The present invention relates to a rotating stirring and/or reacting device particularly suitable for mixing processes that require substantially narrow distribution of energy dissipation rate.
Various types of mechanically stirred reactors are known in the art, generally of cylindrical body, and equipped along their axis with a stirring system, which is commonly a stirrer (turbine, impeller, propeller, blade, etc.) or a group of stirrers. These reactors are hereinafter referred to as “ST (stirred tank) reactors”. The ST reactors are used for processes that require continuous mixing of various components and efficient mass exchange between different phases (e.g. gas-liquid, gas-liquid-solid, liquid-liquid, liquid-solid, etc.). Proper selection of a stirring system for a particular process depends mainly on the viscosity of the mass to be stirred (see “Advances in Chemical Engineering,” vol. 17, pag. 5-8, Academic Press, 1992 (Ref. 1) and U.S. Pat. No. 5,460,447).
A common shortcoming of the ST reactors is a broad distribution of the energy dissipation rate (defined as energy dissipated per unit mass) in the mass contained in the reactors, which is undesired for processes that are sensitive to the local energy dissipation rate. For example, when the reaction kinetics of a polymerization process is sensitive to the local energy dissipation rate, a broad distribution of the energy dissipation rate in the reactor may lead to a broad distribution of molecular weight. For a bio-reaction process, when the distribution of the energy dissipation rate is broad, the large energy dissipation rates in the tail of the distribution lead to large turbulent shear rate, which can damage the bio-cells contained in the system.
An alternative design of reactors used for the processes mentioned above in the art is the Couette flow reactors, composed of two concentric cylinders where the inner cylinder is generally rotating. The gap between the two cylinders is the location where a process takes place. When the rotating speed is low, the Couette flow reactor can generate very uniform laminar shear rate, but mixing in the gap is generally very poor. Moreover, to get sufficiently large shear rate for practical applications, the gap between the cylinders must be very small, leading to very small volume of the reactor, which becomes meaningless in industrial applications. In fact, the Couette flow reactor is generally designed to have significantly large gap (in order to have significantly large volume of the reactor) and to operate at a significantly large rotation speed (see Zhu and Vigil, 2001 (Ref 2), Haut et al., 2003 (Ref 3), U.S. Pat. No. 4,911,847 and U.S. Pat. No. 6,099,730). In this case, with increasing the rotation speed, a series of (laminar, wavy, turbulent) vortices, called Taylor vortices, are generated in the gap, and the reactor is hereafter referred to as “TC” (Taylor-Couette) reactor. Vortices may be generated even at relative low rotational speeds, if V-shaped grooves are present on the inner cylinder as proposed in the U.S. Pat. No. 4,175,871. With respect to the ST reactors, the advantage of the TC reactors is absence of the distribution tails with substantially small and large energy dissipation rates. Therefore, the TC reactors are particularly suitable for applications involving fragile materials such as bio-cells, colloids, etc. However, the TC reactors have the following common disadvantages (see Haut et al, 2003 (Ref 3); Drozdov, 2002 (Ref 4); Resende et al, 2001 (Ref 5)): (1) poor mass transfer within the vortices, (2) possible separation of components in the gap when there is a difference in the density between components, and (3) a large drag torque and high power input per unit volume.
To overcome the above drawbacks of the TC reactors, Drozdov (Ref 4) proposed to use undulated surfaces for both the outer and inner cylinders, based on some sophisticated analytical mathematical formulas. However, manufacturing and scaling-up of such designed reactors are challenging.
In the UK Pat. GB 2 103 229 a further reactor type is described, where the inner reactor body with a polygon-type cross-section rotates coaxially within a tube. During the rotational motion of the inner body or the outer tube, the edges of the inner body make practically sliding contact with the inside of the outer tube and divide the gap between the inner body and the outer tube into several chambers. A limited material exchange between the separated chambers may occur through the thin film generated between the edges of the inner body and the outer tube during the rotation. It is obvious that this type of reactor is not suitable for those reactions, where an intimate intensive mixture between the various reaction components has to be achieved. In addition, the energy dissipation rate in the zones of the sliding contact between the edges of the inner body and the outer tube must be substantially large. Thus, this type of reactor has the same drawback as the ST reactors.
The object of the present invention is therefore to propose a further type of reactor which generates a substantially narrow distribution of energy dissipation rate to overcome the drawbacks as described above.
A new type of rotating stirring device is described hereinunder, which generates a substantially narrow distribution of energy dissipation rate, thus avoiding the drawbacks that the TC and ST reactors have. The invented devices are particularly suitable for processes that require a homogeneous turbulent flow environment and involving fragile components.
