This application is based upon and claims the benefit of priority from Japanese Patent Application No. 2011-099567, filed on Apr. 27, 2011, the entire contents of which are incorporated herein by reference.
Embodiments described herein relate generally to a sound signal processor and a sound signal processing method.
When a user personally listens to reproduced music and voice, he/she often uses headphones such as earphones and stereo phones. Frequency characteristics of the sound output from headphones differ for different products, thereby the sound output from the headphones do not always have a user desired frequency characteristic.
Therefore, there are demands for the sound output from the headphones to have a user desired frequency characteristic.
Conventionally, it is difficult to appropriately correct the frequency characteristic of the earphone at when the user uses the earphone, because there is provided no means to objectively measure the correct frequency characteristic. On the other hand, when an equalizer is used for manual adjustment of the frequency characteristic, a user needs to subjectively adjust the equalizer while listening to musical sound. In this case, the user often repeats the adjustment by trial and error because the subjective adjustment is influenced by, for example, a sound source and the user's mood. Thus, it is difficult to properly correct the sound from the earphone. Furthermore, as a reproducible measurement technique, there is known a technique using a jig of a special type, but this requires the jig for every measurement.
A general architecture that implements the various features of the invention will now be described with reference to the drawings. The drawings and the associated descriptions are provided to illustrate embodiments of the invention and not to limit the scope of the invention.
In general, according to one embodiment, a sound signal processor comprises: a connector; an input module; and a generator. The connector is configured to be connectable with an earphone. The input module is configured to receive and process a plurality of sound signals corresponding to sound of a plurality of times output from the earphone, respectively. The generator is configured to generate, by using first data indicating a frequency characteristic of a first sound signal among the received and processed sound signals and second data indicating a frequency characteristic of a second sound signal among the received and processed sound signals, correction data correcting a frequency characteristic of the earphone to be a target frequency characteristic set as a target. The first data is used for a first frequency band lower than or equal to a reference. The second data is used for a second frequency band higher than the reference.
In following embodiments, a sound signal processor is applied to a personal computer (PC).
The computer body 111 has a thin box shape, and a keyboard 113 on a top surface thereof. The computer body 111 comprises a microphone. The computer body 111 has a microphone hole 102 so that the microphone can efficiently collect sound. The computer body 111 comprises an output terminal for headphones (also referred to as a headphone terminal) on a side surface thereof. The computer body 111 can be connected to an earphone 101 through the headphone terminal. The earphone 101 is one of a pair of earphones.
The plug of the earphones (the earphone 101) is inserted into the headphone terminal of the PC 100. The PC 100 transmits a measurement signal from the earphone 101 through the headphone terminal. The PC 100 can measure a characteristic of the earphone 101 by collecting the signal with the microphone.
The CPU 201 is a processor that controls operation of the PC 100. The CPU 201 executes an operating system (OS) 221, and various application programs such as a media player 222, which are loaded from the HDD 211 to the main memory 203. The media player 222 is application software to reproduce moving picture (video) files and audio files. The CPU 201 executes a BIOS stored in the BIOS-ROM 209. The BIOS is a program for hardware control.
The north bridge 202 is a bridging device connecting a local bus of the CPU 201 with the south bridge 204. The north bridge 202 comprises a memory controller to control access to the main memory 203. The north bridge 202 has a function to communicate with the GPU 205 through a serial bus compliant with the peripheral components interconnection (PCI) EXPRESS standard, for example.
The GPU 205 is a display controller controlling a liquid crystal display panel used as a display monitor of the PC 100. The GPU 205 uses a video random access memory (VRAM), which is not illustrated, as a working memory. Video signal generated by the GPU 205 is transmitted to the liquid crystal display panel.
The south bridge 204 controls devices connected to each other through the bus. The south bridge 204 comprises a serial advanced technology attachment (SATA) controller to control the HDD 211 and the DVD drive 212. The south bridge 204 has a function to communicate with the sound controller 206. The sound controller 206 is a sound source device, and comprises circuits such as a digital-to-analog (D/A) converter converting a digital signal into an analog electrical signal, and an amplifier amplifying electrical signals. The sound controller 206 further comprises a circuit, such as an analog-to-digital (A/D) converter to convert an analog electrical signal received from a microphone 213 into a digital signal.
The EC/KBC IC 216 is a one-chip microcomputer in which an embedded controller for power control and a keyboard controller for controlling the keyboard (KB) 113 are integrated.
