This application is based upon and claims priority to Turkish Patent Application No. 2017/15416, filed on Oct. 11, 2017, the entire contents of which are incorporated herein by reference.
The invention is related to a superposition coded orthogonal frequency division multiplexing (SC-OFDM) system which sets forth a comprehensive solution and deals with factors such as peak-to-average power ratio (PAPR), error performance enhancement, data rate increase, synchronization or channel estimation and multi input and output (MIMO), using a joint system.
The orthogonal frequency division multiplexing (OFDM) technique provides crucial usage conveniences and benefits. OFDM has been preferred in several wireless communication technologies in the recent years. OFDM is a multi carrier waveform and it allows carriers to be practically brought together. It has been able to relatively meet high data rate and error performance expectations. However some characteristic problems of OFDM do not seem to be able to meet the new generation communication technique expectations.
Power consumption inefficiency due to especially peak-to-average power ratio problems and the disimprovement of data performances are important problems.
Moreover, the number of pilots that are used in order to protect data rates must also be limited.
Data rate losses can be observed in the multi input and output application and improvement of channel estimation of OFDM and additional improvement techniques are required due to its synchronization precision. Due to these reasons OFDM, brings about several problems together with it in real life. Even though OFDM supported with hierarchical modulation (HM) provides data rate increase, it still remains as a problematic technique due to its inefficiency relating to error performance loss and other problems.
In the OFDM technique that is enabled by HM, each subcarrier is formed to be modulated with HM. However due to its qualities and due to a critical problem it has only found use in a limited area. In this technique, only data rate increase is being targeted and an intermediate data rate between some known basic modulations is provided. The most important limiting factor is the interference effect that emerges due to low priority (LP) signals. Superposition coding (SC) function is present in the non orthogonal multiple access (NOMA) technique which can be provided as one of the last similar techniques. NOMA is a candidate technology that can be used in 5G and higher communication standards. This technique in which OFDM can also be used is not a waveform technique, but it is a multi access technique. Signals are formed according to the channel conditions of the receiver nodes and power distribution is adjusted accordingly. Together with this NOMA does not change the wave structure and therefore these are evaluated as different approaches and they can also be used together.
In the U.S. Pat. No. 7,558,191 numbered United States patent document of the known state of the art, methods of transmitting and receiving signals for wireless communication and especially wireless communication in OFDM networks are mentioned. The technique that has been given in the reference document resembles the hierarchical modulation technique. The high priority (HP) and LP symbols that are combined with SC are related to being sent to different users rather than the same user. In the document that has been given as reference it is aimed to reduce the interference effect between HP and LP symbols. Therefore, it does not comprise a waveform design such as a superposition coded orthogonal frequency division multiplexing system but it quite the equivalent of the HM technique.
In the article published in 2009 titled Implementation of OFDM-based Superposition Coding on USRP using GNU Radio, the physical layer application of an OFDM based superposition coding system in a software defined radio is described. This document is deemed to be similar to the NOMA technique. Moreover, as it is a technique that is prior to the NOMA technique, it can be counted as one of the studies that forms basis to NOMA studies. In the publication, multi-access technique has been targeted rather than a waveform and the signal to be received by multiple users is combined with the SC technique, similarly to the NOMA technique. Due to this reason, it is far from being in the same category with the superposition coded orthogonal frequency division multiplexing system.
As the loss of synchronization in communication systems leads to receiving a significant amount of erroneous signals, it also leads to reduction of user satisfaction, and decrease in spectral efficiency due to the need for re-transmission. Similarly, the ineffectivity of channel estimation also leads to these two results. The estimated error performance cannot be obtained in many cases due to some problems that have not been modelled in real time. This also causes expenses to increase and service quality to decrease. Moreover, especially under the light of new applications, the need for high data rates increases, however because of limited resources and channel conditions, the improvements of data rates are also limited.
The problem of PAPR is one of the most limiting factors that prevents communication quality improvement and due to this both power efficiency, error performance and communication quality are seriously degraded. In the MIMO systems that are of the most fundamental systems, PAPR problem and pilot contamination problems are also limiting factors and due to this, such systems cannot be realized.
The system subject to the invention not only provides solutions to these problems but it also has the potential to provide the energy efficiency in systems and cost advantages and management feasibility. Especially due to the significant solution mechanisms it has provided for MIMO systems, it has the potential to provide significant outcomes to development of high speed communication systems.
The aim of this invention is to provide a superposition coded orthogonal frequency division multiplexing system which sets forth a comprehensive solution and which deals with aspects such as PAPR, error improvement, data rate increase, synchronization and channel estimation improvement and MIMO with a joint design approach.
