The present invention is directed to systems and methods of power generation. More particularly, the present invention is directed to systems and methods of power generation having neutralizing sorbent injection and second stage heat recovery.
Energy demand is constantly increasing. As the energy demand increases, efficiency for fossil fuel energy sources increases in importance. Generally, the efficiency of fossil fuel powered plants can be impacted by the amount of heat that can be recovered from flue gas.
In some fossil fuel powered plants, flue gas may be cooled by transferring heat to combustion air, thereby improving efficiency of combustion in a boiler. For example Swedish patent SE 448117 B, which is hereby incorporated by reference in its entirety, discloses cooling flue gas below an acid dew point, thereby condensing sulfuric acid. The sulfuric acid can cause heat exchangers and other process elements to foul. To prevent fouling, expensive alloys and corrosion resistant material are used.
EP 0102770 A2, which is hereby incorporated by reference in its entirety, discloses condensing sulfuric acid by cooling flue gas below an acid dew point. To prevent fouling, heat exchangers include special designs and protective coatings, both of which may be expensive.
International patent application WO 2006/087416 A1, which is hereby incorporated by reference in its entirety, discloses heat recovery from flue gas through a fluidized bed boiler combusting sulfurous fuel. The process results in flue gas being cooled below the acid and water dew points. To prevent fouling, heat exchanger tubes are made of plastics and other acid resistant materials, which may be expensive.
Japanese patent application JP 2002162020 A, which is hereby incorporated by reference in its entirety, discloses two stage heat recovery with the second stage heating the flue gas directed to a stack, thereby mitigating visual plume concerns. The additional heat recovered from the flue gas in the second stage is not converted into power and is only used to reheat the flue gas leaving the stack. Thus, the second stage does not improve the efficiency of the power plant.
What is needed is a system and method for improving efficiency in a fossil fuel power plant by increasing the low level heat recovery from the flue gas without relying upon expensive alloys and corrosion resistant materials to prevent fouling of heat exchangers and other process elements.
The instant invention solves problems associated with conventional practices by providing a system and method for controlling and removing SO3 in a sulfur containing flue gas.
In an exemplary embodiment, a power generation system for high sulfur fuel combustion includes a boiler for combusting a sulfur containing fuel to form a sulfur containing flue gas, a heat exchanger arranged and disposed to transfer heat from the sulfur containing flue gas to combustion air, a sorbent injector arranged and disposed to inject sorbent into the sulfur containing flue gas, and a second stage heat recovery mechanism arranged and disposed to transfer heat from the sulfur containing flue gas. The heat exchanger maintains a temperature of the sulfur containing flue gas above a predetermined temperature, the predetermined temperature relating to the acid condensation temperature. The sorbent reduces concentration of sulfur in the sulfur containing flue gas, thereby reducing the acid condensation temperature of the sulfur containing flue gas.
In another exemplary embodiment, a power generation system for high sulfur fuel combustion includes a boiler for combusting a sulfur containing fuel to form a sulfur containing flue gas, a heat exchanger arranged and disposed to transfer heat from the sulfur containing flue gas to combustion air, a sorbent injector arranged and disposed to inject sorbent into the sulfur containing flue gas, and a second stage heat recovery mechanism arranged and disposed to transfer heat from the sulfur containing flue gas to air directed to the heat exchanger. In the embodiment, the heat exchanger maintains a temperature of the flue gas above a predetermined temperature, the predetermined temperature relating to the acid condensation temperature, the predetermined temperature corresponds to a sulfuric acid dew point or is based upon a correlation, the sorbent comprises at least one sorbent selected from the group consisting of limestone, lime, trona, sodium bisulfate, magnesium hydroxide, and combinations thereof, the application of the sorbent results in the sulfur containing flue gas having a SO3 concentration of less than about 50 ppm volume, and the application of the sorbent lowers SO3 concentration in the sulfur containing flue gas by at least 80%.
