Blood pumps remain particularly useful for the treatment of cardiac disease and especially heart failure. Typically, blood pumps are implanted within a patient and connected to the patient's circulatory system as a ventricular assist device or, in some circumstances, as an artificial heart. However, the fragile nature of blood and the absolute necessity of the pump's reliability have presented numerous obstacles to designing a more perfect blood pump.
For example, most blood pumps contain moving parts, such as an impeller, that force blood into and out of the pump housing. If these moving parts are not properly designed and adjusted, the blood passing through the pump can be damaged, causing hemolysis or thrombosis. Further, these moving parts can wear on each other, causing an increased likelihood of part failure and heat buildup that is imparted to the blood.
Two recent blood pump examples can be seen in U.S. Pat. No. 6,234,772 to Wampler, et al. and U.S. Pat. No. 6,250,880 to Woodard, et al. The Woodard patent illustrates a rotary blood pump that includes an impeller supported exclusively by a hydrodynamic bearing. The Wampler patent describes a rotary blood pump that includes both a hydrodynamic support bearing and a radial magnetic bearing that utilizes a repulsive magnetic force.
In the case of either patent, the impeller of the blood pump contains motor drive magnets disposed within the blades of the impeller. Electromagnets are positioned within the pump housing to generate a magnetic field that drives the rotation of the motor drive magnets and therefore the impeller.
Both blood pumps suffer from hydraulic inefficiencies due at least in part to the large, unconventional impeller blade geometry required for containing the motor rotor magnets. Further inefficiencies of these designs arise because of the natural attraction between the motor rotor magnets of the impeller and the back iron of the electromagnets. Additionally, these blood pump designs exclusively rely on hydrodynamic bearing for axial support, which can result in excessive shear forces that can damage the blood and cause medical complications in the patient's health.
In view of the above discussion, it is apparent that there is a need for a blood pump that overcomes the limitations of the prior art. Specifically, what is needed is a blood pump that reduces inefficiencies inherent in prior art pump designs that can lead to pump failure or blood damage.
It is an object of the present invention to overcome the limitations of the prior art.
It is a further object of the present invention to provide a rotary pump with a longer lifespan than prior art designs.
It is another object of the present invention to provide a rotary pump that minimizes damage to a patient's blood.
It is yet another object of the present invention to provide a rotary pump that includes reduced power consumption over prior art designs.
It is another object of the present invention to provide a rotary pump that more efficiently pumps blood through a circulatory system of a patient.
The present invention attempts to achieve these objects by providing a rotary blood pump with both a magnetic axial bearing and a hydrodynamic bearing. In one embodiment according to the present invention, a rotary pump includes a rotor assembly supported within a pump housing assembly by a magnetic axial bearing and a hydrodynamic bearing. The magnetic axial bearing includes at least two magnets oriented to attract each other. One magnet is positioned in the spindle of the pump housing while the other is disposed within the rotor assembly, proximate to the spindle. In this respect, the two magnets create an attractive axial force that at least partially maintains the relative axial position of the rotor assembly. The hydrodynamic bearing is formed between sloping surfaces that form tight clearances below the rotor assembly. As blood enters the pump, the hydrodynamic bearing produces upward axial force on the rotor assembly. Thus, the overall position of the rotor assembly is maintained during operation with minimal or no physical contact with the pump housing during operation.
One preferred embodiment of the present invention includes a pump housing defining a pump chamber having an inlet port and an outlet port; a rotor disposed within said pump housing; and an axial magnetic bearing disposed in said pump chamber to at least partially support said rotor, said axial magnetic bearing including a first magnet shaped such that a center of mass of said first magnet is offset from an axis of said axial magnetic bearing, said first magnet generating a magnetic force in a specified radial direction.
Another aspect of this preferred embodiment may further comprise a spindle and wherein said first magnet is disposed in said spindle.
In another aspect of this preferred embodiment said axial magnetic bearing further comprises a second magnet, said second magnet shaped such that a center of mass of said second magnet is aligned with said axis of said axial magnetic bearing, said second magnet being disposed in said rotor.
