Patent Application
20230302489
Microstructured interfaces can provide functionality due to the geometry of the surface. Examples include light-matter interactions, super-hydrophobicity, self-cleaning, anti-bacterial, radiative, and convective cooling, and drag reduction. Because of their ability to adapt to the environment, many examples of complex structures in biological systems remain a significant source of inspiration in the development of fundamental scientific principles. Nature remains far ahead of human-developed technologies, as biological systems have been using micro-nano scale structures to produce unique functionalities for millions of years. For example, lotus leaves have a specific surface roughness with modified surface chemistry to enable self-cleaning as it does not get dirty even though it grows in a muddy environment. A shark is one of the best swimmers in the ocean. It has a unique skin morphology with periodic microstructures that modify the near-wall vorticity during turbulent flow reducing skin friction. In contrast, Namib desert beetles harvest water from the fog with superhydrophobic-superhydrophilic microstructures that allow them to survive in harsh dry weather. These unique surface topographies with useful functionalities have inspired the development of biomimetic micro-nano structures for applications in self-cleaning surfaces, drinking water harvesting from fog, friction reduction in solid-solid interfaces, and hydrodynamic drag reduction in ships.
Linear periodic microstructures are of great importance in a variety of applications including drag-reduction, biofouling, self-cleaning, and superhydrophobicity. However, practical applications of such surfaces need mass manufacturing techniques which to date are highly challenging. Aspects of the present disclosure are related to methodologies for template-free production of micro/nano-textures. A simple template-free scalable manufacturing technique is demonstrated to fabricate linearly periodic microstructure by controlling the so-called ribbing defects in the forward roll coating. A viscoelastic polymer nanocomposite with tailored properties was synthesized and utilized as the coating material. By the adjustable ribbing parameters in roll-coating variable periodicity of the linear microstructures was obtained with 114-700 μm spacing. The microstructure also showed a linear to random microstructure transition as the instabilities increased. The manufactured surface also holds a high Wenzel roughness factor from 1.6 to 3.6 which results in water contact angles of 128° to 158°. The linear microstructure films can have important applications in mass manufacturing of drag reduction surfaces, whereas the high aspect-ration random microstructure films can have applications in superhydrophobic, self-cleaning, anti-icing, and anti-biofouling surfaces.
Other systems, methods, features, and advantages of the present disclosure will be or become apparent to one with skill in the art upon examination of the following drawings and detailed description. It is intended that all such additional systems, methods, features, and advantages be included within this description, be within the scope of the present disclosure, and be protected by the accompanying claims. In addition, all optional and preferred features and modifications of the described embodiments are usable in all aspects of the disclosure taught herein. Furthermore, the individual features of the dependent claims, as well as all optional and preferred features and modifications of the described embodiments are combinable and interchangeable with one another.
Many aspects of the present disclosure can be better understood with reference to the following drawings. The components in the drawings are not necessarily to scale, emphasis instead being placed upon clearly illustrating the principles of the present disclosure. Moreover, in the drawings, like reference numerals designate corresponding parts throughout the several views.
Functional micro and nano structures have mainly been fabricated by means of templates generated by a photolithography process to obtain the desired geometry. However, the photolithographic process is prohibitively expensive and is not scalable for large area surfaces needed for real-world applications. Disclosed herein are various examples related to a template-free method to obtain “semi-regular” micro/nano-textures by utilizing the ribbing instability behavior in viscoelastic polymers due to shearing stresses, offering low manufacturing cost and scalability for real-world applications. The texture periodicity and height in the polymer coat film can be adjusted through the roll coating process parameters and the polymer composite behavior.
A roll-to-roll process without a template can be used to make micro/nano-scale 3D features with this semi-regular geometry. The width of the roller can be adjusted to produce semi-regular structures on a large area substrate. Applications can include superhydrophobic surfaces in large scale (offering self-cleaning, anti-bacterial, and/or anti-biofouling), electromagnetic and radiation shielding coatings, daytime passive cooling by enhanced radiation emission, among others. Reference will now be made in detail to the description of the embodiments as illustrated in the drawings, wherein like reference numbers indicate like parts throughout the several views.
While various technologies including lithography, laser cutting, micro-coining, 3D printing, and bio-pattern imprinting have been utilized to fabricate these micro-nano structures, there are critical limitations in practical applications as most of these methods are complex, expensive, and time-consuming, making them unsuitable for mass-manufacturing. For example, lithography techniques have been implemented to manufacture periodic linear micro-trench surface that has successfully shown a drag reduction effect in open water turbulent flows. However, the surface samples were made from silicon wafers using microelectromechanical systems (MEMS) technology, limiting them to the size of the wafer—far smaller than a real-life boat or ship. Manufacturing these micro-patterned structures in a low-cost scalable process is important for feasible, practical applications.
The desirability of periodic micro-structures has provided motivation to look more insightfully into a common roll-coating defect known as ribbing instability. The ribbing instability is an interesting phenomenon as spatially periodic patterns form transverse to the roll-coating direction, where spatially periodic patterns appear transverse to the roll-coating direction. During the roll-coating process, a positive pressure gradient is developed in the downstream meniscus of the coating fluid. The flow becomes unstable when the pressure gradient exceeds a critical value, and a finger-like growth is observed. Conventionally, these patterns are undesirable in roll-coating applications such as painting, applying adhesive, or preparing functional films for optical and electrical applications. However, careful control of these ribbing patterns can assist in replicating periodic microstructures obtained by other aforementioned methods.
The ribbing behavior of the Newtonian and non-Newtonian fluids has been studied through experimental and computational models to minimize roll-coating defects. The ribbing periodicity or wavelength (Wλribbing) and amplitude have been studied and found to have a strong relationship with material properties as well as process parameters, including, e.g., the surface energy (γ), viscosity (η), roller radius (R), roller distance or gap (d), and roller speed (U). Although most of the liquids utilized in the coating technologies are non-Newtonian, most of the study was conducted for the ribbing instability with a Newtonian fluid.
