The present invention relates in general to the field of optics and, in particular, to a system and method for the vapor pressure controlled growth of infrared chalcogenide glasses.
Chalcogenide glasses, those containing one or more of the chalcogenide elements sulfur, selenium, or tellurium, are used in a variety of optical applications. Because of their excellent infrared transmittal properties and relatively low production costs, these glasses, especially selenium-based glasses, are commonly used in infrared optical systems, such as thermal imaging and night vision systems.
Currently, most chalcogenide glasses are produced as small boules in sealed quartz reaction containers. This helps minimize the loss of selenium, which is prone to evaporate out of the reaction melt during the glass formation reaction due to its relatively high vapor pressure. However, production processes such as these suffer from high production costs due to the consumption of the quartz reaction containers, long production times, and environmental risks due to possible explosions.
Once the glass is formed, any practical optical application requires that the glass be formed into an optical component, such as a lens. Current production processes for such optics rely mainly on grinding or molding the chalcogenide glass into lenses. These, however, are rather lengthy processes. After the glass is formed from its constituent elements in a quartz reaction container, the glass is cast into a plate and annealed, so as to avoid breakage. The annealed plate is then cut into blanks, which are ground to thickness, edged, and turned or ground into lenses or formed into lenses in a vacuum press. This process can take several days to complete. Furthermore, production volumes are constrained by the size of the mold ovens used to produce the lenses.
The production of chalcogenide lenses is also hampered by the molds used to form the lenses. Molds typically used for such molding are relatively complex, having a large number of parts and requiring measuring and shimming each time the molds are disassembled for cleaning. Because of their high part count, the tolerance stack-up for each mold prevents molds from being built with acceptable tolerances for high yield processes. Furthermore, reassembly of the molds adds much variability to the part tolerance stack-up, as well.
The molds also suffer from a variety of mechanical problems, as various mold components fail due to the high temperatures they are exposed to during casting and molding. Often times threaded fasteners employed in the molds fail or gall at high temperatures. Furthermore, galling and friction with the mold guide pins frequently lead to mold closing failures.
In accordance with the present invention, a system and method for preparing chalcogenide glass are provided. The system comprises a reaction container operable to hold chalcogenide glass constituents during a glass formation reaction, a stirring rod operable to mix the contents of the reaction container, a thermocouple operable to measure the temperature inside the reaction container, and a reaction chamber operable to hold the reaction container. The method comprises placing chalcogenide glass constituents in a reaction container, heating the chalcogenide glass constituents above the melting point of at least one of the constituents, stirring the reaction constituents, maintaining an overpressure of at least one atmosphere over the reaction melt, and quenching the reaction melt to below the chalcogenide glass temperature, such as by pouring the glass into a plate or other desired shape.
A technical advantage of particular embodiments of the present invention includes the ability to produce chalcogenide glasses in large quantities, while minimizing production costs and environmental hazards from production.
Another technical advantage of particular embodiments of the present invention is that the reaction container is not consumed in the chalcogenide production process. Instead, it may be reused for several production cycles, helping to reduce the cost of chalcogenide production.
Yet another technical advantage of particular embodiments of the present invention is a reduction in the possibility of a runaway reaction that could lead to an explosion that could have both commercial and environmental consequences.
Other technical advantages will be readily apparent to one skilled in the art from the following figures, descriptions and claims. Moreover, while specific advantages have been enumerated above, various embodiments may include all, some, or none of the enumerated advantages.
For a more complete understanding of the invention, and for further features and advantages, reference is now made to the following description, taken in conjunction with the accompanying drawings, in which:
With respect to ternary and quaternary glasses based upon selenium, such as Ge—Sb—Se and/or Ge—Sn—Sb—Se, care must be taken to minimize selenium loss due to evaporation. In accordance with the present invention, one or more of five controlling factors may be used to minimize selenium loss: overpressure, melt surface baffling, a hot-wall reaction vessel, heat balance control during phase changes, and reaction control by mixing rate control. Other methods to minimize selenium loss may also be used within the teachings of the present invention.
In
These constituents, referred to collectively as reaction melt 21, are mixed by stirring rod 16 within reaction container 10. In accordance with a particular embodiment of the present invention, the temperature of reaction melt 21 may be monitored by melt thermocouple 17, or by other methods such as an optical pyrometer or by fluorescence decay optical sensors.
