The present invention relates to the field of nuclear reactors. More specifically, the present invention relates to cleaning the reactor pressure vessel bottom mounted instrumentation nozzles.
A pressurized water reactor (PWR) is a nuclear power reactor that uses ordinary (light) water as both coolant and neutron moderator. In a PWR, the primary coolant loop is pressurized so the water does not boil, and heat exchangers, i.e., steam generators, transmit heat to a secondary coolant which is allowed to boil to produce steam for electricity generation, for warship propulsion, and so forth. The reactor pressure vessel contains the reactor fuel, moderator, and coolant under pressure and is the part of the nuclear reactor that produces heat. Some reactor pressure vessels include bottom mounted instrumentation (BMI) nozzles that penetrate the lower head of the reactor pressure vessel. The BMI nozzles may be used, for example, for housing flux monitoring instrumentation.
Through bare-metal visual inspections of penetration regions 30 of BMI nozzles 22 into reactor pressure vessel 20, it has been discovered that leakage at a penetration region 30 can occur. Indeed, such leakage was discovered during a refueling outage at the South Texas, Unit 1, nuclear reactor. The residue from this leakage was subsequently found to contain both boric acid and long-term radionuclides, confirming the source to be the reactor coolant system.
As a result of this event, the Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) issued Bulletin 2003-02 indicating that a significant leak from one of penetration regions 30 could introduce safety concerns in that it would require the actuation of the nuclear reactor safety systems and operation for an extended period of time making it difficult to stabilize the plant. Thus, NRC Bulletin 2003-02 strongly recommended that nuclear plants perform a bare-metal visual inspection of penetration regions 30 at each of BMI nozzles 22 of their reactor pressure vessels 20 during a next refueling outage.
It has further been discovered that many BMI nozzles 22 have remnants of a protective coating 32 left from construction. Protective coating 32, also known as Spraylat, is a latex based paint used to protect metallic components during shipment. Protective coating 32, as well as, rust oil staining, tape, and so forth, creates problems for a bare-metal inspection of one hundred percent of the circumference of each penetration region 30 at which one of BMI nozzles 22 enters reactor pressure vessel lower head 24 of reactor pressure vessel 20. Accordingly, it has been determined that in order to perform a reliable visual inspection of the entire circumferential surface 34 about each penetration region 30, protective coating 32 must first be removed to establish a clean bare-metal surface. Thereafter, reliable visual inspections can be performed at every refueling outage.
One proposed technique for cleaning BMI nozzle penetration regions 30 involves removing insulation package 26 beneath reactor pressure vessel 20, manually cleaning penetration regions 30 for BMI nozzles 22 in lower head 24 of reactor pressure vessel 20 by mechanical or chemical means, and then replacing the insulation. The labor involved for work under reactor pressure vessel 20 was estimated to entail a minimum of a four man crew for four shifts for insulation removal and installation of new insulation. The cleaning activity was estimated to entail a two man crew for two shifts, and craft support called for a six person crew for two shifts. In addition, work under reactor pressure vessel 20 requires that in-core instrumentation (not shown) be inserted at all times, thus delaying reactor core alterations during refueling. Obviously, such a labor intensive activity is costly, and any delays to reactor core alterations results in further additional costs.
Moreover, entry into, and work in, VHRA 28 can present very high radiation hazards. It is well known that exposure to radiation can cause health effects. These health effects may be fairly mild and transitory, such as, weakness, loss of appetite, vomiting, and diarrhea. On the other hand, these health effects may include delayed medical problems such as increased rate of infections, cancer, premature aging, birth defects in progeny, and so forth. Such health effects can occur after repeated large exposure or even after very small exposure in a plant or laboratory, since radiation effects are cumulative. Consequently, it is highly undesirable to expose personnel to the high radiation dosages that might occur by entering into and working in a VHRA, such as under the reactor pressure vessel.
Accordingly, what is needed is a system and method for cleaning a reactor pressure vessel bottom mounted instrumentation penetration region beneath a reactor pressure vessel of a nuclear reactor that minimizes radiation exposure to personnel, is cost effective to implement, and yields a clean bare metal surface around the circumference of each BMI nozzle so that reliable visual inspections may thereafter be performed.
