This disclosure relates in general to phased array antennas and in particular to high power RF channel selection in phased array antennas.
Phased array antennas are a major part of today's military and commercial sensors and communication systems. In phased array antennas, multiple antennas are often configured together into an antenna array to form a directional radiation pattern. More advanced phased arrays use phase shifting techniques to scan their radiation patterns in space. A phased array usually comprises a number of dipole antenna elements, commonly spaced at a equal distance. Each element or sub array of elements are connected to a phase shifter followed by a summing node. Varying the frequency of operation can also be used in lieu of the phase shifters to form the radiation pattern.
Active phased arrays or active electronically scanned arrays (AESAs) include amplifiers at individual antenna elements or subarrays of the antenna array. Compared with passive phased arrays, active phased arrays provide greater sensitivity. In addition, AESAs are more reliable than mechanically scanned antennas. An active phased array system front end typically comprises antennas and Transmit/Receive (T/R) modules. A primary reoccurring cost of an active phased array system is for the T/R modules. The cost of the T/R modules stems from a number of high dollar components required for each T/R module, including switches, amplifiers, phase shifters, variable attenuators, etc., which are multiplied by the total number of T/R modules used in the array. When arrays can have hundreds or even thousands of elements and T/R modules, the number of components, their associated costs, and the dissipated power have a significant impact on the overall performance and cost of the array.
An active phased array's effective radiated power and overall RF system capability are determined largely by the array's transmitted RF power. Therefore, the T/R module and its amplifiers are designed to achieve as much transmitted power as possible. The transmitted power level may be increased by increasing the number of antenna elements and T/R modules in the system. However, phased arrays are typically restricted to a small footprint, reducing the spatial degrees of freedom available to enhance array performance. When the array is spatially contained, the power dissipated by the T/R module may become an increasingly important issue as the number of T/R modules increases. The available space and heat removal capability may limit the level of transmit power that an active phased array can realistically achieve.
Operating at RF and microwave frequencies, the T/R module usually employs Monolithic Microwave Integrated Circuit (MMIC) components to reduce the footprint. As the transmit power becomes greater, the output switch of the T/R module may become more costly and limiting in its performance. The higher the output power, the fewer switches on the market available capable of handling the output power, and the more costly they may become. Many amplifiers are available for use in a T/R module that can deliver more output power than can be handled by any conventional switch. Also, the signal losses through the conventional switch may be substantial enough to impact the transmitted power and the amount of power dissipated as heat. Thus, a low-cost output switch that is capable of transmitting high power level, while reducing power losses, is greatly desired.
In accordance with some embodiments, a switch is disclosed for selecting a port. The switch includes a dielectric layer, a first circuit, and a second circuit. The first and second circuits are disposed on the dielectric layer and electrically coupled to each other through the dielectric layer. The first circuit includes a set of ports. The switch further includes a control port for receiving a control signal and a plurality of switching elements. The control signal selects at least one of the set of ports to be connected to the second circuit by setting operational states of the plurality of switching elements.
In accordance with some alternative embodiments, a method is disclosed for selecting a port. The method includes receiving a control signal through a control port, setting operational states of a plurality of switching elements according to the control signal, selecting one of a set of ports coupled to a first circuit according to the operational states of the switching elements, and transmitting signals between the selected port and a second circuit.
Additional objects and advantages of the invention will be set forth in part in the description which follows, and in part will be obvious from the description, or may be learned by practice of the invention. The objects and advantages of the invention will be realized and attained by means of the elements and combinations particularly pointed out in the appended claims.
It is to be understood that both the foregoing general description and the following detailed description are exemplary and explanatory only and are not restrictive of the invention, as claimed.
The accompanying drawings, which are incorporated in and constitute a part of this specification, illustrate several embodiments of the invention and together with the description, serve to explain the principles of the invention.
Reference will now be made in detail to embodiments of the disclosure, examples of which are illustrated in the accompanying drawings. Wherever possible, the same reference numbers will be used throughout the drawings to refer to the same or like parts.
T/R modules 204 also includes a phase shifter 210 and other amplitude control components 212, which may be incorporated into the amplifiers. Amplitude control components 212 are configured to optimize the amplitude contribution from each element across the array. This is called amplitude weighting or tapering. Amplitude weighting is used to suppress unwanted side lobes in the radiation pattern.
