The present invention relates to x-rays production. More specifically, the present invention is concerned with a method and system for generating microfocused laser-based x-rays suitable for mammography
Mammographic signs of early cancer include calcifications, small masses (densities), neo-densities and architectural distortions. Screening mammography aims at revealing these signs and is highly sensitive and specific. However, still a notable fraction of mammography produces false positive or false negative results These outcomes most occur in the thick and/or dense breast. False positive results may result in an unnecessary additional imaging and biopsy. False negative results, which occur sometimes even when a cancer is palpable, have a severe adverse effect due to delayed biopsy and delayed cancer diagnosis.
Presence of calcifications usually helps to detect breast pathology. Although calcifications demonstrate well-pronounced contrast in mammograms, their detection threshold size is a function of x-ray tube focal spot size, radiographic technique factors including radiation quality, signal-to-noise ratio and exposure time, as well as function of detector and display devices. Even though, in early stages of breast disease microcalcifications are present in approximately half of the cases, they are not apparent on regular screening mammographs before reaching the detection threshold size, which is typically around 100 μm. This especifically applies to punctuate calcifications
Some of the inherent limitations of the x-ray tube based screen-film mammography include:
Regarding the two last restrictions, film-screen mammography utilizes film as a recording medium to properly record and display relatively narrow dynamic range of x-ray exposures. This should be contrasted with specially designed detectors that can correctly record four orders of magnitude of x-ray exposure. This information can be subsequently displayed on specially designed monitors. Moreover, since film-screen mammography aims at obtaining very high contrast images, the slope of the optical density/x-ray exposure curve is very high. As a result, only a very limited range of x-ray exposure is acceptable If exposure is too high or too low, it will produce exceedingly high or low optical density thus rendering the image not useful clinically.
While the two last restrictions can be alleviated to a great extent by digital mammography, the other limitations stem from the inherent limitations of x-ray tube and are unlikely to be overcome in the framework of this technology.
New technology for generating x-rays had emerged in recent years It relies on emission of x-rays from laser-produced plasma (LPP). This phenomenon occurs when a visible or infrared laser beam is focused onto the surface of solids or liquids If the optical power density exceeds a material dependent threshold value, continuous bremsstrahlung and characteristic x-ray emission lines result. However, initially very expensive and large laser systems were required to obtain the required optical power and the LPP x-ray sources were rather large (100 μm-1 mm). The invention of chirped-pulse amplification (CPA) in the late 1980's allowed achievement of high optical power density delivered to the target by the laser beam from compact and significantly cheaper table-top terawatt ultra-fast lasers.
The feasibility of CPA lasers for mammography and angiography has been demonstrated in both “High Magnification Imaging With a Laser-Based Hard X-ray Source”, IEEE Journal of selected topics in Quantum Electron, Special issue on laser in medicine, 5, 911-915 (1999), by J. Yu, Z. Jiang, J. C. Kieffer, A. Krol. and “Laser-Based microfocused X-ray Source for Mammography faisability Study”, Journal of Medical Physics, 24, 725×732 (1997), by A. Krol, A. Ikhlef, J C Kieffer, D. Bassano, C. C. Chamberlain, Z Jiang, H. Pepin, S. C. Parsad. Data in these publications shows the ability to obtain focal spot size of the order of 10 μm necessary to perform high spatial resolution mammographic imaging and confirm system ability to produce x-ray spectra from a number of different target materials, including Mo, Rh, Ag, In and, Sn with characteristic emission energies spanning 17 3 keV to 28.5 keV.
Even though LLP x-ray source created by CPA lasers can be very small (10 μm or less) and bright, with peak power many order of magnitude higher than conventional x-ray tubes, a drawback of CPA laser sources from the prior art has been their low average power However, in recent years, significant progress has been made in this respect 20 W average power CPA lasers are presently available, and a 50 W CPA laser is in the design stage.
