Patent Application
20070192139
Not Applicable
Not Applicable
The present invention generally relates to securing patient identity and, in particular, to de-identifying patient data at an ambulatory patient care provider (PCP) site for submission to a data warehouse system and then re-identify a patient, at the PCP site, from de-identified patient data received from the data warehouse system.
Hospitals typically utilize computer systems to manage the various departments within a hospital and data about each patient is collected by a variety of computer systems. For example, a patient may be admitted to the hospital for a Transthoracic Echo (TTE). Information about the patient (e.g., demographics and insurance) could be obtained by the hospital information system (HIS) and stored on a patient record. This information could then be passed to the cardiology department system (commonly known as the cardio vascular information system, or CVIS). Typically the CVIS is a product of one company, while the HIS is the product of another company. As a result, the database between the two may be different. Further, information systems may capture/retain and send different levels of granularity in the data. Once the patient information has been received by the CVIS, the patient may be scheduled for a TTE in the echo lab. Next, the TTE is performed by the sonographer. Images and measurements are taken and sent to the CVIS server. The reading physician (e.g., an echocardiographer) sits down at a review station and pulls the patient's TTE study. The echocardiographer then begins to review the images and measurements and creates a complete medical report on the study. When the echocardiographer completes the medical report, the report is sent to the CVIS server where it is stored and associated with the patient through patient identification data. This completed medical report is an example of the kind of report that could be sent to a data repository for public data mining. Medication instructions, such as documentation and/or prescription, may also be generated electronically and saved in a data repository.
Data warehousing methods have been used to aggregate, clean, stage, report and analyze patient information derived from medical claims billing and electronic medical records (EMR). Patient data may be extracted from multiple EMR databases located at PCP sites in geographically dispersed locations, then transported and stored in a centrally located data warehouse. The central data warehouse may be a source of information for population-based profile reports of physician productivity, preventative care, disease-management statistics and research on clinical outcomes. The central data warehouse may also be used to benchmark performance across multiple providers of care. Patient data is sensitive and confidential, and therefore, specific identifying information must be removed prior to transporting it from a PCP site to a central data warehouse. This removal of identifying information must be performed per the federal Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA) regulations. Any data that is contained in a public database must not reveal the identity of the individual patients whose medical information is contained in the database. Because of this requirement, any information contained on a medical report or record that could aid in tracing back to a particular individual must be removed from the report or record prior to adding the data to a data warehouse for public data mining.
In order to accurately assess the impact of a particular drug or treatment on a patient it is helpful to analyze all medical reports relating to the particular patient. Removing data that can be used to trace back to an individual patient can make it impossible to group and analyze all medical reports relating to a particular patient. In addition, one of the aims of population analysis is to assemble an at-risk cohort population comprised of individuals who may be candidates for clinical intervention. However, de-identified data is not very useful to the patient care providers who need to know the identity of their own patients in order to treat them. Additionally, users of the system may need the ability to re-identify patients for further follow-up. Portal users may need to re-identify the patients in a process that doesn't involve the portal system, i.e. the process of re-identification occurs on the local user's system.
Therefore, there is a need for systems and methods for re-identifying patients with respect to medical records. There is a need for systems and methods for secure re-identification of patient records in compliance with HIPAA.
Certain embodiments of the present invention provide systems and methods for retrieving and re-identifying de-identified or anonymized patient data.
Certain embodiments provide system and methods for re-identifying patient data. Patient data may be re-identified by retrieving an encrypted or abstracted patient identifier. The identifier is used to retrieve a patient identifier associated with patient identification information. Patient identification information may be inserted into a report or other document at a local computer or web portal for access by an authorized user.
Certain embodiments provide a method for localized re-identification of patient data in an authorized environment. The method includes retrieving, within an authorized environment, an encrypted patient identifier from a file. The method also includes locating a patient identifier associated with patient identification information using the encrypted patient identifier. Additionally the method includes inserting, within an authorized environment, the patient identification information into the file.
Certain embodiments provide a patient re-identification system. The system includes a data storage storing patient data. Patient data includes an encoded patient identifier and a patient identifier. The encoded patient identifier corresponds to the patient identifier. The system further includes a processor configured to connect with the data storage. The processor includes a viewing application capable of viewing patient data in a file including the encoded patient identifier. The processor invokes a procedure to replace the encoded patient identifier in the file with the corresponding patient identifier using the data storage. The replacement of the encoded patient data with the corresponding patient identifier occurs via the processor.