In addition to providing adequate mixing, stirring rod 16 is also used to control the rate of reaction within the reaction melt 21. During glass formation, several temperature spikes are developed in response to the evolved heat of reaction. As these spikes are detected by melt thermocouple 17, the rotation rate of stirring rod 16 is reduced by an appropriate amount to arrest the rate of the temperature increase.
Particular embodiments of the reaction container also feature valve arm 18. Valve arm 18 features a wing-type or shear-type valve device. Unlike a ball-type valve, which could introduce air pockets to the molten glass, a wing-type or shear-type valve slides from side-to-side to open and close the valve. This prevents the introduction of air pockets and facilitates precision metering of glass. Furthermore, as valve arm 18 couples with reaction container 10 to seal valve 19 against hole 22, the valve arm 18, valve seat 19, and reaction container 10 are typically constructed from similar materials to minimize thermal expansion effects, and valve seal 19 and the surface surrounding the hole 22 are ground flat and smooth to function as a liquid tight seal.
As mentioned above, a variety of measures are taken to reduce the loss of selenium or other volatile constituents out of reaction melt 21 due to evaporation, in various embodiments of the present invention. One such measure is the maintenance of an overpressure of at least one atmosphere over reaction melt 21 in space 20. In a particular embodiment, this is accomplished by introducing an inert gas, such as nitrogen, helium, or argon, into reaction container 10 and maintaining a pressure higher than the vapor pressure of the most volatile constituent. In this embodiment, the most volatile constituent is selenium.
The mass transfer of selenium (or other volatile constituents) may also be controlled at the surface of reaction melt 21 by mass boundary layer 15. Similar to a liquid encapsulation reaction (LER), mass boundary layer affects molecular streaming, diffusion, and convection over the reaction melt 21, serving as a physical barrier to the transfer of selenium out of reaction melt 21. One method of establishing such a layer is by introducing a non-reactive material, such as boron oxide (B2O3), that has a melting point lower than the boiling point of selenium and a density lower than that of selenium. Another method is to introduce quartz plates over the reaction melt 21, either floating on the melt surface or placed at the top of reaction container 10.
Another method for minimizing selenium loss employed by particular embodiments of the reaction apparatus is the use of hot-wall reaction chamber 11. The use of hot-wall reaction chamber 11 allows the glass formation to take place under isothermal conditions and prevents the walls of reaction chamber 11 from serving as condensation areas for selenium vapors that escape from reaction melt 21. Reaction chamber 11 can also be lined with materials that are chemically inert to selenium, including a nickel-chromium-iron alloy, such as Inconel®, to prevent selenium loss due to any reactions with the walls of reaction chamber 11 that could form metal selenides. In addition, reaction chamber 11 may be externally heated, prolonging heater life and reducing production costs.
Yet another way selenium loss is minimized in particular embodiments of the reaction apparatus is by using heat balance control during phase changes within reaction melt 21. As mentioned earlier, there are various exothermic effects during glass formation that result in abrupt temperature increases.
First, the selenium sintering temperature spike, spike 181, is exploited to increase the heating rate and bring the temperature quickly above the selenium melting point.
The crystallization temperature spike, spike 182, is detected by monitoring the time derivative of the temperature reported by melt thermocouple 17 near the temperature at which the spike begins (approximately 500° C. at 2 atm). During the upward temperature surge, the heater power is reduced. The size of the temperature spike 182 is also reduced by using large pieces of Sb, thus presenting a smaller reaction interface to the Se melt (larger pieces have less surface area per volume than smaller pieces). This is illustrated in
Once the temperature begins to fall after temperature spike 182, the heater power is restored to remelt the solidified material. Complete remelting is then detected by monitoring the rotation of and/or torque applied to stirring rod 16. When stirring rod 16 rotates freely inside reaction melt 21, its rotation rate is increased to a maximum value to mix reaction melt 21 and promote the glass formation reaction.
In response to the small temperature spikes due to the heat of reaction of Ge with the rest of the elements in reaction melt 21, spikes 183, the mixing rate of stirring rod 16 is also adjusted. As these temperature spikes 183 are detected by melt thermocouple 17, the rotation rate of stirring rod 16 is reduced by an appropriate amount to at least partially arrest the rapid temperature increase.
Once the glass formation reaction is complete and no more temperature ripples are observed, the heater power is reduced and reaction melt 21 is brought down to an acceptable pouring temperature (i.e., a temperature where the glass is easily poured yet does not splatter). After reaction melt 21 has adequately cooled, valve arm 18 is released, pouring the liquid glass through valve 19 where it is allowed to continue to cool. Pouring the glass into another container at a lower temperature facilitates a rapid temperature change, thus quenching the material.
