Systems and methods for regenerative ejector-based cooling cycles

Information

  • Patent Grant
  • 11725858
  • Patent Number
    11,725,858
  • Date Filed
    Tuesday, March 8, 2022
    2 years ago
  • Date Issued
    Tuesday, August 15, 2023
    a year ago
  • Inventors
  • Original Assignees
    • BECHTEL ENERGY TECHNOLOGIES & SOLUTIONS, INC. (Houston, TX, US)
  • Examiners
    • Diaz; Miguel A
    Agents
    • Crain Caton & James
    • Jensen; William P.
Abstract
Systems and methods for regenerative ejector-based cooling cycles that utilize an ejector as the motivating force in a cooling loop to regeneratively sub-cool a refrigerant in a single-stage cooling cycle.
Description
CROSS-REFERENCE TO RELATED APPLICATIONS

This application is a U.S. National Stage Application of PCT Application Serial No. PCT/US22/19352 filed on Mar. 8, 2022, which is incorporated by reference. This application, PCT Application No. PCT/US21/49010, and U.S. Pat. Nos. 11,561,027, 10,514,201, 10,533,793, 10,465,983 and 10,514,202, which are each incorporated herein by reference, are commonly assigned to Bechtel Energy Technologies & Solutions, Inc.


FIELD OF THE DISCLOSURE

The present disclosure generally relates to systems and methods for regenerative ejector-based cooling cycles. More particularly, the systems and methods utilize an ejector as the motivating force in a cooling loop to regeneratively sub-cool a refrigerant in a single-stage cooling cycle.


BACKGROUND

The use of heat exchangers to modify the thermodynamic performance of cooling cycles is well known. An exemplary heat exchanger in a conventional cooling cycle is known as a suction line heat exchanger (SLHX). The purpose of a SLHX is to preheat a refrigerant before it enters the compressor.


Other concepts have been proposed for leveraging heat exchangers to sub-cool a refrigerant in a cooling cycle using an ejector. In FIG. 1, for example, heat exchangers are used in a system 100 for use in a conventional two-stage cooling cycle with an ejector to sub-cool a refrigerant and reduce the total power consumption of the system, which is also referred to as cascade refrigeration.


A vapor first refrigerant enters a first compressor 104 from a vaporized first refrigerant line 102 and is compressed to an evaporating pressure dictated by ambient conditions. The compressed vapor first refrigerant passes through a compressed first refrigerant line 106 to a heat exchanger referred to as an evaporative condenser 108. The condensed liquid first refrigerant passes through a condensed refrigerant line 110 to a first expansion valve 107 and/or an ejector 114 based on a control valve (not shown).


The condensed liquid first refrigerant expands as it passes through the expansion valve 107. The expanded two-phase first refrigerant passes through a first expanded first refrigerant line 118 to a heat exchanger referred to as a cascade exchanger 132 where it is vaporized by heat and used to cool a second refrigerant from a compressed second refrigerant line 130 forming part of the second stage of the cooling cycle. The vaporized first refrigerant passes through the vaporized first refrigerant line 102 to the compressor 104.


The condensed liquid first refrigerant enters the ejector 114 as a motive fluid where it is mixed with vaporized first refrigerant from another vaporized first refrigerant line 126 and is ejected from the ejector 114 as a two-phase first refrigerant. The two-phase first refrigerant passes through a two-phase first refrigerant line 116 to a flash economizer 112 where it is flashed into a vapor first refrigerant and a liquid first refrigerant. The vapor first refrigerant from the flash economizer 112 enters the compressor 104 through the vaporized first refrigerant line 102. The liquid first refrigerant from the flash economizer 112 passes through a liquid first refrigerant line 120 to a second expansion valve 121. The liquid first refrigerant expands as it passes through the second expansion valve 121. The expanded two-phase first refrigerant passes through a second expanded first refrigerant line 122 to a heat exchanger referred to as a sub-cooler 124 where it is vaporized by heat and used to cool the second refrigerant from a cooled second refrigerant line 134 forming part of the second stage of the cooling cycle. The vaporized first refrigerant from the sub-cooler 124 passes through the another vaporized first refrigerant line 126 to the ejector 114.


