Current non-contacting torquemeters are incapable of measuring torque in rotating shafts with accuracy when there is relative motion between a shaft and a transducer assembly. Furthermore, existing torquemeters lack the ability to self-calibrate, requiring in situ or periodic calibration, and have low overall reliability.
There are existing torque and alignment sensors that can address some of these issues. For example, in one existing configuration, multiple sensors are used to measure the timing of two separate toothed target wheels that provide measurements of three degrees-of-freedom of articulation including measurements of twist and angular misalignment. Such an arrangement can provide nearly unparalleled torque measurement accuracy, as well as alignment measurement. This highly reliable sensor is non-contacting and has minimal impact on shaft dynamics, but such a system requires the use of an array of sensors arranged at multiple positions about the measured shaft, and extensive signal processing is needed used to achieve the torque and alignment measurements.
As a result, it would be desirable for a non-contacting torquemeter to be able to measure torque in a rotating shaft with improved accuracy in the presence of relative motion between a rotating shaft and a transducer assembly. It would further be desirable for such a non-contacting torquemeter to have improved robustness and reliability, and to be able to self-calibrate. In addition, it would be advantageous for the non-contacting torquemeter to be able to provide accurate torque measurements using a single transducer assembly positioned at a single azimuthal position on a rotating shaft.
In one aspect, the invention provides for a non-contacting torquemeter assembly. The non-contacting torquemeter comprises a torque wheel assembly configured for coupling to a first portion of a rotating shaft for rotation with the rotating shaft, a plurality of dynamic target teeth configured for coupling to a second portion of the rotating shaft for rotation with the rotating shaft, wherein the plurality of dynamic target teeth are configured to deflect with respect to the torque wheel assembly as a function of a torque applied to the rotating shaft. In this aspect, the non-contacting torquemeter further comprises a transducer assembly including at least one sensor separated from the torque wheel assembly by a gap and configured to measure a position and speed of the torque wheel assembly and the plurality of dynamic target teeth. A processing unit is provided in communication with the transducer assembly and configured to determine the torque applied to the rotating shaft based on the position and speed measured by the transducer assembly.
In another aspect, the invention provides for a non-contacting torquemeter. The non-contacting torquemeter comprises a shaft rotatable about an axis and a torque wheel assembly configured for coupling to a first portion of the shaft for rotation with the shaft. In this configuration, the torque wheel assembly comprises a first torque wheel having a plurality of first recessed sections in an outer edge of the first torque wheel, the plurality of first recessed sections being spaced about the perimeter of the first torque wheel; a second torque wheel having a plurality of second recessed sections in an outer edge of the second torque wheel, the plurality of second recessed sections being spaced about the perimeter of the second torque wheel; and a plurality of reference target teeth each positioned within one of the plurality of second recessed sections. A plurality of dynamic target teeth are coupled to a second portion of the shaft for rotation with the shaft, wherein each of the plurality of dynamic target teeth are aligned within one of the plurality of first recessed sections in the first torque wheel, and wherein the plurality of dynamic target teeth are configured to deflect with respect to the first torque wheel as a function of a torque applied to the rotating shaft. A transducer assembly including at least one sensor is separated from one of the first torque wheel or the second torque wheel by a gap and configured to measure a position and speed of the one of the first torque wheel and plurality of dynamic target teeth or the second torque wheel and plurality of reference target teeth. A processing unit is provided in communication with the transducer assembly and configured to determine the torque applied to the shaft based on the position and speed measured by the transducer assembly.
In yet another aspect, a method for measuring a torque on a rotating shaft is provided. The method comprises measuring a position of a dynamic target relative to a torque wheel assembly, wherein the torque wheel assembly is coupled to a first portion of a rotating shaft for rotation with the rotating shaft, wherein the dynamic target is coupled to a second portion of the rotating shaft for rotation with the rotating shaft, and wherein the dynamic target is configured to deflect with respect to the torque wheel assembly as a function of a torque applied to the rotating shaft. Further, the method comprises measuring a position of a reference target that is fixed in rotation with respect to the torque wheel assembly and comparing the position of the dynamic target relative to the torque wheel assembly to the position of the reference target relative to the torque wheel assembly. In addition, the method comprises determining a torque applied to the rotating shaft based on a difference between the position of the dynamic target relative to the torque wheel assembly to the position of the reference target relative to the torque wheel assembly.
