1. Field of the Invention
The disclosed technology relates to a device and a method for measurement of temperature using a MEMS resonator and, more particularly, to a device and method for measurement of temperature using a frequency difference or frequency ratio of two frequencies. The frequencies are generated by an excitation element that excites the resonator body into separate first and second resonance states.
The technology also relates to a micromechanical resonator device having a passive temperature compensated resonance frequency.
2. Description of the Related Technology
MEMS-based thermometer implementations can be found in the prior art. A dual-mode resonator is for example presented in “Temperature measurement and compensation based on two vibration modes of a bulk acoustic mode microresonator”, M. Koskenvuori et al., IEEE International Conference on Micro Electro Mechanical Systems—MEMS '08, p. 78-81, Tucson Ariz., USA, 2007. Different vibration modes of a fixed resonator can depict different temperature dependencies of their resonance frequencies. Using these characteristics, one can assess the temperature of the resonator by building oscillators using two vibration modes and comparing their oscillation frequencies. The main drawbacks of this approach are: a) either the oscillator circuits have to be fitted with complex filters and/or diplexers to separate the two frequencies and generate the oscillations, and/or b) the resonator has to be excited with two different sets of electrodes addressing each of the two modes of interest, and c) two oscillator circuits are required.
Another drawback is mentioned in the paper: the difference in frequency changes of the two modes is rather small and the resonant frequencies are close to each other. Therefore: a) a very accurate frequency measurement is needed to accurately deduce the small relative changes in frequency, b) the beat frequency of the two modes is fairly high reducing the sensitivity when using the beat frequency to measure the temperature and c) any mixing products of the two excited modes will degenerate the reference oscillator noise performance.
A dual resonator as in U.S. Pat. No. 7,369,004 comprises two separate resonators. These two resonators need to have a different temperature dependency for the same resonance mode. These resonators with slightly different dimensions can be excited with equivalent sets of electrodes. The main drawbacks from this approach are: a) the two resonators have to be thermally strongly coupled for their temperature to be equal, while mechanically weakly coupled for their resonances not to interfere and b) this approach requires roughly double the MEMS area and also requires two oscillator circuits.
Certain inventive aspects relate to a micromechanical resonator device for more accurately measuring a temperature.
Thereto the micromechanical resonator according to one inventive aspect comprises: a resonator body; an excitation element associated with the resonator body and adapted for exciting the resonator body; a control element connected to the excitation element and adapted for controlling the excitation element to excite the resonator body; wherein the resonator body is adapted to resonate in a first and a second predetermined resonance state, the first and second resonance states being of the same eigenmode but having different resonance frequencies, the resonance frequencies having a different temperature dependency; the control element is adapted to supply to the excitation element separately a first bias to excite the resonator body into the first resonance state, and a second bias to excite the resonator body into the second resonance state; whereby the micromechanical device further comprises: a frequency detection element associated with the resonator body, adapted for detecting a frequency at which the resonator body resonates; a temperature determination element connected to the frequency detection element and adapted for determining a temperature of the micromechanical resonator device from a first frequency, detected while the resonator body is in the first resonance state, and a second frequency, detected while the resonator body is in the second resonance state.
By applying two different biases to the excitation element, the resonator body can be brought in a first or a second resonance state. The inventor has found that resonance states of the same eigenmode but corresponding to different biases show a different temperature behavior. This is different from what was already known in the art, namely that resonance frequencies of different eigenmodes of a resonator show different temperature behavior. As the resonance states feature different temperature coefficients of the frequency, the temperature information can be deduced by measuring the frequency change of both states. Only one resonator and a single excitation element are required. This reduces the chip area but also guarantees that the actual resonator temperature is measured.
By using a single resonator structure to measure both frequencies instead of using two resonator structures, a higher temperature measurement accuracy can be achieved because any temperature difference between the two structures is eliminated.
By measuring two frequencies instead of only one, the absolute frequency values are not required, only the relative frequency values, so that an absolute time-base can be omitted.
Preferably the temperature determination element comprises circuitry for determining a frequency difference and/or a frequency ratio using a look-up table and/or a mathematical relationship for determining the operation temperature. By using subtraction and/or division circuitry, the relative deviations of the first and second frequencies can be determined, from which deviations the temperature can be derived using a look-up table and/or a mathematical relationship representative of the temperature dependencies.
In an embodiment the control element is adapted for exciting the resonator body in the first resonance state and the second resonance state alternately. By alternately measuring the first and second resonance frequencies, the temperature can be constantly updated using the two most recent values.
