The invention relates to the field of secure access in a communication network, and in particular to secure access in a Fixed Mobile Convergence network.
Fixed Mobile Convergence (FMC) refers to the convergence of fixed and mobile communication networks. IP-based technologies are commonly used for both fixed and mobile networks, which makes convergence easier. Using FMC, mobile and fixed network operators will be able to utilize their network resources more efficiently. For instance, when a user is running IP-based applications such as Multimedia Telephony (MMTeI) and IP Television (IPTV) inside his home, it is more efficient to utilize a fixed access broadband network instead of a wireless access network, and the user will also be able to run those applications on his mobile telephone when he is away from his home.
“Proxy Mobile IPv6”, IETF RFC5213. 2008-08 is an example of a network-based IP mobility management scheme in 3GPP. Network-based IP mobility management allows network operators to avoid mobility signalling over an air interface, and supports location privacy. In some situations, such as 3GPP Evolved Packet Core (EPC) networks, PMIPv6 is suitable as a mobility protocol for interfaces between network entities, such as the S2 and S5 interfaces (see “Architecture enhancements for non-3GPP Accesses”, 3GPP TS 23.402, V8.2.0, 2008-06). EPC networks are the core networks for 3GPP Long Term Evolution (LTE) networks.
A key concept in FMC is that of a residential network, as this is the most commonly used fixed network access by domestic users. It is therefore necessary to connect mobile devices (or User Equipment, UE) to an EPC network through a residential network. Network-based IP mobility management must be provided for 3GPP UEs that are attached to the fixed access network. This means that any network entity (such as a Broadcast Network Gateway, BNG) inside the fixed access network needs to perform the functionality of Mobile Access Gateway (MAG) which registers the current topological location of the 3GPP UE with the mobility anchor (PDN Gateway) in the EPC.
Note that whilst the description refers to residential networks, this is by way of example, as the same concepts would apply to other types of network such as corporate networks.
“Architecture enhancements for non-3GPP Accesses”, 3GPP TS 23.402, V8.2.0, 2008-06 describes two types of Non-3GPP IP Access, namely Untrusted Non-3GPP IP Access and Trusted Non-3GPP IP Access. The attachment procedure to make the UE attached to the mobile network differs for each of these IP Access networks.
Digital Subscriber Line (DSL) networks, which are a non-3GPP IP Access, can be either Untrusted or Trusted depending on the business relationship between the 3GPP and DSL network operators. Although there is currently no 3GPP specification describing an architecture of EPC using DSL networks as a non-3GPP IP Access, it is not difficult to assume that there is a possible network architecture for DSL networks as a natural extension of another non-3GPP IP Access.
A 3GPP UE, when accessing the EPC network via a residential network that utilizes a DSL network as a WAN interface, would have two different types of attachment procedure. When involving the residential network as part of a non-3GPP IP Access network, some specific problems are raised for each non-3GPP IP Access.
These multiple IP addresses are visible to upper layer protocols such as those used by applications, which raises a general multi-homed problem. An application, when wishing to make use of the IP address of the UE 1, must somehow select which IP is address is most suitable, and whether to use the local or global IPC address. There are two main address selection issues:
A further problem arises when a 3GPP UE 1 attempts to access a trusted non-3GPP IP Access Network (DSL networks) from the residential network 2, as illustrated in
RNs are not considered to fulfil these requirements, and so, the RN should be considered as insecure. For such insecure accesses, as shown in
This gives rise to risks such as incorrect charging, disclosure of confidential information, or compromising terminals and servers.
According to a first aspect of the invention, there is provided a method of providing secure access to a remote communication network via a local communication network for a terminal device. A gateway node located outside the local communication network allocates an IP address to the terminal device. The gateway node subsequently receives a request to establish a secure tunnel between the gateway node and the terminal device. It identifies the terminal device as the same terminal device to which an IP address is allocated, and allocates the same IP address for use by the terminal device as both an inner IP address and an outer IP address for packets sent via the secure tunnel. This ensures that there are no issues as described above in selecting the IP address for use in the secure tunnel, and reduces the risk of a successful man-in-the-middle attack.