Accordingly, it is an advantage of the present invention that a system and method for circumferential work processes and delivery of a medium are provided.
It is another advantage of the present invention that a system and method are provided for remote cleaning of bottom mounted instrumentation (BMI) nozzles in a reactor pressure vessel.
It is another advantage of the present invention that the system and method limit personnel radiation exposure in a very high radiation area of a reactor pressure vessel through remote control of a cleaning vehicle.
Yet another advantage of the present invention is that the system and method are relatively time and cost effectively implemented, and do not require the removal of insulation around the reactor pressure vessel.
The above and other advantages of the present invention are carried out in one form by a system for treating a columnar element at a remote location. The system includes a vehicle including a base moveable along a floor of the remote location, a rotating member coupled to the base, and an effector coupled to the rotating member. The rotating member is configured to rotate relative to the base about the columnar element to enable the effector to act upon a circumferential surface of the columnar element. The system further includes a controller positioned remote from the vehicle. The controller is in communication with the vehicle for directing movement of the vehicle to the columnar element, for directing rotation of the rotating member, and for enabling the effector to work upon the circumferential surface.
The above and other advantages of the present invention are carried out in another form by a system for cleaning a columnar element at a remote location. The system includes a vehicle having a base moveable along a floor of the remote location and a nozzle in communication with the base for delivering a cleaning medium to a surface of the columnar element. A controller is positioned remote from the vehicle. The controller is in communication with the vehicle for directing movement of the vehicle to the columnar element and for enabling the nozzle to deliver the cleaning medium.
The above and other advantages of the present invention are carried out in another form by a method for treating a columnar element at a remote location using a remote controlled vehicle, the vehicle including a moveable base, a clamp mounted on the base, a jack in communication with the base, and an effector coupled to an end of the jack. The method calls for directing movement of the vehicle to the columnar element and actuating hinged jaws of the clamp to encircle the columnar element. The method further calls for extending the jack to lift the effector vertically above the base, and enabling delivery of a medium from the effector to a surface of the columnar element to clean the columnar element.
A more complete understanding of the present invention may be derived by referring to the detailed description and claims when considered in connection with the Figures, wherein like reference numbers refer to similar items throughout the Figures, and:
Referring to
A cleaning system 42 is implemented within environment 40 in accordance with a preferred embodiment of the present invention for cleaning penetration regions 30 of bottom mounted instrumentation (BMI) nozzles 22 to remove protective coating 32, rust, oil staining, tape, and any other potentially masking component that would limit the observation of residue from leakage in subsequent inspections. An inspection system 44 may be utilized thereafter for visually inspecting bare-metal circumferential surface 34 at penetration regions 30 following their cleaning.
Although both cleaning system 42 and inspection system 44 are implemented in environment 40, it should be understood that they need not necessarily be utilized together. For example, once cleaning system 42 has removed protective coating 32 from penetration regions 30 of all of BMI nozzles 22 during a first refueling outage, cleaning system 42 need not be utilized again during subsequent refueling outages.
In addition, cleaning system 42 is described below in terms of its function for removing protective coating 32 from penetration regions 30 of BMI nozzles 22. However, it should be understood that cleaning system 42 need not be limited to such an operation. Rather, cleaning system 42 may be adapted to clean a variety of columnar elements either within high radiation environments or in environments in which radiation levels are not a concern. Moreover, it will become apparent in the ensuing discussion that cleaning system 42 may be further adapted to perform operations, other than cleaning, upon a surface of a columnar element. Such operations may include heat treatment, welding, cutting, engraving, and so forth.
Cleaning system 42 generally includes operator-based equipment 46 positioned at an operator station 48, remote-based equipment 50 located in very high radiation area (VHRA) 28, and intermediate-based equipment 52 located at an intermediate area 54 just outside of VHRA 28. Operator station 48 represents an area within the nuclear reactor facility of environment 40 in which operators 56 may be located without being exposed to unacceptably high radiation levels. As defined previously, VHRA 28 represents an area within environment 40 accessible to individuals, in which radiation levels could exceed 500 rad (5 gray) in one hour at 1 meter from the source or from any surface that the radiation penetrates. Intermediate area 54 represents an area within environment 40 in which radiation levels are lower than those of VHRA 28, but may be higher than radiation levels within operator station 48.
