The present disclosure relates generally to apparatus and methods for testing structures for transferring and storing hydrogen gas, and more particularly, to testing of hollow structures, with single-layer, double-layer, or multi-layer walls composed of one or more solid and/or liquid barrier (e.g., hydrogen containment) materials.
Renewable energy resources in the U.S. could satisfy most of the nation's future energy needs. However, distributed sources of domestic renewable energy—particularly those east of the Mississippi River—cannot meet the concentrated energy demands of large cities and heavy industry. The richest centralized renewable energy resources in the U.S.—wind energy in the Great Plains States, and solar energy in the American Southwest—are largely stranded; i.e., located far from population centers, with no means for energy transmission or storage. Long electric transmission lines could be built to tap these resources, but they are capital intensive, difficult to site and permit, and special financing may be required to recover transmission costs, and to earn a profit. In addition, if the transmitted electricity is produced entirely or mainly from wind or solar energy, overall system performance will be burdened by a low capacity factor (intermittency), and by the inability to store part of the energy to “smooth” or “firm” the delivery of power. For these reasons, converting the produced electricity to hydrogen, and transmitting the hydrogen through a network of pipelines, is a potentially viable alternative strategy for delivering the energy to distant markets. Building new underground pipelines has historically been easier and faster than constructing regional electric infrastructure. Moreover, large-scale electric-transmission and hydrogen-pipeline systems are comparable in capital, operating, and maintenance costs.
Thus, it has been suggested that large-scale, on-site, electrolytic or thermochemical production of hydrogen, bulk storage of the produced hydrogen gas, and long-distance pipeline hydrogen transmission, can provide “seasonally firmed” renewable energy to rural, suburban, and/or city-gate markets. To minimize greenhouse gas emissions, and to lower the costs of gas compression, the hydrogen could be formed from water (pumped from local aquifers, or delivered to each site by pipeline) using electrolyzers that create gaseous hydrogen at pressures as high as 1,500 pounds per square inch (psi). The resulting pressurized hydrogen gas is either directly injected into one or more pipes connected to a pipeline transmission system, or compressed to 2,000-2,500 psi for temporary storage.
Challenges for mass production of hydrogen gas in remote locations, and transmitting the hydrogen to distant points of end-use, are daunting. One of the main difficulties—long recognized and extensively studied, but still largely unresolved—is safe, efficient, and cost-effective pipeline delivery of gaseous hydrogen at pressures greater than or equal to 500 psi. Compressed to such levels, hydrogen is difficult to contain in two respects. First, due to the tiny size of its molecules, hydrogen will pass through the narrowest of passageways, which means that leakage is very difficult to prevent. Second, hydrogen readily dissolves in, and diffuses through, many of the solid materials that are commonly used to contain gases.
Most of the hydrogen produced today for commercial use is transferred short distances through relatively narrow-diameter pipes at nearly constant pressures of just a few hundred psi. For this purpose, carbon steel has been the principal material of choice for pipeline construction; however, cast iron, copper, various plastics—e.g., polyvinyl chloride (PVC) and high-density polyethylene (HDPE)—have also been used, particularly to transfer the gas over short distances.
A major concern for future, high-capacity hydrogen pipelines is long-term durability at internal gas pressures greater than or equal to 500 psi. It is well known that, at these pressures, carbon steels are susceptible to hydrogen embrittlement and cracking, and while the effects of high-pressure hydrogen on plastics are not well known, significant long-term negative impacts on these materials are also a real possibility. Hydrogen embrittlement of metals is generally manifested by surface cracking, crack propagation, decreases in tensile strength, loss of pipeline ductility, and reduced burst-pressure rating. This degradation can lead to premature failure of one or more segments of a pipeline, resulting in leakage of gas—or in extreme circumstances, bursting of a pipe. In view of these risks, it is not surprising that qualification of pipeline materials for hydrogen service at gas pressures greater than or equal to 500 psi is currently an area of active research and development.
