Systems and methods for producing fluorocarbons

Information

  • Patent Grant
  • 7368089
  • Patent Number
    7,368,089
  • Date Filed
    Monday, February 28, 2005
    20 years ago
  • Date Issued
    Tuesday, May 6, 2008
    17 years ago
Abstract
Systems and methods for producing fluorocarbons are provided that include contacting a saturated halogenated fluorocarbon with hydrogen and catalyst to produce a saturated hydrofluorocarbon and an unsaturated fluorocarbon. Aspects of the present invention describe systems and methods for contacting saturated halogenated fluorocarbons such as CF3CClFCF3 and/or CF3CCl2CF3 with hydrogen and catalyst. Systems and methods of the present invention also describe contacting saturated halogenated fluorocarbons with catalysts having one or more of K, Zr, Na, Ni, Cu, Ni, Zn, Fe, Mn, Co, Ti, and Pd. Aspects of the present invention also describe contacting saturated halogenated fluorocarbons with hydrogen under pressure. Saturated hydroflourocarbons and unsaturated fluorocarbons produced in accordance with the systems and methods of the present invention can include one or more of CF3CFHCF3, CF3CH2CF3, CF3CHClCF3, CF3CF═CF2, CF3CH═CF2, and CF3CCl═CF2.
Description
TECHNICAL FIELD

The present invention relates to the production of fluorocarbons. Aspects of the present invention relate to the production of saturated and unsaturated fluorocarbons.


BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION

Hydrofluorocarbons and fluoromonomers such as 1,1,1,2,3,3,3-heptafluoropropane (CF3CHFCF3, HFC-227ea) and hexafluoropropene (CF3CF═CF2, FC-1216, HFP) are commercially desired.


HFP is widely employed as a monomer for the production of fluorine-containing polymers, for example, the thermoplastic FEP (“fluorinated-ethylene-propylene”) resins, formed via the copolymerization of tetrafluoroethylene and hexafluoropropene (see for example, Fluorine Chemistry: A Comprehensive Treatment, M. Howe-Grant, ed., Wiley & Sons, New York, N.Y., 1995, page 404).


HFC-227ea has found use as a blowing agent (U.S. Pat. No. 5,314,926; U.S. Pat. No. 5,278,196), refrigerant (Chen, J., Sci. Tech. Froid (1994), (2 CFCS, the Day After), 133-145), and propellant for use in metered dose inhalers (Clark, R., Aerosol. Sci. Technol., (1995) 22, 374-391). The compound has also found widespread use as a fire suppression agent, for example, the protection of telecommunication facilities where it is marketed under the tradename FM-200® (Great Lakes Chemical Corporation, Indianapolis, Ind.) (Robin, M. L., Process Safety Progress, Volume 19, No. 2 (Summer 2000), p. 107-111).


Numerous methods are disclosed in the prior art for the preparation of halogenated compounds. These methods vary widely, due in part to the different halogens and functional groups involved. The prior art demonstrates that known methods do not readily translate into predictable applications for other compounds.


Methods have been reported for the production of FC-1216. These processes include the thermal cracking of tetrafluoroethylene (TFE) at reduced pressure and temperatures of 700C to 800C as well as the pyrolysis of polytetrafluoroethylene under vacuum at elevated temperatures can yield HFP.


Methods have been reported for the production of HFC-227ea. The vapor phase reaction between HFP and HF over an active carbon catalyst can produce HFC-227ea (GB 902,590). HFC-227ea has also been produced via the treatment of 1,1,1,3,3,3-hexafluoropropane (CF3CH2CF3, HFC-236fa) with elemental fluorine (U.S. Pat. No. 5,780,691) and via the treatment of 2-chloro-1,1,1,3,3,3-hexafluoropropane (CFC-217ba) with HF (WO 99/40053).


It is desired to develop new methods and systems for economically favorable production of HFP and HFC-227ea, and it would be desired for such methods and systems to have broad utility for the production of saturated and unsaturated fluorocarbons.


SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION

Systems for producing fluorocarbons are provided that include, in some aspects, a reactant stream comprising a saturated halogenated fluorocarbon, a reactor configured to bring the saturated halogenated fluorocarbon into reactive proximity with a catalyst that includes Cu and Pd, and a product stream comprising saturated and unsaturated fluorocarbons.


According to an aspect of the present invention, methods for preparing fluorinated compounds are described that include contacting a reactant mixture that includes a C-3 saturated halogenated fluorocarbon and hydrogen with a catalyst having Pd and one or both of Ni and Cu. Such forms a mixture that includes a C-3 saturated hydrofluorocarbon and a C-3 unsaturated fluorocarbon.


In an aspect of the present invention, methods are described for contacting CF3CCl2CF3 with hydrogen in the presence of a catalyst to produce a mixture that includes one or more of CF3CH2CF3, CF3CHClCF3, CF3CH═CF2, and CF3CCl═CF2.


Methods for preparing fluorinated compounds are also described that include contacting a reactant mixture comprising a C-3 saturated halogenated fluorocarbon and hydrogen with a catalyst having one or more of K, Zr, Na, Ni, Cu, W, Zn, Fe, Mn, Co, Ti, and Pd to form a mixture that includes a C-3 unsaturated fluorocarbon and at least about 35% C-3 saturated hydrofluorocarbon.


Aspects of the present invention also provide methods for producing fluorocarbons that include contacting a reactant mixture comprising CF3CClFCF3 and hydrogen with a catalyst system that includes about 9:1 Cu to Pd (weight ratio) and activated carbon.


Aspects of the present invention can also include contacting a reaction mixture comprising CF3CClFCF3 with a catalyst system that includes about 9:1 Cu to Pd (weight ratio) for about 9 to about 55 seconds at a pressure of about 1.0 kg/cm2 to about 10 kg/cm2 and at a temperature of about 220° C. to about 350° C. to form a mixture comprising CF3CHFCF3 and CF3CF═CF2.





BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

Preferred embodiments of the invention are described below with reference to the following accompanying drawings.



FIG. 1. is a diagram of an exemplary system for fluorocarbon production in accordance with an aspect of the present invention.



FIG. 2. is a diagram of an exemplary system for fluorocarbon production in accordance with another aspect of the present invention.





DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS

This disclosure of the invention is submitted in furtherance of the constitutional purposes of the U.S. Patent Laws “to promote the progress of science and useful arts” (Article 1, Section 8).


In one embodiment of the present invention, methods and systems are described for producing a co-stream of two products. Aspects of the present invention will be described with reference to FIGS. 1 and 2.



FIG. 1 depicts a fluorination reaction system 1 that includes a reactor 3, saturated halogenated fluorocarbon reactant 5, hydrogenation reactant 7, and product 9. Examples of saturated halogenated fluorocarbon 5 that can be utilized in accordance of the present invention include those saturated halogenated fluorocarbons that are fully halogenated, as well as, those that are less than fully halogenated. According to an aspect of the present invention, saturated halogenated fluorocarbon 5 includes C-3 saturated halogenated fluorocarbons. Examples of saturated halogenated fluorocarbon include CF3CClFCF3 (CFC-217ba) and/or CF3CCl2CF3 (CFC-216aa).


