The present invention is directed to a susceptor assembly including a field director arrangement which, when used in a microwave oven having a turntable or mode stirrer is adapted to redirect and to relocate regions within the oven having relatively high electric field intensity so that a food product is able to be more uniformly warmed, cooked, or browned.
Microwave ovens use electromagnetic energy at frequencies that vibrate molecules within a food product to produce heat. The heat so generated warms or cooks the food. However, the food is not raised to a sufficiently high temperature to brown its surface to a crisp texture (and still keep the food edible).
To achieve these visual and tactile aesthetics a susceptor formed of a substrate having a lossy susceptor material thereon may be placed adjacent to the surface of the food. When exposed to microwave energy the material of the susceptor is heated to a temperature sufficient to cause the food's surface to brown and crisp.
The walls of a microwave oven impose boundary conditions that cause the distribution of electromagnetic field energy within the volume of the oven to vary. These variations in intensity and directionality of the electromagnetic field, particularly the electric field constituent of that field, create relatively hot and cold regions in the oven. These hot and cold regions cause the food to warm or to cook unevenly. If a microwave susceptor material is present the browning and crisping effect is similarly uneven.
To counter this uneven heating effect a turntable may be used to rotate a food product along a circular path within the oven. Each portion of the food is exposed to a more uniform level of electromagnetic energy. However, the averaging effect occurs along circumferential paths and not along radial paths. Thus, the use of the turntable still creates bands of uneven heating within the food.
This effect may be more fully understood from the diagrammatic illustrations of
As may be appreciated from
Owing to the number of hot regions encountered and cold regions avoided, points J and L experience considerably more energy exposure than Point K. If the region of the food product in the vicinity of the path of point J is deemed fully cooked, then the region of the food product in the vicinity of the path of point L is likely to be overcooked or excessively browned (if a susceptor is present). On the other hand, the region of the food product in the vicinity of the path of point K is likely to be undercooked.
Since this non-uniform level of cooking owing to the presence of hot and cold regions is undesirable, it is believed advantageous to employ a field director structure, whether alone or in combination with a susceptor, that mitigates the effects of regions of relatively high and low electric field intensity within a microwave oven by redirecting and relocating these regions within the oven, so that food warms, cooks and browns more uniformly.
In its various aspects the present invention is directed to structures for use in mitigating the effects of hot and cold regions produced by a is standing electromagnetic wave within a microwave oven.
In a first aspect the present invention is directed to a susceptor assembly comprising a generally planar susceptor having an electric field director structure mechanically connected thereto. The planar susceptor includes an electrically lossy layer, usually supported on a non-conductive substrate.
The field director structure includes at least one, but more preferably, a plurality of two or more vanes mechanically connected to the susceptor. Each vane has a surface at least a portion of which is electrically conductive. A vane may be formed in any convenient configuration. The electrically conductive portion may take any of a variety of shapes on the surface of the vane or may be disposed over the entire surface of the vane.
The vane(s) may be connected to the planar susceptor so that the surface of the vane is oriented at an angle between about forty-five degrees (45°) and ninety degrees (90°) with respect to the planar susceptor. In the most preferred instance the vane(s) is(are) disposed substantially orthogonal to the planar susceptor. The connection may be either a fixed or a flexible articulating connection. In a fixed connection the vane is secured in a desired angular orientation (preferably substantially orthogonal) with respect to the planar susceptor. If the connection is a flexible articulating connection the surface of the vane is movable from a stored position to a deployed position. In the deployed position the surface of the vane is oriented at a desired angular orientation (preferably substantially orthogonal) with respect to the planar susceptor.
The edge profile of a vane may also take any of a variety of contours. A vane edge may have a straight edge contour, a bent edge contour, or a curved edge contour. The portion of the edge length occupied by the conductive portion of vane is preferably in the range from about 0.25 to about twice the wavelength of the standing electromagnetic wave generated within the oven.
The surface of the vane and the planar susceptor physically intersect along a line of intersection that extends in a generally transverse direction with respect to the planar susceptor. Preferably, the line of intersection extends in a generally radial direction passing through the center of the susceptor assembly. Alternatively, the line of intersection may originate from a point in the vicinity of the center. As yet further alternatives, the line of intersection may be offset or inclined with respect to a generally radial direction of the planar susceptor.
