Not Applicable
Chromatography is one of the most widely used analytical tools in pharmaceutical, chemical manufacturing, environmental, and clinical toxicology laboratories. It is a process where a mixture of different chemicals is separated into is substituent components for detection and quantification. One of the main components to a chromatographic system is the chromatographic column. Inside the column there is a chemically modified sorbent, known as the stationary phase. A liquid this then pumped through the column, also known as the mobile phase. The separation occurs because each chemical compound has a different affinity for the mobile phase versus the stationary phase.
In order to keep the stationary phase inside the tubular column or other container, a mechanical filter is placed at the ends of the tube or column or other container. These filters are also called frits or screens. These frits have to be fine enough to hold the stationary phase, but permeable enough to allow the mobile phase and analyte molecules to permeate through. The stationary phase may have particles a few microns diameter, or smaller. Along with retaining the chromatographic media in the column, the filters or frits also act as a physical filter excluding particulate contamination that may be present in the sample or the mobile phase, or that are generated by degradation of the particles.
One side effect of filtering out particulate containing samples is that debris and particulates build up on the filter media. This buildup is especially noticeable if biological fluids are being analyzed as the biological material may fragment into smaller particles which are blocked by the filter. After enough of the particulates have has accumulated on the filter media one of two common side effects may be realized. The first side effect is that the operational pressure of the column will increase as the filter becomes clogged, making it more difficult for the mobile phase to pass through the clogged filter, and causing an increase in the operational pressure. At some point the clogging may cause the operational pressure or back pressure to exceed the system pressure limitations. The second common side effect of a clogged filter is that the filter's pores or passageways have restricted access, which subsequently causes turbulent flow for at least the filter interface and that may cause wide or split chromatographic peaks.
To alleviate these difficulties some columns have been developed using depth filters having graded pore sizes which decrease in the direction of flow through the column during use. Such filters are described in U.S. Pat. No. 5,985,140, the complete contents of which is incorporated herein by reference. As a debris particle enters the wider, upstream opening in the filter it becomes trapped in the filter as the interstitial passages narrow, but fluid flows around the trapped particle. But such filters also clog and have a noticeable pressure increase and noticeable efficiency loss after about 60 injections, depending on the application.
A frit, filter or screen is made of non-woven sintered fibers of metal, preferably stainless steel. The fibers are progressively more densely packed in opposite direction of flow, or more loosely packed in the direction of flow. This results in progressively increasing pore sizes which are the interstitial spaces between the fibers. The increase in interstitial clearance may be attributable to a lesser number of fibers per unit volume on the downstream side of the frit, or to the use of fibers of a progressively smaller diameter on the upstream side and progressively larger diameter on the downstream side of the frit. Most conveniently, however, fibers of a single diameter are used, and the variation is created by stepwise changes in the packing density of the fibers with the fibers being more dense on the upstream side and less dense on the downstream side, at least for the frit on the upstream end of the column during use. In any event, the interstitial clearance on the upstream side of the frit during use begins as a very small diameter or size sufficient to retain the debris associated with whole blood and the interstitial clearance enlarges on toward the downstream side of the frit.
Other relevant aspects of the frit 10 are its thickness and permeability factor, both of which may vary as may the pore size or interstitial passage size. The thickness in most cases will be within the range of from about 0.1 mm to about 1.0 mm, preferably from about 0.2 mm to about 0.6 mm, and most preferably from about 0.3 mm to about 0.6 mm. The permeability factor k is defined by Darcy's Law in which the change in pressure P divided by the thickness of the frit L equals the fluid viscosity times the superficial velocity divided by the permeability factor K. The permeability factor in most cases will be within the range of from about 4×1013 to about 1×10−10 m2, preferably from about 4×10−13 to about 1×10−11 m2, and most preferably from about 4×10−13 to about 4×10−12 m2, when measured in the direction of fluid flowing from the largest to the smallest interstitial passages.
