Patent Grant
11264715
The present invention relates to phased-arrays, and more particularly to calibration of phased-arrays.
Phased array systems have been widely used in radar and astronomy applications. The synthetic aperture provided by a phased-array system enables fast beam scanning when used in a radar system. When used in a radio telescope, a phased-array provides a relatively large receiving aperture.
Conventional systems for calibrating a phased-array rely on matching the length of the transmission lines that distribute the RF signal and the phase shift introduced by the RF components such as phase shifters, mixers, amplifiers, and the like. Due to process variation, temperature fluctuations, impedance mismatch of antenna feeds, coupling between antennas, and the like, the radiated phase from each antenna in the phased-array system will be different than what is intended if such effects are not taken into account.
One conventional system for calibrating the phase settings of the array elements relies on placing a probe either in the near field or far field of a phased-array to calibrate the phase settings. Such systems not only require the extra probe, but require the exact location of the extra probe to be known for calibration thus rendering the system more complicated.
Another conventional system for calibrating the phase settings of the array elements uses couplers or (transmitter/receiver) T/R switches to couple the outgoing power from the antenna to a calibration path. Such systems not only require a separate calibration path but also make the implicit assumption that the calibration paths themselves do not require calibration. The limitations on existing calibration methods for phased arrays have further prevented their adoption in systems where the array elements change their relative positions and timing.
A self-calibrating phased-array, in accordance with one embodiment of the present invention, includes, in part, N transceivers each including a receiver and a transmitter, N being an integer greater than 1, and a controller. The phased-array is configured to transmit a first radio signal from a first element of the array during a first time period, receive the first radio signal from a second element of the array during the first time period, recover a first value associated with the radio signal received by the second element, transmit a second radio signal from the second element of the array during a second time period, receive the second radio signal from the first element of the array during the second time period, recover a second value associated with the radio signal received by the first element, and determine a first phase of a reference signal received by the second element from the recovered first and second values. The first phase is relative to a second phase of the reference signal received by the first element.
In one embodiment, the first value represents a phase. In another embodiment, the first value represents a timing data. In one embodiment, the first phase is defined by one half of a difference between the recovered first and second values. In one embodiment, the phased-array is further configured to determine a phase delay across a transmit path of each of the first and second elements. In one embodiment, the phased-array is further configured to determine a phase delay across a receive path of each of the first and second elements. In one embodiment, the first and second radio signals are modulated.
In one embodiment, the phased-array is further configured to determine a distance between the first and two elements. In one embodiment, the first element is disposed in a first device different from a second device in which the second element is disposed. In one embodiment, the phased-array is an ad-hoc phased-array formed between the first and second devices. In one embodiment, at least one of the first or second devices may be a drone, an airplane, a vehicle, a cell phone, or a satellite. In one embodiment, the controller and phased array are formed in the same semiconductor substrate. In another embodiment, the controller and phased array are formed on different semiconductor substrates.
A self-calibrating phased-array, in accordance with one embodiment of the present invention, includes, in part, N transceivers each including a receiver and a transmitter, N being an integer greater than 1, and a controller. The phased-array is configured to transmit from each element i of the array during an ith time period an ith radio signal, wherein i is an integer ranging from 1 to N, receive the ith radio signal at each of at least of a subset of the remaining elements of the array during the ith time period, recover delay values associated with the radio signals received by the at least first subset, and determine a phase of a reference signal received by each of the at least first subset from the recovered delay values. The phase being relative to a reference phase of a reference clock as received by the ith element of the array.
In one embodiment, the delay values represent phase shifts. In one embodiment, the delay values represent timing data. In one embodiment, the phase of the reference signal received by jth element of the array is defined by one half of a difference between a delay value recovered by the (i+1)th element in response to transmission of the ith radio signal from the ith element and a delay value recovered by the ith element in response to transmission of the ith radio signal by the jth element, where i and j are integers ranging from 1 to N.
In one embodiment, the phased-array is further configured to determine a phase delay across each of a transmit and receive path of the array elements in accordance with the recovered delay values and further in accordance with one or more initial values. In one embodiment, the phased-array is further configured to determine a phase delay across each of a transmit and receive path of the array elements in accordance with the recovered delay values and further in accordance with one or more known relationships between the phased array elements.
In one embodiment, the initial values represent known values associated with the phased array. In one embodiment, the initial values are obtained from computer simulation. In one embodiment, the first and second radio signals are modulated. In one embodiment, the phased-array is further configured to determine a distance between the array elements.
