Snap-acting float assembly with hysteresis

Information

  • Patent Grant
  • 6254351
  • Patent Number
    6,254,351
  • Date Filed
    Tuesday, January 25, 2000
    24 years ago
  • Date Issued
    Tuesday, July 3, 2001
    23 years ago
Abstract
A float assembly for use in actuating a switch based on the level of a fluid includes a pivot member having a pivot axis and a switching surface. First and second floats are coupled to the pivot member so that at a first fluid level the first and second floats lie on different sides of a vertical line extending through the pivot axis and the switching surface causes the switch to assume a first switching state. At a second fluid level, the first and second floats lie on the same side of the vertical line extending through the pivot axis and the switching surface causes the switch to assume a second switching state.
Description




BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION




1. Field of the Invention




The present invention relates generally to float assemblies for sensing fluid levels and, more particularly, to a float assembly for actuating a switch.




2. Background Art




Conventional float assemblies for actuating a switch based on a fluid level typically include a pushrod that extends upwardly from a float and which moves vertically with the float in response to changes in the fluid level. The pushrod may actuate the switch directly or, alternatively, may actuate the switch via an intermediate lever.




In applications where the float assembly controls the operation of a pump, it is desirable to provide switching hysteresis or a control deadband that allows the pump motor to cycle between on and off operational states at an acceptable frequency and duty cycle. As is commonly known, without switching hysteresis, electrical noise or high flow rates into the pumped container may cause the pump motor to cycle rapidly between on and off states when the fluid level is near the switching point. Such rapid cycling of the pump motor can substantially increase power consumption and shorten the life expectancy of the pump motor. It is further desirable to provide a positive (i.e., substantially bounceless) switching action because mechanical bouncing of the switch contacts may cause the pump motor to be turned on and off rapidly despite any switching hysteresis or control deadband and may cause premature wear and failure of the switch contacts.




Some conventional float assemblies provide a control deadband by coupling the float pushrod to the switch via a lost motion connection, which allows the vertical displacement of the float to change over a predetermined range of fluid levels without causing any actuation of the switch. Additionally, many of these conventional float assemblies also incorporate an electrical switch having a snap-acting or detent mechanism to provide a positive switching action that eliminates or minimizes contact bounce.




In one known configuration illustrated in

FIG. 1

, a conventional float


10


follows the level of a fluid within a tank


12


. A pushrod


14


extends coaxially from the float


10


and is coupled to the float


10


so that the pushrod


14


follows the vertical displacement of the float


10


. The pushrod


14


passes freely through an opening (not shown) in a lever arm


16


which is coupled to a detent switch


18


. The pushrod


14


includes an upper pushnut


20


and a lower pushnut


22


that define a control deadband therebetween. This control deadband allows the pushrod


14


to move vertically through the lever arm


16


a predetermined distance without actuating the lever arm


16


or the detent switch


18


.




At a low fluid level


24


, the pushrod


14


is retracted into the tank


12


so that the upper pushnut


20


pulls the lever arm


16


downward to cause the detent switch


18


to be in one of two switching states. Similarly, at a high fluid level


26


, the pushrod extends out of the tank


12


so that the lower pushnut


22


pushes the lever arm


16


upward to cause the detent switch


18


to be in the other one of the two switching states.




While the float assembly shown in

FIG. 1

establishes a control deadband so that a pump motor controlled by the detent switch


18


is turned on at one fluid level and turned off at another fluid level, the structure of

FIG. 1

is relatively expensive to manufacture because it requires the use of an expensive detent switch. Further, placement of the pushnuts


20


and


22


on the pushrod


14


is labor intensive and tends to be imprecise, leading to a wide variation in the minimum and maximum controlled fluid levels.




SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION




In accordance with one aspect of the present invention, a float assembly includes a carrier rotatable about a pivot axis. The carrier includes an actuation surface which is disposed at an actuating position when the carrier is disposed at a first rotational position and which is moved away from the actuating position when the carrier is rotated away from the first rotational position toward a second rotatable position.




The float assembly may further include a pair of spaced floats coupled to the carrier. The floats may be disposed on a certain side of a vertical line extending through the pivot axis when the carrier is disposed at the first rotational position and the floats may be disposed on opposite sides of the vertical line extending through the pivot axis when the carrier is disposed at the second rotational position.




The float assembly may be used in combination with a switch having an actuation arm which is moved to a switch actuation position by the actuation surface as the carrier is rotated to the first rotational position and the actuation arm may be biased by a spring to a switch deactuation position as the carrier is rotated toward the second rotational position.




