This application is a U.S. National Stage Application of International Application No. PCT/EP2014/070866 filed Sep. 30, 2014, which designates the United States of America, and claims priority to DE Application No. 10 2013 220 912.6 filed Oct. 15, 2013, the contents of which are hereby incorporated by reference in their entirety.
The present invention relates to a system and a method for digital data transmission, in particular for the radio transmission of PSK and DSSS signals.
A radio receiver generally does not know whether or when a frame is emitted by a transmitter. The decision regarding whether or when a valid useful signal is present is therefore the responsibility of the receiver controller.
In the so-called frame reception mode, although the controller of the receiver can assume that the transmitter will transmit a frame, the receiver does not know the exact time. The receiver must therefore stay in a search mode for a particular time and must wait for the start of the useful signal. In a so-called polling mode, the receiver is activated at regular intervals in order to check whether a useful signal (wanted signal) is received. If a useful signal is detected, the receiver remains active for a period in order to be able to completely receive a frame.
Irrespective of the reception mode used, a receiver is supposed to be able to successfully detect a useful signal and distinguish it from other signals (for example interference signals, noise, etc.). Incorrect detection (failure to recognize a useful signal) may result in the useful signal not being recognized and in the message contained therein not being received and being ignored as a result. Furthermore, incorrect detection of an interference signal as a useful signal (“false alarm”) may result in the receiver being activated even though a message is not transmitted. In addition to the sequence of bit values which is to be transmitted and represents the information, a frame contains further parts, for example parts used for signal acquisition. At least the bits are represented by a sequence of modulation symbols which are emitted and need to be detected at the receiver end. Depending on the type of modulation used, each modulation symbol has a particular information content. In the case of unspread PSK modulation, one (binary PSK) or more bits (m-fold PSK) are transmitted for each modulation symbol. In the case of DSSS (direct-sequence spread-spectrum) transmission, a plurality of modulation symbols represent one bit. A message may consist of a plurality of frames.
Many implementations of a digital receiver provide for one or more parameters relevant to the demodulation to be determined before the reception signal is demodulated. For example, a frequency error in the carrier signal (also the phase error in the case of coherent demodulation) and/or the modulation symbol timing (phase angle of the modulation symbols) is/are determined. These parameters are determined with such an accuracy that data can be received (that is to say the reception signal can be demodulated). Parameter control can be optionally used to adjust the current values of the relevant parameters (for example symbol timing) on the basis of the current reception signal, in which case the initially recognized parameter values can be used as starting values.
The parameter detection mentioned which is needed to successfully demodulate the reception signal is part of the acquisition method carried out in the receiver. This method usually comprises a plurality of successive steps which are based on one another, a result obtained in one step not being able to be directly verified or falsified in the next step. In the event of an incorrect change from one acquisition step to the next, a long dwell time may be necessary in this step in order to avoid rejecting—possibly correct—useful signal reception.
When carrying out the acquisition method, it may therefore be important to know whether the (estimated) results obtained by a particular algorithm have been obtained on the basis of a valid (actually received) useful signal. The teachings of the present disclosure relate to a method and a system for digitally transmitting data, in which reliable detection of the useful signal contained in the reception signal may be improved at the receiver end.
A method for digitally transmitting data, may comprise: receiving a modulated signal (r(t)) which contains at least one useful signal or noise or interference signals; repeatedly estimating at least one parameter (ξ, ζ; θ) of the received signal (r(t)) that is relevant to the demodulation of the useful signal; monitoring changes (Δξ, Δζ; Δθ) in the repeatedly estimated parameters; and detecting a useful signal using a criterion, according to which a useful signal is recognized if one or more changes (Δξ, Δζ; Δθ) in the repeatedly estimated parameters satisfy at least one particular, predefined condition.
In some embodiments, the useful signal has a sequence of modulation symbols or spreading codes of a particular period (TSYM) and phase angle (φSYM; ξ) which are modulated onto a carrier signal of a particular carrier frequency (fTX).
In some embodiments, at least one frequency error (fE; ζ) of the carrier frequency (fTX) at the receiver end or the phase angle (φSYM; ξ) of the modulation symbols or spreading codes is considered as relevant parameters (ξ, ζ; θ).
In some embodiments, the at least one parameter is repeatedly estimated at least occasionally in an asynchronous manner with respect to the period of the modulation symbols or spreading codes.
In some embodiments, the at least one parameter is repeatedly estimated with approximately the same period (TPER) as the period of the modulation symbols or spreading codes, a delay time which corresponds to a change in the estimated phase angle (φSYM; ξ) being awaited at least once in a series of estimations of the at least one parameter (ξ, ζ; θ).