A vaporized second refrigerant passes through a vaporized second refrigerant line 128 to a second compressor 136. The compressed vapor second refrigerant passes through the compressed second refrigerant line 130 to the cascade exchanger 132 where it is cooled. The cooled liquid second refrigerant passes through the cooled second refrigerant line 134 to the sub-cooler 124 where it is further cooled. The sub-cooled liquid second refrigerant from the sub-cooler 124 passes through a sub-cooled second refrigerant line 135 to a third expansion valve 138. The expanded two-phase second refrigerant passes through an expanded second refrigerant line 139 to a heat exchanger referred to as an evaporator 140 where it is vaporized by heat into the vaporized second refrigerant. The two-stage cooling cycle system 100 thus, requires two cascading cooling loops and a refrigerant for each respective stage.





BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

The detailed description is described below with reference to the accompanying drawings, in which like elements are referenced with like reference numbers, in which:



FIG. 1 is a schematic diagram illustrating a system for use in a conventional two-stage ejector-based cooling cycle.



FIG. 2 is a schematic diagram illustrating one embodiment of a system for use in a single-stage regenerative ejector-based cooling cycle.



FIG. 3 is a Pressure-Enthalpy diagram comparing anticipated pressure/enthalpy values at state points for the system illustrated in FIG. 2 and a conventional four (4) component cooling cycle.



FIG. 4 is the schematic diagram of the system in FIG. 2 with the reference numbers replaced by the corresponding state points in FIG. 3.



FIG. 5 is a schematic diagram illustrating one embodiment of a system for use in two combined single-stage regenerative ejector-based cooling cycles.





DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE ILLUSTRATIVE EMBODIMENTS

The subject matter of the present disclosure is described with specificity, however, the description itself is not intended to limit the scope of the disclosure. The subject matter described herein thus, might also be embodied in other ways, to include different structures, steps and/or combinations similar to and/or fewer than those described herein, in conjunction with other present or future technologies. Although the term “step” may be used herein to describe different elements of methods employed, the term should not be interpreted as implying any particular order among or between various steps herein disclosed unless otherwise expressly limited by the description to a particular order. Other features and advantages of the disclosed embodiments will be or will become apparent to one of ordinary skill in the art upon examination of the following figures and detailed description. It is intended that all such additional features and advantages be included within the scope of the disclosed embodiments. Further, the illustrated figures are only exemplary and are not intended to assert or imply any limitation with regard to the environment, architecture, design, or process in which different embodiments may be implemented. To the extent that temperatures and pressures are referenced in the following description, those conditions are merely illustrative and are not meant to limit the disclosure.


The systems and methods disclosed herein thus, improve conventional two-stage cooling cycles by utilizing an ejector as the motivating force in a cooling loop to regeneratively sub-cool a refrigerant in a single-stage cooling cycle. The systems and methods disclosed herein accomplish the same or greater energy efficiency as a conventional two-stage cooling cycle, but with less equipment because a second stage is not needed to accomplish the subcooling effect. The single-stage cooling cycle disclosed herein also do not require a high entrainment ratio ejector, which reduces the compression ratio and increases the energy efficiency of the cooling cycle.


In one embodiment, the present disclosure includes a system for use in a single-stage cooling cycle, which comprises: i) a single refrigerant; ii) an ejector for mixing a condensed liquid form of the single refrigerant and a first vaporized form of the single refrigerant to form a two-phase form of the single refrigerant; iii) a flash economizer in fluid communication with the ejector for separating the two-phase form of the single refrigerant from the ejector into a second vaporized form of the single refrigerant and a liquid form of the single refrigerant; iv) an expansion valve positioned between a liquid refrigerant line connected to the flash economizer and a sub-cooler for converting a portion of the liquid form of the single refrigerant from the liquid refrigerant line into an expanded two-phase form of the single refrigerant; and v) the sub-cooler in fluid communication with the expansion valve for cooling another portion of the liquid form of the single refrigerant and producing the first vaporized form of the single refrigerant and a separate sub-cooled liquid form of the single refrigerant.


In another embodiment, the present disclosure includes a single stage cooling method, which comprises: i) mixing a condensed liquid form of a single refrigerant and a first vaporized form of the single refrigerant to form a two-phase form of the single refrigerant; ii) separating the two-phase form of the single refrigerant into a second vaporized form of the single refrigerant and a liquid form of the single refrigerant; iii) converting a portion of the liquid form of the single refrigerant into an expanded two-phase form of the single refrigerant; and iv) cooling another portion of the liquid form of the single refrigerant by transferring heat from the another portion of the liquid form of the single refrigerant to the expanded two-phase form of the single refrigerant and producing the first vaporized form of the single refrigerant and a separate sub-cooled liquid form of the single refrigerant.


