The disclosure pertains to purification and characterization, including size and concentration, of intact acellular particles such as extracellular vesicles and membraneless condensate particles.
Most mammalian cells produce and release small acellular particles or structures into biofluids, including cell culture medium, urine, saliva, milk, blood, and semen. These particles perform divergent physiological and pathophysiological functions depending on the cellular background that released them. Two archetypes of acellular particle architectures are present in biofluids. One type is characterized by the presence of lipid bilayer membrane and a second type is characterized by the absence of a membrane. However, both archetypes have the presence of bioactive cargo in common; i.e., assemblage of proteins and nucleic acids.
One of the most widely studied lipid bilayer membrane-encased particle are the nano-sized extracellular vesicles (EVs) such as exosomes, small −30-150 nm vesicles secreted by most cell types. These EVs, membrane-enclosed nanoparticles, facilitate distal and proximal intercellular communications and are present in all body fluids, such as cerebrospinal fluid, urine, blood, saliva, breast milk, vaginal fluid, and semen. Seminal studies in the past decade have demonstrated that EVs largely orchestrate recipient cells' fate by inducing pathogenesis, promoting tumor progression, and regulating neurodegenerative disorders, among other roles. The diversity of EV-mediated regulations of cellular function has been attributed to (i) its bioactive cargo, including of mRNA, miRNA, proteins, lipids, and dsDNA, and (ii) ability to protect the cargo against degradation. These properties of EVs as well as their endogenous nature allowed them to be considered as promising candidates of drug delivery and therapeutic agents.
The other acellular particle archetype are the membraneless particles or membraneless condensates (MCs) that concentrate a wide array of bioactive molecules without an encapsulating membrane. According to in vitro studies, MCs assemble by thermodynamic-mediated liquid-liquid phase separation (LLPS) and they Aggregate biomolecules in concentrations. MCs have been shown to regulate biological process, including but not limited to RNA metabolism, chromatin rearrangement, and signal transduction. Noteworthy is that liquid MCs can transform into solid aggregates or reversible amyloid fibers. The amyloid fibers have been linked to the pathogenesis of amyotrophic lateral sclerosis), frontotemporal dementia and even Alzheimer's disease. Thus, MCs may be biologically important in many processes.
The isolation of EVs and MCs from biofluids requires stringent control to ensure quality and production of particles that meet advanced analytical characterization preparative needs. Meeting these requires instrumentation with comprehensive in-line monitoring and retrieval capability, both of which will facilitate control of critical process parameters, such as particle purity, stratification into sub-populations, and retrieval of preparative quantities. However, research on and use of EVs and MCs have been largely hindered by technical difficulties related to the aforementioned parameters.
Currently, there are numerous methods available to purify EVs from body fluids and tissue culture samples, but none for MCs These EV methods include differential ultracentrifugation, ultrafiltration, density gradient, flow cytometry, immunocapture, microfluidic isolation, SEC, and Asymmetric Flow Field Flow Fractionation (AF4). None of these methods has been demonstrated efficient in sub-population isolation that allows downstream functional analysis. Recently, AF4 was significantly optimized permitting the identification of membraneless EVs, coined “exomeres”. Though interesting, this technology has limitations, and requires some level of special skills and expensive instrumentation. As a result, AF4 is not broadly accessible.
At present, EV properties, especially exosome concentration and size, are determined using the Nanoparticle Tracking Analysis (NTA) technique. Briefly, NTA is a light scattering-based method that measures the Brownian motion of a particle. The speed of motion or diffusion constant is related to the size of the particle that can be calculated using the Stockes-Einstein equation. The NTA system includes a camera that captures scattered light from each particle which is tracked independently over multiple frames, thus allowing, to determine the particle concentration using mathematical derivation. However, the NTA system is very expensive and has limitations. First, NTA (and any light scattering technique) assumes that EV are spherical, which is not true. Indeed, it was proven by cryo-TEM imaging that EVs derived from a single cell type ex vivo have diverse shapes and sizes, much more so than EVs derived from body fluids in vivo. Second, NTA requires very dilute samples (1:40,000-1:100,000) raising questions about precision of measurements and reproducibility. NTA also has a high background noise. Indeed, measurements of filtered saline would give a typical size distribution and a concentration of −105 particles/ml, indicative of room for errors in data interpretation. Furthermore, NTA cannot achieve in-line determination of size and concentration because: (1) NTA employs brownian motion which is affected by the velocity generated by the flow during separation skewing size determination; (2) NTA requires very dilute samples whereas the separation would generate variable concentration of vesicles across the chromatogram; and (3) NTA require CCD/cMOS camera, a very expensive option, that is not needed for Ultraviolet-visible spectroscopy (UV-Vis or UV-VIS) based concentration determination of particles. And while UV-Vis has been used to determine the concentration of EVs, the wavelength used was 280 nm where proteins absorb light. Thus UV-Vis at 280 nm cannot discriminate between EV and EV-free proteins.
There is thus a need for a system and method that eliminates the variations that result from the current preparative and analytical sample preparations for EVs and MCs.
In one aspect the disclosure is directed to a method for isolating intact acellular particles, such as e.g. extracellular vesicles, membraneless condensate particles, or both. In one embodiment, the method comprises (i) providing a biofluid sample containing intact acellular particles of different sizes; (ii) separating the biofluid sample using a size exclusion gradient, such as e.g. by using a particle purification liquid chromatography column that comprises layers of size exclusion beads having different pore sizes, into subpopulations of intact acellular particles wherein each respective subpopulation individually comprises a different size range of intact acellular particles; and (iii) isolating a respective subpopulation, e.g. by elution of a respective subpopulation from the particle purification column into a fraction collector where each fraction contains a respective subpopulation of respectively different particle sizes. In another aspect, the method further comprises (iv) analyzing the respective subpopulation to determine size of the intact acellular particles therein, the concentration of the intact acellular particles therein, or both. In one practice, analyzing comprises obtaining light scattering information for a respective isolated subpopulation, such as e.g. by UV-VIS spectrometry, and using that light scattering information to determine the size and the concentration of the intact acellular particles contained in that respective subpopulation. In another aspect, a distinct RNA profile, a distinct DNA profile, and/or a distinct proteome for each respective subpopulation can be obtained from the method, as well as quantification of total lipids in a respective subpopulation. The method may be practiced dye-free, thus avoiding associated complications.