Various chalcogenide glasses can be made using an apparatus such as that described in
In reacting these constituents to form a chalcogenide glass, the elemental constituents are loaded into a quartz reaction container. Typically, the constituents are layered in the reaction container from top to bottom as follows: Sb, Se, Ge, Se, and Sn (if applicable). Notice that the layer of Ge is disposed between two layers of Se, the two layers dividing between them the total weight of selenium in the reaction melt.
The constituent layers are comprised of various size particles, depending on the elemental constituent. These particle sizes, as well as the amount of each elemental constituents used in each layer in both 5 kg and 10 kg batches, are shown in the table below.
Of course, these tables, and their associated descriptions herein, are provided for illustration and example only. Other chalcogenide glasses have different compositions and reaction conditions. It will be recognized by those of ordinary skill in the art that various techniques may be employed in implementing the process disclosed herein, varying with glass compositions and reaction conditions.
An example of how an apparatus such as that shown in
This process begins with a vacuum bakeout in block 202. In the vacuum bakeout, the walls of the reaction chamber are heated to a predetermined temperature set point, such as 100° C., and the chamber is pumped down to a vacuum, such as a pressure of 100 mTorr or less. This process may be aided by conducting multiple pump and nitrogen backfills, which help to reduce the amount of oxygen and water vapor in the chamber.
Once the temperature indicated by the melt thermocouple is sufficiently warm (e.g., in this example 60° C.), a first heating stage is started in block 203. In this first heating stage, the chamber wall temperature is set to temperature sufficient to initiate Se sintering, and the nitrogen pressure is set to provide an overpressure of at least one atmosphere. In this example, a wall temperature set point of 250° C. and a nitrogen pressure set point of approximately 1520 Torr (or 2 atm) are used. These conditions are maintained for 150 minutes, until the first exothermic reaction temperature spike, due to Se sintering, is detected in block 204.
After the first temperature spike, a second heating stage begins in block 205. In this second heating stage the reaction chamber set point is set to a temperature sufficient to initiate the Sb2Se3 crystallization reaction, such as 580° C., which results in a second temperature spike (due to the Sb2Se3 crystallization) in block 206.
After the second temperature spike is detected, the reaction chamber set point is set a temperature sufficient to initiate the Ge reaction in a third heating stage in block 207. In this example, 725° C. is used.
Block 208 then confirms that the temperature spikes are complete. This assurance is provided when the melt temperature has reached 675° C., or some other predetermined temperature near the desired temperature set point, and the melt thermocouple ramp rate is sufficiently low, such as less than 1.0° C./min.
The reaction melt is then mixed with a stirring rod to assure adequate mixing. Mixing is controlled by adjusting the rotation rate of the stirring rod. At high rotation rates the glass reaction rate may be too high, resulting in an increase in the temperature of the reaction melt due to the exothermic heat of reaction. This could potentially increase the Se vapor pressure, resulting in substantial Se loss. Therefore, the mixing rate is closely controlled.
As part of this close control, the stirring rate is slowly increased in block 209 (e.g., 1 RPM every 5 minutes), but only if the melt ramp rate is still sufficiently low, such as less than 1.1° C./min, and only if the melt thermocouple doesn't indicate a significant temperature increase (e.g., the melt temperature stays below 700° C.). This is done until the stirring rate reaches 60 RPM in block 210.
Once block 210 confirms that the stirring rod has reached 60 RPM, the reaction melt is stirred at 60 RPM for 120 minutes in block 211. After 120 minutes, the stirring rod is slowed to 20 RPM in block 212 by reducing the stirring rate 1 RPM every 10 seconds until a stirring rate of 20 RPM is achieved.
The reaction chamber set point is then set to 0° C. in block 213. Once the melt temperature approaches the appropriate pour temperature (e.g., within 20° C. of the pour temperature), the mixture is allowed to further cool for a specified time, for example 5 minutes, while being stirred to ensure its homogeneity, before it is poured in block 214. For LCG111, the appropriate pour temperature is 560° C., but, of course, this temperature is composition dependent. To prevent crystallization, and at the same time allow the melt to flow and fill the receiving container, the glass may be poured into a heated mold or tray, which in this example is kept at a temperature of approximately 250° C. Otherwise, the glass may simply be poured into any shape of interest.