In general, operator-based equipment 46 of cleaning system 42 includes a vehicle controller 58 in communication with a processor 60 and optionally in communication with a cleaning system monitor 62. Remote-based equipment 50 of cleaning system 42 includes a remote interface 64, a cable tensioner 66, and a cleaning vehicle 68. Intermediate-based equipment 52 includes a vessel 70 containing a cleaning medium 72 whose delivery may be controlled via a cleaning medium actuator 73 positioned at operator station 48. Intermediate-based equipment 52 further may further include an air line 74 coupled to an air source 76, which may be a “plant-provided source.” Air source 76 is further in communication with vessel 70 via a second air line 77.
Cleaning vehicle 68 exhibits a height of less than twelve inches and a width of less than twelve inches so that it may be installed through an existing twelve inch by twelve inch access panel 78 in insulation package 26. Thus, cleaning vehicle 68 is positioned on insulation floor 27 beneath reactor pressure vessel 20. Similarly, cable tensioner 66 is sized such that it may be installed through access panel 78. Remote interface 64 need not be installed through access panel 78 however. Rather, remote interface 64 may be located underneath reactor pressure vessel, just outside of insulation package 26, but still within VHRA 28. Operator-based equipment 46 enables operators 56, positioned within operator station 48, to remotely control remote-based equipment 50 in VHRA 28. In addition, operators 56 may occasionally access intermediate area 54 to manipulate intermediate-based equipment 52 without entering VHRA 28. Thus, radiation exposure to personnel is significantly reduced relative to manually cleaning penetration regions 30 of BMI nozzles 22. In addition, since cleaning vehicle 68 is installed underneath reactor pressure vessel 20 through an existing access panel 78 in insulation package 26, significant time and cost savings are realized by not having to implement modifications to insulation package 26.
Vehicle controller 58 is coupled to remote interface 64 within VHRA 28 via an interface communication cable 80. Remote interface 64 is, in turn, coupled to cleaning vehicle 68 via a vehicular communication and power cable 82. Air line 74 is coupled to remote interface 64, and a vehicular air line 84 interconnects remote interface 64 and cleaning vehicle 68. A media delivery hose 86 interconnects vessel 70 containing cleaning medium 72 with cleaning vehicle 68.
Vehicular communication cable 82, air line 84, and media delivery hose 86 are routed through cable tensioner 66. Consequently, the reference numerals representing the vehicular communication cable, i.e., reference numeral 80, the vehicular air line, i.e., reference numeral 84, and the media delivery line, i.e., reference numeral 86, remain the same on either side of cable tensioner 66. Generally, cable tensioner 66 is a cable management pulley system for keeping vehicular communication cable 82, vehicular air line 84, and media delivery hose 86 that are attached to cleaning vehicle 68 relatively taut. The structure and function of cable tensioner 66 will be described in greater detail in connection with
Remote interface 64 serves as a hub, or interface, between vehicular controller 58 and cleaning vehicle 68. Remote interface 64 may serve as a control signal/video pass-through for signaling between vehicular controller 58 and cleaning vehicle 68. Power may additionally be bundled with the control signals and video in vehicular communication cable 82.
Remote interface 64 further serves as a hub, or interface, between air source 76 and cleaning vehicle 68. Although cleaning vehicle 68 is primarily electrically powered via motors, some elements are powered by fluid. That is, energy is transmitted to cleaning vehicle 68 by pressurizing and controlling a contained fluid, i.e., air, in order to operate some components of cleaning vehicle 68.
Remote interface 64 may include a manifold system (not shown) that receives air from air line 74, and distributes that air to multiple smaller tubes (not shown). These multiple smaller tubes are desirably bundled to form vehicular air line 84. Alternatively, a manifold system may be positioned on cleaning vehicle 68. As such, air is delivered to the manifold system on cleaning vehicle 68 via vehicular air line 84 where it is subsequently distributed to multiple smaller tubes (not shown) to actuate the pneumatically driven components of cleaning vehicle 68.