The following detailed description of embodiments of the disclosure are made in reference to the accompanying figures. Explanation about related functions or constructions known in the art are omitted for the sake of clearness in understanding the concept of the invention to avoid obscuring the invention with unnecessary detail. Embodiments of the disclosure described herein provide a system and method for isolation of intact acellular particles such as Extracellular Vesicles (EV) with near-single-vesicle resolution coupled with on-line characterization. The system and method facilitates disease-specific biomarker discoveries as well as development of new strategies for treatment of currently uncurable diseases.
In one embodiment, the disclosure is directed to use of Particle Purification Liquid Chromatography (PPLC), a high-resolution chromatographic size-guided turbidimetry-enabled system for dye-free isolation, on-line characterization, and retrieval of intact acellular particles, including extracellular vesicles (EVs) and membraneless condensate particles (MCs) from various biofluids. In one practice, chromatographic separation of acellular particles from biofluids derived from various cell cultures, blood, milk, and semen, is achieved using a gradient-bead size exclusion (SEC) column. Purified intact acellular particles are then collected as sub-populations using an automated fraction collector and purification profiles obtained by ultraviolet-visible spectroscopy (UV-Vis). The UV-Vis analyses reveal sample-dependent differences in UV-Vis spectra, with milk and semen having the most complex UV-Vis spectra. Application of industry-ready turbidimetry facilitates accurate physical characterization of seminal particles (Sps), including particle lipid content, size, and concentration. Particle turbidimetry parameters can be validated against nano-tracking analysis and transmission electron microscopy. Furthermore, the naphthopyrene assay—a fluorescence-based technique that allows naphthopyrene fluorescence upon embedment into a hydrophobic environment can be used to validate detection of Sps containing lipid bilayer. Assessment of compositional content of Sps show that different fractions of purified Sps contain distinct DNA, RNA species, and protein cargos. Proteomic data can be analyzed to determine different protein compartmentalization with varied gene ontology functional predictions. Integration of Sps physical characteristics and cargo composition can be used to determine the presence of two archetypal membrane-encase large SEV (SEL) and small SEV (SEVS), as well as novel non-archetypal-membraneless seminal particles, classifiable as membraneless condensate particles (MCs).
In one embodiment the disclosure is directed to a method for isolating intact acellular particles which, without limitation, comprise extracellular vesicles (EVs), membraneless condensate particles (MCs), or both. The method comprises providing a biofluid sample containing intact acellular particles of different sizes. Without limitation, the biofluid sample comprises, which also includes being derived from, one or more of the following: a biological fluid, a body fluid, a culture fluid obtained from a human cell, a culture fluid obtained from a bacterial cell, a culture fluid obtained from a fungus cell. The biofluid sample is then separated using a size exclusion gradient into subpopulations of intact acellular particles, each respective subpopulation individually comprising a different size range of intact acellular particles. In one practice, the separation step comprises contacting the biofluid sample with size exclusion beads under conditions effective to separate the intact acellular particles into the subpopulations. Without limitation, the size exclusion beads comprise different pore sizes and are configured to form the gradient going from largest pore size to smallest pore size and the biofluid sample progressively contacts the gradient from largest pore size to the smallest pore size. As used herein, the term “isolating” and its variants refers to enriching the amount of intact acellular particles in the respective subpopulation to permit one or more of the ensuing analyses as described herein to occur on that subpopulation.
In one non-limiting practice, the biofluid sample is fed to the inlet of a particle purification liquid chromatography column comprising size exclusion beads having different pore sizes. The size exclusion beads are layered within the column to provide a gradient along the length of the column wherein the largest pore size is at the inlet of the column and the smallest pore size is at the outlet the column. Size exclusion beads as, e.g., known in the art for, among other things, exclusion chromatography can by utilized, including such beads comprised of cross-linked dextran gel. For example, macroscopic beads synthetically derived from the polysaccharide dextran are serviceable, including such beads wherein the organic chains are cross-linked to give a three-dimensional network having functional ionic groups attached by ether linkages to glucose units of the polysaccharide chains. Such beads can separate molecules by molecular weight. In exclusion chromatography, the fractionation range of such beads is typically given for globular proteins and Dextrans (Da). Such ranges for Dextrans for a respective gel type size exclusion bead includes the following: beads having a fractionation range of ≤700 Da; ≤1500 Da; 100-5000 Da; 500-10000 Da; 1000-50000 Da; 1000-100000 Da. Beads of this type are commercially available under the name Sephadex, e.g. Sephadex Gel Types G-10 (≤700 Da); G-15 (≤1500 Da); G-25 (100-5000 Da), including G-25 fine (1000-5000 Da); G-50 (500-10000 Da), including G-50 medium (1000-30000 Da); G-75 (1000-50000 Da, including the range of 3000-8000 Da); and G-100 (1000-100000 Da), including the range of 4000-15000 Da). Other, including but not limited to lower and higher dextran ranges, different SEC bead types, or Ion Exchange beads, may be employed. In one non-limiting practice, for a particle purification liquid chromatography column of given length, the size exclusion beads are layered from bottom to top in the following percentages: G-10 (bottom) at about 3 to 7% of column length, e.g. 5%; then G-15 at about 5 to about 9% of column length, e.g. 7.5%; then G-25 fine at about 9 to about 13% of column length, e.g. 11%; then G-75 at about 20 to about 28% of column length, e.g. 24%; and finally G-100 (top) at about 40 to about 45% of column length, e.g. 35%. In another embodiment, a hybrid Ion Exchange and gradient size exclusion beads is used.
The biofluid sample flows through the column from the inlet to the outlet under conditions effective to progressively elute respective subpopulations of intact acellular particles, where each respective subpopulation individually comprises a different size range of intact acellular particles.
The respective eluting subpopulations are isolated, e.g. by collecting the respective subpopulation of intact acellular particles as a fraction of the biofluid using a fraction collector as known in the art which typically has a plurality of wells.