In one embodiment, a first group of the N elements are disposed in a first device different from a second device in which the second group of the N element are disposed. In one embodiment, the phased-array is an ad-hoc phased-array formed between the first and second devices. In one embodiment, at least one of the first or second devices may be a drone, an airplane, a vehicle, a cell phone, or a satellite.
In one embodiment, the phased-array is further configured to determine a phase delay across each of a transmit and receive path of the array elements in accordance with the recovered delay values and further in accordance with one or more known relationships between the phased array elements
In one embodiment, the known relationship represents temperature variation relationships. In one embodiment, the known relationships represents process variation relationships. In one embodiment, the phased-array is further configured to determine a phase delay across each of transmit and receive paths using quadratic minimization to minimize deviation between the determined values and the initial values.
In one embodiment, the phased-array is further configured to trilaterate to further determine distances between the array elements. In one embodiment, the phased-array is further configured to determine the phases of the reference signal while at least a multitude of the array elements are in motion. In one embodiment, the phased-array is further configured to use the distances between the array elements to generate a flexible or conformal phased array. In one embodiment, the controller and phased array are formed in the same semiconductor substrate. In another embodiment, the controller and phased array are formed on different semiconductor substrates.
A method of calibrating a phased-array that includes N transceivers each having a receiver and a transmitter, and where N is an integer greater than 1, includes, in part, transmitting a first radio signal from a first element of the array during a first time period, receiving the first radio signal from a second element of the array during the first time period, recovering a first value associated with the radio signal received by the second element, transmitting a second radio signal from the second element of the array during a second time period, receiving the second radio signal from the first element of the array during the second time period, recovering a second value associated with the radio signal received by the first element, and determining a first phase of a reference signal received by the second element from the recovered first and second values. The first phase is relative to a second phase of the reference signal received by the first element.
In one embodiment, the first value represents a phase. In one embodiment, the first value represents timing data. In one embodiment, the first phase is defined by one half of a difference between the recovered first and second values.
In one embodiment, the method further includes, in part, determining a phase delay across a transmit path of each of the first and second elements. In one embodiment, the method further includes, in part, determining a phase delay across a receive path of each of the first and second elements. In one embodiment, the first and second radio signals are modulated.
In one embodiment, the method further includes, in part, determining a distance between the first and second elements. In one embodiment, the first element is disposed in a first device different from a second device in which the second element is disposed. In one embodiment, the method further includes, in part, forming the phased-array between the first and second devices on the fly. In one embodiment, at least one of the first or second devices may be a drone, an airplane, a vehicle, a cell phone, or a satellite.
A method of calibrating a phased-array that includes N transceivers each having a receiver and a transmitter, and where N is an integer greater than 1, includes, in part, transmitting from each element i of the array during an ith time period an ith radio signal, wherein i is an integer ranging from 1 to N, receiving the ith radio signal at each of at least a subset of remaining elements of the array during the ith time period, recovering delay values associated with the radio signals received by the at least first subset, and determining a phase of a reference signal received by each of the at least first subset from the recovered delay values, said phase being relative to a reference phase of a reference clock as received by the ith element of the array.
In one embodiment, the delay values represent phase shifts. In one embodiment, the delay values represent timing data. In one embodiment, the phase of the reference signal received by jth element of the array is defined by one half of a difference between a delay value recovered by the jth element in response to transmission of the ith radio signal from the ith element and a delay value recovered by the ith element in response to transmission of the ith radio signal by the ith element.
In one embodiment, the method further includes, in part, determining a phase delay across each of a transmit and receive path of the array elements in accordance with the recovered delay values and further in accordance with one or more initial values. In one embodiment, the method further includes, in part, determining a phase delay across each of a transmit and receive path of the array elements in accordance with the recovered delay values and further in accordance with one or more known relationships between the phased array elements.
In one embodiment, the initial values represent known values associated with the phased array. In one embodiment, the initial values are obtained from computer simulation. In one embodiment, the first and second radio signals are modulated. In one embodiment, the method further includes, in part, determining a distance between the array elements. In one embodiment, a first group of the N elements is disposed in a first device different from a second device in which the second group of the N element is disposed.
In one embodiment, the method further includes, in part, forming the phased-array between the first and second devices on the fly. In one embodiment, at least one of the first or second devices may be a drone, an airplane, a vehicle, or a cell phone. In one embodiment, the known relationship represents temperature variation relationship. In one embodiment, the known relationship represents process variation relationship. In one embodiment, the known relationship represents voltage variation relationship.
