The present invention relates to an automated system and method for assessing the functional ability or medical condition (or medical ability) of an actor. More particularly, it relates to a system and method that utilizes multiple sensors and/or interface device(s) to gather functional ability and/or medical condition data relating to the actor, assess the gathered data, and report the assessment and gathered data to persons interested in the actor's welfare such as a caregiver, including alerting those persons to potential emergency situations. Potential domains include in-home monitoring systems, eldercare, and workplace environments (including hazardous work environments) to name but a few.
Elderly people commonly suffer from diminishing physical and/or mental capabilities. Similarly, younger persons suffering from certain maladies (e.g., stroke, disease, etc.) will invariably lose their ability to function independently. In these and other cases, attending physicians (or other caregiver) need to be apprised of changes in the patient's functional ability or medical condition to provide early detection and possible prevention of acute medical conditions.
Currently, gathering of potentially applicable information relating to a patient's functional ability or medical condition is done only as part of a direct, face-to-face interview between the caregiver and the patient. During these periodically-scheduled sessions (e.g., monthly), the caregiver asks the patient a series of questions and generally observes the patient for a short time (e.g., one hour or less). Unfortunately, while a drastic change in the patient (as compared to a previous session) can be identified, it is difficult at best for the caregiver to obtain a true picture of the patient's mental and/or physical capabilities, and in particular to notice slow or incremental deterioration in either facet over time. For example, a typical line of inquiry will relate to the patient's sleeping patterns. For most patients, the response to such a question will inherently be based upon their recollection of the immediately preceding one or two days. Thus, a patient experiencing gradually worsening sleep patterns, but who happened to have a restful night the evening before the caregiver meeting, may report that everything is fine. Further, it is difficult for patients to accurately recall and/or gauge their functional abilities over extended periods of time (e.g., more than a few days). Also, many patients, especially elderly individuals, become nervous or confused when answering questions at an unfamiliar location remote from the patient's home such as a caregiver's office. Again, this problem greatly impedes the caregiver's ability to properly evaluate the patient's actual mental and physical capabilities.
To overcome the above concerns, efforts have been made to develop in-home devices that record information potentially related to a patient's physical and/or mental capabilities. For example, automated pill dispensers are available that record times at which medication is dispensed. In theory, this information can be viewed as being indicative of the patient's mental capabilities in terms of remembering to take prescribed medication. Of course, actuation of the dispenser does not necessarily mean that the dispensed medication was ingested by the patient. Further, and perhaps more importantly, this information presents only one small piece of an overall assessment of the patient. That is to say, numerous other functional/medical condition information is required to accurately assess the patient's abilities, especially as part of a long-term assessment. More technically advanced devices, such as an in-home pacemaker data transmitter, are similarly limited. Thus, while individual devices are available to record information potentially related to a patient's functional abilities and medical condition, direct caregiver interaction/patient interviews are still required, and result in the deficiencies described above.
Alternatively, the patient-caregiver visits can be scheduled on a more frequent basis or a live-in caregiver can be provided. While this may facilitate accumulation of more data points, either approach is quite costly and relies upon the availability of trained personnel. Unfortunately, in most situations the enormous costs and/or lack of qualified caregivers prohibits implementation of either approach.
Periodic, face-to-face patient interviews, while well accepted, are simply inadequate for caregivers to reliably assess the physical and/or mental capabilities of a patient. This is especially true where a long-term assessment of gradually diminishing abilities is of importance or where precursors to certain health emergencies occur (e.g., symptoms of stroke (or fall) often appear several days before the stroke itself) and the ability to identify these symptoms in advance of the event could allow a caregiver to reduce the potential effect of the event. Similar concerns arise in other domains, such as persons working in a hazardous environment where knowing the worker's functional ability could alert others as to potential problems (e.g., exposure to hazardous gases, fatigue, hypoxia, etc.). Even further, actors or workers in less rigorous environments (e.g., assembly line or warehouse) are also susceptible to diminished functional abilities that, if identified in a timely fashion, can be quickly addressed. Unfortunately, other than face-to-face interviews, persons concerned with actors in these environments do not have access to highly relevant, day-to-day information. Therefore, a need exists for a system and method for automated generation, storing and assessment of multiple data sets from multiple sensors relating to certain functions and/or medical conditions of an actor.
