Sports racket with undulations in frame interior surface

Information

  • Patent Grant
  • 6447412
  • Patent Number
    6,447,412
  • Date Filed
    Tuesday, April 18, 2000
    24 years ago
  • Date Issued
    Tuesday, September 10, 2002
    22 years ago
Abstract
A sports racquet comprises a handle and a frame coupled to the handle. The frame includes an inner portion and an outer portion located substantially opposite the inner portion. The inner portion of the frame include a plurality of undulations that extend towards and away from a ball-hitting surface, the undulations reducing the unintended bunching and wrinkling of material that intermittently forms in the frame during the manufacturing process. The undulations can be varied by location, undulation length, undulation height, and frequency and can be used in racquets made from a variety of materials and methods.
Description




TECHNICAL FIELD




This invention relates generally to sports racquets. More particularly, this invention relates to a sports racquet with undulations in the interior surface of the frame for increasing the overall strength, durability and stiffness of the racquet.




BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION




Racquets for sports such as tennis, racquetball, squash and badminton are well known in the art and by the public. Many currently existing racquets include a tubular frame made of a composite or other material which surrounds a string bed, with the string bed serving as the hitting surface for the racquet.




Although such racquets have many beneficial qualities, they also have drawbacks which this invention addresses. In the regions of the racquet frame in which the frame has a high degree of curvature, the material that exists on the outside of the frame will cover a greater distance than the material on the opposite or the inside of the frame. This can be seen in

FIG. 1

, wherein a standard racquetball racquet the length of the inner side of the racquet frame is significantly less than the length of the outer side of the racquet frame. This difference is most pronounced where the curvature of the racquet frame is the greatest. This difference in surface length causes the material on the inside of the frame to bunch or crease. This bunching or creasing, which is the unintended and random result of the manufacturing process, will cause wrinkles to form in materials on the inside of the frame, creating areas of weakness and undesired flexibility, as well as inconsistencies in strength and stiffness, in the frame. The creases, wrinkles or bunching that occurs in the inner side of the racquet can be seen in prior art

FIGS. 2-3

, which show a frame made out of laminations of fibrous material in a resin matrix, per conventional manufacture. As shown in these figures, creases, bunches or wrinkles


120


in the inner side


112


of a racquet frame


102


occur intermittently, causing various weak portions in the racquet frame. The resulting weaknesses, undesired flexibility, and inconsistencies in strength and stiffness, can affect the overall performance of the racquet and can also lead to a cracking or breaking of the racquet frame.




Therefore, it is desirable to develop a racquet frame that reduces or minimizes the incidence of bunches, creases and wrinkles formed on the inside of the racquet frame and proximate areas of curvature of the frame.




SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION




The invention provides for a sports racquet (such as ones used in squash, racquetball, badminton and tennis) including a handle and an elongated frame coupled to the handle. The frame includes a head portion, sometimes a shaft portion, and a throat portion, with the throat portion connecting the head portion to the shaft or handle. An inner side includes a plurality of undulations formed into the racquet that result in a varying frame cross section at different portions along the racquet frame. These undulations result in a longer inner side surface length, making the linear distance on the inner side of the frame more similar to the linear distance on the outer side of the frame for a particular frame segment. The undulations can be used continuously or intermittently inside the frame. A different number and variety of undulations can also be used. The undulations may be varied in frequency, height, length, depth, and shape. The present invention has application to racquets formed from any of a variety of materials including composites and metals.




It is therefore an advantage of the invention to provide a sports racquet that is formed so as to reduce or minimize the number of areas of weakness, undesired flexibility and inconsistencies in strength on the racquet frame.




It is as yet another advantage of the present invention to provide a sports racquet that has an increased overall strength in the racquet frame.




It is still another advantage of the present invention to provide a sports racquet that has a predictable level of strength and stiffness in the frame.




It is yet another advantage of the invention to provide a sports racquet wherein the frame has a more consistent weight and balance.