Hydrogenation reactant 7 can include hydrogen. An exemplary hydrogenation reactant 7 includes diatomic hydrogen.


Generally, saturated halogenated fluorocarbon reactant 5 and hydrogenation reactant 7 can together form all or part of a reactant mixture and/or a reactant stream. As depicted in FIG. 1, saturated halogenated fluorocarbon reactant 5 and hydrogenation reactant 7 are provided to reactor 3 via independent streams. The present invention should not be so limited. Saturated halogenated fluorocarbon reactant 5 and hydrogenation reactant 7 may be combined prior to being transferred to reactor 3 or may be provided to reactor 3 via separate streams as illustrated.


Saturated halogenated fluorocarbon 5 may also be combined with hydrogenation reactant 7 at particular mole ratios. An aspect of the present invention provides combining hydrogenation reactant 7 and saturated halogenated fluorocarbon 5 at a mole ratio of hydrogenation reactant 7 to saturated halogenated fluorocarbon 5 from about 1:1 to about 20:1. Exemplary mole ratios of hydrogenation reactant 7 to saturated halogenated fluorocarbon 5 also include about 2.5:1 to about 20:1, about 1:1 to about 15:1, about 2:1 to about 10:1, and/or about 1:1 to about 5:1.


Aspects of the present invention also provide for the addition of a diluent. FIG. 2 illustrates a system 20 for preparing fluorocarbons according to the present invention that includes saturated halogenated fluorocarbon reactant 5, hydrogenation reactant 7, and diluent 13. Examples of diluent 13 that can be used in accordance with the present invention include hydrogen, helium, and argon gases, as well as, compounds such as CF3CFHCF3 (HFC-227ea) and CF3CH2F (HFC-134a). Diluent 13 can be utilized in combination with hydrogenation reactant 7 and saturated halogenated fluorocarbon 5 at particular mole ratios. Examples of mole ratios useful in accordance with the present invention are diluent 13 to hydrogenation reactant 7 to saturated halogenated fluorocarbon reactant 5 ratios of from about 2:0.6:1 to about 15:5:1 and/or from about 3:1:1 to about 14:2.5:1.


Referring again to FIG. 1, the reactant mixture can be contacted with a catalyst 11 within a reactor 3. According to aspects of the present invention, reactor 3 is configured to bring the reactant mixture into reactive proximity with catalyst 11. Reactor 3 can include, but are not limited to, reactors such as those manufactured of Inconel® (INCO ALLOYS INTERNATIONAL, INC, Delaware) and configured to perform chemical reactions on a laboratory or industrial scale.


Catalyst 11 can comprise, consist essentially of, and/or consist of one or more catalyst precursors such as K, Zr, Na, Ni, W, Cu, Zn, Fe, Mn, Co, Ti, and Pd. In particular aspects, catalyst 11 comprises, consists essentially of, and/or consists of Pd and one or both of Ni and Cu. Catalyst 11 may include Cu and Pd at a weight ratio of Cu to Pd of from about 3:1 to about 28:1, about 8:1 to about 28:1, and/or a weight ratio of Cu to Pd of about 9:1. Catalyst 11 can be in pure or supported form. Examples of supports that can be utilized in accordance with the present invention include activated carbon, aluminum oxide, and/or silica gel supports. An exemplary activated carbon support includes Tekeda® activated carbon (Takeda Chemical Industries, Ltd., Higashi-ku, Osaka JAPAN).


Typically catalysts can be prepared according to accepted catalyst preparation techniques. Exemplary techniques include dissolving the selected catalyst precursor in a suitable solvent with or without support, removing solvent from the catalyst and/or support, and loading the reactor with the catalyst. Once in the reactor, the catalyst can be further prepared by heating the reactor and monitoring the evolution of solvent from the catalyst. The catalyst may be prepared and/or activated in the presence of gases such as hydrogen, helium, argon, and/or nitrogen.


The present invention also provides specific temperatures, pressures, and contact times within the reactor to facilitate the production of fluorocarbons. Systems and methods of the present invention also provide for contacting the reactant mixture with catalyst 11 within reactor 3 for specific amounts of time. This time is typically referred to as contact time and can be calculated from the flow rates of the reactants and the volume of the reactor containing catalyst. Exemplary contact times useful in accordance with the present invention can be from about 4 to about 75 seconds, from about 9 to about 55 seconds, from about 6 to about 30 seconds, and/or from about 10 to about 15 seconds.


In an exemplary aspect, the reaction temperature during contacting of catalyst 11 with the reaction mixture can be from about 100° C. to about 500° C., about 200° C. to about 400° C., about 220° C. to about 350° C. and/or about 220° C. to about 300° C.


Methods also provide for contacting the reactant mixture with catalyst 11 at pressures from about 1 kg/cm2 to about 150 kg/cm2, about 5 kg/cm2 to about 10 kg/cm2, or about 3 kg/cm2 to about 8 kg/cm2.


Referring to FIGS. 1 and 2, systems are depicted for producing a product mixture 9. Product mixture 9 can include saturated fluorocarbons such as hydrofluorocarbons and C-3 saturated hydrofluorocarbons. Exemplary components of product mixture 9 can include CF3CFHCF3 (HFC-227ea), CF3CH2CF3 (HFC-236fa), and/or CF3CHClCF3 (CFC-226da). Product mixture 9 also includes an unsaturated fluorocarbon that can include C-3 unsaturated hydrofluorocarbons such as one or more of CF3CF═CF2 (HFP, FC-1215yc), CF3CH═CF2 (PFP, FC-1215zc), and/or CF3CCl═CF2 (CFC-1215xc). Exemplary aspects of the present invention include product mixtures that include CF3CHFCF3 (HFC-227ea) and CF3CF═CF2 (FC-1215yc). Other exemplary aspects of the present invention include product mixtures that include one or more of CF3CH2CF3 (HFC-236fa), CF3CHClCF3 (CFC-226da), CF3CH═CF2 (FC-1215zc), and/or CF3CCl═CF2 (CFC-1215xc). Aspects of the present invention also provide product mixture 9 that can be at least about 35% saturated fluorocarbon.


Aspects of the present invention are further described with reference to the following non-limiting examples.


Catalyst Preparation


Catalysts utilized in the subsequent examples are prepared in accordance with the following methods.


Method A

The catalyst is prepared by weighing amounts of Takeda® activated carbon support and catalyst precursor into a beaker. Enough water, as a solvent, is added to cover the support and precursor and the mixture is stirred for approximately 15 minutes. The mixture is filtered under water aspirator pressure, and the catalyst is allowed to air dry. The catalyst is packed into the reactor and is heated at 150° C. under a N2 stream until no water vapor is visibly apparent exiting the reactor. The heat is then increased to 200° C. until again no water vapor is visibly apparent exiting the reactor.