Another aim of this invention, is to provide a superposition coded orthogonal frequency division multiplexing system which improves error performance in data communication systems, increases data rates, improves PAPR values, enables to submit a superpositioned channel estimation sequence or a synchronization sequence, and allows these two processes to be carried out more precisely at the receiver.
Yet another aim of this invention is to provide a superposition coded orthogonal frequency division multiplexing system which enables energy efficiency, cost advantages and management ease.
The superposition coded orthogonal frequency division multiplexing system provided in order to reach the aims of this invention has been illustrated in the figures.
According to these figures;
The parts in the figures are numbered and the references of these numbers are listed below.
The invention is a superposition coded orthogonal frequency division multiplexing system that comprises a transmitter which comprises,
The invention is a superposition coded orthogonal frequency division multiplexing system comprising a receiver, which comprises,
The invention primarily contributes to the error performance improvement in data communication systems. In first glance, occurance of interference due to the presence of LP symbols and the decrease in error performance can be expected. However it is possible to obtain error performance enhancement similar to the MIMO system by transmitting the related symbols as LP at different indexes which resembles the multiplexing principle in MIMO. The important point here is that the reception characteristics of LP symbols are known and decoding is carried out by using these characteristics.
Secondly, data rate increase advantages can be obtained. It can be said that an additional transmission dimension becomes available, due to the LP symbol indices. Additional different symbols can be transmitted to HP by using these indices and the data rate can be increased. The important point here is, as LP symbols are more susceptible to errors, it is more suitable to send these after repetition.
Another advantage is that the PAPR value can be improved by the invention. Partial transmit sequence (PTS) and selective mapping (SLM) techniques are well known PAPR improvement techniques. Principally, the techniques have principles such as the subcarriers in the OFDM technique are divided into groups and are passed through an IDFT process and are multiplied by discrete phase coefficients and thereby an optimum PAPR level is tried to be obtained. These two techniques are flexible structures and they may provide the desired PAPR improvement with increased complexity. However the most important problem of these techniques is that the optimum phase coefficients found should be transmitted to the receiver in each transmission. The most generalized approach is to divide some groups to phase coefficient transmissions or to transmit them with a higher power such that the receiver can understand. The first one leads to the decrease in data rate and the second one leads to extra power consumption and error performance loss. By means of the design developed via the superposition coding quality of the invention, power consumption and error performance are maintained and PAPR enhancement is integrated to the technique automatically. This feature ensures the usage potential of the invention to be high in real life usage.
The fourth advantage is that it enables the transmission of an additional channel estimation sequence or synchronization sequence that has been obtained by superposition coding. By this feature, error performance can be maintained in real life and due to this reason the usage of the invention can be preferred.
And the final important advantage is that the invention may provide possible usage advantages to the MIMO systems. In MIMO systems PAPR problem is more difficult and the symbol processing methods provide quite complex solutions. The PAPR enhancement feature the invention provides, can be easily adapted to a multi antenna and due to this reason, it provides a practical solution to the problem which affects both the power consumption and error performance of MEMO systems. Moreover the pilot transmission or the benefits of increasing data rate of the invention can solve the pilot contamination problem in MIMO systems without data loss. Moreover as the antenna index information in the spatial modulation (SM) technique that has been researched comprehensively in the recent years is enabled to be transmitted repetitively, this provides error performance maintaining benefits in such types of MIMO systems. Due to such features the usage potential of the invention in communication applications is quite high.
The superposition coded orthogonal frequency division multiplexing system comprises a novel communication transmitter and receiver structure. The models of the transmitter and receiver structures are detailed below.
Transmitter Model
The qualifications of the system can be expressed with the mathematical model below. If high power and low power symbol sequences are taken into consideration, the frequency domain symbols added onto each other can be defined as follows,
X
d
[k]=
[k]+
[k],
k=0,1, . . . , K−1,
here and
respectively define the determined power levels of the high power and low power symbols and, K defines the number of the data subcarriers in the frequency region. Moreover
[k] and
[k] express the high power and low power subcarriers, respectively.
[k] is obtained as follows,
[k]=MO
[b],
here b=[b(0),b(1), . . . b(log2()−1)] expresses a bit sequence modulated into symbols; MO
, denotes the modulation process by using
-QAM. The symbol set points for
-QAM are selected from the following set
={
(i): 1≤i≤
}.
