The present application claims priority to French Application No. 2213554 filed with the Intellectual Property Office of France on Dec. 16, 2022, which is incorporated herein by reference in its entirety for all purposes.
The invention relates to a target characterisation method for a detection device of multi-panel radar or sonar type with electronic scanning. It is applicable to any set of antenna arrays (each set forming a “panel”) provided with the capacity to phase-shift the signal applied to each of the antennas or each of the subgroups of antennas forming the array, in order to modify the antenna pattern (“electronic scanning”). The systems affected by the invention are notably radars and sonars comprising panels with phase control.
The design of detection modes (a mode is composed of a waveform to be transmitted, of a listening time during which the array digitises the received signals, and a set of processing operations applied to the received signals in order to decide—or not—on the presence of a target) is an active research field, particularly in complex environments.
The complex environments are characterised notably by the presence of ground echoes in the received signal (ground/ground, air/ground or air/air modes when the system is looking downwards), by the presence of sea echoes in the received signal, or, more generally, by the presence of any real echo (i.e. one that is not thermal noise), that is powerful, and/or distributed statistically according to a complex law.
One method that assists in detecting targets consists in estimating the Doppler shift undergone by the waveform transmitted: the ground and sea echoes exhibit a Doppler shift that is of low amplitude, and predictable. For example, in order to dispense with sea clutter in the detection of the targets, it is known practice to combine two observations of the same zone, spaced apart in time by approximately one second. This delay corresponds to the sea clutter correlation time. Any powerful echo exhibiting a Doppler shift that is much greater or much less than those provided for the ground and the sea will be able to be considered as originating from a target.
When generating the waveform, the designer is faced with a set of constraints posed by the hardware capabilities of the detection system (radar/sonar) as well as by the scanning pattern used, limiting the possible choices concerning the waveforms. One of the constraints, well-known to the person skilled in the art, is illustrated by
The left-hand part of
In the right-hand part of
The coherent modes of the prior art (see in particular the article entitled “Radars Traitements avancés du signal radar” (Radars Advanced radar signal processing operations) J. Darricau, Techniques de l'ingénieur) that are based on known scanning methods, canonically exhibit the following properties:
The ambiguous frequency Fa of the integrated sequence of pulses is equal to the frequency of repetition Fr of these pulses, and the ambiguous distance Da is inversely proportional to Fr, with c0 the speed of propagation of the pulse in its environment. In the prior art, Fa and Da are therefore linked by an inverse proportionality relationship, limiting the coherent mode design possibilities.
The right-hand part illustrates the consequence of this mode of operation: without distance ambiguity elimination processing, the instrumented domain is given by the disc contained between the circles C1 and C2. The circle C1 corresponds to the instrumented minimum distance Dmin around the detection device 1 and the circle C2 corresponds to the instrumented maximum distance Dmax (=Da). The radius of the circle C2 is given to within a factor by the constraint (2).
In the prior art, reducing the spectral width Fa necessarily leads to increasing the instrumented domain Da. Given the roundness of the Earth, it is impossible to observe a target of given altitude beyond a certain distance represented in
The scanning method described in the patent application WO 2013/149828 A1 uses a mechanical scanning antenna to scan the environment with a speed of rotation of 60°/s. The antenna also has electronic scanning capabilities for two predefined angles with respect to the line of sight of the mechanical scanning (β30° and +30°). The radar thus revisits each zone of interest after a short time period (approximately one second). This “look-back mode” capability allows the natural decorrelation of the sea clutter to take place between the initial and retrospective samples of the surveillance zone.
Thus, the scanning method described in the patent application WO 2013/149828 A1 makes it possible to create modes subject to the constraint Fa<FR in the case of a radar/sonar system provided with a single electronic scanning panel, mounted on a mechanical positioner. This scanning method is not however compatible with an objective of quasi-instantaneous 360° coverage, because of its single-panel design (a typical electronic scanning panel generally has a maximum angular coverage of 120°).
The use of a mechanical positioner can make it possible to gradually achieve a 360° coverage, but this solution is not satisfactory because of the constraints of the mechanical positioner (mechanical inertia limiting the pointing agility). Furthermore, the realisation of Doppler modes covering all of the relative bearing domain in a time less than a second (sea clutter correlation time) proves very difficult to achieve because of the efforts imposed on the mechanics rotating at these scanning speeds.
There is therefore a need to provide a target characterisation method for a detection device of radar or sonar type, that allows for a greater freedom of mode design, and that makes it possible to develop Doppler modes with very low ambiguous frequency Fa, covering all of the relative bearing domain in a time that is potentially less than a second, and that observes all the directions quasi-simultaneously.
