This application claims priority from European patent application number 06100802.5, filed Jan. 25, 2006, which is hereby incorporated herein by reference in its entirety for all purposes.
The invention relates to a surgical implant having a body comprising polyaryletherketone (PAEK).
Further, the invention relates to a method for manufacturing a surgical implant, the implant having a body comprising polyaryletherketone (PAEK).
Various artificial implants that can be implanted in the organ system are known. Herein, the concept ‘implant’ refers to shaped pieces to be implanted in the organ system, such as membranes, fixation plates, other three-dimensional spatial pieces, fixing means, such as screws, pins, rivets, tacks, and the like, that are used to support or attach tissue or to separate tissue from other tissue while healing.
The implants can be made of biodegradable or bio-stable materials. Bio-stable implants are usually made of metal, but some bio-stable implants are made of highly crystalline polymers, such as PEEK (poly-ether-ether-ketone). The mechanical strength of implants made of bio-stable polymers is usually increased not only by a very high crystallinity rate but also by the use of reinforcing fibres, such as glass fibres and carbon fibres. These kinds of implants have a very stiff structure and, thus, they are suitable for operations where the bone tissue to be supported is exposed to high stresses. One of the most successful bio-stable highly crystalline polymers for surgical implants is PEEK-OPTIMA® biomaterial launched by Victrex® in 1998.
PEEK (polyetheretherketone) is probably the best-known member of the PAEK (polyaryletherketone) plastics family. PAEK plastics are semicrystalline thermoplastics that have many good properties, especially outperforming mechanical properties compared with biodegradable polymers. Additionally, PAEK materials have good thermal, chemical and radiation resistance, and good fatigue durability. Other well-known PAEK plastics are, among others, PEK (poly-ether-ketone), PEKK (poly-ether-ketone-ketone), PEEKK (poly-ether-ether-ketone-ketone) and PEKEKK (poly-ether-ketone-ether-ketone-ketone). PEEK is a polyaromatic semicrystalline thermoplastic, the typical crystallinity degree of which is 30 to 35%, the melting temperature about 343° C., the crystallisation peak about 160° C. when cooling down from a molten state, and the glass transition temperature about 145° C.
Significant advantages of PAEK plastics over metals are, for instance, the elimination of imaging artefacts, the ability to inspect tissue growth and repair using x-rays—which can often be obscured with metal parts, and, more generally in this and other applications, the avoidance of allergic tissue reaction to metallic ions. In diagnostics, as well as in postoperative evaluation, it is increasingly important to monitor the healing process by modern imaging technologies, like X-ray, CT (Computed Tomography) imaging, or MRI (Magnetic Resonance Imaging). In an X-ray image, the intensive shadow produced by a metal implant overlaps the very area important to the surgeon, making it difficult, or sometimes even impossible, to adequately gain information for judging the state of the tissue. This is similar in CT imaging where metal implants create artefacts. Some PAEK plastics are transparent to X-rays and there are no artefacts created in CT images. Because plastics are non-magnetic, MRI technologies still can be used with patients that have received a plastic implant.
An advantage is also that surface modification technologies can be more easily applied to organic surfaces like PEEK polymer than to metal surfaces. This is especially important with implants that are in direct contact with tissue or blood. A further advantage is that plastic processing technology and suitable joining technologies give more freedom in designing and shaping of surgical implants.
One of the problems associated with bio-stable implants made of highly crystalline polymers, such as polyaryletherketones, is that they are difficult to shape in situ into the required shape. For example, a support plate supporting fractured bone should be formed in the anatomical contour of the bone in order to give appropriate support for the bone.
An object of the present invention is to provide an implant and a method for making an implant so as to alleviate the above disadvantages.
The surgical implant of the invention is characterized in that said polyaryletherketone is a homopolymer and that a first section of the body comprises the polyaryletherketone having a crystallization peak in its DSC-curve upon heating in a calorimeter.
Further, the method of the invention is characterized by selecting manufacturing material(s) of said implant, said material(s) comprising polyaryletherketone (PAEK), heating the PAEK in a molten state, forming the implant from said manufacturing material(s), and processing the implant so that the body has a first section that comprises polyaryletherketone having a crystallization peak in its DSC-curve upon heating in a calorimeter.