One aspect of the present invention relates to a method of assessing functional or medical ability of an actor in an environment. The method includes providing a plurality of data sources in the environment. One or more of the data sources are designated as providing information relating to a functional or medical ability. Data from the designated data sources is retrieved and forms the basis of a functional ability evaluation. In one preferred embodiment, a plurality of baseline function categories are established, with information from one or more of the data sources being assigned to at least one of the baseline function categories. In another, related embodiment, the functional or medical ability evaluation is based upon information from two or more of the baseline function categories.
Another aspect of the present invention relates to a system for assessing functional or medical ability of an actor in a daily living environment. The system includes a plurality of data sources and a controller. The controller is adapted to designate one or more of the data sources as providing information relating to a functional or medical ability and retrieve data from the designated data sources. Further, the controller is adapted to automatically evaluate a functional or medical ability of the actor based upon the retrieved information. In one embodiment, the system further includes an actor interface device adapted to selectively interact with the actor. With this embodiment, the controller is further adapted to retrieve responses of the actor to operation of the actor interface device for use in evaluating functional or medical ability. In another, related embodiment, the actor interface device is adapted to engage the actor in a game.
One preferred embodiment of a functional ability assessment system 20 in accordance with the present invention is shown in block form in
The following description of the present invention is with respect to but one acceptable domain of an actor or patient in an in-home or care (e.g., eldercare) daily living environment. Alternatively, the system and method of the present invention are applicable to other domains, such as a workplace, that may be hazardous (e.g., coal mine, space station) or less rigorous, in which one or more actors or workers operate. Thus, any environment in which an actor spends a significant amount of time (e.g., two or more hours) on a regular basis can be considered a “daily living environment”, or simply “an environment”, of the actor 40 in which the present invention is useful.
The key component associated with the system 20 resides in the modules associated with the controller 22. As such, the sensors 24 and the actor interface device 26 can assume a wide variety of forms. Preferably, the sensors 24 are networked by the controller 22. The sensors 24 can be non-intrusive or intrusive, active or passive, wired or wireless, physiological or physical. In short, the sensors 24 can include any type of sensor that provides information relating to activities of the actor 40 or other information relating to the actor's environment 42, including the environmental component 44. For example, the sensors 24 can include a medication caddy, light level sensors, “smart” refrigerators, water flow sensors, motion detectors, pressure pads, door latch sensors, panic buttons, toilet-flush sensors, microphones, cameras, fall-sensors, door sensors, heart rate monitor sensors, blood pressure monitor sensors, glucose monitor sensors, moisture sensors, telephone sensors, thermal sensors, optical sensors, seismic sensors, etc. In addition, one or more of the sensors 24 can be a sensor or actuator associated with a device or appliance used by the actor 40, such as a stove, oven, television, telephone, security pad, medication dispenser, thermostat, computer interface, etc., with the sensor or actuator providing data indicating that the device or appliance is being operated by the actor 40 (or someone else).
Similarly, the actor interface device 26 can also assume a wide variety of forms. Examples of applicable interface devices 26 include computers, displays, keyboards, web pads, telephones, pagers, speaker systems, etc. In general terms, the actor interface device 26 is configured to interact with the actor 40, requesting specific information and recording responses. For example, the actor interface device 26 can be a “standard” personal computer that presents questions to the actor 40 via a display screen and receives answers via a keyboard entry device. Alternatively, the actor interface device 26 can be akin to a television video game whereby the actor 40 is prompted to participate in a designated game as described below, with the actor's success and response time being recorded. Even further, the interface device 26 can be a home audio system operated to perform a hearing test, a graphical interface adapted to perform a vision test, other medical devices with the capability to output their data and readings electronically (e.g., blood pressure and glucose meters), etc.