Preferably the temperature dependency of the resonance frequency of the first resonance state is inverse to the temperature dependence of the resonance frequency of the second resonance state, meaning that one resonance frequency increases with temperature while the other decreases. In this way the average frequency of the resonator stays more stable with temperature as compared to the case where two frequencies would be used having a temperature dependency of the same sign. Alternatively the temperature dependencies can have the same sign but have a measurable different slope.
Preferably the resonator body comprises a material selected from the group of (poly)silicon, diamond, ruby, sapphire, quartz, alumina, nickel and SiGe, as these materials allow fairly standard manufacturing techniques.
Preferably the resonator body comprises a bar resonator suspended above a substrate. A bar resonator has the advantage over a plate resonator that it occupies less space, which is more economical.
Preferably the substrate comprises a material selected from the group consisting of silicon, diamond, ruby, sapphire, glass, quartz, alumina and LCP, as these materials are commonly used substrate materials.
Certain inventive aspects relate to a method for measuring a temperature of such a micromechanical resonator device, and to a micromechanical resonator device having a passive temperature compensated resonance frequency.
Thereto the micromechanical resonator device comprises: a resonator body suspended above and anchored to a substrate and adapted to resonate in a predetermined resonance state at the predetermined resonance frequency; an excitation element adapted for exciting the resonator body, the excitation element and the resonator body being separated from each other and together forming a transconductive structure; a control element connected to the excitation element adapted for applying a predetermined bias to the excitation element to excite the resonator body into the predetermined resonance state; wherein the resonance state is a mechanical vibration mode parallel to the plane of the substrate; the material of the resonator body and the material of the substrate are selected such that the ratio of the coefficient of thermal expansion of the substrate material and the coefficient of thermal expansion of the resonator body material is larger than 1.0; the transconductive structure has a transconductance with a predetermined temperature dependency which is defined by a set of parameters, the set of parameters comprising the material of the resonator body, the material of the substrate, the geometry of the resonator device and the predetermined bias and being selected such that at a predetermined temperature, the predetermined temperature dependency of the transconductance compensates the intrinsic temperature dependence of the resonance frequency. The inventor has found that a resonator having a vibration mode parallel to the plane of the substrate can also be used for passive temperature compensation, by using a structure and materials for the resonator body and the substrate satisfying certain conditions, as described in the claim. With transconductive structure is meant a structure between the excitation element and the resonator body where over the bias voltage is applied, and by which the resonance frequency can be tuned, such as a gap or an interdigitized structure.
An advantage of this structure over the structure described by Tucson Ariz. is that the slope of the temperature dependency can be tuned or selected by choosing proper biases, allowing to increase the accuracy of the measurement.
In one embodiment the resonator body is a free-standing bar resonator adapted to resonate in a longitudinal vibration mode above and parallel to the plane of the substrate. As most resonators use a flexural vibration mode, the inventor was surprised to see that a longitudinal vibration mode, i.e. the expansion/compression of a bar resonator can be used to generate a stable resonator frequency. Advantageously, a closed form formula can be calculated for this structure.
In an alternative embodiment the micromechanical body is a free-standing bar resonator adapted to resonate in a flexural vibration mode above and parallel to the plane of the substrate. Most resonators, especially plate resonators using a flexural vibration mode, use a vibration mode substantially perpendicular to the substrate. Being able to use also other modes to achieve temperature stabilization allows many more structures to be used, offering more degrees of freedom and other trade-offs that can be made depending on the application.
In another embodiment the micromechanical resonator device comprises an interdigitated structure with a first set of fingers connected to the excitation element and a second set of fingers connected to the resonator body, wherein the set of parameters further comprises an overlap between the first and second set of fingers. Whereas most micromechanical resonator structures use a gap having a stiffness that varies with the applied bias, the inventor found that another principle can be used to obtain the same effect, namely by using an interdigitized structure between the excitation element and the resonator body. A similar role that was played by the gap, is now played by the overlapping distance.
Presently preferred embodiments are described below in conjunction with the appended drawing figures, wherein like reference numerals refer to like elements in the various figures, and wherein:
The present disclosure will be described with respect to particular embodiments and with reference to certain drawings but the present disclosure is not limited thereto. The drawings described are only schematic and are non-limiting. In the drawings, the size of some of the elements may be exaggerated and not drawn on scale for illustrative purposes.
