The present invention pertains generally to radar systems and methods for detecting a plurality of closely spaced targets. More particularly, the present invention pertains to systems and methods that use pulse-compressed radar signals for target detection. The present invention is particularly, but not exclusively, useful for detecting a relatively small target that is located in close proximity to a relatively large target.
Pulse radar systems are capable of detecting remote targets and measuring the position (e.g. range), the radar cross section (i.e. size) and the velocity of the detected targets. When pulsed signals are used, the time period corresponding to the round trip travel of the pulse can be used to calculate target range. When pulses having relatively long pulse durations are employed, it is often difficult to detect and accurately calculate the range of two or more closely spaced targets. Specifically, with long pulses, the scattered returns from closely spaced targets overlap, preventing the return signals from being properly distinguished.
Short pulses, on the other hand, can be used to resolve closely spaced targets. However, with the use of short pulses, pulse energy becomes a consideration. Indeed, all other things being equal, a short pulse has less energy than a long pulse. When pulses having insufficient energy are used, the return signals produced have a correspondingly low energy, and cannot be detected. Since radar systems are limited in terms of peak power, it is difficult to produce a short pulse having sufficient energy to detect relatively small targets.
Pulse compression is a technique that can be used to reduce the duration of a pulse while maintaining a relatively large pulse energy. Typically, modern pulse compression techniques introduce a wideband, coded modulation into the pulse. Examples of this wideband modulation include linear frequency modulation and pseudo-random phase modulation.
When a coded pulse encounters a target, a scattered signal containing the code (or a variation thereof) is created. This scattered signal is then received and processed to “find” the code within the scattered return signal data. For this purpose, the correlation property of the code can be used. More specifically, a correlation function defined by
can be used to find a so-called “zero offset” between the code and the correlation function. The location of this “zero offset” results in a peak when pulse power (usually measured in db) is plotted against range. This peak is indicative of the target range. Unfortunately, during this process, so-called “time-sidelobes” are created and show up, together with a peak, in the pulse-compressed signal. Oftentimes, the time-sidelobes of a relatively large target's return signal mask the peak of a relatively small target's signal return. In the absence of a suitable technique to overcome this problem, small targets that are in close proximity of a large target may be undetectable.
In light of the above, it is an object of the present invention to provide radar systems and methods suitable for the purposes of detecting a plurality of closely spaced targets of differing radar cross section. It is another object of the present invention to provide radar systems and methods for detecting a relatively small target having a return signal that is masked by the time-sidelobe of a relatively large target's return signal. Yet another object of the present invention is to provide radar systems and methods for detecting targets which are easy to use, relatively simple to implement, and comparatively cost effective.
The present invention is directed to radar systems and methods for detecting targets using pulse-compressed signals. In one application, the systems and methods can be used to detect one or more relatively small targets whose radar return signals are masked by the radar return signal created by a relatively large target. More specifically, the present invention can be used to detect a target whose return signal is masked by the time-sidelobes of another target's return signal.
For the present invention, the system includes a radar transmitter for generating and transmitting one or more coded pulse signal(s). Each pulse signal is typically modulated with a pre-selected waveform. For example, the signal can be modulated with a pseudo-random coded waveform, or alternatively, a linear frequency modulated (e.g. chirped) waveform can be used. For the system, the transmitter is oriented to direct at least one pulse toward a targeted area. At the targeted area, the transmitted signal is scattered by each target located in the target area. This scattered signal is then received by a receiver and pulse-compressed. The pulse-compressed signal is then processed to detect the targets.
In greater detail, for the present invention, an iterative, detect-and-subtract signal algorithm is used to process the pulse-compressed signal and detect the targets. Recall, that the present invention is applicable to operational environments where the pulse-compressed signal of a relatively small target may be masked by the time-sidelobes of another, typically larger, target's return signal. With this in mind, the processing algorithm operates on the pulse-compressed signal to identify a point spread function (PSF) corresponding to a relatively large (i.e. masking) target. For these methods, the PSF can be characterized as having a central peak and accompanying time-sidelobes.
In one implementation of the invention, the peak of the PSF of the largest target is identified using a constant false alarm rate (CFAR) technique. Once identified, the PSF (including the peak and the time sidelobes) which corresponds to the largest target is then subtracted from the pulse-compressed signal to generate a first residual signal. This first residual signal, in turn, includes the PSFs for the other targets in the targeted area.
After the PSF for the largest target has been detected and subtracted from the pulse-compressed signal, the next step in the present method is to use the first residual signal to identify other targets. For this purpose, the processing algorithm outlined above is repeated. Specifically, the PSF of the largest target in the first residual signal is identified, for example, using the constant false alarm rate (CFAR) technique. Once identified, the PSF corresponding to the largest target in the first residual signal is then subtracted from the residual signal. This process is repeated until all targets having signal returns with energies above a pre-selected threshold are detected.