Method B

The catalyst is prepared by weighing amounts of Takeda® activated carbon support and catalyst precursor into a beaker. Enough CH2Cl2, as a solvent, is added to cover the support and precursor, and the mixture is stirred for approximately 15 minutes. The mixture is filtered under water aspirator pressure and the catalyst is allowed to air dry. The catalyst is packed into the reactor and is heated at 150° C. under a N2 stream until no vapor is visibly apparent exiting the reactor. The heat is then increased to 200° C. until no vapor is visibly apparent exiting the reactor.


Method C

The catalyst is prepared by weighing amounts of Takeda® activated carbon support and catalyst precursor into a beaker. Enough water, as a solvent, is added to cover the support and precursor and the mixture is stirred for approximately 15 minutes. Sufficient NaOH is added to make the mixture alkaline (pH≧12). The mixture is then chilled in an ice bath to 10° C. NaBH4 dissolved in NaOH is added drop-wise until reduction of the catalyst is achieved. The mixture is then heated to boiling until a dry catalyst remained. The catalyst mixture is then filtered and rinsed twice with water before being dried in vacuum oven for approximately 1.5 hours. The catalyst is then packed into a reactor and dried as in Method A.


Method D

The catalyst is prepared by weighing amounts of Takeda® activated carbon support and catalyst precursor into a beaker. Sufficient 5% (wt./wt.) HCl/water solution is added to the beaker to cover the support and precursor, and the mixture is heated to 100° C. for approximately 20 minutes. The mixture is then filtered, packed and dried as described in Method A.


Method E

The catalyst is prepared by weighing amounts of catalyst precursor into a beaker and covering with 5% (wt./wt.) HCl/water solution to form a mixture. The mixture is heated to 100° C. for approximately 20 minutes. To complete the catalyst, sufficient Takeda® activated carbon support to achieve the weight percent indicated is then added to the hot solution. The mixture is then hot filtered and dried as in Method A.


Method F

A catalyst of Cu, Pd, and support is prepared by weighing an amount of the catalyst precursor Cu into a beaker containing water. The solution is heated, and the percent Cu dissolved in the solution is then determined periodically until sufficient Cu is dissolved in the solution. Catalyst precursor Pd is weighed and placed in a beaker containing water. The solution is heated and the percent Pd dissolved in the solution is then determined periodically until sufficient Pd is dissolved in the solution. The Cu and Pd solutions are combined in a beaker to yield the desired ratios. Sufficient Takeda® activated carbon support is added and the solution stirred. The catalyst is air-dried and packed into the reactor and dried as described in Method A.


Method G

A catalyst of catalyst precursor is packed into the reactor. The reactor is heated to 350° C., and H2 is passed over the catalyst at 126 cc/min for 16 hours.


Method H

A solution of 5% (wt./wt.) HCl and water is added to the catalyst precursor in a sufficient amount to wet the catalyst precursor. The wet catalyst is then dried under a N2 stream overnight before being packed and dried as in Method A.


Method I

Catalyst is prepared as in Method E with the additional steps of reapplying the hot filtrate to the catalyst at least twice.


General Reaction Procedures


The reactor of examples 1-8 is a 36.20 cm long Inconel® tube with 1.27 cm outside diameter and a 33.0 cc volume. The reactor is mounted vertically in a Hoskins® (Hoskins Manufacturing Company Corporation. Hamburg, Mich.) electric furnace with a 30.5 cm heated zone controlled with a Watlow® (Watlow Electric Manufacturing Company, St. Louis, Mo.) series 956 temperature control unit. The reactor is equipped with internal and external thermocouples and a pressure gauge. Reactants are fed through calibrated Matheson® (Matheson Gas Products, Inc., Valley Forge, Pa.) flow meters and premixed before entering the heated zone.


Hydrogen is fed through a calibrated Hastings® (Teledyne Hastings Instruments, Teledyne Technologies, Inc., Los Angeles, Calif.) mass flow controller model HFC-202c with model 400 Hastings® power supply. CFC-217ba is fed with calibrated Eldex® (Eldex Laboratories, Inc., Napa, Calif.) metering pumps models A-60-S or B-100-S. The reactants are premixed and heated in a vaporizer before entering the reactor. Pressure is controlled with a proportional valve, driver module, and a Watlow® series 956 control unit. The exit gases are scrubbed through water, passed over Drierite® (W.A. Hammond Drierite Co., Xenia, Ohio), and analyzed by gas chromatography using a Hewlett-Packard® (Hewlett-Packard Company, Palo Alto, Calif.) 5890 series II gas chromatograph equipped with a 30 m×0.32 mm ID silicaplot™ (Varian, Inc., Palo Alto, Calif.) fused silica column and a flame ionization detector. Results are reported herein in area % of total area of response recorded by detector.


EXAMPLE 1
Potassium Catalysts














TABLE 1







Catalyst
Cat.
Temp.
Contact Time
H2/CFC-217

% Selectivity















Precursor
Prep.
(° C.)
(sec)
Mole Ratio
% Conversion
HFP
HFC-227
Total


















10% KCl
A
200
11.5
6.4
19.3
46.4
37.2
83.6


10% KCl
A
250
18.7
3.9
45.6
52.0
19.8
71.9


10% KCl
A
300
14.5
3
63.9
13.7
57.1
70.8






















TABLE 2







Catalyst
Cat.

Contact Time
H2/CFC-217

% Selectivity















Precursor
Prep.
Temp. (° C.)
(sec)
Mole Ratio
% Conversion
HFP
HFC-227
Total


















10% KF
A
300
10.6
4.1
6.9
6.2
65.9
72.1


10% KF
A
250
9.7
4.4
7.22
8.1
66.6
74.7


10% KF
A
300
9.6
7.1
14.0
49.3
27.5
76.8


10% KF
A
350
3.4
5.2
59.6
29.5
31.7
61.1


10% KF
A
400
7.9
5.6
38.7
24.7
20.4
55.0









EXAMPLE 2
Zirconium Catalysts














TABLE 3







Catalyst
Cat.

Contact Time
H2/CFC-217

% Selectivity















Precursor
Prep.
Temp. (° C.)
(sec)
Mole Ratio
% Conversion
HFP
HFC-227
Total


















10% ZrCl2
A
200
11.5
4.1
25.31
38.0
56.1
94.1


10% ZrCl2
A
250
10.3
8.2
66.18
46.1
36.1
82.3


10% ZrCl2
A
300
9.5
6.8
36.43
38.9
36.6
75.5


10% ZrCl2
A
350
8.8
7.3
93.63
18.7
47.4
66.1






















TABLE 4







Catalyst
Cat.