In some embodiments, the phase angle (φSYM; ξ) of the modulation symbols or spreading codes is varied at the transmitter end.
In some embodiments, the useful signal is modulated onto a carrier signal of a particular carrier frequency and the carrier frequency (fTX) is changed at the transmitter end. The at least one relevant parameter (ξ, ζ; θ) may comprise at least one frequency error (fE; ζ) of the carrier frequency (fTX) at the receiver end. The change in the estimated frequency error at the receiver end corresponding to the change in the carrier frequency at the transmitter end.
In some embodiments, the carrier frequency (fTX) is changed at the transmitter end by means of frequency modulation using frequency modulation symbols of a particular symbol duration (TFSK). The frequency error (fE; ζ) of the carrier frequency (fTX) may be regularly estimated at the receiver end at particular estimation times. A useful signal may be recognized during useful signal detection when a predefined number of differences between two estimated values in each case satisfy a predefined criterion. Estimated values whose estimation times are temporally separated by a symbol duration (TFSK) or an integer multiple thereof are used to form the differences.
In some embodiments, two successive estimation times are separated by less than a symbol duration (TFSK).
In some embodiments, a receiver for receiving a modulated signal (r(t)) which may contain both a useful signal and noise and interference signals, may comprise an acquisition unit. The acquisition unit may carry out repeated estimations of at least one parameter (ξ, ζ; θ) of the received signal (r(t)) that is relevant to the demodulation of the useful signal; monitor changes in the repeatedly estimated parameters; and may detect a useful signal, a criterion being used for the detection, according to which criterion a useful signal is recognized when one or more changes (Δξ, Δζ; Δθ) in the repeatedly estimated parameters satisfy at least one particular, predefined condition.
In some embodiments, a system for digitally transmitting data may comprise: a transmitter emitting, as a useful signal, a sequence of modulation symbols or spreading codes of a particular period (TSYM) and phase angle (φSYM; ξ) which are modulated onto a carrier signal of a particular carrier frequency (fTX); a receiver for receiving a modulated signal (r(t)) which may contain both a useful signal and noise and interference signals; and an acquisition unit which carries out repeated estimations of at least one parameter (ξ, ζ; θ) of the received signal (r(t)) that is relevant to the demodulation of the useful signal, monitors changes in the repeatedly estimated parameters, and detects a useful signal, a criterion being used for the detection, according to which criterion a useful signal is recognized when one or more changes (Δξ, Δζ; Δθ) in the repeatedly estimated parameters satisfy at least one particular, predefined condition.
In some embodiments, at least one frequency error (fE; ζ) of the carrier frequency (fTX) at the receiver end or the phase angle (φSYM; ξ) of the modulation symbols or spreading codes is considered as relevant parameters (ξ, ζ; θ).
In some embodiments, the transmitter is designed to change the carrier frequency (fTX).
In some embodiments, the transmitter is designed to carry out FSK or GFSK with a (G)FSK symbol duration which is considerably longer than the period of the modulation symbols or spreading codes.
In some embodiments, the at least one parameter (ξ, ζ; θ) is repeatedly estimated in the receiver at least occasionally in an asynchronous manner with respect to the period of the modulation symbols or spreading codes.
In some embodiments, the at least one parameter (ξ, ζ; θ) being repeatedly estimated in the receiver with approximately the same period (TPER) as the period of the modulation symbols or spreading codes, a delay time which corresponds to a change in the estimated phase angle (φSYM; ξ) being awaited at least once in a series of estimations of the at least one parameter.
In some embodiments, the useful signal is modulated onto a carrier signal of a particular carrier frequency (fTX) and the carrier frequency (fTX) is changed at the transmitter end, and the at least one relevant parameter (ξ, ζ; θ) comprises at least one frequency error (fE; ζ) of the carrier frequency (fTX) at the receiver end, the change in the estimated frequency error at the receiver end corresponding to the change in the carrier frequency at the transmitter end.
In some embodiments, the carrier frequency (fTX) is changed at the transmitter end by means of frequency modulation using frequency modulation symbols of a particular symbol duration (TFSK); the frequency error (fE; ζ) of the carrier frequency (fTX) is regularly estimated at the receiver end at particular estimation times; a useful signal is recognized during useful signal detection when a predefined number of differences between two estimated values in each case satisfy a predefined criterion; and estimated values whose estimation times are temporally separated by a symbol duration (TFSK) or an integer multiple thereof are used to form the differences.