It is finally another advantage of the invention to provide a sports racquet that has an increased level of durability for a given amount of material and weight in the racquet frame.




Further advantages and features of the present invention will be apparent from the foregoing specification and claims once considered in connection with the accompanying drawings illustrating the preferred embodiment of the present invention.











BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS





FIG. 1

is a plan view of a racquetball racquet according to the prior art.





FIG. 2

is a sectional side view of a portion of a sports racquet frame according to the prior art.





FIG. 3

is a side view of a cross section of the racquet frame taken substantially along line


3





3


of FIG.


2


.





FIG. 4

is a side view of a cross section of the racquet taken substantially along line


4





4


of FIG.


2


.





FIG. 5

is a plan view of a portion of a racquet frame according to one embodiment of the invention.





FIG. 6

is a cross-sectional view of the racquet taken substantially along line


6





6


of FIG.


5


.





FIG. 7

is a cross-sectional view of the racquet taken substantially along line


7





7


of FIG.


5


.





FIG. 8

is a view of a top portion of the racquet of

FIG. 5

, looking outward from the center of the frame.





FIG. 9

is a plan view of a portion of a racquet frame according to another embodiment of the invention.





FIG. 10

is a cross-sectional view of the racquet taken substantially along line


10





10


of FIG.


9


.





FIG. 11

is a cross-sectional view of the racquet taken substantially along line


11





11


of FIG.


9


.





FIG. 12

is a view of the racquet of

FIG. 9

, looking outward from the center of the frame.





FIG. 13

is a plan view of a portion of a racquet according to another embodiment of the invention.





FIG. 14

is a cross-sectional view taken substantially along line


14





14


of FIG.


13


.





FIG. 15

is a cross-sectional side view taken substantially along line


15





15


of FIG.


13


.





FIG. 16

is a view of the racquet of

FIG. 13

, looking outward from the center of the frame.





FIG. 17

is a plan view of a portion of a racquet according to another embodiment of invention.





FIG. 18

is a cross-sectional view taken substantially along line


18





18


of FIG.


17


.





FIG. 19

is a cross-sectional view taken substantially along line


19





19


of FIG.


17


.





FIG. 20

is a view of the racquet of

FIG. 17

, looking outward from the center of the frame.





FIG. 21

is a plan view of a portion of a racquet according to yet another embodiment of the invention.





FIG. 22

is a cross-sectional view taken substantially along line


22





22


of FIG.


21


.





FIG. 23

is a cross-sectional view taken substantially along line


23





23


of FIG.


21


.





FIG. 24

is a view of the racquet of

FIG. 21

, looking outward from the center of the frame.





FIG. 25

is a plan view of a portion of a racquet frame according to still another embodiment of the invention.





FIG. 26

is a view looking at the interior surface of the racquet portion shown in FIG.


25


.





FIG. 27

is a plan view of a portion of a racquet frame according to still another embodiment of the invention.





FIG. 28

is a view looking at the interior surface of the racquet portion shown in FIG.


27


.





FIG. 29

is a plan view of a portion of a racquet frame according to still another embodiment of the invention.





FIG. 30

is a view looking at the interior surface of the racquet portion shown in FIG.


29


.





FIG. 31

is a plan view of a portion of a racquet frame according to still another embodiment of the invention.





FIG. 32

is a view looking at the interior surface of the racquet portion shown in FIG.


31


.





FIG. 33

is a plan view of a portion of a racquet frame according to still another embodiment of the invention.





FIG. 34

is a view looking at the interior surface of the racquet portion shown in FIG.


33


.





FIG. 35

is a plan view of a portion of a racquet frame according to still another embodiment of the invention.





FIG. 36

is a view looking at the interior surface of the racquet portion shown in FIG.


35


.





FIG. 37

is a plan view of a portion of a racquet according to a preferred embodiment of the invention.





FIG. 38

is a view looking at the interior surface of the racquet portion shown in FIG.


