1. Field of the Invention
The present invention relates to a thin film magnetic recording medium, which is composed of an underlayer film of a nonmagnetic metal that is formed on a nonmagnetic substrate by a sputtering method and a magnetic film that is formed on the underlayer film by an oblique evaporation process.
2. Description of the Related Art
Recently, recording density of a magnetic recording medium is rapidly advanced towards higher density. During the process of advancing towards higher density, it is commonly known that a magnetic recording medium has been shifted from an iron oxide tape having high coercive force and high magnetic flux density to a metal tape and a thin film magnetic recording medium (thin film magnetic tape) having higher performance.
With respect to an application of such a magnetic recording medium, in the field of a VTR (Video Tape Recorder), for example, a thin film magnetic tape has been gained attention so as to accomplish digitalization and high definition.
A so-called evaporation tape in which a magnetic film is formed by the oblique evaporation process has been put into practical use as a thin film magnetic tape.
By using a piercing electron gun that will be detailed later, such an evaporation tape is manufactured by such that an electron beam emitted form the piercing electron gun is applied to a magnetic material such as Co (cobalt) and CoNi placed in a crucible in a vacuum chamber, and the magnetic material is melted and evaporated while injecting oxygen gas, and then a thin film containing CoO and CoNiO is formed on a base film made of PET (polyethylene terephthalate), PEN (polyether naphthalate), PI (polyimide) or PA (polyamide).
During ordinarily forming a film on a base film 6, the base film 6 wound around the film winding roll 2 (hereinafter referred to as supply roll 2) runs through the tape guide roll 4, the cooling can roll 7, and the other tape guide roll 5 in a forward direction shown by arrows to the other film winding roll 3 (hereinafter referred to as take-up roll 3).
The base film 6 is made of, for example, a PET (polyethylene terephthalate) film having a predetermined thickness as a substrate for a thin film magnetic tape.
A cooling device (not shown) is installed inside the cooling can roll 5 so as to prevent deformation of the base film 6 caused by increased temperature during an evaporation process.
A crucible 8, which is formed in a box shape and contains a magnetic metal material 11 such as Co, is installed at a lower right hand corner from the cooling can roll 7 inside the vacuum chamber 1.
A piercing electron gun 12, which is an evaporation heat source to melt and evaporate the magnetic metal material 11 in the crucible 8, is mounted on a right wall 1a of the vacuum chamber 1 with pointing at the crucible 8 located diagonally downward to the left. The piercing electron gun 8 emits an electron beam 13 towards the magnetic metal material 11 inside the crucible 8. The electron beam 13 melts the magnetic metal material 11 and evaporates so as to coat a surface of the base film 6, which is moving along the cooling can roll 7.
It is essential to cover both edges of the base film 6 so as to prevent a magnetic metal vapor 11a, which evaporated from the crucible 8, from evaporating on the cooling can roll 7 while the base film 6 is running.
Further, it is also essential to control an incidence angle of evaporation of the magnetic metal vapor 11a such as evaporated Co with respect to a surface of the base film 6 due to the improvement of recording characteristics when producing a thin film magnetic tape. In order to prevent deposits in inappropriate areas, incidence angle controlling masks 9 and 10 are installed between the cooling can roll 7 and the crucible 8 as shown in FIG. 15.
Allocating one incidence angle controlling mask 9 to a predetermined position of the cooling can roll 7 controls a maximum incidence angle “θ max” of the magnetic metal vapor 11a of the magnetic metal material 11 with respect to the base film 6. On the other hand, allocating the other incidence angle controlling mask 10 to another predetermined position of the cooling can roll 7 controls a minimum incidence angle “θ min”.
While the base film 6 is running along the outer circumference of the cooling can roll 7, the magnetic metal vapor 11a is deposited on the surface of the base film 6 within a range of angle from a maximum incidence angle to a minimum incidence angle that is adjusted to a predetermined angle, wherein the range of angle is referred to as an evaporation opening area, and then a magnetic film is formed on the surface of the base film 6. Magnetic characteristics of the magnetic film are decided by the maximum incidence angle “θ max” and the minimum incidence angle “θ min” of the magnetic metal vapor 11a of the magnetic metal material 11. Generally, the maximum incidence angle “θ max” is set to 90 degrees and the minimum incidence angle “θ min” is set to 40 degrees.