Optionally, the remote communication network is an Evolved Packet Core network and the local network is a Local Area Network. As a further option, the secure tunnel is an IPsec tunnel established using an Internet Key Exchange protocol. As yet a further option, the terminal device is 3GPP User Equipment.
The method optionally comprises providing the terminal device and the gateway node with a shared secret and using that shared secret to authenticate the gateway node with the terminal device and the terminal device with the gateway node prior to establishing the IPsec tunnel.
The method optionally comprises configuring a security policy database at the terminal device such that packets to be sent to the remote communication network are sent via the secure tunnel, and packets to be sent to other nodes within the local communication network are not sent via the secure tunnel.
According to a second aspect, there is provided a gateway node for use in a communication network. The gateway node is provided with a protocol driver function for allocating an IP address to a terminal device located in a local communication network. A transmitter and receiver are provided for sending signalling establishing a secure tunnel between the terminal device and the gateway node, and the IP address is arranged to be used as both an inner and an outer IP address in the secure tunnel.
The gateway node is optionally arranged to be disposed between a fixed line network and a regional network, wherein the regional network is operatively connected to an Enhanced Packet Core network and the fixed line network is operatively connected to the local communication network.
The gateway node is optionally provided with a memory for storing a shared secret, the shared secret known also to the terminal device, and a processor for using the shared secret to authenticate the terminal device with the gateway node prior to establishing the secure tunnel.
According to a third aspect, there is provided a terminal device for use in a communication network. The terminal device is provided with a receiver for receiving an IP address allocated by a gateway node, the IP address identifying the terminal device. A protocol driver function is provided for obtaining the allocated IP address and establishing a secure tunnel between the terminal device and the gateway node, by using the same credentials for authentication in order to both obtain the allocated IP address and establish the secure tunnel. A processor is arranged to generate an IP packet for sending via the secure tunnel, and the IP packet uses the allocated IP address as both the inner and the outer IP address. A transmitter is also provided for sending the generated IP packet via the secure tunnel. Optionally, the terminal device is a 3GPP User Equipment.
As an option, the terminal device is provided with a security policy database, which includes a list of IP addresses and an indication for each IP address whether data packets addressed to that IP address are to be sent via the secure tunnel or within the local communication network. The terminal device is optionally provided with a memory for storing a shared secret. The shared secret is also known to the gateway node, and a processor is provided for using the shared secret to authenticate the gateway node with the terminal device prior to establishing the secure tunnel.
Referring to
Access Node (AN) 11 in a DSL network 12. The AN 11 can in turn interact with a Broadcast Network Gateway (BNG) 4 in a Regional Network 13. The BNG 4 can communicate with a Packet Data Network Gateway (PDN-GW) 14 via an S2a interface. The PDN-GW 14 in the Evolved Packet Core (EPC) Network 15 communicates with a database including an EPC IP Address Pool, and indirectly with an AAA server 17 or Home Subscriber Server (HSS). An IPsec tunnel 3 is established between the 3GPP UE 1 and the BNG 4 in order to protect the global communications, and in order to address the multi-homed problem described above, the same IP address is used for both the inner and outer IP address of the IPsec tunnel 3. This requires that the 3GPP UE 1 and the BNG 4 cooperate to associate the IP address allocation session for the outer IP address (e.g. DHCP, DHCPv6) with that for the inner IP address (e.g. IKEv2) in a secure manner.
The IP address used by the 3GPP UE 1 and the IP address used any non-3GPP UEs 6 are from different IP address ranges. This scenario is herein termed a “multi-subnet” scenario. In a multi-subnet scenario, local communication is possible by an extension to the RGW 5. The RGW 5 is aware of the presence of the 3GPP UE 1 and maintains a host route. When the non-3GPP UE 6 sends an IP packet to the 3GPP UE 1, the IP packet is forwarded by the RGW 5 to the 3GPP UE. The RGW 5 also forwards IP packets from the 3GPP UE 1 to the non-3GPP UE 6. In this way, local communication between the 3GPP UE 1 and non-3GPP UE 5 is kept within the RN 2.
