1. Field of the Invention
The present invention relates to a method of applying a composition, and, more particularly, to a method of applying a defined tooth whitening composition of predetermined viscosity from a single-dose applicator and the tooth whitening delivery system used to practice the method.
2. Description of the Prior Art
Since the early 1980s, the tooth whitening industry has grown from a scenario in which one could only receive tooth whitening treatments in a dental office to the scenario that exists today in which numerous competitors sell over-the-counter tooth whitening systems including delivery systems such that the average consumer can whiten their teeth in their own home without medical supervision.
Numerous delivery systems have become popular and well known including those employing strips coated with the tooth whitening substance, trays filled with tooth whitener, tooth whiteners incorporated into toothpaste, and other paint-on applicators such as those analogous to felt tip pens, and others using brushes with bristles and foam-type brush applicators. Over-the-counter whiteners today fall into three categories—trays and gels, strips and paint-on whiteners.
Tray and gel systems are designed for the user to fill the flexible tray with the whitening formulation and this is placed on the teeth. The gel extrudes out of the tray on the gingival and the mucosa with a great chance of soft tissue irritation. Strips are placed on the teeth with a good portion of the strip laying on the gingival area and also causing irritation.
A successful tooth whitening composition requires that the following parameters be included:
(1) a sufficient amount of activated active ingredient, e.g. H2O2 present in and delivered by the composition;
(2) an enhanced degree of retention of the composition onto teeth; i.e. its bioadhesion, which is determined by the ratio of its cohesive energy to surface energy;
(3) a favorable degree of penetration of the composition into the tooth enamel;
(4) a suitable viscosity to deliver the composition by selected desirable delivery means; and,
(5) efficacy of bleaching of stained teeth enamel by the composition.
Accordingly, it is the object of this invention to provide a tooth whitener composition and delivery system having, in combination:
(1) a predetermined concentration of active H2O2 in a film-forming complex; which provides for;
(2) effective bioadhesion/retention of the composition on teeth;
(3) advantageous penetration of the composition into the tooth enamel;
(4) a predeterminable viscosity to deliver the composition onto teeth by a suitable delivery means; and
(5) excellent bleaching action on stained teeth.
The following patents illustrate active tooth whitening substances and delivery systems for such substances: U.S. Pat. Nos. 5,077,047, 5,108,742; 5,122,370; 5,130,124; 5,183,901; 5,190,749; 5,206,385; 5,312,619; 5,989,569; 6,669,930; 6,770,266 and 6,893,629.
U.S. Pat. No. 5,098,297 to Chari et al. discloses an apparatus for application of a tooth desensitizing composition. However, Chari et al. fail to teach or suggest tooth whitening; instead, they disclose the use of a swab-type applicator that retains and dispenses a tooth desensitizer onto the teeth. Chari et al. disclose a separate filter disc designed to prevent shards of glass from an ampule containing the desensitizing solution from escaping into the mouth of the patient. The present method differs from the teachings of Chari et al. in several respects. First, the present invention contemplates application of a defined tooth whitening composition of a predetermined viscosity rather than a tooth desensitizing composition. Second, the present invention contemplates evacuating the interior of the glass ampule containing a monodose of the tooth whitening composition so that its shelf life is extended. Third, the present invention contemplates use of a brush to dispense the tooth whitening composition with the brush doubling as the filter preventing glass shards from entering the mouth of the patient. Furthermore, the tooth whitening composition used herein is more viscous than the tooth desensitizing composition taught by Chari et al. Accordingly, the wad-type applicator of Chari et al. would not be suitable for use in dispensing the tooth whitening composition of the present invention.
What is described herein is a liquid, substantially anhydrous tooth whitener composition of predetermined viscosity for effective delivery of a tooth-whitening amount of active whitening ingredient onto teeth from a single-dose applicator, which exhibits, excellent bioadhesion and retention of said ingredient on teeth, advantageous penetration of said ingredient through tooth enamel, and effective bleaching of stained teeth, comprising, by weight,
(a) 10% to 75% of a complex which is (i) a mixture of 78 to 90% of water soluble polyvinylpyrrolidone (PVP) having a molecular weight corresponding to K-12 to K-120 values, and (ii) 10 to 22% of H2O2; providing 1 to 20% of active H2O2 onto a tooth surface;
(b) 0 to 20% of PVP K-60 to K-90, said PVP being present in said composition when the PVP in said complex has a K-value of less than 30, and/or the amount of PVP therein is less than 20%, and
(c) 30 to 90% of a substantially anhydrous solvent,
said composition having, in combination, a Brookfield viscosity of 75 to 300 cps, an in vitro bioadhesion and retention on hydroxyapatite of at least 10% after 5 minutes while immersed in water, and a bleaching efficacy defined by ΔE values of at least 5 in the CIE (L*a*b*) color scale.
Suitably, the tooth whitener composition of the invention includes (a) PVP K-30 to K-90. When present, the PVP in (b) is suitably K-90.