In another exemplary embodiment, a method of generating power includes combusting a sulfur containing fuel to form a sulfur containing flue gas, in a heat exchanger, transferring heat from the sulfur containing flue gas to combustion air, maintaining a temperature of the sulfur containing flue gas leaving the heat exchanger above a predetermined temperature, the predetermined temperature relating to the acid condensation temperature, injecting sorbent into the sulfur containing flue gas, wherein the sorbent reduces concentration of sulfur in the sulfur containing flue gas, thereby reducing the acid condensation temperature of the sulfur containing flue gas, and transferring heat from the sulfur containing flue gas in a second stage heat recovery mechanism.
Wherever possible, the same reference numbers will be used throughout the drawings to represent the same parts.
Provided is a system and method of power generation having neutralizing sorbent injection and heat recovery. Embodiments of the disclosure may improve efficiency in fossil fuel power plants by recovering the low level heat in flue gas without relying upon expensive alloys and corrosion resistant materials to prevent fouling of heat exchangers and other process elements.
An exemplary power generation system 100 may include a boiler 102, a selective catalytic reduction unit 112, a first air preheater 116, a sorbent injection location 124, a particulate removal mechanism 120, a second stage heat recovery mechanism (for example, a second air preheater 128), a flue gas desulfurization unit 134, a wet electrostatic precipitator 142, and a stack 146.
Referring to
The amount of heat energy transferred to the steam may be controlled by the design of boiler 102 and/or by environmental emission control equipment located downstream of boiler 102. In one embodiment, boiler 102 may use preheated air (from any suitable source) at a temperature of about 300° F. to about 600° F. (about 149° C. to about 316° C.). The heat may be transferred to water to generate the steam used to produce power. In one embodiment, the flue gas generated by boiler 102 may be at about 550° F. to 800° F. (about 288° C. to about 427° C.).
The flue gas leaving boiler 102 may include nitrogen oxides (NOx), sulfur oxides (SOx), H2O, and/or particulate. The amount of the SO3 generated in boiler 102 may depend upon various factors including, but not limited to, the sulfur content of the fuel, combustion process conditions, and other process characteristics. For combusting high sulfur containing fuels, the concentration of SO3 in the flue gas present in flue gas conduit 103 can be as high as 300-400 parts per million (ppm) by volume in the flue gas and the acid dew point can be as high as about 340° F. (about 171° C.). System 100 may include environmental control equipment for reducing or eliminating NOx, SOx, and/or particulate. Pre-combustion, combustion and/or post combustion emission control technologies may form environmental control equipment.
Flue gas is provided to selective catalytic reduction (SCR) unit 112 via flue gas conduit 103 as part of the environmental control equipment. SCR unit 112 is in fluid communication with boiler 102 and is arranged and disposed to apply a reductant (for example, from reductant stream 114) to flue gas. SCR unit 112 may reduce NOx in the flue gas generated during combustion into N2 and H2O. The reduction may be performed by applying the reductant (for example, anhydrous ammonia, aqueous ammonia, urea, cyanuric acid, and/or ammonium sulfate) in the presence of a catalyst (for example, ceramic carriers including active catalytic components, such as, oxides of base metals, zeolites, and/or precious metals) to the flue gas within SCR unit 112. In embodiments using urea as the reductant, additional mechanisms for removing CO2 may be included. In one embodiment, SCR unit 112 may reduce NOx by about 60% to about 95%. In the embodiment, the flue gas leaving SCR unit 112 via a flue gas conduit 113 includes about 5% to about 40% of the NOx in the flue gas leaving boiler 102 via flue gas conduit 103 and the concentration of the SO3 may be increased due to SO2 oxidizing to SO3 in the presence of SCR catalyst. Thus, flue gas leaving SCR unit 112 may include particulate, H2O, an increased concentration of SO3, and a decreased concentration of NOx.
The efficiency of system 100 may relate to the amount of heat that can be recovered from the flue gas to form the steam. Including air preheater 116 in system 100 may provide such heat recovery. Generally, including air preheater 116 may transfer heat to combustion air in boiler 102. By heating the combustion air in boiler 102, more heat energy from the combustion of fuel in boiler 102 can be used to form the steam, thereby improving combustion efficiency.