The controller 22 is preferably a microprocessor-based device capable of storing and operating preferred modules, including the functional ability assessment module 30. The components of the present invention can be implemented in hardware via a microprocessor, programmable logic, or state machine, in firmware, or in software with a given device. Depending upon the complexity of the particular installation, the controller 22 can include and operate a number of additional modules, the relationship of which relative to the functional ability assessment module 30 is described in great detail below. In general terms, however, and with additional reference to
The manner in which information 56 is provided to the functional ability assessment module 30, as well as assessment techniques performed thereby, is discussed in greater detail below. In general terms, however, the functional ability assessment module 30 is adapted to gather and evaluate data relating to a wide variety of functions. Individual functions can be analyzed individually, or multiple functions can be evaluated together as part of a functional metric or medical condition evaluation. More particularly, the functional ability assessment module 30 preferably organizes gathered data in the database 52 according to baseline functions of interest. Exemplary baseline functions include activities of daily living (ADLs), instrumental activities of daily living (IADLs), medical conditions (vision, hearing, confusion, gait, heart rate, blood pressure, respiration, pain, strength/weakness, blood sugar, etc.), etc. Within each baseline function designation within the database 52, information from one or more sources of data can be stored, depending upon the types of sensor(s) 24 and/or actor interface device(s) 26 provided with the system 20. The actor's overall functional ability or medical condition can then be evaluated based upon an individual baseline function, or upon a combined evaluation of information from two or more baseline functions.
Depending upon the particular baseline function in question, data can be gathered passively by storing signaled information from appropriate ones of the sensor(s) 24 and/or actor interface device(s) 26 within the actor's environment 42. For example, the ADL baseline function of “bathing” can include data obtained from a water sensor in the actor's bathtub and an air quality sensor in the actor's environment 42. Additionally, gathered data can include recorded visual images of the actor 40. For example, information useful in the content of a “mobility” baseline function can include periodic video segments of the actor 40, evidencing the actor's mobility (e.g., walking, transferring, etc.). In this regard, the functional ability assessment module 30 can be adapted to dictate operation of one or more video cameras in the actor's environment 42 so as to provide a desired video segment that is electronically stored in an assigned location of the database 52. In an even more preferred embodiment, the video segment is automatically analyzed/interpreted by an appropriate program, such as video understanding techniques, with the results of this analysis/interpretation being “attached” to the video segment in the database 52. Similarly, other sensor(s) 24 and/or actor interface device(s) 26 may be of a type that generate information relevant to a functional or medical ability evaluation, but only over the course of a relatively short time period (e.g., only 10 seconds of video feed may be necessary to evaluate mobility; an actor's/employee's heart rate while performing a particular job task can be indicative of stress; etc.). The functional ability assessment module 30 can be adapted to retrieve, or prompt signaling of, information from the so-designated data source(s) from or during only the determined time period instead of a continuous long-term string of information. Finally, gathered data can include responses to questions presented to the actor 40 via the interface device 26. For example, a baseline function category of “pain” can include the actor's responses to specific, pre-determined questions relating to pain. Where appropriate, the functional ability assessment module 30 is preferably adapted to present these questions to the actor 40 at appropriate times (and/or a separate module is provided that regulates presentation of questions to the actor 40, in terms of timing, wording, and/or presentation mode). Further, not only can questioning be done to ascertain specific functional abilities (e.g., how are you feeling today?), but also creative questioning can be presented that assist in gauging the actor's functional health.
With the above baseline functions and data gathering techniques in mind, Table 1 below provides a listing of several baseline functions that can be addressed by the functional ability assessment module 30, along with exemplary data sources and related information.