The present invention utilizes the principle of applying non-constant gap width between an inner and an outer member in the Taylor Couette device in order to reduce or completely destroy the Taylor vortices in the Taylor Couette device, as a result, to obtain a substantially narrow distribution of energy dissipation rate within the gap. The non-constant gap width in this invention is realized by using a non-circular cross-section for the inner member of the Taylor Couette device along the radial direction perpendicular to a rotation axis. The cross-section of the inner member perpendicular to the rotation axis can be any type of equilateral or inequilateral polygons with curved cusps. Typical examples for the cross-section shape of the inner member are: elliptical, triangle, rectangular, square, etc.
The characteristics of the invention will be further illustrated by the following description and by the enclosed drawings relating to a non-limitative embodiment.
With reference to
In this embodiment, the inner member of the polygon shape mounted in the outer e.g. cylinder generates a minimum gap, a, and a maximum gap, b, as illustrated in
With reference to
It is evident that the surface of both the inner and outer members of the present invention can be a porous membrane, which can be used for the purpose of filtration and separation, and as carrier for immobilized catalyst, bio-active species, etc.
Of course, when the inner member has an empty internal body, at each of its two ends a cover must be present in order to prevent the fluid falling into the internal space of the inner member, and the cover is also the location where the rotating shaft or the bearing shaft is fixed. At each of the two ends of the outer cylinder a cover must be present in order to keep the fluid in the reactor. Optionally, the two ends of both the inner and outer members can be designed in conical or spherical form which can improve fluid mixing in the space between the covers of the inner and outer members. Obviously, when the rotating stirring device is installed vertically, the top end cover of the outer cylinder may be avoided, depending on the requirement of the process.
It is evident that as to the embodiment previously illustrated, various changes, adjustments, variants and replacements of elements with other functionally equivalent elements can be carried out, while remaining within the scope of the claims reported hereinafter.
Because of the substantially narrow distribution of the energy dissipation rate, the present invention is particularly advantageous for reactors or mixers to be used in:
As described previously, the rotating stirring device of the present invention generates a substantially narrow distribution of the energy dissipation rate, which leads to a substantially narrow distribution of the shear rate in the stirred fluid. In the case of bio-chemical reactions, a narrow distribution of the shear rate is extremely advantageous, since it allows cells or microorganisms or products to practically operate under the same shear forces, thus avoiding their damage due to the presence of high local shear forces in some regions, as in the case of the ST reactors.
The non-constant gap width utilized in the present invention reduces or completely avoids the presence of the Taylor vortices, as often present in the case of the TC reactors, and it together with the narrow distribution of the shear rate avoids the possible separation of components in the gap when there is a difference in the density between components. Moreover, according to the present invention, the power input is substantially lower than those of the TC reactors, which will be clearly seen hereinafter in TABLE 1.
In the case of polymerizations in emulsion, a narrow distribution of the shear rate leads to the advantage that it avoids the undesired formation of polymer coagula due to the presence of high local shear forces in some regions, as in the case of the ST reactors. It is well known that such coagula, besides of fouling the reactor with subsequent maintenance problems, cause various inconveniences such as reducing the stability of the polymer latexes, contamination of the polymer, lowering the reaction rate, etc.
In the case of polymerizations in suspension, a narrow distribution of the shear rate allows one to obtain a narrow distribution of the polymer beads, as it leads to the formation of the particles occurring in the entire volume of the reactor and to a uniform growth rate of the formed particles. The axis of the present stirring device for the processes of suspension polymerizations is preferably placed horizontally.
Currently, there is no effective technique that can directly measure the distribution of energy dissipation rate or distribution of shear rate in a mechanically stirred reactor, though there do exist techniques to measure average velocity profiles and flow patterns, such as using laser Doppler velocimetry (LDV) (Wu and Patterson, Ref 8) and particle image velocimetry (PIV) (Haut et al, Ref 3). However, the LDV and PIV techniques are difficult to apply to the device of the present invention, because of the deformed inner member, which leads to the flow pattern at a fixed location inside the gap varying periodically with time. On the other hand, it has been confirmed that for single-phase fluid, the commercial software for computational fluid dynamics (CFD) simulations, such as Fluent (Fluent Inc., 10 Cavendish Court, Lebanon, N.H. 03766-1442, USA), CFX (CFX Ltd., The Gemini Building, Fermi Avenue, Harwell International Business Centre, Didcot, Oxfordshire OX1 1 0QR, UK) and StarCD (CD adapco Groupe, London office, 200 Shepherds Bush Road, London W6 7NY, UK), can correctly reproduce the average velocity profiles and flow patterns measured by LDV and PIV techniques (Haut et at., 2003 (Ref. 3); Zhu and Vigil, 2001 (Ref. 4); Mavros et at, 2001 (Ref. 6); Campolo et al., 2003 (Ref. 7)). Therefore, in the following examples, the distribution of energy dissipation rate as well as the other fluid dynamic properties in each rotating stirring device is obtained based on single-phase CFD simulations, using the commercial CFD software, Fluent (version 6.1).