Robotic applications, such as cleaning vehicle 68, typically involve relatively low-speed, high precision motions. Consequently, in a preferred embodiment, electrically-driven components are utilized with cleaning vehicle 68 because of their high precision, lightweight actuators. However, it should be understood that pneumatic and/or hydraulic systems may alternatively be utilized within cleaning vehicle 68.
Vessel 70, containing cleaning medium 72, is positioned near, but outside of VHRA 28, so that cleaning medium 72 has a relatively short distance to travel through media delivery hose 86. In a preferred embodiment, cleaning system 42 utilizes a carbon dioxide cleaning methodology where cleaning medium 72 is supercritical carbon dioxide in the form of dense dry ice pellets. Thus, the cleaning medium will be referred to hereinafter as carbon dioxide pellets 72. As will be discussed in greater detail below, cleaning vehicle 68 delivers carbon dioxide pellets 72 at a high speed to circumferential surface 34 of about each penetration region 30 of BMI nozzles 22 to remove protective coating 32. Carbon dioxide pellets 72 are a preferred cleaning medium because they are a nontoxic, nonflammable material, with no ozone depleting potential. Moreover, upon impact, carbon dioxide pellets 72 sublimate to a gaseous state, leaving the surface clean, dry and undamaged, while keeping the area free from secondary waste and debris.
Although carbon dioxide pellets 72 are preferred, it should be understood that the present invention may be adapted to include another cleaning medium. If an alternative cleaning medium is employed that generates secondary waste, another vessel (not shown), interconnected with cleaning vehicle 68 via a waste vacuum hose (not shown), may be provided at intermediate area 54 for collecting the secondary waste.
Inspection system 44 is a standard mobile inspection system, also known as a camera crawler. Inspection system 44 includes an inspection controller 90 in communication with an inspection monitor 92, both of which are positioned at operator station 48. Inspection controller 90 controls movement of an inspection camera 94 via a communication link 96. Inspection camera 94 may be installed through access panel 78 in insulation package 26, and is positioned on insulation floor 27 beneath reactor pressure vessel 20.
Inspection camera 94 is highly maneuverable, and may be used to locate lanes between BMI nozzles 22 through which cleaning vehicle 68 can be directed. Thus, inspection system 44 can be used as a guide for cleaning vehicle 68. In addition, following cleaning, inspection system 44 may be utilized for the bare-metal inspections of BMI nozzles 22. Although not shown, a stationary camera may also be located underneath reactor pressure vessel 20 for providing a global view of lower head 24 of pressure reactor vessel. However, such a camera would not be used for bare-metal inspections.
Referring to
Cleaning vehicle 68 includes a base 98 moveable along insulation floor 27 and a clamp 100 mounted on base 98. A collar element 102 is fixed to and extends from base 98. In a first turntable configuration 103, cleaning vehicle 68 includes a rotating member 104 and a platform 106 rotatably coupled to collar element 102. The descriptive term “turntable” is utilized herein to emphasize the capability of platform 106, and consequently those elements coupled to platform 106, to rotate relative to base 98. The advantages of this rotational capability will become apparent in the ensuing discussion.
A jack 108 is positioned upon platform 106. Jack 108 has a first end 110 in communication with base 98 via platform 106. An effector, in the form of a nozzle 112 oriented at a suitable inclination, is coupled to a second end 114 of jack 108 (see also
Cleaning vehicle 68 may also include a camera system having a front camera 116 and a rear camera 118 (not visible) that provide front and rear views of a path of travel of cleaning vehicle 68. These front and rear views may subsequently be displayed on cleaning system monitor 62 (
In a preferred embodiment, cleaning vehicle 68 is a tracked vehicle. As such, base 98 includes dual motorized endless treads 120, sometimes referred to as caterpillar treads. Endless treads are typically found on tanks, bulldozers, and the like. Endless treads 120 enable cleaning vehicle 68 to distribute its weight more evenly over insulation floor 27 so as to facilitate the maneuverability of cleaning vehicle 68.
Referring to
With continued reference to
Although an exemplary rotating member 104 is described herein, those skilled in the art will recognize that the present invention may be adapted to include alternative means for enabling rotation of platform 106 and the attached jack 108, nozzle 112, front camera 116, and rear camera 118 relative to base 98.
