Tamper evident resealable closure

Information

  • Patent Grant
  • 8746483
  • Patent Number
    8,746,483
  • Date Filed
    Monday, May 16, 2011
    13 years ago
  • Date Issued
    Tuesday, June 10, 2014
    10 years ago
Abstract
A container for a food product including a tamper-evident closure which forms an opening of a container. The closure comprises a sealing layer, adhesively sealed to the top of the container around the opening. The sealing layer is releasable from the container by pulling back on the sealing layer and resealable against the top layer to seal the opening when the sealing layer is moved back against the top. The tamper-evident feature comprises a portion of the top adjacent the opening and covered by the sealing layer, which extends from a position spaced from, and extends towards and terminates at the opening of the container. A portion of the tamper-evident feature falls into the container after the sealing layer has been pulled back for a first time to thereby indicate that the container has been previously opened.
Description
FIELD OF THE INVENTION

The present invention relates generally to packages for storing articles and, more particularly, to a tamper-evident, resealable closure for such packages.


BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION

Some containers for food products, such as cookies and other snacks, typically include a frame surrounded by an outer wrapper. The frame acts as a tray to hold the food product and to protect the food product from damage. One normally gains access to the contents of the container by opening one end of the wrapper, withdrawing the tray from inside thereof, and removing the food product from the tray. Reclosing the wrapper, once opened, generally includes folding or rolling the end down and clipping the end to keep the wrapper closed.


One recent advancement in the art of food containers includes a resealable container disclosed in U.S. Pat. No. 6,918,532 (hereinafter the “'532 patent”), herein incorporated by reference. The '532 patent discloses a wrapper which forms a top of the container which has an access opening. A sealing layer is adhesively sealed to the top around the opening. The sealing layer is releasable from the container by pulling back on a tab and the sealing layer is resealable against the top layer to seal the opening when the sealing layer is moved back to a flat position on the top.


Other food products come packaged in plastic trays, such as thermoform trays which are sealed on the top using some type of lidding material. Several conventional lidding materials are available for covering conventional trays. Lidding materials may be metal foil, flexible plastic wrap or rigid plastic. One recent advancement in lidding materials for covering thermoform trays is provided in U.S. patent application Ser. No. 11/193,613 (herein incorporated by reference), which incorporates a resealable opening with a sealing layer similar to the one in the '532 patent.


In the packaging art, different methods have been used to indicate whether a package has been previously opened or whether the integrity of the package has been compromised. For example, in one prior dispensing bag for moistened tissues, shown in U.S. Pat. No. 6,428,867, tamper evidence is provided by a sealing label with an ink layer in the sealing area which leaves ink indicia in the sealing area to indicate that the package has been previously opened.


In another container, shown in U.S. patent application Ser. No. 11/029,651, herein incorporated by reference, various additional methods are shown to indicate whether a sealing layer has previously been removed from the container. One disclosed means for tamper-evident indication is the use of die-cut elongated strips running adjacent to the opening in the sealing area which is defined as the area around the opening of the container, under the sealing layer. One limitation with the use of the prior elongated strips is that the wrapper adjacent the elongated strips may become torn as the sealing layer is pulled back, thus compromising the integrity of the container's top.


There is a need in the art for a resealable container, preferably suitable for containing food items, which includes a new and improved tamper-evident indicator.


BRIEF SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION

The present invention generally relates to a resealable closure having a tamper-evident feature in the form of a flap or elongated strip which terminates at an opening covered by the closure which falls into the container after the container has been opened for the first time.


The present invention, in one form, comprises a tamper-evident resealable closure comprising a first film layer, and a first tear line and a second tear line formed in the first film layer. The first tear line defines a first panel section for providing an access opening through the film layer when separated from the first film layer along the first tear line. The second tear line runs from a position spaced from the first tear line to a position terminating at the first tear line and defining a second panel section for indicating an initial opening of the closure when the second panel is separated from the first film layer along the second tear line. A second film layer is disposed on the first film layer and covers the first and second panel sections. The second film layer includes an adhesive layer for resealably adhering a second film layer such that the first panel section is separated from the second film layer to expose the access opening and the second panel section is separated from the first and second film layers to provide a visual indication the closure has been opened after the second film layer has been removed from a first film layer.


In another form of the present invention, a tamper-evident closure comprises a wrapper forming a top of a container where the top has an access opening into the container. A sealing layer is adhesively sealed to the top around the opening. The sealing layer is releasable from the top by pulling the sealing layer back in a peeling direction and reclosable against the top to seal the opening when the sealing layer is moved back against the top. A slit in the wrapper is located in the sealing area between the access opening and an adjacent edge of the container where the sealing layer is adhesively sealed to the top. The slit has a first end spaced from the opening and a second end terminating at the opening wherein the slit extends, in the peeling direction, from being spaced away from the opening to the opening.


In one further embodiment of the present invention, the slit forms an elongated strip. In an alternative further embodiment, the wrapper comprises a second slit adjacent to the first slit, extending from a position spaced from the opening and terminating at the opening, to form an elongated strip having one end spaced from the opening and a second end terminating at the opening.


The present invention, in another form thereof, concerns a tamper-evident food container comprising a wrapper forming a container having a top where the top has an access opening so as to provide hand access to food contents of the container. A sealing layer is provided which is adhesively sealed to the top around the opening. The sealing layer is releasable when the sealing layer is pulled back in a peeling direction and reclosable against the top to seal the opening when the sealing layer is moved back against the top. A slit is provided in the wrapper located in a sealing area between the access opening and the adjacent edge of the container where the sealing layer is adhesively sealed to the top. The slit has a first end spaced from the opening and a second end terminating at the opening wherein the slit extends in the peeling direction from being spaced away from the opening and terminating at the opening.


Other features and advantages of the present invention are stated in or apparent from detailed descriptions of presently preferred embodiments of the invention found hereinbelow.





BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS


FIG. 1 is a perspective view of a package including an exemplary closure according to the present invention;



FIG. 2
a is an enlarged plan view of the closure depicted in FIG. 1, showing the package prior to being opened for a first time;



FIG. 2
b is the same closure of FIG. 2a, shown after the package has been opened and subsequently resealed in accordance with the present invention;



FIG. 3 is a cross-sectional view of the closure of FIG. 2a, taken along line 3-3;



FIG. 4 is a cross-sectional view of the closure of FIG. 3, depicting an initial opening of the closure;



FIG. 5 is a cross-sectional view of the closure of FIG. 3, depicting a resealed configuration of the closure after the initial opening;



FIG. 6 is an enlarged cross-sectional view of the closure of FIG. 2a, taken along line 6-6;



FIG. 7 is a cross-sectional view of the closure of FIG. 2b, taken along line 7-7;



FIG. 8 is a cross-sectional view of the closure of FIGS. 6 and 7, depicting a resealed condition of the closure;



FIG. 9 is a schematic showing the separation of the tamper-evident feature from the package of FIG. 1, in accordance with the present invention;



FIG. 10
a is a plan view of a package including another closure, according to another aspect of the present invention, shown prior to opening the closure for a first time; and



FIG. 10
b is the same closure depicted in FIG. 10a, shown after the closure has been previously opened and resealed.





DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE INVENTION

Referring now to the Figures, and in particular FIGS. 1-9, there is shown package 10 with closure 11 which incorporates a tamper-evident feature. Package 10 includes an outer wrapper which forms a first layer 12 of top 14, side 16 and crimped ends 18, 19. The first film layer 12 is formed from polymeric film or other flexible material that has been cut, folded or otherwise processed to define an interior space or receptacle for receiving the desired product, such as food items to be provided within a package 10. Package 10 can be used to store and distribute foodstuff, such as cookies, crackers, candy or other items. The film layer 12 may include graphics or other indicia to identify the contents of the package 10.


The closure 11 is formed directly on the first film layer 12 and includes a first tear line 20 formed into the first film layer 12. The first tear line 20 defines a first panel 22 that may be separate from the first film layer 12 along the tear line 20 to expose an opening 24 (FIG. 4) whereby access to the contents of the package 10 may be gained. Although the first tear line 20 is in the form of a full or complete rectilinear form, alternatively, tear line 20 may only include three sides, whereby first panel 22 is permanently attached to the first film layer 12 on one end and, thus, not cut on that one end.


Closure 11 further includes at least one second tear line 40 as a slit formed in the first film layer 12 adjacent to the first tear line 20. The second tear line 40 produces a second panel section 42 formed by the second tear line 40, which remains integrally joined to the first film layer 12 along end 44 of the panel 42 proximate the tab 30 end of the package 10. The second tear line 40 has a generally crescent shape extending from a position spaced from the opening 24 defined by the first tear line 20, all the way to the first die cut 20. As a result, as viewed in the peeling direction 32, the second die cut 40 extends from a position spaced away from the first die cut 20 to the die cut 20.


The closure 11 includes a second film layer in the form of a sealing label such as sealing layer 26 disposed on the top 14 of the package 10 on the first film layer 12. The sealing layer 26 extends beyond the periphery of the first tear line 20 along a sealing area adjacent to the opening 24 to thereby cover the first panel section 22 and second panel 42.


This side of the second film layer 26, which faces the first film layer 12, is coated with an adhesive 28 (see FIGS. 3-5) so that the second film layer 26 may be releasably secured to the first film layer 12. The sealing layer 26 is provided with a tab 30 or other gripping feature which is not coated with adhesive 28 so that the sealing layer 26 may be peeled back from the first film layer 12 to open the package 10.


The sealing layer 26 may include a hinge portion 33, depicted in FIGS. 1, 2a and 2b as a series of undulating die cuts 34 formed through the sealing layer 26 along a peripheral edge positioned opposite the tab 30. As the sealing layer 26 is peeled back, the undulating die cuts 34 help to keep the edge of the sealing layer 26 adhesively secured to first film layer 12, while permitting the sealing layer 26 to be moved away from the access opening 24 to facilitate access to the contents of the package 10. While the hinge portion has been shown and described herein as comprising a series of undulating die cuts 34, it will be recognized that the hinge portion 33 may comprise a fold line defining a hinge or other arrangement suitable for hingedly coupling the sealing layer 26 to the first film layer 12.


As shown in FIGS. 3 and 4, the first panel section 22 is separated from the first film layer 12 along the first tear line 20 and remains adhered to the sealing layer 26 as the sealing layer 26 is peeled back in a peeling direction indicated by arrow 32 (FIGS. 1, 2 and 4) to open the package 10. After the contents of the package 10 have been accessed and it is desired to reseal the package 10, the sealing layer 26 may be reapplied to the first film layer 12, approximately in its original position, as depicted in FIG. 5. Because the sealing layer 26 extends beyond the periphery of the first panel section 22, the adhesive 26 disposed thereon facilitates resealing the package 10 with the first panel section 22 positioned over the access opening 24.


When the sealing layer 26 is peeled away from the first layer 12 to separate the first panel section 22 for a first time, a portion of the second panel section 42 is separated from the first film layer 12, but the integrally joined portion 44 of the second panel 42 ensures that the second panel 42 does not become completely separated from the first film layer 12. The second panel 42, therefore, remains attached to the first film layer 12 and eventually becomes separated from the adhesive coated second film layer 26 as the second film layer 26 is peeled back for a first time in direction 32. Referring to the schematic of FIG. 9, as the sealing layer 26 is pulled back for a first time, the first tear line 20 tears successively, as indicated by the series of arrows 50, and the second tear line 40 tears successively as indicated by arrows 52 until the second tear line 40 terminates at the first tear line 20.


An advantage of having the second die cut extend and terminate at a first die cut is that any residual adhesive force which is applied to the respective second portions will be directed to the first die cut and, thus, the opening of the container, and not extend along the first layer to tear and/or potentially jeopardize the integrity of the package.


The material of the first layer 12 is formed such that the second panel section 42 moves in a direction away from the top 14 and inward of the package 10 when it becomes separated from the first film layer 12 and the sealing layer 26, as depicted in FIGS. 2b, 4 and 7. Thereafter, the second panel section 42 provides a visual indication of an initial opening of the package 10 even when the sealing layer 26 is resealed against the first film layer 12 to reclose the package 10. Specifically, the second panel section 42 remains joined to the first film layer 12 at end 44 while the remainder of the second panel 42 extends downwardly into the package 10, as depicted in FIGS. 2b, 4, 5, 7 and 8, to create a void area 46 that is visually detectable when viewing the package 10.


While FIGS. 1-8 show and describe an outer wrapper which forms a first layer 12 that covers the entire exterior of a package, the first layer 12 may form only a top surface of a package having a resealable opening, such as those packages disclosed in U.S. patent application Ser. No. 11/193,613, and thus closure 11 can form a closure over a thermoform tray having a first sealing layer as a lidding material over the top of the tray.


