The application of syngas conversion and purification after a gasification process can be used for integrated gasification combined cycle (IGCC) power plants for electricity production from coal. It can also be used for gasification-based power plants that produce multiple products such as hydrogen and electricity from coal, and it is also useful for plants that include carbon dioxide separation. It is also applicable to purification of other hydrocarbon-derived syngas that can be used for electricity production or power, including syngas derived from natural gas, heavy oil, biomass and other sulfur-containing carbon fuels.
The commercialization of known “coal-to-hydrogen (H2) and electricity” technologies (IGCC power plants or coal gasification-based power plants) has been hampered by the high capital costs associated with removing the most significant impurities, such as sulfur, present in coal. The stringent purity requirements for hydrogen fuel and the fuel specifications for the gas turbine are generally satisfied using a series of clean-up unit operations, which facilitate carbon monoxide (CO) conversion, sulfur removal, and final gas polishing. In addition, carbon dioxide (CO2) removal is desirable in situations where CO2 is captured for sequestration. The cleaned syngas produced can be sent to a combined cycle plant to produce electricity. Because syngas is a feedstock for manufacturing chemical and fuels, it can also be used in a power plant that integrates a combined cycle power plant and chemical reactors for power of electricity and chemical products. The chemical products can include hydrogen, ammonia, methanol, dimethyl ether and Fischer-Tropsch gasoline and diesel fuels. The CO2 rich stream can be compressed and sent to sequestration.
Some known syngas clean-up technologies focus on removing each impurity in a separate unit operation. In a system configured to capture CO2, raw fuel gas exiting the gasifier is cooled and cleaned of particulate before being routed to a series of sulfur removal units and water-gas-shift (WGS) reactors. Those unit operations convert CO and H2O present in the syngas to CO2 and H2, thereby concentrating it in the high-pressure raw fuel gas stream. Once concentrated, CO2 and sulfur present in the stream can be removed using low temperature liquid-based absorption processes. The CO2 is recovered from the absorption process in a manner that results in at least a fraction of the CO2 being recovered at a lower pressure than the feed to the liquid absorber unit. CO2 is then dried and compressed to supercritical conditions for pipeline transport. Part of the clean fuel gas from the liquid-based absorber unit, now rich in H2 and also containing the unreacted CO from the WGS reactor, is either fired directly in a gas turbine, or used in other power systems. Waste heat is recovered from the process and used to raise steam to feed to a steam turbine. Part of the clean stream can be purified further to produce fuel grade H2 product. However, because of the different operating requirements and parameters of each unit, known clean-up technologies may be expensive. Moreover, because of the large number of unit operations used, known clean-up technologies generally require large footprints within a plant. For example, at least some known units have auxiliary requirements for solvent regeneration and pollutant recovery. Known liquid absorption units for CO2 and H2S involve low temperature processes that require the gas stream to be cooled resulting into energy loss and lower efficiency.
Membranes are selectively permeable barriers that can be used to separate gases and can be used in the syngas clean-up process to separate the syngas into a fuel-rich stream that can be used to generate electricity, and a CO2-rich retentate stream to enable “carbon capture”. The use of a membrane for carbon capture can involve the selective permeation of CO2 through the membrane, separating it from the rest of the gas stream, or can involve the selective permeation of hydrogen, the primary fuel gas. In an ideal situation for some power generation systems, gas separation is carried out at high temperature and pressure, so as to minimize the necessity for compressing the CO2 prior to sequestration.
A key challenge associated with hydrogen-selective membranes is the difficulty in recovering all of the fuel components of the shifted syngas stream. WGS reactors do not convert all of the CO in the raw syngas to CO2. Membrane systems are typically suitable for rough stage cuts, and very large membrane areas are required for high recovery rates. Moreover, known hydrogen-selective membranes are not permeable to carbon monoxide and therefore are unable to transfer this gas to the fuel-rich permeate stream. Collectively, the residual H2 and CO in the membrane retentate stream is referred to as the “slip.” Therefore, IGCC plant designs using hydrogen-selective membranes to separate CO2 require additional unit operations to ensure the overall thermal efficiency of the plant is not overly degraded by the H2 and CO slip from the membrane separation system.