The IPsec tunnel 3 is established between the 3GPP UE 1 and the BNG 4 in the same way as the scenario illustrated in
By using the same IP address for both the inner and outer IP addresses, the multi-homed problem described above is addressed. Address selections by the OS and applications are properly performed because the 3GPP UE 1 is allocated a single proper IP address and can't then select an improper IP address. The 3GPP UE 1 need not implement any software, API, or functionalities to solve the multi-homed issues.
B establishing the IPsec tunnel 3 between the 3GPP UE 1 and the BNG 4, the security issue described above is addressed. The IPsec tunnel 3 mitigates most of the risk of a man-in-the-middle attack between the 3GPP UE 1 and the BNG 4.
By providing the 3GPP UE 1 with the same inner and outer IP address, and establishing an IPsec tunnel 3 between the 3GPP UE 1 and the BNG 4, the problems described above are addressed, but a new issue arises. The 3GPP UE 1 must now distinguish between two types of IP packets; packets for global communications that should be tunnelled via the IPsec tunnel 3, and packets for local communications that should not be tunnelled. The solution for this issue is described below.
Turning now to
DHCP-Auth can be used as a protocol for enabling authentication of the 3GPP UE 1 with the EPC network 15. DHCP-Auth is an extension to DHCP that enables authentication of a DHCP client in conjunction with IP address configuration. However, other authentication protocols such as 802.1x and PANA (see “Protocol for Carrying Authentication for Network Access (PANA)”, IETF RFC5191, 2008-05) may be used instead. Assuming that IP address configuration is performed by DHCP, the BNG 4 serves as a DHCP Server. IKEv2 is used by the 3GPP UE 1 and BNG 4 to establish the IPsec 3 tunnel. The BNG 4 behaves as a server (Security Gateway) and the 3GPP UE 1 behaves as a client. During the authentication phase (IKE_AUTH), the client requests allocation of an inner IP address by using Configuration Payload (CFG_REQUEST). The BNG 4 being a Security Gateway refers to an internal database in which an EPC IP address assigned to the 3GPP UE 1 is stored. Note that the internal database is also accessible by the DHCP Server component. The BNG (Security Gateway) 4 sends a response message along with the inner IP address (CFG_REPLY). Accordingly, an IPsec security association is established between the 3GPP UE 1 and the BNG 4. In this way, IP address allocation for the 3GPP UE can be done by the DHCP Server and IKEv2 Security Gateway in a synchronized manner, i.e., the same IP address (EPC IP address) is allocated to the 3GPP UE.
There are at least two ways of authentication for the IKEv2 session, which is denoted as “IKEv2 authentication” in
EAP/AKA (see “Extensible Authentication Protocol Method for 3rd Generation Authentication and Key Agreement (EAP-AKA)”, IETF RFC4187, 2006-01). Using EAP/AKA ensures that the EAP identifier of the 3GPP UE 1 is identical in both the DHCP session and the 3GPP session, and so the BNG 4 can confirm the association of the DHCP and IKEv2 session in secure manner provided that the source IP address of the IKEv2 session and the IP address assigned by the DHCP are the same, and the EAP identifier of the DHCP session and the IKEv2 session are the same.
This implies that two AKA sessions run simultaneously between the 3GPP UE (USIM) 1 and the AAA Server (HSS) 17, and so both the 3GPP UE 1 and the AAA Server 17 must handle two simultaneous AKA sessions for a single IMSI independently (e.g. fast re-authentication, authentication vector, sequence number etc).
EAP Key Management Framework (see “Extensible Authentication Protocol (EAP) Key Management Framework”, IETF RFC5247, 2008-08) enables the EAP backend authentication server (the AAA Server 17 in the example of
The invention provides for dynamic configuration of a Security Policy Database (SPD) for enabling local communications within the RN 2. The SPD at the 3GPP UE 1 is dynamically configured based on IPv4 ICMP messages or IPv6 router advertisement messages sent by the RGW 5. Note that a SPD on the BNG 4 is also configured, which is a normal behaviour for an IPsec Security Gateway.
The IPsec tunnel 3 does not itself need to be tunnelled, and so traffic between 200.0.0.2 (the 3GPP UE 1) and 1.2.3.4 (the BNG 4) is marked as ‘BYPASS’ on both IPsec SPDs shown in the tables in
Uplink packets for global communications are identified by source IP address 200.0.0.2 in the IPsec SPD of the 3GPP UE 1 and downlink packets for global communications are identified by a destination IP address 200.0.0.2 in the IPsec SPD of the BNG 4, and so this traffic is marked as ‘PROTECT’ which indicates that IPsec protection of the traffic is required.