It should be understood that the baseline functions and data sources referenced in Table 1 are in no way limiting. The functional ability assessment module 30 can track information relating to a number of other functions of interest, and utilize data sources not specifically listed. One particular, additional source of information is monitoring the actor's 40 performance while playing an electronically presented game. Certain diagnostic games provide an indication of mental and/or physical capabilities, such as memory, cognitive mental thinking, hand-eye coordination, etc. Other example baseline functions useful with the present invention can relate to job performance where the actor is an employee in a work place environment.
Regardless of the information source, the functional ability assessment module 30 stores accumulated information in the functional ability database 52. In one preferred embodiment, and with further reference to
Alternatively, as shown in
Even further, the functional ability assessment module 30 can be configured to operate without the functional ability database 52. In more generate terms, the functional ability database 52 serves to conveniently accumulate information potentially of interest to one or more functional or medical ability evaluations. However, with certain system 20 configurations, information from each of the data sources 24, 26 is saved over time regardless of whether the functional ability assessment module 30 is present. Under these circumstances, the functional ability assessment module 30, upon determining that a functional or medical ability evaluation is desired, determines which of the data source(s) 24, 26 generate information relating to the evaluation in question (e.g., the functional ability assessment module 30 can be programmed to include designations of which of the data source(s) 24, 26 relate to a particular evaluation; can be programmed to include a general listing of desirable information sources relating to a particular evaluation and then review the system 20 configuration to identify one or more of the data source(s) 24, 26 that might otherwise “match” the “desired” information source list; etc.). The functional ability assessment module 30 then retrieves information from the data base(s) or data source(s) at which the desired information has been stored and/or is being generated. This retrieved information then forms the basis for subsequent functional or medical ability assessment.
Returning to
As part of the above operations, the functional ability assessment module 30 receives actor function ability-related information directly from the monitoring module 102 or indirectly via the situation assessment module 104. In this regard, the functional ability assessment module 30 can be provided as part of the situation assessment module 104. In either case, and with additional reference to
In a more preferred environment, the protocol device 50, either alone or in conjunction with the situation assessment device 104, is adapted to dictate the manner in which data is gathered from the various sources of interest. For example, where a Baseline Function Category 60a of “laundry” that includes a designated data source 62a of “video of actor doing laundry” is provided with the functional ability assessment module 30, the protocol device 50 can be adapted to prompt operation of a video camera within the actor's laundry room for a short period of time whenever motion is sensed in the laundry room. A digital copy of the short-term video feed (and any computer analysis/interpretation of the video segment, where provided) is then stored in the database 52, along with other related data associated with the “laundry” function. Similarly, the protocol device 50, either alone or in combination with the situation assessment module 104, is preferably adapted to initiate presentation of questions related to functions of interest at appropriate times and in appropriate manners via the actor interface device 26. For example, and again with reference to the exemplary “laundry” Baseline Function Category, the protocol device 50 can initiate presentation of laundry related questions to the actor 40 at predetermined times during the week and/or following occurrence of a designated sensed activity (e.g., sensed activation of a washing machine appliance by one of the sensors 24). The question(s) presented to the actor 40 can be retrieved from an auxiliary data source 118 containing queries specific to the activity in question (e.g., the auxiliary data source 118 can contain “questions about laundry”). The questions can be generated as an output from the functional ability assessment module 30, or via the response planning module 106 that otherwise oversees all outputs from the controller 22. Regardless, the machine learning module 108 preferably operates to adapt the questions and/or timing thereof in a manner most appropriate to the actor 40. Once again, information need not necessarily be stored in a separate functional ability database 52. Instead, for example, the functional ability module 30 can, as part of a functional or medical ability assessment, retrieve information from the data source(s) of interest (either directly or from a separate database related to the desired data source using predetermined guidelines such as the Baseline Function Categories described above).
