Spread spectrum receiver with multi-path correction

Abstract
A spread spectrum receiver uses a comparison of the magnitude of the code correlation amplitudes at equal power at a one chip spacing to the magnitude at a central position there between to determine if multipath interference is present. The lead or lag error from constructive or destructive multipath interference may also be determined. Inaccuracies due to such interference may then be corrected or minimized by, for example, determining the residual code phase error and/or the prompt or accurate code phase delay.
Description




BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION




1. Field of the Invention




This invention relates in general to radio frequency receivers subject to the reception of multipath signals and in particular to receivers measuring the time of arrival of signals received, such as those used in GPS navigation systems, which are adversely affected by multipath signals.




2. Description of the Prior Art




GPS systems, as well as many other radio frequency (RF) communication systems utilizing frequencies high enough to be considered line of sight systems in which there must be a substantially direct line of sight between the transmitter(s) and receivers(s) for optimum operation, often suffer from multipath effects in which the receiver(s) must process signals received over a multiplicity of different paths. A common example is a simple broadcast TV system in which a TV receiver with an antenna receives multiple copies of the signal being transmitted.




The multiplicity of signals being received results from additional, typically unwanted, signal paths including one or more reflections. When the signal path from the transmitter to receiver includes a reflection, this signal path must by definition be longer than the direct path. Multipath signals present a problem in systems, such as GPS systems, in which the time of arrival of the signal is to be measured or used because the time of arrival of the multipath signals depends on the length of the path(s) taken.




The straightforward processing of all signals, including multipath or reflected signals, often degrades the processing performed by the receiver. The direct path is the shortest and therefore requires the least travel time from transmitter to receiver while the various unwanted multipath signals have various greater lengths, and therefore various longer travel times, than the direct path signals.




GPS transmitters are positioned on satellites with complex orbital paths so that the locations of the multiple transmitters are constantly changing. This makes a highly directional antenna system almost completely unusable. Similarly, digital receivers, including those used in a GPS receiver, often do not rely solely on the amplitudes of the signals received, but rather rely on other signal characteristics, such as time of arrival.




Multipath processing techniques currently used for complex receivers, such as GPS receivers, are often quite complex and subject to inaccuracies. An example of one such conventional technique is described in U.S. Pat. No. 5,414,729 issued on May 9, 1995 to Patrick Fenton and assigned as issued to NovAtel Communications Ltd., Canada. In this technique, an autocorrelation function of a partially processed received signal, including multipath components, is compared to an estimated autocorrelation function of an estimated direct path signal to attempt to discern direct path signals from multipath signals for further processing. This technique of comparing processed and estimated correlation power, is complex and may be subject to error in that the partially processed signals relied on are themselves subject to degradation from many effects in addition to multipath effects including receiver limitations, which may reduce the accuracy or effectiveness of the multipath processing techniques.




For example, in tracking a GPS C/A signal to determine position information from GPS satellite transmitters, it is typically important to derive an accurate estimate of the time of arrival, known as code phase, of the PRN modulation of the direct path component of the C/A signals received from each of the various GPS satellites. It is also important to derive an accurate estimate of the phase of the underlying carrier signals transmitted from the satellites on which the modulation is applied, known as the carrier phase. However, as apparently shown for example in

FIGS. 6

,


7


and


8


of the above referenced Fenton patent, the delayed multipath components degrade the tracking of the code and carrier phase estimates by distorting the correlation functions used is such tracking.




What is needed is an improved technique for multipath signal processing which is less complex, less subject to error than conventional techniques and is applicable to a wide range of communication systems, signal encoding approach and conditions.




SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION




In one aspect, the present invention provides an improved terrestrial navigation system using a GPS receiver in which the residual code phase tracking, or pseudorange, error due to simultaneous reception of multipath signals is detected, estimated and corrected. In particular, the distortion of the correlation function of the multi- and direct path signal composite as received with the internally generated code is detected by comparison of an aspect of resultant correlation function with a model of the correlation function expected in the absence of multipath distortion. The comparison provides an indication of the sign of the residual error.




It has been determined that the composite of a direct path and one or more multipath signals distorts the correlation function. If, as in most common cases, the multipath signal(s) are weaker than the direct path signals, the interference between such signals as received results in a predictable distortion of the correlation function. If the carrier phase(s) of the multipath signal(s) are shifted from between about 0° to 90° from the carrier phase of the direct path signal, the signals tend to reinforce each other resulting in a widening of the correlation function. Similarly, if the carrier phase(s) of the multipath signal(s) are shifted from between 90° to about 180° from the carrier phase of the direct path signal, the signals tend to cancel each other resulting in a narrowing of the correlation function.




The correlation products are used in a code tracking loop to track and determine code phase. The most common scheme is to track points of equal magnitude (or power) separated by one C/A code chip width and estimate the time of arrival of the direct path signal as the mid-point between these points of equal magnitude. The points of equal magnitude on either side of the direct path arrival time are known as the early and late correlation time and the estimated arrival time of the direct path is called the punctual correlation time. In the presence of multipath signals, the correlation function has been found to be distorted so that the mid-point between the early and late correlations, that is the prompt correlation, is not an accurate estimation of the arrival time of the direct path signal.




When the correlation function of the composite is distorted to be wider than the correlation function expected for a direct path only signal, the distortion results in a lag error in which the prompt correlation lags the actual direct path signal received. Similarly, when the correlation function of the composite is narrower than expected, the distortion results in a lead error in which the prompt correlation leads the time of arrival of the direct path signal.




The prompt correlation therefore leads or lags the actual time of arrival of the direct path signal by an amount designated herein as the residual code tracking error. The magnitude of the error can be approximated by the degree of narrowing or widening of the correlation function. Reduction of this error, or detection and correction of the error, enhances the accuracy of the resultant position determination.




In another aspect, the present invention provides a spread spectrum receiver including means for correlating a received, code modulated spread spectrum signal with a code modulated signal replica at a first selected code phase delay and at a second selected code phase delay and comparison means for comparing characteristics of said correlations to derive information related to any residual code phase error in said second code phase delay.




In another aspect, the present invention provides a method of processing coded, spread spectrum signals with potential multipath interference by generating a local replica of the code, correlating the local replica with coded, spread spectrum signals as received at a plurality of code phase delays and determining prompt code phase delay from differences in magnitude between at least two of said correlations.











BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS





FIG. 1

is an overview illustration of the operation of a car navigation system according to the present invention.





FIG. 2

is a block diagram of the GPS car navigation system depicted in

FIG. 1

, used for improved navigation during reduced satellite visibility.





FIG. 3

is a schematic representation of a single satellite channel of a GPS receiver used for fast satellite reacquisition.





FIG. 4

is a schematic representation of a portion of the single satellite channel shown in

FIG. 3

in which an additional plurality of sets of delayed code samples are correlated to provide a finer gradation of correlation intervals.





FIG. 5

is a functional block diagram of a preferred implementation, on an ASIC, of the satellite tracking channels and associated processing components of the GPS car navigation system shown in FIG.


1


.





FIG. 6

is a functional block diagram of the Doppler Block of the GPS car navigation system shown in FIG.


1


.





FIG. 7

is a functional block diagram of the Coder Block of the GPS car navigation system shown in FIG.


1


.





FIG. 8

is a functional block diagram of the Correlator Block of the GPS car navigation system shown in FIG.


1


.





FIG. 9

is a function block diagram overview showing the interconnections between the Doppler, Code, Correlator and other blocks of the system described in FIG.


5


.





FIG. 10

is a block diagram of the operation of the system, shown in

FIGS. 5 and 9

, illustrating the data path of the present invention.





FIG. 11

is a series of exploded time segments illustrating the operation of the data path of the present invention.





FIG. 12

is a block diagram overview of a GPS receiver system illustrating a complete receiver system according to the present invention including a more detailed view of the satellite receiver section shown in FIG.


2


.





FIG. 13

is a graph of the correlation product of a direct path signal received without multipath interference, together with correlation products distorted by the presence of multi-path signals whose carrier phase differs from the carrier phase of the direct path signal by about 0° and by about 180°.





FIG. 14

is a schematic block diagram of portions of a GPS receiver illustrating the delay-locked tracking loop with multipath residual code phase error detection, calculation and/or correction according to the present invention.











DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENT(S)





FIG. 1

is an overview illustration of the operation of a GPS car navigation system according to the present invention. The GPS car navigation system, described below in greater detail with respect to

FIG. 2

, is mounted in car


10


which is moving along the center of roadway


12


. NAVSTAR satellite


14


, in the lower left quadrant of the figure, is in view of car


10


. A simulated GPS circular overhead display, positioned approximately over intersection


22


of roadway


12


and roadway


16


indicates that satellite


14


is between 0° and 45° degrees of elevation above the horizon as viewed from car


10


.




For the purposes of illustration, satellite


18


is positioned overhead between the elevation angles of 0° and 45° degrees. However, the line of sight between satellite


18


and car


10


is obscured by buildings


20


so that satellite


18


is not in view of car


10


at the position along roadway


12


as shown. Similarly, the line of sight between satellite


19


and car


10


is obscured by buildings


21


. However, as will be discussed below, when car


10


crosses intersection


22


, the line of sight between satellite


19


and car


10


, when the car is in position


11


within intersection


22


, may momentarily be clear.




Turning now to

FIG. 2

, GPS car navigation system


24


is a first embodiment of a car navigation system according to the present invention which may be installed in car


10


of FIG.


1


. GPS car navigation system


24


includes GPS car system module


26


which is provided with signals received from satellites by GPS antenna


28


, data related to the then current—and expected future—physical environment of car


10


by for example Map Data Base


30


and data input from the operator of the car by for example input device


32


. GPS car system module


26


provides output to the operator, for example, in the form of a GPS map display, via display unit


34


, which may include both visual display as well as a voice interface announcing information as required to supplement or even partially replace visually presented data.




The present invention may be configured for use with only a GPS receiver, a GPS receiver aided by map data from, for example, Map Data Base


30


, and/or a GPS receiver aided by both a map data base as well as an external source of information, for example, from an external sensor. This external source of information may be used for maintaining position information by dead reckoning during those times when a sufficient number of satellites are not in view to provide the desired information.




In operation, a composite of all signals received from NAVSTAR satellites is applied by GPS antenna


28


to satellite receiver section


36


of GPS car system module


26


. Signals from individual NAVSTAR satellites are then tracked in satellite specific tracking channels such as SatTRAK channels


38


,


40


,


42


and


44


. Although it is quite conventional to track 4 to 12 satellites and therefore use 1 to 12 satellite tracking channels, only 4 such channels are shown herein for clarity. The outputs of these satellite specific tracking channels are processed by SatProcessor


46


to provide x


user


, y


user


, z


user


and t


user


data via appropriate logic control to a GPS position processor, such as PosProcessor or Nav Soln


48


which determines the navigation solution to determine position data. Position data is then applied by PosProcessor


48


to an appropriate display for the operator of the car, such as display unit


34


.




External sensor


49


, in

FIG. 2

, may conveniently provide sensor data, or local or satellite position information, or position information which provided local position or satellite position information directly to PosProcessor


48


for comparison with the position information determined by SatProcessor


46


and/or Map/Display Processor


50


. External sensor


49


may conveniently be any sensor which provides information useful for updating position information for dead reckoning including direction, speed, velocity or acceleration or other data from which dead reckoning data may be derived. Conventional sensors include inertial navigation systems, with magnetic or optical gyroscopes, fluxgate compasses, odometer or wheel sensors or the like. Alternatively, external GPS format signals, such as those provided by a pseudolite, may be used to update current satellite or position information.




At the beginning of a navigated trip, the operator of car


10


would typically provide data concerning the physical environment surrounding the intended route to GPS car system module


26


by inserting an appropriate data storage device such as a CD ROM, into Map Data Base


30


, and/or by entering the data via input device


32


which conveniently may be a keypad, keyboard, pointing device, track ball, touch screen, graphical pad, a voice recognition interface and/or a combination of such input devices. The operator of car


10


would also enter the intended destination into GPS car system module


26


via a data entry device such as a mouse or track ball interacting with display unit


34


and/or via input device


32


. Map/Display Processor


50


of GPS car system module


26


would then develop the desired route, typically from the then current location as a point of origin to the desired destination, in accordance with the rules of navigation and details of the locale provided by Map Data Base


30


. The appropriate route data is stored in Route Data Base


52


, including the routing in the form of roadways and turns between roadways. Additional information, such as altitude, width of the roadways and etc. may also be contained within Map Data Base


30


and/or Route Data Base


52


. These data bases may be contained within GPS car navigation system


24


and/or be made available to GPS car system module


26


from outside storage media such as diskettes positioned in appropriate disk drives.




