Scroll machine with capacity modulation

Information

  • Patent Grant
  • 6176686
  • Patent Number
    6,176,686
  • Date Filed
    Friday, February 19, 1999
    25 years ago
  • Date Issued
    Tuesday, January 23, 2001
    23 years ago
Abstract
A scroll-type refrigeration compressor is disclosed which incorporates an efficient, reliable, low cost modulation system employing a single actuator to effect switching between full and reduced capacity operation. The modulation system of the present invention includes an elongated member movably supported on the non-orbiting scroll which operates to ensure simultaneous opening and closing one or more unloading passages thus avoiding the possibility of even transient pressure imbalances between opposed compression pockets during operation of the compressor. In one embodiment, the elongated member has the opposite ends interconnected by springs and is rotatably movable to effect the intended modulation. In another embodiment, the elongated member is movable generally along a radial line of the non-orbiting scroll member. Further, the modulation system of the present invention provides for reduced capacity at both start up and shut down thus enabling the use of more efficient lower starting torque motors and reducing the potential for noise generating reverse rotation on shut down.
Description




BACKGROUND AND SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION




The present invention relates generally to scroll compressors and more specifically to a capacity modulation system of the delayed suction type for such compressors.




Refrigeration and air conditioning systems are commonly operated under a wide range of loading conditions due to changing environmental conditions. In order to effectively and efficiently accomplish the desired cooling under such changing conditions, it is desirable to incorporate means to vary the capacity of the compressors utilized in such systems.




A wide variety of systems have been developed in order to accomplish this capacity modulation most of which delay the initial sealing point of the moving fluid pockets defined by scroll members. In one form, such systems commonly employ a pair of vent passages communicating between suction pressure and the outermost pair of moving fluid pockets. Typically these passages open into the moving fluid pockets at a position normally within 360° of the sealing point of the outer ends of the wraps. Some systems employ a separate valve member for each such vent passage which valves are intended to be operated simultaneously so as to ensure a pressure balance between the two fluid pockets. Other systems employ additional passages to place the two vent passages in fluid communication thereby enabling use of a single valve to control capacity modulation.




The first type of system mentioned above creates a possibility that the two valves may not operate simultaneously. For example, should one of the two valves fail, a pressure imbalance will be created between the two fluid pockets which will increase the stresses on the Oldham coupling thereby reducing the life of the compressor. Further, such pressure imbalance may result in increasing operating noise to an unacceptable level. Even slight differences in the speed of operation between the two valves can result in objectionable noise generating transient pressure imbalances.




While the second type of system mentioned above eliminates the concern over pressure imbalances encountered with the first system, it requires additional costly machining to provide a linking passage across the scroll end plate to interconnect the two vent passages. Further, the addition of this linking passage increases the re-expansion volume of the compressor when it is operated in a full capacity mode thus reducing its efficiency.




The present invention, however, overcomes these and other problems by providing a single valving ring operated by a single actuator so as to ensure simultaneous opening and closing of the vent passages thus avoiding any possibility of even transient pressure imbalances in the fluid pockets. The valving ring of the present invention is in the form of a discontinuous generally circularly shaped ring which in one embodiment is rotatably mounted on the non-orbiting scroll member and includes portions operative to open and close, one, two or more vent passages simultaneously. In another embodiment the ring may be moved in a generally radial direction. Actuation of the valving ring is preferably accomplished by means of a solenoid valve although a fluid pressure operated actuator may be used. In both of the embodiments a minimum number of parts are required to accomplish the capacity modulation. Further, the capacity modulation system of the present invention will preferably be designed such that the compressor will be in a reduced capacity mode at both start up and shut down. The reduced capacity starting mode reduces the required starting torque because the compressor is compressing a substantially smaller volume of refrigerant. This reduced starting torque enables use of a lower torque higher efficiency motor. Also, reduced capacity operation at shut down reduces the potential and degree of noise generating reverse rotation of the scrolls thereby enhancing customer satisfaction. Additionally, the system of the present invention is preferably designed such that should the actuating system fail, the compressor will be able to continue operation in a reduced or modulated capacity mode. This is desirable because under normally encountered operating conditions, the compressor will spend most of its running time in the modulated or reduced capacity mode.




Additional advantages and features of the present invention will become apparent from the subsequent description and the appended claims taken in conjunction with the accompanying drawings.











BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS





FIG. 1

is a fragmentary section view of a hermetic scroll compressor incorporating the capacity modulation system of the present invention;





FIG. 2

is a section view of the compressor of

FIG. 1

, the section being taken along the line


2





2


thereof;





FIGS. 3 and 4

are views of the valving ring and actuator incorporated in the embodiment shown in

FIGS. 1 and 2

shown in closed and open positions respectively;





FIGS. 5 and 6

are section views each similar to that of

FIG. 2

but showing another embodiment of the present invention in open and closed positions respectively; and





FIGS. 7 and 8

are views similar to that of

FIGS. 3 and 4

but showing the embodiment illustrated in

FIGS. 5 and 6

.











DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS




Referring now to the drawings and in particular to

FIG. 1

, there is shown a hermetic scroll-type refrigeration compressor indicated generally at


10


and incorporating a capacity modulation system in accordance with the present invention.




Compressor


10


is generally of the type disclosed in U.S. Pat. No. 4,767,293 issued Aug. 30, 1988 and assigned to the same assignee as the present application the disclosure of which is hereby incorporated by reference. Compressor


10


includes an outer shell


12


within which is disposed orbiting and non-orbiting scroll members


14


and


16


each of which include upstanding interleaved spiral wraps


18


and


20


which define moving fluid pockets


22


,


24


which progressively decrease in size as they move inwardly from the outer periphery of the scroll members


14


and


16


.




A main bearing housing


26


is provided which is supported by outer shell


12


and which in turn movably supports orbiting scroll member


14


for relative orbital movement with respect to non-orbiting scroll member


16


. Non-orbiting scroll member


16


is supported by and secured to main bearing housing for limited axial movement with respect thereto in a suitable manner such as disclosed in U.S. Pat. No. 5,407,335 issued Apr. 18, 1995 and assigned to the same assignee as the present application, the disclosure of which is hereby incorporated by reference.




A drive shaft


28


is rotatably supported by main bearing housing


26


and includes an eccentric pin


30


at the upper end thereof drivingly connected to orbiting scroll member


14


. A motor rotor


32


is secured to the lower end of drive shaft


28


and cooperates with a stator


34


supported by outer shell


12


to rotatably drive shaft


28


.




Outer shell


12


includes a muffler plate


36


which divides the interior thereof into a first lower chamber


38


at substantially suction pressure and an upper chamber


40


at discharge pressure. A suction inlet


42


is provided opening into lower chamber


38


for supplying refrigerant for compression and a discharge outlet


44


is provided from discharge chamber


40


to direct compressed refrigerant to the refrigeration system.




As thus far described, scroll compressor


12


is typical of such scroll-type refrigeration compressors. In operation, suction gas directed to lower chamber


38


via suction inlet


42


is drawn into the moving fluid pockets


22


and


24


as orbiting scroll member


14


orbits with respect to non-orbiting scroll member


16


. As the moving fluid pockets


22


and


24


move inwardly, this suction gas is compressed and subsequently discharged into discharge chamber


40


via a center discharge passage


46


in non-orbiting scroll member


16


and discharge opening


48


in muffler plate


36


. Compressed refrigerant is then supplied to the refrigeration system via discharge outlet


44


.




In selecting a refrigeration compressor for a particular application, one would normally choose a compressor having sufficient capacity to provide adequate refrigerant flow for the most adverse operating conditions to be anticipated for that application and may select a slightly larger capacity to provide an extra margin of safety. However, such “worst case” adverse conditions are rarely encountered during actual operation and thus this excess capacity of the compressor results in operation of the compressor under lightly loaded conditions for a high percentage of its operating time. Such operation results in reducing overall operating efficiency of the system. Accordingly, in order to improve the overall operating efficiency under generally encountered operating conditions while still enabling the refrigeration compressor to accommodate the “worst case” operating conditions, compressor


10


is provided with a capacity modulation system.




The capacity modulation system of the present invention includes a generally circularly shaped valving ring


50


movably mounted on non-orbiting scroll member


16


, an actuating assembly


52


and a control system


54


for controlling operation of the actuating assembly (see FIG.


2


).




As best seen with reference to

FIGS. 2 through 4

, valving ring


50


comprises an elongated strip member


56


formed into a generally circular shape with the opposite ends


58


and


60


thereof being positioned in spaced generally opposed relationship. One or more springs


62


is provided having opposite ends connected to respective ends


58


and


60


of strip


56


and operates to draw them toward each other. Preferably ring


50


will be formed from a relatively thin metal and formed to a generally circular shape having a radius slightly less than the radius of non-orbiting scroll member. A pair of openings


64


,


66


are provided in ring


50


positioned intermediate the ends thereof and in generally diametrically opposed relationship to each other.