An oxygen gas injection pipe (not shown) is installed between the cooling can roll 7 and the incidence angle controlling mask 10 inside the minimum incidence angle “θ min” side. Oxygen gas O2 blows off through a plurality of holes (not shown) provided on the oxygen gas injection pipe towards the magnetic metal vapor 11a evaporated from the crucible 8.
The electron beam 13 emitted from the piercing electron gun 12 is controlled by a deflection magnet 15, which supplies a deflection magnetic field onto a trajectory of the electron beam 13, and another deflection magnet 14, which is installed near the crucible 8. By scanning the electron beam 13 in the longitudinal direction of the crucible 8, the magnetic metal vapor 11a such as evaporated Co is thinly deposited on the surface of the base film 6 as a partial oxide magnetic film such as Co—CoO in a lateral direction of the base film 6. By depositing the partial oxide magnetic film on the base film 6 continuously in the longitudinal direction of the base film 6, a long enough thin film magnetic tape is taken up by the take-up roll 3.
There provided another scanning method of the electron beam 13 such that an ongoing-straight electron beam 13 emitted from the piercing electron gun 12 is controlled to scan the crucible 8 by only the deflection magnet 15 without installing the deflection magnet 14 near the crucible 8. Such a scanning method is also applicable.
In
In other words, as mentioned above, the nonmagnetic underlayer film 16 of the thin film magnetic tape, which is produced by the conventional film-forming apparatus 20 through the oblique evaporation process, is composed of Co particles and CoO particles. Relative quantities of the Co particles and the CoO particles, which constitute each area of the nonmagnetic underlayer 16, are such that more CoO particles exist in the area 17A, which is allocated between columnar areas, and more Co particles exist inside the columnar area 16A.
The columnar area 16A having more Co particles is composed of a plurality of columnar areas 16a through 16n in the longitudinal direction. On the other hand, the area 17A having more CoO particles is composed of a plurality of areas 17a through 17n, which are sandwiched among the plurality of columnar areas 16a through 16n, in the longitudinal direction.
Consequently, a grain boundary, which fixes a boundary between the columnar area 16A having more Co particles and the area 17A having more CoO particles, is made clear.
Further, the magnetic film 18 is formed with columnar areas 18a through 18n having more Co particles and areas 19a through 19n having more CoO particles, which are sandwiched among the columnar areas 18a through 18n.
The plurality of columnar areas 18a through 18n is in a shape of slanting with respect to the surface of the magnetic film 18. In a case that a thin film magnetic tape is produced by forming a CoO magnetic film 18 on the nonmagnetic underlayer film 16 having the columnar areas 16a through 16n by the oblique evaporation process while injecting oxygen gas, the concentration of oxygen gas is lower than the case of forming a nonmagnetic CoO film.
Collision probability of a Co evaporated particle with injected oxygen gas becomes lower than the case of forming the nonmagnetic underlayer film (CoO film) 16, so that the Co evaporated particle is relatively high in a rate of traveling in a straight line, and further the Co evaporated particle is incident into a surface of substrate with slanted because the initial incidence angle is set to “θ max” as shown in FIG. 15. Consequently, it is supposed that an aggregation of particles grows towards a slanted direction close to an incidence direction and forms a columnar construction.
A magnetic flux induction-type head has been used for a conventional recording and reproducing head. However, a carrier to noise (CN) ratio has been limited by the thermal noise of the magnetic flux induction-type head.
Further, a reproduction output decreases in relation to lowering a relative speed between a head and a tape due to a trend of miniaturizing a recording apparatus, and resulted in becoming hard to record and reproduce a signal in a high bit rate.
On the other hand, it is essential for advancing a recording medium towards higher density to thin a film thickness of a magnetic film as well as increasing coercive force.
In a case of coping with the trend for increasing coercive force higher by using the magnetic flux induction-type head, if a film thickness of a magnetic film is drastically thinned, a problem such that a reproduction output decreases and resulted in decreasing a signal to noise (SN) ratio occurs. In order to solve such a problem, an MR (magnetoresistive) head, which applies a magnetoresistive effect, draws attention. The MR head can obtain a high output, independent of a speed relative to a recording medium.
Further, the MR head has a low resistance value in a whole range of band, so that the MR head is advantageous to reduce drastically a thermal noise in comparison with a magnetic flux induction-type head.
An MR element of the MR head is, however, saturated and an operating range of the MR element exceeds a linear area when an amount of magnetic flux from a recording medium exceeds a specific amount. Consequently, the MR head generates distortion in waveform and asymmetry of pulse.