For a Newtonian fluid, the onset condition of the ribbing instability was found describable by two dimensionless parameters: the capillary number Ca=η*U/γ and the geometric factor R/d. The critical capillary number C*a showed a linear proportionality with the geometric factor Rid for Newtonian fluids. On the other hand, the critical capillary number for non-Newtonian fluids is much lower than for Newtonian fluids. However, unlike the Newtonian fluid, the theoretical prediction of the C*a in the viscoelastic fluid is not obtainable. There remains a lack of understanding of how the ribbing occurs in coating applications. The elasticity can be controlled with the concentration of polymer molecules in a Newtonian fluid (glycerol/water) and similar trends in the C*a and the normal stress parallel to the flow can be shown as the polymer concentration increases. The results imply that the behavior of the viscoelastic fluid increases the stress in the flow direction by restricting the flow and causes the ribbing instability at a slower roller speed, i.e., a lower capillary number. According to computational simulations, at any given Ca, there is a Weissenberg number Wi above which the flow becomes unstable. Research on non-Newtonian fluids has focused on identifying the critical capillary numbers or threshold conditions to initiate the instabilities, however the fluid propagation and ribbing formation beyond the onset conditions have not been explored.
Coating with viscoelastic fluids tends to be more complex as these materials exhibit complex rheological phenomena, including shear-thinning, shear-thickening, and thixotropic behavior. Unlike the typical coating applications, it is desirable to retain the deformed shape when the rollers come at a stop. However, the materials tend to flatten due to surface tension. This can be overcome by tailoring the balance between surface energy and the viscosity of the coating paste. Though, increasing the viscosity of the paste makes the ribbing behavior more unpredictable.
A roll-coating method has the potential of producing a large surface micro-patterned area by manipulating the ribbing-instability phenomenon. However, there remains a knowledge gap in understanding the ribbing behavior of non-Newtonian paste. An in-depth investigation on the physical properties of the roll-coating pastes and how it influences the ribbing instabilities in a roll-coating process can help achieve scalable manufacturing of periodic micropatterns surface. These surfaces can significantly impact drag reduction, superhydrophobic, self-cleaning, anti-icing coatings, anti-biofouling, biological sensors, and radiative cooling applications.
Unlike the roll-coating applications, controlling the process parameters to manufacture periodic microstructures by controlling the instabilities beyond the onset conditions is examined here. As observed, for most coating materials the ribbing patterns tend to flatten when the roller stops, as the surface tension dominates over viscosity. However, retaining the deformed shape when the rollers stop is necessary to manufacture the periodic microstructures. The surface flattening can be avoided by tailoring the coating liquid's viscoelastic properties. The viscoelasticity of the polymers (e.g., PDMS, polyurethane, polyethylene, or polyamide) can be engineered by nanoparticle addition. The desired materials can behave only like a fluid above the yield stress but act like a solid when the stress is unloaded. The inclusions' volume fraction and geometry can influence the composite's rheological properties. Notably, composites with cylindrical or high aspect ratio nanoparticles are more likely to possess yield stress than spherical particles.
In this disclosure, the ribbing phenomenon of a Newtonian fluid in forward roll coating process parameters is first studied as a reference. The ribbing formation of polydimethylsiloxane (PDMS, Sylgard 184) in a forward roll coating for various process parameters was investigated. The finger-like ribbing was observed during the roll coating. However, when the rollers stopped, the liquid surface flattened due to the surface tension. It was found that the viscoelastic properties of the elastomer can be manipulated by nanoparticle inclusion, which can result in a viscoelastic non-Newtonian composite paste. This can help balance the viscous force to the surface energy forces to avoid surface flattening when the rollers come to stop. Based on the insights from the reference Newtonian fluid elastomer, the composite paste can be utilized in the roll-coating process to manufacture linearly periodic microstructures.
A viscoelastic composite paste was formulated by adding cylindrical nanoparticles (carbon nanotubes, CNTs) to PDMS. This helped to achieve a yield behavior and avoid surface tension-driven flattening. Utilizing the composite paste, linearly periodic microstructures were manufactured by the roll-coating process. The physical properties of the coating paste and computational fluid dynamics (CFD) analysis of the roll-coating parameters helped to successfully manipulate the ribbing instabilities to manufacture periodic microstructures. The manufactured samples were then applied to a miniature boat to measure the drag reduction and load testing. In addition, the mechanical and electrical properties of the CNT-PDMS composite were also evaluated for multifunctionality and robustness.
Methodology
Coating materials preparation. A nanocomposite paste was synthesized using a polydimethylsiloxane elastomer kit (e.g., PDMS Sylgard 184, Dow chemicals) and multi-walled carbon nanotube (e.g., CNT, 6-9 nm diameter, and 100-200 μm length). The PDMS and CNT were initially mixed utilizing a universal planetary mixer for 10 minutes. Next, the hardener was introduced as 10:1 ratio with the PDMS, and the combined mixture was addressed to a high-shear three-roll milling machine. The roller distances were reduced gradually, and the materials were passed multiple times to ensure adequate dispersion and homogenization of the CNTs. The CNT wt % were varied to get composite pastes with tailored rheological properties.
Forward roll coating. A two-roll coating machine was utilized to fabricate samples and analyze the ribbing behavior.
Rheology measurement. Steady and dynamic oscillatory rheological experiments were conducted on a TA Instruments Discovery Hybrid-3 rheometer with an 8 mm cross-hatched parallel plate geometry, using a 1000 μm−2 mm measuring gap. Frequency sweeps were performed from 0.1-627 Hz at an oscillatory strain of 1%, determined to be within the linear viscoelastic regime according to oscillatory strain sweeps. The lower limit of frequencies for the low modulus sample(s) was often dictated by the transducer limit of the rheometer. Tests were repeated in triplicate, and standard errors were <5%. Average values are reported. The frequency sweep data were later utilized to get steady shear-rate vs viscosity data based on the Cox-Merz rule.