The gradation in interstitial passages may be stepwise or continuous, and the variation from the smaller-pore side to the larger-pore side may vary widely. The pore size differential (i.e., the difference between the largest pore size and the smallest pore size) may thus range from about 1 micron to about 50 microns, or preferably from about 2 microns to about 20 microns. The frit gradations may be continuous or stepped. The frit 10 may contain two or more stepped gradations and preferably three to six stepped gradations. The pore size on the course (downstream) side of the frit (the coarsest portion of the frit) may range from about 2 microns to about 50 microns, preferably from about 2 microns to about 6 microns. The pore size on the finer, upstream side of the frit 10 is smaller than the downstream side, preferably by a factor of about 2 or more, and more preferably by a factor of up to 10 times smaller.
The strands of metal may have a cross-sectional dimension of about 2-20 μm, and each frit 10 preferably has stands of substantially the same dimension and lying in substantially the same plane. The frits are preferably thin, having a thickness from about 10-200 strands thick, although thicker frits can be used. The frit is held in a recess of an end fitting, insert or elastomeric holder (preferably PEEK). An annular elastomeric (preferably PEEK) ring seals at least one face of the circular, disk-shaped frit at a peripheral edge of the frit, and preferably seals both faces at that edge to provide a fluid tight seal at the periphery which forces fluid through the frit rather than around the outer periphery of the frit.
This frit material is used to retain chromatographic media inside of chromatography columns and cartridges. The filtration properties of this frit are believed to allow for an extended lifetime of chromatographic columns and cartridges under certain conditions. In particular, the described filter or frit retains the chromatographic media while resisting fouling due to dirty samples, yet also provides a seal between the column tube, frit, and end fitting.
Most popular frits for retaining chromatographic media are made by sintering a stainless steel or titanium metal powder. The frit's porosity and pore structure is therefore dictated by the size and size distribution of the powdered particles used to make a “green” body, the pressure at which the “green” body is pressed, and the temperature used for sintering. The preferred starting material for the preferred frit is a stainless steel, titanium, or nickel metal fiber with a width of 2-20 μm. The fiber is sintered in a random arrangement but with the fibers or strands arranged in generally the same plane as the thin frit, rather than having the fibers or strands extend predominantly in axial directions perpendicular to the plane of the frit. The fibers are also randomly arranged within the above angular orientations and form non-woven, fiber layers. This non-woven arrangement is believed to be beneficial. Very thin layers of the metal fibers are believed to be particularly desirable, with the layer thickness being on the order of 0.010-0025050 inches (0.254-0.063627 mm) thick. But, thicker layers can be used if particulate retention is an issue.
This material may be used in sandwich configurations where it is trapped between two layers of woven wire mesh. This is believed to be an inferior adaptation of this material for two reasons. The first is that the abrupt change in flow resistance and pore structure between the woven wire mesh material and the non-woven material can cause flow uniformity manifested by chromatographic peak tailing. The second is that it is believed to allow for chromatographic materials to potentially escape around the outside of the frit, because the seal is formed on the woven mesh side and that may allow silica to pass through.
In the preferred frit only a thin layer of sintered fiber material are used in conjunction with a PEEK seal around the peripheral edge of the frit and that seals directly with the fiber material. The PEEK seal can be molded, sonically welded, sandwiched, or just inserted as a gasket. Specific examples of available configurations are shown in the exemplification section.
Further, it is usually advantageous to spread the sample across the surface of the frit. While the orientation of the fibers within the frit itself will distribute the sample laterally, it is preferred to also have a distribution cone that has an angle of 3-10° from the longitudinal flow axis through the frit, or a distribution disk placed against or next to the frit to further distribute the sample.
There is thus provided a chromatography column having: a rigid cylindrical tube defining a separatory media chamber and a direction of flow of carrier fluid therethrough during use of the column. The column has a pair of media-retaining frits. One of the frits borders the chamber at an upstream end thereof and the other frit borders the chamber at a downstream end thereof. The frit at the upstream end preferably comprises sintered, non-woven stainless steel fibers of graded interstitial passages increasing in size in said direction of flow. The column also has a pair of end fittings, each fastened to an opposing end of the column and configured to place the column in fluid communication with equipment during use of the column.