Certain embodiments provide at least one computer-readable medium including a set of instructions for execution on a computer. The set of instructions includes a data store including patient-related data. The patient-related data includes at least one encrypted patient identifier and at least one unencrypted patient identifier. The patient-related data is searchable by the at least one encrypted patient identifier and the at least one unencrypted patient identifier. The set of instructions also includes a viewing application configured to view a file including patient data in an authorized environment. In addition, the set of instructions includes a re-identification routine triggered via the viewing application. The re-identification routine selects an encrypted patient identifier in the file and matches the encrypted patient identifier in the file with one of the at least one encrypted patient identifier in the data store. The re-identification routine locates an unencrypted patient identifier corresponding with the encrypted patient identifier and inserts the unencrypted patient identifier into the file in the authorized environment.
The foregoing summary, as well as the following detailed description of certain embodiments of the present invention, will be better understood when read in conjunction with the appended drawings. For the purpose of illustrating the invention, certain embodiments are shown in the drawings. It should be understood, however, that the present invention is not limited to the arrangements and instrumentality shown in the attached drawings.
An exemplary embodiment of the present invention is a secure process for sending de-identified patient information from an ambulatory patient care provider (PCP) site to a data warehouse system where the patient data may be analyzed and compared with a wider range of patient data. The terms “de-identified patient information” and “de-identified patient data” as used in this document refer to both fully de-identified data as defined by HIPAA and limited data set data as defined by HIPAA. A limited data set is protected health information for research, public health and health care operations that excludes direct identifiers (e.g., name; postal address other than city, state and zip code; social security number; medical records numbers) but in which other identifying information may remain (e.g., dates of examination; documentation; diagnosis; prescription; lab test results). This is contrasted with fully de-identified data as defined by HIPAA, where all data that may be used to trace back to an individual patient is removed from the record. Information obtained through the data warehouse that pertains to individual patients is transmitted back to the originating PCP site, via a cohort report. Cohort reports are generated by queries that are executed against the data warehouse system to identify patient cohort groups. The individual patients included in a cohort report are then re-identified at the PCP site so that the PCPs may consider the information when deciding on treatment options for the individual patients.
In addition, the system of
The network 106 may be any type of known network including a local area network (LAN), a wide area network (WAN), an intranet, or a global network (e.g., Internet). A data warehouse user system 102 may be coupled to the data warehouse system 104 through multiple networks (e.g., intranet and Internet) so that not all data warehouse user systems 102 are required to be coupled to the data warehouse system 104 through the same network. Similarly, a PCP system 108 may be coupled to the data mining host system 104 through multiple networks (e.g., intranet and Internet) so that not all PCP systems 108 are required to be coupled to the data warehouse system 104 through the same network. One or more of the data warehouse user systems 102, the PCP systems 108 and the data warehouse system 104 may be connected to the network 106 in a wireless fashion and the network 106 may be a wireless network. In an exemplary embodiment, the network 106 is the Internet and each data warehouse user system 102 executes a user interface application to directly connect to the data warehouse system 104. In another embodiment, a data warehouse user system 102 may execute a web browser to contact the data warehouse system 104 through the network 106. Alternatively, a data warehouse user system 102 may be implemented using a device programmed primarily for accessing the network 106 such as WebTV.
The data warehouse system 104 may be implemented using a server operating in response to a computer program stored in a storage medium accessible by the server. The data warehouse system 104 may operate as a network server (often referred to as a web server) to communicate with the data warehouse user systems 102 and the PCP systems 108. The data warehouse system 104 handles sending and receiving information to and from data warehouse user systems 102 and PCP systems 108 and can perform associated tasks. The data warehouse system 104 may also include a firewall to prevent unauthorized access to the data warehouse system 104 and enforce any limitations on authorized access. For instance, an administrator may have access to the entire system and have authority to modify portions of the system and a PCP staff member may only have access to view a subset of the data warehouse records for particular patients. In an exemplary embodiment, the administrator has the ability to add new users, delete users and edit user privileges. The firewall may be implemented using conventional hardware and/or software as is known in the art.
