The entire disclosure of any publication or patent document mentioned herein is incorporated by reference.
The disclosure relates generally to biosensing, and in particular to systems and methods for performing surface-plasmon resonance (SPR) biosensing using multiple wavelengths in a manner that reduces or eliminates chromatic aberration.
The disclosure provides systems and methods for real-time SPR biosensing using multiple wavelengths in a manner that reduces or eliminates the detrimental effects of chromatic aberration typically associated with the beam-forming optical system used to focus light onto a SPR biosensor. The SPR biosensing systems and methods have variable penetration depth resolution capability. The disclosure also provides for use of the SPR biosensor systems and methods for performing chemical and biological assays and for related biosensing applications.
In embodiments of the disclosure:
Various embodiments of the disclosure are described in detail below with reference to the drawings. Reference to various embodiments does not limit the scope of the disclosure, which is limited only by the scope of the attached claims. Additionally, any examples set forth in this specification are not limiting and merely set forth some of the many possible embodiments for the claimed invention.
In an example, an optional collection optical system 52 (shown in phantom) is arranged between SPR biosensor 100 and photodetector array 50, and is used to collect reflected light 46 from the SPR biosensor and image it onto the photodetector array. Also, in an example, a translucent screen 54 (dashed line) can be placed in front photodetector array 50 so that reflected light 46 from biosensor 100 forms an image on the screen, and photodetector array 50 includes a CCD camera that can view (detect) the image. A data acquisition unit 60 is operably connected to photodetector array 50. An example data acquisition unit 60 is or includes a computer configured to perform signal processing. A display 70 may be operably connected to data acquisition unit 70.
System 10 is a representative system for illustrating the general principles of the disclosure. Other variations of system 10, such as those discussed below, can incorporate, for example, the addition of fiber or free-space couplers, fiber arrays, arrayed optics, beam splitters, or combination thereof, to enable multiple light sources, multiple photodetectors, and the like into the system.
In an example, multi-wavelength light source system 20 generates p-polarized light beams 26 that travel along axis A1. Light source system 20 can comprise, for example, one or more light-emitting devices 22 operating at different wavelengths that range from visible to near-IR wavelengths, for example, from about 400 nm to about 1,700 nm. Light-emitting devices 22 can also have wavelengths (or spectral bandwidths) across a large range (e.g., 400 to 1,700 nm). Light source system 20 can be configured to sequentially operate light-emitting devices 22 to sequentially generate light beams 26 having the different wavelengths. Light source system 20 can also be configured to simultaneously operate light-emitting devices 22 so that a given light beam 26 has two or more wavelengths at a given time. Examples of these capabilities for light source system 20 are discussed in greater detail below.
Many different types of light-emitting devices 22 with a variety of spectral properties can be used, such as lasers, laser diodes, light emitting diodes (LED), superluminescent diodes (SLD), white light sources, super-continuum light sources, or combinations thereof. In an example, light beams 26 emanating from one or more of light-emitting devices 22 can be delivered to a beam shaper (not shown) having, for example, free-space optics in which optical mirrors, lenses or combinations thereof are used. Light beams 26 can also be delivered, for example, with optical fibers or a fiber bundle. The optical fibers can be single mode, multimode, or a combination thereof, and can polarization-maintaining when the light-emitting devices 22 generate linearly polarized light.
The different wavelengths for light beams 26 can be achieved using, for example, wavelength multiplexing techniques that combine light from multiple light-emitting devices 22 into one fiber or one light beam to simplify the optical configuration for system 10. In this type of configuration, the biosensor measurement is performed at each wavelength. That is, system 10 only measures one data point (i.e., the SPR response) at a given point in time and at a given wavelength and thus at a given penetration depth. For the next measurement, the wavelength is changed to provide a different penetration depth. Changing the wavelength can be accomplished in any number of ways known in the art, including using optical switching techniques, such as flipping mirrors, galvanometers, fiber-optic switches, beam blocking switches, translatable apertures, and like means and methods, or a combination thereof.