37


.





FIG. 39

is a plan view of a racquet frame portion according to an alternate embodiment of the invention, wherein the undulation length, height, and frequency are altered within a single racquet portion.





FIG. 40

is a view of the racquet portion shown in

FIG. 39

, looking at the interior surface of the racquet frame.





FIG. 41

is a plan view of a portion of a racquet with undulations in the handle region.





FIG. 42

is a block diagram of an exemplary racquet molding process according to the invention.





FIG. 43

is a plan view of a shafted racquet frame incorporating the invention.





FIG. 44

is a plan view of a second shafted racquet frame incorporating the invention, the frame having a throat piece.





FIG. 45

is a plan view of a nonshafted racquet frame incorporating the invention.











DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE INVENTION




A sports racquet, shown generally at


100


in

FIG. 1

, includes a frame


102


and a handle


104


coupled to the frame


102


. The racquet frame


102


includes a throat portion


106


and a head portion


108


. The head portion


108


is peripheral to the hitting area


110


in which a string bed (not shown) is installed for hitting a ball (not shown). The racquet


100


can have many different shapes, with the shape depending upon the sport for which the racquet is used. For example, the racquet


100


shown in

FIG. 1

would generally be intended for racquetball. A tennis racquet or badminton racquet may have a shaft (not shown) connecting the handle to the frame, and such a racquet may also have a differently shaped head


108


.




As shown in

FIG. 3

, the outer side


114


of the racquet frame


102


includes a channel


115


located generally in the center of the outer side


114


. The channel


115


is used for the placement of the strings used in the string bed that is connected to the racquet frame


102


. A plastic retaining piece (not shown) may be inserted into the channel


115


to protect the strings and to prevent the strings from abrading and breaking over time.




As can be seen in

FIGS. 2 and 3

according to the prior art, a racquet


100


often develops creases, wrinkles or bunches


120


of fibrous plies of material along the inner side


112


of the racquet frame


102


during manufacture. This is due to the distance along the inside of the racquet frame


102


being less than the distance on the outside of the frame


102


, resulting in some excess material on the inside of the frame. The excess material collects in certain regions, forming ceases or wrinkles


120


along the inside side


112


of the frame


102


. This material can even collect along the upper or lower sides


116


or


118


which connect the inner side


112


to the outer side


114


. Some regions of the racquet frame


102


will develop creases or wrinkles


120


while other regions will not. It is difficult to predict where the creases or wrinkles


120


will occur. These ceases or wrinkles


120


may or may not correspond to the holes


124


through which the strings are connected to the frame


102


, and the creases or wrinkles may or may not be evenly spaced through the frame


102


. In general, the greater degree of curvature, the greater the number and severity of creases or wrinkles will occur.

FIG. 4

shows a cross section of a prior art racquet taken at a point where wrinkles or creases have not accumulated. This is the desired condition throughout the frame, but does not occur uniformly in prior art racquets.




As shown in

FIGS. 5-8

, the occurrence of creases, wrinkles or bunches is reduced or minimized through the molding of undulations


130


into the inner side


112


of the racquet frame


102


.

FIG. 5

shows a plan view of a portion of the racquet frame


102


. For the purposes of this discussion, the undulations


130


are measured by their distance from a reference line


140


that runs through the racquet frame


102


. Each of the undulations


130


has an undulation peak


132


and an undulation valley


134


. In the illustrated embodiment, the undulation peaks


132


and undulation valleys


134


relative to the reference line


140


alternate in the racquet frame


102


. Upper and lower sides


116


and


118


connect the inner and outer sides


112


and


114


to each other. The presence of undulations


130


add to the surface length along interior center line


133


(FIG.


5


), making it more similar in length to exterior center line


135


than would otherwise exist.




