This field of this disclosure relates generally to medical biopsy systems.
Although current image-guided needle biopsies are generally adequate for the collection of material for conventional histopathological analysis, gathering tissue for the detailed molecular analysis needed to truly optimize cancer treatment can be difficult. This is because ultrasound and x-ray images give virtually no information on local tissue chemistry, and even advanced magnetic resonance imaging—despite fabulously expensive equipment—have only limited chemical characterization capabilities. Thus the acquisition of samples with high concentrations of viable tumor cells—extremely important for the accurate biomolecular analysis and characterization of neoplastic tissue—is a hit-or-miss process for biopsies guided in these ways. Adding biochemical sensitivity to the biopsy needle can give the practitioner immediate feedback on the metabolism and physiology of tissue in the local environment, information that can be related to tumor activity. For example, tumor oxygenation has been tentatively shown to be predictive of response to chemotherapy, low pH is associated with rapid tumor growth, and pathophysiologic lactate accumulation is characteristic of solid tumors and has been associated with metastases and poor overall survival in cancer patients. Oxygenation, pH, and lactate levels monitoring enable monitoring tissue metabolism, and in particular glycolysis. It has been observed that most if not all cancer cells, even those in normotic tumors, produce energy by glycolysis (Warburg-like effect) The glycolytic metabolism of cancer was underappreciated for almost a century until the recent recognition of the fundamental role of glycolysis in cancer growth and progression. This has led the scientific community to adopt differential tumor metabolism as an additional hallmark of cancer
Early detection of cancer greatly increases the chances for successful treatment. Approximately 8 million suspicious lesions per annum are discovered by initial screening in the US. Of these, physicians select approximately 1.3 million for biopsy. Breast cancer biopsies in the U.S. average approximately $2,620 per patient, which includes appropriate weighting factors for the number of surgical and core needle procedures performed. The combination of these figures gives a clear view of the significance of continuous developing of advanced biopsy techniques, and the potential market.
Disclosed is a system which adds biochemical sensitivity to a standard biopsy needle such that the practitioner is provided immediate feedback on the metabolism and physiology of tissue in the local environment.
Disclosed is a sensor integrated biopsy device for in situ and real time tissue analysis. The sensor integrated biopsy (SIB) needle system will enable biopsy teams to measure local tissue biochemistry in real time during biopsy procedures, adding a valuable new set of parameters to augment and extend conventional image-guided procedures.
Disclosed is a system which can monitor and quantify in real time glycolysis (Warburg-like effect) during a biopsy procedure, even in normotic tumors. It has been observed that most, if not all, cancer cells, even those in normotic tumors, produce energy by glycolysis. This feature differentiates aspects of the current disclosure from others.
Disclosed is a system which can monitor in real time the biochemistry within the tumor microenvironment (TME), which can increase the pace of TME-targeted drug discovery and may improve early stage diagnosis, prognosis assessment, prediction of effective therapy, and therapy modulation during treatment. Technologies based on the physical properties of tissue cannot provide this information.
In various embodiments, the disclosed SIB probe is virtually indistinguishable from a conventional biopsy needle set. The disclosed SIB probe contains multiple optical fiber chemical sensors that continuously transmit information on physiological chemical levels in the immediate vicinity of the tip. In practice the biopsy team can use this information to guide sample collection, optimizing the effectiveness of the procedure, minimizing the need for repeat biopsy, and assuring that tissue samples are recovered from high tumor content areas and any other regions of interest
In various embodiments, as the needle progresses into the patient's body, real-time biochemical information lets the surgeon know as soon as the needle has encountered the margin of a tumor and tumor tissue, because tumor tissue has a different “biochemical signature” than healthy tissue. For example, tumor oxygenation has been tentatively shown to be predictive of response to chemotherapy, low pH which is associated with rapid tumor growth and pathophysiologic lactate accumulation is characteristic of solid tumors and has been associated with metastases and poor overall survival in cancer patients. This real-time biochemical information will help the surgeon place the needle in regions of maximum tumor cellularity within the biopsied region, and guide precise cutting and removal of tumor masses.
In various embodiments, once a high-quality sample is obtained, genetic analysis and other techniques can determine the “molecular signature” of the malignant material. This in turn enables the treating physician to tightly target treatment to the specific strain of cancer found, and to follow the course of treatment with an unprecedented level of accuracy. SIB needle biopsies will collect the samples needed to accomplish this advance in treatment.
