System for Converting Electromagnetic Radiation to Electrical Energy Using Metamaterials

Abstract

Spectral tuning of heat source to emit radiation at a desired frequency or frequency band is accomplished using metamaterials. The metamaterials include a structured geometry having holes with dimensions and spacing chosen such that the resulting surface will emit radiation in the desired spectrum. A collector can be made of a similar metamaterial or antenna array to detect the emitted radiation and transfer it to a converter device that converts the detected radiation to electricity. Embodiments also provide efficient coupling to the converter device for energy harvesting. Cooling of the converter devices can be accomplished using a cooling sink or deep space.

Description

BACKGROUND

1. Field of the Invention

Embodiments of the present invention relate generally to structures and methods for harvesting energy from electromagnetic radiation and, more specifically, to nanostructures, metamaterials and related methods and systems for harvesting energy from, for example, infrared, near infrared and visible spectrums and capturing millimeter waves and Terahertz energy.

2. Background of the Invention

There is a great need for inexpensive renewable energy in the world right now. Ironically, there is an abundance of energy available in the form of sunlight and heat but using it to support the needs of society requires it to be converted into electrical form. Most electrical energy used today comes from a conversion process involving heat. Nuclear, coal, diesel, and natural gas powered electrical generation plants all convert stored forms of energy into heat for conversion into electricity. Processes in these plants are inefficient and often produce more heat as waste than is converted into electricity.

Harvesting sources of heat into usable electrical power is especially desirable at low cost. The cost of turbine based solutions is well established at this point. As a result, new technological solutions for converting heat to electrical power enter a relatively mature environment. Because of the need and the fixed pricing environment, new technologies are beginning to address this area. These new technologies include thermo photovoltaic (TPV), thermoelectric (TE) and organic rankine cycle (ORC) systems.

TPV technology has encountered difficulties with heat conversion applications since photovoltaic (PV) converts short wave radiation, not the long waves found in the infrared (IR) and near IR spectra associated with heat. New micron gap methods for bringing such long wave energy to the PV cell still require conversion technology better suited to this influx of long wave radiation. The PV cell band gap favors only energetic photons since lower energy photons do not have the energy to surmount the gap and end up absorbed, thereby causing heat in the PV cell.

Thermoelectric has only been able to convert heat to electrical power at low efficiency. To date, TE applications for converting heat to electricity has been unable to provide substantial efficiencies in energy conversion. Despite these hurdles, TE has been used in automotive waste heat recovery, which further demonstrates the need for alternative heat-to-electric conversion technologies.

Organic Rankine Cycle technology harvests waste heat by chaining turbines together with heat exchangers each with a lower boiling point liquid in its system. Unfortunately, ORC systems are bulky and have large numbers of moving parts. They are also limited to the properties of the liquids and ultimately the limit of time, space and marginal results of additional systems in a working space.

BRIEF SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION

The technology of surfaces of paired nanoantenna and diode arrays present tremendous advantages for energy harvesting applications. In the area of waste heat recovery these systems are ideal since they have no moving parts, are inexpensive to manufacture and can be tuned to the frequency spectra of the target source. The ability to tune the collecting elements of the system to the spectral properties of the source make these technologies ideal not only for waste heat applications but for heat harvesting in general and, ultimately, solar energy harvesting as well.

Embodiments described herein involve a method for tuning to the spectral properties of a heat source using metamaterial designs. The combination of collector and source tuning make this a powerful method for harvesting energy from a variety of sources. Beyond tuning of source and collecting elements, embodiments described herein use methods that enable thermal energy to be efficiently coupled into nanostructures for energy harvesting.

In embodiments, a metamaterial device acts as converter between propagating and localized electromagnetic fields, providing an effective route to couple photons into the antenna-based energy harvesters. This structure can exceed the black body radiation limit. The collector array components of these systems are called Nanoantenna Electromagnetic Collectors (NEC).

Various nanostructure-based metamaterial surface treatments have been developed to enhance energy capture from thermal heat sources. Metamaterial layers tune the thermal emissions of a hot body to radiate energy in the channels optimized for high efficiency energy conversion. Methods are demonstrated for affordable, large-scale fabrication of the device.