The first film layer 12 may be formed from polypropylene, polyethylene, cellophane, or any other polymeric material suitable for forming a package enclosure. Likewise, the sealing layer 26 may be formed from polypropylene, polyethylene or any other polymeric material suitable for forming a selectively releasable and resealable cover that can be adhered to the first film layer 12 as described above.


Referring now to FIGS. 10a and 10b, package 110 includes a closure 111 similar to that of package 10. Package 110 differs from package 10 in that a third die cut 141 is formed in first sealing layer 112 which is parallel to second die cut 140 to thereby define a second panel 142 which is in the form of a generally elongated strip extending from a portion 144 spaced away from the first die cut 120 proximate the tab 130 and extending to the first die cut 120 as viewed in the peeling direction 132. As with package 10, one gains access into package 110 by pulling back on tab 130 which releases sealing layer 126 from the first layer 112 sealed to top 114, which separates the first panel 122 from the first layer 112, thereby exposing the opening (not shown). In addition, as the sealing layer 126 is pulled back in direction 132, the second panel 142 is separated from the first outer layer 114 on all sides except for the portion 144 which is permanently attached to the first outer layer 112. As in the embodiment of FIGS. 1-9, as shown in FIGS. 10a and 10b, the outer slit tears along a line that turns in and terminates at line 120. In this embodiment, the inner slit 141 also turn in and terminates at line 120. As a result, the second portion 142 separates from the adhesive of the sealing layer 126 and top 114, and falls into the package 110, as shown in FIG. 9b.


It will now be apparent to one of ordinary skill in the art that the present tamper-evident features of the present closure offers benefits over prior tamper-evident features.

Claims
  • 1. A tamper-evident resealable closure, comprising: a first film layer;a first tear line formed into said first film layer and defining a first panel section for providing an access opening through said first film layer when separated from said first film layer along said first tear line;a second tear line formed into said first film layer, said second tear line running from a position spaced from said first tear line to a position terminating at said first tear line, and defining a second panel section for indicating an initial opening of the closure when the second panel is separated from said first film layer along said second tear line; anda second film layer disposed on said first film layer and covering said first and second panel sections, said second film layer including an adhesive layer for releasably adhering said second film layer to said first film layer such that said first panel section is separated from said first film layer to expose the access opening and said second panel section is separated from said first and second film layers to provide a visual indication the closure has been opened after said second film layer has been removed from said first film layer.
  • 2. The tamper-evident resealable closure of claim 1, wherein said second film layer is transparent.
  • 3. The tamper-evident closure of claim 1, wherein said second panel falls into said container when said second film layer is peeled back for the first time.
CROSS-REFERENCE TO RELATED APPLICATION

This application is a divisional of U.S. application Ser. No. 11/438,705, filed May 23, 2006, which is incorporated herein by reference in its entirety.