Many currently operational radar systems use Doppler filtering to process return signals and determine a detected target's velocity. As described above, the present invention can be used to process pulse-compressed return signals irregardless of whether they have been manipulated by Doppler filtering. When used with Doppler filtered return signals, the present invention uses PSFs corresponding to targets in two-dimensional (range×Doppler) space (i.e. signal power is a function of both range and frequency).
In a first implementation, Doppler filtering can be performed on a single pulse. An example of this type of Doppler filtering is used on the AEGIS SPY-1 radar. For this type of Doppler filtering, the pulse-compressed signal can be characterized as having a frequency, fc, a pseudo-random coded waveform, c(r) and a chip interval, Tc. When a pulse is scattered by a target having a radial speed, v, the pseudo-code of the pulse-compressed signal will be modulated by scattering targets as
cR(rTc)=c(rTc)exp(i2 πθdrTc),
where
and r denotes the range bin index. For this case, the PSF corresponding to the scattering target pf can be computed as a convolution of cR(r) with c(r), namely,
pf(r)=cR(r)c(r).
For another type of Doppler filtering (so-called conventional Doppler filtering), a pulse-compressed signal includes a plurality of pulses in a coherent pulse interval. For this type of Doppler filtering, a two-dimensional PSF can be generated by: 1) weighting the return signal corresponding to a point source, and 2) applying a fast Fourier transform to the weighted return signal. Using the PSF generated in this manner, a detect-and-subtract process as described above can be employed to detect each target.
The novel features of this invention, as well as the invention itself, both as to its structure and its operation, will be best understood from the accompanying drawings, taken in conjunction with the accompanying description, in which similar reference characters refer to similar parts, and in which:
Referring to
Continuing with
For the system 20, each target 22a-c is considered to consist of point sources/scatterers.
For the system 20, it can be assumed that targets 22a-c consist of a collection of point scatterers. As a consequence, the pulse-compressed signal 43 (see
Once the largest target has been identified, the PSF corresponding to the largest target in the pulse-compressed signal 43 is then subtracted from the pulse-compressed signal 43. This PSF includes the peak 44 and accompanying time-sidelobes (see also
Next, the PSF corresponding to the largest target (i.e. target 22b) in the residual signal 48 is then subtracted from the residual signal 48. For this example, this second detect-and-subtract iteration results in the residual signal 52 shown in
The system 20 can also be configured to incorporate the effects of Doppler frequency shifts that are caused by the movement of the targets 22a-c. For this configuration of the system 20, moving targets are characterized not only by amplitude and phase but also by Doppler frequency. In general, to accommodate these characteristics (i.e. amplitude, phase and Doppler frequency) the above-described detect-and-subtract methods can be used by generating PSFs in two-dimensional range×Doppler space.
Mathematically, the Doppler shift can be computed as:
where v is the target radial speed and f, is the radar frequency. In addition, the pseudo-code received by a radar is modulated by the target as:
cR(rTc)=c(rTc)exp(i2πƒdrTc)
where Tc is the chip interval and r denotes the range bin index. For simplicity of notation, Tc can be dropped as long as it does not cause confusion. The corresponding PSF can then be computed as a convolution of cR(r) with c(r):
pf(r)=cR(r)c(r)
where the suffix f of the PSF indicates the dependence on Doppler frequency.
Below, two implementations of the system 20 are described, each of which account for Doppler effects. In these two implementations, PSFs corresponding to targets are generated in two-dimensional range×Doppler space. It is to be appreciated and understood that these two implementations are merely exemplary, and those skilled in the pertinent art can routinely extend the teachings provided herein to other Doppler filtering schemes using PSFs that are generated in two-dimensional range×Doppler space.
In one implementation, the system 20 can be configured for processing a return signal that has been Doppler filtered using a common Doppler signal processing technique that is currently employed in AEGIS SPY-1 radars. These AEGIS SPY-1 radars typically use a pseudo-random coded waveform, and accordingly, a pseudo-random coded waveform is considered here. It is to be appreciated that the algorithm described herein can also be extended to LFM radar waveforms without difficulty. One advantage of the AEGIS crude Doppler filtering is that it requires only one pulse.
In order to make the derivation applicable to general pulse compression techniques, a complex notation is used to represent a code: exp(jφ(r)), where φ(r) denotes the phase at the rth chip. For a bi-phase coding system, φ(r) may be set to either 0 or π.