Embodiments of the present invention also include systems and methods to harvest electromagnetic radiation from far-field plane waves, to harvest EM radiation from near-field evanescent and/or plasmonic waves, and to harvest electromagnetic radiation using a combination of far- and near-field effects. Systems and apparatus for energy capture and concentration include resonant antenna structures and metamaterial films. Systems and apparatus for energy conversion include various types of rectification processes integrated with the antenna device, which is also referred to herein as a rectenna. Energy conversion apparatus and methods include, but are not limited to: metal-insulator-metal (MIM), metal-insulator-insulator-metal (MIIM), and Traveling Wave Diode (TWD) diode devices.

In an embodiment, the present invention is an energy harvesting system that includes resonant elements tuned to frequencies in the range of available radiant energy. Typically, such frequencies are in the frequency range from approximately 10 THz, in the infrared, to over 1000 THz (visible light). In an embodiment, these resonant elements are composed of electrically conductive material, and coupled with a transfer element. The transfer element converts stimulated electrical energy in the resonant element to direct current, to form resonant and transfer element pairs. In an embodiment, the resonant element and transfer element pairs are arranged into arrays that are embedded in a substrate and interconnected to form a power source, for example, for an electrical circuit or other apparatus or device requiring sourced electrical energy to operate. Additional details for resonant and transfer elements of embodiments are described in U.S. patent application Ser. No. 13/708,481, filed Dec. 7, 2012, entitled, “System and Method for Converting Electromagnetic Radiation to Electrical Energy,” (U.S. Pat. App. Pub. No. US 2013/0146117) (the “'481 application”), U.S. patent application Ser. No. 14/108,138, filed Dec. 16, 2013, entitled, “System and Method for Identifying Materials Using a THz Spectral Fingerprint in a Media with High Water Content” (U.S. Pat. Pub. No. U.S. 2014/0172374) (the “'138 application”), and U.S. patent application Ser. No. 14/187,175, filed Feb. 21, 2014, entitled, “Structures, System and Method for Converting Electromagnetic Radiation to Electrical Energy” (copy attached to U.S. Provisional App. 62/015,121 as Appendix A, which is hereby incorporated by reference herein in its entirety) (the “'175 application”), each of which is hereby incorporated by reference herein in its entirety.

In addition to the resonant and transfer elements described above, in an embodiment, the surface of the material is modified to be a metamaterial. The metamaterial enables the surface to radiate energy that matches the spectrum of the NEC components that will harvest it. In an embodiment, the metamaterial comprises a grid of holes of specific depth, area, and spacing. These holes produce an artificial surface resonance at a specific frequency. This operation is similar to surface plasmons on metal surfaces. The electromagnetic field is concentrated over the holes where NEC devices may be placed. Furthermore, the energy available for harvesting is most concentrated in the near field, which is defined as the region within the light wavelength from the surface. In one embodiment, a NEC is placed 3 μm above each hole and the surface and NEC are tuned to 1 THz. In another embodiment, a NEC is placed in the near-field over each hole at less than 0.5 wavelengths of the specific frequency that causes surface resonance. In embodiments, a NEC is placed over some, but not all of the holes. In an embodiment, the specific dimensions of holes and hole placement are determined by computer simulations based on the Maxwell's equations describing the interaction between light and material. For example, in an embodiment, hole spacing is 50 μm, hole diameter is 10 μm and hole depth is 40 μm. The simulation software used was COMSOL available from COMSOL, Inc. and Lumerical, available from Lumerical Solutions, Inc.

In an embodiment, components, elements and substrate of the device are composed of metals and materials that allow them to be manufactured in low cost methods such as roll-to-roll.

In an embodiment, the present invention is a system to convert heat into electricity that includes a metamaterial having a surface that is tuned to generate an enhanced electric field at a desired frequency and a rectenna placed over the enhanced electric field, at a distance to interact with the generated electric field, and to produce electricity from the generated electric field. In an embodiment, the surface of the metamaterial comprises a plurality of holes with dimensions and spacing to cause the surface to generate the enhanced electric field at the desired frequency, and wherein a rectenna is placed over each hole. In another embodiment, the surface of the metamaterial comprises a plurality of posts with dimensions and spacing to cause the surface to generate the enhanced electric field at the desired frequency.

BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

FIG. 1A is a graph of electric field at the surface of a metal supporting surface plasmon resonance

FIG. 1B is a graph of electric field strength as a function of distance above and below the surface in the metal.