As previously mentioned, valving ring


50


is designed to be movably mounted on non-orbiting scroll member


16


. In order to accommodate valving ring


50


, non-orbiting scroll member


16


includes a radially outwardly facing cylindrical sidewall portion


68


thereon having an annular groove


70


formed therein adjacent the upper end thereof.




Groove


70


is sized to movably accommodate ring


50


when it is assembled thereto having a relatively shallow radial depth approximately equal to or slightly greater than the thickness of ring


50


and an axial width just slightly greater than ring


50


. Ring


50


may be easily assembled to non-orbiting scroll member


16


by merely spreading the ends apart slightly to enlarge the diameter thereof and slipping it axially into position within groove


70


. Once in position, springs


62


will operate to bias ends


58


and


60


toward each other thereby retaining ring


50


properly seated within groove


70


. Alternatively, ring


50


may be fabricated in a circular shape from a material having a suitable resilient shape retaining capability so as to enable it to be expanded for assembly yet still be sufficiently resistant to such radial expansion once assembled as to eliminate the need for springs


62


. Of course this resistance to radial expansion must be sufficient as to enable ring


50


to maintain a seal over the capacity modulating vent passages described below when in a position for full capacity operation.




Non-orbiting scroll member


16


also includes a pair of generally diametrically opposed radially extending passages


72


and


74


opening into the inner surface of groove


70


and extending generally radially inwardly through the end plate of non-orbiting scroll member


16


. An axially extending passage


76


places the inner end of passage


72


in fluid communication with moving fluid pocket


24


while a second axially extending passage


78


places the inner end of passage


74


in fluid communication with moving fluid pocket


22


. Preferably, passages


76


and


78


will be oval in shape so as to maximize the size of the opening thereof without having a width greater than the width of the wrap of the orbiting scroll member


14


. Passage


76


is positioned adjacent an inner sidewall surface of scroll wrap


20


and passage


78


is positioned adjacent an outer sidewall surface of wrap


20


. Alternatively passages


76


and


78


may be round if desired however the diameter thereof should be such that the opening does not extend to the radially inner side of the wrap


18


of the orbiting scroll member


14


as it passes thereover.




Actuating assembly


52


includes a solenoid


80


having a cylindrical housing


82


sealingly secured to outer shell


12


and extending generally radially outwardly therefrom which defines a cylinder within which elongated piston


86


is axially movably disposed. An actuating coil assembly


88


is provided on the outwardly projecting portion of cylindrical housing


82


and serves to create a magnetic field when actuated drawing piston axially into cylinder housing


82


. A generally Z-shaped actuating rod


90


has one end rotatably secured to the outer end of piston


86


with the other end being rotatably secured to the outer surface of valving ring


50


in a suitable manner such as by strap


92


. As shown in

FIGS. 3 and 4

, actuating rod is secured to valving ring


50


at a location circumferentially displaced from the axis of piston


86


such that as piston


86


is drawn axially into cylinder


82


, actuating rod


90


will rotate with respect thereto with the end secured to valving ring moving circumferentially toward the line of movement of piston


86


and thus effecting circumferential movement of ring


50


.




As shown in

FIG. 2

, when solenoid coil


88


is de-energized, valving ring


50


will be in a position in which openings


64


and


66


are in alignment with respective passages


72


and


74


thereby venting compression chambers


22


and


24


to the interior of shell


12


. When solenoid coil assembly


88


is energized, piston


86


will be drawn into cylinder housing


82


thereby effecting rotary movement of valving ring


50


with respect to non-orbiting scroll member


16


and moving openings


64


and


66


out of alignment with respective passages


72


and


74


. In this position, valving ring


50


will prevent suction gas from respective compression chambers


22


and


24


being vented to the interior of the shell so that the compressor will then operate at substantially full capacity.




In order to return valving ring


50


to a position in which passages


64


and


66


are vented to the interior of the shell when solenoid coil


88


is de-energized, a spring


94


is provided having one end secured to a post


96


upstanding from main bearing housing


26


and the other end secured to the end of actuating rod


90


that is secured to valving ring. Thus when solenoid coil


88


is de-energized, spring


94


will operate to rotate valving ring in the opposite circumferential direction to move openings


64


and


66


back into aligned relationship with respective passages


72


and


74


as well as to move piston


86


axially outwardly from cylinder housing


82


.




