The present invention relates generally to safety end treatment for guardrail beams; and more particularly, to a tensioned end treatment for dissipating impact energy of a car colliding with the end of the guardrail beam.
Along most highways there are hazards that can be a substantial danger to drivers of automobiles if the automobiles leave the highway. To reduce the severity of accidents due to vehicles leaving a highway, guardrails are provided. The guardrails are installed such that the beam elements are in tension to aid in re-directive type impacts. Guardrails must be installed, however, such that the terminal end of the guardrail facing the flow of traffic is not a hazard. Early guardrails had no proper termination at the ends, and it was not uncommon for impacting vehicles to become impaled on the guardrail causing intense deceleration of the vehicle and severe injury to the occupants. In some reported cases, the guardrail penetrated directly, into the occupant compartment of the vehicle fatally injuring the occupants.
Upon recognition of the problem of proper guardrail termination, guardrail designs were developed that used box beams and W-beams that allow tapering of the end of the guardrail into the ground. Such designs eliminate any spearing effect. While these end treatments successfully removed the danger of the vehicle being penetrated in a head-on collision, it was discovered that these end treatments operate in a ramp-like fashion and may induce launching of the vehicle causing it to become airborne for a considerable distance with the possibility of roll over.
In search for better end treatments, improved energy absorbing end treatments for W-beam guardrail elements were developed. For example, an extruder terminal was developed and typically includes a bending structure that squeezes the guardrail into a flat plate and then bends it about a circular arc directed away from the impacting vehicle. Example extruder terminal products include the ET 2000™ and the ET-PLUS™ offered by Trinity Highway Products. Other extruder terminal products include the SKT 350™ and FLEAT 350™ offered by Road Systems, Inc.
Many of these energy absorbing systems use a cable to connect the first w-beam guardrail segment to the first post in the system. The cable provides tension in the guardrail beam element for a redirective hit along the length-of-need portion of the guardrail. A number of cable releasing posts have also been developed for use in these terminals. The cable release posts are intended to release the cable anchor and, thus, release the tension in the system when the post is impacted in either of a forward (end-on) or reverse direction. Such systems are not able to remain in tension during end-on and reverse-direction type impacts.
The present invention provides a new and improved tension end treatments for highway guardrails.
According to a particular embodiment, an end treatment for a guardrail safety system includes a terminal portion of a guardrail beam comprising a downstream end and upstream end, a first tension cable coupled to an upstream end of the terminal portion. an extruder configured to receive at least a portion of the guardrail beam and at least a portion of the first tension cable, and a terminal support post installed adjacent the roadway at an upstream end of the terminal portion of the guardrail beam. The extruder includes a narrowing throat providing a channel in which at least a portion of the guardrail beam is disposed. The narrowing throat is configured to flatten the guardrail beam in response to a collision with a vehicle moving the extruder in a downstream direction along the guardrail beam. The terminal support post coupled to an upstream end of the first tension cable.
Technical advantages of particular embodiments of the present invention include a guardrail end treatment that dissipates impact energy for deceleration of the impacting vehicle. Another advantage may be that a tensile and resistive coupling may be provided for connecting an end of the W-beam guardrail element to a terminal support post. The components of the system that provide the tensile connection of the guardrail beam to the terminal support post may enable the guardrail beam to remain secured after an end-on or re-directive impact. Thus, the system may remain in tension during both types of impacts. Still another advantage may be that the tension is released when the system is impacted in the reverse direction near the terminal end, however. The releasing of tension in the guardrail element for reverse direction impacts prevents vehicle instability and excessive deceleration
Other technical advantages will be readily apparent to one skilled in the art from the following figures, descriptions and claims. Moreover, while specific advantages have been enumerated above, various embodiments may include all, some or none of the enumerated advantages.
Existing guardrail end treatments have proven to be unsafe for some collision conditions that happen on the highway, sensitive to installation details, and/or very costly. However, the end treatments described below are safety treatments for the ends of a W-beam or other guardrail that provide a higher level of performance over a wider range of collision conditions and reduces end treatment costs and the number of injuries and deaths associated with guardrail terminal accidents. The described system maintains the tension in the guardrail beam element during both end-on and re-directive type impacts. When the system is impacted in the reverse direction near the terminal end, however, the anchorage system may release to prevent vehicle instability or excessive deceleration.