There is a technique for measuring a frequency characteristic of an earphone with good reproducibility by using a jig.
The earphone 101 to be measured is attached to the jig, and then the PC 400 acquires data from the earphone 101. In data acquired by a measurement method using the jig, resonance produced in an external auditory canal of a user is excluded from the characteristics of sound when the user practically listens. Therefore, a frequency characteristic of a high-quality sound earphone and a frequency characteristic of an earphone that a user uses (hereinafter, also referred to as user earphone) are acquired by using a common measurement system using the jig. When the user uses the earphone, sound quality of the user's earphone can be approximated to sound quality of the high-quality sound earphone by setting an equalizer in such a manner that the frequency characteristic of the user's earphone is approximated to that of the high-quality sound earphone.
When employing the measurement technique using the jig, a user needs to purchase the jig, and measure the frequency characteristic of the earphone by using the jig so as to set desired sound quality, thereby incurring costs. In the first embodiment, the frequency characteristic of the earphone is measured without using the jig. The inventors have studied a method to measure the frequency characteristic of an earphone with good reproducibility without using a jig, and have found, based on experiments, that it is effective for achieving the good reproducible measurement method by combining measurement results measured in different conditions a plurality of times. The PC 100 according to the first embodiment measures the frequency characteristic of the earphone in different conditions a plurality of times, and combines the measurement results so that the frequency characteristic of the earphone is determined without using a jig. In the following, conditions of an earphone during the measurement of the frequency characteristic are described.
In view of the above data, the PC 100 according to the embodiment can appropriately correct the frequency characteristic of an earphone as follows: the frequency characteristic of the earphone is measured in the close contact state and the gap state, and designs a correction filter by combining those frequency characteristics.
Referring back to
The correction-reproduction module 320 of the media player 222 comprises a correction filter 321, a sound signal output module 322, a measurement signal storage module 325, a display controller 323, and an operation receiver 324. The correction-reproduction module 320 corrects and outputs sound. The correct sound is heard as sound similar to that output from an ideal earphone when heard by the earphone used for the measurement. For example, a user can enjoy music with high-quality sound when reproducing the music by using the earphone.
The measurement signal storage module 325 stores therein a sound signal used for measuring the frequency characteristic of the earphone 101.
The sound signal output module 322 outputs a sound signal from the earphone 101 connected to the output terminal 214 through the correction filter 321. The sound signal output module 322 outputs a sound signal stored in the sound signal output module 322 if needed. The sound signal output by the sound signal output module 322 is not limited to the measurement sound signal. For example, a sound signal received from an outside and a sound signal stored in the HDD 211 of the PC 100 may be applicable. When a measurement signal is output, the correction filter 321 is set so as not to perform correction.
The correction filter 321 corrects a sound signal received from the sound signal output module 322 by using the correction filter (correction parameters) 321 set by the signal measurement module 310. The correction parameters are described later. An example of the correction filter 321 is a typical parametric equalizer.
The display controller 323 displays a display allowing a user to start measuring the frequency characteristic of the earphone 101 when measuring data. The operation receiver 324 receives a selection of the start of measurement from the user.
The signal measurement module 310 of the media player 222 comprises an input module 311, a measurement module 312, a signal temporary storage module 313, a correction filter design module 314, and a target characteristic storage module 315.
The target characteristic storage module 315 stores therein the frequency characteristic of a high-quality sound earphone that is preliminarily provided as a reference. The frequency characteristic stored in the target characteristic storage module 315 is not limited to the frequency characteristic of the high-quality sound earphone. Any frequency characteristic may be applicable as long as it is used as a target frequency characteristic of an earphone that a user uses. For example, a frequency characteristic modified in accordance with user's preference may be stored. In addition, the number of stored frequency characteristics is not limited to one. A plurality of frequency characteristics that a user regards as ideal may be stored, and the user may select a desired frequency characteristic from them.
The microphone 213 converts input sound into an electrical signal.
The input module 311 receives a sound signal through the microphone 213, and processes the sound signal. The input module 311 converts an electrical signal representing sound into a digital signal by using the A/D converter, and outputs the digital signal to the measurement module 312. When a measurement sound signal is output from the earphone 101 for a plurality of times, the input module 311 receives and processes the sound signals corresponding to the sound of the plurality of times, respectively.
The measurement module 312 measures a sound pressure level of sound based on a digital sound signal received from the input module 311. The measurement module 312 generates measurement data indicating a frequency characteristic of the sound signal based on the measured sound pressure level. The measurement module 312 stores the generated measurement data indicating the frequency characteristic in the signal temporary storage module 313.
