Patent Application
20140222455
A wide variety of potential practical and useful embodiments will be more readily understood through the following detailed description of certain exemplary embodiments, with reference to the accompanying exemplary drawings in which:
When the following terms are used substantively herein, the accompanying definitions apply:
a—at least one.
absolute score—a score reflecting a sum of weighted scores.
activity—an action, act, step, and/or process or portion thereof
adapted to—made suitable or fit for a specific use or situation.
adjusted—to change and/or bring into a predetermined relationship.
and/or—either in conjunction with or in alternative to.
apparatus—an appliance or device for a particular purpose
array—a matrix and/or table.
associate—to connect and/or join together; to combine.
automatically—acting or operating in a manner essentially independent of external influence or control. For example, an automatic light switch can turn on upon “seeing” a person in its view, without the person manually operating the light switch.
best matches—to correspond closer than any other.
better—higher when a scale is organized such that the highest score on that scale is the best possible score on that scale, otherwise lower.
can—is capable of, in at least some embodiments.
cause—to be the reason for, to result in, and/or to bring about.
comprising—including but not limited to.
data—distinct pieces of information, usually formatted in a special or predetermined way and/or organized to express concepts.
define—to establish the outline, form, or structure of
determine—to ascertain, obtain, and/or calculate.
device—a machine, manufacture, and/or collection thereof
distance—a measure of an extent of space between points on a straight line, curve, and/or road-based course.
entry—an element of an array.
facility—a building and/or place that provides a particular service and/or is used for a particular industry.
factor—a criteria and/or something that contributes to a cause of an action.
geographic region—an area on and/or near the surface of the Earth.
haptic—involving the human sense of kinesthetic movement and/or the human sense of touch. Among the many potential haptic experiences are numerous sensations, body-positional differences in sensations, and time-based changes in sensations that are perceived at least partially in non-visual, non-audible, and non-olfactory manners, including the experiences of tactile touch (being touched), active touch, grasping, pressure, friction, traction, slip, stretch, force, torque, impact, puncture, vibration, motion, acceleration, jerk, pulse, orientation, limb position, gravity, texture, gap, recess, viscosity, pain, itch, moisture, temperature, thermal conductivity, and thermal capacity.
healthcare—of and/or relating to the prevention, treatment, and/or management of illness and/or the preservation of mental and/or physical well-being through the services offered by the medical and/or allied health professions, including services offered by physicians, dentists, optometrists, veterinarians, physician's assistants, nurses, nutritionists, therapists, counselors, hygienists, pharmacists, opticians, healers, and/or technicians, etc.
identify—to establish the identity, origin, nature, and/or definitive characteristics of.
identity—the collective aspect of the set of characteristics by which a thing is definitively recognizable and/or known.
importance—significance and/or value.
information device—any device capable of processing information, such as any general purpose and/or special purpose computer, such as a personal computer, workstation, server, minicomputer, mainframe, supercomputer, computer terminal, laptop, wearable computer, and/or Personal Digital Assistant (PDA), mobile terminal, Bluetooth device, communicator, “smart” phone (such as a Treo-like device), messaging service (e.g., Blackberry) receiver, pager, facsimile, cellular telephone, a traditional telephone, telephonic device, a programmed microprocessor or microcontroller and/or peripheral integrated circuit elements, an ASIC or other integrated circuit, a hardware electronic logic circuit such as a discrete element circuit, and/or a programmable logic device such as a PLD, PLA, FPGA, or PAL, or the like, etc. In general any device on which resides a finite state machine capable of implementing at least a portion of a method, structure, and/or or graphical user interface described herein may be used as an information device. An information device can comprise components such as one or more network interfaces, one or more processors, one or more memories containing instructions, and/or one or more input/output (I/O) devices, one or more user interfaces coupled to an I/O device, etc.
input/output (I/O) device—any sensory-oriented input and/or output device, such as an audio, visual, haptic, olfactory, and/or taste-oriented device, including, for example, a monitor, display, projector, overhead display, keyboard, keypad, mouse, trackball, joystick, gamepad, wheel, touchpad, touch panel, pointing device, microphone, speaker, video camera, camera, scanner, printer, haptic device, vibrator, tactile simulator, and/or tactile pad, potentially including a port to which an I/O device can be attached or connected.