As shown in

FIG. 8

, the holes


124


through which the racquet strings are threaded can align with the undulations


130


. For example, in

FIG. 8

each of the holes


124


line up with a respective undulation peak


132


of the racquet frame


102


. It is also possible, however, for the holes to line up with the undulation valleys


134


or not to line up exactly with either the undulation peaks or valleys


132


or


134


.




In the embodiment shown in

FIGS. 5-8

, the difference in height between undulation peaks


132


the undulation valleys


134


of the racquet frame


102


is fairly modest. This design element can be adjusted, however, to make for a greater difference between the undulation peaks and valleys


132


and


134


respectively. Furthermore, the distance between consecutive peaks or valleys in the undulations can also be adjusted in the design. For example, in

FIG. 5

the lateral distance between undulation peaks


132


is of a set amount that can either be shortened or extended. It is also possible for the distance between consecutive undulation peaks


132


to be irregular.




Preferably, in order to reduce unintended creasing, bunching or wrinkling in the racquet, undulations


130


are molded into the racquet


100


at those locations where there is a substantial amount of curvature in the frame


102


. For example, that portion of the frame


102


located in a particular quadrant of the racquet


100


would have at least one and a half undulations


130


in that quadrant, with an undulation defined as that portion of the racquet from one undulation peak


132


to the next undulation peak


132


. For this purpose, “quadrant” is defined as any portion of the frame member that subtends an arc of ninety degrees relative to the center of the racquet frame


102


.





FIGS. 9-12

show an alternative embodiment of the invention, wherein the undulations are much longer than the undulations in the embodiment shown in FIG.


5


. By comparing

FIGS. 5-8

with

FIGS. 9-12

, it is apparent that it is possible to adjust the undulation length while keeping the height of the undulation peaks and valleys


132


and


134


relative to the reference line


140


at the same distance or vice versa.





FIGS. 13-24

show other embodiments of the invention. These embodiments represent a number of different ways in which the undulation height or undulation length can be varied in order to change the contours of the frame.





FIGS. 25-36

show several different embodiments of the invention showing the many different varieties of racquet frames


102


that can be formed using different types of undulations. For example, the undulations


130


in

FIG. 26

extend across the inner side


112


from the upper side


116


to the lower side


118


of the racquet frame


102


. As shown in

FIG. 28

, however, the undulations


130


do not have to extend from the upper side


116


to the lower side


118


. This makes the undulations


130


appear more like dimples in the racquet frame


102


. Furthermore, as shown in

FIG. 28

, it is also possible to have undulations or dimples


130


of varying depths relative to the reference line


140


of racquet frame


102


. For example in

FIGS. 27-28

the deepest portions


144


of the undulations


130


are substantially equidistant from the upper and lower sides


116


and


118


. Outside of the deepest point


144


is a secondary region


142


that is more shallow than the deepest point


144


but still deeper than regions outside of the undulations


130


.




As shown in another embodiment of the invention in

FIGS. 29 and 30

, it is also possible to have undulations


130


of varying widths. For example, in

FIG. 30

the distance from the left edge


150


of the undulation


130


to the right edge


152


of the undulation


130


varies from the upper side


116


to the lower side


118


of the frame. This is in contrast to the frame shown in

FIGS. 33 and 34

where each undulation


130


has a substantially constant width. A particularly preferred embodiment of the invention is shown in

FIGS. 37 and 38

. The “dimple” embodiments shown in

FIGS. 27-32

and


37


-


38


take into account that as one proceeds downwardly or upwardly from the string bed plane, many frame member cross sections will have a tendency to curve away. As one proceeds to the topmost or bottommost sides


116


or


118


, therefore, the side length increases, becoming more like the external side length


114


of the frame member. The amount of undulation or dimpling therefore may need to be less to obtain the same amount of wrinkle or crease correction.




It is also possible for the undulations


130


to have other shapes. For example in

FIG. 32

the undulations


130


are more oval in shape and run substantially parallel to the upper and lower sides


116


and


118


respectively. Using these types of undulations


130


it is possible to have the holes


124


for the string bed located within the undulations


130


. Furthermore, as shown in

FIGS. 33 and 34

it is possible to have some holes


124


located in the undulations


130


while other holes


124


located outside of the undulations


130


.