In further variations, the graded insterstitial passages on the upstream side of the upstream frit are small enough to retain particles 10 microns in diameter, preferably small enough to retain particles 5 microns in diameter, more preferably are small enough to retain particles 3 microns in diameter, and ideally small enough to retain particles about 1 micron in diameter. Moreover, the graded insterstitial passages on an upstream side of the frit are advantageously small enough to retain particles from 1-3 microns in diameter. Further, the graded insterstitial passages on an upstream side of the upstream frit are small enough to retain particles 5 microns in diameter with the upstream frit having a thickness of from about 0.1 mm to about 1.0 mm and a permeability factor of from about 4×10−13 to about 1×10−10 m2 with the permeability measured in the direction of larger to smaller interstitial passages.
I still further variations, the graded insterstitial passages on the upstream side of the upstream frit are small enough to retain particles 1-3 microns in diameter and the upstream frit has a thickness of from about 0.1 mm to about 0.6 mm and a permeability factor of from about 4×10−13 to about 1×10−12 m2 with the permeability measured in the direction of larger to smaller interstitial passages.
There are also provided various means for holding the upstream and/or downstream frits in position in the column. These means are described in more detail herein, and include clamping a periphery of the frit against a ledge on the inside of the column (
The end fitting abutting the various washers and bodies also enhances the formation of a fluid tight seal around the peripheral edge of the frit held by the washer or body. Thus, each of the above described means for holding the upstream and/or downstream frits in position in the column, also provide means for sealing a peripheral edge of the frit during use.
The above chromatography column may be used with any downstream frit, or it may be used with a frit having a graded porosity, advantageously with the graded porosity frit oriented so larger passageways in the downstream frit are closer to the media in the chromatography column than the smaller passageways in the frit, but is preferably orientated so that smaller passageways in the downstream frit are closer to the media in the chromatography column than the larger passageways in the frit.
There is also provided a chromatography method using a chromatography column with a media bed therein and a frit on opposing ends of the media bed. The method includes injecting a fluid sample containing an analyte into an upstream end of the column and passing the sample and analyte through the upstream frit, where the upstream frit has a graded porosity and is oriented such that larger interstitial passageways in the upstream frit are further away from the media than the smaller interstitial passageways in the upstream frit. The method also includes passing at least some of the analyte through the frit on the downstream end of the column. The method may also include analyzing the analyte chromatographically. The upstream frit is formed of sintered, non-woven stainless steel fibers of graded interstitial passages decreasing in size in said direction of flow during use of the column.
These and other features and advantages of the various embodiments disclosed herein will be better understood with respect to the following description and drawings, in which like numbers refer to like parts throughout, and in which:
a shows a scanning electron microscopic images of the sintered metal fiber at a magnification of 500×;
b shows a scanning electron microscopic images of a portion of the sintered metal fiber of
c shows a cross-sectional view of a chromatography column using the frit of
a shows a cross sectional view of a frit as described herein located in an HPLC end fitting using a molded seal and a distribution cone;
b shows a perspective view of the seal of
a and 6b show a cross sectional view of a frit as described herein located in an HPLC end fitting using an O-ring, with a partially exploded view of the frit and O-ring;
c shows a cross-sectional view of the frit and O-ring of
d shows various connections between the frit and O-ring of
a shows a cross sectional view of a frit as described herein located in an HPLC end fitting using a carrier with flow distribution features;
b is a cross sectional view taken along section 7b-7b of
c is a bottom elevation view of the frit and filter of
d is a top elevation view of the frit and filter of
a is a side elevation view of a further embodiment of the frit and fitting of
b is a cross-sectional view taken along section 9b-9b of
Referring to
The frit material is advantageously sintered non-woven stainless steel fibers. The particular stainless steel is not believed to be critical to the invention, and a variety of different stainless steel alloys can be used. Austenitic stainless steels, i.e., those whose chief alloying elements are chromium and nickel, are preferred. A particularly preferred stainless steel is 316L stainless steel, whose composition is approximately 0.03% carbon, 2.00% manganese, 1.00% silicon, 16.0-18.0% chromium, 10.0-14.0% nickel, 0.45% phosphorus, 0.03% sulfur, and 2.0-3.0% molybdenum (all percents by weight).