During navigation, each satellite in view may be tracked in a satellite tracking channel. If, for example, 4 or more satellites are in view, each of the satellites in view will be tracked in an individual channel, such as SatTRAK channels


38


,


40


,


42


and


44


. The output of the satellite tracking channels is then applied to SatProcessor


46


which would provide satellite based solutions of the four unknowns, such as x


user


, y


user


, z


user


and t


user


. The data represented by x


user


and y


user


are conventionally used as the two dimensional orthogonal components of the surface of the earth such as north and east. However, in accordance with the present invention, x


user


and y


user


are preferably used to represent data for a pair of orthogonal directions specific to the direction of vehicle travel called the on-track and cross-track directions.




Conventional bearing, such as north, south, east and west are relative to the magnetic or true north poles of the earth, while on-track and cross-track, as used in the present invention, are bearings made relative to the expected direction of travel of car


10


at any particular point in the route. For example, while a 90° turn from a heading of due north would change the angle of the vehicle velocity vector from 0° to 90° if bearings relative to the Earth's surface such as north and east are used, the same turn would show no change in the 0° angle of the vehicle velocity vector before or after the turn as long as car


10


remained on the expected track.




The data represented by z


user


is typically surface elevation, such as the elevation above sea level, while the data represented by t


user


is the exact time as determined from one or more of the satellite tracking channels.




Solutions for all 4 unknowns of position information may be derived from signals from 4 satellites in view, so that exact position information within the limit of the accuracy then available from the GPS satellite constellation in view can therefore be applied by PosProcessor


48


to Map/Display Processor


50


. The position information determined from the satellites is processed with the physical data from Map Data Base


30


, and/or the desired routing data from Route Data Base


52


, to provide appropriate navigation information to the operator of car


10


via display unit


34


.




If less than 4 satellites are in view, the t


user


solution applied to PosProcessor


48


may be replaced by t


est




54


estimated solution derived for example from an internal clock model


54


in position estimate or model


63


. Similarly, the Z


user


solution may be replaced by z


est




56


solution derived from elevation estimate


56


, also in position model


63


, in accordance with routing data derived from Route Data Base


52


in accordance with then current GPS position information applied to Map/Display Processor


50


. T


est




54


and z


est




56


are applied to PosProcessor


48


, and used in lieu of t


user


and z


user


, when only two satellites are in view. The use of estimated or modeled solutions for the t and z variables, that is the use of t


est




54


and z


est




56


are conventionally known as clock hold and altitude hold, respectively.




It must be noted that the particular configuration of GPS car navigation system


24


as described so far is only one of the many known ways of configuring such systems any of which may be used without departing from the spirit or scope of the present invention as defined by the claims.




In accordance with the present invention, the width of the roadway, either known or estimated, may be used to provide y


est




60


for use in lieu of y


user


when only one satellite is visible. y


est




60


may be derived from Route Data Base


52


and/or Map Data Base


30


. Since the x and y unknowns are orthogonal, x


user


may be used to describe the on-track information, that is, the progress of car


10


along its predetermined track while y


est




60


represents the cross track information, that is, how far car


10


has strayed from the center of the roadway.




Referring therefore to

FIG. 1

, x


user


is used to indicate the progress of car


10


along roadway


12


while y


est




60


is used to represent the width of roadway


12


. The actual width of the roadway may be derived from Map Data Base


30


, or assumed because the actual value of the width of the roadway is relatively small and often therefore insignificant compared to the distances to be measured along the navigation route. Since the maximum allowable cross-track error, i.e. the maximum allowable appropriate value for y, is constrained by the physical width of the roadway, y


est




60


is relatively easy to accurately estimate.




By using y


est




60


, z


est




56


and t


est




54


, it is possible to provide useful navigation data for car


10


along a known roadway using signals from only a single satellite in view. It is important to note that reasonably accurate prior or initial position information may be required and that not all visible NAVSTAR satellites will be suitable for single satellite navigation, depending upon the position of the satellite with respect to the path of car


10


. The position information determined during single satellite navigation is along track position information which may be accumulated and used for determining accumulated along track distance traveled. This data provides, and may be used in place of, the distance traveled information conventionally provided in a vehicle by an odometer.




Referring now to both

FIGS. 1 and 2

, turning data may be used to improve terrestrial GPS navigation by using the detection of a known turn to update progress along a predetermined route. When at least 4 satellites are in view, the position of car


10


may be known to the accuracy of the GPS system. When using clock, altitude or cross-track hold, or some combination thereof, the known position of the car is degraded by any inaccuracy of the estimate or estimates used. For example, during clock hold, internal clock model


54


drift and inaccuracy of the source of t


est




54


will degrade the accuracy to which the position is known as a function of the magnitude of the inaccuracy. Similarly, any change in altitude from the estimated or fixed altitude, that is, any inaccuracy of z


est




56


, will degrade the accuracy of the known position. Changes in roadway width and inaccuracies in the map data with regard to the roadway width, that is, any inaccuracy in y


est




60


, may also degrade the position information.




Even with 4 satellites in view, the geometry of the visible satellites may make it difficult to determine position by measurement of GPS signals. Further, during terrestrial navigation, it is not uncommon for satellites to be temporarily obscured from view during navigation by, for example, being blocked by buildings and other obstructions.




It may therefor be desirable to update the accuracy with which the current position of the vehicle is known with actual position information whenever possible. The update information will sometimes be useful when 4 satellites are in view, but will always be useful as supplemental data when less than 4 satellites are in view. Update information is extremely useful during single satellite navigation to avoid the accumulation of errors in position information.




In operation, an original position and a destination were provided to the system which then determined the track to be followed. The track to be followed, or routing information, may be provided in the form of a data base of route information such as Route Data Base


52


. In the example used, track


62


follows the centerline of roadway


12


to intersection


22


and then makes turn


64


to follow the centerline of roadway


16


. Track


62


, roadways


12


and


16


, intersection


22


and turn


64


are provided to Route Data Base


52


during the preparation of the route by Map/Display Processor


50


from the then current position and the destination entered via input device


32


.




The physical position of car


10


is very accurately known when car


10


turns at turn


64


. This accurate knowledge of the car's position at a particular time may conveniently be used to update the GPS navigation information by providing a position reset which is similar to a known initial position. Update information from turns will most likely be useful if the angle of turn


64


is sufficiently large to provide an unambiguous position determination. It is expected that any turn greater than 45° may be detected. As the speed of the vehicle increases, smaller turn angles may also provide useful information. The position update information is applied to position model


63


to update internal clock or t


est


model


54


, elevation or z


est


model


56


, y


est


model


60


as well as x


est




61


which is a model of the along-track position of the car. These four estimates together for position model


63


, which may be updated by information from Map Data Base


30


, Route Data Base


52


, current position processor


70


, PosProcessor


48


and/or external sensor


49


, to form the most accurate available position model


63


. Position model


63


may also be used to provide estimates to the same data sources.




The actual turning of the car may be detected by a change in the vehicle velocity vector determined from the GPS data or from other conventional means such as a magnetic compass or an inertial navigation sensor. In accordance with the rapid reacquisition system described below with respect to

FIG. 3

, GPS data alone may conveniently detect such turns even when single satellite navigation is required. The turn as detected by turn detector


66


is correlated with data from Route Data Base


52


to determine the actual position of the car to the accuracy of the Map Data Base


30


. The accuracy of the data in Map Data Base


30


may easily and conveniently be much greater than the accuracy available from the GPS system especially if single satellite navigation, or any combination of clock, altitude or cross-track hold, is used. Therefore the position update may provide a substantial increase in the accuracy of the then current position determination.




The benefit of the approach of this embodiment of the present invention is similar to the identification and use of a known waypoint during a dead reckoning navigation run. The cumulative error is reduced substantially at the known waypoint so that additional, future position determination errors do not carry the burden of an accumulation of past errors.




As shown in

FIG. 2

, Route Data Base


52


provides data related to track


62


, typically from Map Data Base


30


, to Map/Display Processor


50


to display the current GPS position and may also provide similar information to turn detector


66


, turn comparator


68


and/or current position processor


70


in order to update PosProcessor


48


with a position reset.




Turn detector


66


may be configured in many different ways and is used to detect turns actually made by car


10


and select turns, such as turn


64


, from Route Data Base


52


for later comparison with the detected turn. In accordance with a preferred embodiment of the present invention, turn detector


66


may operate on the current GPS position provided by PosProcessor


48


to develop a vehicle velocity vector position indicating both the direction and speed of travel. Substantial changes in the direction portion of the vehicle velocity vector would indicate a change in direction, such as a turn. Turn detector


66


may therefore detect turns directly from the GPS information by determining the vehicle velocity vector and detecting changes in the vehicle velocity vector which represent a turn.




Turn detector


66


, or another unit if convenient, also operates on the route information provided by Route Data Base


52


to determine the expected position of car


10


along track


62


based on the then current GPS position information. Once the expected location of car


10


along the route is determined, one or more turns in the area of the expected position of car


10


can be selected for comparison with the indications of a physical turn derived from the GPS data.




When changes in the actual vehicle velocity vector, as derived for example from the GPS position data, compare appropriately with the changes predicted at a particular turn as derived from Route Data Base


52


, the actual position of car


10


at the time of the turn can be very accurately determined and used to update the GPS data at the turn. For example, if an actual turn is detected from a change in the vehicle velocity vector from the GPS position of car


10


near the time predicted for that turn, the actual position of car


10


at the time of the turn can be determined and used to update the then current GPS position for use as a position reset applied to PosProcessor


48


.




Alternatively, turn detector


66


may use non GPS measurements for determining the occurrence of an actual turn of car


10


, such as compass headings or inertial navigation determinations derived for example from external sensor


49


, and applied directly to turn detector


66


or via PosProcessor


48


as shown in FIG.


2


.




Detection of turns from GPS signals may easily be accomplished as long as


2


satellites are in view and provide appropriate geometries for determining two dimensional coordinates of the car's position. During single satellite navigation, as described above, the use of turn information for updating the last known position information becomes even more important, but the location of the single satellite in view, relative to track


62


, becomes of even greater importance so that actual turns may be accurately detected.




Turn detection may also be provided by monitoring changes between acquired and obscured satellites. If, for example, only satellite


14


was visible to car


10


on roadway


12


before intersection


22


, and upon entering intersection


22


, satellite


19


suddenly became visible while satellite


14


was momentarily obscured, the change over from satellite


14


to satellite


19


could be used to indicate a turn in accordance with the data from each satellite. Using a rapid reacquisition scheme, as described herein below, the actual position at which the change of direction, that is, the position at which the switch between satellites occurs, can be sufficiently accurately determined to permit precise position update information at the turn.




Similarly, turn comparator


68


may conveniently be implemented within another component of the system, such as PosProcessor


48


, Map/Display Processor


50


and/or SatProcessor


46


, so that a candidate turn may be selected from the route data for track


62


for comparison with the detected turn data.




Referring now to

FIG. 3

, in another embodiment, the present invention provides for fast reacquisition of satellite signals, useful for example when a previously acquired satellite is obscured and then appears perhaps for only a short time, for example, as a car travels through an intersection.




Referring to the line of sight between car


10


and satellite


19


as shown in

FIG. 1

, it is common in an urban environment for the buildings along the sides of the street to act as a barrier wall obscuring the lines of sight to many GPS satellites. However, the barrier wall formed by buildings


20


and


21


is commonly breached at intersections such as intersection


22


. For example, car


10


while traversing intersection


22


may reach position


11


in which the previously obscured line of sight to a satellite, such as satellite


19


, is momentarily not obscured because of the break between buildings


20


and


21


at intersection


22


. This momentary visibility of a previously obscured satellite may occur while car


10


is in the intersection or at the edges of the intersection.




The length of the momentary contact with satellite


19


is relatively short. For example, if intersection


22


is 60 feet wide and car


10


is traveling at 30 mph, the time taken to cross the intersection may be as short as 1.3 seconds. Conventional GPS navigation systems would not reacquire and derive useful data from satellite


19


, even if previously acquired, during this short time interval.




In accordance with another embodiment, the present invention makes maximum use of such reacquisition opportunities by minimizing the time required for reacquisition, the collection of data and processing of the collected data for position determination. Referring now to

FIG. 3

, a portion of SatTRAK channel


38


is shown in greater detail as an example of the configuration of each of the satellite tracking channels. After original acquisition, SatTRAK channel


38


tracks a single satellite by operating on satellite signals


72


received by GPS antenna


28


. Satellite signals


72


include the signals from the satellite being tracked by SatTRAK channel


38


and are demodulated and selected by being multiplied, in one of the correlators


74


, by a copy of the 1023 chip pseudorandom, spread spectrum code applied to satellite signals


72


by the GPS satellite. Correlators


74


may be configured from exclusive NOR gates to minimize the time required for providing a correlation result.