Surface morphology characterization. The surface roughness and waviness of the samples were characterized by a non-contacting laser scanning confocal microscope (e.g., Keyence VK-X1100, 0.5 nm height resolution, and 1 nm width resolution). Several roughness descriptors such as the Wenzel roughness factor (r), the density of peaks (Spd), and arithmetic mean wavelength (Wλa) were evaluated from the laser confocal data. The surface morphology was also investigated with a high-resolution scanning electron microscope (e.g., FEI Verios 460 L).
Contact angle measurement. Contact angle measurements were conducted with a Ramé-hart goniometer (e.g., model 250) at ambient temperature (e.g., 22-25° C.). A water droplet of 2 μL was carefully deposited onto the sample surface, and the syringe was withdrawn immediately. The water droplet images at 5 different locations for each of the samples were taken by a charge-coupled device camera and 150 W fiber optic illuminator. Finally, the water contact angle was measured using the low bong axisymmetric drop shape analysis plugin of ImageJ software.
Results
Rheological properties of PDMS vs composite paste. The viscoelastic properties of the materials were plotted in
In
In addition to the moduli increase, the physical interlocking of the CNT in the PDMS matrix results in yield stress, which increases with CNT loading.
Apparent Surface Energy. The dynamics between surface energy and viscosity of the fluid, often described as a capillary number in roll coating, have an important role in ribbing instability. The surface energy (γ) of PDMS has been studied. The dispersive component of surface energy was measured 17.5-21.7 mJ m−2 by several methods such as pendant drop, polymer melt, and liquid contact angle measurements approach. The polar component was negligible compared to the dispersive component, as the value ranged from 0.8 to 2.3 mJ m−2. The surface energy of multiwall CNTs was also measured by the Washburn, Wilhelmy, and scanning electron microscopy (SEM) contact angle measurements method. The dispersive component of the surface energy of CNTs with 90%-99% purity was 23-37 mJ m−2, whereas the polar part was 0-16.1 mJ m−2. However, the CNT-PDMS composite has not been studied previously.
Three reference liquids, water, diiodomethane (DIM), and ethylene glycol (EG), were used to measure contact angles in several flat samples of the composite materials. The data were fitted in Owens-Wendt model, and the apparent surface energy was evaluated. A summary of the apparent surface energy is shown in
CFD Simulation of Roll-Coating of PDMS. A fundamental limitation in all prior studies related to roll-coating of non-Newtonian materials was defining the process parameters during the roll coating, such as the capillary number C*a, shear rate ({dot over (γ)}), and wall shear stress (τw). The shear rate-dependent viscoelastic behavior of the coating materials is usually obtained by a rheometer. However, the roll-coating instruments are not intrinsically viscometric, as they do not have the necessary sensors. Thus, the exact viscosity of the coating paste during the roll-coating process is unknown as the associated shear rate is also unknown. Estimating the capillary number relies on either assuming a constant viscosity or estimating the shear rate based on the velocity of the rollers, which results in inaccurate Ca. Accurate measurement of the shear rate can be obtained by finite element analysis to determine the fluid velocity profile gradient during the roll-coating process.
Hence, a CFD simulation was conducted to develop an effective method to determine the unknown process parameters, including the pressure gradient in the fluid flow direction (dp/dx), fluid flow velocities (Vx), shear rate ({dot over (γ)}), and wall shear stress (τw). A commercial software FLOW-3D was utilized to investigate the effect of roll-coating speeds (U) and rollers distance (d) to the parameters mentioned above. Both rollers were kept at the same speed for each simulation (U1=U2=U).
The ribbing formation was observed in the CFD simulation of roll-coating under various process conditions. First, a 3D simulation was conducted at a fixed roller speed of U=40 rad s−1 for different roller distances (d). A dimensionless parameter (R/d) was defined, where R is the roller radius.
The surface tension-driven 3D model in FLOW-3D is highly computationally demanding. As a remedy, further investigation on the pressure gradient, shear rate, and shear stress during the roll-coating was conducted in two-dimensions. The cross-sectional view of the fluid profile showing the velocity and pressure gradient at the roller's interface is shown in
Next, a parametric study is conducted for roller speed (U) of 30, 50, 80, and 100 rpm with R/d of 31.75, 36.29, 42.33, 50.8, and 63.5. The resulting dp/dx, {dot over (γ)}, and τw are plotted in
Ribbing instabilities in roll-coating of PDMS. Before diving into the ribbing phenomenon of the complex shear-thinning viscoelastic paste, a full-factorial experiment was conducted to investigate the ribbing of PDMS for various roller speeds and roller distances. The rheological properties of PDMS were found to be mostly Newtonian, as the viscosity change during steady shear was minimal. The roller's speed (U1=U2=U) was varied between 30 and 100 rpm, and the roller distance (d) was varied between 0.4-0.8 mm. Upon rotation of the rollers, a distinct ribbing phenomenon was observed. The ribbing wavelengths were defined by the distance between each riblet's peaks.
Upon rotation of the rollers, a distinct ribbing phenomenon is observed, identical to what was observed in the CFD simulation in
In summary, two findings are apparent from the roll-coating of the PDMS. It was observed that the wavelength decreases with an increase in roller speed or R/d, wherein the effect of R/d was most significant with the rise of R/d. The dp/dx, {dot over (γ)}, and τw drive the wavelength formation. The PDMS cannot retain the ribbing patterns when the rollers stop as the materials behave as a fluid. This draws interest in synthesizing coating materials that will behave as a solid when at rest, preventing surface tension-driven flattening, but acts as fluid during the roll-coating allowing the ribbing formation to occur. A significantly higher Cais needed for shape-retention of the ribbing structure when the rollers come to a stop. Nanoparticles (e.g., carbon nanotubes or CNTs) were introduced into the PDMS to tailor the viscoelastic properties of the coating materials to achieve a suitable Ca. However, a higher Ca also incurs higher instabilities. By careful experimentation with various CNT wt % with the PDMS, 3.5 wt % CNT-PDMS composites were found to be the most suitable composite as this successfully retained the shape, as well as the instabilities, in a controllable order.