Referring now to FIG. 2, one embodiment of a system 200 for use in a single-stage regenerative ejector-based cooling cycle with a single refrigerant is illustrated. An exemplary refrigerant is an R-134A refrigerant with a cooling duty of 5.4 MW for cooling a circulating cooling water system from 30° C. (86° F.) to 22° C. (72° F.), although others may be used.


A vapor refrigerant enters a compressor 204 from a first vaporized refrigerant line 202 and is compressed to a pressure of 114 psig and a temperature of 107° F. The compressed vapor refrigerant passes through a compressed refrigerant line 206 to a heat exchanger referred to as an evaporative condenser 208. The condensed liquid refrigerant passes through a condensed refrigerant line 210 with the aid of a pump 207 at a temperature of 95° F. to an ejector 214. Due to the flexibility provided by the pump 207 and the ejector 214, the system 200 can achieve a higher coefficient of performance and lower energy consumption than conventional systems. The pump 207 thus, enables a higher discharge pressure at the ejector 214 and a higher intermediate pressure at the flash economizer 212. Optionally, the pump 207 may be removed based on capital costs, maintenance concerns and/or system restrictions.


The condensed liquid refrigerant enters the ejector 214 as motive fluid where it is mixed with vaporized refrigerant from a second vaporized refrigerant line 226 and is ejected from the ejector 214 as a two-phase refrigerant. The motive fluid will always be a liquid because it is located directly downstream from the evaporative condenser 208. The two-phase refrigerant passes through a two-phase refrigerant line 216 to a flash economizer 212 where it is flashed into a vapor refrigerant and a liquid refrigerant. Optionally, an adjustment valve may be used for operational flexibility.


The vapor refrigerant from the flash economizer 212 enters the compressor 204 through the first vaporized refrigerant line 202. The liquid refrigerant from the flash economizer 212 passes through a liquid refrigerant line 220 to a pump 222. Optionally, the flash economizer 212 and the pump 202 may be unnecessary for smaller cooling cycles and thus, removed. The liquid refrigerant is pumped to an expansion valve 223 and/or a sub-cooler 224 based on a control valve (not shown).


The liquid refrigerant expands as it passes through the expansion valve 223. The expanded two-phase refrigerant passes through an expanded refrigerant line 225 to the sub-cooler 224 where it is vaporized by heat and used to cool the liquid refrigerant from the pump 222. The vaporized refrigerant from the sub-cooler 224 passes through the second vaporized refrigerant line 226 to the ejector 214.


The sub-cooled liquid refrigerant from the sub-cooler 224 passes through a sub-cooled refrigerant line 228 to an evaporator 230 where it is vaporized by heat into a vaporized refrigerant that passes through a third vaporized refrigerant line 232 to the flash economizer 212 where it is eventually recycled back to the compressor 204 through the first vaporized refrigerant line 202. The system 200 requires a single refrigerant and thus, fewer components than the conventional system 100 for use in a two-stage ejector-based cooling cycle, which is less economical and efficient at cooling.


The Pressure-Enthalpy diagram in FIG. 3 compares anticipated pressure/enthalpy values at state points for the system 200 illustrated in FIG. 2 and a conventional four (4) component cooling cycle. The dashed lines connect the state points for the system 200 and the dashed/dotted lines connect the state points for the conventional 4 component cooling cycle. The Bubble Point Curve represents the line beyond which the refrigerant is a liquid. The Dew Point Curve represents the line beyond which the refrigerant is a vapor.


In FIG. 4, the system 200 in FIG. 2 is illustrated with the reference numbers replaced by the corresponding state points in FIG. 3. Significantly, the transition of the refrigerant from state point 040 to state point 010 by means of the sub-cooler 224 facilitates a higher inlet pressure at the compressor 204 at state point 001 and a subsequent reduction in the differential pressure between state points 001 and 002. State point 0010 for the system 200 compared to state point 008 in the conventional 4 component cycle illustrated in FIG. 3 demonstrate that the single refrigerant in the system 200 achieves the same cooling temperature as the conventional 4 component cycle while operating at a higher pressure than the conventional 4 component cycle, which reduces compression energy.


Table 1 below compares the anticipated performance of the conventional 4 component cooling cycle and the single-stage regenerative ejector-based cooling cycle illustrated in FIG. 2 using a simulation model (Aspen HYSYS version 12.1) with projected ejector performance. As demonstrated by the anticipated results, the single-stage regenerative ejector-based cooling cycle illustrated in FIG. 2 would yield a higher coefficient of performance with less compression power.