FIG. 2 is a graph illustrating the local density of states versus frequency at different heights above a semi-infinite sample of aluminum.

FIG. 3 is a graph illustrating the emitted energy, at various distances from the surface of a metal, per unit volume per unit frequency across a wide spectrum of frequencies.

FIGS. 4A and 4B illustrate the inter-relationship of elements of one metamaterial structure that generates plasmonic resonance on the surface of a metal.

FIGS. 5A and 5B illustrate a cross sectional view of the metamaterial structure elements.

FIGS. 6A and 6B illustrate a 3-dimensional view of electric field strength simulation results for a rectenna placed near one of the holes in the surface of a metamaterial.

FIG. 7 is a cross sectional view of a metamaterial structure with a rectenna placed at the structure aperture.

FIG. 8 illustrates a cross sectional view of a system that can harvest the earth's heat.

FIG. 9 illustrates a 3-dimensional view of the system of FIG. 8.

FIG. 10 illustrates an embodiment in which THz sources are matched up with THz sensors to provide electrical output carried via an electrical bus to provide power to an electrical device.

DETAILED DESCRIPTION

The following description is presented to enable one of ordinary skill in the art to make and use the invention and is provided in the context of a patent application and its requirements. Various modifications to the described embodiments will be readily apparent to those skilled in the art and the generic principles herein may be applied to other embodiments. Thus, the present invention is not intended to be limited to the embodiments shown but is to be accorded the widest scope consistent with the principles and features described herein.

FIG. 1A is a graph of electric field at the surface of a metal supporting surface plasmon resonance. FIG. 1B is a graph of electric field strength as a function of distance above and below the surface in the metal where δ_d is the distance above the surface, and δ_m is the distance below the surface. FIG. 2 is a graph showing the local density of states versus frequency at different heights above a semi-infinite sample of aluminum. The local density of states represents the number of available photon states and the larger local density of states naturally enables higher optical power density. FIG. 2 shows the local density of states is strongly enhanced at the surface plasmon frequency and this means strongly enhanced optical power density may be achieved at that frequency. The surface plasmon frequency of metal is not engineerable. It is thus necessary to adopt the metamaterial concept which allows us to design an artificially structured surface whose surface plasmon frequency can be tuned. FIG. 3 is a graph of the emitted energy, at various distances from the surface of a metamaterial designed to exhibit surface plasmon modes at 1 THz, per unit volume per unit frequency across a wide spectrum of frequencies. It shows strongly enhanced optical energy density at the surface plasmon frequency.

FIGS. 1A, 1B, 2, and 3 demonstrate that a metamaterial can be engineered to generate an electric field having an enhanced field strength at a resonant frequency that is tunable. As described below, in embodiments, a metamaterial is designed to exhibit resonance, and therefore an enhanced electric field, in the presence of frequencies associated with heat. A rectenna is placed in the electric field to convert the energy in the electric filed to electricity. In an embodiment, a rectenna is a device having antenna elements responsive to the electric field and a transfer to device such as a MIM or MIIM diode that converts the radiated energy from the antenna elements to electricity.

FIGS. 4A and 4B are schematic diagrams of an exemplary metamaterial structure at the surface of a hot object 408. Holes 401 are fabricated in surface 405 using lithographic and etching methods known to those skilled in the art. In an embodiment, the size (or area) of holes 401, represented by dimensions 402 (length) and 403 (width), the spacing 406 between holes 401, and the depth 407 of holes 401 are determined by simulation of electromagnetic waves incident on hot surface 405 and elements of structure 408 so that the metamaterial surface supports a strong surface resonance at or near a desired frequency. In embodiments, the desired frequency is 1 THz. An exemplary such surface resonance near 1 THz is illustrated in FIGS. 2 and 3. In an embodiment, for example, the simulation numerically solves Maxwell's equations with a given geometry. FIG. 4B shows an exemplary geometry used for 3-dimensional simulations in a particular embodiment. In the embodiment, the hole has surface dimensions a and b, to represent width and length respectively. Where dimensions a and b are equal, i.e., the hole is square, resonant frequency can be approximated by:

${\omega }_{\mathrm{pl}}=\frac{\pi c_0}{a\sqrt{{\varepsilon }_H{\mu }_H}}$

where ω_pl is the effective plasmon resonant frequency, c₀ is the speed of light, a is the size of the holes, ε_h is the electric permittivity and μ_h is the magnetic permeability of the material.