US Referenced Citations (453)
Number Name Date Kind
811092 Roberts Jan 1906 A
1065012 Watanabe Jun 1913 A
1106721 Lewis Aug 1914 A
1171462 Rice Feb 1916 A
1791352 Colonnese Feb 1931 A
1949161 Haug Feb 1934 A
1963639 Ahlquist Jun 1934 A
1978035 Thom Oct 1934 A
2066495 Swift Jan 1937 A
2128196 Vogel Aug 1938 A
2475236 Gollub Jul 1949 A
2554160 Von Gunten May 1951 A
2588409 Olsen Mar 1952 A
2605897 Rundle Aug 1952 A
2621788 Hitchcock Dec 1952 A
2684807 Gerrish Jul 1954 A
2965224 Harwood Dec 1960 A
3080238 Kraft et al. Mar 1963 A
3127273 Monahan Mar 1964 A
3179326 Underwood et al. Apr 1965 A
3186628 Rohde Jun 1965 A
3187982 Underwood et al. Jun 1965 A
3217871 Lee Nov 1965 A
3235165 Jackson Feb 1966 A
3245525 Shoemaker Apr 1966 A
3259303 Repko Jul 1966 A
3260358 Gottily et al. Jul 1966 A
3272422 Miller Sep 1966 A
3311032 Lucas Mar 1967 A
3326450 Langdon Jun 1967 A
3331501 Stewart, Jr. Jul 1967 A
3343541 Bellamy, Jr. Sep 1967 A
3373926 Voigtman, Sr. et al. Mar 1968 A
3454210 Spiegel et al. Jul 1969 A
3520401 Richter et al. Jul 1970 A
3528825 Doughty Sep 1970 A
3570751 Trewella Mar 1971 A
3595466 Rosenburg, Jr. Jul 1971 A
3595468 Repko Jul 1971 A
3618751 Rich Nov 1971 A
3630346 Burnside Dec 1971 A
3651615 Bohner et al. Mar 1972 A
3653502 Beaudoin Apr 1972 A
3687352 Kalajian Aug 1972 A
3740238 Graham Jun 1973 A
3757078 Conti et al. Sep 1973 A
3790744 Bowen Feb 1974 A
3811564 Braber May 1974 A
3865302 Kane Feb 1975 A
3885727 Gilley May 1975 A
3905646 Brackmann et al. Sep 1975 A
3909582 Bowen Sep 1975 A
3910410 Shaw Oct 1975 A
3938659 Wardwell Feb 1976 A
3966046 Deutschlander Jun 1976 A
3971506 Roenna Jul 1976 A
3979050 Cilia Sep 1976 A
4113104 Meyers Sep 1978 A
4140046 Marbach Feb 1979 A
4156493 Julius May 1979 A
4185754 Julius Jan 1980 A
4192420 Worrell, Sr. et al. Mar 1980 A
4192448 Porth Mar 1980 A
4197949 Carlsson Apr 1980 A
4258876 Ljungcrantz Mar 1981 A
4260061 Jacobs Apr 1981 A
4273815 Gifford et al. Jun 1981 A
4285681 Walitalo et al. Aug 1981 A
4306367 Otto Dec 1981 A
4337862 Suter Jul 1982 A
4364478 Tuns Dec 1982 A
4397415 Lisiecki Aug 1983 A
4411365 Horikawa et al. Oct 1983 A
4420080 Nakamura Dec 1983 A
4428477 Cristofolo Jan 1984 A
4464154 Ljungcrantz Aug 1984 A
4488647 Davis Dec 1984 A
4506488 Matt et al. Mar 1985 A
4518087 Goglio May 1985 A
4538396 Nakamura Sep 1985 A
4545844 Buchanan Oct 1985 A
4548824 Mitchell et al. Oct 1985 A
4548852 Mitchell Oct 1985 A
4549063 Ang et al. Oct 1985 A
4550831 Whitford Nov 1985 A
4552269 Chang Nov 1985 A
4557505 Schaefer et al. Dec 1985 A
4570820 Murphy Feb 1986 A
4572377 Beckett Feb 1986 A
4608288 Spindler Aug 1986 A
4610357 Nakamura Sep 1986 A
4613046 Kuchenbecker Sep 1986 A
4616470 Nakamura Oct 1986 A
4625495 Holovach Dec 1986 A
4638911 Prohaska Jan 1987 A
4648509 Alves Mar 1987 A
4651874 Nakamura Mar 1987 A
4653250 Nakamura Mar 1987 A
4658963 Jud Apr 1987 A
4667453 Goglio May 1987 A
4671453 Cassidy Jun 1987 A
4673085 Badouard et al. Jun 1987 A
4679693 Forman Jul 1987 A
4694960 Phipps et al. Sep 1987 A
4696404 Corella Sep 1987 A
4723301 Chang Feb 1988 A
4738365 Prater Apr 1988 A
4739879 Nakamura Apr 1988 A
4784885 Carespodi Nov 1988 A
4790436 Nakamura Dec 1988 A
4798295 Rausing Jan 1989 A
4798296 Lagerstedt et al. Jan 1989 A
4799594 Blackman Jan 1989 A
4811848 Jud Mar 1989 A
4818120 Addiego Apr 1989 A
4838429 Fabisiewicz et al. Jun 1989 A
4840270 Caputo et al. Jun 1989 A
4845470 Boldt, Jr. Jul 1989 A
4848575 Nakamura et al. Jul 1989 A
4858780 Odaka et al. Aug 1989 A
4863064 Dailey, III Sep 1989 A
4865198 Butler Sep 1989 A
4866911 Grindrod et al. Sep 1989 A
4874096 Tessera-Chiesa Oct 1989 A
4876123 Rivera et al. Oct 1989 A
4889731 Williams, Jr. Dec 1989 A
4901505 Williams, Jr. Feb 1990 A
4902142 Lammert et al. Feb 1990 A
4917247 Jud Apr 1990 A
4943439 Andreas et al. Jul 1990 A
4972953 Friedman et al. Nov 1990 A
4998666 Ewan Mar 1991 A
4999081 Buchanan Mar 1991 A
5000320 Kuchenbecker Mar 1991 A
5005264 Breen Apr 1991 A
5018625 Focke et al. May 1991 A
5029712 O'Brien et al. Jul 1991 A
5040685 Focke et al. Aug 1991 A
5046621 Bell Sep 1991 A
5048718 Nakamura Sep 1991 A
5060848 Ewan Oct 1991 A
5065868 Cornelissen et al. Nov 1991 A
5076439 Kuchenbecker Dec 1991 A
5077064 Hustad et al. Dec 1991 A
5078509 Center et al. Jan 1992 A
5082702 Alband Jan 1992 A
5085724 Focke Feb 1992 A
5096113 Focke Mar 1992 A
5100003 Jud Mar 1992 A
5103980 Kuchenbecker Apr 1992 A
5124388 Pruett et al. Jun 1992 A
5125211 O'Brien et al. Jun 1992 A
5134001 Osgood Jul 1992 A
5158499 Guckenberger Oct 1992 A
5161350 Nakamura Nov 1992 A
5167974 Grindrod et al. Dec 1992 A
5174659 Laske Dec 1992 A
5184771 Jud et al. Feb 1993 A
5197618 Goth Mar 1993 A
5222422 Benner, Jr. et al. Jun 1993 A
5222813 Kopp et al. Jun 1993 A
5294470 Ewan Mar 1994 A
5307988 Focke et al. May 1994 A
5333735 Focke et al. Aug 1994 A
5344007 Nakamura et al. Sep 1994 A
5352466 Delonis Oct 1994 A
5356068 Moreno Oct 1994 A
5366087 Bane Nov 1994 A
5371997 Kopp et al. Dec 1994 A
5374179 Swanson Dec 1994 A
