 1320 and 1350 can incorporate respective retro-reflectors 1330 and 1360 of varying sizes so as to engage electromagnetic energy threats from a multitude of available targeting frequencies.
The chaff can be fabricated to control its aerodynamics, such that the retro-reflectors can be mixed with standard RF chaff or IR-visible obscurant should a need arise for double duty from one chaff dispenser. For example, if the laser is space-based, a single corner reflector design would be sufficient, as the aerodynamics enable the corner reflector 110 to align upward for space-based beams 150 as shown in view 500. Such a configuration can also be stacked 610 for placement into a small volume as shown in view 600.
The metallization used can be selected for maximum reflectivity when the wavelength range of interest is known, or from a universally reflective material. For example, view 700 shows gold 750 has a higher reflectance than aluminum 730 at longer wavelengths into the infrared while aluminum has lower reflectance, while aluminum shows a broader spectral response overall. Thin-film techniques that incorporate interference of the electromagnetic waves or nanotechnology could also be used to enhance reflectivity.
One common deployment of conventional chaff initiates as a cloud in the shape of a flattened ellipsoid 810 as shown in view 800. This configuration approximates a cloud profile achievable through known deployment mechanisms and assumes a 5:1 equatorial diameter to thickness ratio. Flattened ellipsoid chaff clouds offer enhanced military utility over other shapes and that would also be the case for retro-reflective chaff depending on the concept of operation (CONOPS), details of which can be sensitive. The chaff can be deployed by compressed gas or other known mechanisms. In exemplary embodiments, the cloud boundaries exhibit Gaussian characteristics, but can be of other density profiles as well.
To be effective, the deployed cloud must have more than ten-thousand retro-reflective units. Each unit can be of equal size, different size, or mixed in with traditional chaff depending on CONOPS. This may include a demand for the cloud to maintain its concentration density for a time interval, thereby yielding retro-reflective chaff units that are consistent in size. For a cloud distribution to elongate vertically after initiation, then multiple sizes and/or weight can be mixed into the chaff. Other cloud shapes include planar, spherical, tubular and elliptical.
An example of retro-reflectivity from a confined chaff volume that is expanded into a cloud is shown in view 900. In this example, each retro-reflective particle, whether configured as an octal of trihedrals, a Porro prism, a cat's eye, a Luneburg lens, or other mechanism has an assumed 70% retro-reflectivity. Thus, for example, a chaff delivery volume of 0.01 m3 deploys with a 50% retro-reflectivity with a mean cloud radius of approximately 3 m. Further, one can assume that the chaff particles are electrically neutral, although the chaff particle could be electrically charged upon launch to produce other profiles and faster density distributions and shapes.
Each chaff cloud is deployable from a single canister and will be sufficiently durable to survive storage and deployment dynamics while retaining optical retro-reflectance characteristics. Maximum terminal velocities once deployed (drop velocities) are not anticipated to exceed that of rain, which is approximately 9.6 m/s. The terminal velocity is achieved through particle weight and size manipulations and can be reduced to near 0 m/s. Optical and high frequency electromagnetic radiation bounds exemplary retro-reflective chaff to sizes from 0.4 μm to 1 cm, covering bands from ultraviolet to millimeter wave radiation.
As further explanation, particulate sizes of the exemplary chaff can be associated with dimensions related to specular reflection. In particular, using the well-known relation:
where x denotes a dimensionless reflection scale, r denotes characteristic length of the particle and λ is radar wavelength, then a scale can be defined for the particulates as having ratio
This condition indicates the specular region of reflection, rather than the Mie scattering or Rayleigh scattering regimes.
Thus, when ratio
then reflection scale x≥12.6, which can be treated as x>>1 as an order of magnitude greater than unity. This provides scale over the regions of operation that range from λ=0.3 μm (edge of ultraviolet) to λ=1 cm (edge of millimeter-wave). For the laser, perhaps better examples include fiber lasers that can operate at various wavelengths depending on design and dopants. Common laser wavelengths are 1.06 μm and 1.55 μm, but others exist as well.
For an exemplary density distribution as a function of time and concentration for a cloud deployed with a 5:1 equatorial diameter to polar length ratio, parameters can be established as initial delivery volume of 0.009 m3 (about 2.38 gallons), cloud equatorial diameter of 6.1 m, and retro-reflective chaff particle density of 4.5·106 per-cubic-meter. For purposes of analysis, the size of the retro-reflecting chaff particles was assumed to be 500 μm (0.5 mm) with a notional weight of 30 mg resulting in an approximate estimated terminal velocity of 2 m/s. (This characteristic length is about two orders of magnitude larger than the preference.) Weather conditions of winter and summer are assumed at two global locations over water with nominal deployment altitudes of 10 feet, 50 feet, 100 feet, 500 feet, 1000 feet and 5000 feet.