In one aspect of the invention, an apparatus using a hydrogen-selective membrane for carbon capture comprises a water-gas shift reactor configured to receive a syngas from a gasification unit; a first unit operation in flow communication with the water-gas shift reactor, the first unit operation including a first, high permeance membrane with H2/CO2 selectivity in flow communication with the water-gas shift reactor, the first membrane providing a first, H2-rich permeate stream and a first, H2-poor, CO2-rich and CO-rich retentate stream; and a second unit operation in flow communication with the first operation unit for receiving the first, H2-poor, CO2-rich and CO-rich retentate stream from the first unit operation, and recovering H2 and CO from the first retentate stream to produce a CO2-rich product stream, wherein an entire content of the CO2-rich product stream produced by the second operation unit has a minimum pressure of at least about 10.0 bar.
In another aspect of the invention, an apparatus using a hydrogen-selective membrane for carbon capture comprises a water-gas shift reactor configured to receive a syngas from a gasification unit; a first unit operation in flow communication with the water-gas shift reactor, the first unit operation including a first, high permeance membrane with H2/CO2 selectivity in flow communication with the water-gas shift reactor, the first membrane providing a first, H2-rich permeate stream and a first, H2-poor, CO2-rich and CO-rich retentate stream; a second unit operation in flow communication with the first operation unit for receiving the first, H2-poor, CO2-rich and CO-rich retentate stream from the first unit operation, the second unit operation including a second, high permeance membrane with Knudsen selectivity for permeating H2, CO and CO2 to produce a second permeate stream and a second retentate stream, the second membrane recovering H2 and CO from the first retentate stream to produce a CO2-rich product stream, wherein the first, H2-rich permeate stream and the second permeate stream are combined to produce a H2 and CO-rich fuel stream capable of being used by a combined cycle power generation unit to produce electricity, and wherein an entire content of the CO2-rich product stream produced by the second operation unit has a minimum pressure of at least about 10.0 bar.
In yet another aspect of the invention, an apparatus using a hydrogen-selective membrane for carbon capture comprises a water-gas shift reactor configured to receive a syngas from a gasification unit; a first unit operation in flow communication with the water-gas shift reactor, the first unit operation including a first, high permeance membrane with H2/CO2 selectivity in flow communication with the water-gas shift reactor, the first membrane providing a first, H2-rich permeate stream and a first, H2-poor, CO2-rich and CO-rich retentate stream; and a second unit operation in flow communication with the first operation unit for receiving the first, H2-poor, CO2-rich and CO-rich retentate stream from the first unit operation, the second unit operation including a catalytic oxidation unit for converting the CO in the first retentate stream into CO2 to produce the CO2-rich product stream, wherein the first, H2-rich permeate stream is capable of being used by a combined cycle power generation unit to produce electricity, and wherein an entire content of the CO2-rich product stream produced by the second operation unit has a minimum pressure of at least about 10.0 bar.
In still yet another aspect of the invention, a method for producing hydrogen gas, comprises:
forming a syngas in a gasification unit;
receiving the syngas from the gasification unit in a water-gas shift reactor;
receiving the syngas from the water-gas shift reactor in a first unit operation that includes a first, high permeance membrane with H2/CO2 selectivity in flow communication with the water-gas shift reactor, the first membrane providing a first, H2-rich permeate stream and a first, H2-poor, CO2-rich and CO-rich retentate stream; and
receiving the first, H2-poor, CO2-rich and CO-rich retentate stream from the first unit operation in a second unit operation, the second unit operation recovering H2 and CO from the first retentate stream to produce a CO2-rich product stream,
whereby an entire content of the CO2-rich product stream produced by the second operation unit has a minimum pressure of at least about 10.0 bar.