To allow for bi-directional signal flow for transmitted and received waveforms, T/R module 204 further includes an input switching component 214 and an output switching component 216 at its input and output, respectively. Switching components 214 and 216 may be switches, circulators, diplexers, combinations thereof, or comparable components providing a comparable function. Input switching component 214 selects transmitting channel 207 or receiving channel 205 of T/R module 204 and connects them to subsequent processing components within the phased array antenna. Thus, switching components 214 and 216 may be set to configure T/R module 204 in a receiving state or a transmitting state.
The widths of traces 5 and 6 are shown to be slightly different only for ease of visualization of the circuit. The actual widths of traces 5 and 6 and the thickness of dielectric layer 12 between them may be determined according to the materials used and the performance requirements, such as the desired frequency of operation, the desired input and output impedances of ports 1-4, etc. Traces 5 and 6 each have a “U” shape with an outer dimension 15 approximately equal to ¼ of a wavelength at the desired frequency of operation. Outer dimension 15 is measured from an opening end of the “U” shape to a closed end of the “U” shape. An inner dimension 16 of traces 5 and 6 may be optimized during a tuning of the circuit and is generally minimized to provide desired performance such as a high signal bandwidth. In addition, traces 5 and 6 may substantially overlap each other, while the opening ends of the “U” shapes of traces 5 and 6 are oriented in opposite directions.
Switching component 300 further includes a control node 10 coupled to trace 6 for receiving a control signal Vctr and a ground node 7 coupled to trace 6 for connecting switching component 300 to an RF ground. Control signal Vctr may be a DC control signal with a suitable voltage level. Node 7 is electrically isolated from DC signals and control signal Vctr and couples trace 6 to an RF ground. This can be accomplished by disposing between trace 6 to and node 7 an appropriate capacitor or through an RF quarterwave open ended stub, an open ended radial stub, or other components known in the art to provide similar functionalities.
Switching component 300 further includes switching elements 8 and 9 connected between ports 1 and 2. Switching elements 8 and 9 may be diodes, diode-connected transistors, or other suitable circuit elements that may be switched between “on” and “off” states. Switching components 8 and 9 may be connected in series between ports 1 and 2. The common node between switching elements 8 and 9 is grounded through a ground node 11. According to one embodiment, ground node 11 may be both an RF and a DC ground. The DC ground may be obtained through a via or a through hole in a circuit board. The RF ground may use the via of the DC ground or be obtained by the methods discussed above in connection with ground node 7. Alternatively, ground note 11 may be an RF ground only and is isolated from DC signals through a capacitor.
Still additionally or alternatively, switching component 300 may further include a control node 17 for receiving control signal Vctr*. Control signal Vctr* may be a DC signal with an appropriate voltage level.
In one embodiment, control signal Vctr is provided through control node 10 to control the operational states of switching elements 8 and 9. For example, control signal Vctr* may be kept at a constant voltage level or a DC ground level, control signal Vctr may then set switching elements 8 and 9 to the “on” or “off” state according to the voltage level of the control signal Vctr. In the “on” state, switching elements 8 and 9 present a low RF impedance to the circuit and, in the “off” state, switching elements 8 and 9 present a high RF impedance to the circuit.
In one embodiment, when the control signal Vctr is set to a first voltage level, switching element 8 is biased in the “on” state and switching element 9 in the “off” state. As a result, port 2 is disconnected from the ground and thus selected for connection with ports 3 and 4, and port 1 is grounded through switching element 8 and thus disabled. Under these conditions, switching component 300 may operate as a signal splitter. For example, if an RF signal is input into port 2, it is equally split between ports 3 and 4 and output therefrom. The signals output from ports 3 and 4 are approximately 180 degrees out of phase from each other. According to a further embodiment, the first voltage level may be any voltage level sufficiently greater than the ground level or the voltage level of control signal Vctr*.
Alternatively, switching component 300 may also operate as a signal combiner. In particular, when respective signals are input into ports 3 and 4 with 180 degrees of phase difference between them, a combination of these two signals is output from port 2. When switching component 300 operates as the signal splitter or the signal combiner, port 1 is disabled or isolated from the rest of the circuit and, thus, has negligible power going into or out of it.
In another embodiment, when control signal Vctr is set to a second voltage level, switching element 9 may be biased in the “on” state and switching element 8 in the “off” state. Under these conditions, switching component 216 may operate as a signal splitter. For example, if an RF signal is coupled to port 1, it is equally split between ports 3 and 4. Similarly, the signals from ports 3 and 4 are approximately 180 degrees out of phase from each other. On the other hand, if two RF signals are coupled to ports 3 and 4 with 180 degrees of phase difference between them, a combination of these two signals is output through port 1. In this case, port 2 becomes disabled and isolated from the rest of the circuit. According to a further embodiment, the second voltage level may be any voltage level sufficiently lower than the ground level or the voltage level of control signal Vctr*.