Moreover, in order to verify that the CFD software Fluent has been correctly utilized, before carrying out the computations for the cases in the following examples, the Fluent software has been used to compute the average velocity profiles in a TC reactor and a ST reactor, and the results of the experimental data reported in the literature have been compared. In particular, Haut et al. (Ref 3) have measured axial velocity profiles in the gap of a TC reactor using the PIV technique. The TC reactor has the radii of 4 cm and 4.85 cm for the inner and outer cylinders, respectively, and the inner cylinder was rotating. The results at the rotation speeds of the inner cylinder, 2.15 rad/s and 4.9 rad/s, are reproduced in
A=B=270 mm; C=90 mm; D=93 mm; E=18.6 mm; F=23.25 mm; G=27 mm.
Using Fluent, the volume-based distribution of the energy dissipation rate for the ST reactor geometrically defined above, has been computed with a rotation speed for the Rushton turbine being 8.08 rev/s. The results are reported in
1=140 mm; J=8 mm; K=320 mm.
The distribution of the energy dissipation rate computed using Fluent for the TC reactor geometrically defined above is shown in
According to the present invention as schematically illustrated in
The distributions of the energy dissipation rate computed using fluent for the three reactors geometrically defined above are shown in
The corresponding power input, defined as power per unit volume, of the three TIC (TIC8=12. TIC8=16 and TIC8-22) reactors are shown in columns 3, 4 and 5 of TABLE 1, and compared to the power input of the TC reactor (TC8, in column 2) of the prior art, as geometrically defined in Example 2. The values presented in TABLE 1 are the relative power input, i.e., the ratio of the power input of the reactor of the present invention to the power input of the TC8 reactor. It is seen that the relative power input is always smaller than unity, indicating that a lower power input is required for the present reactor with respect to the TC reactor in order to obtain the same volume-averaged energy dissipation rate.
According to the present invention as schematically illustrated in
T=140 mm; H=320 mm; a=8 mm; b=16 mm.
The distributions of the energy dissipation rate computed using Fluent for the three reactors geometrically defined above are shown in
The corresponding relative power input of the TIC8-16 and SIC8-16 reactors are shown in columns 6 and 7 of TABLE 1, respectively. Again, they are substantially smaller than unity, indicating that a lower power input is required for these reactors with respect to the TC reactor in order to obtain the same volume-averaged energy dissipation rate.
The reactor designs and the examples described with reference to
Again according to a further embodiment, it is possible to rotate both members.
Again according to a further embodiment, it is possible to have an outer and an inner member, which both have a cross-section of non-circular shape.
Again according to a further embodiment, it is possible to move the inner member alternatively in one and the other longitudinal direction to vary the gap between the top or the base area of the inner member and the respective reactor walls.
It is furthermore possible to rotate the members in different rotation directions, or to rotate in the same direction but with different rotation speeds, or to use a temporal variation rotation speed, etc.
Even if in the attached figures and also in the examples always concentrically arranged members are shown or described, respectively, it is of course possible to arrange the inner member body in an eccentric manner, which means that the rotation axis is not in line with the axis of the outer member, which could be e.g. an outer cylinder.
Again, in a further embodiment it is possible that at least one member wall is at least partially permeable for fluids insofar that exchange of components between inside and outside the reactor and/or the mixing vessel is possible. The cylinder wall may be permeable for instance to be used for filtration of components from the reaction mixture in the reactor and/or mixing vessel.
Furthermore, the inner and/or outer member can be made in the form of jacket for different purposes such as for instance for heat exchange.
Finally, it is a question of optimization how to design and dimension the two members like e.g. longitudinal extending bodies. The main point of the basic idea of the present invention is to design and to dimension the two member walls or jackets in such a way that the gap between the two walls or vessel jackets is differing in circumferential direction.
Number | Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
03018073.1 | Aug 2003 | EP | regional |
03019330.4 | Aug 2003 | EP | regional |
This application is a U.S. National Phase application under 35 USC § 371 of International Application PCT/CH2004/000494, filed Aug. 6, 2004, and claims priority under 35 USC §119 of European application no. 03018073.1, filed Aug. 8, 2003, and European application no. 03019330.4, filed Aug. 27, 2003.
Filing Document | Filing Date | Country | Kind | 371c Date |
---|---|---|---|---|
PCT/CH2004/000494 | 8/6/2004 | WO | 00 | 5/19/2008 |