Contact Time
H2/CFC-217

% Selectivity















Precursor
Prep.
Temp. (° C.)
(sec)
Mole Ratio
% Conversion
HFP
HFC-227
Total


















10% ZrCl4
B
200
12.3
12.7
22.95
27.8
21.0
48.8


10% ZrCl4
B
250
11.3
15.4
41.42
46.0
25.3
71.3


10% ZrCl4
B
300
10.5
22.6
76.96
29.9
35.5
65.5


10% ZrCl4
B
350
9.2
11.4
95.19
18.5
44.2
62.7






















TABLE 5







Catalyst
Cat.
Temp.
Contact Time
H2/CFC-217

% Selectivity















Precursor
Prep.
(° C.)
(sec)
Mole Ratio
% Conversion
HFP
HFC-227
Total


















10% CuZrCl2
B
200
12.2
11.8
18.24
30.6
61.3
91.9


10% CuZrCl2
B
250
11.1
11.6
40.41
59.8
28.7
88.5


10% CuZrCl2
B
300
9.2
11.2
40.47
49.3
35.6
84.9


10% CuZrCl2
B
350
9.4
13.3
37.6
46.6
36.9
83.5


10% CuZrCl2
B
400
7.6
11.8
31.24
28.0
52.8
80.9


10% CuZrCl2
B
500
7.6
14.7
31.84
4.0
32.0
36.1









EXAMPLE 3
Tungsten Catalysts














TABLE 6







Catalyst
Cat.
Temp.
Contact Time
H2/CFC-217

% Selectivity















Precursor
Prep.
(° C.)
(sec)
Mole Ratio
% Conversion
HFP
HFC-227
Total


















10% NaW
A
200
12.1
10.3
23.1
44.5
40.3
84.7


10% NaW
A
250
11
11.5
49.98
56.0
25.8
81.8


10% NaW
A
300
10
10.1
95.19
40.2
27.0
87.2


10% NaW
A
350
9.1
9.7
94.98
30.5
28.3
58.8









EXAMPLE 4
Support














TABLE 7








Cat.
Temp.
Contact Time
H2/CFC-217

% Selectivity















Catalyst
Prep.
(° C.)
(sec)
Mole Ratio
% Conversion
HFP
HFC-227
Total


















Activated
A
250
10.9
9.5
23.5
52.5
37.9
90.4


Carbon


Activated
A
300
9.8
9
34.55
13.6
23.3
37.0


Carbon


Activated
A
350
8.8
6.9
55.85
42.5
30.2
72.6


Carbon


Activated
A
350
9.2
11
33.8
39.9
34.6
74.5


Carbon









EXAMPLE 5
Nickel Catalysts














TABLE 8







Catalyst
Cat.
Temp.
Contact Time
H2/CFC-217

% Selectivity















Precursor
Prep.
(° C.)
(sec)
Mole Ratio
% Conversion
HFP
HFC-227
Total


















NiF2
A
200
12.2
11.8
45.8
57.0
8.0
65.0


NiF2
A
250
10.8
9.1
64.9
54.6
23.3
78.0


NiF2
A
250
17.1
4.2
30.1
67.9
18.8
76.8






















TABLE 9







Catalyst
Cat.
Temp.
Contact Time
H2/CFC-217

% Selectivity















Precursor
Prep.
(° C.)
(sec)
Mole Ratio
% Conversion
HFP
HFC-227
Total


















10% NiCl2
C
200
11.8
7.9
67.0-3
44.3
43.7
87.9


10% NiCl2
C
250
10.7
8.4
49.55
60.5
23.8
84.3


10% NiCl2
C
300
10
10.6
81.11
57.6
23.4
81.0


10% NiCl2
C
350
9.1
9.4
73.81
65.8
6.5
72.3


10% NiCl2
C
350
9.3
12
57.52
61.1
20.5
81.6






















TABLE 10







Catalyst
Cat.
Temp.
Contact Time
H2/CFC-217

% Selectivity















Precursor
Prep.
(° C.)
(sec)
Mole Ratio
% Conversion
HFP
HFC-227
Total


















10% NiF2
D
200
6.4
9.9
96.86
34.5
62.1
96.6


10% NiF2
D
250
7.8
2.5
92.9
48.6
27.9
76.5


10% NiF2
D
250
5.5
10.2
79.46
65.0
22.9
87.9






















TABLE 11







Catalyst
Cat.
Temp.
Contact Time
H2/CFC-217

% Selectivity















Precursor
Prep.
(° C.)
(sec)
Mole Ratio
% Conversion
HFP
HFC-227
Total


















10% Ni(O)
A
250
5.3
7.4
99.12
24.6
67.6
92.2


10% Ni(O)
A
250
7.2
5.8
98.19
29.6
49.7
79.4


10% Ni(O)
A
250
12.6
4.8
98.74
22.6
60.3
82.9






















TABLE 12







Catalyst
Cat.
Temp.
Contact Time
H2/CFC-217

% Selectivity















Precursor
Prep.
(° C.)
(sec)
Mole Ratio
% Conversion
HFP
HFC-227
Total





10% Nickel
B
200
11.7
7.4
60.73
51.9
38.9
90.8


acetylacetonate


10% Nickel
B
250
10.8
9.3
69.64
57.8
21.1
78.8


acetylacetonate


10% Nickel
B
300
10.1
5.5
97.33
55.1
20.3
75.4


acetylacetonate


















TABLE 13









% Selectivity















Catalyst
Cat.
Temp.
Contact Time
H2/CFC-217


HFC-



Precursor
Prep.
(° C.)
(sec)
Mole Ratio
% Conversion
HFP
227ea
Total


















10%
B
200
12
9.3
72.85
45.4
41.0
86.4


Bis(tripheylphosphine)


nickel (11)


bromide


10%
B
250
9.4
12.7
41.19
62.3
21.5
83.8


Bis(tripheylphosphine)


nickel (11)


bromide


10%
B
300
9.8
8.8
78.12
43.2
28.6
71.8


Bis(tripheylphosphine)


nickel (11)


bromide






















TABLE 14







Catalyst
Cat.
Temp.
Cont.
H2/CFC-216
%
% Selectivity
















Precursor
Prep.
(° C.)
Time (sec)
Mole Ratio
Conv.
PFP
HFC-236fa
CFC-1215xc
CFC-226da



















10% NiCl2
C
250
10.7
10.3
56.6
5.91
nd
22.3
60.6


10% NiCl2
C
350
8.2
12.5
100
46.3
16.0
nd
2.6









EXAMPLE 6
Nickel/Palladium Catalysts














TABLE 15







Catalyst
Cat.
Temp.
Contact Time
H2/CFC-217

% Selectivity















Precursor
Prep.
(° C.)
(sec)
Mole Ratio
% Conversion
HFP
HFC-227
Total


















NiF2/Pd(O) (5%
A
200
13.3
3.5
27.04
12.9
50.2
63.1


Ni/0.5% Pd)