Finally, there have been studies on sub-picosecond laser-solid-matter interaction devoted to investigation of x-rays generation, from the soft x-rays up to the very hard x-ray emission in the MeV range. However, nobody attempted to simultaneously control the emitted x-ray spectrum, the x-ray source size and conversion efficiency from laser to x-rays.
Method and system for generating microfocused laser-based x-rays allowing to simultaneously optimize the x-ray source size, its spectral distribution, and the conversion efficiency in the 17 3-28.5 keV range is thus desirable.
An object of the present invention is therefore to provide an improved system and a method for generating microfocused laser-based x-rays.
Specifically an object of the present invention is to provide such method and system allowing optimizing the x-ray source size, its spectral distribution, and the conversion efficiency in the 17.3-28 5 keV range (adapted to the breast thickness and/or density) for improved mammography.
More specifically, in accordance with an aspect of the present invention, there is provided a system for generating microfocused laser-based x-rays comprising an ultra-fast laser; and a solid target with elemental composition positioned in the focal plane of said ultra-fast laser; wherein said ultra-fast laser and solid target are configured so that interaction with said solid target of a laser beam produced by said ultra-fast laser produces suprathermal electrons that penetrate said solid target in a spot whose size is comparable to the ultra-fast laser focal spot size, yielding hard x-rays More specifically, in accordance with another aspect of the present invention, there is provided
A method for generating microfocused laser-based x-rays using the above system, the method comprising: without The solid target, generating and amplifying from the ultra-fast laser, a first laser beam pulse train so as to control and adjust the laser energy, positioning the target in the focal plane of the ultra-fast laser so as to offer a fresh surface to the ultra-fast laser; generating and amplifying from the ultra-fast laser, a second laser beam pulse train, and releasing and focusing the second laser beam pulse train on the solid target; whereby the interaction of the second laser beam pulse train on the target generates hard x-rays.
A system and method according to the present Invention allows producing a very small x-ray source with an x-ray spectrum tailored to a specific patient's breast density and thickness suitable to detect pathology in examined breast, for example microcalcifications, with increased sensitivity and specificity, as compared to method and system from the prior-art.
Compared to systems and methods from the prior art, a system and method according to the present invention allows to lower calcification detection threshold size down to approximately 30 μm, improves visualization of morphology of microcalcifications and marginal characteristics of masses, improves detection of densities (masses), especially in a dense breast tissue, lowers mean grandular dose, especially in a dense and thick breast tissue, and enhances both sensitivity and specificity of mammography.
A method and system according to the present invention yields very small (below 30 μm) x-ray focal spot size that will results in:
Moreover a method and system according to the present invention allows x-ray spectrum to be tailored to specific breast thickness/density that will result in:
Other objects, advantages and features of the present invention will become more apparent upon reading of the following non-restrictive description of preferred embodiments thereof, given by way of example only with reference to the accompanying drawings.
In the appended drawings:
Turning to
The x-ray generator 12 is based on both a stationary ultra-fast CPA (chirped-pulse amplified) laser 14 and a solid target 16 with elemental composition so positioned as to be in the focal plane of The laser 14.
As it will be explained hereinbelow in more detail, the ultra-fast laser 14 and solid target 16 are chosen and configured so that interaction of a laser beam produced by the ultra-fast laser 14 with the solid target 16 produces suprathermal electrons that penetrates the solid target 16 in a spot whose size is comparable to the ultra-fast laser 14 focal spot size. This allows simultaneously optimizing the source size, the x-ray yield and the photon energy.
The target 16 is mounted in a movable target chamber 18 provided with rapid target/filter changer (not shown), a precision target positioning system 20, a target position monitor and feedback system 21, a target ablation products removal system (not shown), and a vacuum pump 22 for providing vacuum condition in the chamber and more specifically on the target surface. The target chamber 18 allows to precisely positioning a selected area of the target 16 relatively to an x-ray window 24. The x-ray window is located so as to allow hard x-rays produced by the laser-target interaction out of the target chamber in the direction an image receptor 40 as it will be explained hereinbelow in more detail. The movable target chamber allows obtaining all views required in mammography including cranio-caudal view (CC), the medio lateral oblique view (MLO), the latero media (LM), the medio lateral (ML) and supplemental views.