Guardrail system 100 includes a guardrail beam 102 and support posts 104 that anchor guardrail beam 102 in place along the roadway 101. In a particular embodiment, guardrail beam 102 may include multiple 12-gauge W-beam rail elements of a length on the order of approximately 12.5 feet or 25 feet. The guardrail beam sections may be mounted at a height of on the order of approximately 27 to 31 inches with rail splices positioned mid-span between the support posts 104.
Guardrail beam 102 is attached to support posts 104 with connectors that may include, in particular embodiments, slotted countersunk bolts such as, for example, 16 mm (⅝-inch) diameter by 38 mm (1½-inch) long flat slot machine screws. Oversized guardrail nuts may be used on the back side of the support post 104. Support posts 104 may be embedded in the ground, a concrete footing, or a metal socket. Support posts 104 may be made of wood, metal, plastic, composite materials, or any combination of these or other suitable materials. It is also recognized that each support post 104 within guardrail system 100 need not necessarily be made of the same material or include the same structural features. Furthermore, the cross-section of support posts 104 may be any engineered shape suitable for releasably supporting guardrail beam 102. Such cross-sectional shapes may include, but are not limited to, square, rectangular, round, elliptical, trapezoidal, solid, hollow, closed, or open.
Guardrail system 100 is intended to keep errant vehicles from leaving roadway 101 during a crash or other hazardous situation. In many instances, guardrail 100 is installed between roadway 101 and a significant hazard to vehicles (e.g., another roadway, a bridge, cliff, etc.). Therefore, guardrail system 100 should be designed to withstand a significant impact from a direction generally perpendicular to roadway 101, without substantial failure. It is this strength that allows guardrail system 100 to withstand the impact, and still redirect the vehicle so that it is once again traveling generally in the direction of roadway 101.
However, testing and experience has continuously shown that guardrail systems may actually introduce additional hazards to the roadway and surrounding areas. This is particularly true with respect to vehicles that impact the guardrail system adjacent its terminal section, in a direction generally parallel to the roadway. For example, if the guardrail system were rigidly fixed in place during a crash, serious injury and damage may result to the errant vehicle, its driver and passengers. Accordingly, many attempts have been made to minimize this added risk. Such methods generally include the use of terminal portions that are tapered from the ground up to effectively reduce the impact of head on collisions and to create a ramp-like effect that causes vehicles to go airborne during a crash. Other methods include breakaway cable terminals (BCT), vehicle attenuating terminals (VAT), SENTRE end treatments, breakaway end terminals (BET) and the breakaway support posts of U.S. Pat. No. 6,398,192 (“'192 patent”). Many-such terminals, supports, end treatments and the like are commercially available from various organizations. Examples include the HBA post by Exodyne Technologies and Trinity Industries, and a breakaway support post similar in configuration to that described in the '192 patent.
Referring again to
Although
Terminal section 108 may be installed either parallel to roadway 101 or at an angular departure from roadway 101, as shown best in
In a particular embodiment where terminal section 108 is linearly flared, terminal section 108 may be flared back at an angle of approximately 6 to 7 degrees from the non-terminal portion of the guardrail. Where support posts 104 of terminal section 108 are spaced apart at intervals of approximately 75 inches, the most downstream post 104 of terminal section 108 may be approximately 9 inches offset from a line tangent to the non-terminal portion of the guardrail, in a particular embodiment. Moving toward the upstream end of terminal section 108, the next four successive support posts 104 may be 19, 29.25, 39, and 48 inches offset from a line tangent to the non-terminal portion of the guardrail, in this embodiment. Terminal post 106, which may be positioned directly below guardrail beam 102, may be approximately 47 inches offset from a line tangent to the non-terminal portion of the guardrail, in the described embodiment.
In various embodiments, terminal section 108 includes an end treatment at either or both ends of guardrail system 100. The purpose of end treatment is to dissipate impact energy of the vehicle without creating a dangerous condition such as causing the vehicle to roll-over or allow the guardrail 102 to spear the vehicle or the occupant compartment of the vehicle. In certain embodiments, the end treatment may be designed to maintain tension in the guardrail 102 during and after impact.
End treatment 200 includes a front striking plate 209. coupled to an extruder 210. Extruder 210 surrounds the upstream portion of guardrail beam 204. In one embodiment, extruder 210 may be made up of an upper, U-shaped channel member and a lower, U-shaped channel member, which are secured in a spaced relation to one another by strap plates. The vertical distance between the channel members may be an appropriate distance such that guardrail beam 204 is inserted into the channel created by extruder 210. For example, where guardrail beam 204 comprises a 12-gauge W-beam rail element having a vertical dimension of approximately 12.25 inches, the distance between the top of channel member and the bottom of channel may be approximately 14 inches, in a particular embodiment.