NiF2/Pd(O) (5%
A
250
11
10.7
82.65
12.6
70.7
83.3


Ni/0.5% Pd)


NiF2/Pd(O) (5%
A
300
8.9
8.9
81.99
2.1
79.9
82.0


Ni/0.5% Pd)






















TABLE 16







Catalyst
Cat.
Temp.
Contact Time
H2/CFC-217

% Selectivity















Precursor
Prep.
(° C.)
(sec)
Mole Ratio
% Conversion
HFP
HFC-227
Total


















NiF2/PdCl2
A
200
11.6
7.1
87.3
1.0
82.8
83.8


(1.12%


Ni/0.24% Pd)


NiF2/PdCl2
A
250
10.8
9.4
72.48
7.1
74.3
81.4


(1.12%


Ni/0.24% Pd)


NiF2/PdCl2
A
350
7.6
8.4
97.22
54.8
33.8
88.5


(1.12%


Ni/0.24% Pd)


NiF2/PdCl2
A
350
9.1
9.6
76.1
43.1
41.2
84.4


(1.12%


Ni/0.24% Pd)









EXAMPLE 7
Copper Catalyst














TABLE 17







Catalyst
Cat.
Temp.
Contact Time
H2/CFC-217

% Selectivity















Precursor
Prep.
(° C.)
(sec)
Mole Ratio
% Conversion
HFP
HFC-227
Total


















10% CuCl
A
200
11
5.0
34.27
40.0
55.7
95.6


10% CuCl
A
250
8.3
2.2
39.63
57.3
37.2
94.5






















TABLE 18







Catalyst
Cat.
Temp.
Contact Time
H2/CFC-217

% Selectivity















Precursor
Prep.
(° C.)
(sec)
Mole Ratio
% Conversion
HFP
HFC-227
Total


















10% CuF2
D
200
6.6
9.3
26.34
41.8
43.1
84.9


10% CuF2
D
250
5.8
6.6
56.18
14.0
77.8
91.8


10% CuF2
D
300
5.3
7
90.72
47.5
46.6
94.1


10% CuF2
D
300
5
7.5
31.48
71.8
24.6
96.4


10% CuF2
D
300
5.1
8.5
58.09
60.5
36.4
96.9









EXAMPLE 8
Copper/Palladium Catalysts














TABLE 19







Catalyst
Cat.
Temp.
Contact Time
H2/CFC-217

% Selectivity















Precursor
Prep.
(° C.)
(sec)
Mole Ratio
% Conversion
HFP
HFC-227
Total


















CuF2/PdCl2(5.51%
A
250
10.2
12.8
49.86
28.9
69.4
98.3


Cu/0.42% Pd)


CuF2/PdCl2(5.51%
A
250
10.2
12.8
94.98
30.2
68.6
98.8


Cu/0.42% Pd)


CuF2/PdCl2(5.51%
A
250
14
13/4
97.3
33.0
66.0
99.0


Cu/0.42% Pd)


CuF2/PdCl2(5.51%
A
250
12.9
6.2
69.05
29.5
69.2
98.6


Cu/0.42% Pd)


CuF2/PdCl2(5.51%
A
300
11.1
4.4
94.94
33.2
64.9
98.1


Cu/0.42% Pd)


CuF2/PdCl2(5.51%
A
300
8.2
5.4
92.8
38.7
59.8
98.5


Cu/0.42% Pd)






















TABLE 20







Catalyst
Cat.
Temp.
Contact Time
H2/CFC-217

% Selectivity















Precursor
Prep.
(° C.)
(sec)
Mole Ratio
% Conversion
HFP
HFC-227
Total


















CuF2/PdCl2(11.01%
A
200
10.4
7.4
42.1
35.6
62.0
97.6


Cu/0.65% Pd)


CuF2/PdCl2(11.01%
A
250
10.9
6.8
96.23
38.9
59.2
98.2


Cu/0.65% Pd)


CuF2/PdCl2(11.01%
A
250
9.5
8.6
98.37
37.0
61.8
98.8


Cu/0.65% Pd)






















TABLE 21







Catalyst
Cat.
Temp.
Contact Time
H2/CFC-217

% Selectivity















Precursor
Prep.
(° C.)
(sec)
Mole Ratio
% Conversion
HFP
HFC-227
Total


















CuF2/PdCl2(5.51%
A
200
11.8
8
73.36
22.4
72.1
94.6


Cu/0.65% Pd)


CuF2/PdCl2(5.51%
A
250
11.8
8
97.79
35.0
63.7
98.6


Cu/0.65% Pd)


CuF2/PdCl2(5.51%
A
250
12
9.4
97.3
40.61
58.03
98.6


Cu/0.65% Pd)


CuF2/PdCl2(5.51%
A
250
12
9.2
98.23
41.4
57.5
98.9


Cu/0.65% Pd)


















TABLE 22









% Selectivity















Catalyst
Cat.
Temp.
Contact Time
H2/CFC-217


HFC-



Precursor
Prep.
(° C.)
(sec)
Mole Ratio
% Conversion
HFP
227ea
Total


















CuF2/PdCl2(5.51%
D
250
11.4
6
99.24
32.5
64.6
97.1


Cu/0.675% Pd)


CuF2/PdCl2(5.51%
D
250
11.4
13.9
93.42
33.6
65.8
99.4


Cu/0.675% Pd)


CuF2/PdCl2(5.51%
D
250
12.5
15.1
99.23
33.1
47.3
30.4


Cu/0.675% Pd)


CuF2/PdCl2(5.51%
D
250
6.19
7.8
33.13
31.8
63.0
94.8


Cu/0.675% Pd)






















TABLE 23







Catalyst
Cat.
Temp.
Contact Time
H2/CFC-217

% Selectivity















Precursor
Prep.
(° C.)
(sec)
Mole Ratio
% Conversion
HFP
HFC-227
Total


















CuCl2/PdCl2(5.5%
H
230
9.5
6
93.27
40.7
58.0
98.7


Cu/0.6% Pd)


CuCl2/PdCl2(5.5%
H
230
9.5
6
90.04
43.9
55.0
98.8


Cu/0.6% Pd)


CuCl2/PdCl2(5.5%
H
230
9.6
4.5
68.24
41.3
57.8
99.1


Cu/0.6% Pd)






















TABLE 24







Catalyst
Cat.
Temp.
Contact Time
H2/CFC-217

% Selectivity















Precursor
Prep.
(° C.)
(sec)
Mole Ratio
% Conversion
HFP
HFC-227
Total


















CuCl2/PdCl2(5.5%
F
200
15.1
15.5
98.98
30.4
68.1
98.4


Cu/0.6% Pd)


CuCl2/PdCl2(5.5%
F
250
15.1
15.5
30.63
30.63
68.0
98.6


Cu/0.6% Pd)






