The target/filter allows to properly shape the x-ray spectrum A precision target positioning/feedback allows to keep the x-ray focal spot small.
The precision target positioning system 20 allows mounting and moving, including translation and rotation, the target 16 for reason explained hereinbelow. The target position monitor and feedback system 21 helps precisely position the target relative to the laser focal point and x-ray window 24 As will be explained hereinbelow, the target is to be moved between laser shots so as to expose for each new shot a fresh surface thereof. Since precision positioning systems, and target position monitor and feedback systems are believed to be well known in the art, and for concision purposes, they will not be described herein in more detail.
The x-ray window 24 is preferably made of beryllium. Of course other type of x-ray window may alternatively be used such as Kevlar thin foil.
Of course, the target chamber 18 includes other structures, mechanisms and electronics required for the operation and interactions of the above-mentioned component as it is commonly known in the art. Other features of the movable vacuum target chamber 18 will become more apparent upon reading the following description.
The x-ray generator 12 also comprises an optical beam transfer system 26, coupling the stationary ultra-fast CPA laser 14 and the movable target chamber 18.
The optical beam transfer system 26 includes adjustable mirrors 28 and an optical beam-focusing device 30. The optical beam-focusing device 30 advantageously includes optical feed back system (not shown) for stable laser beam aiming at the target 16, and an adjustable parabolic mirror 32. The vacuum target chamber 18 includes an optical window 34 allowing a laser beam focused by the parabolic mirror 32 to enter the chamber 18 and hit the target 16. The optical window 34 is chosen so as to be transparent to the wavelength of the laser 14 and is advantageously made of MgF. Other suitable transmitting material can also be used. The flat and parabolic mirrors 28, 34 are obviously provided with appropriate mounts (not shown).
Of course, the optical beam transfer system 26 may alternatively have other configurations than the one depicted on FIG. 1. For example, the CPA laser 14 may be positioned so that its beam directly aims at the target 16, with the target positioned at the focal point of the laser 14.
The target chamber 18 further includes a set of filters 36 that are mounted to the x-ray window 24, and an x-ray collimator 37. They allow to properly shape the x-ray spectrum and the x-ray field of view to maximize the image contrast within constrains imposed by the maximum allowable glandular radiation dose and the maximum exposure time.
The x-ray mammography system 10 further includes conventional compression paddles 38 for breast, an image receptor 40 optionally provided with removable mammographic grid 42 allowing for contact magnification imaging, and an automatic exposure and target selection control 44. The automatic exposure control is well known in conventional mammography and is used to avoid over- or under-exposure of the imaged breast. The automatic target selection allows perfect match of the x-ray spectrum and a specific patient's breast thickness/density, resulting in the best contrast at the lowest dose Conventional mammographic x-ray units typically use Mo target Some units have an additional Rh target but the maximum load (mAs) for Rh is significantly constrained, as compared to Mo, and Rh is used infrequently. The image receptor 40 is a mammographic film/screen combination or a mammographic digital detector.
The compression paddles 38 are located between the image receptor 40 and the target chamber 18, and are movable (represented by double-arrow 46 on
The image receptor 40 may take many forms such as a mammographic film/screen combination or a digital detector. Since digital detectors and mammographic film/screen combination are believed to be well known in the art, and for concision purposes, they will not be explained herein in more detail.
Of course, the x-ray mammography system 10 also includes other well-known non-illustrated components such as optical and x-ray shielding for operator and patient protection, and a system diagnostics.
The operation of the x-ray generator 12 will now be described in more detail.
Without target 16, a first sequence of high voltages is triggered for the generation and amplification of a first laser beam pulse train in order to control and adjust the laser energy.
The target 16 is then positioned in the focal plane of the optical beam.
It is to be noted that the motion of the target (rotation and or translation in a fixed plane) is triggered in order to offer a fresh surface at every laser shot.
