Many restaurants serve toasted breads and toasted English muffins as regular menu items. Many of those menu items include sandwiches that are comprised of toasted English muffins and toasted sandwiches.
Toasted food products have a distinctly different flavor than to the same products prior to toasting. Toasting a food product also changes the bread product's color and its texture. In addition to changing flavor, color and texture, the toasting process often gives off a pleasing aroma.
Toasting food products like sliced bread, English muffins, bagels, pizza and other bread products is usually accomplished using infrared energy emitted from one or more electrically-heated wires in a toaster or broiler. The process of toasting, which is also referred to herein as browning, is the result of a chemical reaction known as the Maillard reaction. The Maillard reaction is defined by some, or considered to be the reaction between carbohydrates and proteins that occurs upon heating and which produces browning.
It is believed that when the Maillard reaction goes too far or too long, carbohydrates in a bread product will oxidize completely and form carbon. Carbon absorbs light. The surface of a burned bread product therefore appears black. The term “burn” is therefore considered to be the thermally-induced oxidation of carbohydrates to a point where the carbon content of the bread product surface is high enough to absorb visible light that impinges on the bread product surface and therefore make the surface of the bread product appear to an ordinary observer to be black in color.
A well-known problem with prior art toasters of all kinds is that they often cannot consistently achieve a uniform browning or toasting across bread product surface in the same amount of time. Because of their mass, surface irregularities and temperatures, bread products like English muffins are especially difficult to uniformly and consistently brown in a short amount of time period because the peaks and valleys of an English muffin's surface are at different distances from the IR source that effectuates the toasting process. Since many restaurant operators need and prefer to be able to toast bread products like English muffins as quickly as possible, attempts to shorten browning time by simply increasing the input infrared energy usually results in more bread products being burned rather than toasted. A toaster and a method of toasting food products like bread and English muffins and which can consistently provide uniform browning in a relatively short period of time would be an improvement over the prior art.
In
The front face 15 of the substrate 14 is substantially planar and is optionally provided with a heat-reflecting/IR-reflecting thin metallic coating or a foil of aluminum, silver or gold. When electric current flows through the filament or wire 18, it heats up. As current through the wire increases, the temperature of the filament/wire 18 increases. The filament/wire 18 eventually gets hot enough to emit IR. The emitted IR is identified in the figures by reference numeral 34. At least some of the IR that radiates away from the wire 18 and toward the heat-reflecting/IR-reflecting coating will be reflected back toward the food product 26 to be toasted.
As is well known, the emitted IR 34 effectiveness in toasting the food product 26 will be a function of the emitted IR wavelength. Emitted IR wavelength depends on the surface temperature of the filament wire 18. The amount of the emitted IR energy 34 will also be a function of the surface area of the filament/wire 18 that emits IR, as well as the presence or absence of IR-reflective coatings or material that might be used on the front face 15 of the substrate 14. The emitted IR can therefore be quantified by an emitted infrared energy density, which is considered herein to be measured in watts per square inch.
Since at least some of the IR emitted toward the front face 15 is reflected back toward a bread product 26 to be toasted, emitted energy density is considered herein to be the watts input to an IR-emitting heating element, such as a nichrome wire or CALROD™, divided by the surface area of any surface that emits infrared toward the food product. In the figures herein, the front face 15 of the substrate 14 holding the heating element that is covered with IR-reflective coating is considered to be an IR emitting surface. In
Those of ordinary skill in the art will recognize that when the toaster is operating, the surface of a hole formed in the substrate 14 will eventually reach a temperature greater than room temperature due in part to heat conduction. When room-temperature air from the fan 20 passes through a hole in the substrate 14, the surface temperature of which is greater than the temperature of the air from the blower 20, some heat will be transferred into air passing through the hole. Stated another way, air passing through a hole or holes in the substrate 14 will in fact be slightly heated. Those of ordinary skill in the art will also recognize that the region between the front face 15 of the heater and the bread product support substrate 28 will also be warm. Air that passes from the through the hole 16 will therefore also absorb at least heat present in the region between the heater substrate 14 and the bread product support substrate 28.
As used herein, unheated air refers to ambient, room air, i.e., air at room temperature. “Room temperature” is considered to be above 50 degrees Fahrenheit but less than about one hundred degrees Fahrenheit. Unheated air specifically includes air or an air stream that has passed through a hole or opening in a substrate, such as those described herein, regardless of the surface temperature of the hole or opening and regardless of how high the air stream temperature might have increased as a result of passing through a hole in the substrate. Unheated air also specifically includes an air stream and portions thereof, which have passed through a hole in a substrate and into or through the region or volume between the face 15 of the heater 14 and the thermally insulating substrate 28, regardless of how high the air stream nominal temperature might have increased due to heat absorption. Unheated air also includes an air stream having a nominal temperature measured at the center of a hole in the substrate 14, to be less than three hundred degrees Fahrenheit.