An essential idea of the invention is to manufacture the implant at least partly from PEAK having a low degree of crystallinity.
An advantage of the implant and method of the invention is that amorphous PAEK is suited to the manufacture of a firm implant into which a permanent deformation can be bent in situ.
Further, the idea of an embodiment of the invention is that PAEK has an inhomogeneous form such that a second section of the body comprises the same polyaryletherketone as the first section but has a crystallization peak in its DSC-curve. An advantage is that the implant is stronger than an implant of the same design but comprising only amorphous PAEK, and has a higher elongation at break than an implant comprising only crystalline PAEK.
Further, the idea of an embodiment of the invention is that in the method the cooling rate of the body is controlled in such a manner that the PAEK present in section(s) of the body having smaller cross-sectional areas cools in an amorphous state, and the PAEK present in section(s) of the body having larger cross-sectional areas cools in a crystalline state, or that the implant is formed in a mould that has two or more sections and wherein at least one section is at a lower temperature than another section. An advantage is that the method can be carried out with normal processing steps of injection moulding, extrusion or compression moulding without any additional processing steps.
In the following, the invention will be described in greater detail by means of preferred embodiments and with reference to the accompanying drawings, in which
For the sake of clarity, the figures show the invention in a simplified manner. Like reference numerals identify like elements.
It has surprisingly been found that it is possible to process PAEK into amorphous or nearly amorphous products that exhibit ductile behaviour instead of the rigid behaviour that has been associated with PAEK.
The process for producing amorphous or nearly amorphous products can include the following steps:
1. The temperature of PAEK is raised so high that the material reaches a molten state where it can be formed into the form of a product. This can be done, for instance, in an injection-moulding machine, an extruder, compression-moulding machine, or some other plastic processing machine known per se. Filler materials, if any, can be added to the material in case they are not added to the PAEK prior to its feeding into the processing machine.
2. At least a part of the product is cooled rapidly or quenched, whereupon the PAEK present in the part hardens into the form of a product in an amorphous state. The product may be a finished implant or a semi-finished product that is to be used in manufacturing an implant.
3. Optionally, if PAEK needs to be crystallized in some parts of the product, these parts are heat treated in order to crystallize the amorphous PAEK present in said parts.
The term ‘amorphous’ means that the polymer has a glass transition which is followed by an exothermic crystallization peak which is further followed by endothermic melting peak in its DSC-curve. Differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) is a standard method of characterizing the thermal transitions and the degree of crystallinity of polymers. Various aspects of amorphous PEEK has been discussed, for example, in an article “Enthalpic relaxation in semi-crystalline PEEK,” J. R. Atkinson, J. N. Hay, M. J. Jenkins, Polymer 43 (2002) 731-735.
Amorphous PAEK is usually optically amorphous, i.e. it has a translucent appearance. Therefore, PAEK can be recognized as amorphous on the grounds of its colour and light transmittance. Amorphous PAEK is transparent, whereas crystalline PAEK is opaque. Especially amorphous PEEK-OPTIMA® LT polymers are transparent and dark brown, whereas crystalline PEEK-OPTIMA® LT polymers are opaque and pale brown. When an amorphous PEEK-OPTIMA® LT sheet, the thickness of which is about 0.2 to 2.0 mm, is placed on white paper with black print on it, the print can easily be seen through the sheet. Contrary to this, the print cannot be seen through a crystalline PEEK-OPTIMA® LT sheet of the same thickness.
Other scientific techniques available for measuring the degree of crystallinity of PAEK polymers include density measurements, Fourier Transformed Infra-red Spectroscopy (FTIR), Wide Angle X-ray Scattering (WAXS).
The crystallinity degree of amorphous PEAK is preferably less than 18%, more preferably less than 15%, even more preferably not more than 10%, and most preferably not more than 5%. The lower the crystallinity degree the better the shaping characteristics of the PAEK. The crystallinity degree is naturally adjusted according to the requirements set on the implant.