Furthermore, the terms first, second, third and the like in the description are used for distinguishing between similar elements and not necessarily for describing a sequential or chronological order. The terms are interchangeable under appropriate circumstances and the embodiments of the present disclosure can operate in other sequences than described or illustrated herein.
Moreover, the terms top, bottom, over, under and the like in the description are used for descriptive purposes and not necessarily for describing relative positions. The terms so used are interchangeable under appropriate circumstances and the embodiments of the present disclosure described herein can operate in other orientations than described or illustrated herein.
The term “comprising” should not be interpreted as being restricted to the means listed thereafter; it does not exclude other elements or steps. It needs to be interpreted as specifying the presence of the stated features, integers, steps or components as referred to, but does not preclude the presence or addition of one or more other features, integers, steps or components, or groups thereof. Thus, the scope of the expression “a device comprising means A and B” should not be limited to devices consisting of only components A and B. It means that with respect to the present description, the only relevant components of the device are A and B.
Micro-electro-mechanical (MEM)-resonators are recognized key components for future sensing, wireless and communications applications [1], [2]. Si-based resonators have gained special interest since they offer the perspective to replace bulky quartz resonators on-chip, maintaining high Q-factor (such as about 1000 or more) and reaching high frequencies (such as about 100 MHz or more). In various applications, e.g., time-reference, the temperature (T-) stability is of paramount importance. ET, the T-coefficient of Young's modulus (E), typically dominates the intrinsic T-dependence of the resonance frequency, fres. For Si-based MEM resonators this T-dependence is much larger than for quartz crystal resonators, and too large to allow the passive implementation of these resonators in wide T-ranges such as about −40° C. to +85° C. To circumvent this problem, two main approaches have been proposed in literature: 1) Coating the resonator with negative ET materials, such as SiOx, lowers the effective ET, thus enhancing the T-stability [2]. This passive approach increases the processing complexity and cost, but is often not effective to fully compensate the T-drift and significantly degrades other resonator characteristics, e.g., the quality factor (Q-factor). 2) Implementing an active control loop, e.g. composed of a thermometer and a heater around the resonator allows limiting its T-excursion, thus its T-drift, at the expense of increased design/process complexity and power consumption.
Several solutions addressing the issue of temperature compensation are known. U.S. Pat. No. 6,987,432, which is incorporated herein by reference, discloses active and passive solutions. An active solution comprises determining the actual operating frequency for a beam resonator in relation to a desired resonance frequency, and thereafter applying a compensating stiffness to the resonator to maintain the desired resonance frequency. Passive solutions for frequency stabilization with temperature of a MEMS resonator include for example a method of fabricating a micromechanical resonator. U.S. Pat. No. 7,427,905, which is incorporated herein by reference, discloses a temperature controlled MEMS resonator and a method for controlling resonator frequency by providing an electrical current to the beam structure and thereby heating the beam structure.
The majority of RF-MEMS devices rely on electrostatic actuation, therefore one embodiment will be exemplified by such MEMS device but the present disclosure is not limited hereto.
Expressing the T-dependencies in (1), the intrinsic T-drift of the natural frequency is shown in
MEM resonators require DC-biasing for their linear operation. Note that V used in formula (2) equals the bias voltage Vbias. This DC-offset introduces a parasitic electrostatic spring softening that results in a shift of fres expressed by (2) for V<<VPI, (where VPI is the modal pull-in voltage, i.e. the static voltage that leads to a mode-collapse).
whereby α is a constant depending on the resonator structure and resonance mode used. For the bar resonator described above resonating in longitudinal (extensional) mode. α is estimated to be a value from 5.0 to 9.5, probably approximately a value from 6.5 to 8.0.
In practice however, VPI does depend on T through the material properties (VPI=VPI (T)) and geometry of the bar but also through the transduction gap d which is an increasing or decreasing function of T depending on CTE*sub defined as the ratio of substrate-to-bar CTE's as shown in
For selected materials, the formula (3) gives a relation between Vbias, W0 and d0, thus between the geometry of the resonator and the bias voltage. This implies that the zero-slope at T=T0 only applies for a single Vbias.
With the above mentioned results, a passive compensation of the T-drift of electrostatically-driven MEM-resonators can be enabled. The key of this implementation is the T-driven modulation of the transduction gap that, controlled by design, can fully balance the T-drift due to the intrinsic material properties of the resonator, notably the choice of the bar and substrate materials and the geometry of the bar resonator, in particular the W and d. The further selection of the optimum bias working point V allows compensating for potential processing inaccuracies. In other words, by choosing appropriate materials and appropriate values of the DC-bias voltage and gap the resonance frequency increase with temperature can be tailored to exactly cancel the intrinsic resonance frequency decrease with temperature.