location—a place where something is and/or could be located.
machine instructions—directions adapted to cause a machine, such as an information device, to perform a particular operation or function.
machine readable medium—a physical structure from which a machine can obtain data and/or information. Examples include a memory, punch cards, etc.
match—to mirror, resemble, harmonize, fit, and/or correspond.
may—is allowed and/or permitted to, in at least some embodiments.
memory device—an apparatus capable of storing analog or digital information, such as instructions and/or data. Examples include a nonvolatile memory, volatile memory, Random Access Memory, RAM, Read Only Memory, ROM, flash memory, magnetic media, a hard disk, a floppy disk, a magnetic tape, an optical media, an optical disk, a compact disk, a CD, a digital versatile disk, a DVD, and/or a raid array, etc. The memory device can be coupled to a processor and/or can store instructions adapted to be executed by processor, such as according to an embodiment disclosed herein.
method—a process, procedure, and/or collection of related activities for accomplishing something.
network—a communicatively coupled plurality of nodes. A network can be and/or utilize any of a wide variety of sub-networks, such as a circuit switched, public-switched, packet switched, data, telephone, telecommunications, video distribution, cable, terrestrial, broadcast, satellite, broadband, corporate, global, national, regional, wide area, backbone, packet-switched TCP/IP, Fast Ethernet, Token Ring, public Internet, private, ATM, multi-domain, and/or multi-zone sub-network, one or more Internet service providers, and/or one or more information devices, such as a switch, router, and/or gateway not directly connected to a local area network, etc.
network interface—any device, system, or subsystem capable of coupling an information device to a network. For example, a network interface can be a telephone, cellular phone, cellular modem, telephone data modem, fax modem, wireless transceiver, ethernet card, cable modem, digital subscriber line interface, bridge, hub, router, or other similar device.
outside—the space beyond a boundary and/or limit.
packet—a discrete instance of communication.
plurality—the state of being plural and/or more than one.
predefined—specified and/or determined.
predetermined—established in advance.
processor—a device and/or set of machine-readable instructions for performing one or more predetermined tasks. A processor can comprise any one or a combination of hardware, firmware, and/or software. A processor can utilize mechanical, pneumatic, hydraulic, electrical, magnetic, optical, informational, chemical, and/or biological principles, signals, and/or inputs to perform the task(s). In certain embodiments, a processor can act upon information by manipulating, analyzing, modifying, converting, transmitting the information for use by an executable procedure and/or an information device, and/or routing the information to an output device. A processor can function as a central processing unit, local controller, remote controller, parallel controller, and/or distributed controller, etc. Unless stated otherwise, the processor can be a general-purpose device, such as a microcontroller and/or a microprocessor, such the Pentium IV series of microprocessor manufactured by the Intel Corporation of Santa Clara, Calif. In certain embodiments, the processor can be dedicated purpose device, such as an Application Specific Integrated Circuit (ASIC) or a Field Programmable Gate Array (FPGA) that has been designed to implement in its hardware and/or firmware at least a part of an embodiment disclosed herein.
provide—to furnish, supply, give, send, and/or make available.
rank—to classify and/or to give a particular order and/or position to.
receive—to obtain, acquire, and/or take.
relate—to bring into, connect, and/or link in a logical and/or natural association.
render—make perceptible to a human, for example as data, commands, text, graphics, audio, video, animation, and/or hyperlinks, etc., such as via any visual, audio, and/or haptic means, such as via a display, monitor, electric paper, ocular implant, cochlear implant, speaker, etc.
repeatedly—again and again; repetitively.
score—a tally and/or result, usually expressed numerically.
selectable—capable of being chosen and/or selected.
selection—the act of choosing and/or selecting and/or an assortment of things from which a choice can be made.
set—a related plurality.
statistical measure—a numerical value, such as a standard deviation and/or a mean, that characterizes the sample or population from which it was derived.
store—to place, hold, and/or retain data, typically in a memory.
substantially—to a great extent or degree.
system—a collection of mechanisms, devices, data, and/or instructions, the collection designed to perform one or more specific functions.
user—a person interfacing with an information device.
