Myopia, or short-sightedness, is a rapidly growing disorder that could affect 2.5 billion people by 2020. Far beyond a mild inconvenience, myopia increases the risk of serious disorders such as retinal detachment, glaucoma, and cataracts, and is a leading cause of blindness worldwide. The global economic burden of myopia is immense, including consequences of uncorrected refractive error, costs of treatment, and need for long-term management. Since myopia severity increases with earlier onset of myopia, prophylactic strategies to prevent myopia progression are of great interest. Biomechanical weakening of the sclera (i.e. the white, protective layer of the eye) resulting in accelerated axial eye growth has been identified as a major cause of myopia. Sclera buckling surgery is a proposed technique for mechanically reinforcing the sclera, however this procedure is highly invasive and carries a high risk of complications.
A promising and less invasive strategy for myopia control is photochemical collagen crosslinking, which uses a combination of photosensitizers and light. This technique is already commonly used in the clinic to strengthen the cornea to treat corneal ectasia. However, unlike corneal crosslinking (CXL), technical constraints have limited translation of scleral crosslinking (SXL), including:
To address the above technical challenges, provided herein are embodiments of a flexible, polymer waveguides optimized for efficient and uniform delivery of light into biological tissues. In the disclosed design, a fiber-coupled laser source is inserted into the waveguide, which may then be wrapped around the eyeball to perform SXL. Discussed herein are strategies for designing waveguides with uniform light extraction, using a theoretical model for waveguide loss. Using flexible polymer-based waveguides, successful SXL-induced stiffening of the sclera around the equator of fresh porcine eyeballs is demonstrated.
In accordance with one aspect of the present disclosure, a system is provided for delivering light to a curved surface of a tissue of a subject. The system includes a light source; an optical coupler coupled to the light source; and a flexible waveguide coupled to the optical coupler. The waveguide has a first end and a second end with an elongated flat portion therebetween. Light from the light source is emitted substantially uniformly from along the elongated flat portion of the flexible waveguide, thereby delivering light substantially uniformly along the curved surface of the tissue.
In accordance with another aspect of the present disclosure, a method is provided for delivering light to a tissue of a subject. The method includes steps of: providing a light source coupled to a flexible waveguide by an optical coupler, the waveguide having a first end and a second end with an elongated flat portion therebetween; contacting the tissue with the waveguide; and directing light into the waveguide, the light traveling from the light source through the optical coupler into the waveguide, at least a portion of the light exiting the waveguide toward the tissue.
In accordance with yet another aspect of the present disclosure, an apparatus is provided. The apparatus includes a flexible waveguide having first end and a second end with an elongated flat portion therebetween.
In accordance with still another aspect of the present disclosure, a method is provided for treating myopia in a subject. The method includes steps of: contacting scleral tissue of the subject with a flexible waveguide, the waveguide having a first end and a second end with an elongated flat portion therebetween; and directing light into the waveguide with a light source, the light source coupled to the flexible waveguide by an optical coupler, the light traveling from the light source through the optical coupler into the waveguide, at least a portion of the light exiting the waveguide toward the tissue and interacting with a photosensitizer in the scleral tissue.
In accordance with one aspect of the present disclosure, a system is provided for delivering light to a tissue of a subject. The system includes a light source, an optical coupler coupled to the light source, and a flexible waveguide coupled to the optical coupler. The flexible waveguide has a first end and a second end with an elongated flat portion therebetween. The first end has a first thickness and the second end has a second thickness, where the first thickness is greater than the second thickness.
The foregoing and other aspects and advantages of the invention will appear from the following description. In the description, reference is made to the accompanying drawings which form a part hereof, and in which there is shown by way of illustration preferred embodiments of the invention. Such embodiments do not necessarily represent the full scope of the invention, however, and reference is made therefore to the claims herein for interpreting the scope of the invention.
