Oilfield operators typically want to minimize pulling production tubing from an oil well borehole because it interrupts production and carries the risk that production of the entire well will be lost. Production tubing typically has an inside diameter of 2 to 4 inches (5.1 cm to 10.2 cm). Thus, rock density measuring devices should preferably fit within an instrument with a diameter of 1 11/16 inches (4.28 cm), which is an oil industry standard for production logging tools. Described herein are density measuring devices that take the form of borehole gravimeters. The borehole gravimeters may be fitted in an 1 11/16″ (4.28 cm) diameter logging tool and may be run in wells with deviations from the vertical of up to 80 degrees. Further, these borehole gravimeters may withstand temperatures and pressures of at least 350° F. (177° C.) and 20,000 psi.
The vacuum chamber 125 contains a magnetic sliding weight 140, which may slide up and down within the vacuum chamber 125 and may be generally semi-cylindrically shaped or any other suitable shape. The sliding weight 140 may be propelled upward using an induction coil or other suitable device contained within a catcher 145 for catching the sliding weight 140. Launching the sliding weight upwards with a magnetic field generated by the coil, or by other means using another suitable device, starts a movement cycle in which the sliding weight 140 moves upward in the vacuum chamber 125 until it reaches the top of its trajectory and then moves downward in the vacuum chamber 125 until stopped by the catcher 145.
The vacuum chamber 125 may have an internal surface with a Teflon or other suitable coating to reduce friction between the contact surfaces of the sliding weight 140 and the vacuum chamber 125. Further friction reductions between the contact surfaces may be obtained by maintaining the temperature of the vacuum chamber 125 above approximately 80° C., using a sledge design, and/or equipping the sliding weight 140 with ball bearings or other suitable friction reduction devices.
The sliding weight 140 has an optical prism 150 for reflecting a portion of a light beam 155 to a stationary optical prism 160 located near the bottom end of the vacuum chamber 125. The stationary optical prism 160, in turn, reflects light received from the sliding weight's optical prism 150 to a mirror 175 for reflection to an interference area 165 in the interferometer 130, which also receives another portion of the light beam 155 emitted by the light source 135. The light source 135 may be a laser or other suitable light emitting device, which can be located outside the chamber 125 or at any other suitable location relative to the chamber 125. The interferometer 130 may have two or more fully reflective and/or semi-transparent mirrors that cause the portion of the light beam 155 received from the light source 135 to be directed to the sliding weight's prism 150 and the second portion to the interference area 165. The mirrors may be located within the chamber 125, outside the chamber 125, or some combination of inside and outside the chamber 125. In one embodiment, as shown in
With reference to
The interference of light received directly from the light source 135 (i.e., the first portion of the light beam 155) with light received from the stationary prism 160 (i.e., the second portion of the light beam 155) creates light interference fringes, which provide an indication of the distance that the sliding weight 140 travels during a certain measuring period. The measuring period is determined using the timing device 120 (e.g., an atomic clock). The interferometer 130 may include an optical fringe detector 215 or other suitable device to measure the interference fringes to enable the distance traveled by the sliding weight 140 during the measuring period to be determined. Further, the timing device 120 may be used in conjunction with the optical fringe detector 215 to determine the distance traveled by the sliding weight 140 during any select time period. More particularly, the timing device 120 is utilized in conjunction with the interferometer 130 to establish the number of fringes measured during the select period of time, which is then used to establish the distance traveled by the sliding weight 140 during the select period of time.