A. Synchronization and Channel Estimation Improvement
The low power symbols for this function are generated as follows
here C[k], expresses the kth subcarrier of the related synchronization or channel estimation sequence; KC expresses the set that comprises the related indexes for the C[k] sequence. Moreover, [k], comprises the related phase coefficient that is to be used in the PAPR reduction process and it can be expressed as follows
[k]=βi, kϵKB
here βi, expresses the phase coefficient applied to the ith sub group; and KB=[Kβdi i Kβ
[k] sequence. As shown, in order to guarantee the successful decoding of the phase coefficients in the receiver, each phase coefficient is transmitted several times with different indexes.
B. Error Performance and Data Rate Improvement
i. Error Performance Improvement
As the low power symbols are formed from a certain part of the bit series that has been modulated to high power symbols with -QAM, this bit sequence is expressed as follows
b=p(bA, bB),
here bA=[bA(0), bA(1), . . . bA(log2()−1] expresses the bit sequence used in low power symbol generation and bB=[bB(0), BA(1), . . . bB(log2(
)−1] expresses a bit sequence that is not used in this process. In addition to this bA and bB represent respectively the bit groups included in the A and B index sets of b. Moreover, p(.) expresses the permutation function and forms the b sequence by assigning the bit sequences bA and bB to the related indexes. Similar to
[k],
[k] can be expressed as follows,
[k]=MO
[bA],
here MO, expresses the modulation operation with
-QAM. The symbol set points for
-QAM are selected from the below set
={
(i): 1≤i≤
}.
The high power and low power symbols that express the same bits in order to generate a virtual MEMO effect and in order to benefit from the channel must be sent to different indexes. Therefore =[
[0],
[1], . . . ,
[Kϵ−1]] should be re-expressed as follows
XE=pE),
here the expression pE shall be arranged according to set BS and XE=[XE[0], XE[1], . . . , XE[Kϵ−1]] is obtained. In addition to this Kϵ, expresses the length of the KE set. It should be noted that high power and low power symbols can be selected from different M-QAM symbol sets. For example 16-QAM ve 4-QAM can be used respectively. As a result low power symbols can be obtained as below
here in the ind(k), KE set k. is the function which enables to verify the index number of the index.
ii. Data Rate Improvement
In this function as the high power and the low power symbols, are formed of different bit sequences, there is no need for any kind of index arrangement function. In the low power symbol transmission, the main difference from the high power symbol transmit is that the symbols are assigned to several different indexes. The low power symbols do not have good error performance and this repeated transmit can be desired for good performance.
In this case, the low power symbols can be obtained as follows
here XT[k] expresses the related symbol and it is defined as below
XT[k]={acute over (X)}T(i) kϵKT
here {acute over (X)}T(i) , expresses the i. element of -QAM symbols. Moreover KT
C. PAPR Reduction
In order to obtain improved PAPR performance the PTS algorithm has been added into the superposition coded orthogonal frequency division multiplexing system by taking advantage of the superposition coding in the superposition coded orthogonal frequency division multiplexing system. First of all the data subcarriers are separated into groups and the remaining subcarrier positions are zeroed and vertical sub groups are formed. This is expressed as below
here Xi[k], i. defines the sub group and can be expressed as below
here Ki, i. expresses the index set that has been assigned to a sub group.
Moreover, the total sub group number is U+1 and the quantity U of the group, is given as an input to the PTS algorithm, however the remaining sub group is formed as the group which carries the phase coefficients. According to the principle of the PTS technique, each sub group is converted into the time zone and is multiplied with the related phase coefficient, which lowers the average PAPR level. The time domain symbols are obtained as follows
here xi(n) is expressed as follows following the IDFT process
N denotes the time domain example number. The PAPR level of the symbol is given as below
here E[.] expresses the value operator that is expected. The classic OFDM symbol production procedure, is modified with the phase multiplication process and the symbol following the PTS process is expressed as follows
here the sub group x1(n), is formed of and it carries the phase coefficients as low power symbols. Therefore βi, is the i. component of the phase coefficient vector β and it receives value from the {−1,1} value set. The optimal phase coefficients that minimize the PAPR level of the x(n) symbol are found following the search process and are transmitted. The desired PAPR level is selected with the suitable U value and phase coefficient set selection. Both the data rate and the error performance can be maintained with the suggested effective phase coefficient transmit procedure by means of the superposition coded orthogonal frequency division multiplexing system. Moreover power consumption is maintained and this ensures that the PAPR performance of the superposition coded orthogonal frequency division multiplexing system to be more efficient and effective.