In the exemplary embodiment, the clean-up section 20 includes a plurality of individual unit operations including a high-temperature shift (HTS) reactor 22, a low-temperature shift (LTS) reactor 24, a H2S separation unit 26, a solvent regeneration (Claus/Scot processes) unit 28, a CO2 recovery unit 30, and a pressure swing adsorption (PSA) unit 32. The HTS 22 includes a catalyst optimized for high temperature (about 300-400° C.) operation and the LTS 24 includes a catalyst optimized for low temperature (about 200° C.) operation.
During operation, a thermodynamically limited water-gas-shift reaction (CO+H2OCO2+H2) converts carbon monoxide (CO) to CO2, but does not proceed to completion in the presence of CO2, thus leaving approximately 2-3% CO in the syngas 14. The syngas 14 is then cooled to approximately 50° C. such that, the majority of steam present in the syngas 14 is condensed, along with any water-soluble acid gases such as, but not limited to, hydrogen chloride (HCl) and/or ammonia (NH3). The H2S is then typically removed using either a physical or a chemical absorption process in the H2S separation unit 26. Both the H2S removal processes require the use of solvents, such as Selexol, which are regenerated in solvent regeneration unit 28, and elemental sulfur (S) is produced. The gas exiting the H2S separation unit 26 enters the CO2 recovery unit 30, where a CO2 product stream 34 comprising substreams at different pressures, is removed by using a solvent similar to one used in the H2S separation unit 26. The CO2 product substreams 34 exiting the CO2 recovery unit 30 have pressures of about 1.5, 11.0, 17.0, and 20.0 bar, where a compressor train 50 increases the pressure of the CO2 product stream 52 to at least about 74.0 bars. In a representative example using a physical sorbent, the substreams comprise about 34%, 16%, 36% and 13% of the CO2 entering the CO2 recovery unit 30, respectively. Thus, the compressor train 50 is required to increase the pressure of the CO2 product stream 34 exiting the CO2 recovery unit 30 by up to a factor of about forty (40). After CO2 recovery, the syngas 14 enters the PSA 32, which facilitates removing any remaining impurities, providing approximately 99.99% pure H2 36. The PSA 32 also provides residual fuel gas and the H2 38, which are in turn used by a combined cycle power generation unit 40, which includes a gas turbine 42, a heat recovery steam generator 44 and steam turbine 48 to produce electricity 46.
In the exemplary embodiment, IGCC plant 100 is configured to process syngas 14 through an exemplary embodiment of a syngas clean-up section 120. The syngas clean-up section 120 includes a membrane module 122 positioned between the LTS 22 and the H2S separation unit 26 of
During operation, H2 passes through the membrane 124. A high-pressure sweep gas 126, such as N2, and the like, is introduced to membrane module 122 to remove H2 through a stream 128, which is depleted in CO2 and H2S. The CO2 that is produced by the HTS reactor 22 and the LTS reactor 24 that exits the membrane module 122 is a H2-poor, CO2-rich and CO-rich retentate stream 130 that can be processed by the H2S separation unit 26. The gas stream 132 exiting the H2S separation unit 26 enters the CO2 recovery unit 30, where a CO2 product stream 34, comprising substreams of CO2 at different pressures, is removed by using a solvent similar to one used in the H2S separation unit 26. Similar to the embodiment of
The two-stage water-gas-shift designs of
In the exemplary embodiment, IGCC plant 200 is configured to process syngas 14 through an exemplary embodiment of a syngas clean-up section 220. The syngas clean-up section 220 includes and a first operation unit 122 and a second operation unit 222 arranged in series with the first operation unit 122. However, the first operation unit 122 and the second operation unit 222 can be in a parallel arrangement to facilitate maintenance and fuel flexibility.