Referring to
Jack 108 is a scissor-type jack having arms 142 for lifting nozzle 112 that when extended, form the shape of a diamond. When jack 108 is in a fully contracted position, as shown in
In addition, jack tilt mechanism 145 can be optionally actuated to lift rear edge 147 of jack 108, thus pivoting jack 108 about pivot hinge 144 (
Referring to
As discussed in connection with
Second turntable configuration 150 includes a rotating member 154, in the form of a gear, and a platform 156 that rotatably engage with collar element 102 (
Jack 152 is coupled to platform 156 via pivot hinges 164. An actuator 166 of jack 152 is employed to extend jack 152. In particular activation of actuator 166 causes jack 152 to pivot about pivot hinges 164. This pivoting action results in the imposition of both a vertical lift and a forward tilt on nozzle 158, so as to appropriately position nozzle 158 for cleaning penetration regions 30.
For completeness of discussion, two turntable configurations are described in detail herein, i.e., first turntable configuration 103 with jack 108 and usable in high clearance regions, and second turntable configuration 150 with jack 152 and usable in low clearance regions. However, those skilled in the art will readily recognize that the concepts discussed herein may be adapted to suit a wide variety of clearance profiles.
Cable tensioner 66 functions to provide an additional amount of cable system 166 as cleaning vehicle 68 moves forward (i.e., away from cable tensioner 66). In addition, cable tensioner 66 functions to remove an excess amount of cable system 166 as cleaning vehicle 68 moves backward (i.e., toward cable tensioner 66). To that end, cable tensioner 66 includes a frame structure 168 that holds a body 170 and a pair of hooks 172 (of which one is shown). Hooks 172 are utilized to attach cable tensioner 66 to insulation package 26 (
Cable tensioner 66 includes a motor 174 to which a first roller 176 is coupled. A second roller 178 is coupled to a lever arm 180. As shown, cable system 166 is routed between first and second rollers 176 and 178 when lever arm 180 is lifted in an upward position. Lever arm 180 may then be moved downwardly, as indicated by an arrow 182, and pinned into place utilizing a pin (not shown) directed through one of engagement holes 184 of body 170. Consequently, second roller 178 is secured so as apply pressure on cable system 166. A drive input 186 is in communication with motor 174. Drive input 186, in the form of a cable connection, is further in communication with vehicle controller 58.
In a preferred embodiment, cable tensioner 66 is under automatic control by vehicle controller 58. That is, vehicle controller 58 directs motor 174 to drive cable system 166 in one of a first direction, represented by a first arrow 188, and a second direction, represented by a second arrow 190. Vehicle controller 58 may actuate motor 174 via-drive input 186, in response to a forward command or a backward command given to cleaning vehicle 68 (
Alternatively, the control of cleaning vehicle 68 may be executed under software control utilizing digital signaling. In such an instance, vehicle control pad 192 represents a screen image that may be displayed on a display associated with processor 60. The screen image could be a conventional graphical user interface using pull-down menus and/or direct manipulation of graphical images. Alternatively, the screen image could be displayed on a touch screen input device. Those skilled in the art will recognize that a great variety of control mechanisms, and/or a combination of analog- and processor-based control mechanisms may be employed so that operators 56 may readily control cleaning vehicle 68 positioned in a remote location. Control elements discussed in connection with vehicle control panel 192 will be described herein in terminology typically associated with an analog-based control pad. However, it should be understood that these control elements may be metaphorically represented in a screen image.
Vehicle control panel 192 includes a track control joystick element 194. Track control joystick element 194 is manipulated to direct movement of cleaning vehicle 68 in a forward, and backward direction. Element 194 is further manipulated for directing a rightward or leftward turning motion of cleaning vehicle 68.
Vehicle control panel 192 further includes a lift/turntable control joystick element 196. Lift/turntable control joystick element 196 is manipulated to extend (LIFT UP) either jack 108 (
Jack 108 (
Vehicle control panel 192 is further shown having pushbuttons for controlling the delivery of carbon dioxide pellets 72 (
In this exemplary embodiment, clamp 100 (
Cleaning and inspection process 218 begins with a task 220. At task 220, inspection camera 94 (
A task 222 is performed in response to task 220. At task 222, one of BMI nozzles 22 is selected for cleaning. The one of BMI nozzles 22 may be selected upon the discretion of operators 56 in response to its location, amount of masking protective coating 32, and so forth.