Ribbing Instabilities in Roll-Coating of CNT-PDMS Composite. The CNTs were next introduced into the PDMS to tailor the viscoelastic properties of the coating materials. A yielding material is needed to avoid surface flattening when the rollers stop, which will selectively behave like a fluid in elevated shear stress but behave as a solid when the stress is unloaded. The entanglement of the cylindrical-shaped CNTs allowed such behavior. Composite paste with various concentrations of the CNTs was synthesized and utilized in the roll-coating process. At first, 0.5 and 1 wt % CNT were added to the PDMS matrix, and the roll-coating was observed in a high-speed camera.
Similar to the PDMS, ribbing formation is observed for 0.5 wt % CNT-PDMS composite. However, another phenomenon known as filamentation was also observed during the roll-coating. A small hole appears, generating a filament at the roller's interface. As the roller rotates, the hole becomes more prominent as the filament stretches, eventually breaking and developing a peak on top of the ribs. The produced surface is thus a hybrid of ribbing formation and peaks from filamentation rupture. The elastic relaxation of the composite paste has a important effect in generating such micropeaks, with lower elastic materials expected to have shorter peaks. The extensional viscoelasticity of the composite paste and how it influences the instabilities in roll-coating can also be considered.
The roll-coating with 1 wt % of CNT-PDMS with roller speeds of 20, 60, and 100 rpm and R/d of 50.8, 63.5, and 84.67 were examined. The observed hybrid pattern is similar to 0.5 wt % CNT-PDMS results. At 20 rpm speed, the wavelength reduces from 1.03 to 0.49 mm with an R/d increment from 50.8 to 84.67. Notice that the ribbing wavelengths in PDMS ranged from 2.8 to 5.32 mm, whereas the wavelength significantly reduced with the addition of CNTs. This may be attributed to the higher viscosity of the coating paste, causing more dramatic dp/dx resulting in a shorter wavelength. In addition, the linearity of the wavelength formation is also compromised at higher speed and R/d.
The roll coating of 0.5 and 1 wt % CNT-PDMS provided important understanding. i) The wavelength reduced significantly compared to the PDMS as the viscosity and elasticity increased. ii) An additional mode for pattern formation known as filamentation was also observed, which affects the final patterns. iii) At a lower velocity, it was observed that the patterns were more likely to align linearly. iv) In addition, the wavelength control was more precise by controlling the R/d, which is also observed in the roll coating of the PDMS. These findings guided subsequent experimentation with higher wt % CNTs for potentially reducing ribbing wavelength in the micrometer range.
Coating pastes were prepared by adding various wt % of CNTs to the PDMS. 3-3.5 wt % CNT-PDMS provided the most linearly periodic samples upon extensive experimentation. As the wt % of CNTs increases, the higher viscosity and elasticity cause the generated pattern to be more random. For example, no forms of linearity were observed in roll-coating samples with >5 wt % CNTs. The 3 wt % CNT-PDMS sample showed ribbing instabilities and produced a microtrench profile at R/d of 63.5 at 50 rpm roller speed. However, an attempt to further reduce the ribbing wavelength by increasing the R/d resulted in a linear to vein-leaf shape transition at R/d=84.67. A further increase in R/d to 101.6 results in vein-leaf shape samples with a high aspect ratio with a large ribbing wavelength at a millimeter scale. Thus, a more viscous material, 3.5 wt % CNT-PDMS, was utilized to prepare the final samples and further reduce the microstructured surface's wavelength. The roller's speed was fixed at 20 rpm, while the R/d varied from 56.44 to 127.
Surface Morphology Analysis. The 3.5 wt % CNT-PDMS samples showed a hybrid microstructure created by ribbing and filamentation similar to 0.5 and 1 wt % CNT-PDMS. While the ribbing waves were observed transverse to the roll-coating direction, filamentation resulted in many micropeaks in the longitudinal direction. The SEM images of the samples are shown in
Since the SEM shows only a small area of the samples, a laser confocal microscope was utilized to quantify the wavelengths and surface roughness.
The water contact angles (WCA) of the microstructured samples were measured to demonstrate the hydrophobicity of the surface.
The roll-coated samples were broadly classified into two categories based on the microstructures. The generated patterns were mostly linearly periodic in samples for the 3.5 wt % CNT-PDMS samples with 20 rpm speed and R/d 84.67 as shown in
The pressure gradient in the direction of fluid flow, dp/dx for 3.5 wt % CNT-PDMS, was observed to be an order of magnitude higher than PDMS.
The associated shear rate during the roll-coating experiments was also evaluated based on the CFD analysis. The roll coating of 3.5 wt % CNT-PDMS at 20 rpm speed results in 54.02, 80.81, 93.04, 116.37, 119.87, and 154 s−1 shear rate for R/d of 56.44, 63.5, 72.57, 84.67, 101.6, and 127. Notice that the wall shear stress steadily increases from 0.3 to 0.41 MPa for R/d of 56.44 to 84.67. However, at R/d 101.6, when the shear rate is 119.87 s−1 the wall shear stress increases sharply to 0.45 MPa as shown in
Hydrodynamic Drag Reduction. The hydrodynamic drag reduction of the linear microstructured sample was measured by attaching the sample to the underside of a miniature boat and pulling it parallel to the water surface using a wire-and-pulley system.
This decrease of drag reduction with increasing Reynolds number, which deviates from what is known for laminar flows, can be explained by the large Froude number even at low Reynolds numbers due to the small boat size. Note that the boat's drag in the current experiment comprises skin friction and wave-making, and the given sample can reduce only the skin-friction drag with no effect on the wave-making drag. When Fr<0.25, the skin friction drag is dominant; however, the wave-making resistance dominates when Fr>0.25. When the Froude number increased (0.13, 0.18, 0.29, and 0.48, correspondingly) so that the portion of skin friction in the total drag decreased, the reduction of skin friction had a diminishing effect on the total drag. The sample with the densest linear patterns (R/d=84.67, λribbing=114 μm) was the most significant drag-reduction reported in this section. The samples with broader wavelengths did not have a conclusive result as they lack the ability to retain the plastorn.