The data warehouse system 104 also operates as an application server. The data warehouse system 104 executes one or more application programs to provide access to the data repository located on the data warehouse system, as well as application programs to import patient data into a staging area and then into the data warehouse. In addition, the data warehouse system 104 may also execute one or more applications to create patient cohort reports and to send the patient cohort reports to the PCP systems 108. Processing may be shared by the data warehouse user system 102 and the data warehouse system 104 by providing an application (e.g., java applet) to the data warehouse user system 102. Alternatively, the data warehouse user system 102 can include a stand-alone software application for performing a portion of the processing described herein. Similarly, processing may be shared by the PCP system 102 and the data warehouse system 104 by providing an application to the PCP system 102 and alternatively, the PCP system 102 can include a stand-alone software application for performing a portion of the processing described herein. It is understood that separate servers may be used to implement the network server functions and the application server functions. Alternatively, the network server, firewall and the application server can be implemented by a single server executing computer programs to perform the requisite functions.
The storage device located at the data warehouse system 104 may be implemented using a variety of devices for storing electronic information such as a file transfer protocol (FTP) server. It is understood that the storage device may be implemented using memory contained in the data warehouse system 104 or it may be a separate physical device. The storage device contains a variety of information including a data warehouse containing patient medical data from one or more PCPs. The data warehouse system 104 may also operate as a database server and coordinate access to application data including data stored on the storage device. The data warehouse may be physically stored as a single database with access restricted based on user characteristics or it can be physically stored in a variety of databases including portions of the database on the data warehouse user systems 102 or the data warehouse system 104. In an exemplary embodiment, the data repository is implemented using a relational database system and the database system provides different views of the data to different end-users based on end-user characteristics.
Patient cohort reports 212 are generated by application software located on the data warehouse system 104 and returned to the PCP systems 108 for use by the primary care providers in treating individual patients. Patient cohort reports 212 may be automatically generated by executing a canned query on a periodic basis. PCP staff members, pharmaceutical or other company research team members and personnel from companies that make medical or other products may each run patient cohort reports 212. In addition, patient cohort reports 212 may be created by an end-user accessing a data warehouse user system 102 to create custom reports or to initiate the running of canned reports. Further, patient cohort reports 212 may be automatically generated in response to the application software, located on the data warehouse system 104, determining that particular combinations of data for a patient are stored in the data warehouse. An exemplary patient cohort report 212 includes all patients with a particular disease that were treated with a particular medication. Another exemplary patient cohort report 212 includes patients of a particular age and sex who have particular test results. For example, a patient cohort report 212 may list all women with heart disease who are taking a hormone replacement therapy drug. The patient cohort report 212 would list all the patients with records in the data warehouse 210 that fit this criteria along with a warning about the possible side-effects and the likelihood of the side-effects occurring. In an exemplary embodiment, each PCP site receives the entire report, in another embodiment, each PCP site receives the report only for patients that are being treated at the PCP site.
In an exemplary embodiment of the present invention, the ability to create patient cohort reports 212 based on querying longitudinal patient data is supported by the ability to connect all records relating to a single patient in the data warehouse 210. This requires a unique identifier to be associated with each patient record that is transmitted to the data warehouse 210. The unique identifier must not be traceable back to an individual patient by end-users accessing the data warehouse 210. However, individual PCPs may want to retain the ability to re-identify a patient based on the unique identifier so that the medical personnel located at the PCP site can follow through with the patient in response to information included in the patient cohort reports 212.
The extraction process is performed by application software located on the PCP system 108 and may be executed in the background on a periodic basis (e.g., at 2 a.m. every night, at 2 a.m. every Saturday). In this manner, the extraction process will be less likely to interfere with existing software located on the PCP system 108. The extraction process may also be initiated by a remote system (e.g., the data warehouse system 104) and may include full or incremental back-up schemes. In an exemplary embodiment of the present invention, the following identifiers are removed or transformed in order to create de-identified data that would be classified under the HIPAA definition as fully de-identified data: name, geographic subdivisions smaller than a state including street address, city, county, precinct, zip code (down to the last three digits), dates directly related to an individual (e.g., birth date), phone and fax numbers, electronic mail addresses, health plan number, account number, certificate/license number, device identifier and serial numbers, unified resource locator (URL), internet protocol (IP) address, biometric identifiers, full face photograph, and other unique identifying numbers, characteristics or codes.