Ports 3 and 4 form a balanced pair of ports. Accordingly, switching component 300 connects the balanced pair of ports (e.g., ports 3 and 4) to a user-selectable single port (e.g., port 1 or 2) according to control signal Vctr.
Alternatively, the voltage levels of control signals Vctr and Vctr* may both be varied to select port 1 or port 2. For example, when control signal Vctr has a voltage level sufficiently greater than that of control signal Vctr*, switching element 8 is turned on, while switching element 9 is turned off. Thus, port 2 is selected and connected to ports 3 and 4. When control signal Vctr has a voltage level sufficiently lower than that of control signal Vctr*, switching element 8 is turned off while switching element 9 is turned on. Thus, port 1 is selected and connected to ports 3 and 4.
As depicted in
To produce the equal split of signal power with 180 degrees phase difference at ports 3 and 4, appropriate even and odd mode impedances are designed for the coupled trace sections of switching component 300. The circuit of switching component 300 is generally separated from a ground plane at a distance that is several times that of the distance between the coupled traces 5 and 6. This allows the odd mode impedance to be sufficiently lower than the even mode impedance. This design provides the electromagnetic fields to be primarily coupled between traces 5 and 6, instead of between either of these traces and the ground plane. This is generally desired for proper design and operation.
The width of traces 5 and 6 and the space between them may determine the odd mode impedance in the circuit of switching component 300. According to one embodiment, the circuit shown in
As discussed above, dimension 15 of traces 5 and 6 may be determined according to the wavelength of the signal at the desired frequency of operation, whereas dimension 16 is generally minimized. In addition, minimizing dimension 16 may cause the signals output from ports 3 and 4 to be substantially 180 degrees out of phase when switching component 216 operates as a signal splitter. Other dimensions of traces 5 and 6 are determined according to the performance requirement of switching component 216, such as bandwidth, impedance, available space on the circuit board, etc.
Trace 6 may include two separate sections 41 and 42, each corresponding to and overlapping a respective portion of trace 5. Sections 41 and 42 of trace 6 are coupled to the RF ground through ground nodes 7 and to corresponding control nodes 10A and 10B for receiving respective control signals Vctr1 and Vctr2. In addition, sections 41 and 42 of trace 6 are coupled to ports 1 and 2, respectively. Switching element 8 and 9 are connected between ports 1 and 2, with the cathodes (or their equivalents) of switching elements 8 and 9 coupled to a common node, which is connected to the ground through ground node 11. Ports 1 and 2 may be respectively coupled to the transmitting channel and the receiving channel of a T/R module similar to those shown in
Switching component 400 may select port 1 or port 2 for connection with ports 3 and 4 according to control signals Vctr1, Vctr2, and Vctr*. For example, when control signal Vctr1 has a voltage level sufficiently greater than that of control signal Vctr*, and the voltage level of Vctr2 is sufficiently lower than that of control signal Vctr*, port 2 is selected and connected to ports 3 and 4, while port 1 is disabled and isolated from the circuit. As a result, switching component 400 shown in
Similarly, when control signal Vctr1 has a voltage level sufficiently lower than that of control signal Vctr*, and the voltage level of control signal Vctr2 is sufficiently greater than that of control signal Vctr*, port 1 is selected and connected to ports 3 and 4, while port 2 is disabled and isolated from the circuit. As a result, switching component 216 may operate as a signal splitter, which receives a signal from port 1 and outputs signals through ports 3 and 4, which are 180 degrees out of phase. On the other hand, switching component 216 may also operate as a signal combiner, which receives signals through ports 3 and 4, which are 180 degrees out of phase, and generates a combined signal through port 1.
Trace 5 and 6 may have substantially the same dimension 15 as depicted in
Trace 6 in
Switching elements 8 and 9 are coupled in series between ports 1 and 2. The common node between switching elements 8 and 9 is grounded through a ground node 11 and an appropriate element such as those described above. Additionally, the common node between switching elements 8 and 9 may be further connected to a control port 17 for receiving control signal Vctr*.