In this embodiment, the first operation unit 122 includes a high H2/CO2 selectivity, high permeance membrane 124 used to achieve a stage cut corresponding to H2 recovery between approximately 50% and 99%. The H2 recovery can be selectively adjusted in the membrane 124 to achieve a CO2 capture rate between about 25% and about 90%. The membrane 124 comprises a porous support coated with a H2 selective layer. Desirably, the membrane material is stable at the operating conditions of the apparatus.
For example, the membrane 124 can be made of a ceramic material. Examples of suitable porous support materials include, but are not limited to, aluminum carbide, aluminum nitride, aluminum oxide, beryllium oxide, boron carbide, boron nitride, cubic boron nitride, hafnium carbide, silicon boride, silicon carbide, silicon nitride, titanium boride, titanium carbide, titanium nitride, and zirconium carbide. The porous support provides mechanical support to the microporous ceramic layer and facilitates mass transport from a first surface of the membrane structure to a second surface of the membrane structure. Typically, the porous support has a porosity volume fraction greater than about 5%. In one embodiment, the porous support has a porosity volume fraction in a range from about 20% to about 70%. In one embodiment, the porous support has a median pore size in the range from about 0.1 micrometers to about 10.0 micrometers.
The microporous ceramic includes a plurality of pores disposed within a matrix material. Examples of matrix materials include aluminum oxide, boron nitride, boron carbo-oxynitrides, silicon oxide, titanium oxide, zirconium oxide, and synthetic zeolites. The membrane 124 may comprise various combinations of these ceramic materials, as well as versions of these ceramic materials doped with metal elements. In an exemplary embodiment, the high H2/CO2 selectivity, high permeance membrane 124 comprises an aluminum oxide support coated with a microporous oxide. The dimension of the pores and the density of the pores control the permeance of gas species though the porous membrane structure. H2 has a much greater rate of transport through microporous ceramic materials than CO2 or CO.
In another example, the high H2/CO2 selectivity, high permeance membrane 124 comprises a dense metal film coated onto an inorganic support. Examples of suitable metals include, but are not limited to, cobalt, copper, nickel, niobium, palladium, silver, vanadium, zirconium, or alloys of these elements. In an exemplary embodiment, the membrane 124 comprises a copper-palladium alloy. Metal membranes have a high selectivity for H2 over CO2 and CO.
The retentate stream 130 from the first operation unit 122 is cooled and sent to the H2S separation unit 26. The gas stream 132 exiting the H2S separation unit 26 enters a second operation unit 222 comprising a high permeance membrane 224 with Knudsen selectivity. The high permeance membrane 224 of the second operation unit 222 permeates H2 and CO, along with some amount of CO2. The high permeance membrane 224 can be made of a mesoporous material having a pore size between about 2.0 nm and about 30.0 nm. In an embodiment, the high permeance membrane 224 has a lower selectivity for H2 than the membrane 124. Knudsen selectivity refers to the selectivity obtained when gases diffuse through a porous membrane, wherein the dominant mechanism for transport is Knudsen diffusion. The ideal Knudsen selectivity of a membrane for a given pair of gases is equal to the inverse square root of the molecular masses of the two gases. For example, the Knudsen selectivity of H2/CO2 is about 4.7 (i.e., square root of 44/2=22), the Knudsen selectivity of H2/CO is about 3.7 (i.e., square root of 28/2=14) and the Knudsen selectivity of CO/CO2 is 1.25 (i.e., square root of 44/28=1.6). This is in contrast to a high selectivity membrane 124, where the H2 transport is much faster than both the CO and CO2.
The permeate streams 128, 228 from the first and second operation units 122, 222 are combined to produce a H2 and CO-rich fuel stream 236 and sufficiently low CO2 to achieve the desired rate of CO2 capture at sufficient pressure to be combusted in a turbine to produce electricity. To facilitate operability of the module system in a plant, several unit operations can be inserted between the first and second module to remove components, such as H2O and H2S.