In addition to the foregoing, it is possible to have many different types of undulation orientations in the same racquet


100


while still practicing the invention. For example, it is possible to alter the undulation length or undulation height. Furthermore, it is also possible to have undulations


130


of various shapes. Additionally any of these variables could be altered depending upon particular concerns such as the curvature at a particular point of the racquet head


108


. For example, in

FIG. 1

the head portion


108


substantially opposite the handle


104


has very little curvature and may not require many undulations


130


in order to reduce or minimize any undesired creasing, wrinkling or bunching of material. The left and right sides or “corners” of the racquet head


108


are much more curved, however, potentially requiring more undulations


130


in order to reduce creasing, bunching and wrinkling in those regions and the throat portion if desired.




It is also possible to use different types and styles of undulations


130


in the same racquet. For example, it may be desirable to have oval shaped undulations


130


, as shown in

FIG. 32

, in some portions of the frame


102


while having more uniformly shaped undulations


130


, as shown in

FIG. 26

, in other regions. Also, it may be desirable to have the undulations taper to different degrees, either from racquet to racquet or in the same racquet itself. As shown in detail in

FIGS. 39 and 40

, it is even possible to alter each of these variables in a single racquet portion.




Although it is often desirable to have undulations


130


formed on the inner side


112


of the head portion


106


of the frame


102


, it is possible to include undulations


130


on other portions of the racquet


100


, so long as that particular portion of the racquet curves around a particular center point. For example, the portion


160


of the racquet that connects the frame


102


to the handle


104


curves about a center point


162


that is located outside of the racquet


100


, as shown in FIG.


41


. With the portion


160


curving about the exterior center point


162


, any bunching or wrinkling that occurs is likely to be more pronounced on the outer portion


114


of the racquet


100


than on the inner portion


112


. It is therefore possible to include undulations


130


on the outer portion


114


of the racquet


100


in this case. As is the case with undulations


130


located in other regions of the racquet


100


, the undulation height, length, frequency, and other variables can also be modified in light of certain manufacturing and performance considerations.




The present invention has application to both shafted and nonshafted sports racquets.

FIGS. 43 and 44

are plan views of shafted sports racquets, of the kind which may be used in tennis, squash or badminton. In racquet


320


shown in

FIG. 43

, undulations


322


are formed substantially throughout the entire inner surface


324


of the frame


325


, while a few undulations


326


are formed on an outer surface


328


of the frame in the region of frame


325


's curved junction with shaft


330


. Because there are no relatively sharp “corners” in a head portion of frame


325


, the undulations


322


are more evenly distributed to more evenly provide their function of increasing the length of the frame


325


's interior surface.




In

FIG. 44

, a shafted racquet


332


has a throat piece


334


.




Undulations


336


are formed in the interior surface of the throat piece


334


to reduce creasing or wrinkling in that area. Undulations


322


and


326


are employed elsewhere as in racquet


320


.





FIG. 45

shows a nonshafted racquet


340


having undulations


342


distributed throughout the circumference of the internal surface of its frame


344


.




It is possible for the racquet frame


102


to be made of several different materials. In a preferred embodiment of the invention, a material such as keviar, boron, carbon, fiberglass, aramid, metal fibers, ceramics or graphite may be especially useful, not only for improving the overall functionality of the racquet but also for forming the undulations during the manufacturing process. It is possible, however, for other materials such as aluminum to be used while still taking advantage of the wrinkle-reducing undulation concept.




Composite sports racquets according to the invention may be manufactured according to the following exemplary process as described in FIG.