Electromagnetic waves such as light exhibit polarization. Various states of polarization can occur from environmental/material boundary conditions that induce scatter and absorption. Metamaterials can be designed to respond and extract energy from various modes of polarization. For example, if dimensions a and b are not equal, i.e., the hole is rectangular, the metamaterial becomes anisotropic and exhibits difference responses to different polarizations. Similarly in an embodiment, spacing d in the x direction may be different than spacing d in the y direction. Where spacing d is different in the x and y directions, the metamaterial becomes anisotropic and exhibits difference responses to different polarizations.

FIGS. 5A and 5B illustrate an exemplary geometry used for a 2-dimensional simulation to determine hole dimensions and hole spacing to achieve a desired resonant frequency according to an embodiment. In an embodiment, hole spacing and dimension form a periodic structure of holes 401 in metamaterial 408. As such, the exemplary simulation can be simplified by using a computational cell containing only one unit cell with a periodic boundary condition. For the direction perpendicular to the metamaterial surface, an absorbing boundary condition was used to simulate the infinite extent of the medium. In FIG. 5A, the dimensions are designated by 402, 403, and 407 for length, width, and depth respectively, with a hole spacing 406. In FIG. 5B, the dimensions are designated as a (area of the hole), d (depth of the hole), and p (hole spacing).

In a typical simulation, a plane wave with a fixed wavelength is launched onto the metamaterial surface and the subsequent reflected power is calculated. This simulation is repeated over a range of wavelengths to obtain a reflectance spectrum. The reflectance spectrum should exhibit a dip at the wavelength of surface plasmon resonance. The geometry (dimensions and spacing of the holes) of metamaterial surface is then tuned to shift the resonance dip in the reflectance spectrum into the desired wavelength. Full optimization should also include minimizing the line width and maximizing the depth of the reflection dip because these conditions correspond to the strongest resonance.

In the simulation using the plane wave as described above, the incident wave must couple to the surface wave in order to produce a dip in the reflectance spectrum. This is achieved by the periodicity of the holes which acts as a grating and imparts a momentum necessary for coupling to the surface wave. Specifically, the grating coupling condition is given as:

$\beta =\frac{2\pi }{\lambda }\sin \theta +\frac{2\pi }{\rho }$

where λ, θ, and ρ are the wavelength, incident angle and grating period, respectively. When the propagation constant β matches that of the surface wave, the incident wave will couple to the surface wave, resulting in a dip in the reflectance spectrum.

While coupling occurs whenever this condition is met, the coupling efficiency may vary. Thus some structures may not show prominent reflectance dips even though surface waves do exist. In order to avoid missing surface waves due to poor coupling efficiency, dipole sources are used in the simulation. Dipole sources are basically harmonically oscillating point dipoles. An oscillating point dipole produces an electromagnetic wave emanating isotropically. By placing many point dipole sources on the metamaterial surface coupling into the surface wave is ensured. In this case, the existence of surface wave would be detected by monitoring the electric and magnetic field patterns near the surface. A strong enhancement of field intensity near the surface signifies the presence of surface wave.

Resonances form on the surface of material 408 at the tuned frequency of interest. In an embodiment, this frequency is 1 THz. Materials 408 can be a variety of materials, including, for example, copper, or any other highly conductive material. Other materials may be used if design dimensions are recalculated by simulation as described above. In an embodiment, metamaterial 408 is copper with a thickness of 100 μm. Dimensions for the embodiment are 10 μm for hole length 402, 10 μm for hole width 403, 50 μm for hole spacing 406 and 40 μm for hole depth 407.

FIGS. 6A and 6B illustrate schematically a rectenna 601 placed over a hole 401 with field intensity mapping. Rectenna 601 comprises antenna elements 601a and 601b, and a diode 602. Placing rectenna over a hole 401 in the surface of a metamaterial as shown in FIGS. 6A and 6B is to deliver a concentrated electric field to antenna elements 601 and thereby to diode 602, where harvesting of radiant energy to electricity occurs. Once radiant heat energy is harvested it is carried to a bus structure via leads 603 and 604, and can be used to power electronic devices or to electricity storage facilities. Additional details for rectenna 601 are described in the '481 application, the '138 application and the '175 application.