Following pouring, the process continues to cooldown in block 215. During this time the reaction chamber set point remains at room temperature and the pressure set point remains at 1520 Torr. These conditions are maintained for approximately 60 minutes. After approximately 60 minutes, the material may be slow cooled using heater power to minimize stress as the glass cools through the glass transition temperature, after that all contactors are turned off, and the glass is allowed to free cool in block 216, before the process terminates in block 217.
Once the chalcogenide glass has been formed, the glass may be cast, molded, or machined into shape.
To provide precise control of the centering and perpendicularity, mold halves 40 and 41 also feature circumferential tapers 401a and 401b and shoulders 402a and 402b that mate to properly align the mold halves 40 and 41. Tapers 401a and 401b ensure proper optical alignment for centering, while shoulders 402a and 402b ensure the perpendicularity of the lenses formed. Unless properly centered and perpendicular, the lenses produced by the molds will have limited uses in optical applications. Therefore, tapers 401a and 401b and shoulders 402a and 402b assure proper lens geometry by controlling centering and perpendicularity when the mold closes.
The mold assembly also features a circumferential, shaped reservoir 403 located between lens-shaped cavity 406 and tapers 401a and 401b. This shaped reservoir 403 prevents the flow of molten glass from lens-shaped cavity 406 back into the locating tapers 401a and 401b, and yet allows enough glass to be dispensed into the mold assembly to ensure that the mold is adequately filled. Reservoir 403 also features vertical surface 405, which further helps to prevent molten glass from flowing into the locating tapers 401a and 401b by presenting a surface that is more difficult to climb (relative to the tapered surface 404 located below).
Located at the base of circumferential reservoir 403, between the reservoir 403 and the lens-shaped cavity 406 is flash gap 47. As the name implies, flash gap 47 is a small gap between the area of the mold assembly that forms the lens and circumferential reservoir 403. This gap allows molten glass to flow from lens-shaped cavity 406 up into reservoir 403. Flash gap 47 also helps provide an edge detail on the lens formed by the mold assembly. As flash gap 47 provides only a narrow passage way between the lens face of the mold and reservoir 403, upon cooling, the glass in flash gap 47 suffers a stress fracture along the gap. This leaves an edge detail on the lens formed by the mold assembly. This edge detail can be useful in the mounting of the lens.
The mold assembly also,features a plurality of pins and springs located between the two mold halves 40 and 41, operable to hold the mold halves open for casting. These are illustrated by pins 42a and 42b, and spring 44a coupled with pin 42a (additional springs and pins may be included, but are not illustrated in this figure). In
Mold half 40 also features plurality of inlet holes, illustrated by inlet hole 43. Although not illustrated in this figure, other inlet holes may also be included (see inlet holes 33a–33c in
As shown in
Mold half 41 also features a plurality of mold handling holes, illustrated by mold handling holes 45a and 45b (other mold handling holes may be included, but are not illustrated). These shallow pin holes allow for the automated handling of the mold assembly, especially under high temperature conditions. Mold handling holes 45a and 45b could also accommodate a thermocouple, in addition to serving a mold handling purpose.
The two-piece mold design described above offers several technical advantages. One such advantage is that it uses far fewer parts than previous molds. Some previous molds used as many as 92 different parts. The two-piece design significantly lowers that part count.
Another technical advantage of particular embodiments of the mold is the ability to machine all the critical surfaces of the mold, including the lens faces, lens edges, taper, and shoulder in one setup of a diamond point turning (DPT) lathe. This results in the ability to control the centering and perpendicularity of the lens without any appreciable tolerance stack-up.
The simple tooling is also easy to disassemble and clean in an aqueous system. Furthermore, the lack of any blind, small, or trapped holes prevents the trapping of fluid during cleaning. The design also does not require the use of fasteners, which could fail after several high temperature process cycles.
Additionally, the two-piece design is also smaller and lighter than previous molds, resulting in a mold having less thermal mass.
However, to take advantage of these benefits and yet consistently produce quality lenses, the construction material of the mold assembly must be chosen carefully. As the chalcogenide lens and mold expand and contract as they are heated and cooled, it is important to select a mold material that has a coefficient of thermal expansion similar to that of the chalcogenide glass being formed. Otherwise, as the lens and mold expand and contract at different rates, the lens could potentially be damaged. One example of such a mold material that has an acceptable coefficient of thermal expansion is hardened 420 stainless steel. As liquid chalcogenide glass can erode tool steel up to ⅛ inch deep in one casting cycle, the hardened 420 stainless steel mold may be coated with a surface coating that can protect the mold surfaces, and yet not degrade the optical surfaces of the lens. An example of such a coating that works well with hardened 420 stainless steel is titanium nitride (TiN). Additional protection may be supplied by coating the mold with a mold release compound, such as Kisscote 1086™.