It has been suggested recently that many of the pipeline cost, weight, welding and joining, repair, and safety issues associated with carbon steel can be resolved by switching to fiber-reinforced polymer (FRP) materials. The issues and challenges for adapting existing FRP pipeline technology to hydrogen service at pressures above about 500 psi are: evaluating polymeric materials for hydrogen compatibility and prolonged pressure-cycling; identifying methods for profitable manufacture of pipes with inside diameters greater than four inches; weighing the options for on-site pipeline fabrication, joining, and repair; determining the availability of sensor technologies for measuring gas temperature, pressure, and flow rate in real time; and writing the necessary codes and standards to meet the requirements of local, state, and federal regulatory agencies. In this regard, it is noteworthy that the use of spoolable FRP pipe—or better yet, FRP pipe continuously fabricated in the field—would greatly simplify installation of long-distance hydrogen pipelines, thereby lowering overall costs of pipeline construction. FRP pipes can withstand large strains, which allows them to be “bent” easily and emplaced as a continuous, seamless monolith. Finally, because FRP pipes can be manufactured with sensors embedded in their walls, it is likely that long-distance, large-diameter FRP pipelines built for hydrogen transmission could be operated as “smart structures.” This would enable lifetime performance-monitoring of the pipeline, which could result in substantial safety enhancements and long-term cost savings.
Therefore, there is a need for testing and qualification of pipe, pipeline and storage structures for hydrogen service at elevated gas pressures. According to teachings of this disclosure, the hydrogen-service efficacies of hollow structures of all wall designs, and wall thicknesses may be tested for both kinetically limited and “equilibrium” (steady-state) hydrogen diffusion therethrough.
More specifically, the testing technologies disclosed herein relate to diffusive hydrogen flux across the inner and outer surfaces (walls) of containers, e.g., pipes, or layers within those containers (“interlayers”), formed from one or more solid or liquid “barrier” materials. Containers for hydrogen gas constructed from solid materials often fail to prevent, or adequately control, release of enclosed hydrogen gas. In addition, permeation of hydrogen into a solid material can damage its microstructure and reduce its mechanical strength. The testing technologies described hereinbelow may be used for testing of containers, e.g., pipeline transmission/distribution and storage containers, comprising one or more layers of polymeric, metallic (pure metal and/or metal alloy), metal oxide, and/or liquid material(s), that may be used to either: (i) create one or more supplementary, or enhanced, barriers to diffusion of hydrogen gas; or (ii) capture hydrogen gas before it escapes to the surrounding environment.
Test results for various hydrogen transfer, containment, and recovery practices may be applied to the construction of enclosures and passageways of many different geometrical forms, e.g., planar, spherical, cylindrical, etc. However, testing of tubes of all types, and especially large-diameter (greater than or equal to 4″ inside diameter) pipes, are of particular interest, as they may be used to transmit, distribute and/or store large masses of gaseous hydrogen. These pipes, and some of their applications, are more fully described in commonly owned co-pending U.S. patent application Ser. No. 11/852,364; filed Sep. 10, 2007; entitled “Mitigating Hydrogen Flux Through Solid and Liquid Barrier Materials,” by James G. Blencoe and Simon Marshall; and which is hereby incorporated by reference herein for all purposes. The applications include, but are not limited to: (i) use of one or more layers of homogeneous or laminated polymeric material, and (optionally) solid metal(s), e.g., copper (Cu), aluminum (Al), or stainless steel, each metal with or without oxidized inner/outer surfaces (see FIGS. 1-3 of U.S. patent application Ser. No. 11/852,364) and/or liquid(s), to create multiple equilibrium and kinetic barriers to hydrogen diffusion; (ii) in special circumstances, physical separation of gaseous hydrogen from one or more static or flowing liquid interlayers; and (iii) when necessary, capture and recovery of escaping gaseous hydrogen at the points in a pipeline system where connections are made (see FIGS. 4-6 of U.S. patent application Ser. No. 11/852,364).
Testing of a hollow, single-layer structure, constructed from a metal or metal alloy, is contemplated herein. This structure may be used for transferring and/or storing hydrogen gas.