5375698 Ewart et al. Dec 1994 A
5381643 Kazaitis et al. Jan 1995 A
5382190 Graves Jan 1995 A
5388757 Lorenzen Feb 1995 A
5405629 Marnocha et al. Apr 1995 A
5407070 Bascos et al. Apr 1995 A
5409115 Barkhorn Apr 1995 A
5409116 Aronsen Apr 1995 A
5454207 Storandt Oct 1995 A
5460838 Wermund Oct 1995 A
5460844 Gaylor Oct 1995 A
5461845 Yeager Oct 1995 A
5464092 Seeley Nov 1995 A
5470015 Jud Nov 1995 A
5489060 Godard Feb 1996 A
5499757 Back Mar 1996 A
5503858 Reskow Apr 1996 A
5505305 Scholz et al. Apr 1996 A
5515965 Boldrini et al. May 1996 A
5519982 Herber et al. May 1996 A
5520939 Wells May 1996 A
5524759 Herzberg et al. Jun 1996 A
5531325 Deflander et al. Jul 1996 A
5538129 Chester et al. Jul 1996 A
5550346 Andriash et al. Aug 1996 A
5558438 Warr Sep 1996 A
5582342 Jud Dec 1996 A
5582853 Marnocha et al. Dec 1996 A
5582887 Etheredge Dec 1996 A
5591468 Stockley, III et al. Jan 1997 A
5630308 Guckenberger May 1997 A
5633058 Hoffer et al. May 1997 A
5637369 Stewart Jun 1997 A
5647100 Porchia et al. Jul 1997 A
5647506 Julius Jul 1997 A
5664677 O'Connor Sep 1997 A
5688394 McBride, Jr. et al. Nov 1997 A
5688463 Robichaud et al. Nov 1997 A
5702743 Wells Dec 1997 A
5709479 Bell Jan 1998 A
5725311 Ponsi et al. Mar 1998 A
D394605 Skiba et al. May 1998 S
5749657 May May 1998 A
5770283 Gosselin et al. Jun 1998 A
5791465 Niki et al. Aug 1998 A
5795604 Wells et al. Aug 1998 A
5819931 Boucher et al. Oct 1998 A
5820953 Beer et al. Oct 1998 A
5826101 Beck et al. Oct 1998 A
5833368 Kaufman Nov 1998 A
5855435 Chiesa Jan 1999 A
5862101 Haas et al. Jan 1999 A
5873483 Gortz et al. Feb 1999 A
5873607 Waggoner Feb 1999 A
5882116 Backus Mar 1999 A
5885673 Light et al. Mar 1999 A
5906278 Ponsi et al. May 1999 A
5908246 Arimura et al. Jun 1999 A
5928749 Forman Jul 1999 A
5938013 Palumbo et al. Aug 1999 A
5939156 Rossi et al. Aug 1999 A
5945145 Narsutis et al. Aug 1999 A
5956794 Skiba et al. Sep 1999 A
5993962 Timm et al. Nov 1999 A
5996797 Flaig Dec 1999 A
5997177 Kaufman Dec 1999 A
6015934 Lee et al. Jan 2000 A
6026953 Nakamura et al. Feb 2000 A
6028289 Robichaud et al. Feb 2000 A
6029809 Skiba et al. Feb 2000 A
6056141 Navarini et al. May 2000 A
6060095 Scrimager May 2000 A
6065591 Dill et al. May 2000 A
6066437 Kosslinger May 2000 A
6076969 Jaisle et al. Jun 2000 A
6077551 Scrimager Jun 2000 A
6099682 Krampe et al. Aug 2000 A
6113271 Scott et al. Sep 2000 A
6125614 Jones et al. Oct 2000 A
6126009 Shiffler et al. Oct 2000 A
6126317 Anderson et al. Oct 2000 A
6152601 Johnson Nov 2000 A
6164441 Guy et al. Dec 2000 A
6213645 Beer Apr 2001 B1
6228450 Pedrini May 2001 B1
D447054 Hill Aug 2001 S
6273610 Koyama et al. Aug 2001 B1
6279297 Latronico Aug 2001 B1
6296884 Okerlund Oct 2001 B1
6299355 Schneck Oct 2001 B1
6309104 Koch et al. Oct 2001 B1
6309105 Palumbo Oct 2001 B1
6318894 Derenthal Nov 2001 B1
6352364 Mobs Mar 2002 B1
6364113 Faasse, Jr. et al. Apr 2002 B1
6365255 Kittel et al. Apr 2002 B1
6383592 Lowry et al. May 2002 B1
6402379 Albright Jun 2002 B1
6420006 Scott Jul 2002 B1
6427420 Olivieri et al. Aug 2002 B1
6428867 Scott et al. Aug 2002 B1
6446811 Wilfong, Jr. Sep 2002 B1
6450685 Scott Sep 2002 B1
6457585 Huffer et al. Oct 2002 B1
6461043 Healy et al. Oct 2002 B1
6461708 Dronzek Oct 2002 B1
6471817 Emmert Oct 2002 B1
6476743 Brown et al. Nov 2002 B1
6482867 Kimura et al. Nov 2002 B1
6502986 Bensur et al. Jan 2003 B1
6517243 Huffer et al. Feb 2003 B2
6538581 Cowie Mar 2003 B2
6539691 Beer Apr 2003 B2
6554134 Guibert Apr 2003 B1
6563082 Terada et al. May 2003 B2
6589622 Scott Jul 2003 B1
6592260 Randall et al. Jul 2003 B1
6594872 Cisek Jul 2003 B2
6612432 Motson Sep 2003 B2
6616334 Faaborg et al. Sep 2003 B2
6621046 Kaji Sep 2003 B2
6669046 Sawada et al. Dec 2003 B1
6691886 Berndt et al. Feb 2004 B1
6698928 Miller Mar 2004 B2
6726054 Fagen et al. Apr 2004 B2
6726364 Perell et al. Apr 2004 B2
6746743 Knoerzer et al. Jun 2004 B2
6750423 Tanaka et al. Jun 2004 B2
6767604 Muir, Jr. et al. Jul 2004 B2
6815634 Sonoda et al. Nov 2004 B2
6852947 Tanaka Feb 2005 B2
6865860 Arakawa et al. Mar 2005 B2
6889483 Compton et al. May 2005 B2
6918532 Sierra-Gomez et al. Jul 2005 B2
6929400 Razeti et al. Aug 2005 B2
6951999 Monforton et al. Oct 2005 B2
6969196 Woodham et al. Nov 2005 B2
6983875 Emmott Jan 2006 B2
7007423 Andersson et al. Mar 2006 B2
7021827 Compton et al. Apr 2006 B2
7032757 Richards et al. Apr 2006 B2
7040810 Steele May 2006 B2
7048441 Pape May 2006 B2
7051877 Lin May 2006 B2
7165888 Rodick Jan 2007 B2
7172779 Castellanos et al. Feb 2007 B2
7207718 Machacek Apr 2007 B2
7207719 Marbler et al. Apr 2007 B2
7213710 Cotert May 2007 B2
7228968 Burgess Jun 2007 B1
7254873 Stolmeier et al. Aug 2007 B2
7261468 Schneider et al. Aug 2007 B2
7262335 Motsch et al. Aug 2007 B2
7302783 Cotert Dec 2007 B2
7344744 Sierra-Gomez et al. Mar 2008 B2
7350688 Sierra-Gomez et al. Apr 2008 B2
7351458 Leighton Apr 2008 B2
7352591 Sugahara Apr 2008 B2
7371008 Bonenfant May 2008 B2
7404487 Kumakura et al. Jul 2008 B2