TABLE 25







Catalyst
Cat.
Temp.
Contact Time
H2/CFC-217

% Selectivity















Precursor
Prep.
(° C.)
(sec)
Mole Ratio
% Conversion
HFP
HFC-227
Total





CuCl2/PdCl2(5.5%
F
275
9.5
4.4
94.38
43.8
49.0
92.9


Cu/0.9% Pd)


CuCl2/PdCl2(5.5%
F
275
9.9
5.7
95.46
50.8
42.6
93.4


Cu/0.9% Pd)






















TABLE 26







Catalyst
Cat.
Temp.
Contact Time
H2/CFC-217

% Selectivity















Precursor
Prep.
(° C.)
(sec)
Mole Ratio
% Conversion
HFP
HFC-227
Total





CuCl2/PdCl2(2.0%
A
200
27.8
5.3
97.66
0.9
76.2
77.1


Cu/0.6% Pd)


CuCl2/PdCl2(2.0%
A
150
27.8
5.3
71.06
1.3
75.1
76.4


Cu/0.6% Pd)


CuCl2/PdCl2(2.0%
A
100
27.8
5.3
34.54
2.8
69.7
72.4


Cu/0.6% Pd)


CuCl2/PdCl2(2.0%
A
250
27.8
5.3
83.37
8.4
75.4
83.8


Cu/0.6% Pd)






















TABLE 27







Catalyst
Cat.
Temp.
Contact Time
H2/CFC-217

% Selectivity















Precursor
Prep.
(° C.)
(sec)
Mole Ratio
% Conversion
HFP
HFC-227
Total


















CuCl2/PdCl2(5.5%
C
200
9
5.2
53.58
29.3
69.4
98.7


Cu/0.6% Pd)


CuCl2/PdCl2(5.5%
C
250
9.3
6.2
39.48
45.9
52.9
98.8


Cu/0.6% Pd)


CuCl2/PdCl2(5.5%
C
230
9.7
3.6
72.3
44.4
54.6
99.0


Cu/0.6% Pd)


CuCl2/PdCl2(5.5%
C
230
16
4.7
75.81
46.8
52.2
99.0


Cu/0.6% Pd)


CuCl2/PdCl2(5.5%
C
230
21.8
3
30.54
36.1
62.9
99.0


Cu/0.6% Pd)


CuCl2/PdCl2(5.5%
C
230
35.4
1.2
88.17
26.71
71.21
97.9


Cu/0.6% Pd)






















TABLE 28







Catalyst
Cat.
Temp.
Contact Time
H2/CFC-217

% Selectivity















Precursor
Prep.
(° C.)
(sec)
Mole Ratio
% Conversion
HFP
HFC-227
Total


















CuF2/PdCl2(12.5%
I
250
8.9
6.8
91.67
35.4
63.5
98.9


Cu/1.4% Pd)


CuF2/PdCl2(12.5%
I
275
9.9
6.7
98.56
43.0
55.7
98.8


Cu/1.4% Pd)


CuF2/PdCl2(12.5%
I
300
5.1
9.5
97.46
50.7
48.2
98.9


Cu/1.4% Pd)


CuF2/PdCl2(12.5%
I
350
5
6.4
99.53
51.0
45.7
96.7


Cu/1.4% Pd)


CuF2/PdCl2(12.5%
I
350
4
5.7
98.59
53.6
43.4
97.0


Cu/1.4% Pd)


CuF2/PdCl2(12.5%
I
350
3
5.8
95.34
54.0
44.3
98.2


Cu/1.4% Pd)


CuF2/PdCl2(12.5%
I
350
2
5.8
86.29
52.6
45.6
98.2


Cu/1.4% Pd)






















TABLE 29







Catalyst
Cat.
Temp
Cont. Time
H2/CFC-216
%
% Selectivity
















Precursor
Prep.
(° C.)
(sec)
Mole Ratio
Conv.
PFP
HFC-236fa
CFC-1215xc
CFC-226da



















CuCl2/PdCl2(5.5%
C
100
11
11.8
99.9
38.6
28.6
28.6
nd


Cu/0.2% Pd)


CuCl2/PdCl2(5.5%
C
125
8.6
8.1
91.6
26.0
16.4
19.2
34.9


Cu/0.2% Pd)


CuCl2/PdCl2(5.5%
C
150
11.8
8.1
97.0
46.5
11.2
18.6
21.3


Cu/0.2% Pd)


CuCl2/PdCl2(5.5%
C
175
11.8
8.1
98.5
58.2
6.7
20.3
12.8


Cu/0.2% Pd)


CuCl2/PdCl2(5.5%
C
200
8.6
13
100
58.3
7.3
19.0
 8.5


Cu/0.2% Pd)


CuCl2/PdCl2(5.5%
C
270
6.8
12.2
100
27.7
12.4
36.4
20.2


Cu/0.2% Pd)


CuCl2/PdCl2(5.5%
C
380
14.4
7.7
100
84.8
8.8
1.7
nd


Cu/0.2% Pd)


CuCl2/PdCl2(5.5%
C
380
14.4
7.7
100
84.4
8.5
2.5
nd


Cu/0.2% Pd)


CuCl2/PdCl2(5.5%
C
400
7.5
10.4
100
60.0
3.2
28.3
nd


Cu/0.2% Pd)


CuCl2/PdCl2(5.5%
C
500
7.5
10.4
100
67.9
2.3
11.2
nd


Cu/0.2% Pd)