TABLE 1








Conventional
FIG. 2




Cooling Cycle
Cooling Cycle




















Cooling Duty, MW
5.4
5.4



Coefficient of Performance
10.05
11.43



Compression Power, kW
534
470










The system 200 in FIG. 2 can be combined with another single-stage regenerative ejector-based cooling cycle like the one illustrated in FIG. 2 by replacing the evaporator 230 in one cooling cycle and the evaporative condenser 208 in the other cooling cycle with a single cascade exchanger 502 as illustrated in FIG. 5, which enables cooling at lower temperatures such as, for example, in ultra-low temperature applications with independent refrigerants.


While the present disclosure has been described in connection with presently preferred embodiments, it will be understood by those skilled in the art that it is not intended to limit the disclosure of those embodiments. Preexisting ejector-based cooling cycles may be retrofitted or modified according to the disclosure herein, which may also be implemented in any other refrigeration process employed in an enclosed structure for heating or cooling to achieve similar results. It is therefore, contemplated that various alternative embodiments and modifications may be made to the disclosed embodiments without departing from the spirit and scope of the disclosure defined by the appended claims and equivalents thereof

Claims
  • 1. A system for use in a single-stage cooling cycle, which comprises: a single refrigerant;an ejector for mixing a condensed liquid form of the single refrigerant and a first vaporized form of the single refrigerant to form a two-phase form of the single refrigerant;a flash economizer in fluid communication with the ejector for separating the two-phase form of the single refrigerant from the ejector into a second vaporized form of the single refrigerant and a liquid form of the single refrigerant;an expansion valve positioned between a liquid refrigerant line connected to the flash economizer and a sub-cooler for converting a portion of the liquid form of the single refrigerant from the liquid refrigerant line into an expanded two-phase form of the single refrigerant; andthe sub-cooler in fluid communication with the expansion valve for cooling another portion of the liquid form of the single refrigerant and producing the first vaporized form of the single refrigerant and a separate sub-cooled liquid form of the single refrigerant.
  • 2. The system of claim 1, further comprising a pump positioned between the flash economizer and the sub-cooler for distributing the liquid form of the single refrigerant.
  • 3. The system of claim 1, further comprising an evaporator in fluid communication with the sub-cooler for heating the separate sub-cooled liquid form of the single refrigerant by transferring heat from an external source to the separate sub-cooled liquid form of the single refrigerant and producing a third vaporized form of the single refrigerant.
  • 4. The system of claim 3, wherein the flash economizer is connected to the evaporator for receiving the third vaporized form of the single refrigerant.
  • 5. The system of claim 1, further comprising a compressor connected to the flash economizer for compressing the second vaporized form of the single refrigerant.
  • 6. The system of claim 1, further comprising a pump positioned upstream from the ejector for increasing at least one of a discharge pressure at the ejector and an intermediate pressure at the flash economizer.
  • 7. The system of claim 1, wherein a temperature and a pressure for the second vaporized form of the single refrigerant are substantially 72° F. and substantially 89 psia, respectively.
  • 8. The system of claim 1, wherein a temperature and a pressure for the liquid form of the single refrigerant are substantially 95° F. and substantially 129 psia, respectively.
  • 9. The system of claim 1, wherein a temperature and a pressure for the separate sub-cooled liquid form of the single refrigerant are substantially 68° F. and substantially 88 psia, respectively.
  • 10. The system of claim 1, wherein a temperature and a pressure for the two-phase form of the single refrigerant are substantially 72° F. and substantially 89 psia, respectively.