A first example of results show concentration as a function of time for two different launch altitudes at 50 feet and 1000 feet, for example as shown in view 1000. In this example, the density of the cloud maintains for at least 10 seconds and up to approximately 20 seconds depending on launch altitude. This density consistency can be important to select military CONOPS. View 1100 illustrates the concentration as a function of altitude and demonstrates a consistent concentration for a significant altitude drop, which then gets dispersed mostly due to wind speed, and atmospheric boundary layers. View 1200 shows an image of the cloud dropping through the atmosphere that assumes conditions of a Gaussian profile launched at 1000 feet in a summer atmosphere at 3 m/s.
For chaff used at optical or extremely high (EHF) frequencies (one-to-ten millimeter wavelengths), the retro-reflectors would comprise fibrous materials that can get lodged deep in the lungs, causing health issues—similar to those induced by asbestos. By contrast, the much smaller exemplary chaff does not contain such fibrous materials, and the normal lung evacuation process would render the material safe.
Exemplary embodiments provide chaff that effectively directs electromagnetic radiation back to its source. Broadly, exemplary embodiments provide a defense mechanism against an adversary's use of laser, or other such electromagnetic weapons. Directed energy may be reflected back to the source, thus using the adversary's own energy against them. Such directed energy weapons require considerable energy to operate, and can suffer damage when a small portion is fed back into the source. Corner reflectors 110 are geometrically shaped objects used to reflect energy directly back to a source. Exemplary incorporation of corner reflectors 110 in chaff enables friendly military platforms to escape while concurrently neutralizing the adversary's directed energy asset.
Corner reflectors 110 and/or multi-reflectors 210 can be fabricated cheaply. For example, they can be fabricated from cheap plastic to reduce cost and plated with a thin metallic coating. They can be fabricated to have one to eight reflectors, or more, in each individual unit to control aerodynamic and directional aspects. They can be fabricated of various sizes and materials to control their buoyancy in the air. Corner reflectors 110 can be designed so they pack together tightly in a package 610 to minimize storage volume. The chaff can be used for other applications, such as a disruption in communications between two points. Other forms of retro-reflectors exist that are suitable for retro-reflecting chaff.
As an example of application, an aircraft might detect illumination by an adversary's laser beam, or other electromagnetic weapon. In response, the aircraft might immediately turn in a direction away from the weapon and launch a canister of corner reflector chaff. By releasing the chaff to be disposed between the adversary's weapon and the target craft, the corner reflectors directs the laser weapon back on itself and into the adversary's directed energy weapon causing damage to, and neutralizing the threat with its own energy.
Other applications for the corner reflector chaff exist as well. For example, the corner reflector chaff can be used to protect commercial craft, for example, from internal or external threats. Exemplary embodiments could be used to temporarily disrupt communications by dropping the material between a transmitter and a receiver, and thus be useful for law enforcement. Also, retro-reflecting chaff can provide a more efficient distress signal than conventional chaff. Also, retro-reflecting chaff can prevent optical trackers from maintaining track.
Damage to the deployed retro-reflective chaff is inconsequential due to its low fabrication cost and prospective biodegradability, both to promote expendability. The exemplary chaff only needs to last for sufficient duration to either damage the threat, or for the target craft to move to a safe distance from the laser weapon directed thereto. In fact, the number of corner reflectors for the multi-corner configuration 210 mitigates the primary counter-counter-measure available to an opponent. In particular, an intense beam would be required to degrade a single reflector and either dissipate its energy as heat at the chaff cloud or serve as a sacrificial element for part of the beam with other inexpensive reflectors loitering for backup.
Exemplary embodiments, as well as parent application Ser. No. 13/374,641 include octal trihedrals fabricated from metal or with a metal covering only. Alternative embodiments include transparent prisms with indices of refraction that differ from the ambient air that the chaff operates. Both configurations utilize particulates that visually small or microscopic. Exemplary embodiments are distinguishable from U.S. Pat. No. 2,475,633 to Morris et al. disclosing a spring-loaded corner reflector; U.S. Pat. No. 6,061,012 to Sakimura disclosing a radar reflector of circular plates with a diameter of 44 mm; U.S. Pat. No. 4,072,948 to Drews et al. disclosing a balloon-suspended reflector; U.S. Pat. No. 2,746,035 to Norwood disclosing a balloon-suspended disk with medially intersecting semicircular elements; U.S. Pat. No. 4,099,183 to Wolff providing a passive reflective element with a corner reflector as a location marker; U.S. Pat. No. 7,623,059 to Klein teaching dispersing scattering media from an aircraft; and U.S. Pat. No. 4,852,452 to Barry et al. disclosing corner cube retro-reflectors on satellites to deflect radar attacks.