In some embodiments, two successive estimation times are separated by less than one symbol duration (TFSK).
The invention is explained in more detail below using the examples illustrated in the figures. The illustrated examples should not necessarily be understood as restricting the invention, rather importance is attached to explaining the principles on which the invention is based. In the figures:
The teachings of the present disclosure include a method for digitally transmitting data. According to one example, the method comprises the following: receiving a modulated signal which may contain both a useful signal and noise and interference signals; repeatedly estimating at least one parameter of the received signal that is relevant to the demodulation of the useful signal; and monitoring changes in the repeatedly estimated parameters. A useful signal is detected using a criterion, according to which a useful signal is recognized when one or more changes in the repeatedly estimated parameters satisfy at least one particular, predefinable condition. Such detection of a useful signal makes it possible to reduce the false alarm rate, that is to say the incorrect recognition of a useful signal.
The useful signal may have a sequence of modulation symbols or spreading codes, the modulation symbols or spreading codes, which can be assigned a period and a phase angle, being modulated onto a carrier signal of a particular carrier frequency. At least one frequency error of the carrier frequency at the receiver end or the phase angle of the modulation symbols or spreading codes comes into consideration as relevant parameters. Both parameters are estimated in the receiver and are needed to demodulate the useful signal.
In order to change the phase angle of the modulation symbols or spreading codes received with the useful signal, the at least one parameter can be repeatedly estimated at least occasionally in an asynchronous manner with respect to the period of the modulation symbols or spreading codes. According to one exemplary embodiment, the at least one parameter is repeatedly estimated with approximately the same period as the period of the modulation symbols or spreading codes. In this case, a delay time which then corresponds to a change in the estimated phase angle is awaited at least once in a series of estimations of the at least one parameter.
As mentioned, the frequency error of the carrier frequency at the receiver end comes into consideration as a relevant parameter to be estimated. The useful signal is modulated onto a carrier signal of a particular carrier frequency in the transmitter and this carrier frequency can be changed at the transmitter end, with the result that the change in the estimated frequency error at the receiver end corresponds to the change in the carrier frequency at the transmitter end.
The carrier frequency can be changed at the transmitter end by means of frequency modulation using frequency modulation symbols of a particular symbol duration. The frequency error of the carrier frequency is regularly estimated at the receiver end at particular estimation times. A useful signal is recognized during useful signal detection when a predefinable number of differences (changes) between two estimated values in each case satisfy a predefinable criterion. In this case, estimated values whose estimation times are temporally separated by a symbol duration or an integer multiple thereof are used to form the differences. However, two (immediately) successive estimation times are temporally separated by less than a symbol duration. As a result, estimated values which are based on frequency values in the transition ranges (caused by frequency modulation) from one frequency value to another do not result in the recognition of a useful signal. However, at the next estimation time, the carrier frequency error can then be correctly estimated in the receiver and the estimated results can be used for signal acquisition and demodulation.
In the figures, identical reference symbols denote identical or similar components or signals with an identical or similar significance.
The oscillator signal mTX(t) (also called carrier signal) which is supplied to the mixer 20 has a frequency fTX and a phase φTX (carrier frequency and carrier phase). This means that the spectrum of the RF transmission signal sRF(t) is spectrally shifted by the absolute value of the carrier frequency fTX in comparison with the spectrum of the transmission signal s(t) in the baseband (the signal spectrum is then symmetrical around the carrier frequency fTX). The block diagram of the described transmitter is illustrated in FIG. 1a and the corresponding block diagram of the receiver is illustrated in
The (radio-frequency) transmission signal sRF(t) transmitted via the channel CH is distorted by the transmission channel CH and has interference and noise superimposed on it on the way to the receiver. The reception signal corresponding to the transmission signal sRF(t) is denoted rRF(t). The reception signal rRF(t) is therefore a superimposition of the transmission signal sRF(t) distorted by the channel with interference signals j(t) and noise n(t).
At the receiver end, the reception signal rRF(t) is converted to the baseband with the aid of a complex multiplication 30 (with the aid of the nominal oscillator frequency at the receiver end, that is to say the carrier frequency fRx). The result of the complex multiplication 30 comprises an in-phase signal rI(t) and a corresponding quadrature signal rQ(t), both together being referred to as a complex signal r(t)=rI(t)+j·rQ(t) (j is the imaginary unit).