On the other hand, an amount of magnetic flux that is absorbed by the MR element is in proportion to Brδ, that is, a cross product of residual flux density Br and a magnetic film thickness δ. Therefore, it is essential to assign Br and δ that is most suitable for a MR head. Generally, a magnetic film thickness δ that is most suitable for a MR head becomes thinner than that of a magnetic flux induction-type head.
In a case that a film thickness is thinned as thin as less than 1000 Å so as to assign a magnetic film, which is formed by the oblique evaporation process, to the most suitable film thickness for a MR head, there arose a problem such that coercive force Hc decreases drastically.
With respect to a method of solving the problem, a method such that forming an underlayer film of nonmagnetic CoO, which is formed by evaporating Co as a magnetic metal material in an atmosphere of oxygen gas through the oblique evaporation process, on a nonmagnetic substrate and forming a CoO magnetic film on the underlayer film through the oblique evaporation process prevents coercive force Hc in the range of less than 1000 Å of magnetic film thickness from deteriorating has been suggested in the Japanese Patent No. 2988188 and in the publication: Japanese Society of Applied Magnetics”, vol. 121, No. 4-2 (1997), entitled “Effect of a CoO underlayer on CoO films evaporated obliquely”.
According to the method mentioned above, when forming a Co—CoO magnetic film on growing particles of an isolated CoO nonmagnetic underlayer film, by isolating growing particles of the Co—CoO magnetic film with following the growing particles of the CoO nonmagnetic underlayer film, magnetic interaction among particles of the Co—CoO magnetic film can be reduced. Consequently, the method prevents magnetostaitc characteristics from deteriorating even in an extremely thin Co—CoO magnetic film. However, there existed some problems mentioned below by this method.
By this method,
In consideration of the above-mentioned problems, it is found that the problems occur in an area such as a material of nonmagnetic underlayer film and its film thickness.
Further, it is also found that desired magnetic characteristics can not be obtained in some cases due to conditions of fine particles, which constitute a nonmagnetic underlayer film, although the nonmagnetic underlayer film has been formed excellently.
Accordingly, in consideration of the above-mentioned problems of the prior art, an object of the present invention is to provide a thin film magnetic recording medium, which can exhibit desired magnetostatic characteristics when a structure of fine particles constituting an underlayer film, a film thickness of the underlayer film and a material of the underlayer film is in a predetermined standard.
According to an aspect of the present invention, there provided a thin film magnetic recording medium comprising: an underlayer film constituted by a nonmagnetic metal oxide film and formed on a nonmagnetic substrate; and a magnetic film of Co (cobalt) system formed on the underlayer film through an oblique evaporation process, wherein the underlayer film and the magnetic film are laminated in order, the thin film magnetic recording medium is further characterized in that fine particles of the nonmagnetic metal oxide film grow isotropically in the underlayer film constituted by the nonmagnetic metal oxide film and the underlayer film is formed in a construction without having a clear grain boundary separating a aggregation of the fine particles.
Another aspect of the present invention, there provided a thin film magnetic recording medium comprising: an underlayer film constituted by a nonmagnetic metal nitride film and formed on a nonmagnetic substrate; and a magnetic film of Co (cobalt) system formed on the underlayer through an oblique evaporation process, wherein the underlayer film and the magnetic film are laminated in order.
Other object and further features of the present invention will be apparent from the following detailed description when read in conjunction with the accompanying drawings.
[First Embodiment]
In
In
In this first embodiment, as the sputtering method is used for forming the underlayer film 32 of nonmagnetic CoO, a large amount of oxygen gas or argon gas to be injected can be used. Consequently, a pressure inside a vacuum chamber of film-forming apparatus for producing a thin film magnetic recording medium can be increased in comparison with the case of forming the nonmagnetic underlayer film 16 of columnar CoO through the oblique evaporation process according to the prior art, so that a Co particle sputtered from a sputter target, will be detailed later, reaches to the surface of a substrate from more random directions than that of an evaporated particle by the oblique evaporation process according to the prior art.
Further, particle energy by the sputtering method is higher than that by the oblique evaporation process, so that a moving amount of a particle reached to the surface of substrate is large. Accordingly, it is supposed that unlike the prior art, an isotropic construction as a CoO particle is obtained.