Numerous objects and advantages of the invention will become apparent as the following detailed description of the preferred embodiments is read in conjunction with the drawings, which illustrate such embodiments.
In accordance with this disclosure, a non-contacting torquemeter capable of measuring torque in a rotating shaft with improved accuracy in the presence of relative motion between a rotating shaft and a transducer assembly is provided. The non-contacting torquemeter has improved robustness and reliability, and is able to self-calibrate. The non-contacting torquemeter is able to provide accurate torque measurements using a single transducer assembly positioned at a single azimuthal position on a rotating shaft
In one aspect shown in
Similarly, a substantially disc-shaped second torque wheel 26 is likewise arranged substantially coaxially about rotating shaft 22. As shown in
As further illustrated in
To measure this relative deflection, torquemeter assembly 10 includes at least one transducer assembly 12. As illustrated in
In particular,
As shown in
Referring to
Referring to
Referring to
Referring to
Referring to
Referring to
In the example depicted in
(Δx)2+(Δy)2≦(1.0 mm)2 (1)
VR sensor 14 is rigidly mounted along a radial line emanating from nominal center of rotation 80, shown as the x-axis in
Table 2 below illustrates some representative non-limiting example operating conditions used to explain the invention. Nothing in the illustrative example is intended to limit the scope of the invention.
Referring to Table 2, based upon radius R of first torque wheel 24 and using the shaft speed of rotating shaft 22 identified in column 1, the target velocity is determined and depicted in column 2. Target velocity is a parameter for sizing VR sensor 14. In the example used in Table 2, the specified target radius R is R=50.15 mm. The maximum and minimum shaft speeds are selected to illustrate the example.
In order to achieve the desired angular twist resolution (i.e. the minimum measurable non-zero change in twist angle) in the example, a high-speed clock is used. For example, in some embodiments, the high-speed clock has a clock speed greater than 10.48 MHz. For the example, including a factor of safety, the clock rate is: fclock=48 MHz.
Nominal (i.e., no-load) relative angular spacings of the edges A, B, C, and D are estimated. Combining this geometric information with the high-speed clock rate of the corresponding timing information in microseconds, and the number of high-speed clock counts for each of the angles is established.
The longest time duration that the counter measures is the portion of each rotational quadrant where the counter is waiting for the next set of target edges to arrive. This physical angle is called the “Quadrant Remainder”. The longest time is associated with the lowest operational shaft speed. To support this maximum time, a high-speed counter must have at least 17 bits of resolution. The currently available number of bits for the counters in this application is 32 bits, but it is expected to grow with the capacity of computing power.
Referring to
Regarding self-calibration, the torque wheel assembly has two sets of target teeth as discussed above. Specifically, dynamic target teeth 25 are radially movable relative the adjacent surfaces of first torque wheel 24 as a function of applied torque, whereas reference target teeth 27 are fixed to second torque wheel 26. In this way, in some embodiments, measurement of the timing at which the edges of second target wheel 26 and reference target teeth 27 pass a corresponding one of VR sensors 14 provides a real-time reference against which the timing of first torque wheel 24 and dynamic target teeth 25 can be compared. As a result, the radial movement of dynamic target teeth 25 relative to first torque wheel 24 that is attributable to the torque applied to rotating shaft 22 can be isolated. In this regard, reference target teeth 27 can be used during a calibration period prior to operational use as is done with conventional calibration systems, but the twist processing method of rotating shaft 22 effectively eliminates the need for such in situ calibration and in fact improves the overall accuracy of the twist measurement. It is noted, however, that these benefits come at the expense of an added sensor. That being said, VR sensors 14 are less expensive than the currently used Hall Sensors, and VR sensors 14 have very high reliability. As a result, the expense of additional sensors is at least partially mitigated by the use of lower cost, highly reliable sensors.