In accordance with another aspect of the present invention, a float assembly for actuating a switch based on a level of a fluid includes a pivot member having a pivot axis and a switching surface and first and second floats coupled to the pivot member. At a first fluid level, the first and second floats lie on different sides of a vertical line extending through the pivot axis and the switching surface causes the switch to assume a first switching state and, at a second fluid level, the first and second floats lie on the same side of the vertical line extending through the pivot axis and the switching surface causes the switch to assume a second switching state.




In accordance with yet another aspect of the present invention, a float assembly includes a pivot member having a pivot axis and a float coupled to the pivot member. The float provides a first torque to the pivot member in a first direction when the float lies substantially to one side of a vertical line extending through the pivot axis and a second torque in a second direction to the pivot member when the float lies substantially on another side of the vertical line extending through the pivot axis. The float assembly may further include a means for applying a third torque in the second direction to the pivot member to cause the float to move from substantially the one side to substantially the other side of the vertical line through the pivot axis.




The invention itself, together with further objects and attendant advantages, will best be understood by reference to the following detailed description, taken in conjunction with the accompanying drawings.











BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS





FIG. 1

is a diagrammatic, partial sectional view illustrating a prior art configuration for a float assembly that actuates a switch based on a fluid level;





FIG. 2

is an elevational view, partially in section, of a fluid reservoir system incorporating the float assembly of the present invention with a carrier or pivot member in a first position together with a block diagram of a pump and pump motor;





FIG. 3

is a view similar to

FIG. 2

with the carrier or pivot member in a second position; and





FIG. 4

is an isometric view of the carrier or pivot member shown in FIGS.


2


and


3


.











DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS




The float assembly described herein eliminates the need to use a snap-acting or detent switch and pushnuts, which are commonly used with conventional float assemblies, and instead uses one or more floats mounted on a carrier or pivot member to provide a snap-acting float assembly with hysteresis. Thus, the float assembly described herein may be used to actuate a relatively inexpensive limit switch to control the operation of a pump so that the pump motor is not subjected to rapid cycling between on and off conditions.





FIGS. 2 and 3

are views of a fluid reservoir system


50


that controls the level of a fluid between a minimum fluid level


52


and a maximum fluid level


54


. The fluid reservoir system


50


includes a container or tank


56


, a float assembly


58


, a limit switch


60


, a pump motor


62


and a pump


64


. The fluid reservoir system


50


may be, for example, a system that collects condensate (i.e., condensed water vapor) in one location and conveys the collected condensate away from the fluid reservoir system


50


.




The pump


64


is driven by the pump motor


62


and is coupled via a fluid conduit


66


to an opening


68


in the tank


56


. The pump motor


62


drives the pump


64


to remove fluid from the tank


56


via the fluid conduit


66


and conveys the removed fluid to an outlet conduit


70


, which carries the removed fluid away from the fluid reservoir system


50


. Preferably, the opening


68


is located below the minimum fluid level


52


to enable the pump


64


to draw fluid from the tank


56


when the fluid level is at or near the minimum level


52


without drawing air into the fluid conduit


66


and the pump


64


. While the pump


64


is configured to remove fluid from the tank


56


, alternative configurations may be used. For example, the pump


64


and the opening


68


may be configured so that the pump


64


adds fluid to the tank


56


via the fluid conduit


66


. Also, the pump


64


and/or motor


62


may be disposed within the tank


56


.




The pump motor


62


may be any electrical motor suitable for the particular application of the fluid reservoir system


50


. Additionally, the pump motor


62


may be integral with the pump


64


or may, alternatively, be separate from the pump


64


, in which case the pump motor


62


may be coupled to the pump


64


via a shaft, gear train, magnetic coupling, and/or any other suitable coupling mechanism.




The limit switch


60


includes a switch button


72


, a spring biased switch actuation arm


74


that is mounted to the limit switch


60


at a pivot point


76


and which may be moved against the spring bias to depress the switch button


72


, a common terminal


78


, a normally-open terminal


80


and a normally-closed terminal


82


. The common terminal


78


and the normally-open terminal


80


are serially interposed in the path of power supplied to the pump motor


62


so that when the switch button


72


is not depressed, the limit switch


60


is not activated and interrupts the flow of power to the pump motor


62


so that the pump


64


is inactive.