During tracking, the copy of the code produced by code generator


76


and applied to exclusive OR correlators


74


by delay


78


is synchronized with the code in satellite signals


72


, as received, so that the copy of the code correlates with satellite signals


72


. This may be accomplished in several different manners known in the art, including by shifting the time of generation of the code in code generator


76


and/or adjusting the amount of delay applied by an external delay. In any event, the code applied to exclusive OR correlators


74


when SatTRAK channel


38


is locked to the selected satellite, is synchronized with the code being received from that selected satellite. This correlation is commonly called the on-time or prompt correlation to indicate this synchronization.




Conventional GPS receivers maintain a lock on a satellite signal after acquisition by performing additional correlations, often called early and late correlations or correlations performed by early and late correlators. These correlations are displaced in time by a certain delay such as one half the width of a C/A code chip from the on-time or prompt correlator. That is, if the time of occurrence of a particular chip in the satellite signals is time t


0


, the prompt correlator under ideal conditions would multiply satellite signals


72


with a replica of the code with the same chip at time t


0


. The early correlation would be performed at time t


0


−½ chip and the late correlation would be performed at a time equal to t


0


+½ chip. Whenever the synchronization between code generator


76


and satellite signals


72


as received begins to drift, the correlation results begin to change in favor of either the early or late correlation at the expense of the prompt correlation.




One conventional approach to maintaining lock on the signals from a particular satellite is to adjust the timing of code generator


76


with a feed back loop used to maintain the power in the correlation products in the early and late correlators to be equal. In this way, code generator


76


may be continuously resynchronized with satellite signals


72


so that the accuracy of the system is within one half chip in either direction (early or late) of the signals received.




When satellite signals


72


are temporarily lost, for example, because the satellite signals are temporarily obscured by buildings


20


and


21


as shown in

FIG. 1

, various techniques are used to attempt to synchronize code generator


76


with satellite signals


72


as received so that SatTRAK channel


38


can reacquire the signals from the desired satellite. As noted above, conventional techniques include clock and altitude hold and one embodiment of the present invention provides another technique called cross-track hold. However, unless the obscuration of the satellite signals is very brief, the accuracy of prediction of such techniques is not enough to maintain synchronization except for a very brief period of obscuration.




In accordance with another embodiment of the present invention, massively parallel correlation is used to create an expanded capture window of correlation capture around the then current predicted synchronization time in order to immediately reacquire a previously acquired, and then obscured, satellite signal. In particular, the speed of reacquisition is made sufficiently fast according to the present invention so that useful GPS position data may be acquired during the time car


10


travels through intersection


22


even though, for example, the signals from satellite


19


were obscured by buildings


20


until car


10


was within intersection


22


.




To this end, an expanded series of correlations are performed with a series of delays a fixed fraction of a chip width, such as ½ chip width, apart extending both early and late of the predicted prompt correlation. As shown in

FIG. 3

, satellite signals


72


are devolved into a fixed number of samples, by for example analog to digital conversion in A/D Converter


73


, to provide n Signal Samples


75


. A similar number of code samples are provided through k fixed ½ chip width delays


78


to provide k−1 sets of n Code Samples


80


, progressing from a first set of n Code Samples


80


with no delay to the k−1st set of n Code Samples


80


which have been delayed by a total of k delays


78


. It is convenient to use ½ chip delays for each delay


78


, but other fractions of a chip width may be used.




The k/2th set of n Code Samples


80


, or the set nearest k/2, may conveniently be delayed the correct amount to perform the prompt correlation in one of the exclusive OR correlators


74


with n Signal Samples


75


from A/D Converter


73


during tracking. The k/2th−1 set of n Code Samples


80


may then be used to perform the early correlation while the k/2th+1 set of n Code Samples


80


may then be used to perform the late correlation while tracking. The additional correlations may also be performed during tracking, but provide a substantial advantage when used during reacquisition.




That is, in the present invention, the early, prompt and late correlations conventionally used in tracking may also be used during reacquisition mode, aided by a substantial number of correlations using additional delays. Whether or not the early and late correlations are used, a convenient number of additional delays on each side of the prompt delay results from (k−1)=20 so that nine or ten ½ chip delays are provided on each side of the k/2th prompt delay. In this way, correlations are performed during reacquisition at time delays of 5 chip widths on either side of the predicted prompt or on-time delay. This represents an expanded capture window of on the order of ±5×300 meters of potential error. That is, if the predicted synchronization with satellite signals


72


modeled by GPS car system module


26


drifted by as much as the equivalent of a ±1500 meter position error during signal loss from a particular satellite resulting from, for example obscuration in an urban setting, at least one of the plurality of exclusive OR correlators


74


would provide the required prompt correlation to immediately lock onto satellite signals


72


.




Once the correlations are performed, the correlation results for each set of n Code Samples


80


are summed in summers


84


to produce a series of values each separately indicating the correlation of n Signal Samples


75


with each of the sets of n Code Samples


80


. These correlation results are applied to threshold test


82


, the output of which is applied to SatProcessor


46


only when satellite signals


72


have been successfully received. The output of threshold test


82


specifies the number of delays which represent the prompt correlation for the reacquired satellite signal. It is important to note that in accordance with the present invention, the satellite tracking and reacquisition modes are not separated functions but rather interact seamlessly. That is, by providing a substantially expanded capture window, the correlations used for tracking are also automatically useful for immediate reacquisition as long the capture window is sufficiently wide to include any position error accumulated during signal obscuration or other loss.




Because the speed of reacquisition is very important in order to maximize the opportunity to utilize the brief time during travel through intersection


22


when satellite


19


may temporarily be in view, it is advantageous to perform all such correlations in parallel. Further, it is advantageous to continuously perform all such correlations in the capture window in order to minimize time when a satellite signal is not being tracked. In accordance with the presently preferred embodiment, exclusive OR correlators


74


are implemented in hardware rather than software to maximize the speed of correlation and minimize any error accumulation by minimizing the time for reacquisition.




In operation, when car


10


follows track


62


along roadway


12


, during at least part of the time buildings


21


obscure the line of sight between car


10


and satellite


19


. If satellite


19


had previously been acquired by GPS car system module


26


, an approximate time value to synchronize with the satellite signals will be predicted. This value is maintained as accurately as possible within GPS car system module


26


while satellite


19


is obscured. In order to maintain the prediction for the required delay as accurately as possible, that is, to minimize the position error accumulated during signal loss, the above described techniques for maintaining or updating position accuracy by using cross-track hold, resetting position at a determined turn and/or the use of external sensors for dead reckoning provide a substantial benefit for use with the combined, expanded tracking and reacquisition windows described above.




Present technology makes it convenient to provide ½ chip delays between correlators, but other delay values may be used. Similarly, it is convenient to expect that the prompt correlation can be maintained within plus or minus 5 chips of the timing of the satellite signals.

FIG. 3

therefore portrays a series of 9 or 10 early and 9 or 10 late correlators surrounding prompt correlator


74


to achieve the ±5 chip capture window surrounding prompt correlator


74


in 20 half chip steps. A different number of correlators and other delays would also work with the present invention.




Use of a plurality of fixed delays of one half chip width permit the immediate reacquisition of signals from a satellite to within an accuracy of one half chip width. In accordance with satellite signals


72


as presently provided by the NAVSTAR satellites, one half chip width represents about 150 meters of maximum position error. It is possible to substantially reduce the maximum position error, and/or the speed of processing the data, by using fixed delays of a different amount of delay, e.g. fixed delays of one third, one quarter, one fifth or some other value of a chip width.




Conventional approaches for different modes of operation, switch between wide and narrow delays at acquisition and/or reacquisition in order to provide a compromise between the width of the capture window and the number of correlations required for the desired range. In accordance with the present invention, a new technique is used which permits the convenient use of fixed, chip width delays to provide a finer gradation of correlation steps. In particular, as shown in

FIG. 4

, two sets of half width delays are used to provide the equivalent of a set of quarter width delays. The number of sets of fixed delays and the offset between them may be selected in accordance with the requirements of the application being addressed.




Referring now to

FIG. 4

, a first plurality of sets of n Code Samples


80


are derived directly from code generator


76


, delayed from each other by ½ chip width delays


78


and correlated with n Signal Samples


75


in exclusive OR (or NOR) correlators


74


as provided in FIG.


3


. For convenience of explanation and drawing, the outputs from this first set of set of n Code Samples


80


are shown applied to summers


84


to indicate that the correlation products produced in exclusive OR correlators


74


from each such set of n Code Samples


80


are applied to threshold test


82


via summers


84


. All such correlation products are applied, but for clarity only the correlation products having no delay, the predicted prompt or k/2th delay and the kth delay are depicted. The correlation products from this first plurality of sets of n Code Samples


80


are spaced apart by ½ chip width delay as noted above.




In addition, in accordance with the present invention, additional sets of correlation products at different spacings are available by use of one or more additional sets of ½ chip delays


78


by, for example, tracking the same satellite in two or more channels offset in time from each other. It is important to note again that other delays and/or offsets may also conveniently be used and the delays need not all be the same.




In particular, a second plurality of sets of n Code Samples


86


are derived from code generator


76


and delayed from each other by ½ chip width delays


78


. However, the delays in the second sets of n Code Samples


86


are offset from the delays in the first sets of n Code Samples


86


by a fixed amount, such as a ¼ chip width delay, by insertion of ¼ chip width delay


79


between code generator


76


and the first set of n code samples in sets of n Code Samples


86


. This results in each of the samples in sets of n Code Samples


86


falling halfway between two of the sets of n Code Samples


86


. As shown in

FIG. 4

only k−1 sets of n Code Samples


86


are required with k sets of n Code Samples


86


.




Each of the sets of n Code Samples


84


are correlated with n Signal Samples


75


in exclusive OR correlators


74


as provided in

FIG. 3

to produce correlation products which are then summed by additional summers


84


. As noted above, the dashed lines between each of the sets of code samples and summers


84


are used to indicate that the correlation product between that set of code samples and n Signal Samples


75


is applied to a particular one of summers


84


. As can then easily be understood from

FIG. 4

, correlation products separated from each other by ¼ chip width delays, from the 0th delay to kth delay, are produced using sets of ½ chip width delays and a single ¼ chip delay (which may represent the offset delay between two channels) and after individual summation are applied to threshold test


82


to determine which delay represents the currently prompt delay of satellite signals


72


from a satellite being reacquired by GPS car system module


26


.




The second set of ½ chip delays may easily be implemented by having a second channel track the same satellite, offset, however by ¼ chip width delay


79


.




In this way, the range of delay within which a satellite signal lock may be acquired, maintained and/or reacquired may be reduced from ±½ chip width, to about ±¼ chip width, which permits faster pull in to lock, i.e. when the tracking has been optimized and range error reduced to minimum.




It is important to note the seamless integration of tracking and reacquisition provided by the present invention in that the same correlations are used for tracking and reacquisition and the related speed of capture and lock and simplicity provided thereby. The ability to rapidly reacquire within a capture window so that one of the correlations may immediately be used as a prompt correlation, speeds up all data acquisitions thereafter. It is also convenient to utilize a first plurality of sets of n Code Samples


80


for tracking and, when satellite signals


72


are lost, provide additional accuracy in reacquisition by using a second plurality of sets of n Code Samples such as sets of n Code Samples


84


. In particular, the same plurality of sets of n Code Samples


84


may be used for reacquisition of signals


72


for different satellites at different times in order to reduce the total number of components and steps required to produce all the necessary correlations and summations.




In operation, GPS car system module


26


continuously attempts to track and reacquire the signals from satellite


19


in SatTRAK channel


38


while satellite


19


is obscured from view. As car


10


passes through intersection


22


, the line of sight to satellite


19


is momentarily not obscured by buildings


21


. Whenever any of the correlations performed in SatTRAK channel


38


indicate that the satellite signals are being received with sufficient strength so that the correlation products from some of the correlators are above threshold, reacquisition is immediately accomplished. Reacquisition occurs when the correlator output indicating the largest magnitude is selected as the new prompt correlator. Conventional techniques for improving the quality of the data are then employed.




The data from satellite


19


is used to immediately, after a settling time for lock, update the GPS data and correct the currently known position information derived therefrom. Even if satellite


19


is then again immediately obscured, the update information derived during travel through the intersection by fast reacquisition provides a substantial improvement in accuracy of the GPS determined position. This will permit GPS car system module


26


to continue accurate navigation even through otherwise very difficult areas, such as city streets.