When the light-emitting devices 22 are combined by wavelength multiplexing techniques, the wavelength selection can be achieved by, for example, turning on each light-emitting device 22 using one or a series of optical switches. To adequately detect biological events using the multi-wavelength techniques disclosed herein, it is particularly advantageous to switch between light-emitting devices 22 through the range of available wavelengths at a rate faster than the rate at which those biological or biochemical events occur at the sample. Examples of light source system 20 with such wavelength-switching capability are discussed below.
An example light source system 20 includes four light-emitting devices 22 in the form of four laser diodes emitting at wavelengths of 650 nm, 800 nm, 980 nm, and 1500 nm, and also includes respective single-mode optical fibers optically coupled to the light-emitting devices. An example of such a light source system 20 is discussed in greater detail below.
The specific wavelengths for light-emitting devices 22 can be selected to lie within a spectral range in which the sample absorption and scattering loss are relatively low. For samples having a strong fluorescence emission, the wavelengths may be selected to avoid the fluorescence absorption peak to minimize its impact on index of refraction sensitivity. In contrast, in a system where surface plasmons are to be used to specifically excite, for example, surface fluorescence or quantum dots, then the opposite is true, and the wavelength may be selected to lie within the excitation band of the fluor(s) or quantum dots.
With continuing reference to
Beam-forming optical system 30 is configured to form from each light beam 26 a corresponding incident light beam 36 having any one of a number of possible desirable beam shapes and a suitable numerical aperture, thereby providing for controlled illumination of an area of SPR biosensor 100 as defined by a focus spot (or focus image) 38. Incident light beam 36 is focused to provide a range Δθ of incident illumination angles θ at focus spot 38. As discussed below and illustrated schematically in
Beam-forming optical system 30 can comprise, for example, a number of optical lenses, one or more polarizers, and a beam modulation element. Focus spot 38 can be a point, a line, a dot, an elongate spot, or have any reasonable extended shape, and the word “focus spot” is used herein as shorthand to denote all of these light image possibilities. A polarizer (or multiple polarizers) can be used in beam-forming optical system 30 to ensure that each light beam 26 is p-polarized, which polarization is in the plane of incidence of incident light beam 36. For example, consider illuminating SPR biosensor 100 with a line focus spot 38 using a light source system 20 that employs optical fibers coupled to corresponding light-emitting devices 22. The light beams 26 emanating from the optical fiber end have circular beam cross-sections need to be reshaped into rectangular or elliptical beam cross-sections. This transformation can be accomplished with beam-forming optical system 30 having, for example, a combination of cylindrical lenses and other commonly used lenses, such as spherical, aspherical lenses, anamorphic lenses, diffractive optic beam shapers, mirrors, prisms or a combination thereof. In an example embodiment, beam-forming optical system 30 is anamorphic.
Since only the p-polarization component of incident light beam 36 can couple to the SPR resonance of SPR biosensor 100, the s-polarization component is not necessary and can potentially impair the ability of system 10 to optimally detect the SPR minimum in reflected light 46. Hence, a polarizer may be needed to block any residual s-polarization component in the incident light beam 36 and allow only p-polarized light to be incident upon SPR biosensor 100. Similarly, a polarization-controlling element (e.g. such as fiber optical polarization controlling paddles) may be used to ensure light beam 26 is substantially p-polarized at sample 124. A beam-modulation element (not shown) may be necessary to overcome detrimental speckle effects when the spectral width of light beam 26 is sufficiently narrow (e.g., less than about 0.01 nm). In this instance, the beam-modulator element changes the beam location slightly (e.g., less than about 3 degrees) at a speed much faster than the data collection speed (e.g., 100 Hz) to minimize speckle and thus improve the signal-to-noise ratio.
In the general operation of system 10, light beam 26 from light source system 20 is received by beam-forming optical system 30 which, as discussed above, forms therefrom the corresponding incident light beam 36. Incident light beam 36 travels through prism input surface 112 and through coupling surface 113 and forms focus spot 38 at the location where SPR biosensor chip 120 resides. In particular, focus spot 138 is formed substantially at the interface surface 134 between glass substrate 130 and metal layer 136. A portion of incident light beam 36 is strongly reflected from SPR biosensor chip 120 and forms reflected light 46. Reflected light 46 travels back through prism coupling surface 113, through prism output surface 114 and then propagates to photodetector array 50. Photodetector array 50 detects reflected light 46 and converts the reflected light into electronic signals S50 that are received and processed by data acquisition unit 60. Measurement results can be displayed on optional display 70.