Similar to the embodiment depicted in
During operation, switching component 500 may receive signals from port 1 or 2, selected according to the control signal Vctr and/or control signal Vctr*, and generate output signals from ports 3 and 4 that are 180 degrees out of phase. Switching component 500 may also receive input signals from ports 3 and 4 that are 180 out of phase and generate output signal from port 1 or 2 selected according to the control signals.
Similar to the embodiment depicted in
Second section 72 may include a first trace 721 and a second trace 722, each coupled to the “U” shape of trace 6 in first section 71. First and second traces 721 and 722 may be disposed on the same surface of the dielectric layer as trace 6. Ports 3 and 4 may be coupled to the “U” shape of trace 5, while ports 1 and 2 may be coupled to the first and second traces 721 and 722. Switching elements 8 and 9 are disposed between ports 1 and 2 in series, with the common node between switching elements 8 and 9 coupled to the RF ground through ground node 11. In addition, the common node between switching elements 8 and 9 may be coupled to control node 17 for receiving control signal Vctr*. Additionally, port 1 or port 2 may be further connected to a control node 10 for receiving control signal Vctr.
First section 71 of switching component 700 may be substantially similar to the switching component depicted in
During operation, switching component 700 receives control signal Vctr through control node 10 and selects port 1 or 2 according to control signal Vctr for connection with ports 3 and 4. In particular, when control signal Vctr has a first voltage level that is sufficiently greater than that of control signal Vctr*, switching element 8 is turned on and switching element 9 is turned off. As a result, port 2 is selected and connected to ports 3 and 4, while port 1 is disabled. In addition, trace 721 of second section 71 further isolates disabled port 1 from the rest of the circuit by presenting an open circuit to first section 71 and a low impedance at the input of the circuit.
Alternatively, when control signal Vctr has a second voltage level that is sufficiently lower than that of control signal Vctr*, switching element 8 is turned off and switching element 9 is turned on. As a result, port 1 is selected and connected to ports 3 and 4, while port 2 is disabled. Trace 722 of second section 72 further isolates disabled port 1 from the rest of the circuit by presenting an open circuit to first section 71. In addition, switching component 700 may operate as a signal combiner or a signal splitter as described above. According to a further embodiment, the first voltage level may be any voltage level sufficiently greater than the ground level or the voltage level present at control port 17, and the second voltage level may be any voltage level sufficiently lower than the ground level or the voltage level present at control port 17.
Still alternatively, switching component 700 may select port 1 or port 2 based on the combination of control signals Vctr and Vctr*. For example, when control signal Vctr has a voltage level sufficiently greater than that of control signal Vctr*, switching element 8 is turned on, while switching element 9 is turned off. Thus, port 2 is selected for connection with ports 3 and 4, while port 1 is isolated from the rest of the circuit. Alternatively, when control signal Vctr has a voltage level sufficiently lower than that of control signal Vctr*, switching element 8 is turned off, while switching element 9 is turned on. Thus, port 2 is isolated from the rest of the circuit, while port 1 is selected for connection with ports 3 and 4.
According to a still alternative embodiment, switching component 800 may select port 1 or port 2 according to controls signals Vctr1, Vctr2, and Vctr*. For example, when control signal Vctr1 has a voltage level sufficiently greater than that of control signal Vctr*, and the voltage level of Vctr1 is sufficiently lower than that of control signal Vctr*, switching element 8 is turned on, while switching element 9 is turned off. As a result, port 1 is disabled and isolated from the rest of the circuit, and port 2 is selected and connected to ports 3 and 4 for transmitting or receiving signals. Alternatively, when control signal Vctr1 has a voltage level sufficiently lower than that of control signal Vctr*, and the voltage level of control signal Vctr2 is sufficiently greater than that of controls signal Vctr*, switching element 8 is turned off, while switching element 9 is turned on. As a result, port 2 is disabled and isolated from the rest of the circuit, and port 1 is selected and connected to ports 3 and 4 for transmitting or receiving signals. In both cases, when port 1 or 2 is disabled, section 82 further isolates the disabled port from the rest of the circuit by presenting an open circuit to section 81 of switching component 800.
Trace 6 may include a plurality of sections 94-97. In particular, section 94 of trace 6 may have an elongated shape, disposed proximate to circular opening 91 and perpendicular to slot opening 93. Section 97 of trace 6 may also have an elongated shape, disposed proximate to circular opening 92 and perpendicular to slot opening 93. The widths of sections 94 and 97 may be determined according to performance requirements of the switching component, such as the signal bandwidth and the input and output impedances.