A currently preferred frit medium is BEKIPOR® ST filter medium, and in particular BEKIPOR® ST 3AL3, a product of NV Bekaert SA of Belgium, available through Bekaert Fibre Technologies Europe, Zwevegem, Belgium, and Bekaert Corporation, Atlanta, Ga., USA. This medium is made of 316L stainless steel fibers, randomly compressed in a non-woven structure and sintered, and is supplied in sheets, with typical lateral dimensions of 1180 mm.times.1500 mm and 0.35 mm in thickness. This particular product has an absolute filter rating of 3 microns, a bubble point pressure of 12,300 Pa (ASTM E 128061, equivalent ISO 4003), an average air permeability of 9 L/dm.sup.2/min at 200 Pa (NF A 95-352, equivalent IOS 4022), a permeability factor k of 4.80.times.10.sup.-13, a weight of 975 g/m.sup.2, a porosity of 65%, and a dirt holding capacity of 6.40 mg/cm.sup.2 according to Multipass method ISO 4572 with 8″ initial differential pressure—all when the frit is reversed from its use as described herein so that fluid flows from the larger interstitial passages toward the narrower passages. Other media of similar characteristics and made of similar materials can also be used.
When used in the chromatography column 14 as described herein, the frit 10 is orientated so that the gradation of the pore size during use is such that the debris-containing sample fluid enters the frit through the side with the smaller interstitial spaces, passes through the frit, and leaves the frit through the side with the larger interstitial spaces. The larger pore sizes and passageways are toward the media contained by the frit 10. The degree and spatial rate of gradation of size may vary within the scope of this invention, as may the pore sizes themselves. Best results however are believed to be obtained with a pore size gradation that begins with a size that is narrow enough to retain particles that are 10 microns in diameter, preferably 5 microns in diameter, and most preferably 1 to 3 microns in diameter, all on the upstream side of the frit during use. The downstream side of the frit has larger pore sizes, openings or interstitial spacing than the upstream side—at least for the upstream frit 10a.
As used herein, the relative directions top and bottom refer to the orientations of the parts as shown in the drawings, with top usually being in the vertically upward direction. The upstream and downstream directions refer to the direction of fluid flow through the chromatographic column 14 during use.
As sheets of the filter medium are supplied by commercial suppliers of the medium, the side with the larger pore size is frequently differentiated by being colored or otherwise marked to guide the user in obtaining the desired orientation. In the drawing, the frit at the upstream end of the column during use has the frit oriented so the smaller pore size is also located upstream during use. Since the frit medium is thin and flexible, mechanical support is preferably provided to assure that the frit medium remains flat. Several examples of frit supports are described later.
In use a frit 10 is placed at upstream or top end of a chromatographic column 14 having a longitudinal axis 16. The chromatography column 14 comprises a tube, typically of metal such as stainless steel, having a media chamber therein containing media bounded by frits 10, with end caps or end fittings holding the frits in place and placing the column in fluid communication with chromatography equipment during use. The tube, especially when packed with media, is rigid. The column 14 may take the form of an elongated column as shown, or it may comprise a guard column, or it may comprise a guard cartridge in which the tubular column is inserted within another tubular column upstream of another column or cartridge. The reference to a chromatography column thus encompasses both columns and cartridges unless noted otherwise.
The frit 10 may optionally also be placed on the downstream end of the column 14, or other filter types may be used on the downstream end. The downstream end of the column 14 may also have a depth filter with the filter in either orientation. Thus, the column 14 has upstream frit 10a in the form of a depth filter with the interstitial passages or pore size of the filter increasing in the direction of flow. That is contrary to the conventional wisdom of using a depth filter in the reverse orientation where the interstitial passages decrease in size the direction of flow. The downstream frit 10b may be any type of filter, with a non-graded, woven metal filter being believed suitable, with a depth filter having the interstitial passages decreasing in size in the direction of flow being believed usable, and with a depth filter having the interstitial passages increasing in size in the direction of flow being believed usable and believed preferable.
When the frit 10 is used as described herein on the upstream end of the chromatography column or a bed of chromatography media a surprising improvement in the life of the column is achieved. Comparative tests indicated that the rate of column backpressure increase was the about the same regardless of which side of the frit 10 was facing the packing media. The columns 14 with the fine side of the frit 10 facing the packing material in the column took about twice as long to reach a failure state versus standard frits of sintered powder metal, whereas the columns 14 with the fine side of the frit 10 facing away from the packing material in the column took 3 times as long to reach a failure state. A failure state was defined as the loss of 50% of the chromatographic performance of the column, or a backpressure of 400 bar. This shows that it is better to have the coarse side of the graded porosity frit 10 facing the packing material and the fine side of the frit 10 facing away from the packing material. This frit orientation is contrary to the orientation taught in the prior art and goes against the teachings of the prior art.