7422142 Arippol Sep 2008 B2
7470062 Moteki et al. Dec 2008 B2
7475781 Kobayashi et al. Jan 2009 B2
7516599 Doll et al. Apr 2009 B2
7518599 Doll et al. Apr 2009 B2
7533733 Nolan May 2009 B2
7533773 Aldridge et al. May 2009 B2
7600641 Burgess Oct 2009 B2
7703602 Saito et al. Apr 2010 B2
7708463 Sampaio Camacho May 2010 B2
7717620 Hebert et al. May 2010 B2
7740923 Exner et al. Jun 2010 B2
7744517 Bonenfant Jun 2010 B2
7758484 Peterson Jul 2010 B2
7858901 Krishnan et al. Dec 2010 B2
7963413 Sierra-Gomez et al. Jun 2011 B2
7971718 Aldridge Jul 2011 B2
8002171 Ryan et al. Aug 2011 B2
8002941 Exner et al. Aug 2011 B2
8029428 Selle et al. Oct 2011 B2
8038349 Andersson et al. Oct 2011 B2
8114451 Sierra-Gomez et al. Feb 2012 B2
8181784 Bouthiette May 2012 B2
8240546 Friebe et al. Aug 2012 B2
20010000480 Stagg et al. Apr 2001 A1
20020068668 Chow et al. Jun 2002 A1
20030019780 Parodi et al. Jan 2003 A1
20030039412 Rodick Feb 2003 A1
20030047695 Zik et al. Mar 2003 A1
20030051440 Chow et al. Mar 2003 A1
20030053720 Smith et al. Mar 2003 A1
20030118255 Miller Jun 2003 A1
20030127352 Buschkiel et al. Jul 2003 A1
20030170357 Garwood Sep 2003 A1
20030183637 Zappa et al. Oct 2003 A1
20030183643 Fagen et al. Oct 2003 A1
20030210838 Steele Nov 2003 A1
20030223656 Razeti et al. Dec 2003 A1
20040011677 Arakawa et al. Jan 2004 A1
20040035719 Ebbers et al. Feb 2004 A1
20040060974 Dacey Apr 2004 A1
20040062838 Castellanos et al. Apr 2004 A1
20040067326 Knoerzer et al. Apr 2004 A1
20040083680 Compton et al. May 2004 A1
20040091184 Miller May 2004 A1
20040112010 Richards et al. Jun 2004 A1
20040150221 Brown Aug 2004 A1
20040175060 Woodham et al. Sep 2004 A1
20040180118 Renger et al. Sep 2004 A1
20040206637 Sierra-Gomez et al. Oct 2004 A1
20050000965 Boardman Jan 2005 A1
20050031233 Varanese et al. Feb 2005 A1
20050084186 Caris Apr 2005 A1
20050116016 Lo Duca Jun 2005 A1
20050117819 Kingsford et al. Jun 2005 A1
20050220371 Machacek Oct 2005 A1
20050247764 Sierra-Gomez et al. Nov 2005 A1
20050276525 Hebert et al. Dec 2005 A1
20050276885 Bennett Dec 2005 A1
20060018569 Bonenfant Jan 2006 A1
20060066096 Kan Mar 2006 A1
20060083446 Sampaio Camacho Apr 2006 A1
20060124494 Clark, Jr. et al. Jun 2006 A1
20060144911 Sierra-Gomez et al. Jul 2006 A1
20060147129 Miller Jul 2006 A1
20060171611 Rapparini Aug 2006 A1
20060199717 Marbler et al. Sep 2006 A1
20060251342 Forman Nov 2006 A1
20060257056 Miyake et al. Nov 2006 A1
20060257599 Exner et al. Nov 2006 A1
20060285779 Golas Dec 2006 A1
20070023435 Sierra-Gomez et al. Feb 2007 A1
20070023436 Sierra-Gomez et al. Feb 2007 A1
20070095709 Saito et al. May 2007 A1
20070140600 Nowak et al. Jun 2007 A1
20070209959 Burgess Sep 2007 A1
20070269142 Tyska et al. Nov 2007 A1
20070275133 Sierra-Gomez et al. Nov 2007 A1
20080013869 Forman Jan 2008 A1
20080031555 Roberts Feb 2008 A1
20080037911 Cole et al. Feb 2008 A1
20080041750 Kohlweyer Feb 2008 A1
20080053861 Mellin Mar 2008 A1
20080060751 Arrindell Mar 2008 A1
20080063324 Bernard et al. Mar 2008 A1
20080063759 Raymond et al. Mar 2008 A1
20080063760 Raymond et al. Mar 2008 A1
20080131035 Rogers Jun 2008 A1
20080135428 Tallier Jun 2008 A1
20080152264 Pokusa et al. Jun 2008 A1
20080156861 Sierra-Gomez et al. Jul 2008 A1
20080159666 Exner et al. Jul 2008 A1
20080203141 Friebe et al. Aug 2008 A1
20080214376 Bonenfant Sep 2008 A1
20080240627 Cole et al. Oct 2008 A1
20080273821 Doll Nov 2008 A1
20080292225 Dayrit et al. Nov 2008 A1
20090001143 Cowan et al. Jan 2009 A1
20090014491 Fuisz et al. Jan 2009 A1
20090022431 Conner Jan 2009 A1
20090028472 Andersson et al. Jan 2009 A1
20090053372 Hambrick et al. Feb 2009 A1
20090074333 Griebel et al. Mar 2009 A1
20090097786 Goglio et al. Apr 2009 A1
20090161995 Henderson et al. Jun 2009 A1
20090190866 Hughes Jul 2009 A1
20090211938 Aldridge Aug 2009 A1
20090226117 Davis et al. Sep 2009 A1
20090273179 Scott et al. Nov 2009 A1
20100002963 Holbert et al. Jan 2010 A1
20100018974 Lyzenga et al. Jan 2010 A1
20100019022 Ryan et al. Jan 2010 A1
20100111453 Dierl May 2010 A1
20100113241 Hebert et al. May 2010 A1
20100172604 Andersson et al. Jul 2010 A1
20100226598 Stoeppelmann Sep 2010 A1
20100230303 Buse et al. Sep 2010 A1
20100278454 Huffer Nov 2010 A1
20100303391 Cole et al. Dec 2010 A9
20110049158 Bouthiette Mar 2011 A1
20110127319 Golden Jun 2011 A1
20110132976 Drewnowski et al. Jun 2011 A1
20110147443 Igo Jun 2011 A1
Foreign Referenced Citations (174)
Number Date Country
768679 Jun 2001 AU
2002334419 May 2003 AU
768679 Dec 2003 AU
2004295316 Jun 2005 AU
2005254459 Dec 2005 AU
2008223524 Mar 2007 AU
2006337982 Aug 2007 AU
2007309154 May 2008 AU
2008229190 Sep 2008 AU
5500885-2 Nov 2001 BR
6202030-7 Apr 2003 BR
6804636-7 Oct 2009 BR
1848870 Mar 1962 DE
9003401 May 1990 DE
9005297 Aug 1990 DE
9014065 Apr 1991 DE
90140656 Apr 1991 DE
4134567 Oct 1991 DE
4134567 Jan 1993 DE
4241423 Jun 1994 DE
19738411 Apr 1999 DE
19822328 Nov 1999 DE
202004012301 Dec 2004 DE
202007005487 Jun 2007 DE