The mixer 30 represents, by way of example, frequency conversion (implemented in any desired manner) of the reception signal rRF(t) to the baseband. This frequency conversion can be carried out in one step (referred to as direct down-conversion) or in a plurality of steps (with a plurality of successive (complex) multiplications). The spectral component of the useful signal which occurs during frequency conversion and has a frequency which is the opposite in terms of absolute value and is twice the mixing frequency can be suppressed by the reception filter 40 which usually has low-pass properties.
In any case, the spectral situation of the useful signal at the output of the frequency conversion (that is to say the signal r(t)) has only one frequency error fE. This frequency error fE corresponds, for example, to the difference in the (carrier) frequency used at the transmitter end and at the receiver end for up-conversion and down-conversion, that is to say fE=fTX−fRX. This arises as a result of the fact that, in practice, the nominal transmission frequency (carrier frequency) can be provided both at the transmitter end and at the receiver end only with finite accuracy, that is to say the frequency normals used (for example crystals), from which the frequencies for up-conversion and down-conversion are derived, have errors.
In addition to the frequency error fE, the spectral situation of the useful signal at the output of the frequency conversion (that is to say the signal r(t)) may also have further frequency error components which may be produced, for example, by the Doppler effect during radio transmission via the channel CH. A phase error φE=φTX−φRX must also be heeded during coherent demodulation. The mixer 30 therefore very generally represents the (single-stage or multistage) conversion of the received RF signal rRF(t) to the baseband.
This (previously estimated) frequency error fE is corrected using a second complex multiplication (mixer 31). Only the frequency error on account of the frequency estimation which was possible only with limited accuracy then remains. The mixer 31 therefore very generally (irrespective of the specific implementation) represents the correction of the above-mentioned frequency error. If coherent demodulation is used, the phase error φE can also be corrected with the aid of the mixer 31, for example.
In addition to the distortion and interference mentioned, the output signal r′(t) (which is complex and, with regard to the estimation accuracy, no longer has a frequency error) from the second mixer 31 (that is to say the corrected reception signal in the baseband) contains the modulation symbol sequence, that is to say the temporally offset pulse responses gTX(t−i·TBIT) and −gTX(t−i·TBIT) corresponding to the transmission signal s(t). The signal r′(t) is supplied to a reception filter 40 whose pulse response gRX(t) can be matched to the transmitted pulses gTX(t). This is referred to as “matched filter reception”. Data reception with the aid of matched filters is known per se and is therefore not explained in any more detail. However, in a manner deviating from the known theoretical relationships, simplifications can be made, in particular at the receiver end, in terms of the implementation (for example a raised cosine filter pulse response in the transmitter but a rectangular filter pulse response in the receiver).
The receiver from
The tracking unit 51 is designed to adjust the estimated frequency and phase errors fE, φE in the event of a temporal change in the carrier frequencies fRX, fTX and the corresponding phases φRX, φTX and in the event of a temporal change in the phase angle of the modulation symbols. Such a control loop is also referred to as a “carrier tracking loop”. The tracking unit 51 is also designed to adjust the estimated phase angle of the received modulation symbols. Such a control loop is also referred to as a “symbol tracking loop” or “clock tracking loop”. The control loops (and therefore the tracking unit) need not necessarily be present, for example if the values estimated by the acquisition unit are sufficiently accurate for transmitting a frame.
The acquisition unit is used to (roughly) determine the carrier frequency and the phases of the carriers and the modulation symbol timing, but is not used for control. A closed control loop is usually used only in tracking; strictly speaking, there are two control loops, namely the “carrier tracking loop” mentioned and the “symbol tracking loop”. This adjustment of the estimated phase and frequency error and of the phase angle of the modulation symbols is known per se and is therefore not explained in any more detail. The actual implementation also does not play a significant role for the present invention.
The blocks illustrated in the figures (mixer, filter, acquisition unit, tracking unit, etc.) should not be understood as a structural unit but rather purely as functional units. Depending on the application, they can be implemented in very different ways. The mixers 5, 10, 30 and 31 represent a mathematical operation (possibly a complex multiplication). The acquisition unit and the tracking unit therefore generate signals of the form exp(j(2π·Δf·t+Δφ)) for the respective mixer 31 which uses them to implement a frequency conversion by a difference frequency Δf and a phase rotation by Δφ. This complex multiplication also represents, by way of example, a wide variety of possible implementations (for example with one or two multipliers/mixers in any order).