Electrical Conductivity Measurements. Adding a conductive filler in a nonconductive polymer matrix was found to incur electrical conductivity based on prior studies. Such reinforcement by mechanical-mixing procedure was also observed to improve the electrical and mechanical properties simultaneously. Since CNTs are highly conductive, there is a potentiality of achieving multifunctionality of the SHPo samples if electrical conductivity is also observed. The electrical sheet resistance of the CNT-PDMS composite samples was measured by a custom-made four-point setup following the Van der Paw method with varying CNT wt % and is represented in
In a percolated network, electrons move across the network under an applied electrical field, which increases electrical conductivity. This increase in electrical conductivity, therefore, decreases the measured sheet resistance. Thus, as more CNTs are added, the percolated network grows and enables a decrease in the sheet resistance by increasing electrical conductivity. The PDMS-Sylgard 184 sample resistance was undetermined in the experiment, possibly due to very high resistivity.
This is also important to mention that manufacturing SHPo surfaces capable of plastron regeneration has been carried out by attaching additional conductive electrodes integrated into the surface, which allowed plastron regeneration by electrolysis when the water began to penetrate the microtrench cavities. However, the fabricated microtrench structure would also be able to regenerate plastrons without additional electrode molding since the CNT-PDMS material is reasonably conductive. The plastron regeneration capabilities of the manufactured SHPo surface may be determined.
Scratch Testing. The robustness of the 3.5 wt % CNT-PDMS microstructured sample was tested to identify the load of cohesive and adhesive failure. This load is the smallest load that causes microstructural damage for possible cracking or plastic deformation. Although this test is not a comprehensive materials property test as the test parameters also have an effect, the load observed in such a scratch test is also a function of the mechanical strength of the materials. The first mode of failure, or the cohesive failure (LC1) in the CNT-PDMS sample, was observed for 7 N force as there seemed to be a sudden increase in the frictional force.
A comprehensive investigation was conducted to study the ribbing formation during a roll-coating process both computationally and experimentally. First, ribbing instabilities for the pure PDMS were investigated. It was found that the pressure gradient occurring due to roller speed, R/d, and the material's viscoelastic properties is the driving force of the ribbing instabilities. The wavelengths for the PDMS were observed in the 7.03-3.52 mm range for roller speeds from 30 to 100 rpm and R/d of 31.75 to 63.50. The ribbing formation of PDMS was also observed to flatten when the roller stops due to lower surface energy compared to the viscosity and also not having yield stress. Increasing the CNT content on the PDMS allows the polymer to retain its solid shape even after stopped roll-coating as yield stress of 0.0025, 0.01247, and 0.08737 MPa was observed for 1, 3.5, and 10 wt % of CNT-PDMS. The observed microstructure of the surfaces by the roll-coating was characterized as a hybrid pattern due to ribbing instability and filamentation due to elastic relaxation of the coating paste.
The manufactured samples showed a controllable 114-777 μm size. However, as the roller distance decreases further to increase the R/d to 101.60, the linear ribbing transitions into the random microstructure with a high Wenzel roughness factor (r) of 3.56. The water contact angle of the samples ranged from 128.17° to 158.63°. The CNTs addition also made the samples conductive, opening opportunities for multifunctional applications. The mechanical durability of the fabricated microstructures is also investigated by scratch testing. Finally, the fabricated pieces demonstrate drag reduction capabilities in miniature model ships, self-cleaning surfaces, and anti-biofouling applications.
A simple, scalable fabrication process has been demonstrated to achieve periodic microstructures. Suitable material composition and process parameters have been identified to control the microtrenches' periodicity. However, the periodicity and uniformity in the produced samples are not close to the photolithography-based manufactured samples. The technique has enormous potential for scalable manufacturing. The complete sample preparation needed only half an hour, beginning with the coating paste preparation, roll-coating, and heat-curing. The maximum size achievable with the presented two-roll-coater was 300 mm×150 mm, only constrained by the diameter and length of the rollers. Taking advantage of the ribbing instabilities, a large periodic microstructured surface can be obtained quickly by employing a more robust roll-coater with continuous substrate-feeding capabilities. The process parameters can be fine-tuned, including materials that may improve the control of the surface morphology to move closer to the photolithography-based techniques.
Passive Radiative Cooling of Photovoltaics
With the global temperature on the rise, renewable energy has become increasingly popular. Solar energy consumption saw a 27% increase per year at the start of the 21st century largely due to increasing solar panel installation in residential applications. In 2020, solar photovoltaic energy accounted for over 115,000 GWh of energy being produced in the United States, with significant additions around the world as well. With this increase in solar energy, it is important that solar panels function at the highest possible efficiency. Both dust and increased temperatures are detrimental to the efficiency of photovoltaic panels. As such, it is necessary to develop mitigation for these hazards.
Most silicon-based photovoltaic cells generate power using visible light and near-infrared (IR) (0.4-1.1 μm). All other wavelengths are absorbed by the panel as heat. Electrical losses also contribute to the heating of solar cells. Solar panel efficiency is inversely proportional to the temperature of the photovoltaic cell. It is known that a 1° C. increase in temperature can lower the efficiency of a solar cell by 0.4-0.5%. Furthermore, prolonged exposure to increased temperature can decrease the lifespan of photovoltaic panels. Therefore, maintaining a low operational temperature is important to optimize the function of solar cells.
Most previous methods of cooling photovoltaics involve increasing the convective heat transfer between the solar cell and the surrounding air. This has been demonstrated using both water and air as heat transport mechanisms. These methods act by transferring heat from the solar cell to a transport medium and dissipating excess via a heat exchanger. While these methods were proven to be effective, they require additional hardware to be added to the solar cell making them more expensive, bulky, and less efficient for industrial applications.