In an alternate exemplary embodiment of the present invention, the following identifiers are removed or transformed in order to create de-identified that that would be classified under the HIPAA definition as limited data set information: direct identifiers such as name, postal address (other than city, state and zip code), social security number and medical records numbers. In the limited data set information implementation of the present invention some identifying information may remain such as dates of examination, documentation, diagnosis, prescription and lab test results.
A novel EPID 308 is assigned to each patient based on the PID 304 associated with the patient and a password entered by the PCP. The PID 304 to EPID 308 mapping is not maintained persistently. As depicted in the exemplary embodiment shown in
An embodiment of the present invention allows for ambulatory PCPs to send patient data into a data warehouse containing patient data from other ambulatory PCPs. In this manner, patient data may be analyzed and compared to a larger population of patients. The de-identified patient data includes an EPID 308 that may be useful in creating longitudinal reports that analyze more than one record for a particular patient. The effects of certain drugs and treatments on patient cohort groups can be analyzed and may lead to improvements in the use or composition of the drugs and treatments. In addition, an embodiment of the present invention allows for the PCP to receive cohort reports 212 based on data contained in the data warehouse. These patient cohort reports 212 include an EPID 308 for each patient. The EPID 308 may be decoded at the PCP site that created the EPID 308 and used to identify a particular patient. In this manner a PCP, by considering the information contained in the cohort report, may be able to provide improved treatment to the patient. This ability to provide useful information back to a patient level may also lead more PCPs to participate in sending patient data to a data warehouse. Having more data in the data warehouse may provide more useful information to third parties such as pharmaceutical companies, medical device companies and physicians about the effects and risks of particular treatments, while minimizing the risk of disclosing patient-identifying information to third parties. This may lead to improvements in preventative care as well as other types of medical care.
As described above, the embodiments of the invention may be embodied in the form of computer-implemented processes and apparatuses for practicing those processes. Embodiments of the invention may also be embodied in the form of computer program code containing instructions embodied in tangible media, such as floppy diskettes, CD-ROMs, hard drives, or any other computer-readable storage medium, wherein, when the computer program code is loaded into and executed by a computer, the computer becomes an apparatus for practicing the invention. An embodiment of the present invention can also be embodied in the form of computer program code, for example, whether stored in a storage medium, loaded into and/or executed by a computer, or transmitted over some transmission medium, such as over electrical wiring or cabling, through fiber optics, or via electromagnetic radiation, wherein, when the computer program code is loaded into and executed by a computer, the computer becomes an apparatus for practicing the invention. When implemented on a general-purpose microprocessor, the computer program code segments configure the microprocessor to create specific logic circuits.
At step 515, the user invokes a viewing program, such as Microsoft Excel® or other spreadsheet or reporting software. Alternatively, the viewing program may be launched automatically upon download of the patient-related data. At step 520, from within the viewing program, the user is authenticated with an EMR system to ensure the user has proper authorization to view patient chart information. For example, a user's password, signature and/or biometric identification may be verified to authorize access to patient data. Without user authentication, a user may not be able to execute stored EMR procedures. For example, an authentication mechanism residing in an EMR host system may be invoked for user name and password as well as verify a privilege level.
At step 525, the user selects or otherwise activates a re-identification function with respect to de-identified patient data. For example, an icon, button, menu option and/or command may be added to the viewing program to activate or trigger execution of the re-identification function for all of the displayed patient data entries or a selected subset of the entries. At step 530, the viewing program, such as Excel, searches column headers or other field(s) of the report for a column and/or field containing an encrypted identifier, such as an EPID. It should be understood that encrypted is used herein to indicate that the identifier or patient information is encoded, de-identified, abstracted, anonymous and/or otherwise encrypted to protect patient privacy. For example, a file, such as a worksheet, spreadsheet, table or other document, may be scanned for a column header or other field identifying an appropriate column or series of data to be re-identified.