Of course, even with these materials, it is still typical in the molding and casting of lenses to cast a lens with a slightly different shape than that which is ultimately desired. This is done to compensate for shrinkage and distortion of the lens as it cools so that the ultimate product has the exact optical qualities desired.
A clamp assembly may also be added to the mold assembly to hold the mold open for casting and closed for molding. Such a clamp assembly is illustrated in
One technical advantage of molds such as those illustrated in
The construction of mold chamber 70 and casting chamber 71 also offers several benefits. Both mold chamber 70 and casting chamber 71 feature a hot wall construction. This results in a lower thermal mass, uniform heating, longer heater life, and minimum volatile condensation on the interior walls of mold chamber 70 and casting chamber 71. The construction of mold chamber 70 is also easily scalable, which allows the capacity of the automated casting system to be increased by simply increasing the length-of mold chamber 70.
Separating mold chamber 70 and casting chamber 71 is pressure isolation valve 72. Separating mold chamber 70 and casting chamber 71 with pressure isolation valve 72 allows the two chambers to be loaded, evacuated, and heated independently. During casting, however, pressure isolation valve 72 is open, allowing molds to be moved from mold chamber 70 to casting chamber 71 to be filled with liquid chalcogenide glass.
Molds are loaded into mold chamber 70 through loading stations 76b. Once inside mold chamber 70, the molds are moved through the chamber in a closed loop. This is accomplished by mold pushers 74a–75b. Mold pushers 74a and 74b work in concert to move the molds in one plane, while mold pushers 75a and 75b work in concert to move the molds in another, perpendicular plane.
A better understanding of the operation of the automated casting system is available from
The automated casting system shown in
Open molds are loaded in mold chamber 80 on 3-by-1 trays through loading stations 86b. As with the molds, the choice of a tray material is also important (though to a lesser extent), as the trays tend to gall and degrade after repeated exposure to the extreme temperatures inside the mold chamber. Therefore, the trays are constructed of a material able to withstand repeated exposure to these temperatures without prematurely degrading. One such material that has proven adequate for this purpose is H13, a hardenable stainless steel alloy, although other materials may be used as well.
Once the trays of molds are loaded into the mold chamber, the trays are then moved counter-clockwise through mold chamber 80 by mold pushers 84a–85b. Mold pushers 84a–84b work in concert to move the trays in one plane, while mold pushers 85a–85b work in concert to move the trays in another, perpendicular plane. Although other mechanisms, such as belts, rollers, or walking beams, may be used to move the molds within the mold chamber, the four-point pusher system of mold pushers 84a–85b offers the added benefits of reduced costs and enhanced scalability.
Once the molds reach the end of mold chamber 80 adjacent to casting chamber 81, transport arm 87 reaches through casting chamber 81 and pressure isolation valve 82 to grab a single mold. This mold is then brought back through pressure isolation valve 82 into casting chamber 81, where it is filled with liquid chalcogenide glass. Once filled, the mold is then returned to its tray inside mold chamber 80.
After casting, the molds continue to move in the closed loop in mold chamber 80. At the end of mold chamber 80 opposite casting chamber 81, the filled molds are closed by mold press 88. The molds continue along the closed loop until all molds are closed. Once close, the molds are allowed to cool until they are cool enough to be removed.
Beneath casting tray 94 is dump tray 95. Dump tray 95 helps prevent any system damage due to casting failures. In the event of such a casting failure, dump tray 95 serves as a collection point for any excess chalcogenide glass, protecting the rest of the machine from the glass, which could potentially damage the machine and would require an extensive clean-up before any further production runs could be completed. The mold lift mechanism supports the mold during casting, and supports the dump tray. A loadcell within the lift mechanism senses changes in weight of the dumptray and the mold. The loadcell is used to measure the amount of glass dispensed into a mold. The loadcell is also used to measure the amount of glass dispensed during practice dispenses, into the dump tray before casting into molds. The dispense algorithm determines the amount of time the dispense valve is to be opened. The valve open time for the next dispense is adjusted based on analysis of the several previous dispense weights and times. The loadcell also senses any leakage from the melt chamber to allow early intervention.
Dump tray 95 is also useful in learning to dispense molten glass into the molds in casting chamber 91. As the viscosity of molten chalcogenide glass is very sensitive to temperature changes, the flow characteristics of the glass can change during casting. Therefore, it is often useful to practice and/or calibrate the dispensing of molten glass by pouring onto dump tray 95 instead of into a mold.