The light incident on SPR biosensor 120 in incident light beam 36 excites a surface plasmon wave 150 in metal layer 136 of SPR biosensor chip 120. Surface plasmon wave 150 has an attendant SPR evanescent field 152 that penetrates into sample 124 to a penetration depth ΔP. The penetration depth is defined as where the SPR evanescent field intensity drops to 1/e (i.e., about 37%) as compared to its intensity at the interface of metal layer 136 and sample 124. The penetration depth ΔP is on the order of 0.25× to 1.5× the resonant wavelength, and depends on the wavelength of light used and the particular biosensor configuration. In an example, system 10 provides a penetration depth ΔP in sample 124 in a range from about 200 nm to about 1,500 nm.
Under static conditions and at a given wavelength, the penetration depth ΔP is fixed. As surface plasmon wave 150 propagates along metal layer 136, its power is attenuated through Ohmic losses, thereby removing optical power from incident light beam 36. The portion of incident light beam 36 that does not couple to the plasmon wave resonance is reflected strongly and forms the aforementioned reflected light beam 46. This resonant absorption leads to a reflection minimum that identifies the SPR minimum reflection angle. The angle at which the intensity of reflected light 46 is at a minimum is influenced by the properties of sample 124. Shifts in the SPR minimum reflection angle can be measured with photodetector array 50. Near-surface biological and biochemical-related events occurring in sample 124 can be monitored and measured by tracking the changes in the SPR minimum reflection angle, which correspond to changes in the location of the minimum intensity of reflected light 46 detected at photodetector array 50.
The penetration depth ΔP of SPR evanescent field 152 into sample 124 is a function of wavelength.
For surface chemistry binding sensing applications, sample 124 has a binding volume that experiences a binding-related index of refraction change, but the biding volume thickness (binding thickness) is generally much less than the penetration depth. While there may a bulk index change in sample 124, the sample generally undergoes a rapid step-index change, which can be normalized out by simple subtraction. In this surface binding case, the penetration depth does not influence the SPR binding response and any SPR instrument with a fixed penetration depth that well exceeds the binding thickness will work. In contrast, for samples 124 that have binding and mass transport events that occur within a thickness on the order of or greater than the penetration depth, a fixed penetration depth may not be able to measure the different SPR responses throughout the sample binding volume. For example, sensing applications on biological cells would be advantaged if the cellular responses could be continuously monitored at different depths, because the biological processes could be monitored simultaneously near and between the cell membrane, the intracellular matrix, and even at the nucleus.
Hence, a configuration for system 10 that allows for sampling at multiple penetration depths would be highly desirable. This can be accomplished using multiple wavelengths for light beam 26 to provide variable detection depths (i.e., penetration depths) so that the sample refractive indices at different depths can be monitored. This information can then be compared against parameterized simulations of biological responses. The fitting parameters can then be used to characterize and quantify biological events, biochemical events, or both, throughout an extended volume of the sample. Thus, collecting SPR responses at different wavelengths and at different times allows for measuring the dynamic SPR response at different depths in the sample.
In any multi-wavelength system 10, it is highly desirable to use the same optical components and substantially the same optical path OP for multi-wavelength operation. However, it is well know by those skilled in the art that chromatic aberration in refractive beam-forming optical systems 30 can become problematic when the wavelengths are many nanometers apart (typically 100 nm and more). Chromatic aberration has the undesirable effect of shifting the image plane of beam-forming optical system 30 to different locations along axis A1 for different wavelengths. Hence, when using a simple beam-forming optical system 30, if multiple and chromatically well-separated wavelengths emanate from a single location, only one of those well-separated wavelengths can be optimally focused onto SPR biosensor chip 120. The other wavelengths will be out of focus because their image planes will lie slightly in front of or slightly behind the best-focus location on SPR biosensor chip 120.