Provided are systems, methods, and apparatus for delivering light to tissue via a waveguide for therapeutic and other purposes. Light from a light source propagates through the waveguide by internal reflection and a portion of the light exits the waveguide and may impinge on a surrounding tissue with which the waveguide is in contact. The light impinging on the tissue may have therapeutic effects on the tissue, for example by interacting with a photosensitizer in the tissue. Light that travels through and is emitted from an end of the waveguide (e.g. excitation light from the light source or fluorescence light, for example from the tissue) can be detected and used to monitor progress of a therapeutic or other procedure.
Waveguide fabrication and optical characterization
To achieve efficient light propagation inside the waveguide (
An image of an embodiment of the elastomer waveguide is shown in
When the slab waveguide is wrapped around a structure such as an eyeball, the internal reflection angles are generally altered, for example due to the curvature of the waveguide due to being wrapped around the structure. This situation is illustrated in
For example, for a waveguide having a thickness t=1 mm and being wrapped around a structure which gives a radius of curvature of R=12 mm, the angle is θ=˜67.4 deg. For a waveguide made of a material such as PDMS, which has an index of refraction of n=1.42, the critical angle for total internal reflection at the PDMS-air interface (i.e. the outer-facing side of the waveguide, which in this instance is not in contact with a structure such as the sclera) is 44.8 deg. Therefore, a PDMS-based waveguide such as that described above and shown in
In clinical applications, however, the waveguide may be inserted into the extraocular socket and the outer surface of the waveguide may be in contact with a structure such as the Tenon's capsule, which has a refractive index close to 1.4. Light leakage to surrounding tissues could also be absorbed by the retina and/or the choroid as well as blood and other tissue fluids, causing potential phototoxicity. Therefore, to ensure high reflection at the outer surface and minimize optical loss to the external tissue, in some embodiments the reflectivity of the outer surface of the waveguide may be increased and/or the light loss from the outer surface may be decreased, for example by making the waveguide from a material having a higher refractive index than an adjacent layer or the surrounding tissue and/or by applying a reflective or light-blocking coating to the outside surface of the waveguide, i.e. the portion of the waveguide not facing the scleral tissue of the eyeball.
In one embodiment, the waveguide may be made of a high-refractive-index polymer having a refractive index greater than 1.5. For example, in one particular embodiment the waveguide may be constructed from a 1,3-glycerol dimethacrylate-based polymer, which has a refractive index close to 1.52 and which would have a critical angle of 65 deg. at the interface with a tissue having an index of refraction of 1.38. In other embodiments, the waveguide may be constructed from certain elastomers made of transparent styrenic copolymers having a refractive index of 1.577 and which give a critical angle of 61 deg. Waveguides such as these, made of high index of refraction materials, can efficiently guide excitation light coupled from low numerical-aperture pigtail fibers when the waveguides assume a curved geometry such as happens when the waveguides are wrapped around an eyeball in a subject. In various embodiments, a low refractive index polymer or hydrogel may be applied in a coating on the inner and/or outer surface of the high-index waveguide to further optimize the light delivery profile and possibly enhance biocompatibility.
In certain other embodiments, one or multiple light blocking layers may be applied at the outer surface of the waveguide to enhance internal reflection of light along the outer surface, and/or to reduce light loss from the outer surface of the waveguide to ensure that light is delivered primarily to the therapeutic side of the waveguide. To accomplish this, the waveguide may have a reflective or absorptive outer side that prevents light leakage and/or reflects light back into the waveguide core. However, for such a layer to be added, a core-cladded waveguide is necessary to maintain total internal reflection inside the waveguide that would be otherwise disturbed. In one embodiment, the absorptive layer may be a dye-doped polymer such as PDMS that could absorb any light that leaks from the waveguide core. In other embodiments, a thin sheet of reflective metal, such as aluminum or gold, may be applied to the outer surface of the waveguide. In such embodiments, an additional polymer layer may be deposited over the metal layer to prevent mechanical tissue prevent mechanical tissue damage that may otherwise arise from contact of the metal coating with tissue.
Based on the design of
Optimizing waveguide design to achieve uniform light extraction
To optimize waveguide design for uniform light extraction into tissues, the sources of waveguide loss and the distribution of light inside and extracted from the waveguide should be considered. Here, waveguide loss was modeled through surface scattering as a simple exponential decay along the length of the waveguide. Let Iin (z) be the light intensity inside the waveguide at position z.