In another aspect of this preferred embodiment a cross-section of said first magnet is non-circular.
In another aspect of this preferred embodiment said non-circular cross-section of said first magnet is substantially a “D” shaped cross-section.
Another preferred embodiment of the present invention includes a blood pump comprising: a pump housing defining a pump chamber having an inlet port and an outlet port; a spindle disposed in said pump chamber; a rotor disposed in said pump housing and at least partially around said spindle, said rotor including a first magnet; and a second magnet disposed within said spindle, said second magnet shaped such that a center of mass of said second magnet is offset from an axis of said spindle so that said second magnet provides a reduced radial magnetic forces in a predetermined direction outward from said second magnet; wherein said first magnet and said second magnet comprise an axial magnetic bearing.
In another aspect of this preferred embodiment said center of mass of said first magnet is aligned with an axis of said rotor.
In another aspect of this preferred embodiment said first magnet is ring shaped.
In another aspect of this preferred embodiment said second magnet has a non-circular cross-sectional shape.
In another aspect of this preferred embodiment said first magnet includes poles oriented in an opposite direction of poles of said second magnet.
Another preferred embodiment of the present invention includes a method of compensating for radial bias in a blood pump comprising: providing a blood pump for circulating blood; rotating an impeller on an axial magnetic bearing within said blood pump so as to cause movement of blood through said blood pump, said movement of blood causing a radial bias on said rotor; producing a magnetic force having a substantially opposite direction and magnitude to said radial bias, said magnetic force being generated by a magnet shaped to have a center of mass spaced from an axis of said axial magnetic bearing.
In another aspect of this preferred embodiment the producing of said magnetic force includes providing a magnet having a non-circular cross-section.
In another aspect of this preferred embodiment the providing of a magnet having a non-circular cross-section comprises providing a magnet having a “D” shaped cross-section.
In another aspect of this preferred embodiment producing a force further comprises providing a spindle around which said impeller rotates and providing a magnet in said spindle.
Another preferred embodiment of the present invention includes a blood pump comprising: a housing assembly including an interior space; a rotor disposed in said interior space; an axial magnetic bearing consisting of: a first magnet disposed in said rotor and having a north pole and a south pole; and a second magnet disposed in said interior space near a center of said rotor and having a north pole and a south pole.
Another aspect of this preferred embodiment may further comprise a spindle disposed in said housing assembly and wherein said second magnet is disposed in a spindle.
In another aspect of this preferred embodiment said north pole and south pole of said first magnet is oriented in an opposite direction of said north pole and south pole of said second magnet.
Another aspect of this preferred embodiment may further comprise a position adjustment assembly coupled to said second magnet to modify a position of said second magnet relative to said first magnet.
Another preferred embodiment of the present invention includes a blood pump comprising: a housing assembly comprising a first housing member and a second housing member, said first housing member being formed from one continuous non-assembled piece of material; said housing members defining a pump chamber having an interior surface; a plurality of lifts formed integrally on an interior surface of said first housing member; said lifts providing a hydrodynamic bearing surface to a rotor during operation of said blood pump.
In another aspect of this preferred embodiment said first housing member includes a stator chamber.
In another aspect of this preferred embodiment said stator chamber comprises a removable access cover for selectively accessing said stator chamber from an exterior of said blood pump.
In another aspect of this preferred embodiment each of said plurality of lifts comprise an elongated sloping surface.
In another aspect of this preferred embodiment each of said plurality of lifts further comprise a shortened flat surface coextensive with said elongated sloping surface.
Another preferred embodiment of the present invention includes a blood pump comprising: a housing defining an interior pump chamber having an interior surface; a rotor disposed within said interior pump chamber; said interior surface beneath said rotor being formed from a continuous, non-assembled material that constitutes a lower portion of said housing and having a plurality of lifts integrally formed from said interior surface, said lifts forming a hydrodynamic bearing with a bottom surface of said rotor.