The signal temporary storage module 313 temporarily stores therein the measurement data indicating the frequency characteristic of the sound signal, which is stored by the measurement module 312, until the correction filter design module 314 reads the measurement data.
The correction filter design module 314 comprises a combining module 316, a generator 317, and a setting module 318. The correction filter design module 314 designs a correction filter in such a manner that the frequency characteristic of the user's earphone is approximated to the frequency characteristic of the high-quality sound earphone stored in the target characteristic storage module 315 as the target characteristic.
In the embodiment, it is advantageous that an equalizer is designed by using the first measurement data in a frequency band of equal to or lower than about 800 Hz as illustrated in
The combining module 316 combines the first measurement data of the frequency characteristic of a sound signal of the earphone 101 in the frequency band of equal to or lower than about 800 Hz, and the second measurement data of the frequency characteristic of the sound signal of the earphone 101 in the frequency band of higher than about 800 Hz so as to generate measurement data of a frequency characteristic to be corrected.
The term “about 800 Hz” used in the first embodiment as a reference means a predetermined frequency band. When the first measurement data and the second measurement data are combined with each other, the combining module 316 decreases a ratio of using the first measurement data and increases a ratio of using the second measurement data, as the frequency increases in the predetermined frequency band.
In the embodiment, the predetermined frequency band is set between 600 Hz and 900 Hz. The combining module 316 combines the first measurement data and the second measurement data in the frequency band while continuously changing the ratio of the first measurement data and the second measurement data. The change of the ratio can suppress discrepancy to occur at the border of the frequency bands.
As a detailed example, the combining module 316 changes the ratio of the first measurement data as follows: the ratio is 100% in a frequency band of equal to or lower than 600 Hz, the ratio is gradually decreased from 100% to 0% from 600 Hz to 900 Hz, and the ratio is 0% in a frequency band of higher than 900 Hz. The combining module 316 uses the second measurement data in accordance with the remaining ratio.
The generator 317 generates correction parameters based on a difference between target frequency characteristic data stored in the target characteristic storage module 315 and measurement data, which is combined by the combining module 316, of the frequency characteristic, which is to be corrected, of the earphone 101. The generator 317 generates the correction parameters so that the combined frequency characteristic of the earphone 101 is approximated to the target frequency characteristic, in relation to sound that is output from the earphone 101 and reaches an eardrum of a user. The correction parameters comprise parameters used in a typical parametric equalizer, for example. The parameters used in the parametric equalizer are a center frequency, a width of a frequency band to be adjusted, and a gain.
The technique generating the correction parameters is not limited to that of the embodiment, i.e., the correction parameters are generated after the combination of measurement data. Any technique may be employed as long as the technique can generate the correction parameters that correct the combined frequency characteristic of the earphone 101 so as to be the target frequency characteristic by the following manner: the generator 317 uses, in a frequency band of equal to or lower than a reference, data indicating the frequency characteristic of a sound signal measured in the state in which the earphone 101 and the microphone 213 are brought close in contact with each other, and uses, in a frequency band of higher than the reference, data indicating the frequency characteristic of a sound signal measured in the state in which a gap is provided between the earphone 101 and the microphone 213.
The setting module 318 sets the correction parameters produced by the generator 317 to the correction filter 321.
Measurement variance in acquiring the second measurement data in the state in which a gap is provided between the earphone 101 and the microphone 213 is described below. One of the techniques to provide a gap between the earphone 101 and the microphone 213 is illustrated in
The combining module 316 according to the first embodiment shifts (normalizes) the level of the second measurement data so that a difference between an average level of the first measurement data and an average level of the second measurement data in a frequency band of from 600 Hz to 900 Hz, which is a reference for combining, is to be a fixed value. In the embodiment, the fixed value is set as zero dB. The fixed value, however, is not limited to zero dB, and any value may be set.