In another embodiment, fraction collection of intact acellular particles, e.g. EVs, permits downstream applications such as functional studies, RNA sequencing and Matrix-Assisted Laser Desorption/Ionization (MALDI) mass spectrometry. In one practice, a fast fraction collector that is able to collect as low as 50 μl per fraction in a 96-well plate format is used; in another practice, 10 μl fractions in a 384 well plate are collected, e.g., by controlling the flow rate. A CO2 and temperature-controlled fraction collector can be used where fractions are titrated onto pre-incubated cells in a 384 well plates. In one embodiment, the fraction collector accommodates four plates or more in series without stopping the separation. Alternatively, the fraction collector can directly spot EV fractions into an RNA sequencing plate or on a MALDI plate (with automatic pre-mixing with a chosen matrix). The latter (a MALDI-ready format fraction collector) is commercially available from Shimadzu (AccuSpot model). In another embodiment, a diagnostic tool that uses EV UV 3D profiles to indicate a physiological and/or pathological state of a patient, as well as monitor patient's response to treatment can be used. Distinct 2D and 3D UV profiles of blood and semen EVs with a new class of EV subpopulation are shown to be present in seminal plasma and absent in blood plasma. The embodiments of the disclosure provide a fully automated EVpurification system that can: (1) isolate EV to the near-single vesicle resolution; (2) accurately determine size and concentration of EV in real time; (3) allow intact EV fraction collection for downstream functional and analytical studies; and (4) be used in a clinical setting as a miniaturized device that can monitor EV profiles in patients, as a marker of disease or response to therapy.
In addition, the method comprises analyzing the respective subpopulation of intact acellular particles, e.g. the respective eluate subpopulation isolated by a fraction collector, to determine the size of the intact acellular particles therein, the concentration of the intact acellular particles therein, or both. In one embodiment, such analyzing comprises obtaining light scattering information for the respective subpopulation, which light scattering information is used to determine the size and the concentration of the intact acellular particles contained in the respective subpopulation. In one aspect, the light scattering information includes absorbance by the respective subpopulation of light in the visible range of between about 400 nm to about 600 nm. In one aspect, UV-VIS spectrometry is performed on the respective subpopulation within the one or more wells of the fraction collector to obtain light scattering information for that respective subpopulation and determining from the light scattering information the size of the intact acellular particles contained in that respective subpopulation, the concentration of the intact acellular particles contained in that respective subpopulation, or both. In one practice, a portion of the visible range (about 400 nm to about 600 nm), where turbidity derived from the presence of lipid membranes, is measured. Lipid-membrane-derived turbidity is indicative of the presence of EVs. To precisely identify lipid-membrane-derived turbidity from contaminant scatterers, turbidity ratios, R1=A400/A600 and R2=A600/A650, are defined as an EV existence index. In fractions where R1 and R2 proportionally increase above background, it is indication of the presence of EVs. When R1 and R2 vary disproportionally, it is indication of the presence of contaminant scatterers, such as colored materials (phenol red, bilubrin, urobilin, etc.). These turbidity ratios operate concurrently to delimit vesicle-containing fractions without the need for a PDA detector. These ratios can be interpreted as purity indicators for vesicles, in the same manner A260/A230 and A260/A280 are used in the art for nucleic acid purity assessment.
In one practice, UV-Vis spectroscopy is employed. In the UV range (230 nm-350 nm), the biomolecular fingerprint of the collected fractions, including the identity of biological cargo, concentration and purity, is extracted. In the visible range (400 nm-600 nm), information about the lipid content, particle size, and particle concentration is registered as shown in
In another aspect, the disclosure is directed to a system for isolating intact acellular particles the system comprising a station for separating, by using a size exclusion gradient, a biofluid sample containing intact acellular particles of different sizes into subpopulations of intact acellular particles, each respective subpopulation individually comprising a different size range of intact acellular particles, and a station for isolating a respective subpopulation. In one instance, the station for separating comprises a particle purification liquid chromatography column comprising size exclusion beads having different pore sizes, the size exclusion beads layered within the column to provide a gradient along the length of the column wherein the largest pore size is at the inlet of the column and the smallest pore size is at the outlet the column, the biofluid sample flowing through the column from the inlet to the outlet, as described herein; and the station for isolating can comprise a fraction collector. The system can further comprise a station for analyzing the respective subpopulation to determine size of the intact acellular particles therein, the concentration of the intact acellular particles therein, or both. The station for analyzing can comprise a UV-VIS spectrometer to obtain light scattering information, including absorbance by the respective subpopulation of light in the visible range of between about 400 nm to about 600 nm, as described herein. In another aspect, the disclosure is directed to an assembly for isolating intact acellular particles comprising, in combination, a particle purification liquid chromatography column having an inlet and an outlet and configured to flow therethrough a biofluid sample containing intact acellular particles of different sizes, the column comprising size exclusion beads having different pore sizes, the size exclusion beads layered within the column to provide a gradient along the length of the column wherein the largest pore size is at the inlet of the column and the smallest pore size is at the outlet the column; a fraction collector configured to receive an eluate from the outlet; and a UV-VIS spectrometer configured to obtain light scattering information on the elute, as described herein. The assembly can further comprising, in combination: an analyzer to determine the size of an intact acellular particle in the eluate, the concentration of an intact acellular particle in the eluate, the refractive index of intact acellular particles in the eluate, or all together.
The following Examples are illustrative of the disclosure and not limiting to same.
This example describes a high-resolution chromatographic size-guided turbidimetry-enabled dye-free system for purification and analysis of intact acelluar particles comprising EVs and MC from biofluids, with semen as a model. The method employed herein is based on the principle of size exclusion using a column with gradient bead sizes. This gradient column, coupled with an automated fraction collector, permitted obtention of an unprecedented high-resolution separation of particles into fractions of various sub-populations. Furthermore, UV-Vis spectroscopy was employed to accurately identify the separated particles and calculate particle size and concentration using turbidimetry calculations. Validation of turbidimetry size measurements was made by TEM, and NTA measurements, while concentration was validated by fluorescence spectroscopy. Immuno blotting, RNA profiling and proteomics analysis provided compositional validation.
Materials and Methods:
Ethics: All experiments in this study were completed according to University regulations approved by The University of Iowa and Stony Brook University Institutional Review Boards (IRB). All participants were adults who provided written informed consent for semen samples, and all laboratory personnel were blinded to clinical data.