42


. An elongate, flexible mandrel is first inserted into a similarly elongate and flexible, relatively gas-impermeable and heat-resistant bag made from materials known in the art, shown at


200


. Several laminations of material are added to the outside of the bag surface at


202


. These pieces of material may and usually do differ one from another in size, shape, composition and fiber orientation. Preferably, they are preimpregnated with resin.




Once the material has been wrapped to the bag surface, the mandrel is removed from an open end of the bag, shown at


204


. The bag, including the laminations of material (collectively known as a “layup”), is bent into a shape that approximates the future frame member, shown at


206


, and is inserted into one-half of a mold, shown at


208


. It is this bending step that creates the wrinkles or bunching in the material. But in the present invention, and unlike in prior processes, the mold is constructed to have undulations in its surface which are the negative of the undulations to be formed in the surface of the frame member. The bag is sealed at one end at step


210


. An upper half of the mold is fixed to the lower half of the mold to enclose the layup, shown at


212


.




A source of pressurized gas is used to inflate the bag to a high pressure such as 100 to 300 pounds per square inch, as shown in


214


. This forces the laminations of material against the mold walls. The laminations of the material will be forced against the mold undulations (at those locations where undulations are to be formed), and in being forced to this position many of the wrinkles in the laminations will diminish or disappear. The closed and inflated mold is then subjected to heat sufficient to cause the impregnated resin to flow, bonding the laminated materials together and forming the frame member, shown at


216


. After cooling the mold, shown at


218


, the member is removed and finished by removing flash, painting, etc, shown at


220


.




Other manufacturing processes may be used to obtain the same result, i.e., undulations formed on an inner side of one or more curved portions of the frame. For example, instead of inflation, the mold sides may be displaced inwardly from an initial outward position by springs to impress the undulations into the layup. The laminations of the layup may be drawn outwardly to conform to the mold's negative undulations by applying a partial vacuum to the mold. A layup with a bag may be used in which the bag holds ammonia, with heating of the mold causing the ammonia to expand the bag. Foam may be used as a bag expansion agent. Finally, similar techniques can be employed without a bag.




While preferred embodiments have been shown and described, it is understood that changes and modifications can be made to the invention without departing from the invention's broader aspects. For example, the undulation length, undulation height, undulation shape and undulation frequency can be altered in numerous respects while still taking advantage of the inventions broader aspects. Also of note is the fact that the undulations can be placed at virtually any location on one side of the frame. Thus it is apparent that alternative embodiments are available to those of skill in the art therefore the present invention is not limited to the described and illustrated embodiment, but only by the scope and spirit of the independent and dependent claims.