The acquisition unit 52 is also used to ascertain the correct (sampling) times (bit and symbol limits) at which a decision (decision-making unit 50) relating to the value of a transmitted data symbol is intended to be made. During tracking, these times are tracked by the tracking unit 51. The mentioned frequency error fE (or else the carrier phase φRX in the case of coherent demodulation) in the reception signal is estimated by the acquisition unit 52 with such accuracy that the control loops in the tracking unit (PLL or FLL) can be started. As shown in
The parameters estimated by the acquisition unit 52 can generally be considered to be a vector θ[m], where m denotes a discrete time. The acquisition unit 52 processes the baseband reception signal r′(t) or the filtered reception signal (pulse response gRX(t)) and uses it to estimate a parameter vector θ[m] at discrete times. This relationship is illustrated in
Estimation algorithms (acquisition algorithms) which can be used to estimate said parameters and a parameter vector θ[m] are known per se and are not explained in any more detail here. The publication WO 2012/069471 A1 describes, for example, an acquisition algorithm which is suitable for spread spectrum signals (in the case of DSSS transmission methods, DSSS=“direct-sequence spread-spectrum”). In this case, a code phase of the spreading code is estimated instead of the modulation symbol phase. The receiver shown in
In some embodiments, a first parameter vector θ[m] is estimated at a first time m and a second parameter vector θ[m+n] is estimated at a second, later time m+n. The estimation is carried out on the basis of the reception signal r(t) and always provides a result irrespective of whether or not the reception signal actually contains a useful signal. A difference vector Δθ θ[m+n]−θ[m] is then calculated. If the difference vector satisfies a particular relationship, for example ∥Δθ∥>ε (where ε is a predefined small positive numerical value), a valid useful signal is detected in the reception signal. In this respect, the transmission signal is manipulated at the transmitter end in such a manner that a particular change in the estimated parameter vectors can be detected (and possibly quantified) at the receiver end. This makes it possible to reliably prevent a useful signal being incorrectly recognized in the reception signal in the receiver even though no useful signal is present. The so-called false alarm rate (FAR) can therefore be reduced.
When receiving linearly modulated data symbols, for example when using phase shift keying (PSK) or quadrature amplitude modulation (QAM), the two components ξ and ζ of the parameter vector θ to be estimated are, in particular, the mentioned carrier frequency error fE and the modulation symbol timing (symbol phase angle φSYM).
In this case, the two-dimensional estimated vectors can be represented in a field according to
As already mentioned, an estimation algorithm always provides a result irrespective of whether or not the reception signal contains a useful signal. For reliable useful signal detection, the estimated results must be verified. This can be achieved, inter alia, by restarting the estimation algorithm periodically (period duration TPER), in particular with an integer multiple k of the a-priori approximately known modulation symbol period duration TSYM, that is to say TPER=k·TSYM, where (k∈N). This situation is illustrated in
In the example shown in
Instead of searching for an estimated result θ[m] which remains the same (within a certain tolerance range), it is possible to search for particular changes Δθ1, Δθ2, etc. in the parameter vector in order to reduce the false alarm rate (FAR), as illustrated in
Carrying out the estimation algorithm asynchronously (with respect to the modulation symbol period TSYM) produces defined “jumps” Δθ1, Δθ2, etc. in the estimated results θ[1], θ[2], etc. if a useful signal is present. With a relationship of k=TPER/TSYM=1.25, the parameter estimation is carried out four times within five symbol periods (or spreading code periods). If a useful signal is present, approximately the same result is therefore estimated only in every fourth estimation, that is to say θ[m]=θ[m+4] for m=1, 5, 9, etc. Asynchronously carrying out the estimation algorithm changes only the modulation symbol phase ξ. In order to change the frequency error ζ to be estimated, the carrier frequency can additionally be changed at the transmitter end in the transmission system. A carrier frequency change only at the receiver end would concomitantly shift the interference signal components and would therefore be ineffective.
The mentioned carrier frequency change at the transmitter end may be achieved, for example, by means of frequency modulation, for example FSK (frequency shift keying) and, in particular, GFSK (Gaussian frequency shift keying). One example of this is outlined in
One example of useful signal detection is now explained using
In some situations, information relating to the symbol timing (symbol phases) is not (yet) available at the receiver end and a frequency change impressed at the transmitter end must be detected. In these cases, the decision regarding whether a useful signal is received must be made on the basis of this frequency change. The detected points are then on a horizontal line in the two-dimensional result field, as illustrated in
For example, in the example illustrated in
In the case of pure frequency shift keying (solid line in
For reliable estimation, the period TPER for which estimated results are evaluated and the FSK symbol duration of the (FSK) frequency modulation TFSK are (approximately) matched to one another. In the example illustrated in
For example, in the example illustrated in
Estimations which are based on frequencies in the transition ranges do not result in useful signal recognition because the difference Δζ′<ΔζSW is too small, that is to say in terms of absolute value. These estimations are therefore discarded or ignored. If a useful signal is detected, the frequency estimations have not been obtained on the basis of input signals with frequencies in the transition ranges. Basically, this means that the subsequent reception steps (for example further signal acquisition steps and/or demodulation) can use these estimated frequency results with sufficient accuracy to correct the frequency error. The threshold value ΔζSW can be selected such that estimated results based on frequencies in said transition ranges do not result in useful signal recognition during useful signal detection.