The frit 10 has a thickness measured along that longitudinal axis that may vary, but which is preferably thin, on the order of a few thousandths of an inch thick, preferably from about 0.01-0.003 inches (0.25-0.07 mm) thick. But thicker frits 10 may be used if particulate retention is an issue, and if the frit 10 is sandwiched between additional screens or filters the thickness may also increate. Since the strands 12 used in the frit are from 2-20 μm thick, while the frit is from about 0.06 to 0.25 mm thick, anywhere from a few strands to a couple hundred strands may be stacked in generally parallel planes in order to each other to achieve the axial thickness. For example, at 0.2 μm thick, 127 strands create a frit 10 with a thickness of about 0.25 mm, and 32 strands with a thickness of about 0.20 μm create the same thickness. Using strands with a thickness of about 20 μm, from 3 to 13 strands can create the same thickness. Thus, only thin layers of the non-woven metal fibers or strands 12 are advantageously used, with thinner frits 10 being preferred for chromatographic reasons—as long as the frit functions of particulate retention and specified (preferably low) back pressure are met.
As seen in
The strands 12 are non-woven and preferably randomly stacked and then sintered to form the frit 10. This non-woven arrangement is an important distinction, as there are several woven screen arrangements available using metal strands. The orientation of the frit 10 with the smaller interstitial passages on the upstream end during use is also an important distinction, as it is the opposite of the arrangement described for the depth filter of U.S. Pat. No. 5,985,140. But these prior art frits do not provide the same filtration performance as the described frit 10, as discussed later.
The downstream frit 10 may be a screen or filter with uniform porosity and distribution, it may comprise a depth filter with the larger pores, openings or fiber spacing located on the upstream side and decreasing in size toward the downstream side as with a traditional depth filter, or with the smaller pores and spacing on the upstream side and increasing toward the downstream side.
Referring to
In use, the end of a column 14 and end fitting 18a are threaded together using threads 26 with the end of the column abutting washer 34 and pressing the washer against the periphery of frit 10 to form a fluid tight seal. The frit 10 is oriented so the smaller openings are upstream and larger openings downstream during use of the column 14. This same orientation is used on all upstream frits 10 in columns 14 and may not be repeated through the detailed description of various embodiments. The inner periphery of washer 34 overlaps the outer periphery of the frit 10 and is pressed against and seals against the frit in order to prevent analyte or particles from passing between the outer periphery of the frit and the first recess 30 and past the washer 34. The washer 34 and frit 10 in the described arrangement thus provide a fluid tight seal. The overlap of the washer 34 and the frit 10 also helps prevent small particulates from getting underneath the washer 34 and passing around the outer periphery of the frit 10.
Advantageously, the first stepped recess 30 is not orthogonal to the longitudinal axis 16, but is slightly inclined away from the column and toward the axis 16 and toward recess 22 in order to form a shallow conical surface having an inclination of about 4° and sloping toward the recess 22. The shallow angle helps distribute fluid passing through the through passage 24, across the frit 10 so the fluid more evenly spreads across the end of the column abutting the washer 34. The tightening of the end fitting 18a may deform the outer portion of the frit toward this conical surface but that does not prevent the conical distribution surface from more evenly distributing the fluid across the frit 10. The PEEK washer 34 may be thin measured along axis 16, with a thickness of about 0.003 inches (0.076 mm) or large believed suitable.
Still referring to
While the above description of end fitting 18a refers to inlet fitting 22, the same construction may be used for an outlet coupling, with the inclined wall 30 funneling filtered fluid to the outlet recess 22, rather than distributing it over the frit 10. A gripping or wrenching surface 41 is typically provided on the outside of the end fitting 18a so a user can use the surface 41 to tighten the end fitting 18a to the desired equipment using threads 16.