As mentioned above, a mold press may be used to close the molds after casting.
A process for using an automated casting system similar to that shown in
Empty molds are prepared in step 113, including coating the mold surfaces with a mold release compound. These prepared molds are then loaded into the mold chamber in step 114.
The mold chamber undergoes a vacuum bakeout at approx 100° C. and 3 mTorr to reduce the oxygen (O2) and water vapor (H2O) concentrations within the chamber to below 100 ppm and 500 ppm, respectively, and then the chamber and molds are heated to a temperature above the melting temperature of the chalcogenide glass, typically 300° C., all in step 115. Glass is then cast into the molds in step 116. After the molds have been filled with liquid chalcogenide glass, the molds are closed by the mold press in step 117.
Following pressing, the mold chamber and casting chamber are cooled in step 118, during which time the power to the heater is reduced, typically cooling the chamber to approximately 200° C. Cooling rates are controlled with heater power to minimize thermal stress on the hot wall chambers, and to reduce stress in the glass as it cools through the glass transition temperature. At lower temperatures (step 119) the cooling rate is accelerated by force cooling the heaters and mold chamber and casting chamber. In this process, forced air is blown between the heaters and the walls of the chambers to speed their cooling.
After the molds have adequately cooled, the molds are removed from the mold chamber in step 120, and the lenses are removed from the molds in step 121. Afterwards, the molds and melt chamber are cleaned in step 122, in preparation for another run when the production cycle restarts in step 111.
Although embodiments of the invention and their advantages are described in detail, a person skilled in the art could make various alterations, additions, and omissions without departing from the spirit and scope of the present invention as defined by the appended claims.
Number | Name | Date | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
2306789 | McNamara | Dec 1942 | A |
2804378 | Upton | Aug 1957 | A |
2871624 | Upton | Feb 1959 | A |
2887359 | Gans | May 1959 | A |
3209641 | Upton | Oct 1965 | A |
3214241 | Forber et al. | Oct 1965 | A |
3451794 | Patterson | Jun 1969 | A |
3656924 | Chapman et al. | Apr 1972 | A |
3663192 | Perry | May 1972 | A |
3743492 | Ogita | Jul 1973 | A |
3773529 | Plumat | Nov 1973 | A |
3883340 | French et al. | May 1975 | A |
4542108 | Susman et al. | Sep 1985 | A |
4747864 | Hagerty et al. | May 1988 | A |
4778505 | Hirota et al. | Oct 1988 | A |
5098460 | Omi et al. | Mar 1992 | A |
5171347 | Monji et al. | Dec 1992 | A |
5173100 | Shigyo et al. | Dec 1992 | A |
5273567 | Richards | Dec 1993 | A |
5329406 | Nakanishi et al. | Jul 1994 | A |
5346523 | Sugai et al. | Sep 1994 | A |
5766294 | Takagi et al. | Jun 1998 | A |
6634189 | Hudgens et al. | Oct 2003 | B1 |
6668588 | Hilton et al. | Dec 2003 | B1 |
6800574 | Anderson | Oct 2004 | B1 |
20030007203 | Amon et al. | Jan 2003 | A1 |
20030029332 | Matsuzuki et al. | Feb 2003 | A1 |
20040040837 | McTeer et al. | Mar 2004 | A1 |
20040079114 | Aitken et al. | Apr 2004 | A1 |
20040141241 | Claytor | Jul 2004 | A1 |
20040206119 | Syllaios et al. | Oct 2004 | A1 |
20040206121 | Autery et al. | Oct 2004 | A1 |
20040206122 | Autery et al. | Oct 2004 | A1 |
Number | Date | Country |
---|---|---|
296427 | Jul 1990 | DE |
0250091 | Dec 1987 | EP |
0378292 | Jul 1990 | EP |
62059534 | Mar 1987 | JP |
01157424 | Jun 1989 | JP |
01290537 | Nov 1989 | JP |
03131537 | Jun 1991 | JP |
05132325 | May 1993 | JP |
05345622 | Dec 1993 | JP |
06024766 | Feb 1994 | JP |
06092652 | Apr 1994 | JP |
08188424 | Jul 1996 | JP |
2002128533 | May 2002 | JP |
2002187727 | Jul 2002 | JP |
WO 0230837 | Apr 2002 | WO |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
20040206119 A1 | Oct 2004 | US |