A second sequence of high voltages is then triggered for the generation and amplification of the interacting laser beam pulse train with appropriate energy and pulse number. The pulse number is selected using an adjustable gate.
The pulse is compressed in an optical compressor composed of a set of gratings and mirrors. The shutter is opened at the compressor exit to release the pulse train on the target 16. The laser pulse 50 (see
Hard x-rays 54 are produced during the interaction laser beam-target interaction.
Turning now to
The angle of incidence of the laser pulse 50 on the target 16, the laser polarization and the target 16 are so chosen as to match the density gradient scale length set by the radiation pressure confinement. Under these conditions, the resonance absorption mechanism that is at the origin of the hot electrons 48, and thus the energy transfer from the laser 14 to the hot electron population 48 is optimized As the resulting plasma is a thin two-dimensional slab (as illustrated in
f(e)=AE1/2 exp(−E/kTH,
where TH is the hot electron temperature and k is Planck constant.
A judicious choice of target geometry and composition, of the laser pulse duration, polarization and/or intensity, allows shaping the x-ray spectrum and to maintain and control the hot electron temperature between 10 and 50 keV. The conversion efficiency is drastically reduced for hot electron temperatures lower than 10 keV It has also been found that hot electron temperatures higher than 50 keV induce a degradation of imaging contrast due to the high-energy tail in the x-ray spectrum The emitted x-ray spectrum is composed of continuum bremsstrahlung and discrete emission lines. The Kα lines radiation is dominant over bremsstrahlung and can be used, with appropriate filtering for imaging.
As it will be explained hereinbelow in more detail, the laser 14 is configured for providing sufficiently high-contrast sub-picosecond pulses with peak and average power optimized for the imaging task, i.e. breast thickness, composition and imaging time.
According to the present invention, the radiation pressure of the pulse produced by the laser 14 is used to balance the thermal plasma pressure occurring on the target 16 during the laser pulse. This allows the thermal and hydrodynamic mechanisms tending to spread the plasma to be overcome and thus the plasma size (perpendicularly to the target surface) to remain very small. The trajectories of hot electrons 48 above the target 16 surface are then limited and controlled, thus minimizing the x-ray source size.
The laser parameters are controlled as follows. A very high contrast laser pulse (10101), indicative of the intensity peak/background noise ratio, is required to help prevent significant plasma expansion before the arrival of the main pulse The pulse duration is set larger than 300 fs and the laser intensity is selected so as to be in the range 1018 W/cm2-1019 W/cm 2. At lower intensity the thermal pressure is dominant and the plasma freely expands during the laser pulse, while at higher intensities the radiation pressure can be so high that plasma profile modification becomes a problem In the optimum intensity range, a still two-dimensional plasma slab 52 having characteristic dimensions of optical laser diameter (typically 3 μm) by thermal penetration depth (typically 0.3 μm) is produced during the laser pulse, resulting in constrained hot electron 48 trajectories above the target surface 55
The control of the x-ray source size imposes utilization of a well-defined narrow intensity range (1018 W/cm2-1019 W/cm2). It has been found that this intensity range is also the most appropriate one for the x-ray photon energy adjustment to optimize imaging for a given breast thickness/density It has also been found that the energy conversion efficiency (ηk) from hot electrons into characteristic line emission reaches maximum when the hot electron temperature (kTn) is about 3 times the photon energy (Ek) of the characteristic line emission (see
The hot electron temperature can be adjusted by a careful laser intensity control indeed, it has been found through experiments that
kTη=α(lλ2)1/3,
where l is the laser intensity and λ is the laser wavelength. Radiation Confined Plasmas yields α=5×10−5 when kTn is in keV, l in W/cm2 and λ in μm as deduced from experiments with a 400 fs laser pulse at 0.53 μm wavelength. This yields the following expression for the optimum intensity (corresponding to kTη/Ek=3)
lopt=bEK3/λ2
This optimum intensity as a function of the target material atomic number Z is shown in
The laser intensity window, for example, for a laser having a 400 fs pulse and 0 53 μm wavelength, is in the 2×1018 W/cm2-1019 W/cm2 range for production of x-ray spectra suitable for optimized imaging of breast thickness between 2 cm and 8 cm with target atomic number Z between 38 and 50. The use of this intensity range simultaneously allows
It has been found that a pulse duration between 200 fs and 600 fs allows to optimize the plasma confinement effect Through radiation pressure and thus to optimize the x-ray source parameters. Through experiments and calculations, it has also been found that shorter (150 fs) and longer (1 ps) pulse resulted in lower conversion efficiency and/or larger x-ray spot size. According to a preferred embodiment of the present invention, a typical value used for the pulse duration is 400 fs (with no pre-pulse and/or pedestal)
A theoretical investigation of the optimum monochromatic x-ray energy for imaging various simulated pathologies in the breast for a large range of breast thickness spanning the 2-cm-8-cm range was performed. The following figure of merit (FOM) was evaluated
FOM=(contrast)2/dose
Simulated pathologies included 200-μm calcifications and 5-mm masses.