Front striking plate 209 may be secured by welding to extruder 210 of end treatment 200. Front striking plate 209 may be vertically elongated, in particular embodiments. Thus, front striking plate 209 may extend both above and below extruder 210 to permit front striking plate 209 to be easily engaged by either the high bumper of trucks, SUV's, and other taller vehicles and the low set bumpers of smaller cars impacting in a frontal manner. Front striking plate 209 is also positioned so as to engage the vehicle frame or rocker panel to reduce vehicle intrusion when the upstream end of end treatment 200 is impacted by a vehicle in a sideways manner.
During an end-on or oblique end-on collision of a vehicle with front striking plate 209, extruder 210 may be displaced in a downstream direction and downstream portions of guardrail beam element 204 may be forced into the displaced extruder 210. During such a collision, extruder 210 functions as a guide to guide guardrail beam element 204 into flattening portion 212, which includes a narrowing throat 213. Extruder may include guides that prevent shaving of the W-beam guardrail element 204 by ends of extruder 210 as extruder 210 moves along the length of the guardrail beam element 204 during a collision. The guides may accommodate any irregularities or bumps in guardrail beam element 204 to ensure proper feeding of guardrail beam element 204 into flattening portion 212.
As extruder 210 of end treatment 200 moves along guardrail beam element 204 and downstream portions of guardrail beam element 204 are forced into flattening portion 212 through narrowing throat 213, guardrail beam element 204 is flattened vertically. Portions of guardrail beam element 204 exiting the upstream end of flattening portion 212 are flattened into what may appear to be two vertically stacked plates, in a particular embodiment. As this flattening process occurs, substantial energy is dissipated slowing the impacting vehicle.
To aid in initial flattening of guardrail beam element 204 and to aid in the coupling of guardrail beam 204 to tension cable 206, a terminal end of guardrail beam element 204 may be slotted as shown in
Slotted zone 214 may initiate at a terminal end of guardrail beam 204 and extend a desired distance downstream. The horizontal length of slotted zone 214 may vary depending on the horizontal length of end treatment 200. It may be desirable for slotted zone 214 to include the portion of guardrail beam 204 that is coupled to paddle 208 and the portion of guardrail beam 204 that traverses through flattening portion 212. Generally, slotted zone 214 may extend from the terminal, upstream end of guardrail beam element 200 to some distance between the first and second support posts 104.
The placement of one or more slots in slotted zone 214, according to a particular embodiment, may be better understood with reference to the cross- section for a typical W-beam guardrail 204 as also shown in
A slot should be of a size sufficient to enhance the ability of the terminal end of guardrail beam 204 to be coupled to paddle 208 and to be flattened. For example, in one particular embodiment, a slot may be approximately 0.5 inches, as measured vertically. Thus, in a particular embodiment, the slot may have a width on the order of 0.5 inches and extend approximately 81-82 inches. Alternatively, an effective size for the slot has been found to be approximately 0.75 inches, as measured vertically. Thus, the slot may have a width on the order of approximately 0.75 inches and extend approximately 81-82 inches. The provided dimensions are for example purposes only, however. Any number of slots and any size of slot may be used for the one or more slots to enhance the ability of guardrail beam 204 to be coupled to tension cable 206.
While guardrail beam 204 may include W-beam rail elements, it is generally recognized that the illustrated guardrail beam 204 is merely an example of a beam that may be used in a guardrail system. Guardrail beams 204 or portions of guardrail beams 204 may include conventional W-beam guardrails, thrie beam guardrails, box beams, wire ropes, or other structural members suitable for redirecting an errant vehicle upon impact. It is also recognized that the configuration and dimensions of any of the above-described elements within guardrail system 100 may vary as desired.
Returning to
The tension in guardrail beam 102 may also be retained in this manner when guardrail system 100 is subject to a redirective impact in the length of need portion of guardrail system 100. For example, when an impacting vehicle traveling in a direction substantially parallel to the downstream direction of guardrail system 100 leaves the roadway and impacts guardrail system 100, any support posts 104 impacted by the vehicle may operate to release guardrail beam 102 as they are impacted. Modified support posts 104 may be bent toward the ground such that the support posts 104 are displaced and do not pose a hazard to the impacting vehicle. Because the tension in guardrail beam 102 is maintained, guardrail beam element 102 continues to operate to redirect the vehicle back onto the roadway even after one or more support posts are released from guardrail beam element 102.