Biofluid samples: The University of Iowa and Stony Brook University Institutional Review Board (IRB) approved the use of human blood and semen specimens. All samples were received unlinked to any identifiers. All experiments were performed in accordance with the approved University guidelines and regulations. Whole, 2% fat, and fat free cow milk (Derle Hygrade) were purchased from Walmart. Conditioned media was collected from cells cultured in their respective media supplemented with 10% 18 h-ultracentrifuged EV-depleted FBS.
Samples processing: Seminal specimens from healthy men, collected by dry ejaculation were stored at −80° C. until used. The samples were thawed at room temperature (RT), differentially centrifuged at 500×g for 10 minutes, 2000×g for 10 min, and 10,000×g for 30 min to remove spermatozoa, leftover cells, and large materials, respectively. Samples were aliquoted either after pooling 3-6 samples or as individual donor aliquots and stored at −80° C. Blood samples from 4 healthy donors were collected in different anti-coagulant type tubes (K2EDTA, Heparin, Citrate and no anti-coagulant). The samples were left undisturbed for 2 hours, and then centrifuged at 2,000×g for 10 minutes at RT. Serum and plasma were collected, centrifuged at 10,000×g for 30 minutes, and pooled by tube-type. 300 μl of each pool was used for separation. The rest of the samples were aliquoted and stored at −80° C. 20 ml of milk samples, with at least 10 days prior to expiration, were centrifuged in 50 ml falcon tubes at 10,000×g for 30 minutes, the fat layer was carefully removed and 1 ml was subjected to column separation. First void clean catch urine sample was collected from a healthy male, clarified by centrifugation at 2,000×g for 10 minutes, and 10,000×g for 30 minutes, before concentration 10 times from 40 ml to 4 ml using Amicon ultra centrifugal filter unit, 3000 Da, of which 1.5 ml was used for column separation. Cells, U1 (NIH AIDS reagent Program), 293T (ATCC), and MDA-MB-231 (ATCC) were cultured in 150×20 mm dishes for 3 days until confluency in complete media supplemented with 10% 18 h-ultracentrifuged EV-depleted FBS (Atlanta Biologics). 10 ml of each supernatant was clarified by differential centrifugation and concentrated (Pierce™ Protein Concentrator 3K MWCO, Thermofisher) to 1 ml and separated on the gradient column.
Size Exclusion Column (SEC) description and separation: An empty glass column of 100 cm length, 1 cm inner diameter, and 79 ml volume (Econo-Columns®, Bio-Rad, cat #7371091) was packed in-house at room temperature by gravity with a gradient of epichlorohydrin cross-linked dextran beads of various exclusion limit controlled by different degrees of cross-linking The beads are commercially available from Cytiva and sold under the trade name Sephadex (previously branded for GE Healthcare). The beads characteristics are described in Table 1. The beads were slowly packed from bottom to top after overnight swelling in ultrapure water, starting with G-10 (at bottom of column; outlet) and ending with G-100 (at top of column; inlet). 1× or 0.1× Phosphate Buffered Saline (PBS) was used as mobile phase. Fractions were collected in Greiner UV-Star® 96 well plates using a fraction collector (Gilson, FC204), with 6 drops per well. UV-Vis and fluorescence of the fractions were measured using a plate reader (Synergy H1, Biotek).
&as advertised in the product specifications from the manufacturer at: https://www.cytivalifesciences.com/en/us/shop/chromatography/resins/size-exclusion.
Nano Tracking Analysis (NTA): Size distribution and particle concentration of purified fractions were determined using ZetaView (PMX 110, Particle Metrix). The system was calibrated using 100 nm Nanosphere™ size standards (3100A, Thermofisher). Samples were diluted to the appropriate concentration in filtered ultrapure water and measurements were acquired using ZetaView software v8.04.02. Shutter was kept at 70 and sensitivity was adjusted to 2-4 points below the noise level in an effort to capture the small particle. Measurements were taken in triplicates. For the zeta potential, samples were diluted in filtered PBS to the appropriate concentration for measurements as noted by the software (usually between 80,000 to 200,000 times) and measurements were taken in pentaplicate. Experiments were repeated at least three times with similar results.
Acetylcholinesterase (AChE) Assay: AChE enzymatic activity was measured as known in the art: briefly, 15 μl of each fraction were lysed in 0.5% Triton X-100 in a 96-well plate, to which was added a solution of 100 μl of a 1:1 volumetric ratio of 1.25 mM acetylthiocholine chloride (Sigma-Aldrich) and 0.1 mM 5,5′-Dithiobis2-nitrobenzoic acid (Sigma-Aldrich). 15 μl PBS was used as AChE negative control. Absorbance was read at 450 nm for 30 min at 37° C. every 5 minutes in a plate reader (Synergy H1, Biotek). Data are reported as the mean from triplicate wells and error bars are S.D. Experiments were repeated at least three times with similar results.
SDS-PAGE protein profiles: One microliter from each fraction of the preparation was withdrawn for SDS-PAGE separation, which was carried out on 4-20% Bis-Tris gel (Bio-Rad) for 120 min at 100 V. Gel was stained with Coomassie Blue. Because F3 and F4 contained low to no detectable levels of proteins, 20 μl of F3 and F4 were concentrated and loaded in separate lanes. Experiment was repeated at least three times with similar results.
Western blot: Primary antibodies against CD63, CD9 (mouse, Developmental Studies Hybridoma Bank, DSHB, Iowa City, Iowa, USA), CD81 (mouse, Proteintech, Rosemont, Ill., USA), TSG 101 (rabbit, Proteintech), HSP70 (rabbit, R&D systems, Minneapolis, Minn., USA), and Semenogelin-1 (SEMG-1, mouse, Santa Cruz Biotechnology, Dallas, Tex., USA) were used for western blot analysis. After incubation with primary and secondary (IRDye 800CW Donkey anti-Mouse/Rabbit IgG, LI-COR, Lincoln, Nebr., USA) antibodies, the membranes were imaged with LI-COR Odyssey Infrared Imaging System (LI-COR).