According to an alternative embodiment, switching component 900 may have a multi-layer structure as depicted in
Ports 1 and 2 may be coupled to respective ends of section 94 of trace 6. Ports 3 and 4 may be coupled to respective ends of section 97 of trace 6. A ground node 11 may be coupled to section 94 for connecting section 94 to a ground through a capacitor or other suitable components. In addition, a control node 17 may be coupled to section 94 for receiving a control signal Vctr*.
Sections 95 and 96 may be open ended stubs each connected to one of switching elements 8 and 9 at one end. The free ends of sections 95 and 96 are left open to provide a closed circuit for RF signals and an open circuit for DC signals. Sections 95 and 96 have substantially similar lengths 98, which preferably are approximately equal to ¼ of a wavelength of a signal at a desired operational frequency.
Further, sections 95 and 96 may be coupled respectively to control nodes 10A and 10B for receiving control signal Vctr. Again, control signals Vctr and Vctr* may be DC signals with suitable voltage levels that properly biases switching elements 8 and 9 so as to control their operational states. Alternatively, control signal Vctr* may be coupled to a DC ground and the switching component 900 can still operate properly.
Switching element 8 may be disposed between sections 94 and 95, with the anode (or its equivalent) of switching element 8 coupled to section 95 and the cathode (or its equivalent) of switching element 8 coupled to section 94. Switching element 9 may be disposed between sections 94 and 96, with the cathode (or its equivalent) of switching element 9 coupled to section 96 and the anode (or its equivalent) of switching element 9 coupled to section 94.
According to one embodiment, the voltage level of control signal Vctr* is fixed during operation. This may be achieved by coupling control node 17 to a ground level. When control signal Vctr has a first voltage level, switching element 8 is turned on, while switching element 9 is turned off. As a result, port 1 is disabled and isolated from the rest of the circuit, and port 2 is selected and connected to ports 3 and 4 for receiving and transmitting signals. Alternatively, when control signal Vctr has a second voltage, switching element 8 is turned off, while switching element 9 is turned on. As a result, port 2 is disabled and isolated from the rest of the circuit, and port 1 is selected and connected to ports 3 and 4 for receiving and transmitting signals. According to a further embodiment, the first voltage level may be any voltage level sufficiently greater than the ground level or the voltage level present at control port 17, and the second voltage level may be any voltage level sufficiently lower than the ground level or the voltage level present at control port 17.
Alternatively, switching component 900 may select port 1 or port 2 according to both control signals Vctr and Vctr*. For example, when control signal Vctr has a voltage level sufficiently greater than that of control signal Vctr*, switching element 8 is turned on, while switching element 9 is turned off. Thus, port 2 is selected for connection with ports 3 and 4, while port 1 is isolated from the rest of the circuit. Alternatively, when control signal Vctr has a voltage level sufficiently lower than that of control signal Vctr*, switching element 8 is turned off, while switching element 9 is turned on. Thus, port 2 is isolated from the rest of the circuit, while port 1 is selected for connection with ports 3 and 4.
When integrated in a T/R module, ports 3 and 4 may be coupled to an antenna that requires a balanced input, and ports 1 and 2 may be coupled respectively to a transmitting channel and a receiving channel of the T/R module. Slot opening 93 provides a transmission path for transmitting electromagnetic signals between ports 3 and 4 and ports 1 and 2.
During operation, switching component 1000 of
Trace 6 of switching component 1100 may include sections 114-116. Section 114 has an elongated trace disposed perpendicularly to slot opening 112. Sections 115 and 116 are metal stubs similarly to sections 95 and 96 of
During operation, switching component 216 may select port 1 or 2 according to control signal Vctr or the combination of control signals Vctr and Vctr* received through ports 10A, 10B, and 17 and connect the selected port to antenna 111 for transmitting and receiving signals.