The detrimental effect of the change in the size and location of focus spot 38 with wavelength due to chromatic aberration in beam-forming optical system 30 is illustrated in
The different focus spot widths are a result of defocus caused by the chromatic aberration in beam-forming optical system 30. The focus spots 38 for the different wavelengths target significantly different areas of SPR biosensor chip 120, which would in turn make the interpretation of SPR response data from studies of complicated specimens (e.g. cell assays) questionable, if not impossible.
The use of multi-element achromatic lenses in beam-forming optical system 30 can mitigate the adverse effects chromatic aberration to some degree and can extend the spectral band over which the focus spot 38 is well-focused on sample 124 by up to 250 nm to 300 nm. A two element achromatic lens, for example, can form substantially identical focus spots 38 on SPR biosensor chip 120, with focus spots associated with other wavelengths being slightly out of focus and thus having a different but still acceptable size. However, outside of this 250 nm to 300 nm spectral band, the chromatic aberration again becomes significant so that these focus spots 38 will have a substantially different size at SPR biosensor chip 120.
System 10 of the present disclosure is configured to utilize a very broad range of wavelengths and a simple beam-forming optical system 30, e.g., one that employs as few as two refractive lens elements. This is achieved by configuring the light source system 20 so that light beams 26 for the different wavelengths originate at different axial locations (i.e., object planes) selected to compensate for (i.e., reduce or eliminate) chromatic aberration in beam-forming optical system 30. This approach allows focus spots 38 with different wavelengths to have substantially the same spot size, shape and image location on SPR biosensor chip 120. When coupled with wavelength selection control capability, system 10 is able to detect SPR responses from substantially the same region on sample 124 over an extended range of penetration depths ΔP within a given sample and to monitor the responses in real time. As a result, system 10 can be made compact and inexpensive and can be used to provide a broad range of penetration depths for biological/biochemical assays and fundamental research.
Optical fiber ends 23E-1, 23E-2 and 23E-3 need not all lay along the optical axis A1, and in the embodiment shown two of the optical fiber ends 23E-1 and 23E-3 are laterally displaced from axis A1, thereby forming a staggered object plane configuration for the optical fiber ends. In this configuration, the axial displacement is in the direction of axis A1 and is not necessarily directly along (i.e., co-axial with) axis A1. However, light beams 26 emanating from such optical fiber ends 23E are still considered to be directed along axis A1 even if the light beams are slightly displaced therefrom.
In an example, light-emitting devices 22-1, 22-2 and 22-3 operate at 650 nm, 980 nm, and 1480 nm, and optical fibers 23-1, 23-2 and 23-3 are selected so that they respectively optimally transmit light at or near these wavelengths. In an example illustrated in
In an example, optical fiber ends 23E are perpendicular to their respective fiber axes AF (
Thus, in an example, programmable switch 250, one or more optical switches 260, or a combination thereof, can be configured to sequentially generate light beams 26 of different wavelengths in a time series, allowing for system 10 to capture a SPR response image in photodetector array 50 for each wavelength used. In one mode of operation, light source system 20 cycles through its switching program repeatedly during a measurement. In an example, for system 10 to achieve a wide range of penetration depths ΔP, e.g., from about 200 nm to about 1,500 nm, light-emitting devices 22 can be chosen to operate at different wavelengths ranging from about 600 nm to about 1,500 nm.
With reference again to
Cylindrical lens L1 received light beam 26 and forms therefrom a collimated incident light beam 36 along the Y-direction. The staggered offset arrangement of fiber ends 23E thus creates multiple Y-direction collimated incident light beams 36 when the multiple light-emitting devices 22 of varying wavelengths are activated. Second cylindrical lens L2 focuses each incident light beam 36 to corresponding line type focus spots 38 that are perpendicular to the X-Z plane at the location of sample(s) 124 on SPR biosensor chip 120. By a suitable choice of cylindrical optics L1 and L2, line-type focus spots 38 can be made to have a large aspect ratio, e.g., with a narrow dimension (image width) of 3 microns to about 300 microns, and a long dimension (collimated length) of between 3 millimeters and about 100 millimeters.