(Embodiment 1)
A method of producing the thin film magnetic recording medium 30 having the construction according to the first embodiment is detailed next.
In
During ordinarily forming a thin film on the base film 31, the base film 31 that is wound around the film winding roll 2 (hereinafter referred to as supply roll 2) runs through the tape guide roll 4, the cooling can roll 7, and the other tape guide roll 5 in a forward direction shown by arrows to the other film winding roll 3 (hereinafter referred to as take-up roll 3).
The crucible 8, which is formed in a box shape and contains a magnetic metal material 11 such as Co, is installed at a lower right hand corner from the cooling can roll 7 inside the vacuum chamber 1.
The piercing electron gun 12, which is an evaporation heat source to melt and evaporate the magnetic metal material 11 in the crucible 8, is mounted on a right wall 1a of the vacuum chamber 1 with pointing at the crucible 8 located diagonally downward to the left. The piercing electron gun 8 emits an electron beam 13 towards the magnetic metal material 11 inside the crucible 8. The electron beam 13 melts the magnetic metal material 11 and evaporates so as to coat a surface of the base film 31, which is moving along the cooling can roll 7.
The electron beam 13 emitted from the piercing electron gun 12 is controlled by a deflection magnet 15, which impresses a deflection magnetic field onto a trajectory of the electron beam 13, and another deflection magnet 14, which is installed near the crucible 8.
In order to prevent deposits in inappropriate areas, incidence angle controlling masks 10 and 49 are installed between the cooling can roll 7 and the crucible 8 as shown in FIG. 3. Allocating one incidence angle controlling mask 49 to a predetermined position of the cooling can roll 7 controls a maximum incidence angle “θ max” of the magnetic metal vapor 11a of the magnetic metal material 11 with respect to the base film 31. On the other hand, allocating the other incidence angle controlling mask 10 to another predetermined position of the cooling can roll 7 controls a minimum incidence angle “θ min”.
The sputter target 41 is arranged between the tape guide roll 4 and the incidence angle control mask 49 along the cooling can roll 7.
As shown in
Circumferential pressure and constituting gas for forming a thin film varies by each processing method of the sputtering method and the oblique evaporation process, so that the vacuum chamber 1 is divided into the upper vacuum chamber 1A and the lower vacuum chamber 1B by the partitions 42a and 42b. Each of the upper and lower vacuum chambers 1A and 1B is exhausted by an individual exhausting system (not shown) and maintained at predetermined pressure.
In a film forming process of forming a nonmagnetic underlayer film on a virgin base film 31 made of PET as shown in
While the base film 31 formed with the underlayer film 32 of nonmagnetic isotropic CoO is running along the outer circumference of the cooling can roll 7, by blowing off oxygen gas O2 through an oxygen gas injection pipe (not shown) towards the magnetic metal vapor 11a evaporated from Co as the magnetic metal material 11 in the crucible 8, the magnetic metal vapor 11a is deposited on the surface of the base film 31 within a range of angle from a maximum incidence angle to a minimum incidence angle that is adjusted to a predetermined angle, and then a CoO magnetic film 33 is formed on the surface of the base film 31 through the oblique evaporation process.
When forming the CoO magnetic film 33 by the oblique evaporation process, a growth particle of the CoO magnetic film 33 is formed on the base film 31 with transferring its evaporation condition from a sparse evaporation condition in the maximum incidence angle “θ max” side to a dense evaporation condition in the minimum incidence angle “θ min” side.
On the other hand, in the underlayer film 32, a nonmagnetic particle grows isotropically, and then the underlayer film 32, is formed in a structure not having a clear grain boundary that separates the aggregation of fine particles.
Further, the base film 31 formed with the underlayer film 32 having such an isotropic structure and the CoO magnetic film 33 is taken up by the take-up roller 3.
In addition there to, a thin film magnetic tape according to the embodiment 1 is produced by such that a film thickness of the underlayer film 32 is varied by a range of 5 Å to 600 Å and the CoO magnetic film 33 is formed by following film-forming conditions.
The film-forming conditions of the underlayer film 32 are as follows:
The film-forming conditions of the CoO magnetic film 33 are as follows:
By using the film-forming apparatus 20 shown in
Further, a CoO magnetic film is formed on the nonmagnetic CoO underlayer film under the same film-forming conditions as the embodiment 1 through the oblique evaporation process.