A differentiating factor of various embodiments is the capability of the SIB needle system to deliver real-time biochemical information, asset glycolysis, during biopsy by a suite of tiny optical fiber chemical sensors integrated into the trocar of the coaxial needle through which the biopsy is carried out. In the disclosed SIB needles, the standard trocar is replaced by a trocar designed as a hollow tube capable of integrating up to six optical fibers, with a solid sharp tip to maintain its cutting capability.
In various embodiments the SIB needle is assembled by introducing optical fibers inside the trocar, with the tip of each fiber functionalized for pH, oxygen, or lactate monitoring. The hollow trocar 301 has a small “window” 305 milled into its side, very close to its tip, to expose the sensor tips 302 to tissue. The fiber optic sensor tips (sensor elements) 302 are placed in that “window.” To create the permeable segment for sensor exposure to the tissue, the open side will be filled with a biocompatible, medical grade permeable material that will accomplish two functions: (1) it will maintain the cylindrical shape of the trocar, but still allow the target analytes to diffuse towards the sensors; (2) it will assure the biocompatibility of the sensor segment. Only a few tenths of a millimeter of the sensor “window” is actually exposed to the tissue; most of the “window” is covered by the coaxial needle. T
As shown in
In accordance with the standard biopsy procedure, the coaxial introducer needle with the trocar is inserted, guided by imaging, and with the SIB needle is guided by real-time monitoring of the selected biomarkers as well. Once the monitoring determines that the needle is in potential tumor tissue, the needle is secured and the trocar is removed, leaving space for insertion of the cutting cannula needle that takes the tissue sample.
Integrating the sensor with the coaxial introducer needle instead of the cutting cannula needle has significant advantages:
The heart of a fiber optic chemical sensor 506 shown in
In various embodiments, the measured emission intensity from the sensor element is affected by fluctuations in the excitation source intensity, and by the detector response, dimensions of the optical fibers, manipulation of the optical fiber, and variation in the thickness of the sensor element. In contrast, time domain measurements that rely on the fluorescence lifetime are insensitive to these interferences, making the measurements reliable and stable.
The direct determination of luminescence decay kinetics or emission lifetime requires complex and costly instrumentation. However, comparatively simple and compact phase-resolved luminescence measurement equipment that can determine the emission lifetime indirectly can be manufactured at low cost.
Various embodiments utilize phase-resolved luminescence detection which measures the time delay between the excitation of the sensor material with blue light and the emission of red light. None of the instrumental parameters that affect the intensity change the time delay between these two signals. Thus, the measurement (phase shift) does not depend on the excitation source intensity or the detector response, and it is insensitive to movements of the optical fiber due to manipulation of the biopsy needle. Furthermore, the phase shift does not depend of the amount of sensor material attached at the tip of the fiber. This is relevant to sensor repeatability as it significantly reduces the cost of calibration.
The disclosed system utilizes a compact fiber optic phase-resolved luminescence readout device that has characteristics for use in the proposed sensor system. The disclosed system also utilizes optical sensors which are based on indicator chemistry whose emission—and the variations therein caused by the interaction with the target analyte—can be determined by phase-resolved luminescence measurement.
For use in various embodiments of the disclosed system, three luminescent sensor materials were chosen, each of them specifically sensitive to one of the three target metabolic markers selected. These sensor materials may be fabricated as individual microprobes with 250 μm plastic optical fibers. Plastic fibers have lower transmission than glass fibers, but tremendously simplify sensor fabrication and integration, since they are not subject to breaks, being flexible and robust.
The exemplar individual fiber optic sensors were assessed for measurement range and accuracy, using saline solutions prepared with known levels of dissolved oxygen, pH, or lactate concentration, demonstrating measurement range and sensitivity at relevant levels.
A challenge which was overcome in fabricating the exemplar biopsy needles was to do so with the thin needles needed for the animal model tests on mice. Two designs were selected for fabricating exemplar SIB needles: (1) sensor integrated needle and (2) sensor integrated trocar. The sensor integrated trocar approach has significant advantages, probably the most relevant being that only the trocar used with a coaxial introducer needle in standard biopsies is the part modified, which makes the integrated sensor needle compatible with all current coaxial introducer needles and completely compatible with current protocols and imaging systems.