Head 404 includes a front striking plate 412 coupled to an extruder 414. Extruder 414 surrounds the upstream portion of guardrail beam 406. In one embodiment, extruder 414 may be made up of an upper, U-shaped channel member and a lower, U-shaped channel member, which are secured in a spaced relation to one another by strap plates. The vertical distance between the channel members may be an appropriate distance such that guardrail beam 406 is inserted into the channel created by extruder 414. For example, where guardrail beam 406 comprises a 12-gauge W-beam rail element having a vertical dimension of approximately 12.25 inches, the distance between the top of channel member and the bottom of channel may be approximately 14 inches, in a particular embodiment.
Returning to
During an end-on or oblique end-on collision of a vehicle with front striking plate 412, extruder 414 may be displaced in a downstream direction and downstream portions of guardrail beam element 416 may be forced into the displaced extruder 414. Extruder 414 may include guides that prevent shaving of the W-beam guardrail element 406 by ends of extruder 414 as extruder 414 moves along the length of the guardrail beam element 406 during a collision. The guides may accommodate any irregularities or bumps in guardrail beam element 406 to ensure proper feeding of guardrail beam element 406 into constant slope snout 402.
As extruder 414 of end treatment 400 moves along guardrail beam element 406 and downstream portions of guardrail beam element 406 are forced into constant slope snout 402, guardrail beam element 406 is flattened vertically. Portions of guardrail beam element 406 exiting the upstream end of constant slope snout 402 are flattened into what may appear to be two vertically stacked plates. As this flattening process occurs, substantial energy is dissipated slowing the impacting vehicle.
To aid in initial flattening of guardrail beam element 406 and to aid in the coupling of guardrail beam 406 to tension cable 408, a terminal end of guardrail beam element 406 may be slotted in a manner similar to that described above with regard to
Slotted zone 416 may initiate at a terminal end of guardrail beam 406 and extend a desired distance downstream. The horizontal length of slotted zone 416 may vary depending on the horizontal length of end treatment 400. It may be desirable for slotted zone 416 to include the portion of guardrail beam 406 that is coupled to paddle 410 and the portion of guardrail beam 406 that traverses through constant slope snout 402. Generally, slotted zone 416 may extend from the terminal, upstream end of guardrail beam element 406 to some distance between the first support post 420 and a second support post (not depicted).
While guardrail beam 406 may include W-beam rail elements, it is generally recognized that the illustrated guardrail beam 406 is merely an example of a beam that may be used in a guardrail system. Guardrail beams 406 or portions of guardrail beams 406 may include conventional W-beam guardrails, thrie beam guardrails, box beams, wire ropes, or other structural members suitable for redirecting an errant vehicle upon impact. It is also recognized that the configuration and dimensions of any of the above-described elements within guardrail system 100 may vary as desired.
As depicted, guardbeam rail 406 feeds into a downstream end of constant slope snout 402. Conversely, tension cable 408 feeds through an upstream end of constant slope snout 402 at a downstream end of end treatment 400. Further, constant slope snout 402 extends from the upstream end and slopes toward the ground. Specifically, constant slope snout 402 is configured to transition guardrail beam 406 from a height above the ground level that is appropriate for redirecting an impacting vehicle (31 inches, in a particular embodiment) to ground level.
According to certain embodiments, end treatment 700 includes a terminal portion of a guardrail beam 102 comprising a downstream end and upstream end. At least a portion of the upstream end feeds into extruder 210. In certain embodiments, a tension cable 708 is coupled to a terminal support post using any suitable technique described above. Tension cable 708 feeds through cable outlet 706 at an upstream end of extruder 210. In a particular embodiment, for example, tension cable 708 may feed through cable outlet 706 of striking plate 208. Tension cable 708 then traverses through cable guide 702 from an upstream end to a downstream end of extruder 210.
In the illustrated embodiment, cable guide 702 comprises a tube through which the tension cable 708 is threaded. The cable guide 702 may be configured to transition the tension cable from a first height above ground level to a second height that is lower than the first. Cable guide may be uniformly sloped from the first height to the second height. At a downstream end of extruder, tension cable 708 may be threaded through cable 704 to exit the extruder 210.
In a particular embodiment, cable guide 702 may include two sections through which tension cable 708 is disposed. The first portion is a downstream portion that is substantially horizontal and runs substantially parallel to extruder 210 and guardrail beam 102. A second portion extends from the upstream end of the first portion and slopes toward the ground. In a particular embodiment, the second portion may be uniformly sloped from the first height to the second height. Specifically, the second portion is configured to transition tension cable 708 from a first height above the ground level that is appropriate for redirecting an impacting vehicle (31 inches, in a particular embodiment) to an outlet 706 of extruder 210 that is lower than the first height.