To mitigate the need for extra hardware, recent research has shifted to the use of passive radiative cooling films. These films cool the underlying surface by reflecting much of the incoming light as well as promoting increased IR emission which is radiated back into space through the atmospheric window (8-13 μm).
Recent studies have shown that passive cooling using nanoparticle composites and photonic structures can be effective for cooling solar panels. Transparent passive cooling films have been demonstrated as being capable of cooling the underlying surface by up to 14.95° C. These cooling films can be created by dispersing ZnO nanoparticles in a low-density polyethelene matrix. A nanocomposite film using SiO2 particles embedded in a polymethyl methacrylate matrix have been developed that can cool the underlying surface 4-5° C. below ambient temperature using a compression molding process. Precise process control is needed in to apply appropriate amounts of pressure to avoid substrate damage. Precise molding temperature, molding pressure, and holding time are important variables in the compression molding process, which can impact polymer performance. A transparent radiative cooling layer composed of SiO2 gratings on an Si wafer simulating the Si-based photovoltaics have been fabricated using the UV photolithography process. Both photolithography and compression molding are time and material intensive. Furthermore, these manufacturing methods tend to be costly and are not scalable.
In this disclosure, novel manufacturing methods are presented for the creation of photonic passive cooling surfaces using a roll coating process, which has manufacturing advantages in terms of cost as well as scalability, are developed. In this process, as viscous material passes through the gap between two rollers, a positive pressure gradient is made in the coating meniscus downstream. The pressure gradient, along with shearing stress applied by the coating roller, causes instabilities and defects to form. This instability, when a certain value is reached, causes linear patterns, ribboning, or spiked defects to appear on the surface. The manufacturing parameters which influence what type of surface is generated include the roller gap, which influences the pressure gradient, and the roller speed, which influences the shear rate. High shear rates coupled with a small roller gap will create higher density randomly spiked patterns.
Referring to
Similar interfacial behavior is often observed in the texture of walls painted by the roll-brush. Typically, these defects disappear after being extruded through the roller gap because the material's surface tension causes the defects to flatten over time. This property of viscous materials can be manipulated by adding nanoparticles to modify the materials rheological properties. The addition of nanoparticles can also carry secondary effects such as increasing the materials IR emittance or solar reflectance. With added nanoparticles, the viscosity and yield strength dominate over the surface tension. The size and spacing of the defect peaks were demonstrated to have a correlation with material properties (such as surface energy and viscosity) along with manufacturing parameters (e.g., roller radius, roller gap, and roller speed). By adding varying fractions of nanoparticles and changing manufacturing parameters, the topology of fabricated films can be manipulated to desired constraints.
In this example, SiO2/Polydimethylsiloxane (PDMS) nanocomposite films were developed using roll coating methods for use in passive cooling of solar cells. These films were designed to have rough surface textures to promote increased radiation emittance and anti-fouling properties. The composite films were designed with two optical criteria in mind: visible transparency, and high mid-IR emission. Furthermore, the films were designed to have very rough surface textures in order to promote increased emission as well as create possible anti-fouling properties.
Ultraviolet-Visible (Uv-Vis) and FTIR spectroscopy were performed in order to characterize the optical properties of the material. The surface roughness was characterized by laser confocal microscopy and measurement of the water contact angle (WCA). Images of the water contact angle were measured by a goniometer. The images were then processed using an open-source software named ImageJ. Finally, the films performance on solar cells was characterized by outdoor solar panel tests.
Materials. To create the films, an appropriate amount of Sylgard 186 silicone elastomer (purchased from Krayden, Inc) was measured. Varying volume percentages of SiO2 nanoparticles were then added into the mixture. The SiO2 nanoparticles are spherical in shape with average diameter 20-30 nm purchased from US-nano, Inc. Hardener was added to this mixture in a 10:1 ratio of PDMS/hardener. This mixture was initially stirred by hand. Once a uniform paste had been formed, it was placed in a centrifugal mixer for 10 minutes before being roll coated.
Polydimethylsiloxane (PDMS) was chosen as the substrate due to its high IR emission. Fourier-Transform infrared (FTIR) spectroscopy reveals peaks at 3000 nm as well as a series of peaks between 6000-20000 nm range. SiO2 nanoparticles were chosen to modify the viscosity of PDMS because they have high IR emission while maintaining visible transparency. SiO2 particles are able to enhance the mid-IR emission due to the absorption peak at 9 μm. Phonon polarization resonance is another characteristic of uniformly distributed SiO2 nanoparticles, which contributes to their thermal emissivity. Furthermore, since appropriate transparency in the solar spectrum is an important requirement for any solar panel cooling film, SiO2 nanoparticles were chosen because they closely match the refractive index of PDMS (nPDMS=1.43, nSiO2=1.45).
Roll Coating Process. Eight different SiO2/PDMS films were manufactured for this experiment: Four flat and four rough films with 4, 6, 8 and 10 volume percent of SiO2 (10, 14, 18, 21 weight percent). The machine used to fabricate the samples had 2 rollers each with radius 25.4 mm and 300 mm in length. The speed, direction, and distance of each roller was able to be individually controlled. One roller was coated in a layer of Kapton tape which allowed the samples to be easily removed from the roller after the roll coating process was complete. Initially, both rollers were kept at rest and the SiO2/PDMS paste was spread on the rollers. The speed of each roller was then simultaneously increased. All samples tested in this report were fabricated using a roller distance of 0.1 mm and a roller speed of 100 rpm.
To manufacture films with a flat surface, the paste of nanoparticles and PDMS was spread on the rollers. The speed of one roller was then slowly increased to 100 rpm while the other roller was kept stationary. This caused the paste to be spread over the moving roller in an even film. To manufacture the rough films, the PDMS was spread on the rollers as before. Next, the speed of both rollers were simultaneously increased to 100 rpm. After removing the Kapton Tape from the rollers, the films were cured in an oven at 125° C. for 30 minutes. This process is illustrated in
Surface Topography Characterization. The surface topography of the rough samples was characterized by a non-contacting laser scanning confocal microscope (Keyence VK-X1100, 0.5 nm height resolution, and 1 nm width resolution). The peak height and density were then evaluated from this data.