At step 1206, one of the set of ports may be selected according to the operational states of the switching elements. For example, as shown in
At step 1208, signals are transmitted between the selected port and the second circuit. For example, a signal may be received through the selected port (e.g., port 1 or 2), split into two signal components, and output through ports 3 and 4 as described above in connection with
The switching components disclosed herein may be orders of magnitude cheaper and may be more versatile than existing solutions. As an example, conventional high power (e.g., greater than 2 Watt), high frequency (e.g., greater than 6 GHz) switch MMICs or integrated chips generally cost $20 or more each, even when manufactured in large quantities. At power levels above 2 Watts and frequencies greater than 12 GHz, the cost per switch can extend to $80 or more for each unit. In embodiments of the present disclosure, however, the primary cost is in the cost of the switching elements (e.g., switching elements 8 and 9). The printed traces may be part of the circuit board of the T/R module and may be manufactured at substantially lower cost than prior known components. Switching elements that support up to 20 GHz and have advantageous performance properties, such as low resistance, low capacitance, and high power handling capability, are readily available at prices of $1.50 to $3.00 each. Also, embodiments of the present disclosure may require only a control input (e.g., the control signal Vctr) for selecting port 1 or 2. This leads to less peripheral control circuitry than conventional designs, such as a single pole, double throw (SPDT) switch, which require multiple control inputs and complex circuitry. For systems that employ hundreds if not thousands of T/R modules or other circuits that require high power switches, the disclosed embodiments may provide substantial cost savings.
The embodiments disclosed herein may be integrated in any circuit that requires switching of RF signals and is capable of processing signals above 2 Watts or more. In particular, the switching components may operate at the Ku-band or higher and transmit signals with power level of 4 Watts or more. The power handling capability of the presently disclosed embodiment may be determined by the power handling capability of switching elements 8 and 9 and the ratio of their resistance to that of the input impedance of ports 1 and 2.
Switching element 8 and 9 may operate within the range of 12 GHz to 20 GHz and provide a greater bandwidth than existing switching solutions for a fraction of the cost. For example, for a common input impedance of 50 ohms at ports 1 and 2, the presently disclosed embodiments can handle as much as 10 Watts of input power. For greater input impedances, the embodiments disclosed herein can provide even much greater power handling capability. Switching elements 8 and 9 are usually a fraction of the size of the conventional switches, providing a substantial size advantage.
The conventional high power switches typically generates a 1 to 1.5 dB of power loss at high frequencies, whereas the embodiments disclosed herein have only approximately 0.4 dB of power loss or, in some cases, even less. In high power applications, the disclosed embodiments provide a significant advantage in reducing power loss over the conventional switches. For example, in a T/R module that transmits 2 Watts of signals at the output, a conventional switch requires an output power of at least 2.82 Watts to counter the power loss, whereas the present embodiments require an output power of only 2.19 Watts. This reduction in power loss is significant, considering that the T/R module is typically used in an array of hundreds or thousands of elements, where the power loss is dissipated as heat. For a 256 element array, the conventional switch causes additional 161 Watts of power loss, compared to embodiments disclosed herein.
In addition, a conservative estimate of a HPA's efficiency is 30%. For the above example, a conventional switch would cause the array to dissipate approximately 1894 Watts of heat from circuit. In comparison, the present embodiments may lead to a total dissipation of only 1356 Watts. This is a 28% reduction in power dissipation. As a result, the disclosed embodiments generate much less heat than the conventional switches. The lower power loss provided by the disclosed embodiments also benefits the performance of the T/R module and improves the sensitivity of the T/R module because the loss prior to the LNA is significantly reduced.
Other embodiments of the invention will be apparent to those skilled in the art from consideration of the specification and practice of the invention disclosed herein. It is intended that the specification and examples be considered as exemplary only, with a true scope and spirit of the invention being indicated by the following claims.
Number | Name | Date | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
3659227 | Whistler | Apr 1972 | A |
4791421 | Morse | Dec 1988 | A |
5363071 | Schwent et al. | Nov 1994 | A |
5834990 | Hahn et al. | Nov 1998 | A |
6714169 | Chau et al. | Mar 2004 | B1 |
20030020664 | Thudor et al. | Jan 2003 | A1 |
20030034929 | Bolzer et al. | Feb 2003 | A1 |
20050285809 | Louzir et al. | Dec 2005 | A1 |
20060077028 | Huang | Apr 2006 | A1 |
20080290962 | Kim et al. | Nov 2008 | A1 |
20100194493 | Thompson | Aug 2010 | A1 |
20100246454 | Ansari et al. | Sep 2010 | A1 |
Number | Date | Country |
---|---|---|
WO 0180349 | Oct 2001 | WO |
Entry |
---|
Petropoulos et al. “Phased Array Antenna Receives 4G Networks”, Microwaves & RF, Nov. 2012, pp. 1-12. |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
20160344105 A1 | Nov 2016 | US |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
61553661 | Oct 2011 | US |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
Parent | 13665044 | Oct 2012 | US |
Child | 15160437 | US |