10 2007 030267 Jan 2009 DE
307924 Mar 1989 EP
0388310 Sep 1990 EP
0408831 Jan 1991 EP
0447636 Sep 1991 EP
0 474 981 Mar 1992 EP
0474981 Mar 1992 EP
0488967 May 1992 EP
0488967 Jun 1992 EP
0546369 Jun 1993 EP
0085289 Aug 1993 EP
0447636 Mar 1994 EP
0613824 Mar 1994 EP
0608909 Aug 1994 EP
0513824 Sep 1994 EP
0613824 Sep 1994 EP
0629561 Dec 1994 EP
0661154 Jul 1995 EP
0667828 Aug 1995 EP
0744357 Nov 1996 EP
0752375 Jan 1997 EP
0768993 Feb 1997 EP
0796208 Sep 1997 EP
0758993 Mar 1998 EP
0905048 Mar 1999 EP
0744357 Oct 2000 EP
1046594 Oct 2000 EP
1056066 Nov 2000 EP
1086906 Mar 2001 EP
1136379 Sep 2001 EP
1318081 Jun 2003 EP
1350741 Aug 2003 EP
1 375 380 Jan 2004 EP
1375380 Jan 2004 EP
1382543 Jan 2004 EP
1437311 Jul 2004 EP
1449789 Aug 2004 EP
1457424 Sep 2004 EP
1468936 Oct 2004 EP
1477425 Nov 2004 EP
1488936 Dec 2004 EP
1086906 May 2005 EP
1608567 Dec 2005 EP
1609737 Dec 2005 EP
1609737 Jan 2006 EP
1619137 Jan 2006 EP
1637472 Mar 2006 EP
1697230 Sep 2006 EP
1712468 Oct 2006 EP
1712488 Oct 2006 EP
1755980 Feb 2007 EP
1760006 Mar 2007 EP
1770025 Apr 2007 EP
1608567 Jul 2007 EP
1846306 Oct 2007 EP
1858776 Nov 2007 EP
1873082 Jan 2008 EP
1908696 Apr 2008 EP
1939107 Jul 2008 EP
1858776 Oct 2008 EP
1975061 Oct 2008 EP
1712488 Dec 2008 EP
1846306 Mar 2009 EP
2033910 Mar 2009 EP
2189506 May 2010 EP
0669204 Aug 1995 ER
1327914 Apr 1963 FR
2674509 Oct 1992 FR
2693988 Jan 1994 FR
2766794 Feb 1999 FR
2783512 Mar 2000 FR
2171077 Aug 1986 GB
2266513 Nov 1993 GB
2276095 Sep 1994 GB
57163658 Oct 1982 JP
60-80405 May 1985 JP
60080405 May 1985 JP
52171479 Jul 1987 JP
H0581083 Nov 1993 JP
9150872 Jun 1997 JP
09156677 Jun 1997 JP
9156677 Jun 1997 JP
63022370 Jan 1998 JP
1059441 Mar 1998 JP
10059441 Mar 1998 JP
10120016 May 1998 JP
10129685 May 1998 JP
1998-152179 Sep 1998 JP
11198977 Jul 1999 JP
200335542 Dec 2000 JP
2000335542 Dec 2000 JP
2002002805 Jan 2002 JP
2003-26224 Jan 2003 JP
2003072774 Mar 2003 JP
2005015015 Jan 2005 JP
200662712 Mar 2006 JP
2006062712 Mar 2006 JP
2007045434 Feb 2007 JP
8606350 Nov 1986 WO
9411270 May 1994 WO
9532902 Dec 1995 WO
9725200 Jul 1997 WO
2000064755 Nov 2000 WO
0140073 Jun 2001 WO
02066341 Aug 2002 WO
02064365 Aug 2002 WO
02066341 Aug 2002 WO
03013976 Feb 2003 WO
03013976 Feb 2003 WO
03037727 May 2003 WO
03035504 May 2003 WO
03059776 Jul 2003 WO
03059776 Jul 2003 WO
2004087527 Oct 2004 WO
2005054079 Jun 2005 WO
2005056420 Jun 2005 WO
2005110042 Nov 2005 WO
2005110865 Nov 2005 WO
2005110876 Nov 2005 WO
2005110885 Nov 2005 WO
2005120989 Dec 2005 WO
2005123535 Dec 2005 WO
2006055128 May 2006 WO
2006108614 Oct 2006 WO
2007090419 Aug 2007 WO
2008051813 May 2008 WO
2008062159 May 2008 WO
2008074060 Jun 2008 WO
2008074060 Jun 2008 WO
2008108969 Sep 2008 WO
2008115693 Sep 2008 WO
2008122961 Oct 2008 WO
2008146142 Dec 2008 WO
2009065120 May 2009 WO
2009111153 Sep 2009 WO
2010002834 Jan 2010 WO
2010080810 Jan 2010 WO
2010046623 Apr 2010 WO
2010080810 Jul 2010 WO
2010084336 Jul 2010 WO
2010084336 Jul 2010 WO
2010088492 Aug 2010 WO
2010088492 Aug 2010 WO
2010114879 Oct 2010 WO
2010149996 Dec 2010 WO
2010149996 Dec 2010 WO
2011004156 Jan 2011 WO
2011004156 Jan 2011 WO
2011121337 Oct 2011 WO
2011121337 Oct 2011 WO
Non-Patent Literature Citations (69)
Entry
Patent Abstracts of Japan, vol. 1997 No. 10, Oct. 31, 1997 & JP09156677 A (Fuji Seal Col Ltd.), (Jul. 6, 1997) abstract in English and 7 figures.
“Elite Edam Cheese”, Mintel gnpd, Dec. 3, 2001, Mintel Publishing.
“New Easy Peel Cheese Packaging”, Mintel gnpd, Aug. 10, 2001, Mintel Publishing.
“Soft Bread Sticks”, Mintel gnpd, Mar. 20, 1998, Mintel Publishing.
Machine Update, Mar./Apr. 2002, pp. 59-60.
Reseal-it. [Homepage of Macfarlane Group] [Online] 2005. Available at http//www.reseal-it.se [accessed Mar. 14, 2005].
Giant Baby Wipes package, item No. 80203-91, resealable package having die cut-out portions (tabs) which remain affixed to the top of the package after label is withdrawn from the top, whereby tamper evidence is indicated by a misalignment of the die cut-out portions with the holes formed in the label.
Reseal-It. Web page Internet print out. (accessed Mar. 14, 2005).
“Cheese Range”, Mintel gnpd, Jan. 26, 2001, Mintel Publishing.
“Elito Edam Cheese”, Mintel gnpd, Dec. 3, 2001, Mintel Publishing.
“margin”, Merriam-Webster Online Dictionary, 2010, Merriam-Webster [Online], retrieved on May 6, 2010. Retrieved from the internat URL: <http//www.merriem-webster.com/dictionary/margin>.
“New Easy Peel Cheese Packing”, Mintel gnpd, Aug. 10, 2001, Mintel Publishing.
“New on the Shelf—Product Instructions and Packaging Trends”, Circle Reader Service Card No. 93, Aug. 1998, Baking & Snack.
“Soft Bread Sticks”, Miniel gnpd, Mar. 20, 1998, Mintel Publishing.
European Patent No. 1679269 Opposition documents, Apr. 30, 2012.
European Patent No. 1679269 Opposition documents, May 2, 2012.