The water contact angle of each film was measured by a Ram'e-hart goniometer (model 250, with the charge-coupled device camera and a 150 W fiber optic illuminator accessories) at ambient temperature of 23° C. For each sample, 2 μL of water were dropped on the surface. Images were captured at three different locations on each sample. Finally, the water contact angle of each image was found using the drop analysis plugin for ImageJ software.
Optical Properties Characterization. The reflectance of each film was measured by Uv-Visible spectroscopy spectrometer (UV-Vis, 300-2000 nm, Agilent technologies, Cary 6000i) using a calibrated BaSO4 integrating sphere and a BaSO4 reference at 0.3-1.8 μm. Emittance was measured by a Fourier Transform Infrared spectrometer (FTIR, 4-18 μm, Thermo Scientific, iS50) using a diffuse gold integrating sphere.
Solar Panel Testing. Outdoor tests were performed to test the passive cooling ability of the films as well as evaluate their impact on the power generation of the solar cells. An image of the test setup and a graphical description of the experimental setup is shown in
A thermocouple was attached to the back of the solar cell. The voltage output of the solar cell was measured using a voltmeter. Measurements of temperature and voltage were taken every 10 minutes for 3 hours. The outdoor experiments were performed in Raleigh, North Carolina. Three solar cells were tested at a time. The first solar cell had no film applied to it in order to act as a control sample. The next two cells had the flat and rough SiO2/PDMS films applied respectively. This allowed for the different volume percents to be compared to a control sample.
Surface Characterization—Water Contact Angle. The water contact angle was measured for each sample.
Surfaces with high water contact angles tend to show antifouling merits due to the fact that the surface texture makes it harder for large dust particles to settle on the surface and easier for water to wash away contaminants. The 4 and 6 volume percent samples showed no significant variation in WCA between the flat and rough samples and had poorly defined surface topography in comparison to the 8 and 10 volume percent samples. Due to these poor results, the 4 and 6 volume percent samples were excluded from further experiments.
Surface Characterization—Laser Confocal. Laser confocal microscopy was performed to characterize the surface topology of the 8 and 10 volume percent rough samples and is shown in
Surface Characterization—Optical Characterization. Uv-Vis and FTIR Spectroscopy were performed to characterize the optical properties of our coatings.
Surface Characterization—Outdoor Solar Panel Passive Cooling Tests. All outdoor solar panel tests were conducted in Raleigh, North Carolina (35.77° N-78.68° E). The solar panel test of the 8 volume percent film was conducted on Aug. 9, 2022 which featured rare passing clouds. This experiment begun at 10:30 A.M. and lasted 3 hours with humidity ranging from 66% at the start of the test to 60% at the end. Additionally, outdoor air temperature ranged from 30.5° C. at the start to 34.4° C. at the tests end. The test of the 10 volume percent film was conducted on Sep. 1, 2022 which featured mostly sunny skies with passing clouds. This experiment began at 3:20 P.M. featuring a 3 hour duration, being conducted later in the day as the morning featured completely cloudy skies. The humidity ranged from 38% at the start of the experiment to 50% at the end. Temperature ranged from 90° C. to 29.4° C. with sunset being at 7:42 P.M. in the Raleigh area.
The average temperature difference between the solar panels with 8 volume percent SiO2/PDMS films and the control with no film was 1.1° C. and 3.5° C. for the flat and rough samples respectively and is shown in
The average temperature difference between the solar panels with 10 volume percent SiO2/PDMS films and the control was 2.1° C. and 3.3° C. for the flat and rough films respectively and is shown in
For both volume percents, the rough samples consistently provided a greater temperature difference below the control. This is due to the increased surface area of the rough films which led to greater amounts of radiation being emitted. Furthermore, increased amounts of SiO2 nanoparticles also contributed to greater temperature differences. Furthermore, it can be expected that at higher temperatures and lower humidity, such as desert or space environments, passive cooling of our films given their parameters could show a stronger impact and positively affect the voltage output.
A composite film was developed that enables the passive cooling of solar panels while having minimal impacts on their power generating efficiency. This film was manufactured utilizing a novel roll coating process. An SiO2/PDMS nanocomposite polymer-film was produced which included a rough surface topography in order to enhance emittance in mid-IR. The topography of these films was generated by exploiting ribbing instabilities in roll coated polymers. The positive pressure gradient created as a fluid passes between two rollers causes a random microstructure to be formed. Furthermore, the samples with rough surface topography were shown to have high water contact angles promoting anti-fouling merits.
Optically, the films were shown to have high transmission in the visible spectrum while having increased emission in mid-IR. During outdoor testing, it was found that this film can decrease surface temperature of a solar panel by 3.5° C. on average whilst having minimal impact upon the electrical efficiency of the solar cell. The important values of our manufactured composite films can be found in TABLE
The manufacturing methods used to create these films are cost effective, scalable, and fast. On a small scale, several films can be made in the span of a few hours and the process could be easily scaled by increasing the size of the manufacturing machine. This solves several problems that are created by traditional manufacturing techniques such as compression molding and photolithography. Furthermore, the roll coated films perform similarly to films made in previous studies which use other more costly manufacturing processes.
Daytime Ambient Passive Radiative Cooling
In this study, a template-free roll-to-roll method combined with polymetric nanocomposites is demonstrated to fabricate photonic spike coatings for daytime radiative cooling.