Specifically, the combining module 316 normalizes the second measurement data with an offset amount of 28.3 dB for the measurement result 1301 of a small gap. The combining module 316 normalizes the second measurement data with an offset amount of 32.4 dB for the measurement result 1302 of a large gap. Both measurement data allows the measurement data 1201 of the earphone 101 illustrated in
A sound pressure level measured in the state in which a gap is provided between the earphone 101 and the microphone 213 is smaller than that measured in the state in which the earphone 101 and the microphone 213 are brought close in contact with each other. The PC 100 according to the embodiment, thus, adjusts at least one of a sound volume of a sound signal output by the sound signal output module 322 through the earphone 101 and sensitivity of the microphone 213, through which the input module 311 receives a sound signal to be processed, so as to be larger when a sound signal is measured in the gap state (the second measurement data is received and processed) than when a sound signal is measured in the close contact state (the first measurement data is received and processed). Even if measurement is performed by changing a volume of a sound output from the earphone 101, no combination result theoretically varies because of the same reasons as described above. As a result of the adjustment, measurement in the gap state can be performed with high accuracy because it is hardly affected by surrounding noises.
Setting processing of the correction filter in the PC 100 according to the embodiment is described below.
The media player 222 detects whether the earphone 101 is connected to the output terminal 214 (S1401). If it is detected that the earphone 101 is not connected to the output terminal 214 (No at S1401), the display controller 323 displays a display urging a user to connect the earphone 101 to the output terminal 214 (S1402), and the media player 222 detects again whether the earphone 101 is connected to the output terminal 214 (S1401).
On the other hand, if the media player 222 detects that the earphone 101 is connected to the output terminal 214 (Yes at S1401), the setting module 318 of the correction filter design module 314 sets the correction filter 321 so as not to perform correction, and initializes the sound settings for measurement (S1403).
The display controller 323 displays a guidance display urging a user to hold the earphone 101 such that the earphone 101 is brought close in contact with the microphone 213 (S1404). An example of the guidance display is the screen illustrated in
After the user holds the earphone 101 such that the earphone 101 is brought close in contact with the microphone 213, operation to start measurement is performed. The operation receiver 324 receives the operation to start measurement from the user (S1405). Then, the sound signal output module 322 reads a measurement sound signal from the measurement signal storage module 325, and reproduces (outputs) the sound signal from the earphone 101 (S1406).
Then, the input module 311 receives the sound signal through the microphone 213, and processes the sound signal (S1407). The measurement module 312 generates the first measurement data indicating the frequency characteristic of the sound signal based on the sound signal received from the input module 311. The measurement module 312 determines whether error occurs during the generation of the first measurement data (S1408). If it is determined that the error occurs (Yes at S1408), the procedure returns to S1404 to start processing from S1404 for re-measurement.
On the other hand, if determining that no error occurs (No at S1408), the measurement module 312 stores the generated first measurement data in the signal temporary storage module 313. Thereafter, the display controller 323 displays a guidance display urging the user to slant and hold the earphone 101 such that a gap is provided between the earphone 101 and the microphone 213 (S1409). An example of the guidance display is the screen illustrated in
Then, in order to achieve high accuracy measurement in the gap state, an adjustment is performed such that a sound volume of a sound signal output by the sound signal output module 322 through the earphone 101 is increased, or such that sensitivity of the microphone 213 through which the input module 311 receives a sound signal to be processed is increased (S1410). The adjustment is not limited to be performed on only one item. The adjustment may be performed on both of the sound volume and the sensitivity.
Then, after the user slants and holds the earphone 101 so as to provide a gap between the earphone 101 and the microphone 213, operation to start measurement is performed. The operation receiver 324 receives the operation to start measurement from the user (S1411). Then, the sound signal output module 322 reads a measurement sound signal from the measurement signal storage module 325, and reproduces (outputs) the sound signal from the earphone 101 (S1412).
Then, the input module 311 receives the sound signal through the microphone 213, and processes the sound signal (S1413). The measurement module 312 produces the second measurement data indicating the frequency characteristic of the sound signal based on the sound signal received from the input module 311. The measurement module 312 determines whether error occurs during the generation of the second measurement data (S1414). If it is determined that error occurs (Yes at S1414), the procedure returns to S1409 to start processing from S1409 for re-measurement.
On the other hand, if determining that no error occurs (No at S1414), the measurement module 312 stores the generated second measurement data in the signal temporary storage module 313. Thereafter, the combining module 316 combines measurement data of the received and processed sound signal (S1415). Specifically, the combining module 316 reads the first measurement data and the second measurement data stored in the signal temporary storage module 313, and combines two pieces of measurement data by using the above-described technique.
The generator 317 generates correction parameters based on a difference between target frequency characteristic data stored in the target characteristic storage module 315, and measurement data, which is combined by the combining module 316, of the frequency characteristic, which is to be corrected, of the earphone 101 (S1416).