The exemplary embodiments are distinguishable by specular return reflection, rather than conventional scattering. Additionally, exemplary embodiments are not restricted to corner reflectors or to operating in isolation, as they can be attached to substrate materials to benefit from conventional chaff to serve multiple purposes against a wide range of electromagnetic search frequencies. The goal for the exemplary embodiments is to retro-reflect light from the millimeter to ultraviolet bands for return to the radiation source for its effective neutralization against the intended target that releases the exemplary retro-reflecting chaff.
Artisans of ordinary skill will recognize that many additional changes in the details, materials, steps and arrangement of parts, which have been herein described and illustrated herein in order to explain the nature of the invention, may be performed within the principle and scope of the invention as expressed in the appended claims. It is, therefore, to be understood that the appended claims are intended to cover all such modifications and changes as fall within the true spirit of the embodiments.
The invention is a Continuation-in-Part, claims priority to and incorporates by reference in its entirety U.S. patent application Ser. No. 13/374,641 filed Dec. 8, 2011 and assigned Navy Case 100617.
The invention described was made in the performance of official duties by one or more employees of the Department of the Navy, and thus, the invention herein may be manufactured, used or licensed by or for the Government of the United States of America for governmental purposes without the payment of any royalties thereon or therefor.
| Number | Name | Date | Kind |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2475633 | Morris | Jul 1949 | A |
| 2746035 | Norwood | May 1956 | A |
| 3126544 | Greatbatch, Jr. | Mar 1964 | A |
| 3953850 | Redman | Apr 1976 | A |
| 4028701 | Parks | Jun 1977 | A |
| 4072948 | Drews et al. | Feb 1978 | A |
| 4099183 | Wolff | Jul 1978 | A |
| 4149304 | Brynjegard | Apr 1979 | A |
| 4446793 | Gibbs | May 1984 | A |
| 4517569 | Gerharz | May 1985 | A |
| 4531128 | Mensa | Jul 1985 | A |
| 4683824 | Gibbs | Aug 1987 | A |
| 4695481 | Billard | Sep 1987 | A |
| 4733236 | Matosian | Mar 1988 | A |
| 4823131 | Bell | Apr 1989 | A |
| 4852452 | Barry et al. | Aug 1989 | A |
| 5047782 | Law et al. | Sep 1991 | A |
| 5061929 | Bell | Oct 1991 | A |
| 5212488 | Konotchick | May 1993 | A |
| 5589961 | Shigeta et al. | Dec 1996 | A |
| 5671869 | Althouse | Sep 1997 | A |
| 6017628 | Stevens | Jan 2000 | A |
| 6047644 | Malecki | Apr 2000 | A |
| 6061012 | Sakimura | May 2000 | A |
| 6507307 | Huber, Jr. | Jan 2003 | B1 |
| 6559790 | Buehler | May 2003 | B1 |
| 6650269 | Huber, Jr. | Nov 2003 | B1 |
| 6688032 | Gonzalez | Feb 2004 | B1 |
| 6742903 | Canning | Jun 2004 | B2 |
| 6876320 | Puente Baliarda | Apr 2005 | B2 |
| 7369081 | Ganz et al. | May 2008 | B1 |
| 7400287 | Saccomanno | Jul 2008 | B2 |
| 7533615 | Ganz et al. | May 2009 | B1 |
| 7623059 | Klein | Nov 2009 | B2 |
| 7847721 | Carlsson et al. | Dec 2010 | B1 |
| 7965220 | Ganz et al. | Jun 2011 | B2 |
| 20010019775 | Warfel | Sep 2001 | A1 |
| 20040080447 | Bas | Apr 2004 | A1 |
| 20100283655 | Dunn | Nov 2010 | A1 |
| 20110216411 | Reed | Sep 2011 | A1 |
| 20130009801 | Carlsson | Jan 2013 | A1 |
| 20130300594 | Rard | Nov 2013 | A1 |
| Number | Date | Country |
|---|---|---|
| WO 2007136308 | Nov 2007 | WO |
| Entry |
|---|
| R. B. Nilson and X. J. Lu, “Optimum design of spherical retroreflectors with regractive indices close to 2.0,” Transactions of the Institute of Measurements and Control, vol. 18, pp. 212-215, 1996. |
| Webster, C.A.G. “Optimum design of spherical retroreflectors with refractive indices close to 2.0,” Transactions of the Institute of Measurements and Control, vol. 18, pp. 212-215. 1996. |
| P. Moitra et al.: “Experimental demonstration of a broadband all-electric metamaterial perfect reflector”, App. Phys Lett. 104 171102 (2014). http://aristotle.sri.com/srini/95-APL.pdf. |
| P. Moitra et al.: “Large-Scale All-Dielectric Metamaterial Perfect Reflectors”, ACS Photonics 2 692-698 (2015). http://www.vanderbilt. edu/vinse/acsphotonics_5b001481.pdf. |
| Number | Date | Country | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Parent | 13374641 | Dec 2011 | US |
| Child | 15239829 | US |