One subject of the invention is therefore a target characterisation method for a detection device of multi-panel radar or sonar type with electronic scanning, comprising the steps of:
Advantageously, the interleaving pattern comprises a sequential transmission of the pulses of different transmission frequencies in a plurality of directions, each direction being associated with a set of transmission frequencies, the transmission frequencies being used cyclically in one and the same direction, the pulses being spaced apart by a repetition period that is predefined from one direction to another, the ambiguous period between two pulses of the same frequency in a same direction at the end of each scan over the relative bearing domain being greater than the repetition period.
As a variant, the interleaving pattern comprises a sequential transmission of the pulses of the same transmission frequency in a plurality of directions, the pulses of the same frequency being spaced apart by a predefined repetition period, the transmission frequency being modified at the end of each scan over the relative bearing domain, the ambiguous period between two transmissions of the same frequency in a same direction being greater than the repetition period.
As a variant, the interleaving pattern comprises a sequential transmission of pulses having different transmission frequencies in a same direction, the pulses being spaced apart by a predefined repetition period, the ambiguous period between two transmissions of the same frequency in a same direction, at the end of each scan over the relative bearing domain, being greater than the repetition period.
Advantageously, the repetition period and the ambiguous period are determined in such a way that:
Advantageously, a coherent integration is performed on the pulses of a same direction and of a same transmission frequency.
Advantageously, the interleaving pattern is repeated, by applying, on each repetition, an angular offset equal to the width of the main lobe.
Advantageously, the interleaving is spread out over three panels with phase control, the relative bearing domain to be covered being equal to 360°.
Advantageously, the pulses are generated over a number of transmission frequencies lying between two and six inclusive.
The invention relates also to a detection device of multi-panel radar or sonar type with electronic scanning, the detection device being configured to:
Other features, details and advantages of the invention will emerge on reading the description given with reference to the attached drawings which are given by way of example.
The method according to the invention comprises a first step in which a plurality of pulses is generated on a plurality of antenna panels of the detection device, according to a temporal and angular interleaving pattern, so as to cover all of the relative bearing domain of the detection device. “All of the relative bearing domain” is understood to mean a complete scan, over the relative bearing domain to be covered.
The detection device advantageously comprises three panels, such that each panel has a coverage substantially equal to ±60°. The invention is however not limited to three panels, and other configurations can be envisaged, for example with four panels.
In a second step, several detection maps are generated. For that, the observations of the echoes corresponding to the pulses transmitted in the first step are integrated. The integration can be coherent (phase coherent between transmission and reception) or non-coherent. Each detection map is obtained in a given direction corresponding to the width of the main lobe of the antenna panel.
In the case where the integration is non-coherent, the detection map is a distance/recurrence map, and not a Doppler map (no Fourier transform). In the case where the integration is coherent, the detection map is a distance/frequency map (also called Doppler map in the state-of-the-art). In the present application, mention is made of detection maps, which includes the distance/recurrence maps and the distance/frequency maps.
The detection maps are then combined so as to detect a presence of a target in the relative bearing domain of the detection device. The combination of the detection maps, or post-integration processing, is well known to the person skilled in the art. The detection maps established for a same direction can be combined, for example, by summing the squared modulus of each detection map, or by any other function leading to the formation of a test statistic which maximises the probability of detection for a given false alarm rate.
Thus, the fact that a detection map is obtained quasi-simultaneously, in several directions, through the temporal and angular interleaving, makes it possible to design novel Doppler modes with a very low ambiguous frequency Fa, less than the pulse repetition frequency Fr.
The three steps are reiterated as many times as necessary depending on the mission entrusted to the detection device.
A first embodiment of the invention is represented in
According to this first embodiment, the interleaving pattern comprises a sequential transmission of the pulses of different transmission frequencies in a plurality of directions. The ellipses EL schematically represent the width of the main lobe of the radiation pattern of the transmitter panel, and therefore the pointing direction.
Each direction is associated with a set of transmission frequencies, the transmission frequencies being used cyclically, in the same direction. In
The sequence represented in
At the initial instant, a pulse at the frequency Fel is transmitted. After a period TR, a pulse at the frequency Fe2 is transmitted with the same panel, the main lobe being electronically steered. After a new period TR, a pulse at the frequency Fe3 is transmitted with the same panel, the main lobe being electronically steered, and so on. The ambiguous period corresponds to the delay between two pulses of the same frequency, in a same main antenna lobe (same direction).