Another aspect of this preferred embodiment may further comprise a stator chamber accessible from an exterior of said blood pump.
In another aspect of this preferred embodiment said lifts are comprised of an elongated sloping surface.
In another aspect of this preferred embodiment said lifts are further comprised of a shortened flat surface coextensive with said elongated sloping surface.
Another preferred embodiment of the present invention includes a blood pump comprising: a housing assembly, an impeller disposed in said housing assembly a pump chamber formed from said housing assembly, said pump chamber having an inlet and an outlet; and an outlet flow path including a first groove positioned around a circumference of the pump chamber forming a torus shape and a second groove connecting to said first groove and said outlet; said second groove having a size larger than a size of said first groove; said first groove sized so as to throttle flow upstream of said outlet and thereby cause a leakage flow between said impeller and said housing assembly.
In another aspect of this preferred embodiment said second groove progressively increases in size towards said outlet.
In another aspect of this preferred embodiment said leakage flow is between said impeller and a spindle of said housing assembly.
In another aspect of this preferred embodiment said second groove cooperates with said body to form an outlet passage in communication with said outlet.
Another preferred embodiment of the present invention includes a blood pump comprising: a pump housing defining a pump chamber having an inlet port and an outlet port; a rotor disposed within said pump housing; and a torus-shaped volute defined by said pump housing; said volute circumferentially disposed around said pump chamber and forming an outlet passage in communication with said outlet port and increasing in diameter towards said outlet port; said torus-shaped volute having a size that throttles fluid flow upstream of said outlet port and thereby cause a leakage flow between said rotor and said pump housing.
In another aspect of this preferred embodiment said volute is disposed around the entire circumference of said pump chamber.
In another aspect of this preferred embodiment said volute is comprised of matching grooves of mating portions of said pump housing.
In another aspect of this preferred embodiment said outlet passage has a generally circular cross section.
Another preferred embodiment of the present invention includes a method of pumping blood comprising: providing a pump housing defining a pump chamber moving blood from an inlet in said pump housing through an impeller of said pump chamber to an outlet in said pump housing; and increasing the pressure of said blood in said pump chamber upstream of said outlet so as to force a leakage flow blood between mating surfaces of said impeller and said pump housing.
In another aspect of this preferred embodiment said increasing of the pressure of said blood in said pump chamber comprises passing blood through a throttling volute in said pump chamber.
In another aspect of this preferred embodiment passing blood through a throttling volute in said pump chamber comprises passing blood through said volute having a diameter between about 2-5 mm.
In another aspect of this preferred embodiment passing blood through a throttling volute in said pump chamber comprises increasing the pressure inside the pump relative to the outlet between about 50% and about 100%.
Another preferred embodiment of the present invention includes a blood pump comprising: a pump housing defining a pump chamber having an inlet and an outlet; a rotor rotatably disposed in said pump chamber; and at least one lift positioned on a surface of said pump chamber to create a hydrodynamic bearing surface with said rotor; said lift including a first surface extending at an angle from said pump chamber and a second surface connected to said first surface and extending substantially parallel to said surface of said pump chamber; wherein said first surface is at least longer than said second surface.
Another aspect of this preferred embodiment may further comprise a plurality of lifts.
In another aspect of this preferred embodiment said first surface is angled from said surface of said pump chamber is between about 0.5 degrees and about 3 degrees.
Blood is primarily driven through the rotary blood pump 100 by a rotor assembly 105 within a housing assembly 101, as seen in
Turning to
Generally speaking, the pump housing assembly 101 makes up the main body of the rotary blood pump 100, including a housing top 102 and a housing bottom 104 which fastens by welding and aligned by alignment pins 112 to a top and bottom side of a housing middle 106.