As is commonly known, limit switches, such as the limit switch


60


, are relatively inexpensive in comparison to snap-acting and detent switches, which are typically used with conventional float-based fluid level control systems. Although the float assembly described herein may be advantageously used within a fluid level control system (such as the fluid level control system


50


shown in

FIGS. 2 and 3

) to allow the use of an inexpensive limit switch for the control of a pump motor, conventional snap-acting and detent switches, as well as other types of switches, may nevertheless be used with the float assembly described herein.




The float assembly


58


rotates clockwise and counter-clockwise about a pivot axis


84


in response to changes in the fluid level within the tank


56


. The float assembly


58


includes a carrier or pivot member


88


, a lower float


90


disposed on centerline


92


, an upper float


94


, a switching surface


96


, and a pivot member stop surface


98


. The pivot member stop surface


98


contacts a wall


100


of the tank


56


to limit the clockwise rotation of the float assembly


58


and the upper float


94


contacts a tank stop surface


102


, which may be integral to the tank


56


, to limit counter-clockwise rotation of the float assembly


58


.




The switching surface


96


acts as a cam surface that converts the angular or rotational position of the float assembly


58


into a vertical displacement of the switch actuation arm


74


and the switch button


72


. Preferably, the switching surface


96


is profiled so that as the lower float centerline


92


moves to the right of a vertical line


104


extending through the pivot axis


84


, the switching surface


96


vertically displaces the switch actuation arm


74


to depress the switch button


72


, thereby activating the limit switch


60


. When activated, the limit switch


60


completes an electrical path between the common and normally-open terminals


78


and


80


which turns the pump motor


62


on so that fluid is removed from the tank


56


.




Generally speaking, the pivoting action of the float assembly


58


is determined by the pivot member


88


, the weight and buoyancy (which are a function of density and geometry) of the floats


90


and


94


, and the location of the floats


90


and


94


with respect to the pivot axis


84


and the vertical line


104


. As will be discussed in more detail below, the center of gravity of the pivot assembly


58


lies on or, preferably, to the right of the vertical line


104


as seen in

FIGS. 2 and 3

. Thus, when the fluid level is below the minimum level


52


, the float assembly


58


rotates to the fully clockwise position to drive the pivot member stop surface


98


against the wall


100


. While the weight and location of the floats


90


and


94


can substantially determine the center of gravity of the pivot assembly


58


, those skilled in the art will recognize that the center of gravity of the pivot assembly


58


is also determined, at least in part, by many other factors including, but not limited to, the materials and geometry of the pivot member


88


.




When the fluid level rises to contact one or more of the floats


90


and


94


, the buoyancies of the floats


90


and


94


become dominant in controlling the rotational position of the pivot assembly


58


. In general, the respective buoyant forces and torques provided by the floats


90


and


94


increase in direct proportion to the volume of fluid which is displaced by each of the floats


90


and


94


.




The magnitudes and directions of the buoyant torques exerted by the floats


90


and


94


change as the rotational position of the pivot assembly


58


varies. This is due to the fact that the direction and magnitude of the torque developed by each float are dependent upon the angle between the vertical line


104


and a line extending through the pivot axis


84


and the center of the float. Preferably (although not necessarily) the magnitude of the counter-clockwise buoyant torque provided by the upper float


94


increases as the pivot member


88


rotates counter-clockwise from the fully clockwise position to the fully counter-clockwise position. On the other hand, the magnitude of the torque provided by the lower float


90


decreases to zero as the pivot member


84


rotates to bring the lower float centerline


92


into coincidence with the vertical line


104


and increases from zero as the lower float centerline


92


moves to the right of the vertical line


104


.




One particularly interesting aspect of the float assembly


58


is that the direction of the buoyant torque provided by the lower float


90


changes abruptly as the lower float centerline


92


crosses the vertical line


104


. Specifically, when the lower float centerline


92


lies to the left of the vertical line


104


, the lower float


90


provides a clockwise buoyant torque and when the lower float centerline


92


lies to the right of the vertical line


104


, the lower float


90


provides a counter-clockwise buoyant torque. As described in more detail below, this abrupt reversal in the direction of the buoyant torque provided by the lower float


90


results in a snap-action pivoting movement for the pivot assembly


58


.