Receiver Model
Following CP addition symbol transmission is carried out. In the receiver, the received symbol is expressed as follows
y(n)=h(n)*x(n)+w(n),
n=0,1, . . . , N+NCP−1,
here * expresses the linear convolution operator; NCP, expresses the number of CP examples; h(n) expresses channel impact response and w(n) expresses AWGN. Following CP subtraction the frequency domain expression is expressed as below following N-pointed FFT
Y[k] can also be defined as below
Y[k]=H[k]X[k]+W[k],
n=0,1, . . . , N−1,
here X[k], H[k] and W[k] are expressed with the frequency domain of x(n), h(n) and w(n) respectively. Following channel estimation and equalization the sub group comprising the phase coefficients is decoded first. The ML detector can be used as below in order to decode the high power symbols
here [k] ve
[k], Kβ expresses the symbol and channel coefficient received from the k. sub carrier in the index set. By means of these metrics the approximate phase coefficients are obtained as below with the ML detector
here [k]=
[k]−
[k]
[k] is expressed as below. Moreover Kβ
here Hd[k] and Wd[k] , expresses the channel coefficient and noise component in the k. subcarrier in the remaining U sub group.
A. Synchronization and Channel Estimation Improvement
If the synchronization sequence is preferred inside the superposition coded orthogonal frequency division multiplexing system following the phase coefficient equalization process, the most precise carrier frequency offset (CFO) value which impairs the symbol with a correlation based algorithm can be found. The sequence added to the high power symbols must have this kind of feature and this shall reduce the sensitivity of the system against CFO. If the preferred sequence is a pilot sequence, an improved estimation performance is obtained as a natural result of the extra pilot number.
The detector procedure can be different according to the transmit preference.
If the channel does not change during the coherency time quickly, symbols and the channel can be estimated as follows by means of the pilot transmit in the initial transmit
here k=0,1, . . . KE−1. During the first pilot transmit, the symbols that have been transmitted to other transmits can be estimated as below with correct channel estimation assumption.
Following this channel estimation is applied as below
This method provides good performance and improved spectral efficiency with exact information of the coherency time by means of suitable channel conditions.
B. Error Performance Improvement
i. Joint Detector
In this case, SIC procedures have not been taken into consideration and a joint ML decoding structure has been applied to high power and low power symbols. Accordingly the symbols that have been successively transmitted are obtained as follows
following this, the related data bits are obtained.
ii. Detector Where the Low Power Symbols are Known
In this detector the transmitted low power symbols are precisely known at the receiver. When these symbols are known the transmitted data symbols are obtained as follows
iii. Detector Where the High Power Symbols are Known
Similarly to the prior detector group of the transmitted symbols are known precisely at the receiver. In such a case high power symbols are known and the low power symbols are obtained as
following this, index arrangement procedure is applied and low power symbols are expressed as[k]=pB
[k]).
iv. The Proposed Detector Structure
As low power symbols are received with high bit errors, it is not efficient to use these symbols directly in the decoding structure. An efficient approach is to use good low power symbols that has been obtained in small numbers, to decode high power symbols. If it can be guaranteed that a limited number of low power symbols are received correctly, the errors observed in high power symbols can be improved. At the first stage such a usage may not seem efficient, however a small number of successfully received low power symbols may provide improved performance. Therefore this decision can be reached correctly by using some metrics such as SNR and EVM. The procedure can be summarized as follows
if not here bA is decoded with symbols that reflect the bit sequence. bB, is obtained as follows for a bit sequence
where l ϵ{A, B} and this expresses the subcarriers that correspond to the related indexes in the A and B sets of [k] and Hd,l[k], Yd[k] and Hd[k] Follow this, these symbols are combines and inverse permutation is applied and
[k] is obtained as follows
=p(
),
and the bits transmitted with the demodulation process is obtained as follows
{tilde over ({tilde over (b)})}=DEMOD(),
here DEMOD, expresses demodulation operation.
C. Data Rate Increase
Similar to the phase coefficient decoding procedure, an ML detector having a decoding structure where different indexes are evaluated together should be applied. Similarly, ML detector is applied as follows for high power symbols
Following this, low power symbols can be obtained as below with the ML detector.
Number | Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
2017/15416 | Oct 2017 | TR | national |
Number | Name | Date | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
6449246 | Barton | Sep 2002 | B1 |
7558191 | Monogioudis | Jul 2009 | B2 |
7894818 | Khan | Feb 2011 | B2 |
20190132171 | Limberg | May 2019 | A1 |
Entry |
---|
Zhenhua Gong et al., Implementation of OFDM-based Superposition Coding on USRP using GNU Radio,University of Notre Dame,Sep. 2009. |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
20190109748 A1 | Apr 2019 | US |