Generally, this volute shape minimizes the risk of thrombus formation by providing a steady “leakage” behind the rotor assembly 105 to prevent stagnation of the flow. As seen best in
Normal operation of a typical centrifugal pump generates a pressure gradient so that the pressure rises as fluid approaches the outlet of the rotor blades. In a typical left ventricle assist device (LVAD) implantation, this pressure would be high enough to ensure good leakage around the rotor, similar to the flow path previously described. In such an arrangement, the static pressure at the periphery of the impeller is less than the pressure at the pump discharge nozzle. This is due to the volute and discharge nozzle being shaped to convert velocity head to static head and improve the hydraulic efficiency of the pump.
However, the design of the present preferred embodiment considers applications that are not configured with a higher pressure head at the outlet of the pump versus the inlet. More specifically, the “working head” of the present preferred embodiment is low and therefore if an efficient, optimized volute and discharge nozzle (i.e., outlet 108) were used, the driving pressure would not be enough to insure sufficient leakage across the leak path.
Accordingly, the present preferred embodiment increases the driving pressure across the leak path by increasing the pressure in the pump housing by throttling the flow with a constricted volute shape, as previously described. The diameter of the torus-shaped volute is so small (e.g., between about 2-5 mm in diameter) that there is significant pressure losses in the volute. These losses in the volute result in a lower pressure at the outlet 108 compared to the pumping chamber inside the pump 100. The resulting higher pressure at the periphery of the rotor assembly 105 provides enough driving pressure (e.g., about 100 mm Hg at a given design point, e.g., 1.3 lpm, 25 mm Hg at flow rates below a given design point, e.g., 0.7 lpm and 200 mm Hg at flow rates above a given design point, e.g., 2 lpm) and leakage flow to minimize the risk of thrombus formation. For example, when the rotor assembly 105 is rotating between about 2500 RPM to 6000 RPM there is an increase of about 50%-100% over the pressure measured at the outlet.
In addition to the motor assembly 103, the compartment 104A also allows access to the interior of spindle 114D of the thrust plate 114 (
In an alternate preferred embodiment, not shown, the compartment 104A of the housing bottom 104 may be accessible from a top or inner surface. More specifically, the thrust plate 114 may be nonintegral or removable, preventing access from an outside of the pump 100.
As seen in
Within the sealed, annular compartment 104A sits the motor assembly 103, as best seen in
It should be noted that in an alternate preferred embodiment where the thrust plate 114 is not integral with the housing bottom 104 (e.g., the thrust plate 114 is attached with a bonding agent or epoxy), the top side of coils 130 are covered with a titanium foil which is welded to the housing bottom 104 to provide a hermetic seal between the blood and the motor assembly 103. The thrust plate 114, which may also be composed of titanium, can additionally be welded to the housing bottom 104. In the preferred embodiment where the thrust plate 114 is an integral part of housing bottom 104, the titanium foil is not necessary.
The motor assembly 103 also includes a back iron 134, having a circular shape similar to that of the circular compartment 104A. Preferably the back iron 134 is positioned underneath the flexible circuit 132 to enhance the magnetic fields generated by the coils 130. Once activated, the motor assembly 103 generates magnetic fields that drive the rotation of the rotor assembly 105, positioned above the thrust plate 114.
Additionally, the motor assembly 103 includes outer members 135B, inner member 135A and top member 137 which are preferably composed of a nonconductive material to help electrically insulate the coils 130.
The outer shape of the rotor assembly 105 is defined by a rotor housing bottom 126, as seen in
The rotor assembly 105 contains three main components: the rotor axial magnet assembly 124, a motor rotor magnet 122, and a back iron 120. As best seen in
In one preferred embodiment, the motor rotor magnet 122 is composed of a plurality of magnet regions 122A having alternating polarity, as seen in
The motor rotor magnet 122 is preferably a permanent magnet attracted to the back iron 134 of the motor assembly 103. This attraction tends to pull the rotor assembly 105 towards the thrust plate 114, creating significant axial load on the rotor assembly 105. Previous rotary pump designs, such as those seen in U.S. Pat. Nos. 6,234,772 and 6,250,880, primarily rely on hydrodynamic thrust bearings to overcome this axial loading force. However, since these hydrodynamic bearings utilize a thin layer of blood between a rotor and a thrust plate, the passing blood must support the full force of this axial load. Consequently, blood cells can more easily become damaged due to strong shear forces, creating serious complications such as hemolysis and clotting. Further, the power required to sustain the hydrodynamic bearing increases as the load increases. Thus, highly loaded hydrodynamic bearings can impose a significant power penalty on the pump.