In one embodiment, the method further includes, in part, determining a phase delay across each of transmit and receive paths using quadratic minimization to minimize deviation between the determined values and the initial values. In one embodiment, the method further includes, in part, performing trilateration to further determine distances between the array elements. In one embodiment, the method further includes, in part, determining the phases of the reference signal while at least a multitude of the array elements are in motion. In one embodiment, the method further includes, in part, using the distances between the array elements to generate a flexible or conformal phased array.
In accordance with one embodiment of the present invention, a phased-array includes a built-in controller configured to calibrate the phase, timing, and position of the array elements without using any extra calibration paths. The following description of the present invention is provided with reference to a phased-array each element of which includes a transmitter and a receiver operating at a frequency synchronized to a reference signal. It is understood that the reference signal may be at the same frequency or at a frequency different from the frequency at which the transmitter/receiver (transceiver) operates.
Although the following description of the present invention is provided with reference to phase delay calibration, it is understood that the embodiments of the present invention are equally applicable to time delay calibration. Because of phase wrapping, a phase shift of, e.g., 45° is indistinguishable from a phase shift of e.g., (45°+360°). For example, assume a pair of transceivers (elements) of a phased array both of which transmit a carrier signal at a phase of π/2 relative to a reference phase. However, the second transceiver may lag an entire cycle behind the first transceiver, meaning it is actually transmitting at 5π/2 relative the reference. Therefore, while the pair of elements are phase delay matched, they are not time delay matched. Embodiments of the present invention are adapted to calibrate for phase delay, timing delay as well as positions of the array elements.
Embodiments of the present invention further measure and hence take into account and calibrate the degree of phase shift that occurs in distributing the reference signal. In the following description it is assumed that the reference signal is at the same frequency as the signal used to operate the transmitter and receiver disposed in each array element. It is understood, however, that the reference signal may be at a frequency different from the frequency at which the phased array transmitter/receiver elements operate.
For example, element 501 is shown as including a transmitter 101, a PA 121, an optional duplexer 141, a transmit/receive antenna 161 and a receiver with a phase recovery unit 201. Likewise, element 50N is shown as including a transmitter 10N, a PA 12N, a duplexer 14N, a transmit/receive antenna 16N and a receiver with a phase recovery unit 20N. Embodiments of the phased array in which PAs 12i are adapted to be turned on and off may not include duplexers 14i. Furthermore, although phased array 100 is shown having a one-dimensional array of elements, it is understood that a phased array, in accordance with embodiments of the present invention, may have a two-dimensional or three-dimensional array of elements.
As shown in
In the embodiment shown in
The signal received by antenna 16i of element 50i is represented by θi. For example, the phase of the signal received by antenna 161 is assumed be θi; the phase of the signal received by antenna 162 is assumed be θ2; and the phase of the signal received by antenna 16N is assumed be θN. Since receiver 20i of element 50i uses Φi as a reference phase to recover the phase of the signal it receives via its associated antenna 16i, receiver 16, recovers a phase defined by Ωi=θi−Φi. Therefore, for example, the phase of the signal recovered by receiver 201 is represented by Ωi=θ1−Φ1; and the phase of the signal recovered by, for example, by receiver 202 is represented by Ω2=θ2−Φ2.
To calibrate phased array 100, in accordance with one embodiment of the present invention, controller 200 turns off all but one of the transmitters 10i. In the following description it is assumed that controller 200 turns off all transmitters except transmitter 101. It is understood however that to perform calibration, in accordance with embodiments of the present invention, controller 200 may turn off all but any of the other transmitters, such as 102 or 103. As described above, for the embodiment shown in
After turning on, e.g., transmitter 101, and turning off the remaining (N−1) transmitters, the receiver of each of the remaining (N−1) elements in the array recovers the phase of the signal transmitted by, in this example, transmitter 101. In the following, the first index used with any of the parameters Ω. ν. Φ refers to the corresponding element number in the array receiving a signal and the second index represents the element number in the array that transmits the signal so received. For example, the phase of the signal transmitted by element 501 (via its associated antenna 161) as recovered by element 502 (via its associated receiver 202) is represented by Ω21. Similarly, the phase of the signal recovered by element 50j due to transmission of this signal by element 501 is represented by Ωj1. In general, the phase of the signal recovered by element 50m due to transmission of this signal by element 50n is represented by Ωmn, where m and n are integers ranging from 1 to N for the embodiment shown in
As was described above, the phase of the signal transmitted by antenna 161 is assumed to be the same as the phase of the reference clock signal CLK received by element 501 in which antenna 161 is disposed. As described above, the phase of the signal transmitted by antenna 161 and received by antenna 162 is represented by θ21. Phase θ21 relative to the phase of the signal as it is transmitted by antenna 161, namely Φ1, may be defined as:
θ21=Φ1−ΔΦ21 (1)
where ΔΦ21 represents the degree of phase shift that the signal transmitted by antenna 161 experiences as it travels from antenna 161 to antenna 162.