Claims
  • 1. A sports racquet, comprising:a handle; a frame formed from a fibrous material and coupled to the handle, the frame disposed peripherally of a string bed having: an inner portion of the frame disposed proximate to the string bed and an outer portion located substantially opposite the inner portion to be remote from the string bed, the inner portion of the frame including a plurality of undulations that extend towards and away from the string bed, no corresponding undulations being formed on the outer portion of the frame.
  • 2. The sports racquet of claim 1, wherein the frame is a composite.
  • 3. The sports racquet of claim 1, wherein the undulations are spaced substantially equidistantly from each other along the inner portion of the frame.
  • 4. The sports racquet of claim 1, wherein the undulations are included substantially in the head portion of the frame.
  • 5. The sports racquet of claim 1, wherein the racquet is a shafted racquet.
  • 6. The sports racquet of claim 3, wherein the maximum distance between the inner and outer portions of the frame at one cross-section is of substantially the same magnitude at corresponding points in each undulation.
  • 7. The sports racquet of claim 1, wherein the maximum distance between the inner and outer portions at a specific cross-section varies between adjacent undulations.
  • 8. The sports racquet of claim 1, wherein the minimum distance between the inner and outer portions of a specific cross-section varies between adjacent undulations.
  • 9. The sports racquet of claim 1, wherein a distance between the maximum and minimum distances between the inner and outer portions at a specific cross-section varies between adjacent undulations.
  • 10. A racquet, comprising:a frame formed from a fibrous material and having an interior surface and an exterior surface; and a string bed residing substantially in a plane; wherein the frame intersects the string bed plane at an exterior locus and an interior locus, the exterior locus forming a smooth arc shape, and wherein the interior locus defines a plurality of undulations such that an interior linear distance formed at the intersection of the inner surface and the plane is more similar to an exterior linear distance formed at the intersection of the exterior surface and the plane than would be the case without the undulations being present.
  • 11. The racquet of claim 10, wherein the interior locus defines a plurality of evenly spaced undulations through the inner surface of the frame.
  • 12. The racquet of claim 11 wherein the radius of curvature of one undulation is substantially identical to the radius of curvature of each other undulation.
  • 13. A racquet comprising:a handle; an endless frame of a fibrous material coupled to the handle and formed around a center, the frame divided into four quadrants each subtending an arc of ninety degrees as measured from the center, wherein at least one quadrant of the frame comprises at least one and one-half undulations on an inside surface of the frame, no corresponding undulations being formed on an outside surface of the frame quadrant opposite the undulations on the inside surface.
  • 14. The sports racquet of claim 1, wherein the outer portion of the frame adjacent the handle includes a plurality of undulations that extend towards and away from the string bed, no corresponding undulations being formed on the inner portion of the frame.
US Referenced Citations (52)
Number Name Date Kind
1422993 Larned Jul 1922 A
1451836 Larned Apr 1923 A
1541828 Larned Jun 1925 A
1588139 Penney Jun 1926 A
1750727 Norton Mar 1930 A
2282195 Compte May 1942 A
2626804 Robinson Jan 1953 A
3086777 LaCoste Apr 1963 A
3265401 Spier Aug 1966 A
3568290 Carlton Mar 1971 A
3647211 Doessel et al. Mar 1972 A
3727295 Gildemeister Apr 1973 A
3810620 Decker, III et al May 1974 A
3814423 Shockley et al. Jun 1974 A
3833219 Dean Sep 1974 A
3912268 Robinson Oct 1975 A
3947029 Gallagher Mar 1976 A
3949988 Staufer Apr 1976 A
3986716 Taussig et al. Oct 1976 A
3993308 Jenks Nov 1976 A
4005862 Portz et al. Feb 1977 A
4061520 Cecka et al. Dec 1977 A
4066260 Rodgers, Jr. Jan 1978 A
4102533 Ida Jul 1978 A
4165071 Frolow Aug 1979 A
4177990 Kajiwara Dec 1979 A
4185822 Li Jan 1980 A
4205844 Gombas Jun 1980 A
4280699 Drake Jul 1981 A
4365806 Reid et al. Dec 1982 A
4664380 Kuebler May 1987 A
4725059 Du Gardin et al. Feb 1988 A
4747598 Curtis May 1988 A
4768786 Kuebler Sep 1988 A
4772021 Maynard Sep 1988 A
4793958 Mott Dec 1988 A
4911444 Yoneeyama Mar 1990 A
4919438 Yoneeyama Apr 1990 A
4935185 Moff Jun 1990 A
5009422 Soong Apr 1991 A
5037098 Davis Aug 1991 A
5082266 Lo Jan 1992 A
5183265 Umlauft et al. Feb 1993 A
5197731 Svoma et al Mar 1993 A
5306004 Soong Apr 1994 A
5306005 Lacoste et al. Apr 1994 A
5310180 Wu May 1994 A
5312115 Wu May 1994 A
5386991 Roehette Feb 1995 A
5462274 Takatsuka Oct 1995 A
5538243 Yamamoto et al Jul 1996 A
5573242 Yoo Nov 1996 A
Foreign Referenced Citations (6)
Number Date Country
538523 Apr 1993 EP
2056863 Feb 1981 GB
2262892 Jul 1983 GB
2198959 Jun 1988 GB
2203653 Oct 1988 GB
9400203 Jan 1994 WO