Testing of a hollow structure that is enclosed by (overlain, lined or coated with), or constructed from, layered polymer/metal/metal oxide material is contemplated herein. This structure may be used for transferring and/or storing hydrogen gas. Often, two or more layers of one or more of these three materials will be pressed together tightly to form one or more thicker, composite layers. This layering/interlayering of materials impedes diffusive hydrogen flux in three ways. First, it automatically creates “contact resistance” to hydrogen flux, a phenomenon whereby diffusion of gaseous hydrogen is deterred kinetically by abrupt changes in microstructure at the boundaries of the individual layers in the multi-layer structure. Second, permeation of gaseous hydrogen through the composite structure slows when the gas reaches the metal layer(s)/interlayer(s), because the equilibrium solubility of hydrogen in, and the steady-state rate of hydrogen diffusion through, the metallic material will be, respectively, much lower, and much slower, than in the non-metallic material. Third, when gaseous hydrogen moves through a layer of metallic material sandwiched between two layers of non-metallic material, the structural state of the gas is forced to switch from diatomic (in the inner layer of non-metallic material), to monatomic (in the metallic material), back to diatomic (in the outer layer of non-metallic material)—an alternation that is kinetically constrained by itself, but in addition, is further restrained physicochemically by the sharp discontinuities in solid-state microstructure that occur at the boundaries between the metallic and non-metallic layers.
Testing of a hollow structure for transferring and/or storing hydrogen gas is contemplated herein. This structure may be a three-layer, composite configuration consisting of an inner layer of polymeric material (e.g., high-density polyethylene, HDPE), an interlayer of metal (possibly with its inner and/or outer surfaces oxidized to enhance hydrogen-containment performance), and an outer layer of polymeric material (e.g., HDPE) (FIGS. 2 and 3 of U.S. patent application Ser. No. 11/852,364).
Testing of a hollow structure for transferring and/or storing hydrogen gas is contemplated herein. This structure may include one or more gas-tight covers placed over one or more parts of the structure (FIGS. 4-6 of U.S. patent application Ser. No. 11/852,364), or a single gas-tight cover may enclose the entire structure. Hydrogen gas exiting the structure is captured in the gas-tight cover(s) before it can escape to the surrounding environment. The gaseous hydrogen that accumulates in the interior of a cover is removed through one or more ports in the cover. Employing this strategy for hydrogen “recovery,” escape of gaseous hydrogen from containers is managed adequately rather then prevented completely.
Testing of a hollow structure for transferring and/or storing hydrogen gas is contemplated herein. This structure may have one or more walls that contain one or more interlayers of a (largely) stagnant or flowing liquid, which either: (i) affords the opportunity to use a “material of construction” that is much cheaper and much more flexible than one or more layers of polymer/metal/metal oxide; (ii) diverts the solid/liquid-state diffusion of hydrogen, or its buoyant ascent as a separate gas phase, toward one or more predetermined “points of egress”; or (iii) in the case of pipeline transfer of hydrogen gas from sites of electrolytic or thermochemical generation to remote destinations where it is used as a fuel, enables reverse flow of either high-purity water or an aqueous solution (see FIG. 7 of U.S. patent application Ser. No. 11/852,364).
Testing of one or more pipes with one or more polymer/metal ± metal oxide layers or interlayers is contemplated herein. These one or more pipes may be used primarily for storage of hydrogen gas. When the goal is to store large masses of gaseous hydrogen for stationary (“off board”) applications, tightly packed sets of these pipes may be placed in hydrogen “warehouses” or “silos” that provide seasonally firmed supplies of the gas to rural, suburban, and/or city-gate markets.
It is contemplated and within the scope of this disclosure that the various embodiments claimed herein may be utilized for testing and qualification of materials of construction for tubular, pipe, and pipeline transfer and/or storage of high-purity hydrogen and/or hydrogen-bearing gas, e.g., hydrogen gas mixed with methane/natural gas and/or biomethane.
According to a specific example embodiment of this disclosure, an apparatus for testing hydrogen flux through barrier materials comprises: a source of compressed hydrogen gas; a barrier material specimen test fixture, wherein the barrier material specimen test fixture is adapted for coupling hydrogen gas to a barrier material specimen under test, wherein the barrier material specimen forms an enclosed cavity that is pressurized from the source of compressed hydrogen gas; at least one first pressure measurement device coupled to the barrier material specimen test fixture, wherein the at least one pressure measurement device measures the hydrogen gas pressure in the enclosed cavity of the barrier material specimen; a temperature-controlled fluid in which the barrier material specimen test fixture and the barrier material specimen are immersed therein; at least one temperature measurement device, wherein the at least one temperature measurement device measures the temperature-controlled fluid; a volume-calibrated hydrogen-gas reservoir for collecting and temporarily storing hydrogen gas that permeates through the enclosed cavity formed by the barrier material specimen; at least one second pressure measurement device coupled to the volume-calibrated hydrogen-gas reservoir, wherein the at least one second pressure measurement device measures the hydrogen-gas pressure therein; and at least one fluid pump for raising and lowering the hydrogen gas pressure inside the enclosed cavity of the barrier material specimen.