The phase of the signal recovered by receiver 202 is defined by a difference between the signal received by antenna 162 and the phase of the reference clock CLK as received by element 502. Therefore, the phase of the signal recovered by receiver 202 may be defined as:
Ω21=θ21−Φ2 (2)
Substituting for θ21 in equation (2) as it is defined in equation (1), Ω21 may be defined as:
Ω21=Φ1−ΔΦ21−Φ2 (3)
In a similar manner, the phase of the signal transmitted by antenna 161 and received by antenna 16N is represented by θN1. Phase θN1 relative to the phase of the signal as it is transmitted by antenna 161, namely Φ1, may be defined as:
θN1=Φ1−ΔΦN1 (4)
where ΔΦN1 represents the degree of phase shift that the signal transmitted by antenna 161 experiences as it travels from antenna 161 to antenna 16N.
The phase of the signal recovered by receiver 20N is defined by a difference between the phase of the signal received by antenna 16N and the phase of the reference clock CLK as received by element 50N. Therefore, the phase of the signal recovered by receiver 20N may be defined as:
ΩN1=θN1−ΦN (5)
Substituting for θN1 in equation (5) as it is defined in equation (4), ΩN1 may be defined as:
ΩN1=Φ1−ΔΦN1−ΦN (6)
Embodiments of the present invention use the principle of reciprocity of electromagnetic waves which require that the phase shift incurred by a wave propagating in a forward direction be equal to the phase shift incurred by the wave propagating in a reverse (backward) direction. Therefore, with reference to
As described above, the phase of the signal recovered by element i of the phased-array due to transmission from element 1 of the phased-array may be defined as:
Ωi1=Φ1−ΔΦi1−Φi (7)
Similarly, the phase of the signal recovered by element 1 of the phased-array due to transmission from element i of the phased-array may be defined as:
Ω1i=Φi−ΔΦ1i−Φ1 (8)
Because ΔΦ1i=ΔΦi1 as described above, by subtracting equation (7) from (8) and dividing the results by two, the following result is achieved:
Φi−Φ1=½(Ω1i−Φi1) (9)
The propagation phase delay from element 1 to element i may be defined as:
ΔΦi1=½(Ω1i+Ωi1) (10)
Therefore, in accordance with one embodiment of the present invention, by recovering the phase of the signal received by element i of the phased array due to transmission from any of the other elements, e.g., element j of the array, recovering the phase of the signal received by element j of the array due to transmission from element i of the array, and subtracting the phase recovered by element i from the phase recovered by element j, the difference between the phase of the reference clock signal as received by element i relative to the phase of the reference clock signal as received by element j, is obtained, as shown in equation (9).
In accordance with another embodiment of the present invention to further increase diversity and accuracy, at any given time period, signal transmission is performed by one of the N elements of the array (element j) and received at remaining (N−1) elements of the array. The phase of the signal received by each or a subset of the remaining (N−1) elements is then recovered by the element's associated receiver. For element i of the array, the recovered (or measured) phase is represented by Ωij (which is measured relative to the phase of their local reference clock).
Next, the transmitter associated with element i is turned off and one of the remaining (N−1) elements (e.g., element j+1) is turned on to transmit a radio signal. The phase of the transmitted signal is recovered by each or a subset of the remaining (N−1) elements. For element i of the array, the recovered (or alternatively referred to measured, determined or detected) phase is represented by Ωi(j+1) which is measured relative to the phase of element i′s local reference clock Φi.
This process continues until each element (e.g., element m) of the array recovers (also referred to as determined or detected) the phase of the signal transmitted by another element (e.g., element n) of the array. The phase offset between the clock signals arriving at elements m and n of the array, namely Φm−Φn is defined by the following: (as also described above)
Φm−Φn=½(Ωnm−Ωmn) (11)
In the embodiments described above, it is assumed that no phase errors/uncertainties exit in the transmitter and the receiver and as such the controller calibrates for phase delays in the reference clock signal distribution network. However, embodiments of the present invention can also calibrate for phase errors/uncertainties in the transmit and receive paths.