Furthermore, the nonmagnetic CoO underlayer film according to the comparative example 1 is an underlayer film of nonmagnetic columnar CoO in which a nonmagnetic fine particle grows cylindrically and a structure having a clear grain boundary that separates the aggregation of fine particles is formed.
A thin film magnetic tape according to a comparative example 2 is produced by using the film-forming apparatus 20 shown in
With respect to the underlayer film 32 of the thin film magnetic tape produced as the embodiment 1 and the underlayer film of nonmagnetic columnar CoO and the CoO magnetic film of the thin film magnetic tape produced as the comparative example 1, change of coercive force Hc of the magnetic film that is caused by conditions of each underlayer film and film thickness is shown in FIG. 4.
As it is apparent from
Further, as it is also apparent from
Furthermore, it is apparent that the coercive force Hc of the thin film magnetic tape without the underlayer film is as many as 1200 Oe approximately and the thin film magnetic tape can not receive practical application.
(Embodiment 2)
An isotropic underlayer film 32 is formed under the same film-forming conditions as the embodiment 1 in the film thickness of 50 Å by the sputtering method.
Further, a CoO magnetic film 33 is formed on the isotropic underlayer film 32 under the same film-forming conditions as the embodiment 1 with having a film thickness within a range of 100 Å to 1800 Å by the oblique evaporation process.
A thin film magnetic tape according to a comparative example 2 is produced by the same film-forming conditions as the embodiment 2 except for the isotropic underlayer film 32 that is not formed. Only a CoO magnetic film 33 having a film thickness within a range of 100 Å to 1800 Å is formed on a PET base film 31 by the oblique evaporation process.
A relation between a film thickness of the magnetic film and coercive force Hc of the thin film magnetic tapes according to the embodiment 2 and the comparative example 3 is shown in FIG. 5. As shown in
As shown in
Further,
Furthermore, when forming a CoO magnetic film under the film-forming conditions “1” and “2” of enabling to obtain coercive force Hc of 1400 Oe and 1100 Oe, providing a columnar underlayer film decreases the initial growth angle by one degree to two degrees in response to a case whether or not a nonmagnetic CoO columnar underlayer film having a film thickness of 100 Å formed by the oblique evaporation process is provided. Therefore, it is supposed that an isotropic underlayer film has a stronger effect of laying down an initial growth direction towards the horizontal direction than a columnar underlayer film. Consequently, a self-shadowing effect increases and an effect of increasing coercive force Hc is enlarged as a result of the strong effect.
With referring to
It is apparent from the surface of the magnetic film observed by the high resolution SEM that there is existed no gap in the grain boundary of the CoO magnetic film, which is not provided with an underlayer film, shown in
[Second Embodiment]
In
(Embodiment 3)
A method of producing the thin film magnetic recording medium 50 according to the second embodiment of the present invention is explained next.
Essentially, the film-forming apparatus 40 shown in
In the film-forming apparatus 40 used for producing the thin film magnetic tape 50 according to the second embodiment, a difference from the thin film magnetic tape 30 according to the first embodiment is basically the nonmagnetic underlayer film. A nitride film is used for the nonmagnetic underlayer film of the thin film magnetic tape 50. Consequently, using a Co target as the sputter target 41 and injecting argon gas (Ar) and nitrogen gas (N2) forms a film through the sputtering method.
In a film-forming process of forming a nonmagnetic underlayer film on a virgin base film 31(51) made of PET as shown in
While the base film 51 formed with the nonmagnetic underlayer 52 of Co-nitride is running along the outer circumference of the cooling can roll 7, by blowing off oxygen gas O2 through the oxygen gas injection pipe (not shown) towards the magnetic metal vapor 11a evaporated from Co as the magnetic metal material 11 in the crucible 8, the magnetic metal vapor 11a is deposited on the surface of the base film 51 within a range of angle from a maximum incidence angle to a minimum incidence angle that is adjusted to a predetermined angle, and then a CoO magnetic film 53 is formed on the surface of the base film 51 through the oblique evaporation process.
When forming the CoO magnetic film 53 by the oblique evaporation process, a growth particle of the CoO magnetic film 53 is formed on the base film 51 with transferring its evaporation condition from a sparse evaporation condition in the maximum incidence angle “θ max” side of the incidence angle controlling mask 49 to a dense evaporation condition in the minimum incidence angle “θ min” side of the incidence angle controlling mask 10.