The present invention distributes this axial load force between a hydrodynamic bearing and an axial magnetic bearing as discussed in detail in U.S. application Ser. No. 10/940,419 (previously incorporated by reference). However, it is useful to elaborate on this configuration in the present application.
As previously discussed, the hydrodynamic bearing includes three thrust tapers or lifts on the thrust plate 114 which, due to the relative motion between the bottom surface of the rotor and the thrust tapers 114 creates an upward force on the rotor assembly 105 when in a predetermined proximity to the thrust plate 114. In a preferred embodiment, the cumulative total area of all the lifts 114A is within a range of about 40% to 90% of the total area of the thrust plate 114. It has been determined that three lifts in this configuration provide the necessary hydrodynamic bearing effect necessary for the inventive pump.
As seen in
The axial pre-load or bias force produced by the magnets 119 and 124 can be adjusted during assembly of the axial magnetic bearing. Preferably, sufficient positive force should be applied to the rotor toward the rear of the pump in order to stabilize the rotor assembly 105 and prevent undesirable motion at the maximum speed. A minimum force should be applied to achieve this pre-load since excessive force will increase power losses in the hydrodynamic thrust bearings (as discussed elsewhere in this application) and may increase hemolysis.
Preferably, the optimum position of the spindle magnet 119 can be determined empirically during a functional test with a blood analog in a mock circulatory loop. The maximum speed is determined by characterizing the hydraulic performance of a plurality of pumps. Once the maximum speed is established, each pump of the plurality of pumps is adjusted to a flow of 2.0 lpm and a pressure of 105 mm Hg and the position of the axial magnet 119 adjusted until instability of the rotor assembly 105 is detected (e.g., detected by listening to the pump housing assembly 101 for a change in the sound produced). When this instability threshold is detected, the shaft assembly 109A can be rotated (i.e., moved toward the housing bottom 104) beneath this threshold. Thus, the spindle magnet 119 may ultimately be positioned at one of many different heights relative to the rotor axial magnet 124.
In another preferred embodiment, the magnets 119 and 124 can be composed of a plurality of different combinations of regions. For example, one magnet 119 may have a single N-S region whereas the other magnet 124 has an S-N region on top and an N-S region below it as depicted in
The force generated by the axial magnetic bearing in either of the embodiments shown in
In yet further embodiments of the invention, the rotor axial magnet 124 could be a permanent magnet whereas the spindle magnet 119 could be a ferromagnetic material, or vice versa. Similarly, the spindle magnet 119 and the axial magnet 124 could be comprised of a two separate regions, one being a made of a permanent magnet material and the other a ferromagnetic material. Of course the polarity of the magnetic materials in any of these embodiments would conform to one of the embodiments discussed above in order to provide the axial bearing load as discussed in connection with the invention.
It should be noted that further embodiments of the magnetic axial bearing are possible according to the present invention. For example, the rotor axial magnets 124 could be disposed near the outer circumference of the rotor assembly 105 while the spindle magnet 119 could be embedded within the sidewall of the housing middle 106. In this respect, the different position of the magnets may also produce an axial force to compensate for downward preloading of the rotor assembly 105.
As best seen in
In some instances there may exist a radial bias exerted on the rotor assembly 105 due to the movement of the blood flow through the pump 100. For example, as the blood is forced to exit the pump 100, an outlet pressure at the outlet arises that can cause the aforesaid bias on the rotor assembly 105. In one preferred embodiment seen in
In another preferred embodiment, this bias is compensated with surface features such as sloping surfaces, tapers, pads, or other surface geometry changes along the thrust plate 114, the inner circumferential surface of the housing middle 106, or both. By placing these features unevenly, for example on one side of the housing middle 106, a hydrodynamic bearing is created on one side of the pump 100, creating a biasing force in a radial direction. With proper positioning of these radial hydrodynamic bearings, the outlet 108 bias force can be substantially reduced.