Giant Baby Wipes package, item No. 80203-91, resealable package having die cut-out portions (tabs) which remain affixed to the top of the package after label is withdrawn from the top, whereby tamper evidence is indicated by a misalignment of the die-out portions with the holes formed in the label.
Japanese Office Action translation, Japanese Patent Application No. 2009-172352, mailed Feb. 14, 2012.
Machinery Update, Mar./Apr. 2002, pp. 59-60.
Patent Abstracts of Japan, vol. 1997 No. 10, Oct. 31, 1997 & JP0156677 A (Fuji Seal Co. Ltd), (Jul. 6, 1997) abstract in English and 7 figures.
Reclosure system lengthens food life, Packaging News PPMA Preview, Sep. 2001, p. 40.
Reseal-It. Web page Internet print out accessed Mar. 14, 2005; 19 pages.
English Translation of JP H09-156677 published Jun. 17, 1995; 8 pgs.
English Translation of JP S60-80405 published Aug. 5, 1985; 21 pgs.
English Translation of JP 2003-26224 published Jan. 29, 2003; 13 pgs.
English Translation of JP 1998-152179 published Sep. 6, 1998; 6 pgs.
English Translation of JP 2001-114357 published Apr. 24, 2001; 8 pgs.
Fuji Packaging GmbH; Fachpack Brochure; Nuernberg, Oct. 10-12, 2001; 2 pgs.
European Packaging Pack Report; Nr. 5, Mai, 2001; 6 pgs.
Machinery Update; Issue 5, vol. XII, Sep./Oct. 2001; 4 pgs.
Machine translation of claim for BR5500885-2 from Googletranslate.com; 1 pg.
Machine translation of for BR6804636-7 from Googletranslate.com; 1 pg.
Machine translation of claim for BR6202030-7 from Googletranslate.com; 1 pg.
English Translation of JP Official Notice of Rejection mailed on Jan. 29, 2013 in JP Appl. No. 2008-087152, 5 pages.
European Search Report 06118142.6 dated May 3, 2007, citing DE90140656.
International Search Report, PCT/EP2011/054250 dated Jun. 28, 2011.
Partial European Search Report for Appl. No. EP11155570, dated Jun. 12, 2011, 9 pages.
Defendants' Unenforceability Contentions Pursuant to LPR 2.3, dated May 17, 2013, 13 pages.
Defendants' LPR 2.3 Initial Non-Infringement Contentions Exhibit A, dated May 17, 2013, 39 pages.
Defendants' Invalidity Contentions Pursuant to LPR 2.3, dated May 17, 2013, 23 pages.
Defendants' Invalidity Contentions—Exhibit A-1, dated May 17, 2013, 55 pages.
Defendants' Invalidity Contentions—Exhibit A-2, dated May 17, 2013, 35 pages.
Defendants' Invalidity Contentions—Exhibit A-3, dated May 17, 2013, 34 pages.
Defendants' Invalidity Contentions—Exhibit A-4, dated May 17, 2013, 35 pages.
Defendants' Invalidity Contentions—Exhibit A-5, dated May 17, 2013, 39 pages.
Defendants' Initial Non-Infringement Contentions Pursuant to LPR 2.3(a), dated May 17, 2013, 7 pages.
Defendants' Answer, Affirmative Defenses, and Counterclaims Responsive to Complaint, dated Apr. 5, 2013, 25 pages.
Plaintiff's Complaint for Patent Infringement, dated Jan. 16, 2013, 7 pages.
Plaintiff's Answer to Counterclaims of Defendant, dated Apr. 26, 2013, 20 pages.
Plaintiff's Initial Response to Defendant's Initial Invalidity Contentions, dated May 31, 2013, 20 pages.
Global Brands' LPR 2.5 Initial Response to Defendants' Initial Invalidity Contentions Chart Ex. A-1, dated May 31, 2013, 30 pages.
Global Brands' LPR 2.5 Initial Response to Defendants' Initial Invalidity Contentions Chart Ex. A-2, dated May 31, 2013, 20 pages.
Global Brands' LPR 2.5 Initial Response to Defendants' Initial Invalidity Contentions Chart Ex. A-3, dated May 31, 2013, 21 pages.
Global Brands' LPR 2.5 Initial Response to Defendants' Initial Invalidity Contentions Chart Ex. A-4, dated May 31, 2013, 17 pages.
Global Brands' LPR 2.5 Initial Response to Defendants' Initial Invalidity Contentions Chart Ex. A-5, dated May 31, 2013, 14 pages.
“Wall's Bacon—A Sizzling Success Story” and The Grocer: “When sealed delivers”, the second page of which bears a date of Aug. 21, 1999.
Machine translation of DE 202007005487, published Jun. 14, 2007, provided by Espacenet, 3 pages.
Defendants' Final Invalidity Contentions—Exhibit A-1, dated Sep. 27, 2013, 55 pages.
Defendants' Final Invalidity Contentions—Exhibit A-2, dated Sep. 27, 2013, 35 pages.
Defendants' Final Invalidity Contentions—Exhibit A-3, dated Sep. 27, 2013, 34 pages.
Defendants' Final Invalidity Contentions—Exhibit A-4, dated Sep. 27, 2013, 35 pages.
Defendants' Final Invalidity Contentions—Exhibit B-1, dated Sep. 27, 2013, 135 pages.
Defendants' Final Invalidity Contentions—Exhibit B-2, dated Sep. 27, 2013, 64 pages.
Defendants' Final Invalidity Contentions—Exhibit B-3, dated Sep. 27, 2013, 140 pages.
Defendants' Final Invalidity Contentions—Exhibit B-4, dated Sep. 27, 2013, 273 pages.
Defendants' Final Invalidity Contentions—Exhibit B-5, dated Sep. 27, 2013, 146 pages.
Defendants' Final Invalidity Contentions—Exhibit B-6, dated Sep. 27, 2013, 226 pages.
Defendants' Final Invalidity Contentions Pursuant to LPR 3.1, dated Sep. 27, 2013, 22 pages.
Defendants' Final Unenforceability Contentions Pursuant to LPR 3.1, dated Sep. 27, 2013, 14 pages.
Related Publications (1)
Number Date Country
20110253718 A1 Oct 2011 US
Divisions (1)
Number Date Country
Parent 11438705 May 2006 US
Child 13108582 US