The manner in which the above-described torques interact to provide a snap-acting float assembly with hysteresis can be best understood in connection with the following exemplary description of the operation of the fluid reservoir system


50


of

FIGS. 2 and 3

. Initially, the tank


56


is empty, and because the center of gravity of the pivot assembly


58


lies to the right of the vertical line


104


, the pivot member


58


to rotates fully clockwise to drive the pivot stop surface


98


against the wall


100


. With the float assembly


58


in the fully clockwise position (i.e., with the pivot member stop surface


98


in contact with the wall


100


), the switching surface


96


is spaced from the switch actuation arm


74


allowing the arm


74


to be biased downwardly so that the switch button


72


is not depressed. As a result, the pump motor


62


and pump


64


are off, and fluid is not removed from the tank


56


.




As the fluid level within the tank


56


rises, the fluid first contacts the lower float


90


, which causes the lower float


90


to exert a clockwise buoyant torque on the float assembly


58


, thereby holding the pivot member stop surface


98


firmly in place against the wall


100


(as shown in FIG.


2


). Further, as the fluid level continues to rise, an increasing proportion of the lower float


90


becomes submerged which increases the clockwise buoyant torque provided by the lower float


90


. When the fluid level rises sufficiently high to completely submerge the lower float


90


, the lower float


90


exerts a maximum clockwise buoyant torque on the pivot assembly


58


.




When the fluid level rises to contact the upper float


94


, the upper float


94


begins to provide a counter-clockwise buoyant torque to the pivot assembly


58


. Eventually, when a sufficient portion of the upper float


94


becomes submerged, the counter-clockwise buoyant torque provided by the upper float


94


exceeds the maximum clockwise buoyant torque provided by the lower float


90


. This effect may be achieved in any suitable manner, such as by designing the upper float


94


to have a greater buoyancy than the lower float


90


and/or locating the upper float


94


at a suitable distance from the pivot axis


84


relative to the distance of the lower float


90


from the pivot axis


84


, etc. In any event, further increases in the fluid level cause the pivot assembly


58


to rotate counter-clockwise. When the fluid level rises sufficiently (i.e., to the maximum fluid level


54


) to cause the lower float centerline


92


to cross the vertical line


104


, the clockwise buoyant torque provided by the lower float


90


abruptly changes direction to become a counter-clockwise buoyant torque which, without any further increase in the fluid level, causes the float assembly


58


to rotate fully counter-clockwise so that the upper float


94


is driven against the tank stop surface


102


(as shown in FIG.


3


). Additionally, as the lower float centerline


92


crosses to the right of the vertical line


104


, the switching surface


96


displaces the switch actuation arm


74


upward to depress the switch button


72


and activate the limit switch


60


. When activated, the limit switch


60


provides an electrical path between the common and normally-open terminals


78


and


80


to turn the pump motor


62


on, which drives the pump


64


to remove fluid from the tank


56


.




As the pump


64


decreases the fluid level within the tank


56


to below the level of the upper float


94


, the float assembly


58


remains rotated fully counter-clockwise with the upper float


94


driven against the tank stop surface


102


. The float assembly remains in the fully counter-clockwise position because the lower float centerline


92


remains to the right of the vertical line


104


and the lower float


90


provides a counter-clockwise buoyant torque that is greater than the clockwise torque provided by the weight of the pivot assembly


58


. As a result, the limit switch


60


continues to provide power to the pump motor


62


and the pump


64


continues to remove fluid from the tank


56


.




When the fluid level decreases to about the minimum level


52


(as shown in FIG.


2


), the counter-clockwise buoyant torque provided by the lower float


90


becomes substantially zero and the clockwise torque provided by the weight of the pivot assembly


58


causes the float assembly


58


to rotate fully clockwise to drive the pivot member stop surface


98


against the wall


100


, thereby allowing the spring biased switch actuation arm


74


to move downward to deactivate the limit switch


60


, which turns off the pump motor


62


so that the pump


64


stops removing fluid from the tank


56


.




As can be understood from the above discussion of the operation of the float assembly


58


, the switching surface


96


of the float assembly


58


causes the limit switch


60


to switch between two switching states so that one of the two states turns the pump motor


62


on at the maximum fluid level


54


and the other of the two switching states turns the pump motor


62


off at the minimum fluid level


52


. Thus, the operation of the float assembly


58


provides switching hysteresis that eliminates rapid cycling of the pump motor


62


. Additionally, the float assembly described herein provides a positive detent or snap-action switching action due to the reversal of the direction of the buoyant torque provided by lower float


90


that occurs as the lower float centerline


92


crosses the vertical line


104


.