Once the column is located, at step 535, the program collects the set of EPIDs and sends this to an EMR system and/or database or data warehouse through a data communication connection, such as a data connection (e.g., an Open DataBase Connectivity (ODBC) or an Object Linking and Embedding DataBase (OLE DB) connection). For example, the file document may be scanned to identify which one of the column headers or other field identifiers corresponds to a Patient column or similar structure. Then, for example, the set of EPIDs from the patient report are sent to an electronic medical record data warehouse via a compliant connection. The selected or identified EPIDs found in the patient column may be organized in an array or other data structure, for example.
At step 540, a stored procedure in the EMR database is invoked to augment the EPIDs with patient identifiable information such as a patient identifier (e.g., a PID), patient first name, patient last name, etc. The EMR database may be a HIPAA-compliant database, data warehouse and/or other data store, for example. At step 545, the array or other structure of EPIDs is scanned, and, for every EPID pulled from the patient column, a record or other data is sent via a data connection (e.g., ODBC or OLE DB) to the EMR database, and a re-identification stored procedure is invoked to pull a resultant first name, last name, etc. For example, the stored procedure may call a database resident algorithm which passes an internal identifier to the procedure. In certain embodiments, a hash function is used to generate a PID from the EPID, for example. Alternatively, an offset, algorithm based on patient name, age and social security number and/or other algorithm may be used to generate an internal identifier for a patient record, for example. The internal identifier is passed as parameter for a query which in turn returns name and/or or other identification information corresponding an EPID record. For example, the PID or other identifier may be used to index or search records in the database to identify appropriate record(s).
At step 550, the identification information is then sent back to the viewing application, such as Microsoft™ Excel or other spreadsheet or database program. At step 555, columns and/or other fields are inserted and/or replaced in the file, such as a spreadsheet or other document, for the patient identifiable information (e.g., patient id, first name, last name, etc.). For example, PID and/or patient name columns and/or fields may be added to a file and/or may overwrite EPID and/or other columns or fields in the file.
One or more of the steps of the method 500 may be implemented alone or in combination in hardware, firmware, and/or as a set of instructions in software, for example. Certain embodiments may be provided as a set of instructions residing on a computer-readable medium, such as a memory, hard disk, DVD, or CD, for execution on a general purpose computer or other processing device.
Certain embodiments of the present invention may omit one or more of these steps and/or perform the steps in a different order than the order listed. For example, some steps may not be performed in certain embodiments of the present invention. As a further example, certain steps may be performed in a different temporal order, including simultaneously, than listed above.
In certain embodiments, once patient information is re-identified, the user may send the corresponding list of patients into EMR as an inquiry for further analysis, manipulation, etc. A re-identified patient record may be modified, compared, and/or otherwise manipulated by the authorized user and saved locally and/or in an EMR database or other storage. A modified record may be de-identified before is it saved, for example.
In certain embodiments, EMR updates are “pulled”, “pushed”, or otherwise communicated to a database, data warehouse and/or other data store on a periodic basis (e.g., nightly, weekly, etc.). In certain embodiments, changes made locally to re-identified patient records are de-identified and communicated to the EMR system and/or database for storage.
In certain embodiments, a user may search for one or more patient records within EMR by invoking a “find” dialog or search function. The user may search by the EPID, for example, and enter or select an EPID number to activate a search. The corresponding patient chart may be retrieved and displayed. Thus, a patient may be re-identified for an authorized healthcare provider who has been identified and verified.
Thus, re-identification is a mechanism or pattern that enables encrypted and re-encrypted data to work in physically separated systems together. Whereas the encrypted system may host patient-level information that's HIPAA compliant and provide features that are useful from an encrypted point of view (e.g. provide data views to a larger audience, etc.), a need exists to leverage the information from the encrypted system and to re-identify the information for those audiences who are physically separated from the encrypted system but who have the authorization to view patient identifiable information (e.g., an authorized environment). The process of re-identifying the patients is a process that occurs, for example, on the local system.
In certain embodiments, separation of de-identified and identified patient data facilitates broader analysis of patient populations without breaching individual patient security. Population-based analysis may be performed safely while maintaining patient privacy. Re-identification may occur at the local system level to allow a patient's healthcare provider to diagnose, treat and/or provide other services to the patient.
Thus, broader analysis of patient information may be allowed while at the same time respecting patient privacy. Communities of health care providers may benchmark, and compare patient populations without compromising patient privacy. At the same time, a patient's provider may re-identify patients from within the patient populations at the local level that are hosted/presented by the encrypted site. Re-identification algorithms may be stored locally at the healthcare provider level, for example. This physical separation may limit a potential risk of other providers who are viewing de-identified data on a portal from viewing patient identifiable information.