Although the present invention has described implementation of the functional ability assessment module 30 as part of a complete in-home monitoring and response system, a standalone system can instead be provided. For example, as shown in
Returning to
Other possible metrics that can be tracked and reported upon by the functional ability assessment module 30 include a confusion metric that groups and assesses such functions as the actor's performance while playing designated games, monitoring the ease with which the actor is distracted at various points during the day (e.g., length of time to complete a task), and monitoring difficulty of the actor in completing certain different cognitive activities, such as cooking or dressing. Similarly, a dementia metric can be established, whereby information relating to certain functional ability subject matter such as confusion, memory, toileting, and aggression are tracked and stored. A wandering metric can also be provided, with functional ability subject matters such as sundowning (i.e., actor trying to leave the daily living environment when the sun goes down), tracking paths walked by the actor 40, tracking times the actor 40 is walking, etc. are provided. Also, a depression metric can be established that tracks and evaluates functions such as sleep patterns, overall activity, changes in appetite, changes in voice patterns, weight changes, concentration, memory, etc. are established. Further, an alcohol abuse metric can be provided that tracks and evaluates data from sources such as a cabinet sensor, a bottle sensor, breath sensors, wandering, aggression, etc. Furthermore, the assessment module 30 can be adapted to specifically watch for a priori symptoms of certain medical problems. For example, the module 30 can monitor for the possible on-set or recent occurrence of stroke via functional information relating to gait, voice, confusion, etc.
The output 58 from the functional ability assessment module 30 can assume a wide variety of forms, including presentation of requested information via a computer or paper printout. Additionally, the functional ability assessment module 30 can be adapted to signal an alert to a caregiver in the event a significant change in a particular function and/or medical condition is determined.
The system and method of the present invention provides a marked improvement over previous designs. In particular, in-home (or other daily living environment) sensing/actor interface is used to assist in assessing or to assess the functional ability or medical condition of the actor. Because these evaluations occur on-site, they are inherently more accurate then a patient interview that occurs at a remote location. Further, the evaluations are continuous and hence capture minor changes in the actor's capabilities. Thus, a system and method is provided for early detection and possible prevention of acute medical conditions in a manner not heretofore available, with the system essentially serving as an automated diagnosis engine. The system and method of the present invention are also useful in a number of other environment domains; for example, the system and method are capable of assessing employees in a workplace, identifying employees experiencing functional or medical difficulties, and/or employees working at below-expected levels.
Although the present invention has been described with reference to preferred embodiments, workers skilled in the art will recognize that changes can be made in form and detail without departing from the spirit and scope of the present invention.
This application is related to, and is entitled to the benefit of, U.S. Provisional Patent Application Ser. No. 60/424,257, filed Nov. 6, 2002, the teachings of which are incorporated herein by reference.
Number | Name | Date | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
4259548 | Fahey et al. | Mar 1981 | A |
4665385 | Henderson | May 1987 | A |
4803625 | Fu et al. | Feb 1989 | A |
4952928 | Carroll et al. | Aug 1990 | A |
5036462 | Kaufman et al. | Jul 1991 | A |
5045839 | Ellis et al. | Sep 1991 | A |
5086385 | Launey et al. | Feb 1992 | A |
5228449 | Christ et al. | Jul 1993 | A |
5311185 | Hochstein et al. | May 1994 | A |
5400246 | Wilson et al. | Mar 1995 | A |
5410471 | Alyfuku et al. | Apr 1995 | A |
5441047 | David et al. | Aug 1995 | A |
5997476 | Brown | Dec 1999 | A |
6238337 | Kambhatla et al. | May 2001 | B1 |
6280198 | Calhoun et al. | Aug 2001 | B1 |
6280380 | Bardy | Aug 2001 | B1 |
6524239 | Reed et al. | Feb 2003 | B1 |
20020019586 | Teller et al. | Feb 2002 | A1 |
20030083822 | Brunner et al. | May 2003 | A2 |
Number | Date | Country |
---|---|---|
0 558 975 | Feb 1993 | EP |
WO 01075653 | Oct 2001 | WO |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
20040147817 A1 | Jul 2004 | US |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
60424257 | Nov 2002 | US |