Alternatively, the tooth whitener composition herein includes PVP K-90 in (a), and (b) is absent.
Preferably the amount of the complex (a) in the composition is 20 to 60% and (b) is 0.1-10%.
Preferably the solvent in the tooth whitener composition is ethanol in an amount of 65 to 80 wt. % of the composition.
Preferably, the tooth whitener composition of the invention has a viscosity of 75 to 300 cps, most preferably 125 cps.
The inventive method includes in one embodiment providing an ampule with the defined tooth whitening composition which is vacuum sealed within a chamber of the ampule. The ampule may be contained within a cylindrical plastic sleeve closed at one end and enclosed at its other open end by the proximal termination of a brush-type applicator. An adhesive such as glue may be used to adhere the periphery of the brush to the inner surfaces of the plastic cylinder. The bristles preferably have circular cross-sections so that when they are tightly packed together and adhered to the plastic cylinder, the interstices between adjacent bristles are sufficiently large enough to permit flow through of the tooth whitening composition, while being sufficiently small enough to prevent shards of glass from the ampule, when the ampule is made of glass and is broken open, to pass through the brush. The bristles are used to apply the tooth whitening composition to teeth where it is retained for a sufficient time to whiten the teeth and then it is rinsed off with water.
Other embodiments of the present invention incorporate use of any desired single dose applicator for tooth whitener. Examples of such applicators include a dipstick-type applicator including a single-dose chamber into which a soft liquid absorbent applicator tip is inserted to absorb a desired quantity of tooth whitener to be applied to the user's teeth, as well as applicators wherein the container for the single dose of tooth whitener also comprises the applicator itself. In such an example, an overcap may initially cover a porous applicator mounted over a sealed opening to a chamber containing tooth whitener. The overcap includes a downwardly depending inner pin that may pierce the seal through the porous applicator to cause the tooth whitener to be absorbed by the applicator and then applied to the user's teeth. Any other single dose applicator may suitably be used in accordance with the teachings of the present invention.
1. Amount of Activated H2O2
In one embodiment of the invention, the complex in the tooth whitening composition is available as the commercial product PEROXYDONE® (ISP), which is made up of, by weight, 80-83%, of water soluble polyvinylpyrrolidone (PVP), e.g. K-15/K-30/K-90, and 17-20%, by weight, hydrogen peroxide (H2O2).
This PVP-H2O2 complex, with or without added (b) PVP, e.g. Plasdone® K-90 (ISP), to increase its viscosity, is mixed with a suitable proportion of a solvent, e.g. absolute ethanol. When applied to the surfaces of the teeth of the user, the ethanol immediately begins to evaporate resulting in a marked increase in the concentration of H2O2 thereby enhancing the whitening power of the formulation.
Typical tooth whitening compositions of the invention are shown in Tables 1 and 2 below.
2. Viscosity of Composition
As is shown in Tables 1 and 2, when the PVP ingredient in the complex includes PVP having a K-value of K-90, and the complex is present in an amount of at least 15% of the composition, the viscosity of the composition increases substantially. On the other hand, when the K-value of the PVP in the complex is K-30 or lower, and its amount therein is 40% or lower, the viscosity of the composition is less than 300 cps. A suitable viscosity for delivery from the ampule applicator is about 75 to 300 cps, preferably about 100 to 200 cps.
3. Bioadhesive/Retention of Composition on Teeth
The relative retention capacity of a test formulation on tooth surfaces can be measured by weight difference from the surface of a hydroxyapatite (HAP) plate that has been coated with the formulation and immersed in artificial saliva. An in-vitro test for formula weight retention on HAP is described below.
These in-vitro tests for formulation efficacy can be used to collectively determine the relative performance of paint-on teeth bleaching compositions.
Formula Retention Test
After five minutes immersion time, the 25% K-90 EtOH formulation is the best retained on HAP. The blend of K-90 and K-30 also exhibits effective retained time on HAP (at five minutes), as did the 50% K-30 EtOH formulation.
4. Bleaching Efficacy
The stain bleaching efficacy of the teeth whitening products compositions of the invention is determined by the rate of peroxide bioadhesion into the teeth and retention of the vehicle on the tooth surface. Two recent in-vitro methods to measure bleaching activity of such compositions were developed by Colgate-Palmolive Company and published in a poster session at the 2004 meeting of the Intl. Assoc, for Dental Research*.
*Subramanyam, R.; Cameron, R; Colgate Palmolive Co.; “Comparative Delivery of Bleaching Agent from At-home Whitening Products”; Poster #3527; Presented at IADR Annual Meeting; Honolulu, Hi.; Mar. 10-13, 2004
These methods are based on a dye compound that acts as a surrogate for teeth stain on the exterior of teeth (extrinsic stain) or within the teeth (intrinsic stain). The rate of bleaching of a fixed amount of dye can thus indicate the peroxide release rate from a formulation. Additionally, the relative rate of absorption or penetration by the peroxide from the formulations can be determined by the bleaching of a previously dyed porous substance.