The electrically conductive portion of the vane is disposed no farther than a predetermined close distance from the electrically lossy layer of the planar susceptor such that extension of the conductive surface of the vane will lie along the line of intersection. The predetermined close distance is preferably less than 0.25 of the wavelength of a standing electromagnetic wave generated within the oven.
In use, such as in the presence of a standing electromagnetic wave generated within the oven, only an attenuated electric field component of the electromagnetic wave exists in a plane tangent to the surface of the vane in the vicinity of the conductive portion of the vane. The attenuation of the electric field component of the electromagnetic wave in the plane tangent to the surface of the vane results in the enhancement of the components of the electric field in the planar susceptor.
Rotation of the susceptor assembly within the oven, or variation of the standing electromagnetic wave generated within the oven (as by a mode stirrer) results in a substantially uniform warming, cooking and browning effect on a food product placed on the planar susceptor.
In another aspect the present invention is directed to a field director structure comprising one or more vanes so that, in use, the vane(s) is(are) able to be disposed in a predetermined orientation with respect to a predetermined reference plane within the oven. In the presence of a standing electromagnetic wave only an attenuated electric field component of the electromagnetic wave exists in a plane tangent to the surface of the vane(s) in the vicinity of the conductive portion thereon. The attenuation of the electric field component of the electromagnetic wave in the plane tangent to the surface of the vane results in the enhancement of the component of the electric field substantially orthogonal to the conductive surface. The field director structure in accordance with the present invention may be used with a planar susceptor, if desired.
In one embodiment the field director structure comprises at least a single vane having a surface thereon, at least a portion of the surface of the vane being electrically conductive. The vane has a first and a second end thereon. The vane may be supported by a suitable support member so that the vane(s) is(are) able to be disposed in a predetermined orientation with respect to a predetermined reference plane within the oven. If more than one vane is used, the vanes may or may not be connected to each other, as desired.
In other embodiments the field director is a collapsible structure comprising one or more vane(s) that is(are) able to made self-supporting so that, in use, the vane(s) is(are) able to be disposed in a predetermined orientation with respect to a predetermined reference plane within the oven.
A vane may have one or more fold or bend line(s) defined between the first and second ends of the vane along which the vane may be folded or bent into a self-supporting configuration. Alternatively, the vane be curved or have a region of flexure or curvature defined between the first s and second ends so that the vane may be made self-supporting.
A collapsible field director structure may include an array of two or more planar or two or more curved vanes. At least a portion of the surface of each vane is electrically conductive. Each vane is flexibly connected at a point of connection to at least one other vane. The flexibly connected vanes are positionable with respect to each other whereby, in use, the array is self-supporting with each vane being disposed in a predetermined orientation with respect to a predetermined reference plane within the oven.
Use of a field director structure of the present invention in a microwave oven that includes a turntable or a mode stirrer results in a substantially uniform warming, cooking and browning effect on a food product.
The invention will be more fully understood from the following detailed description, taken in connection with the accompanying drawings, which form a part of this application and in which:
Throughout the following detailed description similar reference characters refers to similar elements in all figures of the drawings.
With reference to
The susceptor assembly 10 comprises a conventional, generally planar susceptor 12 having a field director structure generally indicated at reference numeral 14 connected thereto. As will be developed herein the field director structure 14 is useful for redirecting and relocating the regions of high and low electric field intensity of the standing wave pattern within the volume of the oven. When used in conjunction with a turntable the positions of the redirected and relocated regions change continuously, further improving the uniformity of warming, cooking or browning of a food product placed on a susceptor assembly 10 that includes the field director structure 16.
In the embodiment shown in
The planar susceptor 12 shown in the figures is generally circular in outline although it may exhibit any predetermined desired form consistent with the food product to be warmed, cooked or browned within the oven M. As shown in the circled detail portion of
The substrate 12S may be made from any of a variety of materials conventionally used for this purpose, such as cardboard, paperboard, fiber glass or a polymeric material such as polyethylene terephlate, heat stabilized polyethylene terephlate, polyethylene ester ketone, polyethylene naphthalate, cellophane, polyimides, polyetherimides, polyesterimides, polyarylates, polyamides, polyolefins, polyaramids or polycyclohexylenedimethylene terephthalate. The substrate 12S may be omitted if the electrically lossy layer 12C is self-supporting.