EXAMPLE 9
Zinc Catalysts














TABLE 30







Catalyst
Cat.
Temp.
Contact Time
H2/CFC-217

% Selectivity















Precursor
Prep.
(° C.)
(sec)
Mole Ratio
% Conversion
HFP
HFC-227
Total


















20% ZnCl2
A
300
12.8
6.4
100
46.46
46.46
92.92


20% ZnCl2
A
300
12.46
5.33
99.39
42.58
50.26
92.84


20% ZnCl2
A
300
12.33
4.57
74.38
39.54
51.64
91.18


20% ZnCl2
A
450
18.54
4
84.06
48.26
40.63
88.89


20% ZnCl2
A
450
14.37
5.5
83.83
24.11
55.02
79.13









EXAMPLE 10
Iron Catalysts














TABLE 31







Catalyst
Cat.
Temp.
Contact Time
H2/CFC-217

% Selectivity















Precursor
Prep.
(° C.)
(sec)
Mole Ratio
% Conversion
HFP
HFC-227
Total


















10% FeCl3
A
500
5.87
3.62
81.06
41.65
45.11
86.76


10% FeCl3
A
500
8.57
4.12
73.28
20.51
61.16
81.67


10% FeCl3
A
500
7.67
10.5
93.39
40.44
42.23
82.67









EXAMPLE 11
Manganese Catalysts














TABLE 32







Catalyst
Cat.
Temp.
Contact Time
H2/CFC-217

% Selectivity















Precursor
Prep.
(° C.)
(sec)
Mole Ratio
% Conversion
HFP
HFC-227
Total


















19% MnCl2
A
400
24.69
4.33
63.6
10.22
59.42
69.64


19% MnCl2
A
450
22.21
3
24.99
5.16
62.1
67.26


19% MnCl2
A
500
16.24
9.5
60.29
6.63
62.26
68.89









EXAMPLE 12
Cobalt Catalysts














TABLE 33







Catalyst
Cat.
Temp.
Contact Time
H2/CFC-217

% Selectivity















Precursor
Prep.
(° C.)
(sec)
Mole Ratio
% Conversion
HFP
HFC-227
Total


















20% CoCl2
A
400
24.14
4.33
36.26
9.16
63.38
72.54


20% CoCl2
A
500
16.69
9.5
99.05
38.99
34
72.99


20% CoCl2
A
500
16.59
9.5
99.66
29.22
33.23
62.45


20% CoCl2
A
500
14.36
3.8
69.14
10.67
69.51
80.18









EXAMPLE 13
Titanium Catalysts














TABLE 34







Catalyst
Cat.
Temp
Contact Time
H2/CFC-217

% Selectivity















Precursor
Prep.
(° C.)
(sec)
Mole Ratio
% Conversion
HFP
HFC-227
Total


















20%
B
200
12.12
4.22
2.66
17.67
6.39
24.06


bis(cyclopentadienyl)


titanium dichloride


20%
B
300
12.34
4.57
12.54
38.52
38.52
77.04


bis(cyclopentadienyl)


titanium dichloride


20%
B
400
24.25
4.33
42.72
17.09
38.95
56.04


bis(cyclopentadienyl)


titanium dichloride


20%
B
450
21.71
2.4
30.28
13.97
50.56
64.53


bis(cyclopentadienyl)


titanium dichloride


20%
B
500
16.39
9.5
98.21
14.8
53.99
38.79


bis(cyclopentadienyl)


titanium dichloride


20%
B
500
16.34
9.5
91.48
30.05
34.9
64.95


bis(cyclopentadienyl)


titanium dichloride









EXAMPLE 14
Reaction Pressure















TABLE 35







Catalyst
Cat.
Temp.
Pressure
Contact
H2/217 Mole

% Selectivity
















Precursor
Prep.
(C.)
(kg/cm2)
Time (sec)
Ratio
Conv. %
HFP
HFC-227
Total



















CuF2/PdCl2(11.01%
I
250
1
9.5
8.6
98.4
37.0
61.8
98.8


Cu/0.65% Pd)


CuF2/PdCl2(12.5%
I
275
1
10.4
6.7
97.8
40.1
58.9
99.0


Cu/1.4% Pd)


CuF2/PdCl2(12.5%
I
300
1
9.9
6.7
99.9
46.7
50.4
97.1


Cu/1.4% Pd)


CuF2/PdCl2(12.5%
I
350
1
3
5.8
95.3
54.0
44.3
98.2


Cu/1.4% Pd)


CuF2/PdCl2(5.5%
I
250
1
8.9
5.3
91.3
36.2
59.7
95.9


Cu/0.9% Pd)


CuF2/PdCl2(5.5%
I
300
1
9.1
4.2
91.5
50.0
44.9
94.9


Cu/0.9% Pd)


CuF2/PdCl2(5.5%
I
300
8
9.8
7.2
74.5
21.8
75.0
96.8


Cu/0.9% Pd)


CuF2/PdCl2(5%
I
350
8
3.8
4.9
42.6
28.0
70.5
98.4


Cu/0.6% Pd)









EXAMPLE 15
With Diluent
















TABLE 36







Catalyst
Cat.
Temp.
Pressure
Contact

Diluent:H2:217

% Selectivity

















Precursor
Prep.
(C.)
(kg/cm2)
Time (sec)
Diluent
Mole Ratio
Conv. %
HFP
227
Total




















CuCl2/PdCl2(5%
C
350
8.9
5.1
He
  6:1:1.1:1
59.3
32.8
63.7
96.5


Cu/0.6% Pd)


CuCl2/PdCl2(5%
C
350
6.1
16.7
He
2.3:0.38:1
56.7
26.4
68.5
94.9


Cu/0.6% Pd)


CuCl2/PdCl2(5%
C
350
6.1
13.1
HFC-134
9.8:1.9:1
90.8
35.7
62.3
98


Cu/0.6% Pd)


CuCl2/PdCl2(5%
C
350
6.4
10.8
HFC-227ea
 14:2.5:1
99.3
19.2
78.5
97.7


Cu/0.6% Pd)


CuCl2/PdCl2(5%
C
350
1
9.8
HFC-227ea
5.3:0.4:1
67.2
40.7
58.4
99.1


Cu/0.6% Pd)


CuCl2/PdCl2(5%
C
350
1
9.3
HFC-227ea
4.4:1.9:1
50.8
42.9
55.7
98.5


Cu/0.6% Pd)









In compliance with the statute, the invention has been described in language more or less specific as to structural and methodical features. It is to be understood, however, that the invention is not limited to the specific features shown and described, since the means herein disclosed comprise preferred forms of putting the invention into effect. The invention is, therefore, claimed in any of its forms or modifications within the proper scope of the appended claims appropriately interpreted in accordance with the doctrine of equivalents.

Claims
  • 1. A system for producing fluorocarbons comprising: a reactant stream comprising hydrogen and one or both of CF3CCl2CF3 and CF3CClFCF3;a reactor configured to bring the saturated halogenated fluorocarbon into reactive proximity with a catalyst, wherein the catalyst consists essentially of Cu and Pd, a weight ratio of Cu to Pd being from about 3:1 to about 28:1; anda product stream comprising:one or more of CF3CF═CF2, CF3CH═CF2, and CF3CCl═CF2; andone or more of CF3CFHCF3, CF3CH2CF3, and CF3CHClCF3.
  • 2. The system of claim 1 wherein the weight ratio of Cu to Pd is about 9:1.
  • 3. The system of claim 1 wherein the reactant stream consists essentially of CF3CClFCF3.
  • 4. The system of claim 1 wherein the reactant stream consists essentially of CF3CCl2CF3.
  • 5. The system of claim 1 wherein the product stream consists essentially of: one or both of CF3CFHCF3 and CF3CH2CF3; andone or both of CF3CF═CF2 and CF3CH═CF2.
  • 6. The system of claim 1 wherein the product stream consists essentially of CF3CFHCF3 and CF3CF═CF2.
  • 7. The system of claim 1 wherein the product stream comprises at least about 35% (wt./wt.) of the one or more of CF3CFHCF3, CF3CH2CF3, and CF3CHClCF3.
  • 8. The system of claim 1 wherein the catalyst further consists essentially of an activated carbon support.
  • 9. The system of claim 1 wherein a pressure within the reactor is maintained at from about 3 kg/cm2 to about 8 kg/cm2.
  • 10. The system of claim 1 wherein a temperature within the reactor is maintained at from about 220° C. to about 350° C.
Parent Case Info

This application is a divisional of U.S. application Ser. No. 10/641,527 filed on Aug. 13, 2003, and which is incorporated herein by reference.