Transmission electron microscopy (TEM): TEM analysis of the isolated fractions were conducted as known in the art: briefly, carbon-coated copper grids were glow discharged to make the film hydrophilic (Pellco Easiglow, 0.2 mpar, 30 mA, 40s, negative), then ten microliters of F1-4 were applied to the grid and allowed to sit for 30 seconds. After removing the excess samples with filter paper, the grids were washed with distilled deionized water (ddH2O) twice, followed by staining with 0.7% Uranyl Formate solution for 20 seconds. The grids were allowed to air dry before viewed. TEI Tecnail2 BioTwinG 2 electron microscope was employed to view the samples and an AMT XR-60 CCD Digital Camera system was used to capture the samples. Experiment was repeated three times. At least two images from each repeat were used in the particle size determination using ImageJ (NIH).
1-palmitoyl-2-oleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (POPC) and Oleic Acid (OA) vesicle preparation: The method is known in the art: briefly, 5 mM phospholipid solution was prepared by evaporating 150 μl of 25 mg/ml of POPC in chloroform (Avanti Polar Lipids, Alabaster, Ala.) under a stream of nitrogen in a glass vial. The POPC thin film was hydrated with 1 ml of 1×DPBS and tumbled overnight at RT on a rotary mixer. For OA vesicles, 32 μl of OA (Sigma Aldrich) were dissolved in 1 ml of NaOH (0.1 M) to form a 100 mM OA micelle solution, of which 50 μl were added dropwise to 1 ml of 1×DPBS to form a solution of 5 mM OA vesicles. Vesicles were tumbled overnight at RT on a rotary mixer. POPC and OA vesicles were extruded through various size polycarbonate membranes (50-1000 nm) using a mini-extruder (Avanti Polar Lipids) to form monodisperse unilamellar vesicles.
Naphthopyrene (NP) assay for total lipid concentration: Naphtho[2,3-a]pyrene (>98%) was purchased from TCI America and dissolved in DMSO at a stock concentration of 2.5 mM. Two μl of stock NP was added to 1 ml of clarified seminal plasma, for a final NP concentration of 5 μM, and the mixture was incubated on a rotary mixer at RT for 1 h before gradient column separation. In parallel, 5 mM phospholipid solution (POPC), was serially diluted, and NP was added for a final amount of 5 μM, corresponding to 0.1 mol % of POPC. Fluorescence (Ex/Em, 292/465) and absorbance at 280 nm, 400 nm, and 600 nm, and 650 nm were recorded for both the seminal plasma and the POPC standard curve. The standard curve data were fitted to a linear function for NP fluorescence and A400 to infer the total lipid content in the seminal plasma fractions.
Vesicle size and concentration modeling: For core-shell structures such as vesicles, the scattering cross section depends on a set parameter whose equations are known in the art. For this example, the exact Lorenz-Mie solution was used as opposed to the Rayleigh-Gans-Debye approximation for two reasons: First, Lorenz-Mie solution applies to wider ranges of sizes, which fits the heterogenic nature of EVs, whereas Rayleigh scattering is only applicable in a narrow ranges of sizes where the particle radii should be significantly smaller than the wavelength of the scattered light. Second, the exact Lorenz-Mie solution is more favorable when studying charged particles, which is also the case of EVs that have been reported to be negatively charged. Thus, we applied the well=known Wang et al. model (Biophysical Journal 116:659-669) that was developed to calculate the scattering cross section of concentric vesicles with arbitrary size, lipid concentration, membrane thickness or number of layers. This model uses the open-source light-scattering package HoloPy (holopy.readthedocs.io/) and is available on GitHub with illustrative example (https://github.com/anna-wang/vesicle-turbidity). In this Example, the EV turbidity spectra for F1 wells was first calculated from the absorbance measured in the visible range (400-600 nm) with a 5 nm step using the following equation:
Calc.Turbidity(400-600)=2.303×(Absorbance(400-600)−BG)
whereas Absorbance(400-600) corresponds to spectra measured by the plate reader and BG is the background absorbance, mainly resulting from the plastic interference of the 96-well plate.
Next was inputted Calc.Turbidity(400-600) for each well of F1 together with its corresponding total lipid concentration that was calculated in the above section, and, for each input concentration was generated an array of Modeled Turbidity(400-600) spectra with a step of 5 nm for vesicles of size ranging from 40 to 300 nm, with a 1 nm step. This size range was chosen to encompass EVs of all sizes.
Subsequently computed was a cost function (CF400-600) as follow:
whereas n is the number of wells for which the data is input, i is the index of the well, yi is the calculated turbidity based on the experiment, and ŷi is the array of modeled turbidity for the same concentration as i. When CF400-600 reached a minimum for a given i, the vesicle size for that i corresponded to that from the closest Modeled Turbidity(400-600)).
Finally, with the hydrodynamic radius for each well now known, was calculated the vesicle concentration (NC) using the following equation for hollow spheres:
whereas L represents the lipid concentration (in M−1), NA is the Avogadro number, R is the radius of the vesicles, lE represents the bilayer thickness (5 nm), lW represents the thickness of the interlamellar aqueous phase (3 nm), and AL denotes the area per lipid (0.627 nm2).
RNA bioanalyzer: 20 μl of each fraction were purified using RNeasy kit (Qiagen) with on-column DNase I digestion step. RNA was eluted with 14 μl of water and analyzed with Agilent 2100 Bioanalyzer on an RNA 6000 pico chip (Agilent Technologies, Santa Clara, Calif.) according to manufacturer's instruction. Experiment was repeated three times with three different biological replicates with similar results.
Nucleic acids denaturing PAGE: 500 μl of each fraction were used for nucleic acids extraction twice with phenol/chloroform/isoamyl alcohol (25:24:1), pH 8.0 (Thermofisher) and twice with chloroform. The aqueous phase was transferred to a new tube and the nucleic acids were precipitated with 300 mM sodium acetate pH 5.2 and 2.5 equivalent volume of Absolute Ethanol. After chilling for 1 hour at −86° C., precipitated nucleic acids were pelleted by centrifugation (19,000 g, 20 min, 4° C.) and the pellets were resuspended in 100 μl water. 18 μl of each nucleic acids solution was mixed with 2 μl of 10× DNase I reaction buffer (New England Biolabs), to which vehicle PBS, 2.5 units RNase A and 100 units RNase T1 (RNAse cocktail A+T1, Invitrogen), 1 unit DNase I (NEB), or RNase and DNase together were added and the tubes were incubated for 1 h at 37° C. After 1 hour. 20 μl stop solution (50% formamide 50 mM EDTA and 0.1% Bromophenol and 0.1% xylene cyanol) was added and samples were subjected to 8M urea PAGE. The gel was run at 1000V constant for 5 hours and then stained with Sybr Gold® stain (Thermofisher) for 20 minutes and visualized by UV at 254 nm.