In various embodiments, the sensor area is covered with a medical grade polymer. As has been shown in tested exemplar embodiments, the three sensors retain their analytical characteristics after integration with the biopsy needle prototypes. Sensor durability of exemplar embodiments was tested rigorously in the laboratory. The integrated sensor needle exemplar prototypes, once tested for chemical response, were inserted multiple times to a depth of 3-4 cm in beef liver and in chicken breast at an insertion speed of ˜0.5 cm/sec. Probes were inspected carefully under an optical microscope for any signs of physical damage, and particularly for partial or complete delamination of the sensor coatings covering the optical fibers. No sign of sensor damage was observed. After the insertions, probes were tested again for chemical response. The sensors maintained complete functionality, demonstrating the robustness of the probes.
In furtherance of demonstrating the effectiveness of the disclosed system, animal models were used in testing. The protocol for the animal model studies includes the use of 30 FVB/N-Tg(MMTV-PyVT)634Mul/J female mice between 6 and 10 weeks of age. This mouse strain was selected because it is a spontaneous breast cancer model. Performance of the exemplar testing utilized the Bard Mission Disposable Core Biopsy Instrument and the Bard Max-Core Disposable Core Biopsy Instrument, both compatible with the Bard TruGuide Disposable Coaxial Biopsy Needle. The sensor integrated trocar prototypes were inserted in TruGuide needles from the same supplier. Thus testing demonstrated the use of off-the-shelf components in combination with various disclosed elements. Throughout the testing procedure, the real-time sensor signals from the three fiber optic sensors were recorded in real time. The three regions under study were easily identified visually by the participating physicians and veterinarians, and are identified as follows:
Region 1: ˜5 mm before entering the tumor.
Region 2: at the margin of the tumor, before the needle enters the tumor itself
Region 3: when the needle is within the tumor.
Normalized phase-sift measurements profile for an exemplar procedure of an embodiment of the disclosed system is illustrated in
In order to validate the efficacy of an exemplar embodiment, a total of 23 tests inserting the sensor integrated device into the tumor were conducted. Infiltrating Ductal Carcinoma was identified in all samples from full tumors at the area of insertion of the sensor integrated device. In all cases, sensor insertion into the tumor corresponded to a significant deviation of the signal from the control values for all three sensors. In none of the test did any of the three sensors exhibit significant deviation from the control signal in the control area. Furthermore, the multisensory probe was able to discriminate with 100% accuracy between the edge of the tumor and total insertion inside the cancer tissue. Thus, in this study the multisensory probes were able to report the location of the needle with 100% accuracy—0% false positives and 0% false negatives. We performed an analysis based on the percentage of variation of the sensor signal, which enabled us to combine and compare the information from the sensor reporting units for lactate (mg/L), oxygen (mmHg), and pH.
In order to further validate the disclosed methodology and system, three situations were simulated which could lead to false negative histopathology analysis: (A) in one test the needle was directed at the last step to be 1 mm away from the tumor mass, (B) in one additional test the needle was located at the last step to be touching the tumor at the bottom of the tumor mass but not inside it, and (C) in another test the needle was located at the last step to be touching the tumor at the top of the tumor mass but not inside it.
The sensor data collected for the exemplar embodiment being validated at the supposed tumor region for the three imprecise procedures indicates clearly that the needle was outside the target, which would have immediately triggered a warning for the surgeon.
In
In a standard biopsy procedure, doctors typically take several tissue samples with the same needle device. Exemplar embodiment needles were tested at least three times. In order to test needle durability, one of the fabricated exemplar needles was tested by performing eight consecutive biopsy procedures; the tested needle maintained functionality throughout the eight tests. Robustness and the capability of reusing the sensor device for one mouse were demonstrated.
What has been described herein is considered merely illustrative of the principles of this invention. Accordingly, it is well within the purview of one skilled in the art to provide other and different embodiments within the spirit and scope of the invention.
This application for patent claims the benefit of provisional application 62/483,436, filed on Apr. 9, 2017. The application is incorporated herein in its entirety.
This invention was made with government support under contract #NIH HHSN261201600029C awarded by the National Institute of Health. The government has certain rights in the invention.
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
62483436 | Apr 2017 | US |