For the borehole gravimeter 105 depicted in
X
i
=X
oi
+V
oi
t
i+½g0(cos θ−η sin θ)ti2 (1)
where Xoi is the initial position of the sliding weight;
X
j
=X
oj
+V
oj
t
j+½g0(cos θ+η sin θ)tj2 (2)
where Xoj is the initial position of the sliding weight; and
X
i=½g0(cos θ−η sin θ)ti2 (3)
and
X
j=½g0(cos θ+η sin θ)t2 (4)
Setting Xoi, Xoj, Voj, and Voi equal to zero additionally results in the elimination of the terms for the second and third order powers of time multiplied by the gravitational gradient, which were ignored in equations 1 and 2. This leaves only time to the fourth power multiplied by the gravitational constant (i.e., γg0t4/24) as the term ignored when using equations 1 and 2. This fourth power of time term will generally be very small compared to numbers resulting from the terms used in equations 1 and 2, and thus will generally not significantly impact the calculated distances using equations 1 and 2. If the length of the time period of the sliding weight's downward travel is selected equal to the length of the time period of the sliding weight's upward travel (i.e., ti=tj=t), then equations 3 and 4 may be added together to obtain the following equation:
X
i
+X
j
=g
0(cos θ)t2 (5)
and equation 3 may be subtracted from equation 4 to obtain the following equation:
X
j
−X
i
=ηg
0(sin θ)t2 (6)
By combining the downward and upward distances traveled by the sliding weight 140 during a trajectory cycle, the effect of the coefficient of friction is eliminated. By subtracting the downward distance traveled by the sliding weight 140 from its upward distance, the coefficient of friction can be determined using, as described in more detail below, the gravitational acceleration determined from equation 5. Additionally, the fourth order power of time term ignored in equations 1 and 2 will cancel out in equation 6, thus resulting in substantially no difference in coefficient of friction values obtained between using equations that take into account the fourth order power of time terms and using those that ignore this term.
As further described below, in some embodiments, multiple measurements of upward and downward distances traveled by the sliding weight 140 during a period of time at a specific location are taken to enable multiple calculations for the gravitational acceleration and the coefficient of friction to be done. These multiple calculations help to average out the error in the gravitational acceleration calculations, and provide a continuous check for the constancy of the coefficient of friction for the vacuum chamber.
Elimination of the coefficient of friction from the determination of the gravitational acceleration by adding together the upward and downward distances traveled by the sliding weight 140 means that the sliding weight 140 may contact the walls of the vacuum chamber 125 so long as the upward and downward paths of the sliding weight 140 are substantially similar and the angle of the gravimeter 105 relative to vertical remains substantially constant during the upward and downward travel cycle of the sliding weight 140. Further, the effect of any remaining air resistance in the vacuum chamber 125 also cancels out in a manner similar to the canceling out of the coefficient of friction when both upward and downward movement of the sliding weight 140 are combined to determine the gravitational acceleration. Thus, the vacuum requirements in the vacuum chamber 125 may be relaxed. With less strict vacuum requirements, an ion vacuum pump, which is typically used in surface falling weight gravimeters, may be eliminated. Elimination of the ion vacuum pump reduces the required size of the borehole gravimeter 105 since this component tends to be rather large and generally does not fit in a 2″ (5.08 cm) diameter or less wireline borehole logging tool.
Returning to equation 5, the distance traveled upward by the sliding weight 140 for the selected time period length prior to the sliding weight 140 reaching its top trajectory may be determined. Additionally, the distance traveled downward by the sliding weight 140 from its top trajectory over the same time period length may also be determined. Further, since the angle of the borehole gravimeter 105 related to the vertical at any time is known, the angle of the borehole gravimeter relative to vertical during the selected time periods may be determined. Thus, every variable of equation 5 is known except for the gravitational acceleration, which may be determined by inputting the data for the known variables into the equation.
Once the gravitational acceleration is determined, the rock density around the borehole may be determined. Specifically, the density ρb of a rock layer with thickness Δz is proportional to the difference in gravitational acceleration Δg measured over the layer:
In operation, the tool 100 containing the borehole gravimeter 105 is inserted into a borehole. At a desired depth for measuring the gravitational acceleration, the borehole gravimeter 105 is maintained in a substantially stationary position by clamping the tool 100 to the borehole wall or by using any other suitable mechanism or method to maintain the borehole gravimeter 105 in a substantially stationary position. The sliding weight 140 is propelled upwards using the induction coil or any other suitable means. Measurements using the tilt meter 115, the interferometer 130, and the timing device 120 are taken during the sliding weight's upward and downward path of travel. These measurements are provided to a processor 220, which utilizes the measurements to calculate the gravitational acceleration at the location of the measurements. In one embodiment, the processor 220 is part of the gravimeter 105. In another embodiment; the processor 220 is separate from the gravimeter 105, but electrically coupled to the gravimeter 105 via a hardwire or wireless connection.