Control system


54


operates to control actuation of actuating assembly


52


and includes a control module


98


and one or more sensors


100


. Control module


98


is connected to solenoid coil


88


via line


102


and operates to selectively energize solenoid coil


88


in response to system operating conditions as sensed by sensors


100


and transmitted thereto via line


104


. Preferably, control module


98


will operate to ensure that solenoid coil


88


is de-energized both just prior to shut down of compressor


10


as well as at start up.




When valving ring


50


is in the position shown in

FIG. 2

, moving fluid pockets


22


and


24


will remain in fluid communication with lower chamber


38


at suction pressure via passages


72


,


76


and


74


,


78


after the initial sealing of the flank surfaces of the scroll wraps at the outer end thereof until such time as the moving fluid pockets have moved inwardly to a point at which they are no longer in fluid communication with passages


76


and


78


. Thus, when valving ring


50


is in a position such that fluid passages


72


and


74


are in open communication with the suction gas chamber


38


, the effective working length of scroll wraps


18


and


20


is reduced as is the compression ratio and hence the capacity of the compressor. It should be noted that the degree of modulation or reduction in compressor capacity may be selected within a given range based upon the positioning of passages


76


and


78


. These passages will preferably be located so that they are in communication with the respective suction pockets at any point up to 360° inwardly from the point at which the trailing flank surfaces move into sealing engagement. If they are located further inwardly than this, compression of the fluid in the pockets will have begun and hence venting thereof will result in lost work and a reduction in efficiency.




It should also be noted that by ensuring passages


72


and


74


are in open communication with suction pressure at start up, the required starting torque for the compressor is substantially reduced. This enables the use of a more efficient lower starting torque motor, thus further contributing to overall system efficiency.




In any event, so long as system conditions as received by control module


98


indicate, compressor


10


will continue to operate in this reduced capacity mode. However, should system conditions dictate that additional capacity is required such as may be indicated by a signal from sensor


100


to controller


98


, controller


98


will actuate solenoid valve


80


causing valving ring


50


to rotate in a clockwise direction as shown in

FIG. 2

so as to substantially simultaneously close off passages


72


and


74


thereby avoiding the possibility of pressure imbalances between fluid pockets


22


and


24


. With valving ring


50


in this position, it overlies and closes off passages


72


and


74


respectively thus preventing further venting of the suction fluid pockets therethrough and increasing the capacity of compressor


10


to its full rated capacity. So long as system operating conditions require, solenoid valve will be maintained in its energized position thereby maintaining compressor


10


at its full rated capacity. It should be noted that because the solenoid valve is selected to be in a normal position to reduce the capacity of the compressor, failure of either the solenoid valve or control module will not prevent continued operation of the compressor.




It should be noted that if desired the actuating solenoid valve assembly may be replaced by a pressure actuated piston assembly. In such an embodiment, it is contemplated that a solenoid valve would be incorporated to control flow of pressurized fluid to and venting from the actuating piston/cylinder. It is also contemplated that the discharge fluid would be utilized as the pressurized fluid to actuate the piston cylinder assembly in such an embodiment.




Another embodiment of a modulation system in accordance with the present invention is illustrated and will be described with reference to

FIGS. 5 through 8

. As this embodiment is very similar to the embodiment shown in

FIGS. 1 through 4

except for the valving ring and a portion of the actuating mechanism as noted below, corresponding portions will be indicated by the same reference numbers used in

FIGS. 1 through 4

primed.




In this embodiment valving ring


106


is fabricated from a suitable resilient shape retaining material such as spring steel and has a generally circular shape extending circumferentially somewhat greater than 180° . The opposite ends


108


and


110


of valving ring


106


are spaced apart approximately 90° and flare slightly radially outwardly. Preferably, valving ring


106


will have an unstressed diameter slightly less than that of the diameter of groove


70


′ provided in non-orbiting scroll


16


′ within which it is seated.




Actuating mechanism


112


is similar to actuating mechanism


80


in that it utilizes a solenoid actuated plunger to effect movement of valving ring


106


. However, a rocker arm


114


is pivotably supported on main bearing housing


26


′ by means of a suitable pivot pin


116


. Rocker arm


114


includes a first arm


118


extending outwardly from pivot pin


116


, the outer end of which is pivotably connected to the outwardly projecting end of plunger


86


′. A second arm


120


extending outwardly from pivot pin


116


in generally the opposite direction from arm


118


is adapted to pivotably receive one end of an actuating rod


122


. The other end of actuating rod


122


is fixedly secured to the outer periphery of valving ring


106


via strap


124


such as by welding. Preferably, valving ring


106


will be positioned relative to non-orbiting scroll member


16


′ such that the midpoint thereof is substantially centered with respect to diametrically opposed vent passages


72


′ and


74


′ and actuating rod will be secured thereto at this midpoint location.