Those skilled in the art will recognize that the floats


90


and


94


may be made from any suitable material providing buoyancy such as, for example, styrofoam. Additionally, the floats


90


and


94


may be approximately spherical in shape or may, alternatively, be of any other shape needed to accomplish the above-described pivoting action in response to a fluid level. In fact, the floats


90


and


94


may be integrated so that the function of the separate floats


90


and


94


is accomplished using a substantially one-piece float. Further, the shape, material, volume, location with respect to the pivot axis


84


and one another, etc. of the floats


90


and


94


may be different, if needed, to provide any desired pivoting action, minimum fluid level, maximum fluid level, etc. Still further, those skilled in the art will recognize that the upper float


94


may be eliminated altogether and instead a lever arm or any other mechanical and/or electromechanical device may be substituted and manually or automatically controlled based on fluid level or some other parameter to apply a torque to the pivot assembly


58


to cause the lower float centerline


92


to cross the vertical line


104


.





FIG. 4

is an exemplary isometric view of a pivot member


120


that may be used with the float assembly


58


shown in

FIGS. 2 and 3

. The pivot member


120


includes barbed fittings


122


and


124


for securely engaging with complementary openings (not shown) in the floats


90


and


94


, shoulder portions


126


and


128


, a pivot bearing


130


, a cam surface


132


, and stops


134


and


136


. Fillets or webs


138


and


140


(and other fillets which are not shown) may be included to strengthen the shoulder portions


126


and


128


to prevent breakage of the barbed fittings


122


and


124


when pressing the floats


90


and


94


onto the barbed fittings


122


and


124


. Preferably, the pivot member


120


is a one-piece structure molded from a thermoplastic material. Alternatively, the pivot member


120


may be a die-cast part or may be fabricated using one or more component pieces from plastics, metals, and/or any other suitable materials.




Those of ordinary skill in the art will readily appreciate that a range of changes and modifications can be made to the preferred embodiments described above. The foregoing detailed description should be regarded as illustrative rather than limiting and the following claims, including all equivalents, are intended to define the scope of the invention.