user interface—any device for rendering information to a user and/or requesting information from the user. A user interface includes at least one of textual, graphical, audio, video, animation, and/or haptic elements. A textual element can be provided, for example, by a printer, monitor, display, projector, etc. A graphical element can be provided, for example, via a monitor, display, projector, and/or visual indication device, such as a light, flag, beacon, etc. An audio element can be provided, for example, via a speaker, microphone, and/or other sound generating and/or receiving device. A video element or animation element can be provided, for example, via a monitor, display, projector, and/or other visual device. A haptic element can be provided, for example, via a very low frequency speaker, vibrator, tactile stimulator, tactile pad, simulator, keyboard, keypad, mouse, trackball, joystick, gamepad, wheel, touchpad, touch panel, pointing device, and/or other haptic device, etc. A user interface can include one or more textual elements such as, for example, one or more letters, number, symbols, etc. A user interface can include one or more graphical elements such as, for example, an image, photograph, drawing, icon, window, title bar, panel, sheet, tab, drawer, matrix, table, form, calendar, outline view, frame, dialog box, static text, text box, list, pick list, pop-up list, pull-down list, menu, tool bar, dock, check box, radio button, hyperlink, browser, button, control, palette, preview panel, color wheel, dial, slider, scroll bar, cursor, status bar, stepper, and/or progress indicator, etc. A textual and/or graphical element can be used for selecting, programming, adjusting, changing, specifying, etc. an appearance, background color, background style, border style, border thickness, foreground color, font, font style, font size, alignment, line spacing, indent, maximum data length, validation, query, cursor type, pointer type, autosizing, position, and/or dimension, etc. A user interface can include one or more audio elements such as, for example, a volume control, pitch control, speed control, voice selector, and/or one or more elements for controlling audio play, speed, pause, fast forward, reverse, etc. A user interface can include one or more video elements such as, for example, elements controlling video play, speed, pause, fast forward, reverse, zoom-in, zoom-out, rotate, and/or tilt, etc. A user interface can include one or more animation elements such as, for example, elements controlling animation play, pause, fast forward, reverse, zoom-in, zoom-out, rotate, tilt, color, intensity, speed, frequency, appearance, etc. A user interface can include one or more haptic elements such as, for example, elements utilizing tactile stimulus, force, pressure, vibration, motion, displacement, temperature, etc.
user-selected—that which is chosen by a user.
via-by way of and/or utilizing.
weight—a factor assigned to a number in a computation to make the number's effect on the computation reflect its importance.
weighted score—a score reflecting a product of a score and a weight.
Described herein is a decision-support tool, sometimes referred to as the Hospital Advisor, that can allow a user to rank order the selection of resources, such as healthcare facilities. This ranking is novel and unique in that it allows the user to assign weights based on personal preferences to objectively established criteria associated with each of the healthcare facilities. In certain exemplary embodiments, the Hospital Advisor can comprise a decision-support tool designed to help users find the healthcare facility that is a best match for their needs for one or more medical procedures and/or services. The user can first express his or her preferences, or personal weightings, for each of a set of selection factors or accept the default criteria selected by a panel of medical experts. The user can also specify a geographic area and a distance (radius, driving time, etc.), which can be the outer distance limit for travel. The algorithm which implements Hospital Advisor can return a list of hospitals best meeting that set of criteria relative to the geographic area specified. In certain exemplary applications, the best match can appear as the first item in the list. Alternatively, better matches from outside the specified geographical area, for example top regional and national matches, can also be presented to give the consumer some sense of the relative scale of the comparisons. Users can learn more about any one hospital, or compare up to three hospitals at a time. The information displayed can include the number of patients receiving that procedure, various hospital characteristics, whether the hospital meets patient safety guidelines, etc. A hospital's “match score” can vary according to the preferences selected by the user. Extension of this approach to other domains within the healthcare realm (for example, selection of physicians, dentists, optometrists, therapists, counselors, professionals, aides, service providers, outpatient facilities, long-term care, home healthcare, pharmacies, laboratories, reimbursement plans, health insurance, procedures, treatments, services, medications, supplements, devices, machines, tools, software, and/or information services, etc.), and/or to other resources within and/or outside the healthcare realm, can be implemented based on the approach described herein.