The field director structure 14 includes one or more vanes 16. In the embodiment illustrated in
For purposes of illustration the vanes shown in
The front and back of each vane define a surface area 16S. In
At least a portion of the surface of the front and/or the back of each of the vane(s) 16 is electrically conductive. Any region of drawing
Each vane has an edge 16F extending between a first end 16D and a second end 16E. The edge 16F of a vane may exhibit any of a variety of contours. For example, the edge 16F of a vane may be straight, as illustrated by the vanes 16-1 to 16-3. Alternatively, the edge 16F of a vane may be bent or folded along one or more bend or fold line(s) 16L as suggested by the vane 16-4. Moreover, the contour of the edge 16F of a vane may be curved, as suggested by the vanes 16-5 (
A vane may have its first end 16D and its second end 16E disposed at any predetermined respective points of origin and termination on the planar susceptor 12. The distance along the edge 16F of a vane between its first end 16D and its second end 16E defines the edge length of the vane. The vanes in the field director structure 14 may have any desired edge length, subject to the proviso regarding the length of the conductive portion 16C mentioned below.
The vanes 16 may be integrally constructed from an electrically conductive foil or other material. In such a case the entire surface 16S of the vane is electrically conductive (e.g., as shown in
Alternatively, a vane may be constructed as a layered structure formed from a dielectric substrate with an electrically conductive material laminated or coated over some or all of the front and/or back of its surface area. One form of construction could utilize a paperboard substrate to which an adhesive-backed electrically conductive foil tape is applied.
If provided over less than the full surface area of a vane the electrically conductive portion 16C may itself exhibit any convenient shape, e.g., trapezoidal (as shown for vanes 16-2 and 16-3) or rectangular (as shown for vanes 16-4 and 16-5 and vane 16-1′ in
Whatever the shape of the conductive portion it may be desirable to radius or “round-off” corners to avoid arcing, as will be developed in connection with
Selection of the shape and the length of the electrically conductive portion of the vane and the spacing of the conductor portion from the susceptor plane and other vanes permits the field attenuating effect of the vane to be more precisely tailored.
Wherever its points of origin and termination a vane may also be arranged to pass through the geometric center 10C.
The vanes 16 extend in a generally radial direction with respect to the geometric center 10C of the susceptor assembly 10. The vanes 16 may be angularly spaced about the center 10C at equal or unequal angles of separation. For example, the angle 18 between the vanes 16-1 and 16-2 may be smaller than the angle 20 between the vanes 16-2 and 16-3.
It should be appreciated that the term “generally radial” (or similar terms) does not require that each vane must lie exactly on a radius emanating from the center 10C. For example, vanes may be either offset or inclined with respect to the radius.
Each vane 16 is physically (i.e., mechanically) connected to the planar susceptor 12 at one or more connection points. A connection between a vane 16 and the planar susceptor 12 may be a fixed connection or a flexible articulating connection.
A fixed connection is shown in
A flexible articulating connection is shown in
Whatever the form of construction, configuration of the vane's surface area, shape of the conductive portion, edge contour of the vane, edge length of the vane, length of the conductive portion on the vane, path of the vane with respect to the center of the susceptor, and the orientation of the vane with respect to plane of the susceptor, the electrically conductive portion 16C of the vane 16 must be disposed no farther than a predetermined close distance from the electrically lossy layer 12C of the planar susceptor 12. In general the predetermined close distance should be no greater than a distance approximating 0.25 times the wavelength of the electromagnetic energy generated in the oven. It should be understood that so long as a food product or other article is present the predetermined close distance can be zero, meaning that the conductive portion 16C of the vane abuts electrically against the lossy layer 12C of the planar susceptor.
In a typical implementation, shown in
Alternatively, as seen from
The planar susceptor 12 and a surface area 16S of a vane 16 intersect along a line of intersection 12L extending in a generally transverse direction with respect to the planar susceptor 12. When intersected with the planar susceptor 12, a straight-edged vane 16 will produce a straight line of intersection 12L. A vane 16 having a bent edge or curved edge, when intersected with the planar susceptor 12, will produce a bent or curved line of intersection 12L, respectively. The magnitude of the bend angle or the shape of curvature of the line of intersection, as the case may be, will depend upon the angle of inclination of the vane to the planar susceptor. Whether the line of intersection is a straight line, a bent line or a curved line, the extension of the conductive surface of the vane will lie along the line of intersection.