As also shown in
The flue gas entering air preheater 116 may contain particulate. Particulate may include fly ash and/or other solid or semi-solid combustion products carried by the flue gas. The heat exchanger may be configured to operate in the presence of particulate (or other high-solids conditions). For example, the heat exchanger may be configured to operate despite fouling that may be caused by particulate. In one embodiment, the heat exchanger may be a rotating regenerative heat exchanger (for example, Ljungstrom type heat exchangers or other suitable regenerative heat exchangers). In the rotating regenerative heat exchanger, the flue gas and the air may flow counter-currently, thereby permitting the heat exchanger to have a flue gas side and an air side. The heat exchangers may include a round basket having corrugated sheet metal plates that rotate inside a round housing between the flue gas and the air provided to air preheater 116. The corrugated sheet metal plates may be heated by flue gas. The corrugated sheet metal plates may then rotate and transfer heat to the air in the air side of the heat exchanger.
Flue gas entering air preheater 116 via flue gas conduit 113 may be cooled by the exchange of heat in the air preheater 116 but is maintained above a predetermined temperature. The predetermined temperature corresponds to an acid dew point (for example, a sulfuric acid dew point), thereby reducing or eliminating corrosion and fouling within air preheater 116. The acid dew point is a temperature at which acid condensation begins. The sulfuric acid dew point is the temperature at which sulfuric acid begins to condense. As shown in
As used herein, the term “corresponds,” “corresponding,” and grammatical variations thereof refer to a relationship of the predetermined temperature and preselected operating conditions. The predetermined temperature corresponds to the acid dew point of preselected operating conditions. The flue gas may be maintained above the predetermined temperature independent of whether the preselected operating conditions are present. Thus, the predetermined temperature may correspond to an acid dew point but not be the actual acid dew point.
In one embodiment, the predetermined temperature may be based upon a dew point correlation. The dew point correlation may be any suitable dew point correlation, including, but not limited to, the Kiang correlation. As used herein, the “Kiang correlation” is a mathematic formula for predicting the dew point of an acid. For example, the Kiang correlation for sulfuric acid is the following: 1,000/TDP=2.276−0.0294 ln(PH2O)−0.0858 ln(PH2SO4)+0.0062 ln(PH2O)ln(PH2SO4). In the Kiang correlation, TDP is the acid dew point (in Kelvin), and P is the partial pressure (in units mm Hg).
In maintaining the flue gas above the predetermined temperature (for example, the sulfuric acid dew point), corrosion and fouling may be reduced or eliminated, despite the sulfur in fuel oxidizing into SO2 and SO3 in boiler 102. In one embodiment, maintaining the predetermined temperature may prevent the decrease in temperature of the flue gas (for example, in air preheater 116) from condensing gaseous H2SO4 at the sulfuric acid dew point. For example, maintaining the predetermined temperature above about 500° F. (about 260° C.) may prevent the SO3 in the flue gas from reacting with H2O in the flue gas to form H2SO4.
Maintaining the predetermined temperature may control the amount of heat recovered from the flue gas based upon the sulfuric acid dew point. In one embodiment, maintaining the temperature of the flue gas above the predetermined temperature may prevent sulfuric acid condensate from reacting with the reductant introduced in SCR unit 112. For example, maintaining the predetermined temperature may prevent ammonia from reacting with the sulfuric acid condensate to form ammonium bisulfate, which may foul the heat exchanger. In the embodiment, preventing the fouling of the heat exchanger may prevent a reduction in heat transfer, may prevent drops in pressure, may reduce or eliminate use of expensive anti-fouling and/or anti-corrosion materials (for example, in ducts for flue gas, air preheater 116, particulate removal mechanism 120, and/or air preheater 128), and/or may prevent shutdown of boiler 102 for cleaning and/or repair of air preheater 116.
In one embodiment, maintaining the temperature of the flue gas above the predetermined temperature may permit the formation of a small amount of sulfuric acid condensate on the heat exchange surface. In the embodiment, which may rely upon the Ljungstrom type heat exchanger, the basket element of the heat exchanger rotates from air inlet 132 to the flue gas, thereby contacting the flue gas with cold metal plates in the heat exchanger. The temperature of the cold metal plates in the heat exchanger may be below the sulfuric acid dew point, thereby forming some sulfuric acid condensate.