In the context of the invention, it is not necessary for different frequencies to be transmitted. The act of transmitting the pulses on different frequencies is preferable because that makes it possible to obtain echoes from independent targets, which renders the post-processing more efficient. With a single transmission frequency, the target echoes, which would be weakly separated temporally, would be greatly correlated with one another, and little information could thus be extracted from the echoes by the post-processing operations.
The method according to the invention operates, optimally, with a number of transmission frequencies lying between 2 and 6.
Thus, the invention implements an angular, temporal, and generally frequency, interleaving.
Thus, the coherent integration (usually a Fourier transform) can be performed only on the pulses of a same direction and of a same transmission frequency.
It is recalled that the coherent integration is performed on a single transmission frequency, and the post-processing (post-integration) is performed on a plurality of transmission frequencies.
The spectrum thus obtained results from samples integrated at the rate Fa=FR/NbFe (in which NbFe corresponds to the number of transmission frequencies), while transmitting the pulses at the rate FR.
Thus, Ta>TR, that is to say Fa<FR.
In
In
directions, and by using several panels, so as to scan all of the relative bearing domain. When the complete scan has been performed, the pulses are generated with at least one second frequency Fe2, in different directions, and by using several panels, so as to scan all of the relative bearing domain.
In
The successive pointings are spaced apart in relative bearing by ΔG=360°/Nbpointings.
For example, to hold a setpoint ambiguous frequency Fa=55 Hz, with nine pointings over a complete antenna scan, the spacing between the successive pointings can be set at ΔG=40°.
When ΔG>>θ3dB, it is no longer necessary to separate the different successive pointings in frequency, which makes it possible to greatly reduce the number of transmission frequencies used. This embodiment advantageously makes it possible to use only two transmission frequencies Fe1 and Fe2, while, in the example of
The determination of ΔG, to be very much greater than θ3dB, depends notably on the antenna pattern, the objective being to be made insensitive to a potential echo of second recurrence which would be received through a side lobe of the antenna pattern. This parameterisation can be performed by the person skilled in the art using his or her general knowledge.
Advantageously, a coherent integration is performed on the pulses of a same direction and of a same transmission frequency. The integration is performed over an integration period Tintegration defined by the following relationship:
NDop corresponds to the number of pulses over which the Fourier transform is
calculated.
In the example of
At the end of an integration period Tintegration, a set of detection maps is obtained that are of spectral width Fa<<FR, distributed over 360°, constructed quasi-simultaneously, and separated angularly by ΔG=360°/Nbpointings.
For NbFe independent detection maps in each pointing direction, these NbFe detection maps can be combined in order to characterise the targets in the coverage domain.
In order to fill the blind zones between two successive detection maps, the interleaving pattern, of time Tintegration, is repeated, by applying, on each repetition, an angular offset G0 equal or substantially equal to the width of the main lobe θ3dB. Thus, at the end of the complete interleaving pattern of
When designing the Doppler mode, it is possible to act on the duration of the observation holes of width ΔHole≈ΔG−θ3dB to scan all of the relative bearing domain over a single time Tintegration, while observing the setpoints linked to the repetition frequency FR and Fa<FR.
According to another embodiment, illustrated by
Thus, the embodiment illustrated by
In the embodiment illustrated by
The embodiments illustrated by
The method described according to one or other of the embodiments makes it possible to design a new class of Doppler modes with very low ambiguous frequency Fa, with a high recurrence frequency FR>Fa, and exploiting the electronic scanning agility to very rapidly produce detection maps over all of the relative bearing domain) (360°). Thus, the detection maps can be produced at the end of a delay Tintegration (approximately 100 ms) if an angular spacing of the detection maps equal to ΔHole is tolerated, or at the end of a delay Tintegration.ΔHole/θ3dB (approximately 1 s) if the angular holes are eliminated.
An example of design of the Doppler mode illustrated by
The designer of the mode first defines:
An instrumented maximum distance Da∝c0/(2.FR), with co the speed of propagation of the transmitted pulse
A spectral width of setpoint Fa<FR
The number of pulses integrated NDop to form each map DaVa (detection map or even Ambiguous Distance Ambiguous Speed map)
The refresh time
with
NbDava the number of maps DaVa desired in each direction, for the purposes of post-integration or any other processing
Since these parameters are set, the secondary parameters can be obtained:
The elementary pattern of time Tintegration is repeated
times, by applying, on each repetition i, an angular offset
so as to fill the blind directions.
Number | Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
2213554 | Dec 2022 | FR | national |