Certain embodiments allow for patient information to be shared with interested parties without compromising patient privacy. In the broader healthcare space, there will be applications where researchers, government agencies, communities of practice, may want to study patient populations but are, as of now, restricted because no good mechanism exists to work with source data providers in de-identifying and re-identifying patients. Certain embodiments facilitate such interaction. For example, decrypted information may be re-identified and then consumed by or imported into a patient's provider system within Microsof™ Excel, Centricity Physician Office EMR application and/or other application. Other entities, such as researchers and agencies, may view and/or manipulate the encrypted or de-identified data with reduced risk of compromising patient privacy.
The components of the system 600 may be implemented alone or in combination in hardware, firmware, and/or as a set of instructions in software, for example. Certain embodiments may be provided as a set of instructions residing on a computer-readable medium, such as a memory, hard disk, DVD, or CD, for execution on a general purpose computer or other processing device. Certain components may be integrated in various forms and/or may be provided as software and/or other functionality on a computing device, such as a computer. Certain embodiments may omit one or more of the components of the system 600 to execute the re-identification and/or de-identification functions and communicate data between a local user and a data store.
In operation, the workstation 610 or other processor may request data via the web portal 620 or other web service. For example, a user at the workstation 610 requests patient-related data via a web browser that accesses the web portal 620. The web portal 620 communicates with the data store 630 via a data link 640. For example, the web portal 620 requests the data from the data store 630, such as from an EMR data mart, via a network, such as the Internet or a private network. The data store 630 returns the requested data to the workstation 610 via the web portal 620. The data may include non-HIPAA-protected data, de-identified/encrypted patient data, re-identified patient data, and/or other data, for example.
The user workstation 610 may communicate with the display 650 to display data transmitted from the data store 630. Data may also be printed and/or used to generate a file, for example. The workstation 610 may also communicate with the data server 660 to transmit the data and/or other update, for example.
In certain embodiments, a de-identified patient report is transmitted to the workstation 610 from the data store 630 via the web portal 620 in response to a request from the workstation 610. The workstation 610 performs a re-identification of the de-identified patient data locally at the workstation 610. The re-identification may be performed via lookup of an EPID to determine a corresponding PID or other similar technique, for example. The re-identification functionality may be integrated into a document viewing/editing program, such as Microsoft Excel, Microsoft Word, and/or other software, for example. The re-identification function may access data in an external source, such as the data store 630 and/or the data server 660, to match the EPID to the PID. In certain embodiments, the EPID is replaced with the PID and/or other patient identifying information (e.g., patient name) in a document at the workstation 610.
In certain embodiments, the workstation 610 may first authenticate a privilege or right of access via the server 660, for example, before the patient data is re-identified. The workstation 610 may also lookup patient and/or provider attributes via the server 660 and/or data store 630, for example.
While the invention has been described with reference to exemplary embodiments, it will be understood by those skilled in the art that various changes may be made and equivalents may be substituted for elements thereof without departing from the scope of the invention. In addition, many modifications may be made to adapt a particular situation or material to the teachings of the invention without departing from the essential scope thereof. Therefore, it is intended that the invention not be limited to the particular embodiment disclosed as the best mode contemplated for carrying out this invention, but that the invention will include all embodiments falling within the scope of the appended claims. Moreover, the use of the terms first, second, etc. do not denote any order or importance, but rather the terms first, second, etc. are used to distinguish one element from another.
This application relates to and claims priority from, as a continuation-in-part, U.S. patent application Ser. No. 10/420,218, entitled “Method, System and Computer Product for Securing Patient Identity,” filed on Apr. 22, 2003, which is herein incorporated by reference in its entirety. The application also relates to and claims priority from U.S. Provisional Application No. 60/795,453, entitled “Systems and Methods for Patient Re-Identification,” filed on Apr. 27, 2006, which is herein incorporated by reference in its entirety.
| Number | Date | Country | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 60795453 | Apr 2006 | US |
| Number | Date | Country | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Parent | 10420218 | Apr 2003 | US |
| Child | 11469747 | Sep 2006 | US |