FIG. 7 illustrates a cross sectional view of a metamaterial 408 with a rectenna 601 that comprises antenna elements 601a and 601b and a diode 602. In the embodiment shown in FIG. 7, hole 401 is filled with a highly insulating material 708. Exemplary highly insulating materials 708 include SUB, Aerogel, air, and vacuum. Material 708 must be insulating but transparent to radiation. Rectenna 601 is set at a distance 703 from the surface of the metamaterial 408. This distance is important since the power of the electric field decreases exponentially with distance from the surface. In one embodiment the distance is at or approximately 3 μm which offers a good balance of thermal insulation and proximity for field strength. In another embodiment, rectenna 601 is placed in the near-field over hole 401 at less than 0.5 wavelengths of the specific frequency that causes surface resonance. In an embodiment with a plurality of holes 401, a rectenna 601 is placed over each hole 401. In an embodiment with a plurality of holes 401, a rectenna is placed over some, but not all, holes 401.

Materials 706 and 707, on top of rectenna 601, conduct heat and couple the rectenna 601 to a cold source 710. Materials 704 and 705, which surround rectenna 601, are insulating to prevent lost heat from the source 701 and serve to guide heat via radiation to rectenna 601.

FIG. 8 illustrated an embodiment of the present invention that is configured to harvest heat from the Earth in the context of the low temperature of deep space. In such embodiment, deep space acts as the cooling source for a rectenna 1101. As shown in FIG. 8, rectenna 1101 is placed in the near field of post metamaterial structure 1104. Post structure 1104 concentrates the electric field, generated by a surface from heat delivered by a terrestrial source (e.g., Earth), and delivers this electric field at a frequency set by the design of the surface metamaterial structures using a simulation as described above. To maximize the Carnot system advantages of this system it is desirable to tune rectenna 1101 to a frequency in a clear band of the Earth's atmosphere. Two such bands are well known: 3 μm to 5 μm and 8 μm to 12 μm. Rectennas tuned in this band will radiate freely with the cold source of deep space and create a system whose Carnot zone is nearly 100% (C=1−Tc/Th; where Tc=3K and Th=300K).

In an embodiment using deep space as a cold source, as shown in FIG. 8, the metamaterial is in the form of a plurality of posts 1104, rather than holes 401, one of which is shown in FIG. 8. In an embodiment, a plurality of posts are placed periodically as described above for holes 401. Post 1104 is surrounded by a heat insulating and radiation transparent material 1103. An exemplary such material 1103 is Aerogel. In another embodiment, material 1103 is replaced with a vacuum to optimize thermal insulation properties. In an embodiment, rectenna 1101 is placed at or approximately 2 μm above post 1104. In another embodiment, a rectenna 1101 is placed in the near-field over post 1104 at less than 0.5 wavelengths of the specific frequency that causes surface resonance. In an embodiment, a rectenna 1101 is placed over some but not all posts 1104. In an embodiment, post 1104 is at least the height of ¼ wavelength of the tuned frequency of rectenna 1101. Post design 1104 allows an element of rectenna 1101 to radiate into space 1106 since it is more than a quarter wavelength away from the surface of the metal. The combination of near proximity to post 1104 and greater than quarter wavelength to the surface metal 1105 allows rectenna 1101 to receive energy from the tuned metamaterial 1104 yet still radiate into deep space 1106.

It is advantageous for the tuned frequency of rectenna 1101 to equal the tuned frequency of the metamaterial 1104 so surface plasmons will deliver energy most efficiently to the rectennas 1101. Also, rectennas 1101 need to be tuned within the clear band regions of the atmosphere.

The system illustrated in FIG. 8 harvests energy as electricity since rectenna 1101 is stimulated into oscillation by terrestrial heat. A source of efficiency in embodiments results from the reflection of energy coming from nearby terrestrial sources that is in the bands outside the clear atmospheric windows. The system needs to reflect away this “out of band” energy for rectenna 1101 to stay cooled by deep space 1106.

This is part of the purpose of environmental overcoat 1102. Environmental overcoat 1102 is heat insulating and radiation transparent in the “in band” wavelengths of the atmosphere, i.e., in the clear band. Directionality is also an important factor in design. Because the system is in contact with the sky, rectennas 1101 need to be pointed toward the sky and not obscured by intervening objects.