In operation, when solenoid coil


80


′ is de-energized valving ring will be in a position as shown in

FIG. 5

in which the midpoint portion thereof is positioned in radially spaced relationship to non-orbiting scroll member


16


′ with the opposite ends thereof being positioned within groove


70


′. When in this position, vent passages


72


′ and


74


′ will both be in open communication with chamber


38


which is at suction gas pressure as valving ring will be radially outwardly spaced therefrom as shown in the drawings. Thus, the compressor will operate at a reduced capacity.




Should conditions indicate that increased capacity is required, solenoid valve


80


′ will be energized by the control module in response to signals from system load sensors. Energization of solenoid valve


80


′ will result in plunger being drawn radially outwardly with respect to compressor


10


′ thereby causing rocker arm


114


to pivot about pin


116


in a clockwise direction to a position as shown in FIG.


6


. This pivoting motion of rocker arm


114


will in turn move valving ring


106


radially inwardly with respect to non-orbiting scroll member


16


′ such that it is fully seated within groove


70


′. In this position valve ring


106


will be in overlying relationship to respective vent passages


72


′ and


74


′ and will operate to prevent venting of suction gas therethrough. Thus, the compressor will operate at substantially full capacity until such time as the sensors indicate it can be returned to reduced capacity.




It should be noted that because the opposite ends of valving ring


106


extend more than 90° in opposite directions from the radial line of movement of actuating rod


122


, the radially inwardly directed biasing force exerted by opposite end portions


108


and


110


on the radially outwardly facing curved surface of groove


70


will operate to assist solenoid coil


80


′ in moving valving ring


106


into a closed position. Further, the slight radially outward flare provided on end portions


108


and


110


ensures that the radially inner edges at the opposite terminal ends of valving ring


106


will not dig into the groove


70


and thereby resist movement into a closed non-venting position. While the circumferential extent of valving ring


106


is not critical, it should be sufficient to ensure that it will expand radially enough to uncover passages


72


′ and


74


′ so that the compression pockets may be vented to the low pressure chamber of the compressor.




While it will be apparent that the preferred embodiments of the invention disclosed are well calculated to provide the advantages and features above stated, it will be appreciated that the invention is susceptible to modification, variation and change without departing from the proper scope or fair meaning of the subjoined claims.