Proteomic Analysis: Three seminal plasma pools (6 donors each) were clarified and 1.5 ml of each pool was purified on 100×1 cm gradient SEC column described above. Fractions 1-3 were concentrated under reduced pressure and quantified by the Bradford assay. 50 μg were denatured in 8M urea and 50 mM Tris-HCl, pH 8.0, reduced with 10 mM TCEP for 60 min at RT, alkylated with 2 mM iodoacetamide for 60 min at RT, and then diluted to 2M urea with 50 mM Tris-HCl, pH 8.0. Two micrograms of Trypsin Gold (Promega) was added for overnight digestion (18 h, 37° C.), and then the tryptic peptides were immediately desalted using Pierce C18 spin columns (Thermo Fischer Scientific) at RT. Peptides were eluted with 80% acetonitrile and 0.1% formic acid (FA), dried completely on a SpeedVac Concentrator and resuspended in 5 μl of 0.5% FA before loading onto a 3-phase MudPIT column (150 μm×2 cm C18 resin, 150 μm×4 cm strong cation exchange SCX resin, filter union, and 100 μm×12 cm C18 resin). The other LC-MS parameters are known in the art.
Peak Lists and Search Engine Parameters: Peak lists, protein identifications and database searches were conducted using BSI PEAKS Studio search engine software version 8.5 (Bioinformatics Solutions Inc., Waterloo, Ontario Canada). For label-free quantitation (LFQ), employed was the Q module of BSI PEAKS software which uses expectation—maximization algorithms on the eXtracted Ion Chromatograms (XIC) of the three most abundant unique peptides of a protein to calculate the Area Under the Curve (AUC) [82].
Sequence Databases: The Swiss-Prot UniProt Human non-redundant database (up000005640) which consisted of 20,303 annotated human proteins was used as the reference database (https://www.uniprot.org/uniprot). Enzyme specificity was fully tryptic with maximum 3 missed cleavages and maximum 1 non-specific cleavages. Modifications used were Carbamidomethylation (57.02) as fixed and Oxidized Methionine (15.99) as variable. Parent mass error tolerance was set as 20.0 ppm, and fragment mass tolerance set to 0.5 Da. Known contaminants to be excluded were identified and removed using the common Repository of Adventitious Proteins (cRAP) database version 1.0, release 2012.01.01 (https://www.thegpm.org/crap/). This is a listing of common laboratory proteins, including bovine serum albumin (BSA) and trypsin precursors, non-sample lab contaminants from dust and human sample handling and molecular weight standard proteins. Threshold score/expectation value: The BSI PEAKS peptide score (−10 lgP) was used for significance score of detection was for all peptide-spectrum search results. This is a derived score from the peptide-spectrum match (PSM) p-value. The protein level PEAKS score is the weighted sum of the −10 lgP PEAKS peptide scores. A PEAKS protein score of >=20 was used as the significance threshold for all database search results. For the label-free quantitation (LFQ), an additional threshold of XIC AUC of the 3 most abundant peptides of a protein to be >1e5. FDR was set to 0.1% at the peptide-spectrum match (PSM) level.
Data mining and visualization: KEGG pathways and GO terms were determined using WEB-based Gene SeT AnaLysis Toolkit 2019. Clustering Heatmaps were drawn using heatmapper. The clustering method used was the average linkage with Euclidean distance measurement applied to both rows and columns. Venn diagrams were obtained using Venny platform (v2.1).
Results:
Multi-bead gradient SEC column as prepared above were used to isolate EVs from a variety of samples: Size exclusion separation is based on the principle of size discrimination where large size molecules are excluded from the beads and flush-out directly, while small size molecules are included in the beads and hence travel a longer time through the column. Thus, the large size molecules elute in the void peak while the small size molecule elute in the latter peak (
With more specific reference to
Multi-bead gradient SEC column isolates different EV-subpopulations and MCs from seminal plasma: Post-column fractions were collected in 96-well plates and were binned into four pool fractions (F) named F1-F4, frozen and concentrated under reduced pressure (
With more specific reference to
UV-Vis analysis identifies the molecular components of the purified seminal fractions: Absorbance at 280 nm (A280) has been used to determine the presence of EV during size exclusion chromatography; however, this wavelength is not ideal for EV detection since free proteins may be confounded for EVs. Monitoring the EV separation in the turbidity range (400-600 nm) was chosen instead for EV detection. The hydrophobic interlayer of the EV membrane scatters light in the visible spectrum range of light making the lipid vesicle-containing solution turbid. The UV spectrum range (190-350 nm) is also essential as it contains critical information regarding the nature, the concentration, and the purity of organic molecules. Thus, the full UV-Vis spectrum of fractions F1-F4 was measured (
Three dimensional (3D) UV-Vis profile validates components of the purified seminal fractions: In order to test and extend the ranges of the system in depicting the nature of the biofluid-derived components, 3D UV-Vis measurements were employed (fraction/wavelength/intensity) in the UV-range (
With more specific reference to
UV-Vis analysis accurately determined the lipid concentration of purified EVs: Turbidity is converted into a quantitative parameter of EV particle number. To this end was added 1 μM of Naphtho[2,3-α]pyrene (NP), a polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbon that fluoresces only when embedded in the lipid bilayer to clarified seminal plasma. After brief tumbling at room temperature using a rotary mixer, the seminal plasma was purified and both absorbance and fluorescence (
With more specific reference to
UV-Vis analysis accurately determines the size and particle number of purified EVs: As demonstrated above, the application of turbidimetry is an effective, dye-free way to accurately determine lipid concentration in fractions during EV purification. But total lipid concentration alone does not permit particle number calculation without information about the particle size (
With more specific reference to
High-resolution chromatographic size-guided turbidimetry-enabled dye-free system permits identification of EV- and MC-associated cell-free nucleic acids (cf-NA): Human semen derived EVs contain a repertoire of small non-coding RNA and seminal RNA plays critical roles not only in sperm maturation and fertilization, but also in embryo preimplantation and early embryogenesis. Human seminal EVs were also demonstrated to contain DNA fragments ranging from ˜500 to ˜16,000 bp, but DNA (or RNA) species fractionation was not yet achieved. The method of the disclosure was used to separate different nucleic acid species. RNA was then extracted from F1-F4 using RNeasy® with the optional on-column DNase I digestion performed, and eluted RNA samples subjected to Agilent Bioanalyzer RNA profiling. The RNA profiles (