Although the use of single satellite navigation data by cross-track hold and then updating a satellite data by detecting turns and/or immediately reacquiring satellite signals in intersections have all been described separately, they are also very useful in combination. Terrestrial navigation systems, using GPS receivers in a stand alone mode, aided by map displays and data bases and/or aided by external sensors such as inertial navigation systems may benefit from the use of combinations of one or more such modes. In a preferred embodiment of the present invention, all three techniques are combined to maximize the ability of the car navigation system to provide accurate and useful navigation data while traversing a difficult environment such as city streets.




Referring now to

FIG. 5

, a preferred embodiment of the present invention is described in which major portions of SatTRAK channels


38


,


40


,


42


and


44


and SatProcessor


46


of the present invention are implemented in an Application Specific Integrated Circuit or ASIC


102


. Many of the functions of a conventional satellite processor may still, however, be performed in software. The particular implementation depicted provides a 12 channel GPS acquisition and tracking system with fast reacquisition capabilities as described above while substantially reducing the number of gates required on the ASIC to implement this system.




The signals received by GPS antenna


28


are digitized and downconverted to form a digital composite of signals received from all satellites in view to produce sample data


100


which is at a frequency of 37.33 f


0


where f


0


is the chip rate of the C/A code applied to each GPS satellite. For convenience, the frequencies described below will be designated in terms of multiples of f


0


. Each of 12 Space Vehicles (SVs) or satellites are tracked in ASIC


102


under the control of Central Processing Unit, or CPU,


101


which provides control signals and data to ASIC


102


. In particular, CPU


101


provides data regarding the predicted Doppler shifts and C/A code applied to each SV to Random Access Memory, or RAM, R


1




103


associated with ASIC


102


which provides the data to RAM R


2




105


at designated times. RAM R


2




105


provides data to and receives data from ASIC


102


, permitting CPU


101


data updating and ASIC


102


processing of old data to operate simultaneously. RAM R


2




105


is used as a buffer by ASIC


102


primarily to store intermediate values of signals during processing. Other conventional portions of a microcomputer including a CPU are not shown but conveniently may include devices operating software implementing the single satellite, cross-track hold and other techniques described above as well as other functions of SatProcessor


46


.




Sample data


100


is applied to C/A code acquisition, tracking and reacquisition block CACAPT


104


in ASIC


102


where it is split into in-phase and quadrature-phase, or I and Q, signals at baseband by I/Q splitter


106


. After processing by CACAPT


104


, the I,Q signals are rotated for Doppler shift in 12 channel Doppler Block


108


which separately compensates for the expected Doppler frequency shifts of each of the 12 SVs which can be tracked.




The Doppler rotated I,Q signals for each SV are then applied to Correlator Block


110


where each signal sample, which is from one of the 12 SVs, is correlated in a multiplexed fashion with 20 delayed versions of the C/A code, produced by 12 channel Coder Block


112


, for that SV. During each segment of time, as described below with regard to

FIG. 11

in greater detail, Correlator Block


110


performs 240 C/A code correlations in accumulator


175


to enhance the speed of acquisition and reacquisition. The output of Correlator Block


110


is applied to IQACCUM Block


114


, and the output of IQACCUM Block


114


is applied to IQSQACCUM


116


, in Accumulator Block


115


. IQACCUM Block


114


is conveniently configured from another block of RAM associated with ASIC


102


, identified herein as RAM


3


. Similarly, IQSQACCUM


116


is conveniently configured from another block of RAM associated with ASIC


102


, identified herein as RAM


4


.




Accumulator Block


115


operates in different fashions during acquisition, tracking and reacquisition modes under the direction of CPU


101


. During acquisition mode, Coder Block


112


is caused to sequence through as many sets of 240 different codes delays as necessary to acquire the satellite signals from a particular space vehicle. That is, as many sets of 240 different delays are correlated in Correlator Block


110


to provide IQSQACCUM


116


with an appropriate correlation output whose power indicates that correlation has been achieved with that satellite. The process is then repeated for each satellite to be acquired. For convenience, all delays may be tested.




During reacquisition, a single set of 20 delays are correlated in Correlator Block


110


to determine if one such delay provides a peak value above a predetermined threshold to indicate that a correlation has been achieved and the satellite thereby reacquired. The reacquisition mode operates transparently within the tracking mode in that a set of 20 delays are correlated in Correlator Block


110


. If tracking is maintained, the peak signal may migrate from a particular delay to the next adjacent delay but will be maintained within the current set of 20 delays being correlated. It is convenient to consider the delay producing the signal with the greatest magnitude as the prompt delay, producing the prompt correlation product. The signals produced by one more and one less delay then become the early and late correlation products which may be processed in a conventional manner to maintain lock with each satellite.




If the signal from the satellite is temporarily obscured or lost for any other reason, the then current set of 20 delays is correlated and searched for a peak of sufficient magnitude to indicate reacquisition. The Doppler and code values are continuously updated based upon the last available position information including velocity, and the correlations are performed, until the satellite signal is reacquired or sufficient time has elapsed so that the satellite signal is considered lost.




The operation and configuration of ASIC


102


will now be described in greater detail with regard to the in-phase or I signal path. The quadrature phase or Q signal path is identical and need not be separately described.




Within CACAPT


104


, sample data


100


is applied at 37.33 f


0


to I/Q splitter


106


to produce a 2 bit signal at 18.67 f


0


which is further reduced to 2 f


0


by Digital Filter


118


which operates by adding sets of 10, 9 and 9 samples which are summed, quantized, and then stored serially in 11 sample deep buffer


120


. When 11 sample deep buffer


120


is filled, the data is transferred in a parallel fashion to an identical buffer, called parallel block


122


, for Doppler rotation. Data is therefore transferred out of 11 sample deep buffer


120


when 11 samples are received, that is, at a chip rate of {fraction (1/11)}th of 2 f


0


or approximately 0.18 f


0


. 11 sample deep buffer


120


operates as a serial to parallel converter while parallel block


122


operates as a parallel to serial converter. This results in 186 parallel transfers per msec.




Data is shifted out of parallel block


122


at 24 f


0


to 12 channel Doppler Block


108


so that the Least Significant Bit or LSB of the serial converter, parallel block


122


, is the output of CACAPT


104


in the form of CapIOut and CapQOut which are applied as CACAPT Data output


123


to 12 channel Doppler Block


108


. The increase in chip rate from 2 f


0


to 24 f


0


provides an operating speed magnification of 12 as will be described below in greater detail.




Referring now also to

FIG. 6

, 12 channel Doppler Block


108


is now described in greater detail. Doppler Block


108


receives satellite specific CACAPT Data output


123


including CapIout and CapQOut from CACAPT


104


for storage in Doppler Register


124


. Satellite or source specific predicted Doppler phase, after processing by Carrier Numerical Control Oscillator or NCO


125


and sine/cosine look-up table


134


, is also applied to Doppler Register


124


where it is added to CapIOut and CapQOut for the same SV (or other source) to form dopIOut and dopQOut. Within Doppler Block


108


, Carrier_NCO


125


operates at an effective rate of 2 f


0


for each satellite channel because the data sample rate is 2 f


0


.




For each SV, CPU


101


stores the satellite specific predicted carrier phase dopPhaseParam, and predicted carrier frequency dopFreqParam, in RAM R


2




105


. Sat_Mem


186


then transfers the dopPhaseParam and dopFreqParam as shown in

FIG. 9

to Carrier Phase Register


126


and Carrier Phase Output Buffer


128


, respectively, at each 1 msec boundary. Adder


130


adds carrier phase to carrier frequency, derived from dopPhaseParam and dopFreqParam, to produce the current carrier phase value in Carrier Phase Register


126


shown as Carrier_NCO.




The four Most Significant Bits or MSBs of Carrier_NCO in Carrier Phase Register


126


are applied to sine/cosine look-up table


134


which includes 2 4-bit registers for storing its output. The output of sine/cosine look-up table


134


is applied to Doppler Multiplier


132


in Doppler Register


124


for Doppler rotation of CACAPT Data output


123


(CapIOut and CapQOut) to produce rotated SV output signals dopIOut and dopQOut. Doppler Register


124


uses Doppler Multiplier


132


, as well as four 4-bit registers, two adders, another pair of 5-bit registers and a quantizer to form dopIOut and dopQOut. Referring for a moment to

FIG. 8

, dopIOut and dopQOut are applied to parallel converter


166


and rotated SV output signal


127


is the output of serial to parallel converter


166


which is applied directly to 11 bit Holding Register


140


.




During each segment of time, the beginning value for the Doppler phase of each SV is stored in RAM R


2




105


, retrieved therefrom by Doppler Block


108


for the rotation of the SV during that segment. At the end of each segment, the end value of Doppler phase is stored in RAM R


2




105


for use as the beginning value for the next segment. Under the control of gpsCt


1




182


, Doppler phase value dopP_Next in Carrier Phase Output Buffer


128


, saved at the end of each rotation for a particular SV by dopsave, is applied to Sat_Mem


186


for storage in RAM R


2




105


for that SV, to be retrieved by Doppler Block


108


again during the next Doppler rotation of that SV in the following segment. The operation of Multiplexer Block


129


may be best understood from the description of the triple multiplexing of ASIC


102


associated with

FIGS. 10 and 11

.




Referring now also to

FIG. 7

, 12 channel Coder Block


112


includes Coder_NCO


136


and Code Generator


138


. Coder_NCO


136


, which is similar to Carrier_NCO


125


shown in

FIG. 6

, creates Gen_Enable whenever Phase Accumulator


148


overflows. Gen_Enable is the MSB of the output of Phase Accumulator


148


and is applied to Code Generator


138


.




In particular, under the control of gpsCtl


182


, Sat_Mem


186


applies the satellite specific 24 bit code frequency parameter, coderFreqParam, and the 24 bit satellite specific code phase parameter, codePhaseParam, at each 1 msec edge to Coder_NCO


136


from RAM R


2




105


. CoderFreqParam is added to codePhaseParam effectively at 4 f


0


per channel in Phase Adder


150


even though codePhaseParam operates at 48 f


0


during tracking and reacquisition. A pulse can be generated for Gen_Enable between 0 Hz and 4 f


0


Hz. In order to generate Gen_Enable at 2 f


0


, the value of half the bits (23:0) of Phase Accumulator


148


must be loaded in as coderFreqParam.




The LSB of codePhaseParam represents {fraction (1/256)}th of a C/A code chip. CodePhaseParam initializes the contents of Phase Accumulator


148


. Gen_Enable is generated whenever Phase Accumulator


148


overflows. Phase Accumulator


148


is a 25 bit register initialized by the value of codePhaseParam when corHoldRegLoad


152


from CPU


101


is active at each 1 msec edge when new data is written from CPU


101


. The 24 LSBs of 25-bit Phase Accumulator


148


are then added to coderFreqParam in Phase Adder


150


and returned to Phase Accumulator


148


. Phase Buffer Register


154


stores and buffers the contents of Phase Accumulator


148


, to produce CoderPNext which is updated whenever codCodeSave


158


from gpsCtl


182


is active. CoderPNext is applied to Sat_Mem


186


for storage in RAM R


2




105


. The operation of multiplexer


142


may be best understood from the description below of the triple multiplexing of ASIC


102


provided with

FIGS. 10 and 11

.




Gen_Enable is applied to Code Generator


138


to cause a new code to be generated. C/A Codes parameters G


1


and G


2


are parallel loaded from RAM R


2




105


by Sat_Mem


186


as g


1


ParIn and g


2


ParIn into Code Generator


138


to produce g


1


GenOut and g


2


GenOut which are returned to RAM R


2




105


by Sat_Mem


186


. The bit-


0


of both G


1


and G


2


generators in Code Generator


138


are internally XOR=d and generate genSerOut


160


which is serially applied to


11


bit Code Shift Register


170


in Correlator Block


110


, as shown in FIG.


5


. Code Generator


138


generates the following C/A codes:






G


1


=1+X


3


+X


10










G


2


=1+X


2


+X


3


+X


6


+X


8


+X


9


+X


10


.






The output of Code Shift Register


170


is applied to correlators


74


, 11 bits at a time at 48 f


0


so that at least 20 code delays, separated by one half chip width, are correlated against each Doppler rotated sample from each SV. The increase in chip rate from 2 f


0


to 48 f


0


provides a magnification factor of 24 as will be described below in greater detail.




Values of G


1


and G


2


are be stored in RAM R


2




105


during each segment after correlation with the Doppler rotated sample in correlators


74


for that SV so that they may then be retrieved by Coder Block


112


during the next time segment for correlation of the next 11 bit sample from the same SV.




Referring now also to

FIG. 8

, Correlator Block


110


is shown in greater detail. DopIOut and dopQOut in the rotated SV output from Doppler Block


108


are applied to serial to parallel converter


166


which is then parallel loaded to Holding Register


140


. GenSerOut


160


from Coder Block


112


is applied to Code Shift Register


170


in Correlator Block


110


. These data sets represent the Doppler shifted data received from the SV, as well as the locally generated code for that SV, and are applied to Exclusive NOR gate correlator


74


for correlation under control of gpsCtl


182


.