The change in light intensity inside the waveguide can expressed as:
Where γ is loss due to material absorption, and ascatt is a scattering cross-section describing loss due to surface scattering. Given that ascatt»γ for the waveguides, Equation 2 can be solved to obtain:
I
in(z)=I0*exp(−ascattz) (3)
Where I0 (z) is the initial light intensity at z=0. The light extracted into tissues at position z can be expressed as:
Thus, the extracted light profile is non-uniform with exponentially more light being extracted near the proximal end of the waveguide (near z=0 mm) compared to the distal end (near z=70 mm in one case). To compensate for this exponential attenuation, the waveguide can be designed by varying the scattering cross-section ascatt, as a function of z. For uniform light delivery, the following is required:
Solving Equation 7, and assuming Iin (z)≠0, the following is obtained:
Where C is a constant. To find an optimal ascatt (z) for uniform light delivery, it is noted that ascatt=A/t, where A is a constant, and t is the thickness of the waveguide. The physical interpretation of this equation is that, as the thickness of the waveguide decreases, there are more reflections inside the waveguide as a function of unit length and thus higher scattering loss. Assuming that ascatt (z=0)=A/t0, where t0 is the initial waveguide thickness at z=0:
Equation 10 indicates that a tapered waveguide with decreasing thickness as a function of z is sufficient to obtain homogenous light extraction. In practice, ascatt (z) can also be optimized by using different materials or coating layers to alter the scattering and refractive index profile of the waveguide, and to improve uniformity of light extraction.
To compute the extracted light profile with a tapered thickness t(z), Equation 2 needs to be rewritten as:
Which has a solution of:
The extracted light profile can be expressed as:
To validate the above theory, the light extraction profiles of flat and tapered waveguides were compared. As shown in the schematic of
To measure the uniformity of light extraction, 450 nm blue light was coupled into a waveguide wrapped around the equator of a riboflavin-stained porcine eyeball (
To compare the results with theoretical considerations, the profile for flat 1 mm waveguides was fit to Equation 4, yielding a scattering loss coefficient of ascatt=0.0175±0.0008 mm−1. Using Equation 13, the predicted extraction profile is plotted in
The results indicate significantly improved uniformity of light delivery using tapered waveguides as compared to flat waveguides. Using Equation 10, ideal linear tapering for uniform light extraction gives t(z)=t0−0.0175z. For t0=1.5 mm, t(z=70 mm)=0.28 mm. Thus, further improvement in uniformity may be achieved by increasing the tapering gradient of the waveguides or by optimizing other material properties. However, it should be noted that thin waveguides (<2 mm) are required for SXL due to anatomical constraints to scleral access in the orbit in vivo.
In various embodiments, other synthetic polymers, such as poly(lactic-glycol acid), poly(ethylene glycol), and natural polymers, such as silk, may also be suitable materials for waveguide fabrication instead of PDMS. Waveguides made with materials with lower refractive indices than that of tissue, such as hydrogels, may be used for light delivery into tissues along a short distance. However, for certain embodiments of the SXL application it is preferred to use waveguides with indices higher than 1.38.
In particular embodiments, other crosslinking agents (besides Riboflavin) such as Rose Bengal can be applicable, which typically uses an excitation wavelength of 532 nm. In addition to SXL, the methods and systems disclosed herein may also be generally applicable to other light-activated therapies such as photodynamic therapy (exciting photosensitizers), photothermal therapies for cancer (for example, gold nanoparticles), ultraviolet therapy in dermatology, blue-light therapy for anti-microbial treatment, and low-level light therapy for pain relief and wound healing. In each of these other applications, the waveguide would be placed adjacent to the particular tissue (e.g. skin) and light having suitable properties (e.g. particular wavelengths and/or intensities) would be directed into the waveguide for suitable periods of time.