The term ‘crystalline’ means that the polymer has no exothermic crystallization peak in its DSC-curve. The degree of crystallinity of crystalline PAEK is preferably at least about 20%, more preferably 25% or more.
It is to be noted that with the addition of a filler material by a compounding process, which may be in the form of carbon or glass fibres, or Kevlar fibres, or whisker fibres, for instance, or any other fibres made of polymers, metals and/or ceramics, the strength of natural unfilled PAEK may be increased significantly in order to cater for greater stress-demanding applications. Stiffness tailoring to bone is also possible with the judicious selection of fibres or other fillers at an appropriate concentration. Such bone modulus matching may be important in applications for which stress shielding should be minimized. Amorphous or crystalline sections separately, as well as both of them, can be filled and reinforced.
Regular sized dog-bone shaped tensile test specimens were produced using conventional injection moulding techniques. The length of the specimens were 100 mm, thickness 1.2 mm and width 10.5 mm. Pellets of PEEK-OPTIMA® LT1 and PEEK-OPTIMA® LT3 polymers were obtained from Invibio Ltd, of Thornton Cleveleys, England. Prior to injection moulding, the raw materials were dried at 120° C. for 10 hours to remove residual moisture.
The test specimens were moulded with a generally known Kraus-Maffei KM50C2 electro-hydraulic injection moulding machine. Barrel temperatures were between 355 and 375° C. for both PEEK-OPTIMA® LT1 and PEEK-OPTIMA® LT3 materials.
Mould temperature was 55° C. for PEEK-OPTIMA® LT1 material and 40° C. for the more easily flowing PEEK-OPTIMA® LT3 material. In other words, the mould temperature was substantially lower than the glass transition temperature Tg of the material to be processed. This resulted in rapid cooling and solidification of the material in the mould. Because of the rapid cooling, the material lacked time to generate a sufficient number of crystalline cores to be properly crystallized, and the material solidified into an amorphous state.
Accordingly, cooling of the material was implemented with a very cold mould. Similarly, a very fast cool down of the polymer melt after extrusion nozzle can be used in extrusion. An alternative is to use extremely cold liquids or gases for cooling the mould or the polymer melt, for example liquid carbon dioxide or nitrogen, which can be applied directly to the surface of a component or a semi-finished product or to a tool or a mould. The semi-finished product or the component may also be immersed in these liquids, gases or solid states thereof, such as dry ice, for example.
Some of the amorphous test specimens were crystallized post moulding by heat treatment in order to obtain reference test specimens. Since PAEK crystallizes rapidly, crystalline mouldings can be also obtained if the temperature of the mould cavity is heated to the range of crystallization peak temperature during the injection moulding process. The post moulding crystallization heat treatments of amorphous specimens were carried out in a vacuum furnace according to the following program: first, the temperature was raised to the value 150° C., where it was kept for 16 hours. The temperature was then raised to the value 175° C. for four hours, after which the temperature was raised to the value 200° C., where it was kept for 16 h. Finally, the temperature was allowed to fall freely to room temperature.
The test specimens were subjected to tensile stress tests in accordance with the ISO 527 Plastics tensile stress test standard ‘Determination of tensile properties’, in order to enable the study of the differences between amorphous PEEK and heat-treated crystalline PEEK. The results are presented in Tables 1 and 2 below.
The degrees of crystallinity of the test specimens were determined with a TA Instruments Q1000 DSC device at a heating speed of 20° C./min. A theoretical value of 130 J/g was employed for the melting enthalpy of a 100% crystallized PEEK polymer. The calibration of DSC was carried out with a pure Indium standard sample, whereby the measured melting temperature of Indiumin was 157.35° C. and the melting enthalpy 28.39 J/g.
The degree of crystallinity of amorphous PEEK-OPTIMA® LT1 test specimens was 14.8%, whereas the degree of crystallinity of amorphous PEEK-OPTIMA® LT3 test specimens was 9.7%. The degree of crystallinity of crystallized PEEK-OPTIMA® LT1 test specimens was 34% and the degree of crystallinity of crystallized PEEK-OPTIMA® LT3 test specimens was 33%. Amorphous PEEK was optically amorphous, in other words, it was manifestly translucent. In contrast, crystallized PEEK was opaque.