Analogous, a passive compensation approach can be enabled for MEMS resonating devices using electromagnetic transduction (as illustrated in
A method for designing a micromechanical resonator device is presented. The method comprises the steps of: determining a first temperature dependency of the resonant frequency and compensating the device for the temperature dependency of the resonant frequency in a predefined working point within a predetermined temperature range. The compensation step comprises the steps of: determining a second temperature dependency of the excitation signal generated by the excitation element 3 (i.e. a Vbias or NIbias) upon excitation of the resonator body 2; and designing the gap, such that the second temperature dependency cancels out the first temperature dependency in the predetermined temperature range in a selected working point, e.g. applied bias voltage for electrostatic transduction or applied bias current for electromagnetic transduction.
Another inventive aspect is directed to a temperature measurement system. The system comprises a micromechanical resonator device, comprising a resonator body 2, an excitation element 3 associated with the resonator body 2, a control element 4 and a frequency detection element 5. The resonator body is adapted to resonate in at least a first and a second predetermined resonance state, the first and second predetermined resonance states being of the same eigenmode but having a different resonant frequency, whereby the frequency varies differently with varying operating temperature T. The excitation element 3 (for example an electrode or a coil) is associated with the resonator body 2 and is arranged for exciting the resonator body 2 in a particular resonance mode. The control element 4 is connected to the excitation element 3 and is provided for controlling the excitation element 3 to excite the resonator body 2 into the first and second resonance states. The frequency detection element 5, associated with the resonator body 2, is arranged for detecting a frequency at which the resonator body 2 resonates.
For the thermometer, the resonator structure can be a temperature compensated structure as described above, but this is not required. Using a temperature-compensated structure and bias voltages corresponding to an inverse temperature dependence might be advantageous in applications where the average frequency should remain constant, but other structures and biases will also work for measuring a temperature, if the resonance frequency need not be constant.
The states feature different temperature coefficients of the resonance frequency and therefore by measuring the frequency change of both states (corresponding to both biases) the temperature information can be deduced. Only one resonator 2 and a single excitation element 3 are required. This reduces the chip area cost but also guarantees that the actual resonator temperature T is measured.
In an embodiment, the control element 4 is adapted to supply to the excitation element 3 a first bias to excite the resonator body 2 into the first resonance state, and a second bias to excite the resonator body 2 into the second resonance state. In an embodiment the first bias comprises a first DC voltage component and the second bias comprises a second DC voltage component. In another embodiment, the first bias comprises a first current component and the second bias comprises a second current component.
In an embodiment, the control element 4 is adapted to supply the first and second biases alternately.
In an embodiment, the temperature dependence of the resonant frequency of the first resonance state is opposite/inverse to the temperature dependence of the resonant frequency of the second resonance state, i.e. they have opposite signs.
In an embodiment, the micromechanical resonator device further comprises a temperature determination element connected to the frequency detection element and provided for determining a temperature from a first frequency, detected while the resonator body 2 is in the first resonant state, and a second frequency, detected while the resonator body 2 is in the second resonant state. A shift in the first and/or second frequency or a ratio between the first and second frequency fres1, fres2 is monitored by the temperature determination element 6 (e.g. a control circuit) thereby providing an output signal Tout related to the operating temperature T. The temperature determination element 6 may include processor circuitry arranged for determining the operation temperature T using a look-up table and/or a mathematical relationship.
In an embodiment the resonator body may be fabricated in (poly)silicon, diamond, ruby, sapphire, quartz, alumina, nickel, SIGe or any other material known to the person skilled in the art.
In an embodiment the micromechanical resonator device is a bar resonator, a plate resonator, a flexural beam resonator, etc. that are electrostatically or electromagnetically excited.
In an embodiment the device may include a substrate and supports for supporting the resonator 2 and the electrode 3 above the substrate. The substrate may be a semiconductor substrate such as a silicon substrate but any other material known by the person skilled in the art may be used e.g. diamond, rubi, sapphire, glass, quartz, alumina, LCP.