As shown in
Sorbent 126 may be any suitable neutralizing agent(s). For example, sorbent 126 may comprise at least one member selected from the group consisting of limestone, lime, trona, sodium bisulfate, and/or magnesium hydroxide. The amount of sorbent 126 applied to the flue gas, the specific sorbent to be applied, the method of applying sorbent 126 may be adjusted to correspond to the selected sorbent.
With the addition of sorbent 126, the amount of SO3 in the flue gas may be reduced. For example, if trona is used as sorbent 126, triona is calcined with the following reaction and then the resultant Na2CO3 reacts with SO3 to form Na2SO4:
Calcination: 2Na2CO3.NaHCO3.H20→3Na2CO3+CO2+5 H2O
SO3 Removal: Na2CO3+SO3→Na2SO4+CO2
As shown in
Referring again to
Particulate removal mechanism 120 is arranged and disposed to receive the flue gas from air preheater 116. A portion or all of a SO3 neutralization product resulting from the application of sorbent(s) 126, any excess sorbent 126, and/or particulate may be removed by any suitable mechanism. For example, the SO3 neutralization product, sorbent(s) 126, and/or particulate may form particulate waste 122, which may be removed by particulate removal mechanism 120. In one embodiment, particulate removal mechanism 120 may include particulate material collection equipment (not shown) such as, an electro-static precipitator (ESP) and/or a filter medium (bag house). The flue gas may be treated by the particulate material collection equipment to remove a predetermined amount of particulate waste 122 in the flue gas. For example, in one embodiment, about 99% of particulate is removed from the flue gas as particulate waste 122. In another embodiment, all particulate above a predetermined size (for example, about 10 microns) is removed from the flue gas as particulate waste 122.
The flue gas with reduced or eliminated particulate may travel from particulate removal mechanism 120 to a second air preheater 128 for second stage heat recovery. Air preheater 128 may be any suitable preheater. Air preheater 128 may be the same type of air preheater as air preheater 116. Air preheater 128 is arranged and disposed to directly or indirectly receive the flue gas via flue gas conduit 121 from particulate removal mechanism 120 and to receive air 130.
Referring to
As shown in
As shown in
Within FGD unit 134, cooling of the flue gas may remove a portion of the remaining SO3 in the flue gas by condensing as sulfuric acid. In one embodiment, a portion of SO3 is removed with waste product 140. The flue gas may then be optionally provided for further processing via flue gas conduit 135. For example, if SO3 in the flue gas is below a predetermined concentration and/or amount, the flue gas may be released via flue gas conduit 143 to the atmosphere through stack 146. If SO3 in flue gas is above a predetermined amount, the flue gas may be provided to wet electrostatic precipitator 142.
Wet electrostatic precipitator (WESP) 142 is arranged and disposed to receive wash water 144 and to provide the flue gas to stack 146 via flue gas conduit 143. WESP 142 may treat remaining SO3 (for example, a sulfuric acid mist) and remaining particulate (for example, very fine particulate, such as particulate smaller than about 10 micrometers). WESP 142 may remove the remaining SO3 and the remaining particulate by charged electrodes. The electrodes attract the remaining SO3 and the remaining particulate. The remaining SO3 and the remaining particulate are washed substantially continuously from the charged electrodes with wash water 144 to dilute and remove the remaining SO3 and the remaining particulate.
While the invention has been described with reference to a preferred embodiment, it will be understood by those skilled in the art that various changes may be made and equivalents may be substituted for elements thereof without departing from the scope of the invention. In addition, many modifications may be made to adapt a particular situation or material to the teachings of the invention without departing from the essential scope thereof. Therefore, it is intended that the invention not be limited to the particular embodiment disclosed as the best mode contemplated for carrying out this invention, but that the invention will include all embodiments falling within the scope of the appended claims.
This Application claims the benefit of U.S. Provisional Application No. 61/356,765, filed on Jun. 21, 2010. The disclosure of this Application is hereby incorporated by reference.
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
61356765 | Jun 2010 | US |