On the basis of the results, crystalline PEEK is distinctly harder than amorphous PEEK. The elastic deformation range for both phases is equal in size. On the basis of the elongation at break of the tensile strength test, amorphous PEEK is considerably more ductile than PEEK. Amorphous PEEK is better suited than the crystalline one to an application wherein a product has to be given a permanent deformation without, however, weakening the strength grades. Such a product may be for instance a plate-like implant, whose shape has to be bent suitable for the site of attachment in some operations, for the shape of the surface of a bone, for example.
The reduction in the mould temperature to the level of room temperature, to about 20 to 25° C., may result in degrees of crystallinity below 5%.
The fixation plate 1 shown in
The plate 1 is made of material comprising a PEEK homopolymer, i.e. a polymer that is formed from only one type of monomer. PEEK can be readily melt-processed by injection moulding, extrusion and compression moulding, for example.
The plate 1 shown in
The plate 1 has the advantage that during shaping of the plate 1 it deforms only or at least mainly at the forming sections, i.e. between the holes, while the holes 2 do not deform practically at all, as shown in
The processing parameters of the plate 1 can be controlled in such a way that the first sections 3 are amorphous with excellent ductility and excellent shaping characteristics, whereas the second sections 4 in the direct vicinity of the holes 2 are crystalline. The ductile characteristic of the amorphous sections 3 allows the plate used in osteosynthesis to be bent and contoured to the bone shape. The plate 1 is thus easy to shape and yet supports the healing bone sufficiently.
In an embodiment of the invention, the crystallinity degree of PAEK in the first section of the body is at least 15% lower than the crystallinity degree of PAEK in the second section of the body. This way the mechanical properties of the first section differ clearly from those of the second section, so that when the implant is bent, the bending takes place only in the first section whereas the second section does not bend.
In the embodiment shown in
A method for manufacturing the plate 1 is described in the following example 2.
The plate 1 according to
Next, the amorphous semi-finished product, removed from the mould, was adapted into a heat treatment device comprising heating heads to be heated to a high temperature. Each heating head comprised a contact surface shaped in the shape of the part of the semi-finished product to be heated with said heating head. The heating heads were manufactured from an electrically conductive metal, the heating itself being implemented with electric resistances. The heating heads were pushed against the sites of the semi-finished product to be crystallized and hold in this position approximately 10 to 30 sec. In this case, the sites to be crystallized were located in the vicinity of each fixing hole 2. The areas of the semi-finished product to be left amorphous were not in contact with the heating heads; instead, they were in free contact with the surrounding air. The heating heads raised the temperature of the areas to be crystallized in such a manner that the PEEK comprised by them could be organized into a crystalline state. The temperature of the heating heads is typically at least 230° C. and is chiefly determined on the basis of the thickness, shape and manufacturing material of the semi-finished product. This being so, the entirely amorphous semi-finished product formed into a plate 1, which was non-homogenous comprising amorphous parts 3 and crystalline parts 4. At this stage of the manufacture of the plate 1, external cooling can be utilized, by means of which the parts of the plate to be kept amorphous are cooled while the parts to be crystallized are heated. Cooling can be implemented for instance by dousing said parts of the semi-finished product with a suitable fluid or gas or by using cooling elements, generally made from metal, which are pressed against the parts of the semi-finished product to be cooled. The semi-finished product and the heating heads fastened thereto can also be entirely immersed in a cooling liquid. The time required for crystallizing the parts of the semi-finished product depends not only on the temperature employed but also on the thickness, shape and manufacturing material of the semi-finished product.
The plates 1 according to
The elasticity of amorphous PAEK and the strength of crystalline PAEK can also be utilized in anchors employed for fastening of ligaments and tendons to bone, such as ACL anchors (anterior cruciate ligament), PCL anchors (posterior cruciate ligament), or other soft tissue to bone fixation devices, such as tacks for sutureless repair of tears of labrum or rotator cuff of the shoulder, suture anchors for soft tissue to bone attachment, and the like.