Then, the setting module 318 sets the correction parameters generated by the generator 317 to the correction filter 321 (S1417). The setting module 318 writes again the sound settings initialized at S1403 except the correction parameters (S1418).
Through the above-described processing procedure with PC, a correction filter suitable for the earphone 101 is designed. The sound quality of the earphone 101 is changed to the sound quality of the high-quality sound earphone or sound quality according to user's preference.
In the embodiment, first, measurement is performed in the state in which the earphone 101 and the microphone 213 are brought close in contact with each other, and thereafter measurement is performed in the state in which a gap is provided between the earphone 101 and the microphone 213. The order may be reversed, i.e., first, measurement is performed in the state in which a gap is provided between the earphone 101 and the microphone 213, and thereafter the measurement is performed in the state in which the earphone 101 and the microphone 213 are made close contact with each other.
In the embodiment, the frequency characteristic of an earphone that a user uses is adjusted so as to be approximated to the frequency characteristic of a high-quality sound earphone as a reference. The target frequency characteristic is not limited to that of the actual product such as the high-quality sound earphone. Any target frequency characteristic may be produced as the target obtained by changing the frequency characteristic of the user's earphone.
In the embodiment, about 800 Hz (a frequency band from 600 Hz to 900 Hz) is used as the reference. However, such reference varies for different embodiments. Thus, the reference may suitable be set through experiments and the like, according to different embodiments.
As described above, the PC 100 according to the embodiment enables the frequency characteristic of an earphone to be easily measured without using an expensive measuring device and special equipment such as a jig. As a result, the frequency characteristic of the earphone can be corrected so as to be a frequency characteristic suitable for the earphone.
In the first embodiment, the frequency characteristic of the high-quality sound earphone is stored in the target characteristic storage module 315, as a target. However, a user may prepare any earphone as the target. In this case, correction can be performed by measuring the frequency characteristics of the targeted earphone and an earphone to be corrected in the close contact state and the gap state.
In the first embodiment, the PC 100 reproduces audio data by using the correction filter 321. The reproduction of audio data is not limited to be preformed by the PC 100 as described in the first embodiment. In a second embodiment, correction is performed by an audio reproduction device that is not included in the PC.
The audio reproduction device 1550 comprises an output terminal 1551, a correction filter 1552, a reproducer 1553, and an audio data storage module 1554. The output terminal 1551 is connectable to the earphone 101.
The audio data storage module 1554 stores therein audio data to be reproduced. The reproducer 1553 reads audio data from the audio data storage module 1554, and reproduces the audio data.
The correction filter 1552 corrects an audio signal reproduced by the reproducer 1553 from the audio data. The correction parameters used for correction performed by the correction filter 1552 are set by the PC 1500. The audio signal corrected by the correction filter 1552 is output from the earphone 101 through the output terminal 1551.
The media player 1501 of the PC 1500 comprises a signal measurement module 1510 that performs different processing from that of the signal measurement module 310 of the first embodiment.
The signal measurement module 1510 differs from the signal measurement module 310 of the first embodiment in that the setting module 318 is replaced with a setting module 1512 that performs different processing from that of the setting module 318 in a correction filter design module 1511.
The setting module 1512 sets the correction parameters produced by the generator 317 to the correction filter 1552 of the audio reproduction device 1550.
With the configuration of the second embodiment, the audio reproduction device 1550, which though does not generate the correction parameters, can correct the frequency characteristic of a connected earphone so as to be a frequency characteristic suitable for the earphone.
In the second embodiment, the audio reproduction device 1550 is provided with the correction filter 1552. In a third embodiment, the audio reproduction device is provided with no correction filter.
The audio reproduction device 1650 comprises an output terminal 1651, a reproducer 1652, and an audio data storage module 1653. The output terminal 1651 is connectable with an earphone.
The audio data storage module 1653 stores therein audio data to be reproduced. The reproducer 1652 reads audio data from the audio data storage module 1653, and reproduces the audio data.
The media player 1601 of the PC 1600 comprises a correction-reproduction module 1620 that performs different processing from that of the correction-reproduction module 320 of the first embodiment.
Audio data is corrected by a correction filter 1621 of the correction-reproduction module 1620, and stored in the audio data storage module 1653 of the audio reproduction device 1650. In this way, the configuration of the third embodiment enables audio data corrected so as to be suitable for a connected earphone to be stored in the audio data storage module 1653.
According to the third embodiment, even the audio reproduction device 1650 comprising no correction filter can obtain an effect of correction suitable for an earphone.