With more specific reference to
High-resolution chromatographic size-guided turbidimetry-enabled dye-free system permits identification of EV- and MC-associated proteins: Proteomics analysis can be used to identify seminal proteins that are enriched in SEVs and those that are mostly present in EV-free seminal plasma. Conducted was MudPIT analysis of F1-F3 from three biologically independent pools of seminal plasma. F4 analysis was not performed, since in the separation profile and characterization of seminal plasma F4 consistently contained no detectable proteins. The spectral count (SpC) data identified a total of 2178 proteins with at least one unique peptide (
With more specific reference to
In one aspect the present method and system comprises a chromatography method based on a gradient of size exclusion multi-bead column which allows one-dimensional sub-population EV isolation denoted herein as Particle Purification Liquid Chromatography (PPLC). Unlike fast purification liquid chromatography (PPLC) and high performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) systems, PPLC is for particles such as EVs, viruses, liposomes and synthetic nanocages. In another aspect, use of the drop-based fraction collector with PPLC allows collection of as little as 22 μl per fraction (1 drop), rendering any sample to be fractionated into as many as ˜3000 distinct fractions, based on the current column parameters where the elution between the void and the total volumes typically spanned over 500 fractions of 6 drops each. The PPLC embodiment of the disclosure can employ a UV-Vis which takes advantage of full UV-Vis spectra in order to (i) accurately identify the fractions, (ii) determine total lipid concentration, (iii) particle size and (iv) particle concentration, as well as (v) assess particle purity, without flow cytometers, NTA, and Tunable Resistive Pulse Sensing (TRPS), or reagents such as antibodies, colorimetric lipid quantification kits which are based on the sulfo-phospho-vanillin colorimetric method.
The PPLC aspect of the present disclosure can detect 47-60 nm particles whereas NTA recorded 118-131 nm. And the turbidity-based calculations of the disclosure do not require dilute samples as opposed to NTA which only operates in a narrow concentration range of very diluted particles, making turbidity, but not NTA, suitable for on-line tandem analytical and preparative systems such as PPLC. The 3D UV-VIS profiles of PPLC as in the disclosure precisely distinguishes EVs from protein aggregates, and NA-rich components unlike NTA. PPLC in the method disclosed can also enrich RNA species of interest during EV isolation. MC-associated RNA can also be queried using PPLC. PPLC can separate biofluids into fractions that contain distinct proteins/peptides, although some overlap was observed. UV-Vis detection in PPLC, unlike light scattering, is compatible with preparative separations, with a dynamic range of detection from micro-absorbance to absorbance units. PPLC as used in the method of the disclosure can isolate, characterize, and retrieve MCs that concentrate a wide array of bioactive molecules without an encapsulating membrane. Indeed, co-purification of EVs and MCs or other contaminants is an undesirable feature of most EV isolation protocols. PPLC solves this problem. In the practice of the method disclosed, EVs from MCs and avoid contaminants that often times confound results in EV studies. Practically, it has been reported that cell-free proteins and nucleic acids co-purify with EVs when other isolation methods, such as miRCURY™ Exosome Isolation Kit were use. Precipitation based EV isolation could co-precipitate lipoprotein, 9-15% of plasma proteins, and 21-99% of vesicle-free miRNAs, as well as depending on the individual miRNA. Therefore, the PPLC solves this problem by separating EVs from MCs and other macromolecules, including all from a single sample tube. Finally, PPLC algorithm and use of UV-Vis/turbidimetry calculations provides real-time understanding of biological processes within biofluids that may allow the physiological status of the producer cells to be monitored continuously.
This Example is to the use of Particle Purification Liquid Chromatography to distinguish HIV-1 from Host Cell Extracellular Vesicles.
The media of U1 cells was chosen, a chronically infected HIV-1 cell line, with a focus to separate HIV particles from host cell extracellular vesicle (EVs). The PPLC method and analysis of the disclosure indicated that HIV-enriched fractions elute prior to the EV-enriched fractions.
HIV-1 self-assembles near and underneath the plasma membranes by forming a dense viral genome-containing capsid covered with an envelope of gag- and gag-pol-polyprotein, and ultimately buds on the outer surface of the membrane engulfed by a tight lipid bilayer. This biogenesis pathway through direct budding resembles that of microvesicles, a class of large EVs, more than that of exosomes, a tetraspanin-rich EV class that are secreted through exocytosis. HIV-1 particles may be closer in size to the microvesicles, thus larger than exosomes, the most abundant class of EVs. The PPLC separation method of the disclosure is used to distinguish infectious particles from exosomes. Furthermore, thin section electron microscopy have shown that immature HIV-1 (132 to 146 nm) are slightly larger than the mature particles (110 to 128 nm), further indicating utility of the high-resolution size-guided PPLC approach of the disclosure to purify HIV.
In this Example, the PPLC method of the disclosure was used to separate HIV from exosome from U1 cell culture supernatant. Results showed that HIV readily elutes earlier than tetraspanin-rich EVs, although with some degree of overlap.
Methods: PPLC efficiently separates HIV-1 particles from EVs from cell culture supernatant:
45 million U1 cells, which are U937 monocytes that are chronically infected with HIV, were induced with 50 ng/ml Phorbol 12-myristate 13-acetate (PMA) and cultured at a 3M/ml density in a 150 mm tissue culture dish for three days. The supernatant was collected, concentrated to 1 ml, and loaded onto PPLC. In contrast to seminal and blood plasma which feature four and three PPLC peaks respectively as shown in Example 1, only two peaks were noticeable: a major first peak and small second peak (
With more specific reference to
This example is to the Identification of HIV-1 Inhibition Subpopulations from Seminal Plasma through Particle Purification Liquid Chromatography.