An anchor was made in accordance with the principle presented in Example 2. The degree of crystallinity of the amorphous area, measured from the anchor with DSC, was 15%, the degree of the crystalline area being 32%.
The lock 9 of the cable tie is of a crystalline PAEK material, since the lock 9 is the very part that is subject to the strongest stresses. The band 10 is made from an amorphous PAEK material in order to be easily bendable into shape and in order to endure tensile load, which may even exceed the yield limit of the material to some degree. In this case, the band 10 slightly stretches, but does not break.
The cable tie according to
The cable tie according to
The mechanical differences between amorphous and crystalline PAEK can also be utilized in spinal cages. The spinal cage shown in
Other implants can naturally also be made entirely from an amorphous PAEK material, such as the plate 1 shown in
In some other embodiments of mesh plates, the immediate surroundings of some or even all of the fixing holes are of crystalline PAEK, the spaces between the crystalline areas being of amorphous PAEK.
The plate according to
Crystalline PEEK is known to be a biocompatible, bio-stable and hydrolytically durable material. In contrast, no research on the biocompatibility and bio-stability of PEEK can be found in literature. To find out the biocompatibility and hydrolytic durability of amorphous PEEK, amorphous plates having a degree of crystallinity below 15% were injection moulded with an Inion CPS® PLT-1015 plate mould from a PEEK-OPTIMA® LT3 polymer. Some plates were crystallized by heat treatment in the manner described in Example 1, yielding a degree of crystallinity of more than 25%. The plates were sterilized by gamma radiation using a 25 kGy minimum dose. Some plates were implanted in vivo in the subcutis of sheep under the hide and some plates were subjected to an in vitro hydrolysis test, wherein the plates were stored in a laboratory in a physiological phosphate buffer solution in an incubator at the temperature of 37° C. for a maximum of 3 years.
The shape stability of fixation plates is an essential requirement in facial and cranial surgery, for example. The plates have to be bent often into complex forms, and the plates have to maintain their shape accurately under physiological circumstances. The stability of the angle of curvature of PEEK plates was tested as follows: amorphous (degree of crystallinity less than 15%) and crystalline (degree of crystallinity more than 30%) 1.3 mm thick, 7 mm wide and 37 mm long plates for craniomaxillofacial (CMF) surgery (shape similar to Inion CPS® 2.0 mm system PLT-1038 plate) having 6 holes with a hole spacing of 6 mm and a hole diameter of 2 mm were used as components to be tested. The amorphous plates were manufactured from the PEEK® Optima LT1 material by injection moulding. The crystalline plates were manufactured by crystallizing injection-moulded amorphous plates by heat treatment in the manner described in Example 1. The test arrangements were as follows:
Five parallel experiments were performed in the test in one test series. The test series to be tested were: a) amorphous and b) crystalline. The components to be tested were bent into an angle of 90° with plate bending pliers (Inion® Ins-9024) in the middle of the plates between the holes.
The bending into angle was performed by first bending the plate into an angle of ‘over’ 115°, which was checked by measuring it by means of an angular scale drawn on paper, after which the angle was adjusted to the value 90°. This angle is also measured with the angular scale. The bent components were kept at room temperature for an hour, after which the angle was checked on a measuring scale. The components were then applied to in vitro circumstances in an incubator (phosphate buffer solution pH 7.4, temperature 37° C.).
The stability of the angle was followed during six weeks by performing measurements at the following intervals from the placement into in vitro circumstances: 24 hours, 48 hours, 96 hours, 1 week, 3 weeks, 6 weeks. The measurements were made by means of a measuring scale. Table 3 shows a summary of the stability of the angle of curvature of the plates.
On the basis of the results, amorphous PEEK retains the shape moulded therein better than does crystalline PEEK.
It will be obvious to a person skilled in the art that as technology advances, the inventive concept can be implemented in various ways. The invention and its embodiments are not limited to the examples described above but may vary within the scope of the claims.
Number | Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
06100 802.5 | Jan 2006 | EP | regional |