An embodiment of a light coupling system 100 is shown in
The optical system 100 in some embodiments may also include a monitoring setup or detector 140 to ensure appropriate light delivery (
Measurement of returning excitation and fluorescence light from the waveguide 130 could provide valuable information for clinicians to assist in treatment planning, dosimetry, and monitoring. For instance, sufficient photosensitizer staining can be verified prior to SXL, irradiation parameters (e.g. intensity, exposure time) can be tailored to specific patient characteristics (e.g. pigmentation, scattering and thickness of the sclera), and adjustments can be made in real-time.
Thus, in various embodiments, light from the light source 110 is directed to the waveguide 130 via the optical coupler, which may include one or more optical fibers 120 and/or the fiber-optic coupler 122. Light emitted from the waveguide 130 may be directed to a detector, which may include photodetector 142 to detect fluorescence light and/or another photodetector 144 to detect excitation light. The detector may include optical elements to shape and split the light emitted from the waveguide 130, for example a dichroic beam splitter or dichroic filter 146 and/or a lens 148.
In general the waveguide 130 has an elongated flat portion with a first end and a second end. The waveguide 130 may be tapered such that the first end is thicker than the second end. The thickness of the elongated flat portion of the waveguide 130 may be tapered from the first end to the second end in a linear or nonlinear fashion, tapering generally promoting a more uniform emission of light along the length of the waveguide 130. The elongated flat portion of the waveguide 130, when it contacts a tissue of a subject, may have an ‘inside’ (e.g. the side contacting the sclera when the waveguide 130 is wrapped around an eyeball) and an ‘outside’ (e.g. the side facing out, away from the sclera). In various embodiments a reflective coating may be applied to the ‘outside’ of the elongated flat portion in order to promote internal reflection of light, as disclosed herein. In some embodiments the subject is a human, although in other embodiments various animal subjects may be treated. The length and width of the elongated flat portion may be sufficient to wrap around an equatorial region of the eyeball or near the equatorial region. In various embodiments, the waveguide may be placed adjacent to at least a portion of the equatorial sclera, the posterior sclera, and/or the cornea of the eye of the subject.
In use, a tissue may be contacted by the waveguide 130 and light directed into the waveguide 130 by the light source 110. The light exits the waveguide 130 and interacts with a photosensitizer in the tissue; in the specific case of SXL treatment, riboflavin may be applied to the sclera and the interaction of blue light with the riboflavin leads to localized crosslinking and stiffening of the tissue. Light that is emitted from an end of the waveguide (e.g. fluorescence or excitation light) can be directed to a detector to help monitor the progress of a procedure such as SXL.
Using the tapered waveguides, SXL was conducted on fresh, excised porcine eyes with riboflavin and blue light (
Following SXL, scleral stiffness was measured through conventional tensiometry. Stress-strain curves were obtained for scleral strips excised from eyes treated with SXL using the elastomer waveguide, direct illumination with a laser, and untreated eyes.
In both cases, SXL treatment resulted in a near 2-fold increase in the Young's modulus, which was statistically significant (p<0.001). With the elastomer waveguide, there was no significant difference in stiffness between the proximal and distally treated halves of the sclera (two tailed p=0.22). This results suggests that light extraction is sufficiently uniform for whole-globe sclera crosslinking.
The present invention has been described in terms of one or more preferred embodiments, and it should be appreciated that many equivalents, alternatives, variations, and modifications, aside from those expressly stated, are possible and within the scope of the invention.
This application claims the benefit of U.S. Provisional Patent Application Ser. No. 62/426,906 filed on Nov. 28, 2016, and entitled “Flexible Optical Waveguide for Scleral Crosslinking and Myopia Control,” which is incorporated by reference herein in its entirety.
This invention was made with government support under NIBIB 2P41-EB015903, subproject ID: #7931, TRD1: QUANTITATIVE BIOMECHANICS IMAGING (PI: Seok-Hyun Andy Yun) awarded by the National Institutes of Health. The government has certain rights in the invention.
Filing Document | Filing Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
PCT/US17/63245 | 11/27/2017 | WO | 00 |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
62426906 | Nov 2016 | US |