The phased-array shown in
Performing the same analysis as above, it is seen with these additional unknown delays, the phase recovered by, for example, receiver 202 due to transmission by, for example, antenna 16i may be represented as:
Ω21=Φ1−ΔΦTX1−ΔΦ21−ΔΦRX2−Φ2 (12)
In a similar manner, the phase recovered by receiver 20N due to transmission by antenna 161 may be represented by the following:
ΩN1=Φ1−ΔΦTX1−ΔΦN1−ΔΦRXN−ΦN (13)
Assuming that Φ1 is known, it is thus seen that the number of unknowns in the system is the sum of (i) three times the number of elements minus one (since Φ1 is assumed to be known) in which the 3 unknowns are Φi, ΔΦTXi, ΔΦRXi, and (ii) the number of ΔΦijs which is equal to N(N−1)/2 (Divide by two is due to the fact that ΔΦij=ΔΦji). Hence the total number of unknowns is:
The number of equations that can be formed is equal to number of Ωijs which is equal to N2. However, not all of these equations are linearly independent. Embodiments of the present invention provide additional techniques to solve all the unknowns. In one embodiment, to solve for internal transceiver delays, the Ωii measurements (referred to herein as self-loop measurements according to which the receiver of a unit i recovers the phase of the signal transmitted by unit i) are used, as shown below:
Ωii=(Φi+ΔΦTXi)−(Φi+ΔΦRXi)≤ΔΦTXi−ΔΦRXi (14)
By using Ωii, Ωjj, Ωij, and Ωji, it is seen that in accordance with the embodiments of the present invention described above, controller 100 can solve and determine the values of all ΔΦijs in the system. Embodiments of the present invention provide a number of techniques to solve the other unknowns, namely Φi, ΔΦTXi, ΔΦRXi.
In accordance with first such technique, embodiments of the present invention solve for the remaining unknowns (Φi, ΔΦTXi, ΔΦRXi) by predicting the value of any one of these unknowns. In one embodiment, the predicted values may be obtained from simulated or previously measured values.
For example, an integrated circuit transceiver phased array may include temperature, process and voltage variation compensation circuitry in its receive paths. Such compensation circuitry is adapted to account for phase delay variation in the receive path and thus ensures that ΔΦRXi=τ for all elements i. Using the self-loop measurement, the A ΔΦTXi values can thus be determined as shown below:
ΔΦTXi=Ωii+ΔΦRXi=Ωii+τ (14)
With the internal delays, ΔΦTXi and ΔΦRXi, known, as shown above, parameters Φis may be determined using the same approach as described above with reference to the transceiver shown in
In accordance with a second technique, embodiments of the present invention determine the remaining unknowns by using a non-measured linear or nonlinear equations to perform the calibration, as described further below.
If an integrated circuit transceiver phased array does not include compensation circuitry in its receive paths, parameters ΔΦTXi and ΔΦRXi, may change significantly with process and temperature variations. However, the changes in the transmit and receive path delays are strongly correlated. In such embodiments, a circuit simulation software such as SPICE may be used to determine the relationship between the delays in the transmit and receive paths of the same transceiver element. Assume that using the simulation, it is determined that the delay across the receive path of element i, namely ΔΦRXi, is related to the delay across the delay across the transmit path of element i, namely ΔΦTXi by a constant, α, as shown below:
ΔΦRXi=α*ΔΦTXi (16)
By using the self-loop measurement, as described above, together with equation (14) and description above, the internal delays may be determined as shown further below:
ΔΦTXi=Ωii+ΔΦRXi=Ωii+α*ΔΦTXi=Ωii/1−α (17)
ΔΦRXi=α*Ωii/1−α (18)
Once the internal delays are known, as described above, the remaining unknown Φis parameters may be found, as described above. Such a technique may be used with any non-measured equation (such as equation 16) relating unknowns that is independent from the existing linear equations from the measurements.
In accordance with a third such technique, a mathematical optimization is used to estimate the solution rather than adding equations to reach a single exact solution. Even with no additional calibration circuitry, compensation circuitry or analytical relationships, an accurate estimate of the solution may be found using optimization. A simple implementation using quadratic minimization is demonstrated in the following simulated example. The example shown below calibrates the time delay of the array rather than the phase delay. It is understood that the embodiments of the present invention and the techniques described herein are equally applicable to time, phase and distance calibration.