IP packets for local communications (e.g., UPnP communication between the 3GPP UE 1 and the non-3GPP UE 6) do not need to be tunnelled, and so are marked as ‘BYPASS’ in the IPsec SPD of the 3GPP UE 1. As shown in
For IPv4, the 3GPP UE 1 gets to know the network prefix of the RN 2 by using ICMP Address Mask Request/Reply (see “Internet Standard Subnetting Procedure”, IETF RFC950, 1985-08) without having a local IP address assigned. The 3GPP UE 1 sends an ICMP Address Mask Request message to the broadcast address 255.255.255.255 from the unspecified source address (0.0.0.0), and the RGW 5 responds with the subnet mask in the payload and its IP address in the source IP address of the IP header. The 3GPP UE 1 then adds a new IPsec SPD entry for the network prefix of the Residential Network.
For IPv6, the 3GPP UE 1 sends a Router Solicitation message to the RGW 5 and receives a Router Advertisement message from the RGW 5 that contains the IPv6 prefix(es) assigned to the RN 2. When the 3GPP UE 1 receives a Router Advertisement message, it does not perform IP address auto-configuration based on the Router Advertisement message. Note that the 3GPP UE 1 updates its IPsec SPD according to the Router Advertisement message in order to make local communications work. The 3GPP UE 1 extracts the IPv6 prefix(es) from the Prefix Information option in the Router Advertisement message and inserts a new SPD entry, which suggest exceptional packet processing for user traffic inside the RN 2. In this way, the 3GPP UE 1 can take part in local communications.
S1. The BNG allocates an EPC IP address to the 3GPP UE;
S2. The 3GPP UE initiates IKEv2 to establish the IPsec tunnel with the BNG;
S3. During establishing the IPsec tunnel by IKEv2, the BNG identifies the initiator of IKEv2 as the 3GPP UE to which the EPC IP address is allocated in 51;
S4. During establishing the IPsec tunnel by IKEv2, the BNG allocates the same EPC IP address to the initiator of IKEv2 for the inner IP address of the IPsec tunnel if the initiator of IKEv2 is identified as the 3GPP UE to which the EPC IP address is allocated in S1;
S5. The IPsec tunnel is established between the 3GPP UE and the BNG. The allocated EPC IP address is used for both the inner and outer IP address of the IPsec tunnel;
S6. The 3GPP UE configures the SPD of the IPsec tunnel for local communications by using IPv4 ICMP and IPv6 router advertisement.
The steps need not be carried out in the order shown above.
Turning now to
With reference to
IPsec tunnel 3, the IP packet using the allocated IP address as both the inner and the outer IP address, and a transmitter 26 is provided for sending the generated IP packet via the IPsec tunnel 3. The 3GPP UE 1 may also comprise a SDB 27, as described above. A memory 28 may also be provided for storing a shared secret to be used in authentication processes between the 3GPP UE 1 and the BNG 4.
This invention allows 3GPP UE users to access 3GPP mobile networks and services via a fixed broadband access networks in such a way that applications running on the 3GPP UE do not need to deal with IP address selection, the risk of man-in-the-middle attacks is reduced, and no additional complexity is required for RGWs to residential networks.
The following abbreviations have been used in this description:
3GPP UE 3GPP User Equipment
AN Access Node
BNG Broadband Network Gateway
DSL Digital Subscriber Line
EPC Enhanced Packet Core
ePDG Evolved Packet Data Gateway
FMC Fixed Mobile Convergence
MAG Mobile Access Gateway
PDN Packet Data Network
RGW Residential Gateway
RN Residential Network
SPD Security Policy Database
It will be appreciated by the person of skill in the art that various modifications may be made to the above-described embodiments without departing from the scope of the present invention.
Filing Document | Filing Date | Country | Kind | 371c Date |
---|---|---|---|---|
PCT/EP08/63890 | 10/15/2008 | WO | 00 | 4/14/2011 |