  • 11. A single stage cooling method, which comprises: mixing a condensed liquid form of a single refrigerant and a first vaporized form of the single refrigerant to form a two-phase form of the single refrigerant;separating the two-phase form of the single refrigerant into a second vaporized form of the single refrigerant and a liquid form of the single refrigerant;converting a portion of the liquid form of the single refrigerant into an expanded two-phase form of the single refrigerant; andcooling another portion of the liquid form of the single refrigerant by transferring heat from the another portion of the liquid form of the single refrigerant to the expanded two-phase form of the single refrigerant and producing the first vaporized form of the single refrigerant and a separate sub-cooled liquid form of the single refrigerant.
  • 12. The method of claim 11, further comprising heating the separate sub-cooled liquid form of the single refrigerant by transferring heat from an external source to the sub-cooled liquid form of the single refrigerant and producing a third vaporized form of the single refrigerant.
  • 13. The method of claim 11, further comprising compressing the second vaporized form of the single refrigerant.
  • 14. The method of claim 11, further comprising increasing at least one of a discharge pressure at the ejector and an intermediate pressure at a flash economizer with a pump.
  • 15. The method of claim 11, wherein a temperature and a pressure for the second vaporized form of the single refrigerant are substantially 72° F. and substantially 89 psia, respectively.
  • 16. The method of claim 11, wherein a temperature and a pressure for the liquid form of the single refrigerant are substantially 95° F. and substantially 129 psia, respectively.
  • 17. The method of claim 11, wherein a temperature and a pressure for the separate sub-cooled liquid form of the single refrigerant are substantially 68° F. and substantially 88 psia, respectively.
  • 18. The method of claim 11, wherein a temperature and a pressure for the two-phase form of the single refrigerant are substantially 72° F. and substantially 89 psia, respectively.
  • 19. The method of claim 11, wherein a temperature and a pressure for the first vaporized form of the single refrigerant are substantially 60° F. and substantially 72 psia, respectively.
  • 20. The method of claim 11, wherein the single refrigerant is a refrigerant with a cooling duty of 5.4 MW for cooling a circulating cooling water system from substantially 86° F. to substantially 72° F.
PCT Information
Filing Document Filing Date Country Kind
PCT/US2022/019352 3/8/2022 WO
US Referenced Citations (61)
Number Name Date Kind
3236059 Bernstein Feb 1966 A
3277660 Kemper Oct 1966 A
4112700 Forg Sep 1978 A
4124496 Cummings Nov 1978 A
4325719 Yamazaki Apr 1982 A
5769926 Lockhandwala et al. Jun 1998 A
6550265 Takeuchi et al. Apr 2003 B2
6574987 Takeuchi et al. Jun 2003 B2
6675609 Takeuchi et al. Jan 2004 B2
6925835 Nishijima et al. Aug 2005 B2
7823401 Takeuchi et al. Nov 2010 B2
8713962 Okazaki May 2014 B2
8776539 Verma et al. Jul 2014 B2
8991201 Ikegami et al. Mar 2015 B2
9200820 Okazaki Dec 2015 B2
9217590 Cogswell et al. Dec 2015 B2
9303909 Kolarich Apr 2016 B2
9897354 Yokoyama et al. Feb 2018 B2
10465983 Ladd Nov 2019 B2
10514201 Ladd Dec 2019 B2
10514202 Ladd Dec 2019 B2
10527329 Oshitani et al. Jan 2020 B2
10533793 Ladd Jan 2020 B2
10603985 Nishijiba et al. Mar 2020 B2
10724771 Hellmann et al. Jul 2020 B2
10823461 Hellmann Nov 2020 B2
11209191 Wang et al. Dec 2021 B2
11215386 Hellmann Jan 2022 B2
11365913 Xu et al. Jun 2022 B2
11408647 Cogswell et al. Aug 2022 B2
11561027 Ladd et al. Jan 2023 B2
11561033 Vaisman Jan 2023 B1
20010025499 Takeuchi Oct 2001 A1
20030066301 Takeuchi Apr 2003 A1
20030136146 Fischer-Calderon et al. Jul 2003 A1
20030140651 Takeuchi et al. Jul 2003 A1
20030209032 Ohta Nov 2003 A1
20050028552 Nishijima Feb 2005 A1
20060266072 Takeuchi Nov 2006 A1
20070000262 Ikegami et al. Jan 2007 A1
20070039349 Yamada Feb 2007 A1
20070163293 Ikegami et al. Jul 2007 A1
20100139315 Ikegami et al. Jun 2010 A1
20110005268 Oshitani et al. Jan 2011 A1
20110289953 Alston Dec 2011 A1
20120167601 Cogswell et al. Jul 2012 A1
20120180510 Okazaki Jul 2012 A1