Assume that the array to be calibrated is a four element transceiver array, i.e., N in
It is seen that Φ1=0 in Table I, indicating that the phase of signal CLK at the input of the first elements of the array is used as a reference phase and that the all delays determined by the calibration are relative to Φ1. It is understood however that the phase at any other element Φi may be used as a reference phase. Using the predicted values and the system of equations from the Φij measurements, a quadratic minimization is performed. The following Table II summarizes the calibrated values as determined in accordance with embodiments of the present invention.
While the calibrated values are not the same as exact actual values, they are accurate when compared to the uncalibrated predicted values. In generating
Although the above embodiments of the present invention are described with reference to phase calibration, it is understood that the embodiments of the present invention apply equally to timing calibration when the phase unit is replaced with a time unit. A time delay may be measured by modulating the reference signal and sending frequency modulated continuous wave (FMCW) signals similar to those used in radar.
In addition to calibrating internal and reference delays, time delay calibration, in accordance with embodiments of the present invention, may be used to determine the relative distances between the elements of a phased array. To achieve this, the propagation times between elements (ΔΦijs) is converted to distance knowing the propagation speed of the signal, which is the speed of light when the radio signals travel though free space. The distance between elements i and j is thus defined by v*ΔΦij. With relative distances between elements known, trilateration can be used to determine relative position of all the elements in the array.
Position calibration enables the formation of dynamic phased arrays where the timing and position of transceivers (i.e., phased array elements) are changing. Mechanically flexible and conformal arrays are an example of dynamic phased arrays. These arrays may deform thus resulting in changes in the relative positions of their elements. The changes in position may be dynamically determined by the calibrating techniques, described above in accordance with embodiments of the present invention. Furthermore, because the calibration of phase/time/position in accordance with embodiments of the present invention is performed dynamically and at relatively high speeds, the array elements continue to stay calibrated as the array deforms and its elements move.
Moreover, because the calibration of phase/time/position in accordance with embodiments of the present invention is performed dynamically and with high speed, embodiments of the present invention may be used to form a phased array with transceiver elements that are spread across multiple flying/moving vehicles/objects. For example, a multitude of drones carrying transceivers and locked to the same reference may form a dynamic phased array, in accordance with embodiments of the present invention, when the timing and position of the drones' transceivers are calibrated in flight. Similarly, a dynamic phased array, in accordance with embodiments of the present invention, is formed between transceivers located in groups of independently flying spacecraft and/or airplanes.
Therefore, any set of transceivers that can use a shared reference signal may be calibrated together, in accordance with embodiments of the present invention, to form a dynamic phased array. This enables the formation of an ad-hoc phased array having transceivers disposed on difference devices (personal electronics, vehicles, etc.) that fall within a given range. In other words, embodiments of the present invention enable the formation of an ad-hoc dynamic phased-array on-the-fly between transceivers disposed on different devices, for example, between two cell phones, or two vehicles, or between a cell phone and a drone.
The above embodiments of the present invention are illustrative and not limitative. The embodiments of the present invention are not limited by the number of transmitting elements or receiving elements. The above embodiments of the present invention are not limited by the wavelength or frequency of the signal. The above embodiments of the present invention are not limited by the type of circuitry used to detect the phase of a received signal. The above embodiments of the present invention are not limited by the number of semiconductor substrates that may be used to form a phased array. Other modifications and variations will be apparent to those skilled in the art and are intended to fall within the scope of the appended claims.
The present application claims benefit under 35 USC 119(e) of Application Ser. No. 62/514,319 filed Jun. 2, 2017, the content of which is incorporated herein by reference in its entirety.
| Number | Name | Date | Kind |
|---|---|---|---|
| 5412414 | Ast | May 1995 | A |
| 20010005685 | Nishimori | Jun 2001 | A1 |
| 20070099627 | Kofol | May 2007 | A1 |
| 20100315045 | Zeine | Dec 2010 | A1 |
| 20140167704 | Lafontaine et al. | Jun 2014 | A1 |
| 20140242914 | Monroe | Aug 2014 | A1 |
| 20190219619 | Walker et al. | Jul 2019 | A1 |
| Entry |
|---|
| U.S. Appl. No. 16/042,619, Non-Final Office Action dated Jul. 20, 2020. |
| Number | Date | Country | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 20190140349 A1 | May 2019 | US |
| Number | Date | Country | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 62514319 | Jun 2017 | US |