Having described the various structural details of a susceptor assembly 10 in accordance with the present invention, its effect on a standing electromagnetic wave may now be discussed.
An electromagnetic wave is composed of mutually orthogonal oscillating magnetic and electric fields. At any given instant a standing electromagnetic wave includes an electric field constituent
The electric field
One corollary of Faraday's Law of Electromagnetism is the boundary condition that the tangential electric field at the interface surface between two media must be continuous across that surface. A particular example of such a media interface is that between a perfect conductor and air. By definition, a perfect conductor must have a zero electric field within it. Therefore, in particular, the tangential component of the electric field just inside the conductor surface must be zero. Hence, from the above asserted boundary continuity condition, the tangential electric field in the air just outside the conductor must also be zero. So we have the general rule that the tangential component of the electric field at the surface of a perfect conductor is always zero. If the conductor is good, but not perfect, then the tangential component of the electric field at the surface may be nonzero, but it remains very small. Thus, any electric field existing just outside the surface of a good conductor must be substantially normal to that surface.
The application of this physical law mandates that within that surface area of the vane 16 having the conductive portion 16C only the component vector of the electric field that is oriented perpendicular to that surface, viz., the vector
The component vectors of the electric field lying in any plane tangent to the surface of the vane, (viz., the vector
If the conductive portion 16C of the vane 16 were in electrical contact with the lossy layer 12C the value of the component vector
Thus, the component vectors
The degree of attenuation of the vector component
This effect is utilized by the susceptor assembly 10 of the present invention to redirect and relocate the regions of relatively high electric field intensity within a microwave oven.
Consider the situation at Position 1, near where the vane first encounters the hot region H2. For the reasons explained earlier only an electric field vector having an attenuated intensity is permitted to exist in the segment of the hot region H2 overlaid by the vane 16. However, even though only an attenuated field is permitted to exist the energy content of the electric field cannot merely disappear. Instead, the attenuating action in the region extending from the conductive portion of the vane manifests itself by causing the electric field energy to relocate from its original location A on the planar susceptor 12 to a displaced location A′. This energy relocation is illustrated by the displacement arrow D.
As the rotational sweep carries the vane 16 to Position 2 a similar result obtains. The attenuating action of the vane again permits only an attenuated field to exist in the region extending from the conductive portion of the vane. The energy in the electric field energy originally located at location B on the planar susceptor 12 displaces to location B′, as suggested by the displacement arrow D′.
Similar energy relocations and redirections occur as the vane 16 sweeps through all of the regions H1 through H5 (
The use of the present invention in a microwave oven having a mode stirrer apparatus will result in the same effect.
It is clear from
The support member may be connected to all or some of the vanes.
If desired, the vanes 164-1 and 164-4 may themselves be connected by a length of a non-conductive member 164N. The member 164N is shown in
In a second aspect, the invention is directed to various implementations of a collapsible self-supporting field director structure embodying the teachings of the present invention.
In
In the field director structure 146shown in
In the field director structure 148 shown in
The field director structure 149 shown in
Although the vanes in each of the embodiments illustrated in
It should also be appreciated that a field director structure of the present invention need not be made collapsible, but instead may be made self-supporting through the use of a suitable non-conductive support member.
It should also further be appreciated that any embodiment of a field director structure falling within the scope of the present invention may be used with a separate planar susceptor (earlier described). It should also be appreciated that for some food products it may be desirable to place a second planar susceptor above the food product or to wrap the food product with a flexible susceptor.
The operation of the field director structure and a susceptor assembly in accordance with the present invention may be understood more clearly from the following examples.
Introduction
For all of the following examples commercially available microwavable pizzas (DiGiorno® Microwave Four Cheese Pizza, 280 grams) were used in the cooking experiments.
A planar susceptor comprised of a thin layer of vapor-deposited aluminum sandwiched between a polyester film and paperboard was provided with the pizza in the package. This planar susceptor was used with various implementations of the field director structure of the present invention, as will be discussed. The edge of the paperboard provided was shaped to form an inverted U-shape cooking tray to space the planar susceptor approximately 2.5 cm above a turntable in the microwave oven. A crisping ring (intended for browning the edges of the pizza) provided with the pizza in the package was not used.