In certain exemplary embodiments, the user can be offered a set of selection criteria (factors) to choose from, and can assign varying levels of importance to each. Default settings can be provided for the factors, including both whether or not the factors are selected and their importance weights. These defaults can vary by medical procedure and/or service and can be determined by medical professionals who have clinical experience and/or expertise in key and/or closely-related medical specialties.
The preference weights can be translated in the algorithm as follows:
Step one can be to determine how each hospital in the consumer's area compares to all other hospitals. This can be given as an absolute score for individual hospitals. For each selection criterion, Z-scores can be calculated by facility and by procedure within the facility. The Z-scores for procedure volume can be based on the square root of the procedure volume. This can reflect, for example, the diminishing return in learning from treating each additional patient as the number of patients treated increases. It also can reflect that modest differences in procedure volume are not as important among hospitals performing many procedures as among hospitals performing fewer procedures.
A Z-Score can be calculated as follows:
where:
Missing or insufficient data can result in a Z-score of zero. Each Z-score can be weighted by the user's preferences. The sum of weighted Z-scores can be the total hospital score.
Example: A user is searching for a hospital, and is most interested in the two factors of “Latest Technology Available”, (which the user rates as “Important)”, and “Neonatal ICU” status, which the user rates “Very Important”.
Hospital A has the highest rating (“above average”) on the “Latest Technology Available” measure. It is assigned the highest score for this factor, which is “3” (average is “2”, below average is “1”). The mean (average) score for all hospitals for the technology index is 1.95, with a standard deviation of 0.59. So the Z-score for this hospital for the “technology” metric is (3−1.95)/0.59=1.78.
The score for the NICU status is calculated in a similar fashion: As it turns out, Hospital A does not have a Neonatal ICU. This is a yes/no variable—a hospital either has an NICU or it does not, so this variable is scored either “0” or “1”. The mean score for NICU status is 0.21, and the standard deviation 0.41. Therefore, Hospital A has a score of (0−0.21)/0.41, or −0.51 for the NICU metric.
Step two can be that once Z-scores are calculated for each criterion and hospital, the consumer's preferences can be used to weight each Z-score, and the sum of the preference weight times the Z-score can give the hospital's absolute score.
Example: For Hospital A, the two scores for “Latest Technology Available” and “NICU status” are combined using the user's weights to get the hospital's absolute scores:
Since no other factors are selected, Hospital A's absolute score is:
(0.5)*(1.78)+(1)*(−0.51)=0.38
Looking at another hospital, Hospital B: This hospital turned out to be the best match in the user's search area. It had an average score for “Latest Technology Available”, with a Z-score=(2−1.95)/0.59=0.08. It also has an NICU, with a Z-score of (1−0.21)/0.41=1.79. So this hospital's absolute score is (0.5)*(0.08)+(1)*(1.79)=1.83. Thus, because 1.83 (the absolute score for Hospital B) is larger than 0.38 (the absolute score for Hospital A), Hospital B is a “better match” for the user.
Hospital C, located outside of the user's specified search radius, has both the highest score for latest technology as well as an NICU. Hospital C, then, has an absolute score of
(0.5)*(1.78)+(1)*(1.79)=2.68.
Step three can be that once the absolute scores are calculated, the relative rankings of each hospital can be determined based on the geographic area defined by the consumer. To do this, each hospital can be scored as follows:
where:
The “Worst Hospital” Score can be calculated for all of the consumer's preferences using the worst scores in the database, summed to create a theoretical “worst hospital” absolute score.
Example: Continuing with the example above, the worst hospital has no NICU and has a “below average” rating for “Latest Technology”. This gives the worst hospital an absolute score of (1)*(−0.51)+(0.5)*(−1.61)=−1.32.
Next, the algorithm calculates a match score for each hospital:
Hospital A's match score is 100*(0.37−(−1.32))/(1.83−(−1.32))=54
Hospital B's match score is 100*(1.83−('11.32))/(1.83−(−1.32))=100
Hospital C's match score is 100*(2.68−(−1.32))/(1.83−(−1.32))=127
Recall that Hospital B is the best match in the search area, and note that only hospitals outside the search are can score higher than 100.
With each hospital scored in Step 3, hospitals then can be ranked by descending match score, and/or by distance for those hospitals where match score is identical.