If desired, the sliding weight 140 may be launched upwards multiple times to obtain multiple measurements at a desired depth in the borehole. In some embodiments, at least one hundred upward and downward cycles are measured at the desired depth. This allows for the estimation of the uncertainty in the gravitational acceleration measurement and compensates for small movements that could effect one measurement. Similarly, in some embodiments during any one upward and downward cycle, multiple measurements are taken using the tiltmeter 115 and averaged to account for small variations in the angle of the gravimeter 105 relative to vertical that occur due to micro-seismic movements in the rock.
After completion of at least one upward and downward movement cycle of the sliding weight 140, the borehole gravimeter 105 is moved to another depth in the borehole. At the new depth, the steps for measuring the required parameters for determining the gravitational acceleration at the new location are repeated, and the new measurements are also provided to the processor 220 to calculate a second gravitational acceleration. The processor 220 utilizes the two gravitational accelerations to determine a gravitational gradient, which is utilized to determine the mass density of the rock layer.
To take direct underground rock density measurements, two borehole gravimeters 300, 305 may be arranged within a housing 110 of a wireline logging tool 310 to work in tandem as shown in
Each borehole gravimeter 300, 305 may have its own tilt measuring device 115a,b as shown in
The borehole gravimeters 300, 305 may each use the same light source 135 as shown in
Each borehole gravimeter 300, 305 is operated as described above to obtain measurements for determining a gravitational acceleration. Using equation 7, the determined density represents an average density of the underground rock layer adjacent to the borehole tool 310 between the first borehole gravimeter 300 and the second borehole gravimeter 305. The difference between the gravitational accelerations determined from the measurements made using each borehole gravimeter 300, 305 indicates the gravitational gradient Δg. The distance Δz between the two sensors is known with the required accuracy of 1 mm (0.1%). However, since the exact distance between the tops of the trajectories of the two sliding weights is not known with the required accuracy, calibration on the surface with absolute gravimeters may be necessary.
In operation, the sliding weights 140a,b are moved to their drop position using the lift mechanism 410, which can be a moving electromagnetic coil, a magnetic elevator or other suitable device. When the weights 140a,b are released, they travel downward in the vacuum chamber 125 until their movements are stopped by the catchers 145a,b. The two weights 140a,b have approximately an equal mass, but the contact area A1 of the first weight 140a with the chamber surface of the first weight is approximately twice the contact area A2 of the second weight 140b. The contact areas can be controlled to a high degree of accuracy by using a sledge or other suitable design. Assuming that the start velocities Vo of the two sliding weights 140a,b are equal, the equations that describe the incremental movements ΔXk and ΔXl of the two weights over the same time interval t are:
ΔXk=Vot+½g0(cos θ−A1η′ sin θ)t2 (8)
and
ΔXl=Vot+½g0(cos θ−Δ2η sin θ)t2 (9)
where go is gravitational acceleration;
ΔXk−ΔXl=(A1−A2)goη′(sin θ)t2 (10)
In a manner similar to the one described above for the first embodiment of a borehole gravimeter 100, ΔXk and ΔXl are determined by counting fringes using the interferometers 130a,b and two light beams 415, 420 with different wavelengths. Time t is measured with a timing device 120 (e.g. an atomic clock), the angle θ with a tilt-meter 115, and areas A1 and A2 from calibration at the surface. With this information, the product of g0 η′ may be determined. The gravitational acceleration g0 may then be determined by inserting this calculated product for g0 η′ in either equation 8 or 9.
Although the present invention has been described with reference to example embodiments, persons skilled in the art will recognize that changes may be made in form and detail without departing from the spirit and scope of the invention. The invention is limited only by the scope of the following claims.
This application claims under 35 U.S.C. §119(e) the benefit of U.S. Provisional Application No. 60/822,188, entitled “Sliding Weight Borehole Gravimeter” and filed on Aug. 11, 2006, which is incorporated herein by reference in its entirety.
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
60822188 | Aug 2006 | US |