In another preferred embodiment, this radial bias is compensated for by offsetting the spindle magnet 116 from the center of the spindle 114D and rotor axial magnet 124. For example,
Another aspect of the present invention is the interaction of the hydrostatic pressures of the pump, the axial loads between the motor rotor magnet 122, the stator back iron 120, and the axial magnet 124 and the hydrodynamic bearing created with thrust plate 114. This is described in greater detail below.
During operation of the pump 100, the curved impeller blades 118A of the rotor top 118 generate hydrostatic pressure, most of which is used to create useful flow through the outlet 108. In all centrifugal pumps a hydrostatic pressure is applied to all wetted surfaces of the rotor and housing. The sum of this hydrostatic pressure produces a net force on the rotor which must be carried by bearings. These forces can be difficult to measure; however, they can more easily be predicted with computational fluid dynamic analysis as known in the art. Computational fluid dynamics (CFD) is a finite element program that allows modeling and prediction of the performance of a pump. The results of this analysis can then be used to determine such parameters that can be expected from a particular design, such as the hydraulic performance, efficiency, resulting forces, and shear.
One commercial CFD program, ANSYS CFX-5, was used to create a CFD model of the pump 100 according to the present invention. A periodic model of the complete rotor assembly 105 with the backside, housing clearances and hydrodynamic bearings was used to evaluate forces acting on the rotor assembly 105 and leakage behind the rotor assembly 105.
A laminar model was used since the calculated Reynolds number is a maximum of 236, which is well within the laminar range and well below the transition range of 2,000. The formula for the Reynolds number is:
R=ρVD/μ
In this formula, ρ is density (1.0 kg/l), V is velocity (6.5 m/s), D is clearance (0.0127 cm) and μ is viscosity (3.5 cps).
In this respect, the CFD calculations show that the net axial hydrodynamic/hydrostatic force acting on the rotor assembly 105 (i.e. the difference between the force acting on the top of the rotor assembly 105 and the bottom of rotor assembly 105) is 0.202 pounds in a direction towards the rear of the pump. This net axial hydrodynamic/hydrostatic force also combines with the force resulting from the action of the motor magnets 122 and the back iron 134. A typical attractive force for the motor magnets 122 and the back iron 134 would be about 1.1 pounds. Hence, the hydrodynamic bearing formed by the lifts 114A must compensate for a combination of the net hydrodynamic/hydrostatic force (0.202 pounds) and the motor magnet 122 and back iron 134 attractive force (1.1 pounds) for a total axial force of at least 1.302 pounds. In other words, the hydrodynamic bearing produces an amount of force adequate to compensate for both of these forces, thus maintaining the overall position of the rotor assembly 105 during normal operation with minimal to no physical contact with the housing assembly 101.
In conclusion, the operation of the pump is described. In operation, the blood pump 100 is connected to a circulatory system of a patient by the inlet 110 and the outlet 108. The user activates the blood pump 100 by actuating the blood pump controller. The controller delivers the appropriate electrical current to the flexible circuit 132, which then distributes this current to the coils 130. The current traveling through the wire 130A of the coils 130 creates a magnetic field that interacts with the motor magnet 122, driving the rotor assembly 105 to rotate. The magnetic fields of the spindle magnet 119 and the rotor axial magnet 124 interact to create a magnetic axial bearing to help maintain the axial position of the rotor assembly 105 during rotation. As the rotor assembly 105 spins, additional axial force is imparted to the rotor assembly by the hydrodynamic thrust bearing created by the lifts 114A on the thrust plate 114.