According to another specific example embodiment of this disclosure, a method for testing hydrogen flux through barrier materials comprises the steps of: providing a source of compressed hydrogen gas; providing a barrier material specimen test fixture; providing a barrier material specimen for testing at least one hydrogen gas parameter thereof, wherein the barrier material specimen forms an enclosed cavity that is pressurized from the source of compressed hydrogen gas; providing a temperature-controlled fluid in which the barrier material specimen test fixture and the barrier material specimen are immersed therein; providing a volume-calibrated hydrogen-gas reservoir for collecting and temporarily storing hydrogen gas that permeates through the enclosed cavity formed by the barrier material specimen; measuring the hydrogen gas pressure in the enclosed cavity of the barrier material specimen; measuring the temperature of the temperature-controlled fluid; measuring the hydrogen gas pressure in the volume-calibrated hydrogen-gas reservoir; and raising and lowering the hydrogen gas pressure inside the enclosed cavity of the barrier material specimen.
A more complete understanding of the present disclosure thereof may be acquired by referring to the following description taken in conjunction with the accompanying drawings wherein:
While the present disclosure is susceptible to various modifications and alternative forms, specific example embodiments thereof have been shown in the drawings and are herein described in detail. It should be understood, however, that the description herein of specific example embodiments is not intended to limit the disclosure to the particular forms disclosed herein, but on the contrary, this disclosure is to cover all modifications and equivalents as defined by the appended claims.
Referring now to the drawings, the details of example embodiments are schematically illustrated. Like elements in the drawings will be represented by like numbers, and similar elements will be represented by like numbers with a different lower case letter suffix.
Referring to
Referring to
Referring to
Referring to
Referring to
Referring to
Referring to
In detail, oscillating variation of gas pressure inside a tube/pipe (102 in
Therefore, for example, the hydrogen-gas compatibilities, hydrogen-gas embrittlement susceptibilities, hydrogen-gas containment performances, and/or the hydrogen-gas pressure-cycling durabilities, of short lengths of 1-4 inch O.D. tubes and pipes can be tested in one or more specially designed experimental facilities (tube/pipe testing systems), each possibly including many or all of the following pieces of equipment: (i) a tube/pipe test fixture (
Referring to
Referring to
While embodiments of this disclosure have been depicted, described, and are defined by reference to example embodiments of the disclosure, such references do not imply a limitation on the disclosure, and no such limitation is to be inferred. The subject matter disclosed is capable of considerable modification, alteration, and equivalents in form and function, as will occur to those ordinarily skilled in the pertinent art and having the benefit of this disclosure. The depicted and described embodiments of this disclosure are examples only, and are not exhaustive of the scope of the disclosure.
This application claims priority to commonly owned: U.S. Provisional Patent Application Ser. No. 60/918,767; filed Mar. 19, 2007; entitled “New, Composite Polymeric/Metallic Materials and Designs for Hydrogen Pipelines,” by James G. Blencoe, Simon Marshall and Michael Naney;U.S. Provisional Patent Application Ser. No. 60/910,684; filed Apr. 9, 2007; entitled “New, Composite Polymeric/Metallic Materials and Designs for Hydrogen Pipelines,” by James G. Blencoe, Simon Marshall and Michael Naney; andU.S. patent application Ser. No. 11/852,364; filed Sep. 10, 2007; entitled “Mitigating Hydrogen Flux Through Solid and Liquid Barrier Materials,” by James G. Blencoe and Simon Marshall; all of which are hereby incorporated by reference herein for all purposes.
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
60918767 | Mar 2007 | US | |
60910684 | Apr 2007 | US |