Quite generally, it must only be ensured that useful signal detection is carried out only with suitable synchronization of the estimation times tM−5, tM−4, tM−3, tM−2, tM−1, tM (that is to say the times at which an estimated vector θ is determined) with the FSK symbol duration TFSK and is not carried out in said transition ranges. In the example shown in
Two estimated values whose estimation times are (approximately) separated by a complete FSK symbol duration are always used to calculate the difference Δζ (or Δθ). However, the estimation times are separated by less than an FSK symbol duration, by half a symbol duration TFSK/2 in each case in the present example. In the example in
Choosing TPER≤TFSK/2 also means that a test of useful signal detection exists in any case, which test was obtained on the basis of parameter estimations which are completely within a symbol duration of the respective (G)FSK symbol (if not at the time M, then at the time M+1). If TPER>TFSK/2 were selected, there would be transmitting/receiving constellations which carry out useful signal detection only on the basis of estimated results in said transition ranges. This would result in losses in sensitivity, for example.
It is possible to combine the examples from
The above-described methods and system are particularly suitable for use in motor vehicles, in particular for keyless (remote-controlled) access and starting systems of motor vehicles.
Number | Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
10 2013 220 912 | Oct 2013 | DE | national |
Filing Document | Filing Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
PCT/EP2014/070866 | 9/30/2014 | WO | 00 |
Publishing Document | Publishing Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
WO2015/055418 | 4/23/2015 | WO | A |
Number | Name | Date | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
6337855 | Malkamaki | Jan 2002 | B1 |
6614853 | Koslar et al. | Sep 2003 | B1 |
7035352 | Malone et al. | Apr 2006 | B1 |
8971385 | Opitz | Mar 2015 | B2 |
20060154613 | Hamm et al. | Jul 2006 | A1 |
20060182206 | Coon et al. | Aug 2006 | A1 |
20080298515 | Peyla et al. | Dec 2008 | A1 |
20100159861 | Becker | Jun 2010 | A1 |
Number | Date | Country |
---|---|---|
19820836 | Aug 2000 | DE |
10224284 | Dec 2003 | DE |
1679802 | Jul 2006 | EP |
2012069471 | May 2012 | WO |
2012115453 | Aug 2012 | WO |
2015055418 | Apr 2015 | WO |
Entry |
---|
Sadr, Ramin et al., “Generalized Minimum Shift-Keying Modulation Techniques,” IEEE Transactions on Communications, vol. 36, No. 1, pp. 32-40 (9 pages), Jan. 1988. |
Steingass, A. et al., “Frame Synchronization Using Superimposed Sequences,” Information Theory, IEEE International Symposium IUM on ULM, p. 489 (1 page), Jun. 29, 1997. |
Lamarca, Meritxell et al., “DA-GLRT Burst Detection and Sychronization Based on a Chirp-Like Preamble,” 10th International Workshop on Signal Processing for Space Communications (SPSC), 5 pages, Oct. 6, 2008. |
Gabelli, Giulio et al., “Code Acquisition Under Strong Dynamics: The Case of TT&C for LEOP,” 6th Advanced Satellite Multimedia Systems Conference (ASMS) and 12th Signal Processing for Space Communications Workshop (SPSC), pp. 342-349 (8 pages), Sep. 5, 2012. |
German Office Action, Application No. 102013220912.6, 8 pages, dated Mar. 11, 2014. |
International Search Report and Written Opinion, Application No. PCT/EP2014/070866, 25 pages, dated Dec. 17, 2014. |
Roy, Arban, “Overlay Communications Using Empirical Mode Decomposition,” IEEE Systems Journal, vol. 5, No. 1, pp. 121-128, Feb. 18, 2011. |
German Office Action, Application No. 102013220912.6, 6 pages, dated Oct. 30 2017. |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
20160241426 A1 | Aug 2016 | US |