In one example of performing SPR biosensor measurements with system 10, light source 20 sequentially provides light beams 26 of different wavelengths (or different spectral bands), e.g., through the programmable operation of light source system 20 and corresponding optical fibers 23, as discussed above. In this operational mode, one wavelength (or narrow spectral band) illuminates SPR biosensor chip 120 at a time. An example switching time for transitioning between different light beams 26 is 1 ms to 200 ms, which is much shorter than many biological or biochemical response times of interest, which typically occur in a few seconds, minutes or even hours. In an example, each light-emitting device 22 is left in the “on” state during each signal integration time at photodetector array 50. An example signal integration time is approximately 1 second.
With reference again to
In an example, regions of interests (ROIs) can be selected from a CCD camera image (e.g., using software) at the start of an experiment to form SPR angular response lanes, one per SPR biosensor 120. One can also select more than one ROI lane per SPR biosensor 120 if multiple sensing areas are desired in each biosensing well.
With reference again to
By tracking each SPR minimum reflection angle via the corresponding location of the intensity minimum in the far-field using photodetector array 50, the effective refractive index of one or more samples 124 can be monitored for changes. For biological samples 124, such as cells and bacteria, the change in refractive index that causes the SPR response is an indication of some biological response that originates from within the volume between the sensor-sample surface and the penetration depth ΔP into the sample. For biochemical samples, the change may reflect specific chemical reactions. These might be occurring very close to the sensor surface and hence seen by all the wavelengths. On the other hand, they may occur farther from the surface and hence seen only by the wavelengths having a greater penetration depth. In this manner, system 10 is able to depth-resolve responses from extended samples in real-time.
The combined incident light beam 136 can then be reshaped with beam-forming optical system 30 to illuminate the SPR chip sensing regions with substantially the same illumination area and with substantially the same resultant SPR signals. In this condition, the distances between light-emitting devices 22 and incident beam-forming optical system 30 are selected to compensate for the aforementioned chromatic aberration associated with the incident beam-forming optical system.
When a tunable wavelength filter 410 is used, the wavelength of illumination can be varied and thus leads to variable penetration depths. In an example embodiment, tunable wavelength filter 410 is configured (e.g., via select optical coatings) so that its filter band can be tuned by changing its angle relative to axis A1. In an example where the filtering properties of tunable wavelength filter are sensitive to the incident angle of light thereon, light beam 26 is made substantially collimated prior to being incident upon tunable wavelength filter 410. This can be accomplished using, for example, a collimating optical system 450 (shown in phantom) between broad-band light-emitting device 22BB and tunable wavelength filter 410. In an example, collimating optical system 450 and tunable wavelength filter 410 can be considered part of beam-forming optical system 30.
To compensate for chromatic aberrations, the distance between the single light-emitting device 22 and incident beam-forming optical system 30 is axially adjusted as the wavelength of light beam 26 is changed via filtering, e.g., from λ1 to λn, associated with light beams 26-1 and 26-n, respectively. This is accomplished, for example, by mounting light-emitting device 22 on a traveling stage 420. In an example, traveling stage 420 and light-emitting device 22 are controlled by a controller 440, with the controller synchronizing the light-emitting device activation with its location relative to tunable filter 410, and also optionally controlling tunable wavelength filter 410. Thus, at a given wavelength, a given object plane (e.g., fiber end 23E) is located at the proper location so that focus spot 38 from one object plane PO comes to a proper focus (image plane) onto the same sample region as the focus spot associated with other object planes PO.
An alternative embodiment replaces the broadband light-emitting device 22 with numerous narrow-band light-emitting devices 22 and incorporates a number of optical switches, which may be of a fiber optic or free-space design. Then, as each wavelength is switched, the object plane PO is moved to the proper object location prior to acquiring data for that particular wavelength.
System 10 has a number of advantages, including that it can have a small form factor that can be used to eliminate unnecessary chamber temperature control components and thus reduces instrument costs. Also, unlike conventional SPR configurations where the optical elements have to be designed for specific wavelengths to correct chromatic aberrations, the systems and methods described herein can be applied to any wavelength range to enable multiple penetration depths. No special optical glass, reflection coatings or lens designs are needed to correct a wide range of chromatically induced aberrations.
The disclosure has been described with reference to various specific embodiments and techniques. However, it should be understood that many variations and modifications are possible while remaining within the scope of the disclosure.