20120227426 Deaconu Sep 2012 A1
20120291462 Verma et al. Nov 2012 A1
20130055751 Inaba Mar 2013 A1
20130111934 Wang May 2013 A1
20130251505 Wang et al. Sep 2013 A1
20150033777 Schydlo Feb 2015 A1
20170159978 Ladd Jun 2017 A1
20180023850 Chaudhry Jan 2018 A1
20180274823 Rajendiran et al. Sep 2018 A1
20190323769 Ducote, Jr. et al. Oct 2019 A1
20200355413 Monteith Nov 2020 A1
20220026114 Aidoun Jan 2022 A1
20220236004 Ladd Jul 2022 A1
20220268517 Ladd Aug 2022 A1
Foreign Referenced Citations (20)
Number Date Country
103776189 May 2014 CN
111174453 May 2020 CN
111174453 May 2020 CN
216869235 Jul 2022 CN
10302356 Jul 2003 DE
2754978 Jul 2014 EP
2002286326 Oct 2002 JP
2004037057 Feb 2004 JP
2005233513 Sep 2005 JP
2005249315 Sep 2005 JP
2009263674 Nov 2009 JP
2014190581 Oct 2014 JP
2015004460 Jan 2015 JP
6087744 Mar 2017 JP
2004111556 Dec 2004 WO
2012074578 Jun 2012 WO
2016004988 Jan 2016 WO
2021007548 Jan 2021 WO
2021030112 Feb 2021 WO
2021113423 Jun 2021 WO
Non-Patent Literature Citations (18)
Entry
Wang, F., D.Y. Li, and Y. Zhou. “Analysis for the Ejector Used as Expansion Valve in Vapor Compression Refrigeration Cycle.” Applied thermal engineering 96 (2016): 576-582. Web. (Year: 2016).
Kari Rodriguez, International Search Report and Written Opinion of the International Searching Authority for PCT/US22/19352, dated Jun. 13, 2022, 8 pages, USPTO as the International Searching Authority, Alexandria, VA.
Chen, Jianyong, Sad Jarall, Hans Havtun, and Björn Palm. 2015. “A Reviewon Versatile Ejector Applications in Refrigeration Systems.” Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 49: 67-90.
Chen, Xiaojuan, Yuanyuan Zhou, and Jianlin Yu. 2011. “A Theoretical Study of an Innovative Ejector Enhanced Vapor Compression Heat Pump Cycle for Water Heating Application.” Energy and Buildings 43 (12): 3331-36.
Chen, Xiaonan, Qichao Yang, Weikai Chi, Yuanyang Zhao, Guangbin Liu, and Liansheng Li. 2022. “Energy and Exergy Analysis of NH3/CO2 Cascade Refrigeration System with Subcooling in the Low-Temperature Cycle Based on an Auxiliary Loop of NH3 Refrigerants.” Energy Reports 8: 1757-67.
Chi, Weikai, Qichao Yang, Xiaonan Chen, Guangbin Liu, Yuanyang Zhao, and Liansheng Li. 2022. “Performance Evaluation of NH3/CO2 Cascade Refrigeration System with Ejector Subcooling for Low-Temperature Cycle.” International Journal of Refrigeration.
Young, Lee, International Search Report and Written Opinion for PCT App. No. PCT/US20/62972, dated Mar. 12, 2021, 8 pages, United States Patent and Trademark Office as the International Searching Authority, Alexandria, VA.
Athina Nickitas-Etienne, International Preliminary Report on Patentability, PCT Application No. PCT/US20/62972, dated Jun. 16, 2022, 7 pages, International Bureau, Geneva Switzerland.
Zhang, Energetic and Exergetic Analysis of an Ejector-Expansion Refrigeration Cycle Using the Working Fluid R32, Jul. 6, 2015, Entropy.
Liu, Review on Ejector Efficiencies in Various Ejector Systems, 2014, International Refrigeration and Air Conditioning Confrence, paper 1533 (2014).
Emmanuel Duke, International Preliminary Reporton Patentability, PCT Application No. PCT/US16/61077, dated Mar. 1, 2018, 23 pages, International Preliminary Examining Authority, Alexandria, VA.
Shane Thomas, International Search Report and Written Opinion of the International Searching Authority, PCT Application No. PCT/US16/61077, dated Jan. 24, 2017, 7 pages, International Searching Authority, Alexandria, VA.
Eng. Ghassan F. Albuhairan, Examination Report, GCC Patent Application No. GC 2016-32328, dated Oct. 31, 2018, 4 pages, GCC Patent Office, Saudi Arabia.
Office Action, dated May 28, 2019, JP2018-543292, 6 pages, Japan Patent Office, Japan.
Kosala Gunatillaka, Mar. 19, 2019, Examination Report No. 1, App. No. 2016354095, 3 pages, IP Australia, Australia.
Phillips Ormonde Fitzpatrick, Apr. 18, 2019, Response to Examination Report No. 1, App. No. 2016354095, 16 pages, Australia.
David Teitelbaum, Jun. 26, 2019, International Preliminary Report on Patentability, PCT/US17/60349, 12 pages, USPTO, Alexandria, VA.
Blaine R. Copenheaver, International Search Report and Written Opinion, PCT Application No. PCT/US17/60349, dated Jan. 18, 2018, 12 pages, International Searching Authority, Alexandria, VA.