The output of correlator


74


is applied to Adder


174


and combined in Bit Combiner


176


to corIOut


178


and corQOut


180


which are applied to IQACCUM Block


114


and IQSQACCUM


116


shown in FIG.


5


. Adder


174


and Bit Combiner


176


operate as a partial accumulator as indicated by accumulator


175


in FIG.


5


.




Referring now also to

FIG. 9

, on overview of the operation of ASIC


102


is shown. A dedicated set of on-chip logic controls the operation of ASIC


102


and is identified herein as gpsCtl


182


. In particular, under the control of gpsCtl


182


, sample data


100


from the GPS satellites is applied to CACAPT


104


where it is separated and decimated into I and Q data streams to form CACAPT Data output


123


. SV data


123


is rotated for the predicted Doppler shift of each SV to produce rotated SV output signals dopIOut and dopQOut which are correlated with genSerOut


160


from Coder Block


112


in correlators


74


. CorIOut


178


and corQOut


180


from correlators


74


are accumulated in IQACCUM Block


114


and IQSQACCUM


116


to produce output


184


to CPU


101


.




As will be further described below in greater detail, a portion of memory is used for Sat_Mem


186


which stores and provides the Doppler shift and code information required during multiplexing.




In operation, every millisecond is divided into 186 segments, each of which includes 264 clocks. Within these 264 clocks, 12 channels are processed with each channel taking 22 clocks to compute 22 different correlations or delays. Only 20 of these 22 correlations are stored and used for subsequent processing. For each channel, gpsCt


1




182


controls the loading of Carrier_NCO


125


in Doppler Block


108


using dopLoad and dopSave. Similarly, gpsCtl


182


controls the loading of Coder_NCO


136


in Coder Block


112


via corHoldRegLoad and corCodeSave. The flow of data through Correlator Block


110


is controlled with serialShiftClk, and also corHoldRegLoad and codCodeSave. Control signals are applied to IQACCUM Block


114


and IQSQACCUM


116


for each channel and include startSegment, startChan, resetAcc, peak, iqsq, wrchan, ShiftSelIqSq and acq_mode. Within each segment, gpsCtl


182


provides the periodic signals eng_capShiftClk, capLoad, syncpulse, serialShiftClk to CACAPT


104


to repackage incoming satellite data samples into groups of 11 half chip samples.




All accesses initiated by gpsCtl


182


are processed by Sat_Mem


186


to generate read/write control and address signals for RAM R


1




103


and RAM R


2




105


. GpsCtl


182


controls the flow of data through all data paths together with Sat_Mem


186


and manages the access of channel parameters stored in RAM R


1




103


and RAM R


2




105


. RAM R


1




103


is written to by the user to define the channel parameters that will be loaded to RAM R


2




105


at the end of the corresponding integration or accumulation time. RAM R


2




105


is used by the data path as a scratchpad to store the intermediate values of the various channel parameters during processing.




Data read out of RAM R


2




105


is sent to the various parameter registers in Doppler Block


108


, Coder Block


112


, Correlator Block


110


and gpsCtl


182


under the control of Sat_Mem


186


. Data from these blocks and RAM


1




190


are multiplexed at the input to the write port of RAM R


2




105


. RAM R


1




103


is a 16×108 asynchronous dual port ram used for the parameters for all 12 channels while RAM


2




192


is another 16×108 asynchronous dual port ram used for storing intermediate values of the satellite parameters during processing, while switching from one channel to the next.




Referring now to

FIG. 10

, the system of the present invention includes a multiplexed data path in order to reduce the size and complexity of ASIC


102


on which the majority of the parts of the system can be provided. Conventional receiver designs have multiplexed a single set of correlators for use for each of the separate channels in which an SV is tracked in order to reduce the number of correlators required. The use of the system of the present invention reduces the million or more gates that would be required for a conventional configuration down to a manageable number, on the order of about less than 100,000.




In accordance with the present invention, in addition to multiplexing the satellite channels in a manner in which no data is lost, the code delay correlations are also multiplexed. That is, conventional receivers use two or three correlators to provide early, late and/or prompt correlations for each SV. The present invention multiplexes a plurality of code delays in order to provide far more code delay correlations than have been available in conventional systems without substantially multiplying the hardware, or chip area on ASIC


102


required by the number of gates used.




The multiplexing of code delays permits the wide capture window described above with regard to

FIGS. 3 and 4

that permits rapid SV reacquisition. In particular, 20 delays such as ½ chip delays are provided and constantly monitored for each SV so that GPS data can be acquired even during brief glimpses of the SV, for example, when car


10


is in intersection


22


as shown in FIG.


1


. The SV can be reacquired and useful data obtained because the modeling of the vehicle's position on roadway


12


is sufficiently accurate to keep the predicted code and Doppler values for a previous acquired and currently obscured SV within a window of ±10 half chip code delays. In this way, data obtained during reacquisition can be used directly as GPS data. That is, the reacquisition mode is transparent to the tracking mode. The GPS data is acquired whenever available without substantial lost time for reacquisition.




Further, the operation of satellite tracking is itself multiplexed for each set of data for all 12 channels in order to further substantially reduce the ASIC gate count. That is, only a small portion of the bits in the C/A code is processed at one time for all 12 SVs. In order to digitally process the signals received, the digital representations of these signals must be processed in registers and buffers capable of storing the digital data. The C/A code contains 1023 bits in each repetition which lasts 1 msec. If all 1023 bits were to be processed at once, registers 1023 bits wide would be required. Such registers would be expensive in cost and gate count and quite cumbersome. In accordance with the third level of multiplexing used in the triply multiplexed receiver configuration of the present invention, a smaller register is multiplexed to handle different portions of the 1023 bits of the C/A code. This means the smaller register is used many times during each 1 msec repetition of the C/A code to process enough smaller samples of the data received so that within each msec all 1023 bits can be processed.




In the preferred embodiment described above particularly in

FIGS. 3

to


9


, a configuration using 11 bits registers was used so that each register is used 186 times per msec to process all 1023 bits of a C/A code repetition. Each {fraction (1/186)}th of a msec is called a segment. The tracking of each SV is therefore multiplexed 186 times by processing the 11 bits in each register during each segment. In addition, in the preferred embodiment, 12 channels are used to track a maximum of 12 SVs. This requires that each 11 bit segment is multiplexed 12 times during that segment to apply a Doppler rotation for each SV.




Further, each channel is further multiplexed by a factor of 22 to provide a substantial plurality of different code delays. This requires that the Doppler rotated sample for each SV is correlated 22 times with different C/A Code delays before the Doppler rotated sample for the next channel is produced. In this manner, 22 different code phases may be tested for each of 12 SV during each of 186 segments to provide real time data with only 11 bit wide registers by processing each register 186 times per msec.




It is important to note that the processing of the present invention occurs during a particular segment, i.e. a {fraction (1/186)}th of a repetition of the C/A code, during the length of time required for the segment to be collected. In this optimized manner, no data is lost during tracking or reacquisition or switching between these states because the data being processed in any particular segment is at most 11 half chip delays old.




Referring now to

FIGS. 10 and 11

, the output of Digital Filter


118


shown in

FIG. 5

is sample data stream


119


at 2 f


0


. The chip rate of the C/A modulation of the signals


100


from the SVs is at f


0


. In order to avoid loss of any data, the SV signals must be sampled at least at their Nyquist rate, that is, at twice the chip rate of the modulation of interest which is 2 f


0


. Although sample data stream


119


can be operated at a higher chip rate than the Nyquist rate, which is twice the chip rate, there is no advantage in doing so.




Sample data stream


119


is therefore a series of samples of the digitized and filtered SV data at twice the chip rate of the C/A code, that is, each sample in sample data stream


119


has a width equal to one half of a C/A code chip. The number of bits in each msec or cycle of code in sample data stream


119


is twice the number of bits in the modulation, i.e. 2046 bits each representing one half of a C/A code chip. In accordance with the multiplexing scheme of the preferred embodiment being disclosed, the data is processed in 11 bit segments, and sample data stream


119


is therefore applied serially to 11 bit (10:0) register value buffer


120


. The time required to serially store 11 bits out of a total of 2046 bits in the 2 f


0


data stream is 1÷+(2046÷11=186) or {fraction (1/186)}th of a msec.




During the time the first set of 11 sample bits is being stored in 11 sample deep buffer


120


, no bits are available for processing. After the first 11 sample bits are serially received and serially stored, the 11 sample bits are transferred in parallel to parallel block


122


. This parallel operation therefore occurs every {fraction (1/186)}th of a msec or at a rate of approximately 0.18 f


0


. Each {fraction (1/186)}th of a msec is called a time segment or segment and is the unit of processing for most of the operations. The 1023 chip C/A code of each of the satellites in the composite signal received is processed in 11 half chip bits. Dividing the msec repetition rate of the C/A code into 186 time segments multiplexes each of the 11 bit registers by a multiplexing factor of 186.




CACAPT Data output


123


from parallel block


122


is processed in Doppler Block


108


at a much faster chip rate, for example at 24 f


0


. That is, the 11 bits of sample data in each segment of time is multiplexed by a factor of 12 to permit 12 different operations to be performed to that set of 11 bits of data. In particular, in Doppler Block


108


, CapIOut and CapQOut of CACAPT Data output


123


are multiplied in Doppler Register


124


by twelve different Doppler shifts so that within each segment twelve different Doppler rotations are performed.




Each different Doppler shift represents the predicted Doppler rotation required for each of the maximum of 12 different SVs that can be tracked. The increase in processing chip rate from 2 f


0


to 24 f


0


multiplexes the processing for each of 12 channels of data. It is important to note that the multiplexing to permit one channel to operate as 12 multiplexed or virtual channels each representing a different SV is applied only after the input signals are multiplexed, that is, broken into 186 time segments each including 11 half chip width bits. In this way, the multiplexing for 12 channels or satellites is easily accomplished with relatively inexpensive 11 bit registers without loss of time or data. The selection of the number of sampling to be an integer division of the number of code bits per period is important to achieve these goals. Multiplexer Block


129


in Carrier_NCO


125


controls the timing of this multiplexing under the direction of gpsCtl


182


.




The output of Doppler Block


108


, signals dopIOut and dopQOut, are applied to serial to parallel converter


166


within Correlator Block


110


. Each rotated SV output signal


127


represents the rotated signal from a single SV and 12 such rotated SV output signals


127


are produced in each segment of time.




Rotated SV output signal


127


is loaded in parallel fashion into Holding Register


140


in Correlator Block


110


. The input to Exclusive NOR gate correlator


74


is therefore an 11 bit wide signal which is retained for {fraction (1/12)}th of a time segment as one input to Exclusive NOR gate correlator


74


.




Correlator


74


is a series of 11 separate one bit correlators which all operate in parallel. One input is rotated SV output signal


127


while the other 11 bit input is provided by 11 one bit genSerOut


160


output bits from Coder Block


112


. During the {fraction (1/12)} of a time segment provided for operation on the rotated SV output signal


127


for a particular satellite, the code for that SV is produced serially by Code Generator


138


and applied to Code Shift Register


170


.




At the beginning of the correlation for a particular channel, 11 bits of the code for that SV have been shifted into Code Shift Register


170


and are available therein for correlation. Every {fraction (1/22)}nd of a channel (that is, a {fraction (1/12)} of a segment) each of the 11 bits in Code Shift Register


170


are correlated in one of 11 one bit exclusive Nor gates in Exclusive NOR gate correlator


74


. This produces 11 correlator output bits, the sum of which indicates the magnitude of the correlation between the rotated SV output signal


127


and that code phase. These 11 correlation sums produced in parallel are summed in parallel and stored in the first of 22 summers related to that SV in Accumulator Block


115


.




During the next or second {fraction (1/22)}nd of a channel, Code Generator


138


produces the next bit for the C/A code for that SV. This next bit is applied serially to Code Shift Register


170


. At this time, 10 bits from the first correlation remain in Code Shift Register


170


and together with the newest bit form another 11 bit sample of the expected code for that SV, delayed from the previous 11 bit sample by the time required to generate 1 bit, that is, one half chip width at the rate code is produced, 48 f


0


. The second sample is therefore a one half chip delayed version of the code, delayed one half chip width from the previous 11 bit samples. It is important to note that the two 11 bit code samples just described differ only in that a new bit was shifted in at one end of the register to shift out the MSB at the other end of the register.