Following the selection of one of BMI nozzles 22 at task 222, a task 224 is performed to move cleaning vehicle 68 (
Following placement of cleaning vehicle 68, a task 226 is performed to actuate clamp 100 to a “closed” position, as shown in
Next, a task 228 is performed as needed. At task 228, jack 108 (
Following task 228, a task 230 may be performed as needed. At task 230, jack tilt mechanism 145 (
Following the execution of tasks 224, 226, 228, and 230, cleaning vehicle 68 is appropriately positioned to begin cleaning BMI nozzle 22. Accordingly, a task 232 is performed to periodically deliver carbon dioxide pellets 72 (
Carbon dioxide pellets 72 are in the form of dense dry ice pellets. It has been discovered that media delivery hose 86 can stiffen and freeze due to the presence of carbon dioxide pellets 72 in it during medium delivery task 200. This situation can hinder the performance of the system and/or damage the system. In addition, damaging static potential can build up when carbon dioxide pellets 72 are delivered for a long interval. Accordingly, in a preferred embodiment, carbon dioxide pellets 72 are delivered for approximately fifteen seconds, followed by a short interval of non-delivery of pellets 72. Such a technique enables media delivery hose 86 to thaw and become more flexible.
A task 234 is performed in connection with task 232. At task 234, the position of nozzle 112 (
Nozzles 112 and 158 deliver carbon dioxide pellets 72 in a high pressure spray that effectively cleans a localized area of approximately one half inch down BMI nozzle 22 and approximately one half inch radially along lower head 24 of reactor pressure vessel 20 at penetration region 30.
Process 218 continues with a query task 236. At query task 236, operators 56 determine whether circumferential surface 34 is clean. By viewing images provided by, for example, inspection camera 94 (
At query task 238, a determination is made as to whether another of BMI nozzles 22 (
At task 240, penetration regions 30 are inspected for integrity. Inspection task 240 may be performed utilizing images provided to operator station 48 via inspection camera 94. Inspection camera 94 is desirably equipped with a 300× zoom system (25× optical, 12× digital) for clearly visualizing penetration region 30.
Task 240 is illustrated as immediately following the cleaning methodology described above for simplicity of illustration. However, it should be understood that a bare-metal visual inspection of penetration regions 30 immediately following the cleaning process may not reveal any leakage residue because the leakage residue is likely to have been removed during the cleaning process. However, the immediate execution of task 240 following cleaning may be performed to obtain a baseline inspection of the structural integrity of each of BMI nozzles 22. Such an inspection may reveal cracks, metal degradation, and such that could indicate a potential leak path between lower head 24 (
In summary, the present invention teaches of a system and a method for circumferential work processes and delivery of a medium. In particular, the present invention teaches of a cleaning system that includes a cleaning vehicle that is maneuverable beneath the lower head of a reactor pressure vessel, and is controlled remotely by an operator utilizing a vehicle controller. The cleaning vehicle, under the remote control of an operator, is utilized to clean a circumferential surface about a penetration region between bottom mounted instrumentation (BMI) nozzles and the lower head of a reactor pressure vessel. Once the circumferential surface is cleaned a remotely operated inspection system is utilized to inspect the penetration region for radioactive residue leakage, equipment faults, and so forth. The ability to remotely clean the penetration regions limits personnel radiation exposure to the hazardous radiation levels present in a very high radiation area of a reactor pressure vessel. In addition, the compact size and maneuverability of the cleaning vehicle enables its use underneath the reactor pressure vessel without removing the insulation package around the reactor pressure vessel. Consequently, significant savings in terms of labor costs, time, and reactor core alteration delays are realized.
Although the preferred embodiments of the invention have been illustrated and described in detail, it will be readily apparent to those skilled in the art that various modifications may be made therein without departing from the spirit of the invention or from the scope of the appended claims. For example, the robotic system may be adapted to perform other work processes on columnar elements including, but not limited to, heat treatment, welding, cutting, engraving, and so forth.