Claims
  • 1. A capacity modulation system for a scroll-type compressor comprising:a first scroll member having a first end plate and a first spiral wrap upstanding therefrom; a second scroll member having a second end plate and a second spiral wrap upstanding therefrom, said first and second spiral wraps being interleaved to define at least two moving fluid pockets which decrease in size as they move from a radially outer position to a radially inner position; a first fluid passage provided in said first scroll member and extending generally radially from one of said at least two moving fluid pockets to a radially outer peripheral surface of said first scroll member; a second fluid passage provided in said first scroll member and extending generally radially from a second of said at least two moving fluid pockets to a radially outer peripheral surface of said first scroll member; and an elongated member having opposite ends and extending circumferentially around a portion of said first scroll member, said portion being less than the full circumference of said first scroll member, said elongated member being movable between a first position in which said first and second fluid passages are in open communication with an area at substantially suction pressure and a second position in which communication of said first and second passages with said area at substantially suction pressure is resisted.
  • 2. A capacity modulation system as set forth in claim 1 further including an actuating assembly, said actuating assembly being operative to move said elongated member to said second position when energized and to said first position when deenergized.
  • 3. A capacity modulation system as set forth in claim 2 wherein said actuating assembly is de-energized when said compressor is started thereby enabling use of a lower starting torque motor for driving said compressor.
  • 4. A capacity modulation system as set forth in claim 2 wherein said actuating assembly is de-energized when said compressor is shut down.
  • 5. A capacity modulation system as set forth in claim 2 wherein said actuating assembly includes a solenoid for affecting movement of said elongated member.
  • 6. A capacity modulation system as set forth in claim 5 wherein said actuating assembly includes a member pivotably interconnecting said solenoid and said elongated member.
  • 7. A capacity modulation system as set forth in claim 6 wherein said actuating assembly includes a biasing member operative to return said elongated member to said first position when said solenoid coil is deenergized.
  • 8. A capacity modulation system as set forth in claim 1 further comprising biasing means extending between opposite ends of said elongated member, said biasing means being operative to urge said opposite ends toward each other.
  • 9. A capacity modulation system as set forth in claim 8 wherein said elongated member is circumferentially movably supported on said first scroll member.
  • 10. A capacity modulation system as set forth in claim 5 wherein said elongated member includes openings movable into and out of overlying relationship with said first and second passages.
  • 11. A capacity modulation system as set forth in claim 1 wherein said elongated member is formed of a resilient material operable to exert a radially inwardly directed force on said first scroll member.
  • 12. A capacity modulation system as set forth in claim 11 wherein said elongated member is radially movable between said first and second positions.
  • 13. A scroll-type refrigeration compressor comprising:a first scroll member having a first end plate and a first spiral wrap upstanding therefrom; a second scroll member having a second end plate and a second spiral wrap upstanding therefrom, said first and second spiral wraps being interleaved to define at least two moving fluid pockets which decrease in size as they move from a radially outer position to a radially inner position; a stationary body supporting said second scroll member for orbital movement with respect to said first scroll member, said first scroll member being supportingly secured to said stationary body; a drive shaft rotatably supported by said stationary body and drivingly coupled to said second scroll member; a driving motor operative to rotatably drive said drive shaft; a first fluid passage provided in said first scroll member and extending generally radially from a first fluid pocket and opening outwardly along an outer peripheral surface of said first scroll member; a second fluid passage provided on said first scroll member and extending generally radially from a second fluid pocket and opening outwardly along an outer peripheral surface of said first scroll member, in circumferentially spaced relationship from said first passage; an elongated member movably supported on and extending circumferentially around a portion of the outer periphery of said first scroll member, said elongated member including opposite ends positioned in circumferentially spaced relationship; and an actuating assembly operatively connected to said elongated member, said actuating assembly being operative to effect movement of said elongated member with respect to said first scroll member to selectively open and close said first and second fluid passages.
  • 14. A scroll-type refrigeration compressor as set forth in claim 13 further comprising a hermetic shell, said first and second scroll members and said stationary body being disposed within said shell and said actuating assembly includes a solenoid having a cylindrical member extending outwardly from said shell, an actuating coil supported on an outer surface of said cylindrical member and a plunger movably disposed within said cylinder and projecting into said shell.
  • 15. A scroll-type refrigeration compressor as set forth in claim 14 wherein said actuating assembly includes a rod pivotably connected to said elongated member and said plunger, said rod being operative to effect rotary movement of said elongated member.
  • 16. A scroll-type refrigeration compressor as set forth in claim 15 wherein said elongated member includes first and second circumferentially spaced openings, said openings being movable into and out of alignment with said first and second fluid passages.
  • 17. A scroll-type refrigeration compressor as set forth in claim 16 further comprising a resilient member extending between said opposite ends.
  • 18. A scroll-type refrigeration compressor as set forth in claim 14 wherein said elongated member is radially movable.
  • 19. A scroll-type refrigeration compressor as set forth in claim 18 wherein said actuating assembly includes a rocker arm pivotably supported within said shell, one end of said rocker arm being connected to said elongated member and the other end being connected to said plunger.
US Referenced Citations (15)
Number Name Date Kind
4383805 Teegarden et al. May 1983
4456435 Hiraga et al. Jun 1984
4468178 Hiraga et al. Aug 1984
4497615 Griffith Feb 1985
4514150 Hiraga et al. Apr 1985
4566863 Goto et al. Jan 1986
4673340 Mabe et al. Jun 1987
4747756 Sato et al. May 1988
5074760 Hirooka et al. Dec 1991
5074761 Hirooka et al. Dec 1991
5192195 Iio et al. Mar 1993
5451146 Inagaki et al. Sep 1995
5551846 Taylor et al. Sep 1996
5562426 Watanabe et al. Oct 1996
5678985 Brooke et al. Oct 1997
Foreign Referenced Citations (6)
Number Date Country
35 14230 A1 Oct 1986 DE
0 060 140 A1 Sep 1982 EP
0 174 516 A1 Mar 1986 EP
0 747 597 A2 Jun 1995 EP
0 681 105 A2 Nov 1995 EP
3-202691 Sep 1991 JP