The chemical mechanism by which the toasters and methodologies described herein are able to toast but not burn an English muffin in as little as 15 seconds is not known. It has been observed however, that when the temperature of air striking the surface of a food product exceeds about 300° Fahrenheit, the surface of begins to burn after about 45 to 60 seconds. The preferred methodology for toasting a bread product such as an English muffin in 15 seconds or more and so that it doesn't burn, is to irradiate the food product with IR while directing one or more unheated air streams onto the food product's surface. The air stream angle of incidence on the food product surface is preferably ninety degrees, i.e., measured relative to the geometric plane of the face 15 of the heater however, in alternate embodiments, the air stream angle of incidence can be at almost any angle greater than about ten degrees relative to the geometric plane of the face 15 of the heater.
In
It is important that the unheated air stream(s) strike the surface of a food product. Creating an air stream that will strike the food product surface requires the air to be driven. For purposes of claim construction, it should be noted that the air stream driven through the hole 16 will be substantially columnar in the hole due to the shape of the hole. When the air stream leaves the through hole 16, the shape of the air stream will retain its columnar shape for only a short distance but will nevertheless be columnar or substantially columnar when it leaves the through-hole 16. The portion of the air stream leaving the through hole 16 that remains columnar when it strikes the food product being toasted will depend on factors that include the distance separating the front face of the heater and the food product being toasted and the velocity of the air stream.
When the forced air from the through-hole 16 impinges upon the bread product 26, the air stream diverges from the point of impact on the surface of the bread product 26. Prototype testing revealed that for a given emitted IR energy density, the surface of the bread product 26 tended to burn as the air stream's angle of incidence on the bread product surface decreased from 90°. Stated another way, control of the Maillard reaction decreases as the air stream angle of incidence decreases from normal to the bread product surface.
For purposes of claim construction, the centrally-located through hole 16 depicted in
Those of ordinary skill in the art will recognize that some of the IR energy emitted from the heating element 12 will not travel toward the food product being toasted but will instead travel in different directions. Some infrared energy might impinge upon surfaces of holes formed into the substrate causing the surface temperatures of those holes to rise. Most of the most of the infrared energy 34 emitted from the heating element 12 is nevertheless directed toward a food product 26. Since most of the IR and the air stream are directed toward the food product, the IR that is directed to the food product and the air streams are therefore considered herein to be parallel or virtually parallel to each other. As set forth above, the air stream(s) directed to the food product is/are substantially columnar, at least when leaving holes formed through the substrate, and as can be seen from the figures, when the air streams leave the openings 16, 36 or 38, the air streams will be surrounded or substantially surrounded by infrared energy traveling in the same general direction. From an alternate perspective however, the emitted infrared energy can be considered to be surrounded by one or more air streams.
As used herein, the terms “toasting” and “browning” are used interchangeably and refer to the effectuation of a Maillard reaction and an accompanying color change but without burning the bread product. As stated above, burning is considered herein to be the complete oxidation of carbohydrates and/or proteins to form carbon, the concentration of which on a bread product surface is high enough to make the bread produce surface appear to be grey or black to an ordinary observer, when the surface is viewed without the aid of mechanical devices.
A toasted bread product will almost always give off a pleasing aroma whereas burned bread products give off a pungent odor. A toasted bread product will also have a deeper, richer flavor than the same product will have before being toasted whereas burned bread products have a bitter taste that almost all people find objectionable. Toasting a bread product does not create smoke because toasting does not cause carbohydrates and/or proteins to burn. Burning a bread product almost always generates at least a small amount of black smoke, i.e., carbon particles as a by-product of the complete oxidation of carbohydrates and/or proteins.
The darkness of the color change achieved during the toasting process was experimentally determined to be related to the length of time that the bread product was kept in front of the heater 12 and subjected to the aforementioned cool air stream. Heating the bread product with the IR while cooling it with the air stream (processing) for as long as 45 to 60 seconds produced a deeper brown color while processing it for less than about 15 seconds produced only a slight browning. Several different factors can affect toasting time.
Prototype testing revealed that for a given bread product at a given initial temperature, separated from an IR emitter by a fixed distance, the air stream volumetric flow rate, air stream temperature and the emitted infrared energy density all affected the time required to produce a particular, desired food product color change. By way of example, the time required to toast an English muffin to achieve a commonly accepted gold to golden-brown color varied between 20 and about 40 seconds based on IR emitted energy density, air stream temperature and air stream flow rate.