In one embodiment, a method for designing a micromechanical resonator device 1 is presented. The resonator device 1 comprises a resonator body 2, adapted to resonate in at least one resonant state having a resonance frequency that drifts with temperature, and an excitation element 3 comprising an excitation element (i.e. electrode or coil) placed at a gap from the resonator body 2. The method comprises the steps of: determining a first temperature dependency of the resonant frequency and compensating the device for the temperature dependency of the resonant frequency in a predetermined temperature range. Wherein the compensation step comprises the steps of: determining a second temperature dependency of the excitation signal generated by the excitation element (i.e. a pull-in voltage for electrostatic transduction, a current for electromagnetic transduction) over the gap upon excitation of the resonator body 2 in the resonant state; and designing the gap, such that the second temperature dependency cancels out the first temperature dependency in the predetermined temperature range in a selected working point, e.g. applied voltage for electrostatic transduction or current for electromagnetic transduction.
The device may further comprise a drive electrode structure formed at a position to allow electrostatic excitation of the resonator body 2, and the resonator body 2 and the drive electrode structure 3 may define a gap there between.
The device may further include a magnetic circuit (like a ferromagnetic yoke) and a driving coil formed at a position to allow electromagnetic excitation of the resonator body 2, and the resonator body 2 and the magnetic circuit may define a gap in the latter.
To make a thermometer out of a MEMS resonator, one needs to be able and produce two resonance states with different temperature dependencies, on-chip, in media at the same precise temperature one has to measure. As described above, such states are achieved by using a bar resonator structure resonating in a single eigenmode, e.g. an extensional longitudinal mode, but using two different bias voltages, but the present disclosure is not limited thereto. Other vibration modes parallel to the substrate can also be used, e.g. the bar resonator of
The temperature measurement system is illustrated in
Preferably, the control element 4 supplies a first and a second bias alternating. This has the advantage that the temperature T is measured at a single location, which is not the case when using two separate resonators. This allows to measure the temperature T with a higher accuracy.
The temperature measurement system 1 further comprises a temperature determination element 6 connected to the frequency detection element 5. The temperature determination element 6 is provided for determining a temperature from a first frequency fres1, detected while the resonator body 2 is in the first resonant state, and a second frequency fres2, detected while the resonator body 2 is in the second resonant state. A shift in the first and/or second frequency due to a varying temperature is monitored by the temperature determination element 6 (e.g. a control circuit) thereby providing an output signal Tout related to the operating temperature. When using two fixed bias voltages, the resonator body 2 will resonate at a different frequency (f′res1 and f′res2) when the temperature varies. This is illustrated in
The MEM resonator device 1 may be any resonator device known to the person skilled in the art; a bar resonator, a plate resonator, a flexural beam resonator, etc. that are electrostatically or electromagnetically excited. Different actuation mechanisms are introduced in [4] and more in particular electromagnetic actuation in [5]. Both actuation mechanisms. are illustrated in
The device 1 may further comprise a drive electrode structure formed at a position to allow electrostatic excitation of the resonator body 2, and the resonator body and the drive electrode structure may define a gap there between.
The device 1 may further include a magnetic circuit (like a ferromagnetic yoke) and a driving coil formed at a position to allow electromagnetic excitation of the resonator body 2, and the resonator body and the magnetic circuit may define a gap in the latter.
The temperature measurement principle is described above for a bar resonator 2 resonating at the first harmonic, but also works at higher harmonics.
Note that the above mentioned developments, presented in the case of electrostatically transduced resonators, can be directly transposed to the magnetic transduction of MEM resonators. For this, the quantities V (voltage), q (charge) and (permittivity) have to be substituted with n*I (total winded current), f (magnetic flux) and t (permeability) respectively.
The foregoing description details certain embodiments of the present disclosure. It will be appreciated, however, that no matter how detailed the foregoing appears in text, the present disclosure may be practiced in many ways. It should be noted that the use of particular terminology when describing certain features or aspects of the present disclosure should not be taken to imply that the terminology is being re-defined herein to be restricted to including any specific characteristics of the features or aspects of the present disclosure with which that terminology is associated.
While the above detailed description has shown, described, and pointed out novel features of the present disclosure as applied to various embodiments, it will be understood that various omissions, substitutions, and changes in the form and details of the device or process illustrated may be made by those skilled in the technology without departing from the spirit of the present disclosure.
Each of the following references is incorporated herein by reference in its entirety.
Number | Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
10166586.7 | Jun 2010 | EP | regional |
10169307.5 | Jul 2010 | EP | regional |
This application claims priority under 35 U.S.C. §119(e) to U.S. provisional patent application 61/308,836 filed on Feb. 26, 2010, which application is hereby incorporated by reference in its entirety.
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
61308836 | Feb 2010 | US |