Formulation bleaching efficacy also can be determined by measuring the instrumental color difference of stained HAP disks before and after bleaching. A test was developed that measures the L*a*b* color of tea-stained disks before staining, after staining, and after bleaching. Color differences (ΔE) as a result of bleaching with different formulations can be determined mathematically.
Three separate bleaching efficacy tests were developed. The following procedures are presented for each separate test. Five simple Peroxydon®-based formulas of the invention were evaluated for performance in each test method. The hydrogen peroxide content was determined by permanganate titration.
Table 4 lists the averaged L*a*b* color results of each two disk set before staining, after staining and after staining and bleaching with each of the five prototype whitening formulations. ΔE color differences between each variable and no stain were calculated. Additionally, ΔE color differences realized by bleaching were calculated. These are ΔE's between stained disked before and after bleaching.
HAP Disk Bleaching Test
Commission Internationale de l'Eclairage (CIE) uses L*a*b* scale
L is lightness 0=black, 100=pure white
a is yellow (+) and blue (−)
b is red (+) and green (−)
Total Color Difference (ΔE) between a sample and standard (or control)
ΔE=((ΔL)2+(Δa)2+(Δb)2)0.5
Reference: Hunter Associates Laboratory, Reston, Va.
The ampule apparatus includes, in one embodiment, a glass ampule having a monodose of the tooth whitening composition vacuum sealed therein. The ampule is contained within a cylindrical plastic sleeve closed at one end and enclosed at its other open end by the proximal termination of a brush-type applicator. An adhesive such as glue is used to adhere the periphery of the brush to the inner surfaces of the open end of the plastic sleeve.
The bristles preferably have circular cross-sections so that when they are tightly packed together and peripheral bristles are adhered to the plastic cylinder, interstices between adjacent bristles are sufficiently large enough to permit flow through of the tooth whitening composition while being sufficiently small enough to prevent shards of glass from the ampule, when made of glass, when broken open, to pass therethrough. The ampule may be made of any suitable material, including various plastics, so long as it can be broken open when desired to release the tooth whitener contained therein.
A cardboard sleeve surrounds the plastic cylinder to protect the user from the glass ampule when broken.
The bristles of the brush applicator are sized and configured to permit brushing between teeth into the tooth enamel. It is in these areas where stains often accrue., namely, the inter-proximal areas of the teeth. Thus, a brush rather than a wad is chosen due to its effectiveness with regard to the anatomy of the teeth that are being treated.
The method of delivering the tooth whitening composition in the ampule apparatus, involves
(b) placing the ampule within a plastic cylinder having one end closed and the other end open;
(c) sealing the open end of the plastic cylinder by the proximal end of a brush through the use of adhesive applied therebetween;
(d) providing the brush with bristles that are tightly adjacent one another and have spaces therebetween permitting flow of tooth whitening composition therethrough;
(e) placing a protector, preferably made of cardboard, over the plastic cylinder (this step may be omitted where the ampule is not made of glass);
(f) squeezing the glass ampule through the cardboard protector until it shatters, thus releasing the tooth whitening composition into the plastic cylinder;
(g) flowing the tooth whitening composition between the bristles of the brush while the tightly packed bristles act as a filter preventing the shards of glass from the ampule from traveling therebetween;
(h) pulsating the cardboard protector to dispense the tooth whitening composition through the bristles with the bristles being run over the teeth of the user particularly in the inter-proximal areas until the tooth whitening composition is completely applied to the teeth;
(i) adhering the tooth whitening composition to the teeth for a sufficient period of time so that the tooth whitening composition effectively operates to whiten the user's teeth; and,
Reference is first made to
The plastic cylindrical sleeve 11 has a closed bottom 17 and is upwardly open at 19.
An applicator tip 21 is best seen in
As seen in
As seen in
As seen in
In the operation of the apparatus 10, in the configuration shown in
Other embodiments of the present invention incorporate use of any desired single dose applicator for tooth whitener. Examples of such applicators include a dipstick-type applicator including a single-dose chamber into which a soft liquid absorbent applicator tip is inserted to absorb a desired quantity of tooth whitener to be applied to the user's teeth, as well as applicators wherein the container for the single dose of tooth whitener also comprises the applicator itself. In such an example, an overcap may initially cover a porous applicator mounted over a sealed opening to a chamber containing tooth whitener. The overcap includes a downwardly depending inner pin that may pierce the seal through the porous applicator to cause the tooth whitener to be absorbed by the applicator and then applied to the user's teeth. Any other single dose applicator may suitably be used in accordance with the teachings of the present invention.
While the invention has been described with particular reference to certain embodiments thereof, it will be understood that changes and modifications may be made which are within the skill of the art.
This application is related to U.S. Patent Application Publication No. US 2003/0203338A1, published Oct. 30, 2003; and U.S. patent application Ser. No. 11/168,163, filed Jun. 28, 2005.