Further, the base film 51 formed with the nonmagnetic underlayer film 52 of Co-nitride having the above-mentioned structure and the CoO magnetic film 53 is taken up by the take-up roller 3.
Furthermore, a film thickness of the nonmagnetic underlayer 52 of Co-nitride is assigned to be 100 Å and a film thickness of the CoO magnetic film 53 is formed by following film-forming conditions.
The film-forming conditions of the nonmagnetic underlayer film 52 of Co-nitride are as follows:
The film-forming conditions of the CoO magnetic film 53 are as follows:
A thin film magnetic recording medium according to the comparative example 4 is produced such that a CoO magnetic film is formed on the base film 51 by the same film-forming conditions as the embodiment 3 so as for the film thickness of the magnetic film 53 to be 500 Å without forming the nonmagnetic underlayer 52 of Co-nitride.
Further, it is also apparent that the CoO magnetic film 53 can obtain high coercive force Hc at oxygen gas pressure within a range of 4.0×10−5 Torr to 5.7×10−5 Torr.
(Embodiment 4)
Using a Co target and injecting Ar gas and N2 gas under the same Ar and N2 gas partial pressure as the embodiment 3 forms the nonmagnetic underlayer 52 of Co-nitride on the base film 51 by changing a film thickness within a range of 10 Å to 200 Å through the sputtering method. Then, in the film-forming apparatus 40 shown in
A thin film magnetic recording medium according to the comparative example 5 is produced such that a CoO magnetic film 53 is formed on the base film 51 by the same film-forming conditions as the embodiment 4 so as for the film thickness of the magnetic film 53 to be 500 Å through the oblique evaporation process without forming the nonmagnetic underlayer 52 of Conitride.
According to an observation of the surface of the CoO magnetic film 53 through a high resolution SEM, although not shown in any drawings, there is existed no gap in the grain boundary of the CoO magnetic film 53, which is not provided with an underlayer film according to the comparative examples 4 and 5. However, there existed a gap clearly in the grain boundary of the CoO magnetic film 53, which is provided with the nonmagnetic underlayer film 52 of Co-nitride according to the embodiments 3 and 4. It is supposed that a gap is generated in the grain boundary of the CoO magnetic film 53 by the nonmagnetic underlayer film 52 of Co-nitride, and then isolation of particles is hastened and resulted in increasing the coercive force Hc.
While the invention has been described above with reference to the specific embodiment thereof, it is apparent that many changes, modifications and variations in the arrangement of equipment and devices and in materials can be made without departing the invention concept disclosed herein. For example, the sputtering method is explained as a typical film forming method of an isotropic underlayer film. However, the sputtering method is just one method of film forming methods. Accordingly, the film forming method is not limited to the sputtering method as far as an isotropic underlayer film can be obtained.
According to an aspect of the present invention, there provided a thin film magnetic recording medium, which is low in dropout and excellent in mass-productivity. The thin film magnetic recording medium is composed of an underlayer film, which is constituted by a nonmagnetic metal oxide film and formed on a nonmagnetic substrate, and a magnetic film of Co system, which is formed on the underlayer film through the oblique evaporation process. They are laminated in order, wherein fine particles of the nonmagnetic metal oxide film in the nonmagnetic film grow isotropically and the underlayer film is formed in a construction not having a clear grain boundary, which separates an aggregation of the fine particles.
According to another aspect of the present invention, there provided a thin film magnetic recording medium, which is composed of an underlayer film that is constituted by a nonmagnetic metal nitride film and formed on a nonmagnetic substrate and a magnetic film of Co system that is formed on the underlayer film through the oblique evaporation process, laminated in order. Consequently, the thin film magnetic recording medium is high in coercive force Hc, low in dropout and excellent in mass-productivity.
Number | Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
2001-319112 | Oct 2001 | JP | national |
Number | Name | Date | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
4842917 | Ohno et al. | Jun 1989 | A |
5554440 | Ishida et al. | Sep 1996 | A |
6146754 | Song et al. | Nov 2000 | A |
Number | Date | Country |
---|---|---|
02021417 | Jan 1990 | JP |
5-595491993 | Mar 1993 | JP |
5-3251671993 | Dec 1993 | JP |
6-48621994 | Jan 1994 | JP |
11-1619341999 | Jun 1999 | JP |
2988188 | Dec 1999 | JP |
3093818 | Oct 2000 | JP |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
20030072968 A1 | Apr 2003 | US |