The H2-poor retentate stream 226 from the second operation unit 222 can be purified by a third operation unit 230, such as a catalytic oxidation unit, and the like, to produce a single, high-pressure, CO2-rich product stream 232 having a minimum pressure of at least about 10.0 bar, i.e., substantially the entire content of the CO2-rich product stream 232 produced by the second operation unit 222 has a minimum pressure of at least about 10.0 bar. In a preferred embodiment, the entire content of the CO2-rich product stream 232 produced by the second operation unit 222 has a minimum pressure of at least about 15.0 bar. By contrast, the CO2 product stream 34 produced by the embodiments of
The catalytic oxidation unit 230 converts the H2 in the retentate stream 130 into H2O, and the CO in the retentate stream 226 into CO2 to produce a CO2-rich product stream 232, and the heat generated by the reaction generates a high pressure stream 234 of steam that is introduced to the second operation unit 222 to remove H2 through a stream 128. The high-pressure, CO2-rich product stream 232 from the catalytic oxidation unit 230 is fed to the compressor train 50 that increases the pressure of the CO2 product stream 52 to at least about 74.0 bars. Thus, in this embodiment, the compressor train 50 is only required to increase the pressure of the CO2 product stream 232 exiting the catalytic oxidation unit 230 by a factor of about five (5), as compared to up a factor of about forty (40) for one of the substreams required in the embodiments shown in
In the exemplary embodiment, IGCC plant 300 is configured to process syngas 14 through an exemplary embodiment of a syngas clean-up section 320. The syngas clean-up section 220 includes a first operation unit 122 and a second operation unit 222 arranged in series with the first operation unit 122. However, the first operation unit 122 and the second operation unit 222 can be in a parallel arrangement to facilitate maintenance and fuel flexibility.
The embodiment shown in
Similar to the embodiment shown in
The above-described IGCC plants based on high-temperature membrane separation of carbon dioxide from syngas offers many advantages for an integrated coal-to-H2 and electricity power process. The integrated concept allows for a reduced energy cost for CO2 capture, lower capital cost, and a smaller overall footprint for the plant. Furthermore, the integrated approach leverages synergies between water-gas shift reactions and the need for CO2 removal. The use of membranes for H2S removal eliminates the need for energy-intensive solvent regeneration and sulfur recovery units. The economic benefits of the module will facilitate commercialization of IGCC electricity generation plants or IGCC power with CO2 separation plants. The elimination of four unit operations (H2S removal, CO2 removal, solvent regeneration and PSA) and the consolidation of two others (HTS, LTS) into an integrated module will significantly reduce capital costs which will have a significant impact on the economic feasibility of coal-based H2 production technologies.
An exemplary embodiment of an integrated, high temperature syngas clean-up section is described in detail above. The syngas clean-up section is not limited to the specific embodiments described herein, but rather, components of the clean-up section may be utilized independently and separately from other components described herein. Furthermore, the need to remove CO2 is not unique to coal-derived plants, and as such, the integrated syngas clean-up section could be used for alternative fuel or biomass systems to convert low-value syngas to high-purity H2. Therefore, the invention can be implemented and utilized in connection with many other fuel systems and turbine configurations.
While the invention has been described with reference to an exemplary embodiment, it will be understood by those skilled in the art that various changes may be made and equivalents may be substituted for elements thereof without departing from the scope of the invention. In addition, many modifications may be made to adapt a particular situation or material to the teachings of the invention without departing from the essential scope thereof. Therefore, it is intended that the invention not be limited to the particular embodiment disclosed as the best mode contemplated for carrying out this invention, but that the invention will include all embodiments falling within the scope of the appended claims.
This application is related to U.S. application Ser. No. ______ [Docket No. 233,502], and U.S. application Ser. No. ______ [Docket No. 233,522], both filed on the filing date of the present application. The contents of both of these applications is incorporated herein by reference.