In all examples the planar susceptor was placed directly upon a turntable of a microwave oven. In all examples frozen pizzas were placed directly on the planar susceptor and cooked at full power for 5 minutes, except for Example 5, which was cooked in a lower power over for 7.5 minutes.
For comparison purposes one group of three pizzas was cooked using only the planar susceptor without a field director structure, and another group of three pizzas was cooked using the planar susceptor with a field director structure of the present invention.
The vanes of each field director were constructed using aluminum foil of 0.002 inch (0.05 millimeter) thickness, paperboard, and tape.
For Examples 1 through 7 the field director structure was placed in the space under the planar susceptor. For Example 8 the field director structure was positioned above the pizza.
Browning and Browning Profile Measurements
The percent browned and the browning profile of the pizza bottom crust were measured following a procedure described in Papadakis, S. E., et al. “A Versatile and Inexpensive Technique for Measuring Color of Foods,” Food Technology, 54 (12) pp. 48-51 (2000). A lighting system was set up and a digital camera (Nikon, model D1) was used to acquire images of the bottom crust after cooking. A commercially available image and graphics software program was used to convert color parameters to the L-a-b color model, the preferred color model for food research. Following the suggestion from the referenced procedure the percent browned area was defined as percent of pixels with a lightness L value of less than 153 (on a lightness scale of 0 to 255, 255 being the lightest). Following the methodology described in the referenced procedure the browning profile (i.e., the percent browned area as a function of radial position) was calculated.
The image of the bottom crust was divided into multiple concentric annular rings and the mean L value was calculated for each annular ring.
The following examples are believed to illustrate the improvements in browning and browning uniformity that resulted from the use of different field director structures of the present invention.
A DiGiorno® Microwave Four Cheese Pizza was cooked in an 1100-watt General Electric (GE) brand microwave oven, Model Number JES1036WF001, in the manner described in the introduction. When a field director was employed, the field director structure in accordance with
After cooking an image of the bottom crust was acquired with the digital camera, as described. From the image data the percent browned area was calculated using the procedures described. The average percent browned area for the pizzas cooked without a field director was determined to be 40.3%. The average percent browned area for the pizzas cooked with a field director was determined to be 60.5%.
The experiment described in Example 1 was repeated in four microwave ovens of different manufacturers. The oven manufacturer, model number, full power wattage, and cooking time for each example are summarized in Table 1. The table reports the percent browned area achieved with and without a field director. It should be noted that the percent browned area was improved in all cases.
A DiGiorno® Microwave Four Cheese Pizza, 280 gram, was cooked in an 1100-watt Sharp brand oven, Model R-630DW. When a field director structure was employed, the field director structure in accordance with
After cooking an image of the bottom crust was acquired with the digital camera and the percent browned area was calculated, all as described.
The average percent browned area for the pizzas cooked without a field director was 55.2%. The average percent browned area for the pizzas cooked with the field director was determined to be 73.8%. The browning profile, was plotted and is shown in
The experiment described in Example 6 was repeated using a 1300-watt Panasonic brand oven, Model NN5760WA. The average percent browned area for the pizza cooked without a field director was 50.3%. The average percent browned area for the pizzas cooked with a field director structure was determined to be 51.7%. The substantially uniform browning profile that follows from the use of the present invention may be observed from the plot shown in
The experiment described in Example 1 was repeated in a 700-watt Goldstar brand microwave oven, Model MAL783W. When a field director structure was employed, the field director structure in accordance with
After cooking (for 7.5 minutes at full power of the oven used) an image of the bottom crust was acquired with the digital camera and the percent browned area was calculated, all as described.
The percent browned area for the pizza cooked without a field director was 31.5%. The percent browned area for the pizza cooked with a field director was 65.1%.
Those skilled in the art, having the benefit of the teachings of the present invention may impart modifications thereto. Such modifications are to be construed as lying within the scope of the present invention, as defined by the appended claims.
This application claims the benefit of U.S. Provisional Applications; 60/712,066 and 60/712,154 each of which was filed 29 Aug. 2005, and is incorporated as a part hereof for all purposes
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
60712066 | Aug 2005 | US | |
60712154 | Aug 2005 | US |