For a target with Doppler frequency shift ƒD, the returned pulse may be represented as
s(r)=exp(j2πƒDr)exp(jφ(r)) (1)
where a signal of unit power is assumed for simplicity. In equation (1), the effects of the carrier frequency can be ignored assuming an appropriate downconversion followed by filtering. Also, the sampling interval has been suppressed in equation (1). In equation (1), the term, exp(j2πƒDr), represents the effect of target Doppler in a pulse. The AEGIS Doppler filtering technique is a crude technique which capitalizes on this Doppler shift term. If the signal is pulse-compressed using the code exp(j2πƒDr)exp(jφ(r)), no performance degradation results. Since the target Doppler frequency ƒD is unknown, a finite number of candidate (fixed) Doppler frequencies are assumed and are used for pulse compression. Specifically, L candidate frequencies can be assumed, for which a pulse can be compressed using L “modified” pseudo-codes:
exp(j2π{circumflex over (ƒ)}1r)exp(jφ(r)),l=1,2, . . . , L. (2)
These “modified” codes generate a crude Doppler filter bank.
In another implementation, the system 20 can be configured for processing a return signal that has been Doppler filtered using what is commonly called conventional Doppler filtering. This conventional Doppler filtering technique typically requires multiple pulses in a coherent pulse interval (CPI), unlike the above-described AEGIS crude filtering which requires only one pulse. To describe the implementation of the system 20 for use with conventional Doppler filtering, the post-compressed radar signal of the nth pulse at the rth range bin, y(r, n), is weighted and a fast Fourier transform (FFT) is applied:
where {w(n)} denote weights that are used to reduce high sidelobes associated with a FFT and M is the number of pulses.
Following equation (1), above, the target return for the nth pulse at the rth range bin can be represented as:
pƒ
A pulse is compressed in the Doppler filtering technique using the code sequence, exp(jφ(r)). Thus, a PSF can be computed as:
pf
The target frequency ƒD can be restricted to those of integer multiples of 1/(MTp) as usually assumed in Doppler filtering, i.e., ƒD=mD/(MTp) for some integer mD, mD=0, 1, 2, . . . , M-1. Under this assumption, the number of PSFs to be used can be reduced to M. Substituting ƒD=mD/(MTP) into (5), leads to:
where the subscript mD is used to indicate the dependence of the PSF on target Doppler frequency. The PSF of equation (6) is herein named “time-PSF” to avoid confusion.
A two-dimensional PSF can be computed by replacing y(r, n) in equation (3) with pm
In order to distinguish this PSF from the PSF of equation (6), {circumflex over (p)}m
For the special case where w(n)=1 , n=0, 1, 2, . . . , N. substituting equation (6) into equation (7) yields:
Note: such an orthogonality condition does not generally hold if w(n)≠1.
Referring now to
To detect targets, the system 20 identifies the largest signal in the pulse-compressed signal in range×Doppler space. Specifically, if the signal power level is greater than the pre-determined threshold, a two-dimensional Doppler-PSF corresponding to the range bin and Doppler of the detected target/scatterer is generated (according to equations (6) and (7)) and subtracted. The process is repeated until there are no samples in the residue greater than the threshold.
In some cases, the detection and estimation of target Doppler by the above-described techniques is dependent on the level of sidelobes of Doppler filters. Thus, it is desirable to mitigate sidelobes of Doppler filters and also increase the frequency resolution of Doppler filters. Specifically, this should be done without increasing the number of transmitted pulses to thereby conserve radar resources. One way that target detection may be significantly degraded is if the target Doppler frequencies do not exactly fall on the frequencies of the Doppler filters. However, using a FFT size significantly larger than the number of pulses (thus zero padding is required for Doppler filtering) can be used to significantly improve detection.
While the particular systems and methods for sidelobe reduction using detect-and-subtract techniques as herein shown and disclosed in detail are fully capable of obtaining the objects and providing the advantages herein before stated, it is to be understood that they are merely illustrative of the presently preferred embodiments of the invention and that no limitations are intended to the details of construction or design herein shown other than as described in the appended claims.
The U.S. Government has a paid-up license in this invention and the right in limited circumstances to require the patent owner to license others on reasonable terms as provided for by the terms of Contract No. F30602-03-C-0240 awarded by the Missile Defense Agency, Rome AFRL/SNR.
Number | Name | Date | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
3362024 | Badewitz | Jan 1968 | A |
3649125 | Lehmann | Mar 1972 | A |
4608566 | Ennis et al. | Aug 1986 | A |
5334981 | Smith et al. | Aug 1994 | A |
5534876 | Erickson et al. | Jul 1996 | A |
5583517 | Yokev et al. | Dec 1996 | A |
5760732 | Marmarelis et al. | Jun 1998 | A |
5969662 | Hellsten | Oct 1999 | A |
6078289 | Manoogian et al. | Jun 2000 | A |
6313783 | Kuntman et al. | Nov 2001 | B1 |
6677890 | Halsey et al. | Jan 2004 | B2 |
6724340 | Carlos et al. | Apr 2004 | B1 |
20060227038 | Ohnishi | Oct 2006 | A1 |
20070040729 | Ohnishi | Feb 2007 | A1 |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
20070040729 A1 | Feb 2007 | US |