Seminal plasma is a rich biofluid that contains factors related to reproduction and transmission of infective agents. In addition, seminal plasma harbors various antibacterial and antiviral factors, especially anti-HIV-1. However, the distribution of the anti-HIV-1 factors in seminal plasma is unknown. In this example, the Particle Purification Liquid Chromatography (PPLC) method of the disclosure is used to identify the fraction of seminal plasma with HIV inhibition properties. PPLC-purified seminal plasma fractions were then pooled as subpopulations of large and small seminal extracellular vesicles (SEVL and SEVS), and membraneless condensates (MC), and co-incubated at various concentrations with HIV-1 before cellular infection. Results showed that SEVL and MC, but not SEVS exhibited strong HIV inhibition. Furthermore, SEVL and MC inhibited exogenous tat-mediated HIV promoter activation, indicating that the anti-HIV factors in SEVL and MC may target viral transcription step of the HIV lifecycle.
Seminal plasma is a rich biofluid that contain a myriad mixture of immunomodulatory and cytotoxic factors that play crucial roles in reproduction and transmission of sexually transmitted infections (STIs), but also harbors various antibacterial and antiviral factors, especially anti-HIV-1. As known in the art, anti-HIV factors in seminal plasma are particularly enriched in exosomes, a class of extracellular vesicles, thus narrowing the focus towards a particular molecular subset of seminal plasma to isolate the HIV inhibitors.
The PPLC method of the disclosure was used to fractionate human seminal plasma into sub-populations, which were tested for anti-HIV function. Results presented here show that the seminal plasma anti-HIV factors are enriched in SEVL, SEVS and MC, two compositionally distinct subpopulations, although some inhibitory activity is also noticed in SEVS at higher concentrations.
Methods: Anti-HIV subpopulations were identified through PPLC from seminal plasma
1 ml of seminal plasma was clarified by 2000×g for 10 min and 10,000×g for 30 min before loaded onto the PPLC system. The absorbance profile showed formation of four peaks (F1-F4) as indicated in
With more specific reference to
This Example is to the use of PPLC for purification of blood extracellular vesicles from albumin and other impurities.
In this Example isolates albumin-free EVs from blood plasma, which heretofore has been difficult to accomplish. Blood plasma EV preparations are often contaminated with albumin hindering blood EV-based biomarker discovery. The results presented here demonstrate that PPLC in the method of the disclosure can readily be applied for EV isolation from blood plasma although some EV/albumin overlap is still noticeable. Of note, the SEC gradient column used in this Example was for seminal plasma EV-MC separation. Blood plasma is the most studied body fluid for physiological and pathological assessments during routine clinical checkup and hospitalization, but also in diagnostics. Fetal medicine presents one example of early diagnostic tests such as maternal blood screening for fetal genetic disorders; i.e., trisomies 21, 18 and 13 in pregnancy, fetal aneuploidies, Down, Edwards and Patau syndromes, but also for very early fetal sex determination. Liquid biopsy is another popular example of blood plasma utility in various cancer diagnosis and prognosis such as lymphomas, rectal, ovarian, breast, and pancreatic cancers, to cite but a few. The development of these precision medicine tests rely on the detection of unique biomarkers, whose levels define the medical state of the patient and predict the disease progression. Examples of blood plasma proposed biomarkers include circulating miRNAs cell free DNA (cfDNA), proteins, metals, and more recently extracellular vesicles. These approaches have been limited by assay sensitivity. Indeed, outdated methods of blood plasma processing for protein, DNA, or RNA isolation are still being employed in clinical and research studies.
Albumin is the most abundant circulating protein in the blood plasma and its presence poses challenges for proteinaceous biomarker discovery by proteomics. Albumin depletion protocols have been proposed. However, current protocols are problematic because they often employ organic solvents which denature the proteome a detrimental consequence for any biological relevance. Immunoprecipitation technique were also used, but they are known for their low specificity in proteomics studies. Plasma delipidation is another protein purification method but it risks removing membrane-associated proteins such as those present in EVs. Furthermore, it has been shown that albumin depletion also removes low abundance biomarkers including cytokines and albuminome analysis revealed that critical plasma proteins are actually shuttled with albumin. There is a need for development of a purification method that, instead of depleting plasma components such as albumin, rather fractionates plasma into different component-rich fractions, in non-denaturing minimal shear stress settings to preserve the inherent concentrations and interactions in the plasma. This Example employed a PPLC method of the disclosure to fractionate blood plasma without eliminating any plasma component. The results show that blood plasma can be readily fractionated into more than 500 size-guided fractions. Furthermore, the results show for the first time direct detection of EV markers by western blot, without the need of any blood plasma component removal. Western blot quantification shows 85% removal of albumin from EV-enriched fractions. The results also show that chromatogram profiles obtained by PPLC can accurately predict EV-containing fractions from blood plasma.
Methods: 1 ml of a 4-donor pool of clarified blood plasma was purified by size-exclusion gradient PPLC system. Absorbance at 280 nm (A280) showed that most of the plasma components eluted in a first large peak and 2 other small peaks (
With more specific reference to
The PPLC separation method of the disclosure separates plasma EVs from albumin allowing direct western blot detection of EV markers using a one-step protocol without invoking an ultracentrifugation step. The PPLC-based separation disclosure can be used to enrich for i) blood EVs devoid of most albumin, and ii) albumin fractions devoid of most EV proteins in non-denaturing conditions, thus preserving the native structures of the components of interest.
This application claims priority under 35 U.S.C. § 119 to provisional application U.S. Ser. No. 62/841,448, filed May 1, 2019, the entire contents of which are incorporated herein by reference.
This invention was made with government support under DA042348 awarded by the National Institutes of Health. The government has certain rights in the invention.
Filing Document | Filing Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
PCT/US2020/030914 | 5/1/2020 | WO |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
62841448 | May 2019 | US |