The 11 bit correlation product of the same rotated SV output signal


127


and the second 11 bit sample of code is then stored in the second of the 22 summers related to that SV in Accumulator Block


115


. Thereafter, the remaining 20 serial shifts of the genSerOut


160


from Code Generator


138


are correlated against the same rotated SV output signal


127


to produce 20 more sums of 11 bit correlations for storage in Accumulator Block


115


for that SV. The result is that 22 values are then available within Accumulator Block


115


for processing, each value is a measure of the correlation of the signals from one SV with 22 different code phases or delays, each separated by one half chip width.




During the next {fraction (1/12)} of a time segment, that is, during the processing of the second multiplexed channel, the rotated SV output signal


127


for the next SV, is applied to Holding Register


140


for correlation with 22 different one half chip delays of the code generated for that satellite. At the end of a segment, Accumulator Block


115


includes a matrix of 12 by 20 different sums. In one implementation of the present invention, it has been found to be convenient to save only 20 out of the 22 possible code delay correlation results. The 12 rows of 20 sums represent the measure of correlation for each of the 12 SVs at 20 code phases or delays.




In summary, the data path for the present invention is triply multiplexed in that




(a) each msec, which represents 1023 bits of C/A code, is sliced into 186 to form the 186 segments in a msec of sample so that only 11 half chip wide sample bits are processed at one time;




(b) each segment is then multiplexed by 12 so that each such 11 bit sample is rotated for twelve different sources;




(c) the rotated 11 bit sample for each source is correlated against 20 sets of different code delays for that source to multiplex within each channel by 20; and




(d) the sum of the correlation products for each delay in each channel are then summed to produce the accumulated correlation output.




Although 22 different delays are available, it is convenient to use 20 such delays, or code phase theories for testing the rotated satellite signal. The correlation product having the greatest magnitude for each channel after accumulation, that is, the largest of the 20 sums of 11 bits stored in Accumulator Block


115


for each channel may then be detected by its magnitude, for example by a peak detector, to determine which delay theory is the most accurate. The peak sum represents the on-time or prompt correlation for that SV.




Turning now specifically to

FIG. 11

, the triple multiplexing scheme of the present invention may easily be understood by looking at the slices of time resulting from each of the multiplexing operations. Within each msec, the C/A code for each particular satellite has 1023 bits. In order to preserve all necessary information, the satellite signals are sampled, in a digital composite of signals from all satellites, at the Nyquist rate at 2 f


0


to produce 2046 half chip wide sample bits.




Each sequential set of eleven sample bits are processed together as a segment of time, the length of which is equal to 1/(2046÷11) of a msec, i.e. one {fraction (1/186)}th of a msec. After processing of the 186th segment in a msec all necessary data has been extracted and the 11 bit sample for the next segment is available. Although the partial sums accumulated over each msec in Accumulator Block


115


may only be evaluated at the end of a msec, no data is lost and the results are only 1 segment late. That is, since it takes 1 segment to fill 11 sample deep buffer


120


and transfer the 11 bit sample to parallel block


122


, the data from the first 11 bit sample is being processed while the data for the second 11 bit sample is being collected. Even if the system operated for a year, the sampled being processed to provide position information is still only one time segment old.




The 11 bits of each segment are multiplexed for each SV by being time division multiplexed during Doppler rotation. That is, the 11 bit sample of segment


1


is used to provide 12 different Doppler shifted outputs so that a single 11 bit segment sample is used 12 times to produce 12 different satellite specific Doppler rotated versions, assuming all 12 satellites are in view or being modeled. The operations for one channel then require one twelfth of a segment. It is critical to note that each segment only produces a partial result and that the 12 partial results during each segment must be summed at the end of each msec to provide valid output data.




Each of the operations on one particular channel in a segment are time division multiplexed by a factor of 22 so that 22 different code delays for that partial sum for that satellite can be tested. The peak sum of these 22 correlations can however be detected by magnitude immediately if necessary to select the most likely delay for that channel. In the present embodiment, the information for that channel is only valid once per msec when summed or accumulated so that there may not be a substantial advantage in peak detected with a particular segment. In some GPS applications and in other spread spectrum applications, such as wireless communications, it may be desirable if strong signals are present to accumulate and transfer the sum of the accumulations for each source from R


3


to R


4


more often than once per code repetition rate. The time required to evaluate a particular code phase delay or theory is only {fraction (1/22)}nd of the time required per channel per segment or {fraction (1/22)}nd of {fraction (1/12)} of {fraction (1/186)}th of a msec. This speed of operation is more easily achieved because the 11 one bit correlations required are produced in parallel. Similarly, the speed of generation of the different code delays for a particular SV is more easily accomplished in accordance with the present invention because each 11 bit code delay sample is automatically produced when each single new bit, i.e. each new genSerout


160


, is shifted into Code Shift Register


170


.




The selection of the magnitudes or multiplexing factors used in each level of multiplexing is not arbitrary. The larger the number of segments, the smaller the required size or depth of the registers need for each sample. By using a code repetition multiplexing factor of 186, that is, by dividing the 2046 bits of a 2 f


0


by 186, only 11 sample bit, need to be evaluated at a time.




The number of required channels is bounded pragmatically by the fact that at least 4 SVs must be in view at the same time to determine position accurately in three dimensions. Time is the fourth unknown which must be determined along with each of the three dimensions although provisions for estimating, modeling and/or updating the position information as described above so that position information may be accurately provided even during periods when less than 4 satellites are concurrently in view.




The constellation of 24 NAVSTAR satellites in use are arranged to cover the earth so that a maximum of 12 such satellites may be in view at any one location at any particular time. The maximum number of pragmatically useful channels is, for this reason, no less than about 12 channels. The selected channel multiplexing factor used in the channel level of multiplexing in the embodiment shown herein is therefore a factor of 12.




The number of different code delays is bounded at the low end by an absolute minimum of 1 so that if the exact delay can somehow be maintained, the only necessary correlation would be the on-time or prompt correlation. Conventional GPS receiver systems use at least 2 or 3 different code delays so that conventional tracking techniques, for example those which use early, prompt and late correlations to center the prompt correlation within ±1 delay, may be employed.




In accordance with the present invention, a substantially greater number of different code delays, or delay theories, are tested so that fast reacquisition may be accomplished as described above with regard to

FIGS. 3 and 4

. Although for the particular preferred embodiment described herein, it was determined that a total of 20 different delays, each separated in time by one half the width of a C/A code chip, i.e. ½ of {fraction (1/2046)} of one msec, a code delay multiplexing factor of 22 was selected because the relationship between each of the 3 multiplexing factors is also important.




The product of the three multiplexing factors, code repetition multiplexing factor, channel multiplexing factor and code delay multiplexing factor should optimally be an even integer multiple of the number of bits in each repetition of the spread spectrum modulation. An even integer multiple is required because samples must be taken at twice the chip rate, i.e. at the Nyquist rate, in order to avoid data loss from sampling at a slower rate. Although multiplexing factors can be used successfully even if the product is not exactly equal to an even integer multiple, data loss or unnecessary complexity and costs may result.




In the particular embodiment shown, the spread spectrum code of interest is the C/A code, each repetition of which includes 1023 bits. In accordance with the triple multiplexing product rule discussed above, the product of the three multiplexing factors must equal an even integer multiple of 1023, such as 2046. In the described embodiment, the code repetition multiplexing factor is 186, the channel multiplexing factor is 12 and the code delay multiplexing factor is 22. The product of 186 multiplied by 12 and then by 22 is 49104 which, when divided by 1023, equals 48. 48 is an even integer and therefore the particular set of multiplexing factors used in the present invention provides one of several optimized systems.




The reason this multiplexing factor product rule works well in a tri-level multiplexing configuration for C/A code is that there are three prime factors in 1023. That is, 1023 is the product of three prime numbers, 31, 11 and 3. Each of the three multiplexing factors is evenly divisible by one of these prime numbers. For example, 186 is divisible by 31 six times, 12 is divisible by 3 four times and 22 is divisible by 11 twice.




Using each prime factor of the number of bits in the sampled bit rate in one of the multiplexing factors yields two or more different families of multiplexing configurations for C/A code is spread spectrum receivers. In the first family, if 11 channels are desired, then either the code repetition multiplexing factor or the channel multiplexing factor would have to be divisible by 31. Although it may be desirable in certain applications to use 31 or 62 different code delays, there is a substantial advantage in making the code repetition multiplexing factor as large as possible. This reduces the number of bits required to be saved and processed in each segment. By selecting the code repetition multiplexing factor to be a multiple of 31, the number of delays actually used can be more easily controlled because the code delay multiplexing factor could be any multiple of 3.




In the other convenient family, 6, 9, 12, 15 or 18 satellite channels are desired so that the channel multiplexing factor is an integral multiple of 3. This permits the code delay multiplexing factor to be a factor of 11 while the code repetition multiplexing factor is a factor of 31. The particular embodiment described in the specification above is in this family.




Another constraint on the selection of multiplexing factors is the speed of operation of the lowest level of multiplexing. In the embodiment disclosed, the third level of multiplexing operates at 48 f


0


. The clock speed of the hardware implementation must be sufficient to permit operation at this speed. As faster and faster on chip components are developed, higher clock speeds may be used to accomplish the highest speed processing and larger multiples may be used. For example, with components in the high speed processing sections such as Correlator Block


110


capable of operation at higher rates at multiples of f


0


, such as at 96 f


0


, the code repetition multiplexing factor could be doubled to produce 24 channels with 20 delays or taps or 12 channels with 40 delays or taps or 11 channels with 6 bits and 22 taps.




The system configuration may also be viewed from the standpoint of a time or speed magnification. Operation at the third multiplexing level at 48 f


0


is 24 times faster than the chip rate of the 2 f


0


sample being processed. This amplification factor of 24 permits a hardware multiplexing or gate compression factor of 24. The number of gates on ASIC


102


, or other devices for implementation the present invention, is reduced essentially in direct proportion to the magnification factor. All other factors being equal, the surface area of a chip operated at 48 f


0


is on the order of {fraction (1/24)}th of the surface area that would be required to operate at 2 f


0


. Similarly, an increase in the magnification factor to 96 would permit a reduction in the required chip surface real estate required on the order of almost half.




The particular embodiment of the multiple level multiplexing spread spectrum receiver of the present invention which has been disclosed above is a GPS receiver. The same invention can be used for other spread spectrum signals such as wireless telephone signals with due consideration for the selections of multiplexing factors based on the bit rate of the spread spectrum code used and the environmental factors applicable to that application. The environmental factors for the present configuration, such as the pragmatic constraints on the number of channels and code phases, have been described above.




Referring now to

FIG. 12

, a block diagram overview of a GPS receiver system


200


including a preferred embodiment of the digital signal processing chip


102


described above, ASIC GSP


1




202


, and a radio frequency chip, GRF


1




204


, combined with other components to form a complete receiver system according to the present invention.




Associated with ASIC GSP


1




202


are SRAM


206


, ROM


208


and CPU


101


, interconnected by data and address busses


210


and


212


to provide the functions of RAM R


1




103


, RAM R


2




105


and Sat_Mem 186 and other required functions described above with regard, for example, to FIG.


5


.




GRF


1




204


is including within RF processing subsystem


214


which received satellite signals from GPS antenna


28


and provides sample or GPS data


100


to ASIC GSP


1




202


which returns an automatic RF gain control signal, AGC


216


, back to GRF


1




204


. Associated with GRF


1




204


in RF processing subsystem


214


are RF filter


218


which applies the signals from GPS antenna


28


to low noise amplifier LNA


220


to output of which is applied to GRF


1




204


. In addition, GRF


1




204


uses an outboard filter, IF FILTER


222


as well as crystal


224


. It is important to note that IF FILTER


222


may be a low cost, external 2-pole LC (inductance-capacitance) type intermediate or IF filter, rather than a more expensive and complex 5 or 6 pole filter for the following reasons. GPS receiver system


200


uses a relatively wide IF band followed by a decimator or digital filter, Digital Filter


118


, as shown for example in CACAPT


104


in FIG.


5


.




In particular, the output of LNA


220


is processed by GRF


1




204


using IF FILTER


222


to produce GPS data


100


which is applied to CACAPT


104


in ASIC GSP


1




202


. Within ASIC GSP


1




202


, GPS data


100


is separated into in phase and quadrature phase I and Q signals in I/Q splitter


106


. The I signals are then applied to Digital Filter


118


and the Q signals are processed in the same manner as shown in FIG.


5


and described above.




Referring now to

FIG. 13

, a series of graphs of relative correlation amplitude as a function of time offset are shown for direct path and two examples of multipath interference. These graphs are aligned at a time offset of zero, that is, at the time of arrival of the direct path signal.