A upstream end of tension cable 708 is then anchored to a terminal support post, similar to the terminal support post 106 described with regard to
As illustrated in
The twister may help maintain the flat portion of the rail on a horizontal traversable profile. In certain embodiments, sliding ET 800 may consist of two main components: the slider top 810 and slider bottom 812. The slider top 810 and slider bottom 812 may be joined during construction using bolting and/or clamping fastening techniques.
In a particular embodiment, sliding extruder terminal 900's includes a throat twister 908, which takes the standard w-beam shape and flattens it as the guardrail beam 906 moves through the throat twister 908. Throat twister 908 also simultaneously twists guardrail beam 906 toward the ground. The profile of the w-beam 906 before, thru and after engaging sliding extruder terminal 900 is shown in
In a particular embodiment, the terminal portion of a guardrail beam 1106 includes a downstream end and upstream end. The cone-shaped throat 1104 may be configured to receive at least a portion of the guardrail beam 1106. As depicted, cone-shaped throat 1104 may form a narrowing channel through which at least a portion of the guardrail beam 1106 is threaded. In a particular embodiment, a diameter of a downstream end of the cone-shaped throat 1104 may be greater than a diameter of an upstream end of the cone-shaped throat 1104. As a result, cone-shaped throat 1104 may operate to flatten guardrail beam 1106 in response to a collision with a vehicle, such as when the vehicle results in the displacement of cone-shaped throat 1104 in a downstream direction along the terminal portion of the guardrail beam 1106.
In a particular embodiment, the guardrail beam 1106 comprises a w-beam member such as that described above. Additionally, guardrail beam 1106 may be configured with at least one slotted zone formed in an upstream end of the w-beam member 1106. Cone-shaped throat 1104 may be configured to flatten the slotted w-beam member into a plurality of stacked plates.
In certain embodiments, the guardrail end treatment 1100 may be located where the guardrail transitions from vertical at a support post such as support post 104 to horizontal at the grade. In a particular embodiment, the striking plate 1102 comprises a rounded vertical plate that serves to catch the errant vehicle and push/slide a cone-shaped throat 1104 downstream along the guardrail beam 1106. In certain example implementations, the depicted embodiment may be used as a retrofit to an existing guardrail end treatment system.
Technical advantages of particular embodiments of the present invention include a guardrail end treatment that dissipates impact energy for deceleration of the impacting vehicle. Another advantage may be that a tensile and resistive coupling may be provided for connecting an end of the W-beam guardrail element to a terminal support post. The components of the system that provide the tensile connection of the guardrail beam to the terminal support post may enable the guardrail beam to remain secured after an end-on or re-directive impact. Thus, the system may remain in tension during both types of impacts. Still another advantage may be that the tension is released when the system is impacted in the reverse direction near the terminal end, however. The releasing of tension in the guardrail element for reverse direction impacts prevents vehicle instability and excessive deceleration.
Although the present invention has been described by several embodiments, various changes and modifications may be suggested to one skilled in the art. It is intended that the present invention encompass such changes and modifications as fall within the scope of the present appended claims. For example, the features described above may be used independently and/or in combination with each other or other design modifications.
This nonprovisional patent application claims priority to U.S. Provisional Patent Application No. 62/195,006, filed Jul. 21, 2015 and entitled “Tension End Treatment For Guardrail Safety System.”
Number | Name | Date | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
5775675 | Sicking | Jul 1998 | A |
6173943 | Welch | Jan 2001 | B1 |
6554256 | Ochoa | Apr 2003 | B2 |
6719483 | Welandsson | Apr 2004 | B1 |
6783116 | Albritton | Aug 2004 | B2 |
7694941 | Abu-Odeh | Apr 2010 | B2 |
8215619 | Leonhardt | Jul 2012 | B2 |
8517349 | Ross | Aug 2013 | B1 |
8596617 | James | Dec 2013 | B2 |
9145943 | Sicking | Sep 2015 | B2 |
9689124 | Harman | Jun 2017 | B2 |
9714493 | Dyke | Jul 2017 | B1 |
20030025112 | Sicking | Feb 2003 | A1 |
20070252124 | Heimbecker | Nov 2007 | A1 |
20120217459 | Smith | Aug 2012 | A1 |
20140231735 | Harman | Aug 2014 | A1 |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
20170051461 A1 | Feb 2017 | US |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
62195006 | Jul 2015 | US |