Referring to
In use, the end of a column 14 and end fitting 18b are threaded together using threads 26 with the end of the column abutting washer 34 and pressing it against the periphery of frit 10 to form a fluid tight seal between those two parts. The threading also pushes the frit 10 against the diffuser 42 and against the bottom 28. The inner periphery of washer 34 overlaps the outer periphery of the frit 10 and is pressed against and seals against the frit in order to prevent analyte or particles from passing between the outer periphery of the frit and the first recess 30 and past the washer 34. The washer 34 and frit 10 in the described arrangement thus provide a fluid tight seal. The overlap of the washer 34 and the frit 10 also helps prevent small particulates from getting underneath the washer 34 and passing around the outer periphery of the frit 10 and diffuser 42.
Referring to
Further, end fitting 18c may have the through-hole 24 and the structure forming that hole 24 omitted so the cylindrical wall 38 opens directly into bottom 28 and the first recess 20. Moreover, as seen in
In use, as the end fitting 18c is tightened on the end of a column (not shown in
Referring to
In use, as the end fitting 18d is tightened on the end of a column (not shown in
Referring to
It is believed preferable to fasten the O-ring 64 to the outer peripheral edge of the frit 10. The abutting parts can be releasably connected by having the O-ring 64 slightly smaller in diameter than the frit 10 so that the O-ring is stretched slightly and squeezes against the edge of the frit 10. A shallow recess or circumferential groove 66 (
In use, as the end fitting 18e is tightened on the end of a column (
Referring to
In use, as the end fitting 18f is tightened on the end of a column (
Referring to
The housing 82 may have an outwardly extending flange 86 on one end to help center the insert inside in the cylindrical body of the column during use and is shown on the top end in
The housing 82 may be made of elastomeric material or metal, and is preferably of stainless steel. The O-rings are made of rubber, a suitable elastomer or PEEK.
In use, the frit 10 is placed into recess 84 and pushed against the bottom 85. One or more O-rings are placed in grooves 88. The insert 80 is then placed inside an end fitting or inside a tubular chromatography column, with the flange 85 and O-rings in grooves 88 centering the insert along the axis 16. The housing flange 86 and O-rings in grooves 88 are cylindrical and sized to fit inside the end-fitting or chromatography column. The end of the column abuts and seals against the frit 10. Alternatively, any of the fits and seal configurations described in
The insert 80 and column are moved relative to each other until the frit 10 is sealed in position in the insert and centered on the axis 16, with the O-rings in grooves 88 providing a fluid seal between the insert 80 and the inside of the end fitting or column into which the insert is placed. A silica tube is placed in cylindrical recess 38 with the tube's end abutting the bottom of cylinder 38 to place the through-hole 24 in fluid communication with chromatography equipment. As fluid is introduced into through-hole 24, the tapered surface of the bottom 85 of recess 84 disperses the fluid across the frit 10. If the flow is in the opposite direction, then the tapered bottom 85 helps direct the fluid to the through-hole 24 and the equipment connected to recess 22. The tapered, conical bottom is optional, but is preferred as it is believed to aid fluid flow and distribution.
The preferred frit for chromatographic use has a very high permeability with filtration characteristics that retain 1-10 μm chromatographic particles, while maintaining the particles' high permeability in the presences of sample that contain high levels of protein, or high levels of particulates.
Although these inventions have been disclosed in the context of certain preferred embodiments and examples, it will be understood by those skilled in the art that the present inventions extend beyond the specifically disclosed embodiments to other alternative embodiments and/or uses of the inventions and obvious, modifications and equivalents thereof. In addition, while several variations of the inventions have been shown and described in detail, other modifications, which are within the scope of these inventions, will be readily apparent to those of skill in the art based upon this disclosure. It is also contemplated that various combination or sub-combinations of the specific features and aspects of the embodiments may be made and still fall within the scope of the inventions. It should be understood that various features and aspects of the disclosed embodiments can be combined with or substituted for one another in order to form varying modes of the disclosed inventions. Thus, it is intended that the scope of at least some of the present inventions herein disclosed should not be limited by the particular disclosed embodiments described above.
The application claims the benefit under 35 U.S.C. §119(e) to Provisional Patent Application No. 61/723,251 filed Nov. 6, 2012, the entire contents of which are incorporated herein by reference.
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
61723251 | Nov 2012 | US |