Direct path correlation function


226


, in the center of the figure, is the idealized result of correlating a satellite signal received along a direct, line of sight path in the absence of multipath signal(s), with a replica of the C/A code modulation then present on the direct path signal. The peak


230


of direct path correlation function


226


is shown at the origin to represent the actual time of arrival or zero code phase. In practice, this point may be somewhat offset due to filtering and other biases. Peak


230


will be taken for the purpose of this explanation as the punctual code phase, that is, the time of arrival of the PN Code group from a particular satellite.




Direct path correlation function


226


may be produced for example by operation of Correlator Block


110


correlating the Doppler shifted satellite signals from Doppler Block


108


by the output of Coder Block


112


as shown in

FIG. 9

while changing the estimated code phase. In particular, direct path correlation function


226


shows the shape of the correlation function that would result from adjusting the code phase, in the absence of multipath interference, over a range from about one C/A code chip width early, by a delay or time offset of −1 chip, to about one chip width late, that is, a delay or time offset of about +1 chip.




The triangular shape of direct path correlation function


226


is conventionally understood to result from the following circumstances. There will be almost no correlation between the signal received and the internally generated code when the code phase offset is greater than about 1 to 1.5 chips in either direction. As the time offset is reduced from about 1 chip to about zero, in either direction, the correlation increases to a maximum at zero offset. That is, when the code phase of the internally generated code is exactly equal (less biases, offsets and the effects of filtering) to the code phase of the signal as received, the correlation peaks.




A delay-locked loop is conventionally used for tracking the expected position of peak


230


by using a pair of early and late correlators with a fixed offset or time delay there between to perform early and late correlations in order to surround or straddle peak


230


.




As shown in

FIG. 14

, residual code phase errors resulting from multipath interference can be detected, determined and/or corrected in accordance with the present invention. In particular, satellite signals are received by GPS antenna


28


and processed by various components as described above, as well as by Band Pass Filter


232


, before being correlated with a code replica produced by PN Code Generator


234


. The time offset of the PN code produced by PN Code Generator


234


is controlled by the delay or offset of adjustable delay


236


driven by system clock


238


.




The output of PN Code Generator


234


, as offset, is applied to early correlator


240


for correlation with the satellite signals as processed by Band Pass Filter


232


. The output of PN Code Generator


234


is applied through a pair of ½ chip delays


242


and


244


to late correlator


246


, the other input of each of which is also provided by the output of Band Pass Filter


232


. As a result, the satellite signals are correlated at two points with a fixed 1 chip delay, or separation, there between. The correlation functions are applied to detectors


248


which evaluates a characteristic of the correlation function, such as the power. It should be noted that other values or characteristics of the correlation function, typically a complex number including in-phase and quadrature phase components, can be used in place of power measurements including amplitude measurements.




In accordance with conventional techniques, a delay-locked loop is used for code tracking by adjusting the time offset of adjustable delay


236


so that the amplitude or power of the early and late correlation functions are maintained in a fixed relationship. In a preferred embodiment, the power of the early and late correlation functions are maintained equal by Code Phase Error System


250


which adjusts the code phase time offset to maintain this relationship. Code tracking is then performed in that the actual time of arrival of the code from the satellites is known to be within the one chip separation between the early and late correlations while their powers remain equal.




Referring again also to

FIG. 13

, when the delay-locked loop of

FIG. 14

is shown to be properly tracking the code phase so that the early and late correlation amplitudes are equal, the relative magnitudes of early and late correlations


252


and


254


are half of the magnitude of peak


230


. That is, when the time phase offset is adjusted so that correlation amplitudes of equal value are tracked, these values symmetrically surround, in time, the actual time of arrival of the signals shown in the figure as prompt correlation


256


. In other words, for a direct path signal, prompt correlation


256


is caused to occur midway between early and late correlations


252


and


254


so that prompt correlation


256


occurs at zero time offset, i.e. at the actual time of arrival of the code. As shown in

FIG. 13

, the amplitude of prompt correlation


256


is a relative amplitude assigned an arbitrary value of 1.0. The amplitudes of early and late correlations


252


and


254


have equal values of 0.5.




As shown in

FIG. 14

, to cause the prompt correlation to occur midway between the early and late correlations, the 1 chip delay between early and late correlation is provided by a pair of ½ chip delays


242


and


244


. The output of ½ chip delay


242


is applied to prompt correlator


240


to produce prompt correlation


256


, one half chip offset from early correlator


240


, for evaluation by detector


248


. The input of ½ chip delay


244


is provided by ½ chip delay


242


so the output of ½ chip delay


244


, applied to late correlator


246


, is separated from the input to early correlator


240


, by one full chip offset. The outputs of detectors


248


are then applied to complete the delay-locked loop.




Multipath distortion, if present, causes the prompt correlation to be offset from the actual time of arrival of the satellite signals by an error, described herein as the code phase residual error. The sign of the error between the prompt correlation and the actual time of arrival, either leading or lagging, has been determined to depend upon the relationship between the carrier phases of the direct and multipath signals. When the difference in phase between the carrier phases of the direct and multipath signals approaches 0°, as shown for example as lagging multipath correlation function


258


in the upper portion of the figure, the direct and multipath signals tend to reinforce, increasing the relative amplitude of the correlation products. When the difference in phase between the carrier phases of the direct and multipath signals approaches 180°, as shown for example as leading multipath correlation function


260


in the lower portion of the figure, the direct and multipath signals tend to cancel, decreasing the relative amplitude of the correlation products.




More importantly, the relationship between the location of the actual time of arrival, and the points of equal correlation amplitude, also changes. Without multipath, as discussed above, the points of equal magnitude of early and late correlations separated by a fixed delay are symmetrical about the correlation peak, that is, the actual time of arrival, so that the point midway there between tracked as the punctual correlation is in fact the actual time of arrival of the code.




In accordance with the present invention, however, it has been determined that multipath interference, by reinforcement or cancellation, causes the points of equal amplitude early and late correlations to no longer be symmetrical about the correlation peak. For example, as can easily be seen by inspection of lagging multipath correlation function


258


, the points of equal amplitude early and late correlation


252


and


254


are shifted to the right, that is to a positive or lagging delay, with respect to the points of equal amplitude early and late correlation for direct path correlation function


226


.




When the midway point in time offset between the early and late correlation is tracked, for lagging multipath correlation function


258


, lagging prompt correlation


262


is offset in time from direct path prompt correlation


256


by multipath reinforcement interference lag error


264


. That is, lagging prompt correlation


262


is offset from the actual time of arrival of the direct path signal by a positive or lagging delay time. Similarly, when the midway point in time offset between the early and late correlation is tracked, for leading multipath correlation function


260


, leading prompt correlation


266


is offset in time from direct path prompt correlation


256


by multipath cancellation interference lead error


268


. That is, multipath cancellation interference lead error


268


is offset from the actual time of arrival of the direct path signal by a negative or leading lagging delay time.




In addition, the relationship between the early, prompt and late correlation product amplitudes are changed by multipath interference. As can be seen by inspection of lagging multipath correlation function


258


, when the midway point in time offset between the early and late correlation is tracked, for lagging multipath correlation function


258


, lagging prompt correlation


262


is greater in amplitude than direct path prompt correlation


256


, that is, greater than 1.0. The amplitudes of early and late correlations


252


and


254


for lagging multipath correlation function


258


are also greater than for direct path correlation function


226


, that is, they are greater than 0.5.




In particular, lagging prompt amplitude


270


is greater than 1.0 and equal early and late lagging correlation amplitudes


272


are greater than 0.5. However, as can be seen by inspection and as demonstrated by simulation, equal early and late lagging correlation amplitude


272


is greater than one half of lagging prompt amplitude


270


. Similarly, leading prompt amplitude


270


is less than 1.0 and equal early and late leading correlation amplitudes


276


are less than 0.5. Further, equal early and late leading correlation amplitude


276


is less than one half of leading prompt amplitude


274


.




In accordance with the present invention, these relationships are used to determine the sign and magnitude of the offset errors multipath reinforcement interference lag error


264


and multipath cancellation interference lead error


268


. Code Phase Error System


250


, shown in

FIG. 14

, receives as inputs, the correlation amplitudes (or other characteristics as determined by detectors


248


) of the correlation products from early correlator


240


, prompt correlator


243


and late correlator


246


.




If Code Phase Error System


250


determines that the amplitude of the prompt correlation performed midway between the early and late correlations is less than twice the amplitude of the equal early and late correlations, then multipath reinforcement interference lag error


264


exists. If Code Phase Error System


250


determines that the amplitude of the prompt correlation performed midway between the early and late correlations is more than twice the amplitude of the early and late correlations, then multipath cancellation interference lead error


268


exists.




If, however, Code Phase Error System


250


determines that the amplitude of the prompt correlation performed midway between the early and late correlations is equal to twice the amplitude of the early and late correlations, then no multipath interference error exists.




That is, the existence of a multipath interference error may be detected, and if detected the sign of the error may be determined by comparison of the ratio of the amplitude of the prompt correlation to the equal amplitudes of the early and late correlations offset symmetrically from the prompt correlation.




The relative magnitude of the multipath interference error may be estimated in several different manners. Depending upon the relative amplitude of the multipath signal to the direct path signal, and the differences in carrier phase there between, an appropriate, empirically determined scale factor, such as −0.5, multiplied by either the sum of the early and late correlation amplitudes divided by the amplitude of the punctual correlation, or by the square root of the sum of the squares of the early and late correlation amplitudes divided by the square of the amplitude of the punctual correlation, will provide a suitable correction factor under most circumstances.




In other words, a computation correction to the pseudorange can be made proportional to the amplitude of the (Early+Late)÷Punctual correlations to reduce or eliminate the effect of multipath errors when the multipath delay is less than about 1.5 PRN chips.




As shown in

FIG. 14

, there are three uses for residual multipath code phase error


278


, which includes both the sign and estimated magnitude of the error. This error may simply be used in the rest of the receiver, shown as receiver processor


310


, to computationally refine the pseudorange and therefore the position determination without changing the operation of the delay-locked loop used for tracking the code phase.




Alternately, or in addition thereto, residual multipath code phase error


278


may be applied to adjustable delay


236


which changes the time offset of PN Code Generator


234


to control the offset of early correlator


240


. The two ½ chip delays


242


and


244


maintain the separation from early correlator


240


to late correlator


246


at one full chip width with prompt correlator


243


centered there between. In this manner, prompt correlator


243


may be made to more accurately track the time of arrival of the direct path signal. In addition, separation control signal


280


, produced for example by Code Phase Error System


250


, may be used to narrow or otherwise control the separation of the early and late correlations as well as the symmetry around the prompt correlation to better track the actual time of arrival of the code.




Further, residual multipath code phase error


278


can be used in multipath model


282


to enhance or provide a synthesized model of the interfering multipath signal(s) used, for example, for multipath cancellation. Replica


284


produced by multipath model


282


may be applied as a measurement input to error correcting feedback loop


286


which receives the signals from Band Pass Filter


232


as set point input


287


to produce error signal


288


applied to multipath model


282


. Error signal


288


is used to control replica


284


to reduce any differences between the replica and the signal received until the replica is an accurate representation of the multipath signals. Multipath model


282


may then provide additional code phase correction


290


, added by summer


292


to residual multipath code phase error


278


, for adjustment of PN Code Generator


234


.




As noted above with respect to separation control signal


280


, it may be desirable under certain circumstances to reduce the separation, or time offset, between early correlator


240


and late correlator


246


for improved tracking. This technique of reducing the separation has also been used in attempts to minimize residual error from multipath interference by straddling the peak of the correlation function. It should be noted from inspection of

FIG. 13

that the peak of the correlation function is easiest to select by straddling direct path correlation function


226


because a relatively steep slope occurs on both sides of peak


230


, making the peak easier to distinguish.




As the separation between the early and late correlations is reduced in the presence of multipath, however, at least one of the sides of the peak becomes less steep. For example, the slope of the lagging edge of lagging multipath correlation function


258


is substantially less steep than the leading edge thereof. Similarly, the slope of the leading edge of leading multipath correlation function


260


is also less steep than the slope of its lagging edge. As the slope becomes less steep in the neighborhood of the peak and the prompt correlation, it becomes more difficult to detect or straddle the peak, particularly in the presence of noise. In accordance with one embodiment of the present invention, the sign and magnitude of the error may first be determined in order to reduce multipath effects before reducing the separation for tracking purposes.




It should also be noted from

FIG. 13

that two correlation peaks are produced by the cancellation interference. Although it might be possible to track the wrong peak by accident, it is only necessary to determine if another, earlier and perhaps larger correlation peak exists within a small separation to cause the delay-locked loop to track the correct peak.




In order to provide an accurate assessment of the multipath error, the baseline due to noise must be removed. Referring now to

FIG. 3

, the present invention permits the convenient and accurate assessment of the baseline due to noise as a result of the use of a relatively large number of correlators, such as Exclusive NOR gate correlators


74


. In particular, a correlator


74


at a substantial earlier correlation time or delay than the prompt tap can be used to assess the baseline due to noise. In this way, the noise can be determined without interference by any correlation with the desired signal.