The algorithm can return to the user a list of hospitals best matching the criteria, with the rankings relative to other hospitals in the geographic area and to the “best match” hospitals in the region and the country.
Up to 20 matching hospitals can be included for the search area specified by the user. In the above example, the results for the user's search could include the following:
Best Match(es) in Search Area:
Other Match(es) in Search Area:
Better Match(es) outside the Search Area:
Thus, certain exemplary embodiments can comprise a method that can comprise, for a predetermined user, automatically determining a score for each resource from a plurality of predetermined resources based on the user's weighting of predetermined factors associated with the resources and an objective score for each factor for each resource, ranking the scored resources, and/or providing an identity of a best matched resource for the user.
Also coupled to network 1300 can be a data-serving information device 1400, which can be coupled to one or more databases 1500, such as databases containing information related to specifying, rating, reviewing, comparing, evaluating, ordering, and/or obtaining a medical procedure and/or services at one or more hospitals and/or healthcare facilities. Data-serving information device 1400 can comprise an administrator and/or user interface 1420, server software 1440, and/or database management software 1460.
Also coupled to network 1300 can be one or more hospital information devices 1600 and/or one or more hospital rating service information devices 1700. A hospital information device 1600 can comprise a user interface 1620 rendered by a client 1640 running on a browser 1660.
In certain exemplary embodiments, via one or more user interfaces 2600, such as a graphical user interface, a consumer can view a rendering of information related to specifying, rating, reviewing, comparing, evaluating, ordering, and/or obtaining a medical procedure and/or services at one or more hospitals and/or healthcare facilities.
Still other practical and useful embodiments will become readily apparent to those skilled in this art from reading the above-recited detailed description and drawings of certain exemplary embodiments. It should be understood that numerous variations, modifications, and additional embodiments are possible, and accordingly, all such variations, modifications, and embodiments are to be regarded as being within the spirit and scope of this application.
Thus, regardless of the content of any portion (e.g., title, field, background, summary, abstract, drawing figure, etc.) of this application, unless clearly specified to the contrary, such as via an explicit definition, assertion, or argument, with respect to any claim, whether of this application and/or any claim of any application claiming priority hereto, and whether originally presented or otherwise:
there is no requirement for the inclusion of any particular described or illustrated characteristic, function, activity, or element, any particular sequence of activities, or any particular interrelationship of elements;
any elements can be integrated, segregated, and/or duplicated;
any activity can be repeated, performed by multiple entities, and/or performed in multiple jurisdictions; and
any activity or element can be specifically excluded, the sequence of activities can vary, and/or the interrelationship of elements can vary.
Accordingly, the descriptions and drawings are to be regarded as illustrative in nature, and not as restrictive. Moreover, when any number or range is described herein, unless clearly stated otherwise, that number or range is approximate. When any range is described herein, unless clearly stated otherwise, that range includes all values therein and all subranges therein. Any information in any material (e.g., a United States patent, United States patent application, book, article, etc.) that has been incorporated by reference herein, is only incorporated by reference to the extent that no conflict exists between such information and the other statements and drawings set forth herein. In the event of such conflict, including a conflict that would render invalid any claim herein or seeking priority hereto, then any such conflicting information in such incorporated by reference material is specifically not incorporated by reference herein.
This application is a continuation of U.S. patent application Ser. No. 14/010,253, filed Aug. 26, 2013, which is a continuation of U.S. patent application Ser. No. 13/455,847, filed Apr. 25, 2012, and issued on Aug. 27, 2013 as U.S. Pat. No. 8,521,559, which is a continuation of and claims priority to U.S. patent application Ser. No. 11/344,628, filed Feb. 1, 2006, and issued as U.S. Pat. No. 8,296,162 on October 23, 2012, which claims priority to U.S. Provisional Patent Application Ser. No. 60/648,821, filed Feb. 1, 2005, the contents of each of which are incorporated by reference herein in their entirety.
| Number | Date | Country | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 60648821 | Feb 2005 | US |
| Number | Date | Country | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Parent | 14010253 | Aug 2013 | US |
| Child | 14246235 | US | |
| Parent | 13455847 | Apr 2012 | US |
| Child | 14010253 | US | |
| Parent | 11344628 | Feb 2006 | US |
| Child | 13455847 | US |