Referring to
In particular, in the illustrated embodiment, first and second VR sensors 14a and 14b are in communication with first and second analog pre-processing blocks 31a and 31b, which represent the analog circuitry used to convert the analog VR response waveform (See, e.g.,
A logical trigger signal is generated corresponding to both rising and falling edges as indicated in
In this example, there is no absolute angle reference, and as count data is obtained, there is no way of knowing which count is associated with which tooth passage. However, the Quadrant Remainder count is always significantly larger than any of the other counts in the stream so it may be isolated in the manner shown hereinafter.
With continuing reference to
As mentioned above, there is no means for determining which of the sixteen edges triggers first. Once each circular buffer has completely filled, a startup process will scan through the changes in count value from element to element. As indicated in Table X, the changes in count value in each circular buffer will always consist of three relatively short incremental count values followed by one relatively long incremental count value. For example, at 8000 rpm, and using the approximate data from Table X, a typical count sequence might result in:
Once the long (i.e. “Quadrant Remainder”) interval is identified from the delta count values, the relative positions of all other edges are established. Only four sequential delta count values are required to establish alignment. The startup process runs separately for each of the two circular buffers because it is possible for one of the circular buffers to be advanced or delayed by one sample. Once the Quadrant Remainder is identified in each circular buffer, the data streams are properly aligned. As shown in
The count data from second torque wheel 26 is generated from rising and/or falling edges having no relative motion (i.e., reference target teeth 27 have fixed angular spacing with respect to second torque wheel 26). This means that the relative timing, when combined with the measured rotating shaft speed, will result in fixed and known angular positions. Similarly, half of the count data coming from dynamic target teeth 25 are generated from rising and falling edges that have no relative motion. Only the rising and falling edges of dynamic target teeth 25 vary relative to the other edges.
Dynamic vibrations of rotating shaft 22, shaft whirl, and low-frequency flexing of support structure 20 may cause non-zero time-varying displacements from the nominal center of rotation 80, i.e. Δx(t)≠0, and Δy(t)≠0. Such displacements have a clear impact on not only the gap between the target and the VR sensor, but also on the edge timing measurements. Rather than simply “filter” these effects in an attempt to eliminate them, the presently-disclosed systems and methods directly accommodate this time-varying distortion. Specifically, for example, although the rotating shaft speed is generally time-varying, it is assumed to be constant over any single shaft revolution. In addition, over one quarter revolution of the shaft, the dynamic variation is assumed to be constant (i.e., Δx(t)≈constant, and Δy(t)≈constant). Thus, although the dynamic variations can and will be time varying, they can be assumed to be constant over any quarter revolution. This assumption is based on the knowledge that Δx(t) and Δy(t) have spectral contents that are restricted between DC and the fundamental rotating shaft 22 rotational frequency.
In some embodiments, a further function of compensation/calibration/filtering block 34 is edge-to-edge angular compensation. Because all of reference target teeth 27 associated with second torque wheel 26 have no relative angular movement, and half of the edges on first torque wheel 24 likewise have no relative angular movement, the following angles (edges) nearest to the ith target are always fixed and known:
θCB=θCi−θBt one tooth
θDA=θDi−θAi overall notch
θAD=θAi−θD,i−1 previous quadrant remainder
θAA=θAi−θA,i−1 quarter revolution from previous A edge
θDD=θDi−θD,i−1 quarter revolution from previous D edge
The following additional angles are also fixed and known on simulated target torque wheel 34:
θBA=θBi−θAi notch prior to tooth (falling→rising)
θCA=θCi−θAi falling edge to falling edge (falling→falling)
θDB=θDi−θBi rising edge to rising edge (rising→rising)
θDC=θDi−θCi notch following tooth (falling→rising)
Using data from first and second count data buffers 33a and 33b, uncompensated estimates of the fixed angles are computed as:
These estimates will not match the fixed known angles due to the deviations of center of rotation 80 described above. The fixed angle estimation errors can be computed for each tooth passage as:
εCBi=(θCB)actual−{tilde over (θ)}CBi
εDAi=(θDA)actual−{tilde over (θ)}DAi
εADi=(θAD)actual−{tilde over (θ)}ADi
εAAi=(θAA)actual−{tilde over (θ)}AAi
εDDi=(θDD)actual−{tilde over (θ)}DDi
εBAi=(θBA)actual-sim−{tilde over (θ)}BAi
εCAi=(θCA)actual-sim−{tilde over (θ)}CAi
εDBi=(θDB)actual-sim−{tilde over (θ)}DBi
εDCi=(θDC)actual-sim−{tilde over (θ)}DCi
The following relationships are true for the estimation errors:
εDBi=εCBi+εDCi
εCAi=εBAi+εCBi
εDAi=εDBi+εDBi=εDCi+εCAi
These errors are not dependent on the torque or the resulting twist angle, but instead they are dependent on dynamic displacements Δx(t) and Δy(t) as well as temperature. The estimation errors from the simulated targets are then used to compensate the measurements from the dynamic targets to produce compensated dynamic angles:
(θBAi)comp={tilde over (θ)}BAi+εBAi
(θCAi)comp={tilde over (θ)}CAi+εCAi
(θDBi)comp={tilde over (θ)}DBi+εDBi
(θDCi)comp={tilde over (θ)}DCi+εDCi
In some embodiments, another function of compensation/calibration/filtering block 34 is computation of a shaft speed. Both the calibration and compensation processing require an accurate speed measurement of rotating shaft 22 to transform the count data to geometric dimensions.
In addition, in some embodiments, compensation/calibration/filtering block 34 is configured to calibrate the twist angle. In particular, each of the compensated dynamic angle estimates is related to the actual twist angle. The compensated angles must be “zeroed” using a calibration offset. Each of the four terms will have a different calibration offset because they are physically different angles.
(θBAi)cal=(θBAi)comp+φBA
(θCAi)cal=(θCAi)comp+φCA
(θDBi)cal=(θDBi)comp+φDB
(θDCi)cal=(θDCi)comp+φDC
Where {φBA, φCA, φDB, φDC} are calibration constants chosen such that at zero torque, each of the four calibrated twist angle estimates above will have a value of zero (degrees). Second torque wheel 26 provides a continuous measurement of the twist due to a known torque of 120 m·daN. This simulated torque, when combined with torsional stiffness data, provides an absolute reference twist angle from which the calibration constants can be determined.
The twist angle associated with the ith dynamic target is then computed as the following average:
θtwist,i=¼((θBAi)cal+(θDCi)cal +(θDBi)cal+(θCAi)cal)
One averaged dynamic twist estimate will be generated for each tooth passage.
Referring again to compensation/calibration/filtering block 34, the dynamic twist angle θtwist,i samples will be filtered using a comb filter to eliminate harmonics of 1/rev caused by manufacturing tolerance variation and vibration or shaft whirl effects relative to VR sensors 14, as well as a 15 Hz low-pass filter to restrict the bandwidth and provide an anti-aliasing function.
As indicated above, in addition to VR sensors 14, in some embodiments, torquemeter 10 further includes a RTD sensor 16 configured to measure the temperature of environment in which VR sensors 14 are operating. In such embodiments, RTD sensor 16 is in communication with elements of processor 30, including a signal-conditioning element 35, a digital sampling element 36, and a Callendar-Van Dusen element 37. In some embodiments, the output from this signal processing is a temperature value that is provided to a torsional stiffness compensation block 38 that is further in communication with compensation/calibration/filtering block 34. The torsional stiffness has a known variation with temperature that is characterized and defined in the software. Each rotating shaft has a unique set of torsional stiffness data that varies with temperature. This data is processed with the measured temperature and the measured dynamic twist angle to produce the torque measurement.
Other embodiments of the current invention will be apparent to those skilled in the art from a consideration of this specification or practice of the invention disclosed herein. Thus, the foregoing specification is considered merely exemplary of the current invention with the true scope thereof being defined by the following claims.
Filing Document | Filing Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
PCT/US2014/044688 | 6/27/2014 | WO | 00 |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
61840887 | Jun 2013 | US |