As the rotor assembly 105 rotates, the impeller blades 118A on the rotor housing top 118 drive blood from the inlet 110 and inlet passage 102C and out through the outlet 108. In this respect, the rotating rotor assembly 105 drives the patient's blood through the pump 100, assisting in blood circulation.
Although the invention has been described in terms of particular embodiments and applications, one of ordinary skill in the art, in light of this teaching, can generate additional embodiments and modifications without departing from the spirit of or exceeding the scope of the claimed invention. Accordingly, it is to be understood that the drawings and descriptions herein are proffered by way of example to facilitate comprehension of the invention and should not be construed to limit the scope thereof.
This application is a continuation of U.S. patent application Ser. No. 15/335,369 filed Oct. 26, 2016 entitled Rotary Blood Pump (now U.S. Pat. No. 10,265,499 issued Apr. 23, 2019, which is a continuation of U.S. patent application Ser. No. 13/739,814 filed Jan. 11, 2013 entitled Rotary Blood Pump (now U.S. Pat. No. 9,256,469 issued Feb. 9, 2016), which is a continuation of U.S. patent application Ser. No. 11/694,761 filed Mar. 30, 2007 entitled Rotary Blood Pump (now abandoned), which claims priority to U.S. Provisional Application Ser. No. 60/787,738 filed Mar. 31, 2006 entitled Rotary Blood Pump, al of which are hereby incorporated by reference in their entireties.
Number | Name | Date | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
2305416 | Hansen, Jr. | Dec 1942 | A |
3114582 | Milligan | Dec 1963 | A |
3243238 | Lyman | Mar 1966 | A |
3614181 | Meeks et al. | Oct 1971 | A |
4348065 | Yoshioka et al. | Sep 1982 | A |
4383771 | Freytag et al. | May 1983 | A |
5829338 | Chrestoff et al. | Nov 1998 | A |
5924975 | Coldowsky | Jul 1999 | A |
6183220 | Ohara et al. | Feb 2001 | B1 |
6250880 | Woodard et al. | Jun 2001 | B1 |
6394769 | Bearnson | May 2002 | B1 |
6846168 | Davis et al. | Jan 2005 | B2 |
7976271 | LaRose et al. | Jul 2011 | B2 |
20050025630 | Ayre et al. | Feb 2005 | A1 |
20050069435 | Ikeya | Mar 2005 | A1 |
20050084399 | Wampler et al. | Apr 2005 | A1 |
20050095151 | Wampler | May 2005 | A1 |
20070231135 | Wampler et al. | Oct 2007 | A1 |
20070280841 | LaRose et al. | Dec 2007 | A1 |
20080240947 | Allaire | Oct 2008 | A1 |
20140241904 | Yanai et al. | Aug 2014 | A1 |
20140309481 | Medvedev et al. | Oct 2014 | A1 |
20170128644 | Foster | May 2017 | A1 |
Number | Date | Country |
---|---|---|
WO 2000032256 | Jun 2000 | WO |
Entry |
---|
United States Patent and Trademark Office, Notice of Allowance dated Jul. 26, 2016 in U.S. Appl. No. 13/739,814, 5 pages. |
United States Patent and Trademark Office, Final Office Action dated Apr. 21, 2016 in U.S. Appl. No. 13/739,814, 9 pages. |
United States Patent and Trademark Office, Office Action dated Aug. 28, 2015 in U.S. Appl. No. 13/739,814, 11 pages. |
United States Patent and Trademark Office, Final Office Action dated Oct. 24, 2014 in U.S. Appl. No. 13/739,814, 24 pages. |
United States Patent and Trademark Office, Office Action dated Jan. 6, 2014 in U.S. Appl. No. 13/739,814, 27 pages. |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
20190209754 A1 | Jul 2019 | US |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
60787738 | Mar 2006 | US |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
Parent | 15335369 | Oct 2016 | US |
Child | 16352704 | US | |
Parent | 13739814 | Jan 2013 | US |
Child | 15335369 | US | |
Parent | 11694761 | Mar 2007 | US |
Child | 13739814 | US |