US Referenced Citations (83)
Number Name Date Kind
1132636 Taylor et al. Mar 1915 A
1926395 Midgley, Jr. Sep 1933 A
1926396 Midgley, Jr. Sep 1933 A
2005706 Daudt et al. Jun 1935 A
2005707 Daudt et al. Jun 1935 A
2021981 Bichowsky Nov 1935 A
2413696 Downing et al. Jan 1947 A
2456028 Simons Dec 1948 A
2494064 Simons et al. Jan 1950 A
2519983 Simons Aug 1950 A
2576823 Benning et al. Nov 1951 A
2697124 Mantell et al. Dec 1954 A
2900423 Smith et al. Aug 1959 A
2942036 Smith et al. Jun 1960 A
3080430 Cohen Mar 1963 A
3258500 Swamer et al. Jun 1966 A
3436430 Hall et al. Apr 1969 A
3479286 Gambaretto et al. Nov 1969 A
3636173 Gardner Jan 1972 A
3656553 Rainaldi et al. Apr 1972 A
3715438 Huggett Feb 1973 A
3803241 Stolkin et al. Apr 1974 A
3822207 Howard et al. Jul 1974 A
3844354 Larsen Oct 1974 A
4014799 Owens Mar 1977 A
4158023 von Halasz Jun 1979 A
4225404 Dietrich et al. Sep 1980 A
4226728 Kung Oct 1980 A
4446923 Martin May 1984 A
4459213 Uchida et al. Jul 1984 A
4536298 Kamei et al. Aug 1985 A
4668407 Gerard et al. May 1987 A
4810403 Bivens et al. Mar 1989 A
4826610 Thacker May 1989 A
4851595 Gumprecht Jul 1989 A
4876405 Gervasutti Oct 1989 A
4885409 Gardano et al. Dec 1989 A
4937398 Tung et al. Jun 1990 A
4945119 Smits et al. Jul 1990 A
4954271 Green Sep 1990 A
4996374 Lin et al. Feb 1991 A
5040609 Dougherty et al. Aug 1991 A
5043491 Webster et al. Aug 1991 A
5057634 Webster et al. Oct 1991 A
5068472 Webster et al. Nov 1991 A
5068473 Kellner et al. Nov 1991 A
5084190 Fernandez Jan 1992 A
5115868 Dougherty, Jr. et al. May 1992 A
5141654 Fernandez Aug 1992 A
5146018 Kellner et al. Sep 1992 A
5171901 Gassen et al. Dec 1992 A
5177273 Bruhnke et al. Jan 1993 A
5220083 Webster et al. Jun 1993 A
5268343 Hopp et al. Dec 1993 A
5302765 Manzer et al. Apr 1994 A
5364992 Manogue et al. Nov 1994 A
5416246 Krespan et al. May 1995 A
5430204 Manogue et al. Jul 1995 A
5446219 Manogue et al. Aug 1995 A
5510545 Jansen Apr 1996 A
5523501 Kellner et al. Jun 1996 A
5562861 Nimitz et al. Oct 1996 A
5621151 Manogue Apr 1997 A
5621152 Jansen et al. Apr 1997 A
5659093 Takubo et al. Aug 1997 A
5679875 Aoyama et al. Oct 1997 A
5723699 Miller et al. Mar 1998 A
5730894 Minor Mar 1998 A
5902911 Rao et al. May 1999 A
5919994 Rao Jul 1999 A
6018083 Manogue et al. Jan 2000 A
6065547 Ellis et al. May 2000 A
6156944 Pham et al. Dec 2000 A
6207865 Breitscheidel et al. Mar 2001 B1
6211135 Miller et al. Apr 2001 B1
6281395 Nappa et al. Aug 2001 B1
6291729 Rao Sep 2001 B1
6346203 Robin et al. Feb 2002 B1
6376727 Rao et al. Apr 2002 B1
6461530 Robin et al. Oct 2002 B2
6478979 Rivers et al. Nov 2002 B1
6763894 Schoenrock et al. Jul 2004 B2
6849194 Robin et al. Feb 2005 B2
Foreign Referenced Citations (59)
Number Date Country
902590 Aug 1962 CA
1162511 May 1991 CA
2081813 Oct 1992 CA
1546505 Sep 1970 DE
42 03 351 Aug 1993 DE
0 039 471 Nov 1981 EP
0 349 115 Jan 1990 EP
0 383 443 Aug 1990 EP
0 434 407 Jun 1991 EP
0 434 409 Jun 1991 EP
0 481 618 Apr 1992 EP
0 570 367 Jan 1993 EP
0 539 989 May 1993 EP
0 539 989 Jun 1997 EP
0 253 410 Jan 1998 EP
428361 Sep 1930 GB
428445 May 1935 GB
468447 Aug 1937 GB
698386 Oct 1953 GB
790335 Feb 1958 GB
902590 Aug 1962 GB
1077932 Aug 1967 GB
1132636 Nov 1968 GB
1359023 Jul 1974 GB
1578933 Nov 1980 GB
2 120 666 Dec 1983 GB
2370768 Jul 2002 GB
SHO 48-19093 Mar 1973 JP
51034595 Sep 1974 JP
SHO 50-50864 Apr 1975 JP
SHO 52-25679 Jul 1977 JP
57-93070 Jun 1982 JP
HEI 1-115999 May 1989 JP
HEI 4-96770 Mar 1992 JP
2068718 Aug 1990 RU
WO 9102564 Mar 1991 WO
WO 9104766 Apr 1991 WO
WO 9105752 May 1991 WO
WO 9112853 Sep 1991 WO
0 442 075 Aug 1993 WO
WO 9324586 Dec 1993 WO
WO 9617813 Jun 1996 WO
WO 9640834 Dec 1996 WO
WO 9837043 Aug 1998 WO
WO 9850327 Nov 1998 WO
WO 9926907 Nov 1998 WO
WO 9951553 Oct 1999 WO
WO 9951555 Oct 1999 WO
WO 9962851 Dec 1999 WO
WO 0240102 May 2002 WO
WO 0240102 May 2002 WO
PCTUS0230729 Sep 2002 WO
WO 02078788 Oct 2002 WO
WO 02078790 Oct 2002 WO
WO 02078790 Oct 2002 WO
WO 02078799 Oct 2002 WO
WO 03029173 Apr 2003 WO
PCTUS2004023917 Jul 2004 WO
US2004011563 Jul 2004 WO
Related Publications (1)
Number Date Country
20050148804 A1 Jul 2005 US
Divisions (1)
Number Date Country
Parent 10641527 Aug 2003 US
Child 11069180 US