As described above, according to the first to the third embodiments, correction can be appropriately performed corresponding to the frequency characteristic of an earphone.
The media player program executed by the PC of the embodiments is recorded into a computer readable storage medium with a format installable in or a file executable by a computer, and provided. The examples of the storage medium comprise a compact disk ROM (CD-ROM), a flexible disk (FD), a CD-recordable (CD-R), and a digital versatile disk (DVD).
The media player program executed by the PC of the embodiments may be stored in a computer coupled with a network such as the Internet, and be provided by being downloaded through the network. The media player program executed by the PC of the embodiments may be provided or delivered through a network such as the Internet.
The media player program executed by the PC of the embodiments may be provided by being preliminarily stored in the ROM, for example.
The media player program executed by the PC of the embodiments has a module structure comprising the above-described modules (signal measurement module and correction-reproduction module). In actual hardware, the CPU (processor) reads the media player program from the recording medium and executes the media player program. Once the media player program is executed, the modules are loaded into a main storage, so that the signal measurement module and the correction-reproduction module are formed in the main storage.
Moreover, the various modules of the systems described herein can be implemented as software applications, hardware and/or software modules, or components on one or more computers, such as servers. While the various modules are illustrated separately, they may share some or all of the same underlying logic or code.
While certain embodiments have been described, these embodiments have been presented by way of example only, and are not intended to limit the scope of the inventions. Indeed, the novel embodiments described herein may be embodied in a variety of other forms; furthermore, various omissions, substitutions and changes in the form of the embodiments described herein may be made without departing from the spirit of the inventions. The accompanying claims and their equivalents are intended to cover such forms or modifications as would fall within the scope and spirit of the inventions.
Number | Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
2011-099567 | Apr 2011 | JP | national |
Number | Name | Date | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
5844998 | Nageno | Dec 1998 | A |
7715568 | Nakano | May 2010 | B2 |
8050421 | Fukuda et al. | Nov 2011 | B2 |
8081769 | Fukuda et al. | Dec 2011 | B2 |
8306250 | Watanabe | Nov 2012 | B2 |
20030179891 | Rabinowitz et al. | Sep 2003 | A1 |
20050238176 | Nakano | Oct 2005 | A1 |
20060093159 | Koh et al. | May 2006 | A1 |
20080118078 | Asada et al. | May 2008 | A1 |
20090208027 | Fukuda et al. | Aug 2009 | A1 |
20090296949 | Iwata et al. | Dec 2009 | A1 |
20100053210 | Kon | Mar 2010 | A1 |
20100177910 | Watanabe | Jul 2010 | A1 |
20100278371 | Hanada | Nov 2010 | A1 |
20100329481 | Fukuda et al. | Dec 2010 | A1 |
20110002471 | Wihardja et al. | Jan 2011 | A1 |
20110003615 | Langereis | Jan 2011 | A1 |
20110164757 | Sibbald et al. | Jul 2011 | A1 |
20110222696 | Balachandran et al. | Sep 2011 | A1 |
20120219161 | Amada et al. | Aug 2012 | A1 |
Number | Date | Country |
---|---|---|
H 01-314097 | Dec 1989 | JP |
04-010799 | Feb 1992 | JP |
H 09-185383 | Jul 1997 | JP |
2005-309212 | Nov 2005 | JP |
2005-318061 | Nov 2005 | JP |
2007-043295 | Feb 2007 | JP |
2007-240704 | Sep 2007 | JP |
2008-131089 | Jun 2008 | JP |
2008-268257 | Nov 2008 | JP |
2009-194769 | Aug 2009 | JP |
2009-284097 | Dec 2009 | JP |
2010-056589 | Mar 2010 | JP |
2010-081071 | Apr 2010 | JP |
2010-226332 | Oct 2010 | JP |
2011-015080 | Jan 2011 | JP |
WO 2009-125567 | Oct 2009 | WO |
WO 2009125567 | Oct 2009 | WO |
Entry |
---|
Japanese Patent Application No. 2011-099567, Notice of Rejection, mailed Mar. 13, 2012, (with English Translation). |
Japanese Patent Application No. 2011-0422625, First Office Action, mailed Jan. 31, 2012, (with English Translation). |
Japanese Patent Application No. 2012-067588, First Office Action, mailed Apr. 16, 2013, (with English Translation). |
U.S. Appl. No. 13/294,479, Non-Final Office Action, mailed Dec. 31, 2013. |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
20120275616 A1 | Nov 2012 | US |