Claims
  • 1. A float assembly, comprising:a carrier rotatable about a pivot axis and including an actuation surface which is disposed at an actuating position when the carrier is disposed at a first rotational position and which is moved away from the actuating position when the carrier is rotated away from the first rotational position toward a second rotatable position; and a pair of spaced floats coupled to the carrier wherein the floats are disposed on a certain side of a vertical line extending through the pivot axis when the carrier is disposed at the first rotational position and wherein the floats are disposed on opposite sides of the vertical line extending through the pivot axis when the carrier is disposed at the second rotational position.
  • 2. The float assembly of claim 1, in combination with a switch.
  • 3. The float assembly of claim 2, wherein the switch includes an actuation arm which is moved to a switch actuation position by the actuation surface as the carrier is rotated toward the first rotational position.
  • 4. The float assembly of claim 2, wherein the actuation arm is biased by a spring to a switch deactuation position as the carrier is rotated toward the second rotational position.
  • 5. The float assembly of claim 1, in combination with a container within which the float assembly is mounted.
  • 6. The float assembly of claim 5, wherein the container includes a container stop surface which is contacted by one of the floats when the carrier is disposed in the first rotational position.
  • 7. The float assembly of claim 5, wherein the carrier includes a carrier stop surface that contacts a wall of the container when the carrier is disposed in the second rotational position.
  • 8. The float assembly of claim 5, wherein the container is adapted to hold a liquid having a varying liquid level and wherein one of the floats is disposed below the other float and the one float exerts a torque in a first direction on the carrier when the liquid level is above a first level but below a second level and exerts a torque in a second direction different than the first direction on the carrier when the liquid level is above the second level.
  • 9. The float assembly of claim 8, wherein the other float exerts a torque in the second direction when the liquid level is above the second level.
  • 10. The float assembly of claim 1, wherein a center of gravity of the carrier and the floats is disposed on the certain side of the vertical line extending through the pivot axis.
  • 11. A float assembly for actuating a switch based on a level of a fluid, the float assembly comprising.a pivot member having a pivot axis and a switching surface; a first float coupled to the pivot member; and a second float coupled to the pivot member, wherein at a first fluid level the first and second floats lie on different sides of a vertical line extending through the pivot axis and the switching surface causes the switch to assume a first switching state, and wherein at a second fluid level the first and second floats lie on the same side of the vertical line extending through the pivot axis and the switching surface causes the switch to assume a second switching state.
  • 12. The float assembly of claim 11, wherein the first float is coupled to the pivot member at a first location with respect to the pivot axis and the second float is coupled to the pivot member at a second location with respect to the pivot axis.
  • 13. The float assembly of claim 11, wherein the first float provides a first buoyant torque about the pivot axis and the second float provides a second buoyant torque about the pivot axis greater than the first buoyant torque.
  • 14. The float assembly of claim 13, wherein the first and second buoyant torques are in different directions.
  • 15. The float assembly of claim 11, wherein the switching surface comprises a cam surface that is profiled to actuate the switch between on and off states when a centerline of one of the first and second floats crosses the vertical line extending through the pivot axis.
  • 16. The float assembly of claim 11, further including a pump coupled to the switch and wherein the first switching state turns the pump off to allow the fluid level to increase and the second switching state turns the pump on to cause the fluid level to decrease.
  • 17. The float assembly of claim 11, wherein the first and second floats have substantially the same shape.
  • 18. The float assembly of claim 11, wherein the first and second floats have substantially the same density.
  • 19. A float assembly, comprising:a pivot member having a pivot axis; a float coupled to the pivot member to provide a first torque to the pivot member in a first direction when the float lies substantially to one side of a vertical line extending through the pivot axis and a second torque in a second direction to the pivot member when the float lies substantially on another side of the vertical line extending through the pivot axis; and means for applying a third torque in the second direction to the pivot member to cause the float to move from substantially one side to substantially the other side of the vertical line through the pivot axis.
  • 20. The float assembly of claim 19, wherein the means for applying the third torque comprises a second float.
  • 21. The float assembly of claim 20, wherein at a first level of a fluid the first and second floats lie on different sides of the vertical line extending through the pivot axis and wherein at a second level of the first and second floats to lie on the same side of the vertical line extending through the pivot axis.
  • 22. The float assembly of claim 19, wherein the pivot member further includes a switching surface that causes a switch to switch between first and second switching states associated with respective first and second levels of a fluid.
  • 23. A float assembly for use in controlling a fluid within a fluid reservoir system having a tank that holds the fluid, a pump motor, and a limit switch serially interposed in an electrical path supplying power to the pump motor, the float assembly comprising:pivot member having a pivot axis and a switching surface; a first float coupled to the pivot member; and a second float coupled to the pivot member, wherein at a first level of the fluid in the tank the first and second floats lie on different sides of a vertical line extending through the pivot axis and the switching surface causes the limit switch to assume a first switching state that changes the flow of power to the pump motor, and wherein at a second level of the fluid the first and second floats lie on the same side of the vertical line extending through the pivot axis and the switching surface causes the limit switch to assume a second switching state that changes the flow of power to the pump motor.
  • 24. The float assembly of claim 23, wherein the first float provides a first buoyant torque about the pivot axis which is less than a second buoyant torque provided by the second float.
  • 25. The float assembly of claim 24, wherein the first and second buoyant torques oppose one another.
  • 26. The float assembly of claim 23, wherein the second fluid level is greater than the first fluid level.
  • 27. The float assembly of claim 23, wherein the first switching state turns the pump motor off and the second switching state turns the pump motor on.
  • 28. The float assembly of claim 23, wherein the first switching state allows the fluid level in the tank to increase and the second switching state allows the fluid level in the tank to decrease.
  • 29. The float assembly of claim 23, wherein the first and second floats have substantially the same shape.
  • 30. The float assembly of claim 23, wherein the first and second floats have substantially the same volume.
  • 31. The float assembly of claim 23, wherein the first and second floats have substantially the same density.
US Referenced Citations (22)
Number Name Date Kind
495377 Searle Apr 1893
1882196 Siems Oct 1932
2054205 Palmer Sep 1936
2433968 Wiseley Jan 1948
2592908 Katz Apr 1952
2616003 MacDonald Oct 1952
2616004 Richards Oct 1952
2694171 Campbell Nov 1954
2761467 Arne Sep 1956
2920644 Schulze et al. Jan 1960
3116383 Hoffner Dec 1963
3153422 Marsee et al. Oct 1964
3594722 Shultz Jul 1971
3619084 Gordon Nov 1971
3989043 Dimeff Nov 1976
4080985 Eagle Mar 1978
4081638 Thorn et al. Mar 1978
4084073 Keener Apr 1978
4301824 Payne Nov 1981
5309939 Stickel et al. May 1994
5493086 Murphy, Jr. et al. Feb 1996
5814780 Batchelder et al. Sep 1998