It has been confirmed that the shape and the exact location of maximum depend on the imaging object. However in each case the optimum energy shifts towards higher energy for thicker/denser breast for all the investigated pathologies. It has been found that the optimum photon energy increases from ˜15-18 keV for 2 cm Lucite equivalent breast to ˜25-28 keV for 8 cm Lucite equivalent breast.
For larger breast thickness/density (d>4.5 cm) imaged with ultra-fast-based laser x-ray source, we expect significant improvement in the dose utilization without loss of contrast, as compared to imaging with a mammographic x-ray tube operating at increased kilovoltage (28-31 kVp)
The target 16 can be made in many forms including a continuous thin tape with a plastic substrate, rotating cylindrical or planar solid targets. In any case, the target is rapidly moved between each laser shot so that a fresh surface, with possibly different elemental composition (when required), is exposed to every shot. Possible target elemental compositions include Mo, Rh, Ag, In, Sn, with the Kα lines in the 17 4-27.4 keV range. Via selection of a suitable laser target elemental composition and matching filter 36 material, x-ray spectrum from the LPP x-ray source can be tailored to a specific breast thickness and composition, as well as to a detector used.
Preferably, an x-ray generator 12 according to the present invention includes a shaped target 16′ as illustrated in FIG. 6.
In both cases, hot electron 48 trajectories (illustrated in both
As illustrated in
The operation of the overall x-ray mammography system 10 will not be described herein in more detail since it is believed to be well known in the art
Although the present invention has been described hereinabove by way of preferred embodiments thereof, it can be modified, without departing from the spirit and nature of the subject invention as defined in the appended claims.
Number | Name | Date | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
3961197 | Dawson | Jun 1976 | A |
4201921 | McCorkle | May 1980 | A |
4731786 | MacGowan et al. | Mar 1988 | A |
4872189 | Frankel et al. | Oct 1989 | A |
4896341 | Forsyth et al. | Jan 1990 | A |
5020086 | Peugeot | May 1991 | A |
5089711 | Morsell et al. | Feb 1992 | A |
5151928 | Hirose | Sep 1992 | A |
5175757 | Augustoni et al. | Dec 1992 | A |
5323442 | Golovanivsky et al. | Jun 1994 | A |
5335258 | Whitlock | Aug 1994 | A |
5394411 | Milchberg et al. | Feb 1995 | A |
5418833 | Logan | May 1995 | A |
5606588 | Umstadter et al. | Feb 1997 | A |
5712890 | Spivey et al. | Jan 1998 | A |
5812629 | Clauser | Sep 1998 | A |
5832007 | Hara et al. | Nov 1998 | A |
6094471 | Silver et al. | Jul 2000 | A |
6249566 | Hayashi et al. | Jun 2001 | B1 |
6324255 | Kondo et al. | Nov 2001 | B1 |
6594335 | Davidson | Jul 2003 | B2 |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
20040037392 A1 | Feb 2004 | US |