FIG. 9 illustrates a plurality of such elements. Metamaterial posts 1104 on surface 1105 create the plasmonic structure that concentrates a plasmonic electric field at the tips of the post structures. Rectennas 1101 are placed in the near field of this structure and tuned for near field resonance at the plasmonic frequency. The tuning of rectenna 1101 must also match a portion of the transparent window in the atmosphere.

If an antenna is substituted for rectenna 1101 in the embodiment illustrated in FIGS. 8 and 9, the system converts heat energy to radiation at the tuned frequency of the antenna. Such a system has significant advantages for use as an inexpensive source of THz radiation. In particular, surfaces covered with THz tuned antennas (matched to tuned metamaterial 1104) generate THz radiation at very low cost. The entire THz range can be generated by covering a surface 1105 with subregions of the surface tuned to subregions of the THz spectrum (both antennas and metamaterials).

FIG. 10 illustrates a system for generating THz radiation according to an embodiment. THz sources layers 1202 are matched up with THz sensors 1204. THz source layers 1202 and THz sensors 1204 can be as those described in the '481 application, the '138 application and the '175 application.

As illustrated in FIG. 10, a heat source 1201 generates heat. A THz source layer 1202 comprises a THz metamaterial and an antenna tuned to THz frequencies. In response to the heat generated by heat source 1201, the metamaterial in THz source layer 1202 generates energy at the tuned THz frequencies. The antenna devices in THz source layer 1202, which are also tuned to the THZ frequencies, radiate THz radiation to THz detectors 1204. THz detectors 1204 respond to the radiated THz radiation to provide electrical output carried via electrical bus 1205 to provide power to an electrical device, for example, a computer 1206, which can include, among other things, for example, digital processing capabilities, storage, and display. In an embodiment, THz sources 1202 are such as described above with respect to the antenna variation described above with respect to FIGS. 8 and 9. This system provides active illuminated THz detection at low cost at standoff distances. Both the THz sources 1202 and detectors 1204 are tunable within the THz range so such a system is highly flexible and deployable to a variety of applications.

Claims

1. A system to convert heat into electricity, comprising: a metamaterial having a surface that is tuned to generate an enhanced electric field at a desired frequency; anda rectenna placed over the enhanced electric field, at a distance to interact with the generated electric field, and to produce electricity from the generated electric field.

2. The system of claim 1, wherein the surface of the metamaterial comprises a plurality of holes with dimensions and spacing to cause the surface to generate the enhanced electric field at the desired frequency, and wherein a rectenna is placed over each hole.

3. The system recited in claim 2, wherein each rectenna is placed in the near field over the holes at less than 0.5 wavelengths of the desired frequency.

4. The system recited in claim 1, wherein the rectenna comprises: an antenna tuned to the desired frequency to interact with the generated electric field to generate an electric current in an antenna element; anda transfer structure to convert the electric current into direct current.

5. The system recited in claim 1, further comprising at least one lead to carry the direct current to power another device or to an electricity storage device.

6. The system recited in claim 1, further comprising a cold source to act as a cold sink to cool the rectenna.

7. The system recited in claim 1, further comprising a thermally insulating and radiation transparent material placed between the surface of the metamaterial and the rectenna.

8. The system recited in claim 7, wherein the rectenna comprises an antenna element, further comprising a thermally conductive material to couple the antenna element to a cold source.

9. The system recited in claim 8, further comprising a thermally insulating material on either side of the thermally conductive material to prevent heat loss from a heat source.

10. The system recited in claim 1, wherein the hole dimensions and spacing form a periodic pattern on the surface of the metamaterial.

11. The system of claim 1, wherein the surface of the metamaterial comprises a plurality of posts with dimensions and spacing to cause the surface to generate the enhanced electric field at the desired frequency.

12. The system recited in claim 11, wherein deep space is used as a cold sink for the rectenna.

13. The system recited in claim 11, wherein the rectenna is placed in the near-field over each post at less than 0.5 wavelengths of the desired frequency.

14. The system recited in claim 11, wherein the post is has a height greater than one quarter of the wavelength of the desired frequency.

15. The system recited in claim 11, further comprising a thermally insulating and radiation transparent material surrounding each post.

16. The system recited in claim 11, further comprising an environmental overcoat to reflect away out-of-band energy.

17. The system recited in claim 11, wherein the desired frequency has a wavelength in the bands of one of 3 μm to 5 μm and 8 μm to 12 μm.