Emitted IR energy density can be controlled by controlling the electric current flowing through the filament/wire 18, the area of surfaces that emit IR as well as the area and reflectivity of surfaces that reflect IR toward a food product. Air stream velocity and flow rate can be controlled by controlling fan speed 20, the fan blade pitch as well as the duct size and/or the use of an optional air-flow controlling damper (not shown) located in the air duct either up stream or downstream of the fan.
While the preferred embodiments use forced air streams that are unheated, i.e., at room temperature, alternate embodiments use an stream temperature that is slightly elevated but kept below about 300° F. While an air stream temperature of 300 degrees is well above room temperature, it is nevertheless well below the surface temperatures of the IR source, which can range from 1000 to 2000° F. A small amount of heat is therefore added in some alternate embodiments, depending on the toasting requirements of a particular bread product.
Referring now to
An alternating current (A.C.) source is electrically connectable to the blower 20 through the “B” side of a double-pole switch, i.e., switch 42B. The power source 40 is also connectable to the electrically heated element 18 through the “A” side of the same double pole switch, i.e., switch 42.
The power provided to the electrically heated filament wire 18 and hence the emitted IR is controllable by a current and/or voltage controller identified by reference numeral 44A. The fan speed is also controllable by a similar current/voltage controller 44B. The controllers 44A and 44B are depicted in the figure as variable resistances, however, the controllers are preferably embodied as either silicon controlled rectifiers (SCRs) or TRIACs, well known to those of ordinary skill in the electronic arts. Those of ordinary skill will recognize that the controllers can also be embodied as rheostats.
In
It is not essential that the air stream or streams that impinge on the food product be columnar; air streams of different cross sectional shapes will also work. For that matter, those of ordinary skill in the art will recognize that the shape of the air stream leaving the slots shown in
Referring now to
Once they are started, the IR and the cooling air are continuously applied to the food product for a first time period identified in 106 as T1. At the expiration of T1, the method includes an optional adjustment to the emitted infrared energy density level to a second, lower level 2 as shown at step 108. The second infrared energy density level is maintained for a second time period identified as T2. The infrared energy and blower are shut off at step 112 at the expiration of T2.
In experiments, an English muffin was heated with a first infrared energy density for a first time period T1 of about 15-25 seconds. An air stream at room temperature, i.e., about seventy two degrees Fahrenheit was directed at the English muffin's surface at a ninety degree angle. At the expiration of T1 the first energy density output energy level was reduced by about 90% to 95%. The second, lower energy density was maintained for an additional 15 seconds, as was the air stream. At the end of T1 and T2 the English muffins were uniformly toasted to a medium brown color without burning the English muffin's surface. The total of both T1 and T2 was about 35-45 seconds.
At the expiration of T1 at step 206, the air flow rate is optionally changed to a second, greater or lesser volumetric flow rate at step 208. The second, optional volumetric flow rate is maintained for a second time period T2. At the expiration of T2 the infrared and the blower are shut off.
Steps 302 and 304 show that the air flow is started prior to the application of infrared energy, however, as with the other depicted methods, the air flow and IR can be applied simultaneously or the IR can be applied slightly prior to the air stream. Regardless of whether the air or IR is applied first, at step 306, the temperature of the air exiting the blower 22 is measured at step 308 as to whether the air stream temperature exceeds a predetermined maximum threshold value identified in
Steps 306, 308 and 310 comprise a control loop, not exited until the air stream temperature is below Temp1Max. When or if the air stream temperature is below Temp1Max, a second air stream determination is made at step 312 to determine whether or not the air stream temperature is above Temp1Min. If the air stream temperature is below Temp1Min, the air stream temperature is increased at step 314 by the in-line heater. Steps 306, 308 and 312 are repeated until the air stream temperature is between Temp1Max and Temp1Min, the difference between them being a design choice. Once the air stream temperature range is realized, the air stream volumetric flow rate is maintained for a predetermined time equal to T1 as can been seen in step 314.
In
Using the methods depicted in
For the method shown in
While the preferred embodiments disclosed herein are described with regard to toasting an English muffin, those of ordinary skill in the art will appreciate that the methods and apparatus disclosed herein will have application to the preparation of other foods and/or bread products. The methods and apparatus can be used to cook without burning, sliced bread, pizza, bagels, flat bread and sandwiches in considerably less time than prior art devices that include impingement ovens, toasters and toasting ovens that use infrared and high-temperature and heated air streams, however, bread products like pizza will require more time to cook than fifteen to twenty seconds. The claims should therefore be construed accordingly.
The invention should not be considered to be the foregoing description or any portion thereof. The invention is defined by the appurtenant claims.