The ideal radiative cooling materials should possess high solar reflectivity and thermal emissivity. The transparent PDMS is used for high thermal emission. TiO2 and Al2O3 nanoparticles are mixed with PDMS to enhance solar reflectivity. TiO2 is a commercial white painting material with high reflectivity at a thin thickness due to its high refractive index (about 2.7). However, the TiO2 highly absorbs the UV and blue light due to the 3.0 eV bandgap (413 nm), which limits the solar reflectivity below 91% 27. Low-cost Al2O3 nanoparticles were introduced to suppress UV absorptivity to tackle this challenge. The final design of the bilayer photonic materials is shown in
Besides the improved solar reflectivity, the thermal emissivity was elevated by fabricating the spike microstructures on the top surface of the coating. The spike microstructures (about 30 μm lateral length) only had a negligible effect on the solar spectrum reflectivity by Rigorous Coupled-Wave Analysis (RCWA) as shown in
For cooling energy-saving applications, the radiative cooling photonic coating materials will need to be fabricated on a large scale. The rapid roll-to-roll method fabricates the TiO2/PDMS and Al2O3/PDMS bilayer photonic coating materials with spike microstructures by employing viscoelastic fluid instability. The formation of the spike peaks is described in 19B (15 vol % Al2O3/PDMS, relatively low viscosity and low roller speed are utilized). Previous simulation research demonstrated that surface energy γ, viscosity η (or complex viscosity η*), roller radius R, roller distance or gap d, and roller speed U strongly correlated with the pressure gradient in the flow direction, which directly led to the formation of the spike “defects”. To demonstrate the effects of η, U, γ, and R/d on the final spikes' peak periodicity (pspike), parametric experiments are conducted with U ranging from 20 rpm to 100 rpm, and R/d from 100 to 320. The 4-24 vol % Al2O3/PDMS nanocomposites are prepared for different viscosities. The γ and η* measurement results of the nanocomposites are shown in
In the final bilayer products, a flat 25 vol % TiO2/PDMS is first roll-to-roll fabricated and cured. Then, the top layer is fabricated on the flat layer by roll-to-roll method, where the 26 vol % Al2O3 and 3 vol % SiO2 (10 nm, stabilization particles) are mixed into PDMS to achieve close-boundary viscosity but with processability. When U went to 100 rpm and the R/d went to 320, the about 100 μm pspike is achieved (
It is necessary to characterize the optical properties of solar and mid-IR ranges to prove the radiative cooling capability of the photonic coating. The ultraviolet-visible (UV-vis) and Fourier transform infrared (FTIR) spectrometers characterize solar reflectivity and mid-IR thermal emissivity, respectively. In
To measure the daytime radiative cooling performance of the sample, a Peltier-based measurement platform was set up in Durham, NC. The measurement included a Peltier device, a PID controller, a data acquisition (DAQ) system, a power supply, and a thermopile pyranometer as shown in the image of
Inspired by the radiative cooling and self-cleaning capability, it is proposed that the bilayer photonic coatings can serve as the efficient radiative coatings of the roofs for cooling energy saving in buildings as illustrated in
In this research, low-cost and scalable high-performance passive radiative cooling microstructured photonic coatings were fabricated by a roll-to-roll method. By controlling the nanocomposite's viscosity and fabricating parameter (roller gap and speeds), periodical spike microstructures were generated in the roll-to-roll process, which endowed the materials with 98.6% emissivity and strong self-cleaning capability. A novel Roll-to-roll Defect Coefficient (RDC) was proposed to predict the peak periodicity by materials' viscoelastic properties and fabrication parameters. Such a photonic coating showed a 99.2 W/m2 average cooling power under direct sunlight. Benefiting from the high cooling power, scalable fabrication, and superhydrophobic properties, the coating was proposed to serve as the cooling roof. 15.1% of the year-round cooling energy saving around the US was demonstrated by numerical simulation.
More importantly, this fabrication method is compatible with any viscous composite paste and makes the scalable application of the photonic coatings possible. This research could potentially serve as a platform for broadening the applicability of traditional roll-to-roll fabrication and inspiring technological advancement in radiative cooling materials.
It should be emphasized that the above-described embodiments of the present disclosure are merely possible examples of implementations set forth for a clear understanding of the principles of the disclosure. Many variations and modifications may be made to the above-described embodiment(s) without departing substantially from the spirit and principles of the disclosure. All such modifications and variations are intended to be included herein within the scope of this disclosure and protected by the following claims.
The term “substantially” is meant to permit deviations from the descriptive term that don't negatively impact the intended purpose. Descriptive terms are implicitly understood to be modified by the word substantially, even if the term is not explicitly modified by the word substantially.
It should be noted that ratios, concentrations, amounts, and other numerical data may be expressed herein in a range format. It is to be understood that such a range format is used for convenience and brevity, and thus, should be interpreted in a flexible manner to include not only the numerical values explicitly recited as the limits of the range, but also to include all the individual numerical values or sub-ranges encompassed within that range as if each numerical value and sub-range is explicitly recited. To illustrate, a concentration range of “about 0.1% to about 5%” should be interpreted to include not only the explicitly recited concentration of about 0.1 wt % to about 5 wt %, but also include individual concentrations (e.g., 1%, 2%, 3%, and 4%) and the sub-ranges (e.g., 0.5%, 1.1%, 2.2%, 3.3%, and 4.4%) within the indicated range. The term “about” can include traditional rounding according to significant figures of numerical values. In addition, the phrase “about ‘x’ to ‘y’” includes “about ‘x’ to about ‘y’”.
This application claims priority to, and the benefit of, co-pending U.S. provisional applications entitled “Template-Free Method for Manufacturing of Semi-Regular Functional Micro-Structured Interfaces in Viscoelastic Materials” having Ser. No. 63/322,799, filed Mar. 23, 2022, and Ser. No. 63/453,883, filed Mar. 22, 2023, all of which are hereby incorporated by reference in their entirety.
This invention was made with government support under grant numbers CMMI2030404 and CMMI2031558 awarded by the National Science Foundation. The government has certain rights in the invention.
| Number | Date | Country | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 63322799 | Mar 2022 | US | |
| 63453883 | Mar 2023 | US |