Having now described the invention in accordance with the requirements of the patent statutes, those skilled in this art will understand how to make changes and modifications in the present invention to meet their specific requirements or conditions. Such changes and modifications may be made without departing from the scope and spirit of the invention as set forth in the following claims.



Claims
  • 1. A spread spectrum receiver, comprising:means for correlating a received, code modulated spread spectrum signal with a code modulated signal replica at a first, a second, and a third selected code phase delay; comparison means for comparing characteristics of said correlations to derive information related to any residual code phase error in said second code phase delay; and error means for determining the existence of residual code phase lead or lag error comprising means for determining the existence of multipath interference in said received, code modulated spread spectrum signal causing a residual code phase lag error if the magnitude of the correlation product at the second selected code phase delay is less than twice the magnitude of the correlation product at the first selected code phase delay.
  • 2. A spread spectrum receiver, comprising:means for correlating a received code modulated spread spectrum signal with a code modulated signal replica at a first, a second, and a third selected code phase delay; comparison means for comparing characteristics of said correlations to derive information related to any residual code phase error in said second code phase delay; and error means for determining the existence of residual code phase lead or lag error comprising means for determining the existence of multipath interference in said received, code modulated spread spectrum signal causing a residual code phase lead error if the magnitude of the correlation product at the second selected code phase delay is more than twice the magnitude of the correlation product at the first selected code phase delay.
  • 3. A spread spectrum receiver, comprising:means for correlating a received, code modulated spread spectrum signal with a code modulated signal replica at a first, a second, and a third selected code phase delay; comparison means for comparing characteristics of said correlations to derive information related to any residual code phase error in said second code phase delay comprising means for selecting a prompt phase delay between said first and second code phase delays if the magnitude of the correlation product at the second selected code phase delay is less than twice the magnitude of the correlation product at the first selected code phase delay.
  • 4. A spread spectrum receiver, comprising:means for correlating a received, code modulated spread spectrum signal with a code modulated signal replica at a first, a second, and a third selected code phase delay; comparison means for comparing characteristics of said correlations to derive information related to any residual code phase error in said second code phase delay comprising means for selecting a prompt phase delay at a correlation product peak between said first and second code phase delays if the magnitude of the correlation product at the second selected code phase delay is less than twice the magnitude of the correlation product at the first selected code phase delay.
  • 5. A spread spectrum receiver, comprising:means for correlating a received, code modulated spread spectrum signal with a code modulated signal replica at a first, a second, and a third selected code phase delay; comparison means for comparing characteristics of said correlations to derive information related to any residual code phase error in said second code phase delay comprising means for selecting a prompt phase delay between said second and third code phase delays if the magnitude of the correlation product at the second selected code phase delay is more than twice the magnitude of the correlation product at the first selected code phase delay.
  • 6. A spread spectrum receiver, comprising:means for correlating a received, code modulated spread spectrum signal with a code modulated signal replica at a first, a second, and a third selected code phase delay; comparison means for comparing characteristics of said correlations to derive information related to any residual code phase error in said second code phase delay comprising means for selecting a prompt phase delay at a peak between said second and third code phase delays if the magnitude of the correlation product at the second selected code phase delay is more than twice the magnitude of the correlation product at the first selected code phase delay.
  • 7. A spread spectrum receiver, comprising:means for correlating a received, code modulated spread spectrum signal with a code modulated signal replica at a first, a second, and a third selected code phase delay; comparison means for comparing characteristics of said correlations to derive information related to any residual code phase error in said second code phase delay comprising means for selecting a prompt phase delay at said second code phase delay if the magnitude of the correlation product at the second selected code phase delay is substantially equal to the magnitude of the correlation product at the first selected code phase delay.
  • 8. A spread spectrum receiver, comprising:means for correlating a received, code modulated spread spectrum signal with a code modulated signal replica at a first, a second, and a third selected code phase delay; comparison means for comparing characteristics of said correlations to derive information related to any residual code phase error in said second code phase delay; and means responsive to the comparison means for adjusting the code phase delay of a prompt correlation.
  • 9. A method of processing coded, spread spectrum signals with potential multipath interference, comprising the steps of:generating a local replica of the code; correlating the local replica with coded, spread spectrum signals as received at a first pair of code phase delays separated by a predetermined phase delay difference; determining a second pair of code delays separated by a predetermined phase delay the magnitudes of the correlations at said second pair of code delays having a predetermined relationship, and wherein said first and second pair of code delays include a common code delay said first pair of code phase delays are separated by a code chip width, and said second pair of code phase delays are separated by one half of a code chip width; and determining a prompt code phase delay from differences in magnitude between at least two of said correlations.
  • 10. A method of processing coded, spread spectrum signals with potential multipath interference, comprising the steps of:generating a local replica of the code; correlating the local replica with coded, spread spectrum signals as received at a first pair of code phase delays separated by a predetermined phase delay difference, wherein one of the first pair of code phase delays is selected by determining a second pair of code phase delays, separated by a single code chip width, producing equal correlation magnitudes above a threshold value; and determining a prompt code phase delay from differences in magnitude between at least two of said correlations.
  • 11. The method of claim 10, further comprising the step of:selecting the other of the first pair of code phase delays to be equidistant between said second pair of code phase delays.
  • 12. The method of claim 11, wherein the comparison step further comprises the step of:determining the presence of multipath interference from the ratio of correlation product magnitudes at said first pair of code phase delays.
  • 13. The method of claim 12, wherein the step of determining the presence of multipath interference further comprises the step of:determining the presence of multipath interference if the ratio of correlation product magnitudes at said first pair of code phase delays is substantially different than two.
  • 14. The method of claim 12, further comprising the step of:adjusting one of the first pair of phase delays to be the prompt code phase delay in response to the difference between the ratio of the correlation products and two.
CROSS REFERENCE TO RELATED APPLICATION(S)

This application claims the priority of U.S. patent application filed Apr. 25, 1996, Ser. No. 08/637,457; application filed Apr. 25, 1996, Ser. No. 08/638,021; U.S. Pat. No. 5,901,171 application filed Apr. 25, 1996, Ser. No. 08/637,537; application filed Apr. 25, 1996, Ser. No. 08/638,882; U.S. Pat. No. 5,897,605 application filed Apr. 25, 1997, Ser. No. 08/846,067; application filed Jul. 25, 1997, Ser. No. 08/900,622; application filed Jul. 25, 1997, Ser. No. 08/900,418; U.S. Pat. No. 6,018,704 application filed Jul. 25, 1997, Ser. No. 08/900,894; application filed Aug. 21, 1997, serial number not yet assigned, Attorney Docket No. 6206-119; U.S. Provisional patent application filed Sep. 16, 1996, Ser. No. 60/026,304; and U.S. Provisional patent application filed Mar. 28, 1997, Ser. No. 60/042,868.

US Referenced Citations (125)
Number Name Date Kind
D. 314713 Ciranny et al. Feb 1991
D. 314963 Best et al. Feb 1991
D. 343383 Hall et al. Jan 1994
D. 344942 Gilman et al. Mar 1994
D. 346170 Tang Apr 1994
D. 347436 Tang May 1994
D. 354451 Burrell et al. Jan 1995
D. 354452 Burrell et al. Jan 1995
D. 361569 Jervis Aug 1995
D. 363488 Shumaker Oct 1995
D. 365032 Laverick et al. Dec 1995
D. 365292 Laverick et al. Dec 1995
4754465 Trimble Jun 1988
4758959 Thoone et al. Jul 1988
4807256 Holmes et al. Feb 1989
4847862 Braisted et al. Jul 1989
4890233 Ando et al. Dec 1989
4894662 Counselman Jan 1990
4910526 Donnangelo et al. Mar 1990
4922212 Roberts et al. May 1990
4928106 Ashjaee et al. May 1990
4965586 O'Neill et al. Oct 1990
4970523 Braisted et al. Nov 1990
5043736 Darnell et al. Aug 1991
5075694 Donnangelo et al. Dec 1991
5089822 Abaunza et al. Feb 1992
5101416 Fenton et al. Mar 1992
5108334 Eschenbach et al. Apr 1992
5109344 Kakihara et al. Apr 1992
5111150 Casey May 1992
5119101 Barnard Jun 1992
5134407 Lorenz et al. Jul 1992
5144318 Kishi Sep 1992
5146471 Cowart Sep 1992
5148179 Allison Sep 1992
5157697 Anvari et al. Oct 1992
5165109 Han et al. Nov 1992
5173715 Rodal et al. Dec 1992
5187450 Wagner et al. Feb 1993
5202694 Farmer et al. Apr 1993
5202829 Geier Apr 1993
5210540 Masumoto May 1993
5219067 Lima et al. Jun 1993
5223844 Mansell et al. Jun 1993
5225842 Brown et al. Jul 1993
5239669 Mason et al. Aug 1993
5247469 McCune, Jr. Sep 1993
5265025 Hirata Nov 1993
5266948 Matsumoto Nov 1993
5268064 Woo et al. Dec 1993
5268695 Dentinger et al. Dec 1993
5272485 Mason et al. Dec 1993
5282228 Scott et al. Jan 1994
5293170 Lorenz et al. Mar 1994
5296861 Knight Mar 1994
5306971 McCune Apr 1994
5311149 Wagner et al. May 1994
5311197 Sorden et al. May 1994
5313069 Tham May 1994
5313457 Hostetter et al. May 1994
5319374 Desai et al. Jun 1994
5321799 McCune, Jr. Jun 1994
5323152 Morita Jun 1994
5323322 Mueller Jun 1994
5329549 Kawasaki Jul 1994
5334974 Simms et al. Aug 1994
5337243 Shibata et al. Aug 1994
5345244 Gildea et al. Sep 1994
5347284 Volpi et al. Sep 1994
5347536 Meehan Sep 1994
5347546 Abadi et al. Sep 1994
5349530 Odagawa Sep 1994
5355140 Slavin et al. Oct 1994
5365192 Wagner et al. Nov 1994
5365451 Wang et al. Nov 1994
5365516 Jandrell Nov 1994
5367463 Tsuji Nov 1994
5375059 Kyrtsos et al. Dec 1994
5383127 Shibata Jan 1995
5390124 Kyrtsos Feb 1995
5390207 Fenton et al. Feb 1995
5402347 McBurney et al. Mar 1995
5402450 Lennen Mar 1995
5406491 Lima Apr 1995
5408193 Rodal Apr 1995
5412660 Chen et al. May 1995
5412687 Sutton et al. May 1995
5414729 Fenton May 1995
5416712 Geier et al. May 1995
5418537 Bird May 1995
5420593 Niles May 1995
5422813 Schuchman et al. Jun 1995
5422814 Sprague et al. Jun 1995
5422816 Sprague et al. Jun 1995
5424953 Masumoto et al. Jun 1995
5430654 Kyrtsos et al. Jul 1995
5432841 Rimer Jul 1995
5436632 Sheynblat Jul 1995
5448773 McBurney et al. Sep 1995
5450344 Woo et al. Sep 1995
5450448 Sheynblat Sep 1995
5452211 Kyrtsos et al. Sep 1995
5465413 Enge et al. Nov 1995
5467095 Rodal et al. Nov 1995
5469360 Ihara et al. Nov 1995
5471218 Talbot et al. Nov 1995
5479351 Woo et al. Dec 1995
5485161 Vaughn Jan 1996
5485163 Singer et al. Jan 1996
5486834 Lennen Jan 1996
5490076 Rawicz et al. Feb 1996
5493588 Lennen Feb 1996
5493694 Vlcek et al. Feb 1996
5495257 Loomis Feb 1996
5495499 Fenton et al. Feb 1996
5504491 Chapman Apr 1996
5537121 Lennen Jul 1996
5541845 Klein Jul 1996
5552990 Ihara et al. Sep 1996
5610815 Gudat et al. Mar 1997
5612972 Fukushi et al. Mar 1997
5619212 Counselman, III Apr 1997
5781152 Renard et al. Jul 1998
5828694 Schipper Oct 1998
5903654 Milton et al. May 1999
Foreign Referenced Citations (8)
Number Date Country
0 436 854 A2 Jul 1991 EP
0 501 829 A1 Sep 1992 EP
0 501 828 A1 Sep 1992 EP
0 511 741 A1 Nov 1992 EP
0 635 728 A1 Jan 1995 EP
0 689 034 A1 Dec 1995 EP
2 712 095 May 1995 FR
WO 9508779 Mar 1995 WO
Provisional Applications (2)
Number Date Country
60/026304 Sep 1996 US
60/042868 Mar 1997 US